Senate Passes Michelle and Jordan's Law

January 19, 2012

The New York State Senate today passed legislation to increase penalties for unlawful high-speed car racing which has caused numerous accidents across the state, including the deaths of a 17-year-old Staten Island girl and a 5-year-old Queens boy. Michelle and Jordan’s Law (S.2938A)  is sponsored by Senator Andrew Lanza (R-I, Staten Island) and stems from tragic crashes involving suspected drag racing at excessive speeds.

“Cars which are driven by reckless or inexperienced drivers all too often become deadly weapons,” said Senator Lanza. “Sadly, statistics prove that too many young drivers lose their lives on our roads every year. This bill will protect and save the lives of our young drivers, their friends and the innocent bystanders who are often harmed or even killed by unlawful high-speed car racing.”

“Individuals who engage in illegal drag racing or similarly dangerous activities are not only endangering their own safety, but the safety of passengers, other motorists and the community at large,” Senate Majority Leader Dean G. Skelos said. “This bill would create harsher penalties that will help prevent high-speed vehicle racing and increase awareness of its risks in the hopes that the number of vehicle accidents attributed to speed are significantly decreased.” 

A 2007 crash killed Michelle Arout when a group of four friends driving a Honda Accord got involved in a race with three other friends traveling in a Ford Mustang. As the Honda reached speeds as high as 95 mph, the driver lost control and slammed into the Mustang. The car smashed into the metal post, slicing the car in two, sending Michelle and her boyfriend, who were passengers in the back seat and not wearing seatbelts, ejected into the woods. Michelle died and her boyfriend was left critically injured. 

John Arout, Michelle Arout’s father, said, “The Senate has passed Michelle and Jordan’s Law, along with a number of other bills designed to keep New York’s younger, less experienced drivers safe while on the road, but the Assembly failed to act on any of those bills. This is a good bill and I’m glad the Senate Republicans are continuing the fight, but let’s hope the Assembly passes the bill this time around to save teen lives.”

In 2008, five-year-old Jordan McLean of Queens was thrown from his aunt’s SUV and killed after their vehicle was struck by suspected drag racers. Jordan and his aunt, Claris Edwards, were driving on 109th Avenue in Queens -- a drag racing hot spot -- when they were faced with two cars head-on. After colliding with one car, the other drove off and did not return, while the passengers of the car that hit them fled the scene.

Studies have concluded that speeding increases the likelihood and severity of a crash. The faster a vehicle is moving, the less time the driver has to react to a hazard and less time that other road users can react to that vehicle. A speeding vehicle requires more time and distance to stop and is harder to control. The bill passed today would help reduce speed-related fatalities by increasing penalties for unlawful speed contests and races, and in particular, would provide that a second conviction within 12 months would result in a class E felony punishable by up to one year in prison.

The bill has been sent to the Assembly.