INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
LABOR:
Collective bargaining, protection of
  right..................................  1               17
Commodity or article of commerce,
  not to be considered                     1               17
  .......................................  1               18
Employees, lives, health and safety,
  laws for protection....................  9             2(c)
  ......................................  13               14
Local governments, adoption and
  amendment of local laws................  9             2(c)
Organization, protection of right........  1               17
Prison labor,
  Contract system abolished..............  3               24
  Occupation and employment of prisoners.  3               24
Public works,
  Days and hours, limitation.............  1               17
  Prevailing rate of wages to be paid....  1               17
Representatives, right of selection......  1               17
Right to organize and bargain
  collectively...........................  1               17
Workers' compensation, system, laws......  1               18
LABOR DEPARTMENT OF:
Head of department, appointment and
  removal................................  5                4
LABOR RELATIONS (see "Labor").
LABOR REPRESENTATIVES:
Right of selection by employees..........  1               17
LABOR UNIONS (see "Labor").
LANDS:
Assessment and taxation of,
  comptrollers powers....................  5                1
Canal (see "Canals").
Drainage (see "Drainage", "Drainage
  Systems").
Excess condemnation by cities and
  counties for certain purposes..........  1                7
Forest preserve (see "Conservation").
Lowlands and swamps, drainage by
  private or local bill prohibited.......  3               17
Private roads,
  Damage from opening, determination
  by jury................................  1                7
Necessity for opening, determination
  by jury................................  1                7
Opening, manner..........................  1                7
Persons benefited to pay damage
  and expense............................  1                7
Swamp or agricultural, drainage,
  Compensation for property taken........  1                7
                              -- 1 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Construction of drains, ditches
    and dykes............................  1                7
  Private or local bills prohibited......  3               17
  Property, use..........................  1                7
  Use of ditches and dykes on lands
    of others............................  1                7
LARCENY:
Petit, prosecution by indictment
  unnecessary............................  1                6
LAW, DEPARTMENT OF:
Attorney-general to be head..............  5                4
LAW, PRACTICE OF:
Prohibition in case of certain judges....  6         20(b)(4)
LAW OF LAND:
Citizen not to be disenfranchised or
  deprived of rights except by...........  1                1
LAW OF STATE (see "State").
LAWS:
Enactment................................  3               13
Equal protection, guaranty...............  1               11
Existing law not to be made applicable
  by reference...........................  3               16
Federal laws, reference thereto
  authorized in cases of certain taxes...  3               22
Governor to execute faithfully...........  4                3
LEASES:
Canals, prohibition,..................... 15                1
  Exceptions............................. 15                2
Forest preserves, prohibition............ 14                1
Low rent housing project, excess
  property acquired...................... 18                8
Reforestation, lands acquired............ 14                3
Wild life conservation, lands acquired... 14                3
LEGISLATIVE SESSIONS:
Annual, time for commencement............ 13                4
Extraordinary............................  4                3
LEGISLATURE:
Absentee voting,
  Generally..............................  2                2
Actions and proceedings (see "Actions
  and proceedings" under "Powers").
Additional surrogate, may provide........  6            12(a)
Adjournment,
  More than two days, consent of both
    houses required......................  3               10
  No bill to become law after, without
    approval by governor.................  4                7
Allowances to members for services as
  officers or in special capacities......  3                6
Annual meeting, time..................... 13                4
                              -- 2 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Appeals (see "Appeals" under "Powers").
Appellate division (see "Appellate
  division" under "Powers").
Appellate term (see "Appellate term
  under "Powers").
Apportionment of assembly members (see
  "Apportionment").
Appropriations (see also
 "Appropriations"),
  Bills,
    Amendment or alteration when
      submitted by governor..............  7                4
    Approval by governor, when required,
      Appropriation bills, generally.....  4                7
        .................................  7                6
      Budget bills.......................  7              4,6
    Appropriating public moneys for
      local or private purposes,
      two-thirds vote required...........  3               20
    Certificate of necessity for
      immediate passage of new bills.....  7                5
    Effective after passage without
      action by governor.................  7                4
    Items, approval of some and
      disapproval of others..............  4                7
    Passage over veto of items
      objected to........................  4                7
    Restriction on consideration of
      certain............................  7                5
    Restriction on content of certain....  7                6
    Separate bill for each
      appropriation, when required,
      exceptions.........................  7                6
    Specification of sum, object and
      purpose of appropriation,
      requirement........................  7                7
    Three-fifths quorum required for
      passing............................  3               23
    Two-thirds vote required for
      passing certain....................  3               20
  Claims against state, appropriation
    to pay...............................  3               19
  Contribution to state sinking funds....  7               16
  Court on the judiciary, expenses.......  6            22(h)
  Estimates by departments to governor...  7                1
    .....................................  4                7
  Governor, approval of appropriation
    bills................................  7              4,6
  Housing, low rent, etc.,
    appropriations from general fund..... 18                2
                              -- 3 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Judiciary, appropriations,
    Approval of bills by governor........  7                4
    Restrictions on amendment
      inapplicable.......................  7                4
  Legislature, appropriations,
    Approval of bills by governor........  7                4
    Restrictions on amendment
      inapplicable.......................  7                4
  Moneys not to be paid out except by....  7                7
  New bill, restriction on consideration
    prior to action on governor's
    bills, exception.....................  7                5
  Reforestation, appropriations.......... 14                3
  State debts, payment,..................  7               16
    Failure to make, comptroller to set
      apart revenues.....................  7               16
  State sinking funds,...................  7               15
    Failure to make, comptroller to
      set apart revenues.................  7               16
  Sums not to be fixed by reference
    to other laws........................  7                7
  Supplemental appropriation bills,
    Submission by governor...............  7                3
    Support of government, separate
      bills not required.................  7                6
  Three-fifths quorum required for
    passing..............................  3               23
  Time for payment.......................  7                7
  Two-thirds vote required for passing
    certain..............................  3               20
  Veto of items, reconsideration and
    passage..............................  4                7
  Wild life conservation, appropriations. 14                3
Assembly (see "Assembly").
Assembly districts (see "Assembly
  Districts").
Assembly members (see "Assembly
  members").
Attorney-general, vacancy in office,
  filling................................  5                1
Banking, special charters, prohibition
  against................................ 10                3
Betting on horse races, pari-mutuel,
  authorization..........................  1                9
LEGISLATURE:
Bills ((see also "Bills"),
  Amendment by one house of bills passed
    by other, ...........................  3               12
  Not allowed on last reading............  3               14
  Appropriation (see "Bills" under
                              -- 4 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    "Legislature, Appropriations").
  Approval by governor before becoming
    law..................................  4                7
  Assent of majority of each house
    required for passing.................  3               14
  Ayes and nays on final passage, entry
    on journal...........................  3               14
  Claims or demands of state, bills
    releasing, three-fifths quorum
    for passage..........................  3               23
  Creation of debt, three-fifths quorum
    for passage..........................  3               23
  Desks of members, to remain for three
    calendar legislative days............  3               14
  Enacting clause........................  3               13
  Enactment of laws by bills only........  3               13
  Existing laws not to be made
    applicable by reference                3               16
  Failure of governor to return
    within time allowed..................  4                7
  Final adjournment, no bill
    to become law after, without
    approval of governor.................  4                7
  Final passage,
    Ayes and nays to be taken............  3               14
    Conditions, exceptions...............  3               14
    Majority vote required...............  3               14
    Veto, passage over,
      two-thirds vote required...........  4                7
    Yeas and nays to be taken
      on certain bills and entered
      on journals........................  3               23
  Form, final, to be printed,
    exception............................  3               14
  Governor, action after passage...  3               12
  Introduction...........................  3               12
  Journal, entry of ayes and nays
    on final passage.....................  3               14
  Last reading, no amendment permitted...  3               14
  Law enacted only by bill...............  3               13
  Law, existing, not to be made
    applicable by reference..............  3               16
  Law, when bills to become, without
    signature of governor................ (4                7
    ..................................... (5                4
Local (see "Private and local" under
  "Legislature, Bills").
Messages required for passage
  (see "Bills").
  Origination in either house............  3               12
                              -- 5 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Passage (see "Final Passage" under
  "Legislature, Bills").
  Presentation to and approval by
    governor.............................  4                7
  Printing, requirement..................  3               14
  Private and local (see also "Local
    Laws," "Special Laws"),
      Cases in which not authorized......  3               17
      Embracing more than one subject
        prohibited.......................  3               15
      Statutory revision bills, excepted
        from restrictions against........  3               21
      Title, subject matter to be
        expressed........................  3               15
  Procedure for passing..................  3               14
    Reconsideration after veto...........  4                7
    Statutory revisions, certain
      restrictions inapplicable to
      bills effecting....................  3               21
    Tax, three-fifths quorum required
      for passage........................  3               23
    Time for approval by governor........  4                7
    Veto by governor,
      Passage over veto upon
        reconsideration..................  4                7
      Return to house of origin
        with objections..................  4                7
Vote required for final passage
  (see "Bills").
Board of supervisors (see "Board of
  Supervisors")
Bonus (see "Bonus").
Budget (see "Budget").
Canals (see "Canals").
Capital improvements, New York city
  determination as to exclusion from
  tax limitation.........................  8               11
Cases prosecutable otherwise than
  by indictment of grand jury,
  authority to regulate..................  1                6
Cities (see "Cities").
Citizenship requirement for service
  as member..............................  3                7
City-wide courts, New York city (see
  "City-wide courts, New York city
  under "Duties," "Powers" and
  "Restrictions").
City courts, outside New York city
  (see "City courts, outside New York
  city" under "Duties" and "Powers").
                              -- 6 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
City of New York (see "New York City"
  under "Legislature").
Civil service and veterans'
  preferences (see "Civil Service").
Claims against state (see "Claims
  against state" under "Powers"
  and "Restrictions").
Commencement of term..................... 13                4
Common and statute law of colony of
  New York, alteration...................  1               14
Commutations by governor.................  4                4
Compensation, allowances and traveling
  expenses of members....................  3                6
Compensation of judicial officers
  retired for disability.................  6             2(c)
Comptroller, vacancy in office filling...  5                1
Condition of state, transmission of
  message at each session................  4                3
Condemnation of private property
  (see "Eminent Domain").
  Conservation (see "Conservation")
  Constitutional amendments (see
  "Constitutional Amendments").
Constitutional conventions (see
  "Constitutional Conventions").
  Contractors,
    Employees, safety and welfare........ (1               18
    .....................................(13               14
Corporations (see "Corporations").
  Counties (see also "Counties"),
    Alternative forms of government......  9             1(h)
  Division of power affected by
    restriction on assembly districts....  3                5
  Legislative power over.................  9              1-3
  Local laws affecting,
    Enactment on certificate of
      necessity by governor..............  9             2(b)
    Executive officer, request...........  9             2(b)
      When not required..................  9             2(b)
    Organization and government..........  9             2(b)
    Special or local laws affecting,
      prohibition against, exceptions....  9             2(b)
County courts (see "County courts"
  under "Powers").
County court judges (see "County
  court judges" under "powers" and
  "Restrictions").
County officers (see County Officers").
Court of appeals (see also "Court
  of appeals" under "Powers" and
                              -- 7 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  "Restrictions").
     Judges,
     Removal from office.................  6            23(a)
   Temporary, during military service
     of elected judges...................  6         20(b)(1)
   Jurisdiction, authority to restrict...  6          3(b)(8)
  Right to appeal to, authority to
    restrict.............................  6          3(b)(8)
Court of claims (see "Court of claims"
  under "Powers" and "Restrictions").
Court of general sessions, New York
  county (see "General Sessions").
Court on the judiciary (see also
  "Court on the judiciary" under
  "Powers" "Duties" and
  "Restrictions"),
  Additional powers, right to
    confer...............................  6            22(g)
    Expenses, duty to provide............  6            22(h)
    Removal charges before, notice
      to legislature.....................  6            22(e)
    Stay of proceedings before,
      pending determination of identical
      charges............................  6            22(e)
Courts of record (see "Courts of
  record" under "Powers").
  Criminal cases, appeals from
    judgments, provision.................  6             3(b)
    Criminals,
      Institutions, provision............ 17                5
      Probation and parole, provision.... 17                5
  Debts, state, appropriations for
    payment of principal and interest....  7               16
  Defense and protection of state,
    to provide........................... 12                1
  District courts (see "District courts"
    under "Duties" "Powers" and
    "Restrictions").
    Disqualifications for membership
      (see "Assembly," "Assembly
      members," "Senate," "Senators"),
  Divorce, prohibition against grant.....  1                9
  Doors of each house to be kept open,
    exception............................  3               10
  Duties (see also "Powers,"
    "Restrictions" under "Legislature"),
      Absentee voting, generally.........  2                2
      Agriculture and markets, head of
        department, manner of
        appointment, to prescribe........  5                4
                              -- 8 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      Annual session, duty and time
        of assembly...................... 13                4
      Assembly members, apportionment, to
        provide..........................  3                5
      Attorney-general, filling vacancy
        in office, to provide............  5                1
      Bingo, to enact laws to regulate...  1                9
      Bribery of public officers, payment
        by state of county expenses
        of prosecution, to provide....... 13            13(b)
      Canals, expenses of superintendence
        and repairs, annual
        appropriations................... 15                3
      Children, jurisdiction over
        adoption, guardianship, etc., to
        consider religious persuasion....  6               32
      Cities,
        Organization, to provide.........  9             2(a)
        Power to contract indebtedness,
          method of determining
          exclusions for housing
          purposes, to prescribe......... 18                4
        Power to contract indebtedness,
          manner of determining
          exclusions for education
          purposes, to prescribe.........  8                4
        Powers of taxation, assessment,
          borrowing money, etc., to
          restrict.......................  8               12
      City court, New York city, to
        provide that justices be judges
        of city-wide court of civil
        jurisdiction for remainder of
        term.............................  6            35(c)
      City courts, outside New York city,
        Judges,
          General provisions relating
            thereto, to prescribe........  6            17(d)
          Qualifications, to prescribe...  6            20(c)
          Restrictions, to prescribe.....  6            20(c)
        Jurisdiction, to prescribe,
          limitation.....................  6            17(a)
      City-wide courts, New York city,
        Establishment....................  6       1(a),15(a)
          Transfer thereto, judges of
            abolished courts.............  6          35(c,d)
      Civil service appointments and
        promotions, to enact laws........  5                6
      Comptroller, filing vacancy in
        office, to provide...............  5                1
                              -- 9 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      Constitutional amendments,
        Attorney-general, reference
          for opinion.................... 19                1
        Entry on journals with ayes
          and noes....................... 19                1
        Reference to legislature next
          chosen and publication......... 19                1
        Submission to people, manner
          and time, to prescribe......... 19                1
      Constitutional convention,
        question on holding, submission.. 19                2
      Counties,
        Alternative forms of government,
          to provide.....................  9             1(h)
          Structure of government and
            manner of functioning, to
            set forth....................  9             1(h)
        Organization and government,
          to provide.....................  9             2(a)
      County officers, time for election,
        to fix........................... 13                8
      Court on the judiciary,
        appropriations for expenses,
        to make..........................  6            22(h)
      Defenses and protection of state,
        to provide....................... 12                1
      District courts,
        Judges,
          Qualifications.................  6            20(c)
          Restrictions...................  6            20(c)
      Doors of each house to be kept
        open, exception..................  3               10
      Executive budget, procedure for
        hearings and appearances, to
        prescribe........................  7                3
      Expenses of courts,
        Cost of operating and
          maintaining, certain courts,
          to allocate....................  6            29(a)
        Final determinations of
          estimated financial needs of
          certain courts borne by state,
          to make........................  6            29(c)
        Submission of annual financial
          needs to administrative
          board of judicial conference
          by certain courts, to provide..  6            29(b)
      Gambling, to enact laws to prevent.  1                9
      General laws, cases in which
        action must be taken by..........  3               17
                             -- 10 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      Governmental operations,
        continuity during certain
        emergencies, to provide..........  3               25
      Governor and lieutenant-governor,
        Election by single vote
          applicable to both offices,
          to provide.....................  4                1
      Housing, occupancy of projects, to
        restrict and give certain
        preference....................... 18                6
      Journal of proceedings, each house
        to keep and publish..............  3               10
      Judges and justices, certain, to
        establish compensation...........  6            25(a)
      Judicial conference, composition
        and function, to provide.........  6               28
      Judiciary article, to enact laws
        to effectuate....................  6               33
      Lieutenant-governor and governor,
        Election by single vote
          applicable to both offices,
          to provide.....................  4                1
      Literature fund, revenues, to apply
        for support of common schools
        and libraries.................... 11                3
      Lotto, to enact laws to regulate...  1                9
  Magistrates' court, New York city,
    abolished, to provide that justices
    be judges of city-wide court of
    criminal jurisdiction for remainder
    of term..............................  6            35(d)
  Members, elections, returns and
    Qualifications, each house to judge..  3                9
  Militia, minimum force, to maintain and
    make annual appropriations........... 12                1
  Militia, maintenance and regulation, to
    provide.............................. 12                1
  Municipal corporations, public
    improvements and services, method of
    determining exclusions from
    indebtedness, to prescribe...........  8                5
  Municipal court, New York city,
    abolished, to provide that justices
    be judges of city-wide court of
    civil jurisdictions for remainder
    of term..............................  6            35(c)
  Municipalities, equalization ratio for
    tax limitation, manner of
    determination, to prescribe..........  8               10
  Needy, care and support, to provide.... 17                1
                             -- 11 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  New York city, method of determining
    exclusions of indebtedness,
    Dock purposes, to prescribe..........  8                7
    School purposes, to prescribe........  8                7
    Transit purposes, to prescribe.......  8               7a
  Officers, each house to choose.........  3                9
  Prisoners, labor, to provide...........  3               24
  Protection of state, to provide........ 12                1
  Public health, protection and
    promotion, to provide................ 17                3
  Public officers, certain,
    Removal for misconduct, to provide... 13                5
    Vacancies created by removal, to
      provide for filling................ 13                5
  Public offices, succession to powers
    and duties during certain
    emergencies, to provide..............  3               25
  Reservoirs on forest preserve lands,
    charges for state operation, to
    assess............................... 14                2
  Rules of proceedings, each house to
    determine............................  3                9
  Savings banks, powers, rights and
    liabilities, to conform with general
    laws................................. 10                3
  School districts, certain,
    Consolidated district, tax
      limitation, to prescribe...........  8               10
    Propositions to increase tax
      limitation, qualifications for
      voting, to prescribe...............  8             4,10
  Schools, free common, maintenance and
    support, to provide.................. 11                1
  Senate districts, readjustment or
    alteration, to provide...............  3                4
  Sinking funds, contributions, to make
    appropriations.......................  7            15,16
  State boards and commissions, manner
    of removal of members by governor,
    to prescribe.........................  5                4
  State comptroller, auditing powers
    and duties, to define................  5                1
    Vacancy, to provide for filling......  5                1
  State debts, payment of interest and
    principal, to make appropriations....  7               16
  State departments, heads, manner of
    removal by governor, to prescribe....  5                4
  State departments and officers,
    publication of rules and
    regulations, to provide..............  4                8
                             -- 12 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  State enumeration, when to provide.....  3                4
  Statute of local governments, to enact.  9             2(b)
  Special sessions, New York city, to
    provide that justices be judges of
    city-wide court of criminal
    jurisdiction for remainder of term...  6            35(d)
  State officers, constitutional,
    compensation, to fix................. 13                7
  Taxation,
    Assessments, supervision, review
      and equalization, to provide....... 16                2
    Laws delegating power, types of
      taxes and review, to specify
      and provide........................ 16                1
  Town courts,
    Judges,
      General provisions relating
        thereto, to prescribe............  6            17(d)
      Qualifications, to prescribe.......  6            20(c)
      Restrictions, to prescribe.........  6            20(c)
      Training and education, to
        require for certain..............  6            20(c)
    Jurisdiction, to prescribe...........  6            17(a)
  Towns,
    Organization, to provide.............  9             2(a)
    Power of taxation, assessment,
      borrowing money, etc., to restrict.  8               12
  Vacancies in office, to provide for
    filling.............................. 13                3
  Village courts,
    Judges,
      General provisions relating
        thereto, to prescribe............  6            17(d)
      Qualifications, to prescribe.......  6            20(c)
      Restrictions, to prescribe.........  6            20(c)
      Training and education, to require
        for certain......................  6            20(c)
    Jurisdiction, to prescribe...........  6            17(a)
  Villages,
    Organization, to provide.............  9             2(a)
    Powers of taxation, assessment,
      borrowing money, etc., to restrict.  8               12
  Villages of 5,000 or more,
    Housing indebtedness, method of
      determining exclusion, to
      prescribe.......................... 18                4
  Voters, identification by signature,
    to require, exceptions...............  2                7
  Voting,
    Exclusion from suffrage of persons
                             -- 13 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      convicted of certain crimes, to
      enact laws.........................  2                3
    Right of suffrage and registration,
      to enact laws......................  2                5
Education (see also "Education"),
  Certain persons, provision.............  7                8
  School system, provision............... 11                1
  Transportation of school children,
    authorization........................ 11                3
Elections (see also "Elections"),
  Absentee registration..................  2                5
  Absentee voting, to enact laws.........  2                2
  Authority to provide...................  2                2
  Bi-partisan boards to control..........  2                8
    Inapplicability to town and village
      elections..........................  2                8
  Boards,
    Equal representation of two major
      political parties..................  2                8
    Existing laws to continue until
      changed............................  2                8
    Officers constituting, nomination,
      appointment and election...........  2                8
  Conduct, secrecy of ballot preserved...  2                7
    Permanent registration, systems,
      authority to establish.............  2                6
  Persons entitled to vote, laws for
    ascertainment,.......................  2                5
    Exclusion for disqualification, to
      enact laws.........................  2                3
  Persons excluded from right of
    suffrage.............................  2                3
  Registration of voters, laws,..........  2                5
    Personal application where
     required............................  2                5
  Town and village, registration.........  2                5
Eminent domain (see "Eminent Domain").
Employees (see "Employees").
Enumeration of powers involving use of
  state money or credit..................  7                8
  Not to diminish pre-existing powers....  7                8
Expenditures, certain, determination as
  to exclusion from tax limitation of
  counties, cities, villages and
  school districts.......................  8               11
Expenses of courts (see "Expenses of
  courts" under "Duties").
Extraordinary sessions,
  Governor, power to convene.............  4                3
  Subjects recommended by governor,
                             -- 14 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    action restricted....................  4                3
Family court judges (see "Family court
  judges" under "Powers" and
    "Restrictions").
Final passage of bills (see "Bills").
Financial needs, estimates and
  transmission to governor...............  7                1
Forest lands, use for reservoirs,
  provision.............................. 14                2
Gambling, prevention, laws...............  1                9
General laws,
  Action on enumerated subjects..........  3               17
  Drainage of swamp or agricultural
    lands, construction and maintenance
    of facilities, authorization.........  1                7
General provisions relating to...........  3             1-24
Governor (see also "Governor"),
  Communications by message on condition
    of state.............................  4                3
  Duty to expedite all measures adopted..  4                3
  Recommendation of matters deemed
    expedient............................  4                3
  Reprieves, commutations and pardons,
    Duty to report details...............  4                4
Grand jury (see "Grand Jury").
Health and safety (see "Health
  and Safety").
Highways (see "Highways").
Highways and parkways, use of proceeds
  of bonds for elimination of grade
  crossings..............................  7               14
Horse races, pari-mutuel betting,
  authorization..........................  1                9
Housing (see also "Housing"),
  Authority to provide for low rent
    housing and slum clearance........... 18                1
  Certain ventures prohibited............ 18               10
  Debt, amount, without submission to
    people............................... 18                3
  Eminent domain, grant of power,........ 18                2
    Excess condemnation, powers.......... 18                8
  Exclusions from debt, method of
    ascertaining......................... 18                4
  Limitation on indebtedness............. 18                4
  Local governments, powers.............. 18                2
  Power to enact legislation............. 18               10
  Regulations governing facilities....... 18                2
  Subsidies, authorization............... 18                2
    Conditions for granting.............. 18                6
Impeachment (See "Impeachment").
                             -- 15 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Income taxes, reference to federal laws
  authorized.............................  3               22
Industrial plants, rehabilitation,
  Indebtedness to provide, right to
    authorize............................ 10                7
  Loans to provide, right to authorize...  7                8
Journal of proceedings (see also
"Journals of Legislature"),
  Ayes and nays on final passage of
    bills to be entered..................  3               14
  Certain bills, yeas and nays on final
    passage, entry.......................  3               23
  Governor's objections to bills to be
    entered..............................  4                7
  Keeping and publication by each house..  3               10
  Reconsideration of bills, names of
    members voting to be entered.........  4                7
  Removal of judges and justices,
    Charges to be entered................  6            23(c)
    Yeas and nays to be entered..........  6            23(c)
Judges and Justices (see "Judges and
  justices" under "Duties," "Powers"
  and "Restrictions").
Judicial departments (see "Judicial
  Departments").
Judicial districts (see "Judicial
  Districts").
Judicial officers (see also "Judges
  and Justices"),
  Election or appointment, certain,
    time and manner, to direct...........  6            17(d)
  Removal from office on recommendation
    of governor..........................  6            23(b)
  Retired for disability, compensation...  6            22(c)
Judicial offices (see "Judicial offices"
  under "Powers")
Jurisdiction and proceedings in law and
  equity, alteration and regulation......  6               30
Jury trial (see "Jury").
Justices of the peace (see "Justices of
  the peace" under "Powers").
Law and equity, jurisdiction and
  proceedings, alteration and regulation.  6               30
Law of state,
  Acts of legislature constituting.......  1               14
  Alteration.............................  1               14
  Governor to execute faithfully.........  4                3
Legislative power vested in Senate and
  Assembly...............................  3                1
Legislators ineligible for certain civil
                             -- 16 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  appointments...........................  3                7
Loans,
  Low rent housing projects, conditions.. 18                6
  State money or credit, prohibition
    against, exceptions..................  7                8
Local bills (see "Bills" under
  "Legislature").
Local laws (see "Local Laws," "Special
  Laws").
Magistrates courts (see "Magistrates
  courts" under "Duties").
Manufacturing plants, rehabilitation,
  Indebtedness to provide, right to
    authorize............................ 10                7
  Loans to provide, right to authorize...  7                8
Members (see also "Assembly," "Assembly
      members," "Senate," "Senators"),
    Additional allowances for service as
      officer or in any special capacity.  3                6
    Appropriations for local or private
      purposes, votes of two-thirds
      necessary..........................  3               20
    Commissioner of deeds, eligibility
      for appointment....................  3                7
    Compensation and allowances,.........  3                6
    Constitution and laws to govern and
    control..............................  3                6
    Continuance of existing until
      changed............................  3                6
    Extra compensation prohibited........  3                6
    Fees or perquisites of office,
      receiving for own use prohibited... 13                7
    Not to be increased or diminished
      during term........................  3                6
  Elections, returns and
    qualifications, each house to judge..  3                9
  Elections, when held...................  3                8
  Forfeiture of membership,
    Acceptance of certain offices to
      vacate seat........................  3                7
    Election to congress, acceptance to
      vacate seat........................  3                7
  Ineligibility for certain civil
    appointments.........................  3                7
  Items of appropriation, passage over
    veto, two-thirds vote required.......  4                7
  National guard of state, not
    disqualified for membership..........  3                7
  Naval militia of state, not
    disqualified for membership..........  3                7
                             -- 17 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Oath of office......................... 13                1
  Office having no compensation, not
    disqualified for appointment.........  3                7
  Passage of bills over veto, two-thirds
    vote required........................  4                7
  Quorum, majority to constitute,........  3                9
    Three-fifths required for passage of
      certain bills......................  3               23
  Reserve forces of the United States,
    not disqualified for membership......  3                7
  Salary, uniform, to be fixed...........  3                6
  Speeches and debates, not to be
    questioned...........................  3               11
  Traveling expenses, reimbursement,
    limitation...........................  3                6
Mental defectives, provision for care.... 17                4
Mental health, provision................. 17                4
Mentally ill, education and support,
  provision..............................  7                8
Messages required for final passage of
  bills (see "Bills").
Militia (see also "Militia"):
  Maintenance and regulation, duty to
    provide.............................. 12                1
Municipal corporations, organization,
  restrictions...........................  8               12
  .......................................  9             3(c)
Municipal court (see "Municipal court"
  under "Duties").
Municipalities (see also
  "Municipalities"),
  Authorization of payments to certain
    institutions.........................  8                1
  Government, enactment of laws..........  9              1-2
    Indebtedness,
      Exclusions in computing debt
        limitation.......................  8               7a
      Method of ascertaining, power to
        prescribe........................  8                5
    Incurring, power to restrict.........  8               12
  Taxes,
    Expenditures, certain, exclusion
      from tax limitation................  8               11
    Levying, power to restrict...........  8            10,12
    Limitation, agency and method to
      determine equalization ratio,
      right to prescribe.................  8               10
Needy, aid, care and support provision...  7                8
  ......................................  17                1
New York city (see also "New York
                             -- 18 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  City"),
  Counties within, laws affecting
    certain county offices prohibited,
    exception............................ 13            13(c)
    Message from governor required....... 13            13(c)
    Two-thirds vote required............. 13            13(c)
  Dock purposes, exclusion of
    indebtedness.........................  8                7
  Exclusion of certain indebtedness......  8               7a
  Officers or courts, reservation of
    legislative power
    School purposes, exclusion of
    indebtedness.........................  8                7
  Supreme court, jurisdiction to
    determine,
    Additional exclusions from
      indebtedness.......................  8               7a
    Dock indebtedness, when and how to
      be excluded........................  8                7
New York Port Authority, obligations
  for railroad passenger equipment,
  right to guarantee..................... 10                7
Nursing homes,
  Authority to provide for
    accommodations for persons of low
    income............................... 18                1
  Subsidies, authorization............... 18                2
Oath of members.......................... 13                1
Officers,
  Additional allowances for services.....  3                6
  Each house to choose...................  3                9
Pardons, communication by governor.......  4                4
Parole system, provision................. 17                5
Pensions, public, right to increase......  7                8
Permanent personal registration,
  systems, laws..........................  2                6
Personnel, abolished courts,
  assignment.............................  6            35(1)
Powers (see also "Duties,"
"Restrictions" under "Legislature"),
  Absentee registration, to provide......  2                5
  Absentee voting, to provide............  2                2
  Actions and proceedings (see also
    "Actions" and "Judicial
       Proceedings"),
       New classes, right to create and
         provide for jurisdiction........  6             7(b)
    Transfer, certain, right to
      provide............................  6    19(a,c,g,h,i)
    Verdicts and judgments, right to
                             -- 19 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      provide that certain not subject
      to monetary limitation.............  6            19(k)
  Appeals (see also "Appeals").
    Certain, right to provide for
      transfer thereof...................  6            35(m)
      Pending, certain courts, right to
        provide for hearing and
        determination....................  6            34(a)
  Appellate division, additional
    jurisdiction, to prescribe...........  6             4(k)
  Appellate term, right to provide
    for appeals thereto..................  6       8(e),11(d)
    .....................................         34(a),35(m)
  Apportionments, regulations for
    judicial review, to prescribe........  3                5
  Assembly districts, division of
    counties, time for assembly of
    local boards, to prescribe...........  3                5
  Assemblymembers, additional allowance
    for services as managers of
    impeachment, to fix..................  3                6
  Banking purposes, formation of
    corporations and associations, to
    provide by general laws.............. 10                3
Bills (see also "Bills" under
    "Legislature"),
    Right of each house to initiate
      and amend..........................  3               12
    Vetoed, right to reconsider
      and pass over veto.................  4                7
Bingo, right to regulate.................  1                9
Blind, education and support, to
  provide................................  7                8
Bonus, state debt, right to
  create.................................  7               18
Canals (see also "Canals"),
  Barge canal
    Lease or transfer to federal
      government, right to
        authorize........................ 15                4
    Lands and properties,
      Disposition of unnecessary, right
        to authorize..................... 15                2
      Occupancy or use, revocable
        permits, right to grant.......... 15                1
      Use by public thruway
        corporations, right to
        authorize........................ 10                6
    Manner of improvement, to
      provide............................ 15                3
                             -- 20 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    Navigation, laws and regulations
      governing, right to enact.......... 15                3
  Children,
    Health and welfare services,
      right to provide...................  7                8
    Neglected and dependent, care
      and support, right to provide......  7                8
    Transportation to and from any
      school, right to authorize......... 11                3
  Cities (see also "municipalities"
    under "Legislature, Powers"),
    Additional powers of local
      legislation and administration.....  9             2(c)
    Counties not contained within,
      legislative power unaffected
      by home rule provisions in
      certain cases...................... 13            13(c)
    Excess taking of property for
      certain purposes, right to
      authorize..........................  1                7
    Exclusion of indebtedness for
      housing purposes,
      determination, right to confer
      jurisdiction....................... 18                4
    General or special laws not
      relating to property, affairs
      or government, right to enact......  9             2(c)
    Matters other than property,
      affairs or government, right
      to enact laws......................  9             2(c)
    Public school systems, legislative
      power unaffected by home rule
      provisions.........................  9             3(a)
    Sewage facilities, exclusion of
      indebtedness from debt
      limitation, right to prove.........  8            2-a,5
    Water supply, excess or common,
      right to authorize.................  8              2-a
  City courts, outside New York city,
    Appeals therefrom, right to
       provide therefor..................  6       8(e),11(d)
    Discontinuance, right to
      provide............................  6               17
    Judges, manner of removal,
      right to provide...................  6            22(i)
    Mandates, right to provide for
      service and execution..............  6             1(c)
    Practice and procedure, right to
      establish..........................  6            17(b)
    Processes, right to provide for
                             -- 21 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      service and execution..............  6             1(c)
    Regulation, right to provide.........  6            17(b)
    Uniform jurisdiction, right to
      establish..........................  6            17(b)
    Warrants, right to provide for
      service and execution..............  6             1(c)
  City-wide court of criminal
    jurisdiction, right to grant
    jurisdiction over misdemeanors
    prosecuted by indictment.............  6       7(a),15(c)
  City-wide courts, New York city,
    Judges, manner of removal, right to
      provide............................  6            22(i)
    Jurisdiction, right to prescribe.....  6          15(b,c)
    Mandates, service and execution,
      right to prescribe limitations.....  6             1(c)
    Merger, to provide on request of
      mayor and local legislative body...  6       1(a),15(a)
    Processes, service and execution,
      right to prescribe limitations.....  6            11(c)
    Warrants, service and execution,
      right to prescribe limitations.....  6             1(c)
  City officers, non-constitutional,
    election or appointment..............  9             1(b)
  Claims against state,
    Appropriation for payment, right to
      provide............................  3               19
    Jurisdiction thereof.................  6                9
    Trial of actions and proceedings,
      right to provide manner............  6            18(b)
  Constitutional amendments, right
    to propose........................... 19                1
  Constitutional convention, time for
    submission of question on holding,
    right to fix......................... 19                2
   Contractors, public works, wages,
     hours, welfare and safety of
     employees, right to regulate........  9             2(c)
   Corporations,
     Dues, means of security, right
       to prescribe...................... 10                2
     Formation, right to provide......... 10                1
       Laws affecting, right to alter
       or repeal......................... 10                1
Counties (see also "Municipalities"
  under "Legislature, Powers").
    Additional powers of local
      legislation and administration.....  9             2(c)
    Agreements by two or more for
      discharge of governmental
                             -- 22 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      functions, right to authorize......  9             1(c)
    Alternative forms of government,
      what to contain, right to
      prescribe..........................  9             1(h)
    Division, power unaffected by
      restrictions on creation of
      assembly districts.................  3                5
    Excess taking of property for
      certain purposes, right to
      authorize..........................  1                7
    Laws relating to counties and
      governmental units, right to
      enact..............................  9             1(h)
    Sewage facilities, exclusion of
      indebtedness from debt limitation,
      right to provide...................  8            2-a,5
    Tax limitation, method of
      increasing, right to prescribe.....  8               10
    Water supply, excess or common,
      right to authorize.................  8              2-a
  County clerks,
    Powers and duties, right to
      prescribe..........................  6             6(e)
    Selection of jurors, manner and
      conditions, right to prescribe..... 13            13(a)
  County courts,
    Actions and proceedings, certain,
      right to provide for original
      jurisdiction.......................  6            11(a)
    Appeals thereto, right to provide in
      certain cases......................  6            34(a)
    Equity jurisdiction, right to
      provide............................  6            11(c)
    Money judgments, right to increase
      amount recoverable, limitations....  6            11(a)
  County judges,
    Additional, right to provide.........  6            10(a)
    Combination with certain judicial
      officers, right to provide.........  6               14
    Number, right to increase............  6            10(a)
  County officers, non-constitutional,
    election or appointment..............  9             1(b)
  Court of appeals,
    Appeals as of right, power to
      abolish............................  6          3(b)(8)
    Criminal cases, appeals, right to
      provide............................  6             3(b)
    Judges,
      Right to remove for cause..........  6            23(a)
      Temporary, during military service
                             -- 23 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
        of elected judges, right to
        provide..........................  6         20(b)(1)
  Court of claims,
    Judges, power to increase number.....  6                9
    Jurisdiction, practice and
      procedure, right to provide........  6                9
  Courts of record, additional, right
    to determine.........................  6             1(b)
  Court on the judiciary,
    Additional powers, right to confer...  6            22(g)
    Removal proceedings, stay pending
      determination of same charges......  6            22(e)
  Courts, legislative power unaffected
    by home rule provisions..............  9             3(a)
  Criminals, maintenance and support of
    institutions, right to provide....... 17                5
  Deaf, education and support, right to
    provide..............................  7                8
  District attorneys, New York city
    counties, term of office, right to
    direct...............................  8                5
  District courts,
    Appeals therefrom, right to provide..  6       8(l),11(d)
    Discontinuance, right to provide.....  6            16(i)
    Districts thereof, right to create...  6            16(e)
    Establishment, right to provide at
      request of board of supervisors....  6            16(a)
    Judges,
      Additional, right to provide.......  6            16(f)
      Apportionment, right to provide....  6            16(g)
      Number, right to provide...........  6            16(f)
      Removal, right to provide manner...  6            22(i)
    Jurisdiction, right to provide,
      limitation.........................  6            16(d)
    Mandates, right to provide for
      service and execution..............  6             1(c)
    Processes, right to provide for
      service and execution..............  6             1(c)
    Regulation, right to provide.........  6            16(i)
    Warrants, right to provide for
      service and execution..............  6             1(c)
  Drainage systems, common or excess,
    right to authorize...................  8              2-a
  Dumb, education and support, right
    to provide...........................  7                8
  Education, higher, right to create
    indebtedness.........................  7               19
  Elections,
    Boards and officers, appointment or
      election, right to direct..........  2                8
                             -- 24 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    Permanent registration, systems,
      right to provide...................  2                6
    Presidential, special procedures for
      voting thereat, power to adopt.....  2                9
    Town and village, registration of
      voters, power to require...........  2                5
    Uncontested primary elections, right
      to waive...........................  1                1
    Voting, method, right to prescribe..  2                7
  Employees, protection of lives,
    health and safety, right to enact
    laws.................................  1               18
    ..................................... 13               14
  Employment,
    Indebtedness to provide, right to
      authorize.......................... 10                7
    Loans to provide, right to
      authorize..........................  7                8
  Executive budget,
    Appearances of department heads,
      right to request...................  7                3
    Contents, additional information,
      right to require...................  7                2
  Family court judges,
    Combination with certain other
      judicial offices, right to provide.  6               14
    New York city, number, right to
      provide............................  6            13(a)
  Forest preserve lands,
    Highways, construction and
      maintenance of certain, right to
      provide............................ 14                1
    Reservoirs, construction and
      maintenance, right to provide for
      use................................ 14                2
    Sale or exchange of certain, right to
      authorize.......................... 14                3
    Ski trails, construction and
      maintenance of certain, right to
      authorize.......................... 14                1
    Use of certain, right to prescribe... 14                3
  Governmental employees, wages, hours,
    welfare and safety, right to
    regulate............................. 13               14
  Governmental operations, continuity
    during certain emergencies, right
    to prescribe.........................  3               25
  Governor, salary, right to fix.........  4                3
  Hamilton county, power to abolish
    and annex territory..................  3                5
                             -- 25 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Horse races, pari-mutuel betting,
    right to authorize...................  1                9
  Housing,
    Acquisition of property ultimately
      necessary, limitations, right to
      impose............................. 18                9
    Cooperation with and aid from United
      States, right to authorize......... 18                2
    Excess taking of property, right to
      authorize.......................... 18                8
    Exclusions of indebtedness,
      jurisdiction to determine, right
      to confer.......................... 18                4
    Indebtedness of public corporations,
      guaranty of principal and interest
      by local governments, right to
      authorize.......................... 18                2
    Loans by local governments, power to
      authorize.......................... 18                2
    Power of eminent domain, right to
      grant.............................. 18                2
    Power to enact proper and necessary
      laws............................... 18               10
    State loans, power to make........... 18                2
    State loans and subsidies, additional
      conditions, right to provide....... 18                6
    State subsidies, right to provide.... 18                2
    Subsidies by local governments,
      power to authorize................. 18                2
    Tax exemptions, right to grant or
      authorize.......................... 18                2
  Housing and slum clearance, power to
    provide.............................. 18                1
  Impeachment, majority vote of Assembly
    required to exercise power...........  6               24
  Income taxes, reference to federal laws
    authorized...........................  3               22
  Industrial plants, rehabilitation,
    Indebtedness, guaranty by state...... 10                7
      Loans by state, authorized.........  7                8
    Institutions, visitation and
    inspection, right to authorize....... 17                6
  Institutions for detention of
    criminals, maintenance and support,
    right to provide..................... 17                5
  Joint municipal facilities or services,
    Indebtedness, right to authorize
    and apportion........................  8                1
    Taxes or charges, right to
      authorize..........................  8                1
                             -- 26 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Joint municipal facilities or service
    Indebtedness, right to
      authorize and apportion............  8                1
    Taxes and charges may be imposed
      therefor...........................  8                1
  Journal or proceedings, each house to
    keep and publish.....................  3               10
  Judges and justices,
    Assignment, temporary, certain,
      right to provide...................  6            26(j)
    Compensation, additional for
      certain, right to prescribe........  6            25(a)
    Qualifications, certain, right
      to determine.......................  6            20(a)
    Removal, certain,
      Manner, right to provide...........  6            22(i)
    Right to effect......................  6            23(a)
    To determine those removable by
      senate.............................  6            23(b)
    Retirement for disability, to
      provide compensation...............  6            22(c)
    Temporary, to provide in
      certain cases......................  6         20(b)(1)
  Judicial departments, power to alter
    boundaries...........................  6             4(a)
  Judicial districts,
    Composition, right to alter..........  6             6(b)
    Increase or decrease number,
      right to provide...................  6             6(b)
    Justices in altered districts,
      right to re-apportion..............  6             6(b)
  Judicial officers,
    Compensation of judicial
      officer retired for disability,
      right to provide...................  6            22(c)
  Judicial offices, combination of
    certain, right to provide............  6               14
  Judiciary article, to enact laws
    to effectuate........................  6               33
  Jury, composition in courts of
    original jurisdiction, right
    to provide...........................  6            18(a)
  Jury trial,
    Civil cases,
      Verdict by five-sixths jury, power
        to authorize.....................  1                2
      Waiver, manner, right to enact
        laws.............................  1                2
    Criminal cases, waiver,
      exception, right to enact laws.....  1             2,18
                             -- 27 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Justices of the peace, legislative
    functions on town boards, right to
    abolish..............................  6            17(c)
  Juvenile delinquents, education and
    support, right to provide............  7                8
  Law and equity, jurisdiction and
    proceedings, right to alter and
    regulate.............................  6               30
  Law of state, right to alter...........  1               14
  Legislative power generally, vesting...  3                1
  Lieutenant-governor, salary, power to
    fix..................................  4                6
  Limited dividend housing companies,
    loans by state and local
    governments, right to authorize...... 18                2
  Lotteries, use of proceeds for
    education, to prescribe..............  1                9
  Lotto, right to regulate...............  1                9
  Low rent housing, manner, means,
    terms and conditions, right to
    prescribe............................ 18                1
  Manufacturing plants,
    rehabilitation,
    Indebtedness, guaranty by state...... 10                7
    Loans by state, authorized...........  7                8
  Members,
    Compensation, right to establish.....  3                6
    Elections, returns and
      qualifications, each house to
      judge..............................  3                9
    Senators and assembly members, time
      for holding elections, right to
      fix................................. 3                8
    Services as officer or in special
      capacity, additional allowance,
      right to fix.......................  3                6
  Mental health, protection, manner
    of providing, right to determine..... 17                4
  Mentally ill, education and support,
    power to provide.....................  7                8
  Municipal corporations, public
    improvements and services, power
    to determine exclusions from
    indebtedness, right to provide.......  8            2-a,5
  Municipalities,
    Debt limits, certain exclusions......  8          2-a,4,5
    Laws relating to local government
      right to enact.....................  9              1-3
    Levy of taxes on real estate,
      right to restrict..................  8            10,12
                             -- 28 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    Needy, aid, care and support, right    8                1
      to authorize....................... 17                1
    Payments to institutions for care,
      support and maintenance, right
      to authorize.......................  8                1
    Public improvements and services,
      exclusions of indebtedness.........  8                5
    Right to contract indebtedness
      and levy taxes, power to restrict..  8               12
    State officer or agency to
      determine equalization ratio,
      right to direct....................  8               10
  Needy, aid, care and support, power
    to provide,..........................  7                8
    Manner and means, right to
      determine.......................... 17                1
  Needy sick, aid, care and
    support, right to provide............  7                8
  New York city,
    Capital improvements, period of
      probable usefulness, right to
      determine..........................  8               11
    Counties within, legislative power
      unaffected by home rule provisions. 13            13(c)
    Jurisdiction to determine exclusions
      of indebtedness, right to confer,
      Dock purposes......................  8                7
      School purposes....................  8                7
      Transit purposes...................  8               7a
    Reservation of power to amend or
      repeal laws affecting certain
      county offices, duration........... 13            13(c)
    Tax limitation, determination of
      indebtedness to be excluded,
      right to make conclusive...........  8               11
  Nursing homes accommodations for
    persons of low income, power to
    provide.............................. 18                1
  Officers, each house to choose.........  3                9
  Officers, non-constitutional,
    election or appointment..............  9             1(b)
  Old age, protection against hazards
    right to provide.....................  7                8
  Pardons, regulations governing
    application, right to make...........  4                4
  Parole, systems, right to provide...... 17                5
  Pensions, right to increase amount
    of certain...........................  7                8
  Personnel, abolished courts,
    assignment, right to provide.........  6            35(1)
                             -- 29 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Physically handicapped, education
    and support, right to provide........  7                8
  Port of New York authority, certain
    obligations, right to guarantee...... 10                7
  Practice and procedure, courts,
    right to delegate power to regulate..  6               30
  Primary elections, uncontested, right
    to waive.............................  1                1
  Private property taken for public use..  1                7
  Private roads, opening, right to
    enact laws...........................  1                7
  Probation, systems, right to provide... 17                5
  Public corporations,
    Acquisition of properties and
      payment of indebtedness by state
      or political subdivision, right
      to authorize....................... 10                5
    Indebtedness, future, manner of
      granting local consent, right
      to prescribe.......................  8                3
    Water supply, excess or common,
      right to authorize.................  8              2-a
  Public health, protection and
    promotion, manner and means of
    providing, right to determine........ 17                3
  Public offices,
    Existence of vacancy, right to
      declare............................ 13                6
    Succession thereto, during periods
      of certain emergencies, of right
      to provide therefor................  3               25
    Term of office, right to fix......... 13                2
  Public officers, oath of office,
    right to exempt inferior officers
    from requirement..................... 13                1
  Public officers and employees,
    compensation, power to tax........... 16                5
  Railroad crossings at grade,
    Reimbursement by railroad
      companies, time, manner and
      interest, right to prescribe.......  7               14
    State debt for elimination, right
      to create..........................  7               14
  Railroad passenger facilities,
    obligations, right to guarantee...... 10                7
  Regents, corporate powers, right
    to change............................ 11                2
  Religious schools, inspection, use of
    public property, etc., right to
    authorize............................ 11                3
                             -- 30 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Retirement systems, right to increase
    pensions of members of certain.......  7                8
  Rules of proceedings, each house to
    determine............................  3                9
  School districts (see
    "municipalities" under
    "Legislature. Powers" "School
    Districts").
  Schools, transportation of children,
    right to authorize................... 11                3
  Senators, services on impeachment
    trials, additional allowance, right
    to fix...............................  3                6
  Sewage facilities, exclusion of
    indebtedness from debt limitation,
    right to prescribe...................  8            2-a,5
  Sewage systems, common or excess,
    right to authorize...................  8              2-a
  Sheriff's, renewal of security,
    right to require..................... 13            13(a)
  Sickness, protection against
    hazards, right to provide............  7                8
  Ski trails, certain, construction and
    maintenance on forest preserve
    lands, power to authorize............ 14                1
  Slum clearance, right to provide....... 18                1
  Social welfare, rules and regulations,
    right to prescribe procedure for
    making............................... 17                2
  State commissions, temporary, right to
    create...............................  5                3
  State comptroller, powers and duties
    respecting real estate,
    Assessment, right to assign..........  5                1
    Equalization, right to assign........  5                1
    Taxation, right to assign............  5                1
  State comptroller, duties respecting
    municipalities,
    Accounts, supervision, right to
      assign duty........................  5                1
    Determination of exclusions from
      debt limitation, right to provide..  8              4,5
    New York city fiscal officer,
      approval of determination of
      exclusions from tax limitation,
      right to make conclusive...........  8               11
    Vacancy, right to provide for
      filling............................  5                1
  State debts,
    Laws creating,
                             -- 31 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      Power to forbid contracting of
        further liability................  7               11
      Power to repeal....................  7               11
    Notes or other obligations, right
      to provide for issuance............  7                9
    Power to contract,
      Invasion, etc., to repel...........  7               10
    Taxes and bond proceeds, before
      receiving..........................  7                9
    Privilege of pre-payment,
      reservation........................  7               12
    Probable life of work or purpose,
      right to enact laws................  7               13
  State departments, number, right to
    reduce...............................  5                3
  State departments and officers,
    powers and functions, right to
    assign and change....................  5                3
  State enumeration in lieu of federal
    census, right to provide.............  3                4
  State highways, certain, construction
    and maintenance on forest preserve
    lands, right to authorize............ 14                1
  State highways and parkways,
    construction and reconstruction,
    right to appropriate certain moneys..  7               14
  State properties and revenues,
    offices for protection, right
    to create............................  5                5
  State thruway corporations,
    Bonds, right to make state
      liable............................. 10                6
    Canal lands, right to permit use..... 10                6
    Obligations, right to make state
      liable............................. 10                6
  State university, right to create
    indebtedness.........................  7               19
  Supreme court,
    Justices,
      Decrease in number, right to
        provide..........................  6             6(d)
      Increase in number, limitation.....  6             6(d)
      Removal for cause..................  6            23(a)
    Temporary justices, right to
      provide, during military service of
      elected justices...................  6         20(b)(1)
  Supreme court, appellate division,
    Housing, jurisdiction to determine
      exclusions of indebtedness, right
      to confer.......................... 18                4
                             -- 32 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    Jurisdiction, authority to confer....  6             4(k)
    Municipalities, jurisdiction to
      determine exclusions from
      indebtedness, power to confer......  8           5,7,7a
  Surrogate's courts,
    Judges,
      Additional, right to provide.......  6            12(a)
      Combination with certain other
        judicial offices, right to
        provide..........................  6               14
    Jurisdiction, right to provide.......  6          12(d,e)
  Swamp or agricultural lands, drainage,
    right to enact laws..................  1                7
  Taxation,
    Excise taxes measured by income,
      right to consider income from
      intangibles........................ 16                3
    Exemptions, right to alter or
      repeal, exception.................. 16                1
    Income taxes, reference to federal
      laws authorized....................  3               22
    Power not to be surrendered or
      suspended, exception............... 16                1
    Public officers and employees,
      compensation, right to tax......... 16                5
  Tax revenues, funds for
    stabilization, right to establish....  7               17
  Trial without jury, certain cases,
    right to authorize...................  6            18(a)
  Thruways (see "State thruway
    corporations" under "Legislature,
    Powers").
  Town courts,
    Appeals therefrom, to provide........  6       8(e),11(d)
    Discontinuance, right to provide,
      limitation.........................  6            17(b)
    Judges, manner of removal, to
      provide............................  6            22(i)
    Mandates, service and execution,
      right to provide...................  6             1(c)
    Processes, service and execution,
      right to provide...................  6             1(c)
    Regulation, right to provide.........  6            17(b)
    Warrants, service and execution,
      right to provide...................  6             1(c)
  Town officers, non-constitutional,
    election or appointment..............  9             1(b)
  Towns (see also "Municipalities"
    under "Legislature, Powers"),
    Division, power unaffected by
                             -- 33 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      restrictions on creation of
      assembly districts.................  3                5
    New, power to create unaffected by
      restrictions on assembly
      districts..........................  3                5
    Water supply, excess or common,
      right to authorize.................  8              2-a
  Treason, power to grant reprieves,
    commutations and pardons.............  4                4
  Unemployment,
    Indebtedness to alleviate, guaranty
      by state........................... 10                7
    Loans to alleviate, right to
      authorize..........................  7                8
    Protection against hazards, right
      to provide.........................  7                8
    University of the State of New York,
      corporate powers, right to change.... 11                2
    Vacancy in office, existence, right to
      declare.............................. 13                6
    Veterans, preference in retention in
      civil service, right to provide......  5                6
    Village courts,
      Appeals therefrom, right to provide..  6       8(e),11(d)
      Discontinuance, right to provide.....  6            17(b)
      Judges, manner of removal, to
        provide............................  6            22(i)
      Mandates, service and execution,
        right to provide...................  6             1(c)
      Processes, service and execution,
        right to provide...................  6             1(c)
      Regulation, right to provide.........  6            17(b)
      Warrants, service and execution,
        right to provide...................  6             1(c)
    Village officers, non-constitutional,
      election or appointment..............  9             1(b)
    Villages (see "Municipalities" under
      "Legislature, Powers").
    Villages of 5,000 or more,
      Housing, determination of
        exclusion of indebtedness, right
        to confer jurisdiction............. 18                4
    Village taxes,
      Assessment, levy and collection
        by larger subdivisions, right
        to provide......................... 16                2
      Unpaid, loans or advances by
        counties, right to authorize....... 16                2
    Visitation and inspection, right to
      authorize............................ 16                2
                             -- 34 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    Water supply, excess or common, right
      to authorize.........................  8              2-a
    Wild life and forest conservation
      acquisition of land, right to make
      appropriations....................... 14                3
    Workers' compensation, system, right
      to establish.........................  1               18
  Primary elections, uncontested, right
    to waive...............................  1                1
  Prison labor,
    Occupation and employment of
      prisoners............................  3               24
    Products, disposition to state and
      political subdivisions, authority
      to provide...........................  3               24
  Private and local bills (see "Bills"
    under "Legislature").
  Private roads, opening, power to
    prescribe manner.......................  1                7
  Privilege of members.....................  3               11
  Probation, system, provision............. 17                5
  Public contracts, regulation of certain
    matters affecting...................... 13               14
  Public corporations,
    Creation by special act only,
      exceptions........................... 10                5
    Interstate compact, powers when
      created pursuant to.................. 10                5
    Liability for obligations not to be
      imposed on state or political
      subdivision.......................... 10                5
    Powers, limitation..................... 10                5
  State thruways (see "State thruway
    corporations" under "Legislature,
    Powers").
Public health, protection, provision..... 17                3
Public money or property for local or
  private purposes, two-thirds vote
  required...............................  3               20
Public office, conduct, power of grand
  jury not to be suspended or impaired...  1                6
Public officers (see also "Public
  Officers"),
  Election or appointment when not
    provided by constitution.............  9             1(b)
  Fees or perquisites of office
    not to be received................... 13                7
    .....................................  9             2(c)
  Legislative powers..................... 13               14
  Removal provision...................... 13                5
                             -- 35 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Vacancies in office,
    Existence, declaration............... 13                6
    Filling, provision................... 13                5
Public school system, legislative power..  9             3(a)
Public utilities operated by
  municipalities, restrictions on
  legislative powers.....................  3               18
Public work, hours, days of labor and
  wages..................................  1               17
Qualifications for membership............  3                7
Quorum,
  Majority of members of each house to
    constitute...........................  3                9
  Three-fifths to constitute in certain
    cases................................  3               23
Railroad crossing elimination, amount
  of bond proceeds available for
  highways and parkways..................  7               14
Railroad passenger facilities, certain
  obligations, guaranty.................. 10                7
Recommendations of governor..............  4                3
Refunding state debt prior to maturity...  7               13
Rehabilitation of slum areas, provision.. 18                1
Removal of judicial officers,
  Court of appeals, judges subject to
    removal by concurrent resolution.....  6            23(a)
  Court on the judiciary, time within
    which legislature must act to stay
    action...............................  6            22(e)
    Legislature deemed to be in session
      on receipt of notification.........  6            22(e)
  Supreme court, justices subject to
    removal by concurrent resolution.....  6            23(a)
Reprieves, commutations and pardons,
  duty of governor to communicate........  4                4
Reservoirs,
  Apportionment of costs of improvements. 14                2
  State lands, use, authorization........ 14                2
Restrictions (see also "Duties" and
  "Powers" under "Legislature"),
  Action for wrongful death,
    Damages recoverable not subject to
      statutory limitation...............  1               16
    Existing, not to be abrogated........  1               16
  Adjournment for more than two days,
    consent of both houses required......  3               10
  Alleys, opening, closing, etc.,
    action by general laws only..........  3               17
  Appropriation bills,
    Changes in bills submitted by
                             -- 36 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      governor...........................  7                4
    Provisions to relate to particular
      appropriation......................  7                6
    New, neither house to consider until
      final action on governor's bills...  7                5
  Appropriations,
    Laws making, continuing or reviving,
      sum, object and purpose to be
      distinctly stated..................  7                5
    Separate bills required, each for
      single object or purpose,
      exceptions.........................  7                6
  Banking purposes, prohibition against
    special chargers..................... 10                3
  Bills,
    Appropriations of public money for
      private purposes, two-thirds vote
      for passage........................  3               20
    Final passage........................  3               14
      Last reading, no amendment
        allowed..........................  3               14
      Private or local,
        Cases in which not authorized....  3               17
        Not to embrace more than one
          subject to be expressed in
          title..........................  3               15
    Requirement for printing and
      placing on desks of members,
      exception..........................  3               14
    Three-fifths quorum required for
      passage of certain.................  3               23
  Boards of supervisors, election of
    members, action by general laws only.  3               17
  Bonus, laws creating debt..............  7               18
  Bookmaking, prohibition against
    authorization........................  1                9
  Bridges, building, action by general
    laws only, exception.................  3               17
  Canals,
    Sale, lease, abandonment or other
      disposition, prohibition against... 15                1
      Exception, in case of barge
        canal............................ 15                4
    Tolls for transportation,
      prohibition against imposition..... 15                3
    Work, prohibition against extra
      compensation to contractors........ 15                3
  Capital or infamous crimes, no
    person to be held without
    indictment, exceptions...............  1                6
                             -- 37 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Change of venue, action by general
    laws only............................  3               17
  Cities,
    Annexation of territory, referendum
      required...........................  9             1(d)
    Housing, indebtedness in excess of
      constitutional limitations,
      conditions for authorization....... 18                4
    Property, affairs and government,
      action by general laws only,
      exceptions.........................  9             2(b)
    Special laws affecting, request of
      mayor or local legislative body
      required...........................  9             2(b)
  City officers,
    Elections to be held in odd-
      numbered years, exception.......... 13                8
    Terms of office to expire at end
      of odd-numbered years, exception... 13                8
  City-wide courts, New York city,
    compensation of judges, prohibition
    against decrease during term.........  6            25(a)
  Claims against state,
    Audit, allowance or payment, barred
      by lapse of time...................  3               19
    Private, not to audit or allow.......  3               19
  Corporations, prohibition against
    creation by special act, exception... 10                1
  Counties,
    Prohibition against enactment of
      certain laws.......................  9             2(b)
    Referendum required for certain
      laws following adoption of
      alternative form of government.....  9             1(h)
    Special or local laws affecting,
      prohibition against, exceptions....  9             2(b)
  County court judges, compensation,
    prohibition against decrease during
    term.................................  6            25(a)
  County officers, counties within
    cities,
    Elections to be held in odd-
      numbered years, exception.......... 13                8
    Terms of office to expire at end of
      odd-numbered years, exception...... 13
  County seat, locating or changing......  3               17
  Court of appeals, judges,
    compensation, prohibition against
    decrease during term.................  6            25(a)
  Court of claims, judges, compensation,
                             -- 38 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    prohibition against decrease
    during term..........................  6            25(a)
  Court on the judiciary, retirement
    proceedings not to be stayed by
    legislative action...................  6            22(e)
  Cruel and unusual punishments not to
    be inflicted.........................  1                5
  Defendant in criminal cases, rights....  1                6
  Discrimination in civil rights
    because of race, color, etc.,
    prohibition against..................  1               11
  Disfranchisement, prohibition against,
    exception............................  1                1
  District courts, judges, compensation,
    prohibition against decrease
    during term..........................  6            25(a)
  Divorce, prohibition against granting,
    exception............................  1                9
  Double jeopardy, prohibition against...  1                6
  Due process of law guaranteed..........  1                6
  Elections,
    Boards and officers to be bi-
      partisan...........................  2                8
    Opening and conduct, action by
      general law only...................  3               17
    Secrecy in balloting, requirement....  2                7
  Equal protection of laws guaranteed....  1               11
  Excessive bail and fines, prohibition
    against..............................  1                5
  Exclusive privilege, immunity or
    franchise, action by general laws
    only.................................  3               17
  Exemption from taxation, action by
    general laws only....................  3               17
  Extraordinary sessions, action
    restricted to subjects recommended
    by governor..........................  4                3
  Family court, judges, compensation,
    prohibition against decrease during
    term.................................  6            25(a)
  Forest preserve lands,
    Lease, sale, exchange or taking,
      prohibition against................ 14                1
    Preservation of wild character....... 14                1
    Reservoirs, limitation on use........ 14                2
    Timber, prohibition against sale,
      removal or destruction............. 14                1
  Freedom of speech and press guaranteed.  1                8
  Gambling not to be authorized or
    allowed, exception...................  1                9
                             -- 39 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Grand juries, powers not to be
    suspended or impaired................  1                6
  Habeas corpus, writ not to be
    suspended, exceptions................  1                4
  Highways, opening, closing, etc.,
    action by general laws only..........  3               17
  Housing,
    Local governments,
      Indebtedness, limitation........... 18                4
      Periodic subsidies, limitation on
        duration......................... 18                4
    State debts, laws authorizing........ 18                3
    State loans or subsidies............. 18                6
    State subsidies,
      Payment from general fund only..... 18                2
      Prohibition against payment to
        remedy or avoid certain defaults. 18                5
      Restrictions and limitations....... 18                3
    Tax exemptions, limitation on
      duration........................... 18                2
  Incorporation of existing law by
    reference, prohibition against.......  3               16
  Judges and justices,
    Compensation, prohibition against
      diminution during term.............  6            25(a)
  Judicial officers, certain,
    prohibition against removal except
    for cause............................  6            23(b)
  Jurors, selection, empaneling, etc.,
    action by general laws only..........  3               17
  Labor of human beings not to be
    considered commodity or article of
    commerce.............................  1               17
  Law not to be enacted except by bill...  3               13
  Literature fund, capital to be
    preserved............................ 11                3
  Lottery, prohibition against
    authorization........................  1                9
  Lottery tickets, prohibition against
    sale.................................  1                9
  Members,
    Civil appointments, certain, not to
      receive............................  3                7
    Compensation and allowances,
      prohibition against increase or
      diminution during term.............  3                6
    Extra compensation not to be given...  3                6
  Money, regulating rate of interest,
    action by general laws only..........  3               17
  Municipal public utility services,
                             -- 40 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    laws governing profits...............  3               18
  Municipalities, right to levy taxes
    for previously-contracted
    indebtedness, not to restrict........  8               12
  Names of persons, changing, action by
    general laws only....................  3               17
  New York city, certain county offices
    within,
    Prohibition against passage of
      certain laws affecting,
      exceptions......................... 13            13(c)
  New York city,
    Prohibition against passage of
      certain laws affecting,
      exceptions......................... 13            13(c)
  Pension and retirement systems,
    benefits not to be diminished or
    impaired.............................  5                7
  Petition, right, prohibition against
    abridgement..........................  1                9
  Pool-selling, prohibition against
    authorization........................  1                9
  Prison labor, use and disposition of
    products.............................  3               24
  Prisoners, labor, prohibition against
    certain disposition..................  3               24
  Private property not to be taken
    without just compensation............  1                7
  Public corporations,
    Certain, prohibition against
      creation except by special act..... 10                5
    Creation, prohibition against,
      exceptions.........................  8                3
    Obligations, state or local
      liability, prohibition against
      acceptance or imposition,
      exceptions......................... 10              5,6
    Powers to contract indebtedness and
      collect real estate charges,
      referendum required, exception..... 10                5
  Public officers,
    Compensation fixed by law, not to
      receive additional................. 13                7
    Members of legislature...............  3                6
    Fees, etc., increasing or decreasing
      during term, action by general
      laws only..........................  3               17
    Oath of office, constitutional,
      other tests prohibited............. 13                1
  Public work, limitation on days, hours
                             -- 41 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    and wages............................  1               17
  Railroad tracks, privilege of laying,
    action by general laws only..........  3               17
  Registration of voters, certain cities
    and villages, personal application
    not required.........................  2                5
  Religious schools, aid or maintenance,
    use of public money or property
    prohibited........................... 11                3
  Religious worship, freedom, guaranty...  1                3
  Right of assembly and petition not to
    be abridged..........................  1                9
  Roads, opening, closing, etc., action
    by general laws only.................  3               17
  Savings banks, capital stock and
    interests of directors and trustees.. 10                3
  Searches and seizures, unreasonable,
    prohibited...........................  1               12
  Self-incrimination, prohibition
    against..............................  1                6
  Senate districts, formation............  3                4
  State comptroller, prohibition
    against assignment of administrative
    duties, exception....................  5                1
  State credit, prohibition against
    gifts or loans for private purposes,
    exceptions...........................  7                8
  State debts,
    Laws creating, approval of people
      required, limitations on
      submission.........................  7               11
    Manner of payment, limitations.......  7               12
    Prohibition against contracting
      except for single work or purpose..  7               11
    Term not to exceed probable life of
      work or purpose....................  7               12
  State departments, new, prohibition
    against..............................  5                3
  State officers, constitutional,
    Compensation, prohibition against
      increase or decrease during term... 13                7
    Fees, prohibition against receiving.. 13                7
  State moneys, prohibition against gifts
    or loans for private purposes,
    exceptions...........................  7                8
  Street railroads, construction or
    operation, consents required.........  3               17
  Supreme court justices,
    Compensation, prohibition against
      decrease during term...............  6            25(a)
                             -- 42 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    Number, limitation...................  6             6(d)
  Surrogates' court, judges,
    compensation, prohibition against
    decrease during term.................  6            25(a)
  Swamp or agricultural lands, drainage,
    prohibition against special laws.....  1                7
  Swamps and low lands, draining, action
    by general laws only.................  3               17
  Taxation,
    Assessments not to exceed full
      value.............................. 16                2
    Exemptions, granting by general laws
      only............................... 16                1
    Intangible personal property,
      Excise tax, prohibition against
        levy because of ownership or
        possession....................... 16                3
  Taxing ad valorem, prohibition
    against.......................... 16                3
    Religious, education and charitable
      corporations, certain, prohibition
      against alteration or repeal of
      exemptions......................... 16                1
    Surrender or suspension of power,
      prohibition against, exception..... 16                1
    Undistributed profits, prohibition
      against taxing..................... 16                3
  Taxes, discrimination in rates or
    methods prohibited................... 16                4
  Tax laws, tax and object to be
    distinctly stated....................  3               22
  Tax revenues, funds for stabilization,
    requirements.........................  7               17
  Telephone and telegraph communications,
    communications, unreasonable
    interceptions prohibited.............  1               12
  Trial by jury, right to remain
    inviolate............................  1                2
  United States deposit fund, capital
    to be preserved...................... 11                3
  Vacancies in office, elective,
    limitation on duration of
    appointments......................... 13                3
  Villages,
    Incorporation, action by general
      law only...........................  3               17
    Property, affairs or government, action
      by general laws only, exceptions...  9             2(b)
    Special laws affecting, prohibition
      against, exceptions................  9             2(b)
                             -- 43 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Villages, 5,000 or more,
    Housing, indebtedness in excess of
      constitutional limitations,
      conditions for authorization....... 18                4
  Voting, designating places, action by
    general laws only....................  3               17
  Wild life conservation and reforestation,
    prohibition against lease, sale,
    exchange or taking of lands.......... 14                3
  Witnesses, prohibition against
    unreasonable detention...............  1                5
  Rules and regulations of state
    agencies, filing and publication.....  4                8
  Rules of proceedings, each house
    to determine.........................  3                9
  Savings banks,
    Charters to be made uniform.......... 10                3
    Special charters not to be
      granted............................ 10                3
  School districts (see "School Districts").
    Schools (see "Schools").
  Senate (see also "Senate"):
    Heads of departments, appointment
      subject to advice and consent......  5                4
    Lieutenant-governor to have only
      casting vote.......................  4                6
    Members of boards and commissions,
      appointment subject to advice and
      consent............................  5                4
    President, lieutenent-governor to
      serve..............................  4                6
Senate districts (see "Senate Districts").
  Senators (see "Senators")
  Sessions,
  Annual session, time for meeting....... 13                4
    Court on the judiciary, notification
      of removal charges, legislature
      deemed to be in session............  6            22(e)
  Extraordinary,
    Governor, power to convene...........  4                3
    Subjects recommended by governor,
      action restricted to...............  4                3
    Sinking funds (see "Sinking Funds").
    Slum clearance (see "Housing" under
      "Legislature").
Social welfare (see Social Welfare").
  Social welfare board (see "Social Welfare
    Board").
Speaker, assembly to choose..............  3                9
Special laws (see "Local Laws," "Special
                             -- 44 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Laws").
Special sessions (see Special Sessions,
  New York city" under "Duties").
  State agencies, powers and formation...  5                3
State claims or demands, bills releasing,
  three-fifths quorum for passage........  3               23
State comptroller (see "State
  Comptroller").
State debts (see also "State"),
  Approval, power to forbid further
    debt or liability....................  7               11
  Bills creating, three-fifths quorum
    for passage..........................  3               23
    Refunding, conditions................  7               13
    Repeal, when allowable...............  7               11
    Single purpose or work, statement
      in law authorizing.................  7               11
State departments (see also "State
  Departments"),
    Assignment of new powers and
      functions..........................  5                3
    Consolidation........................  5                3
    New departments not to be created....  5                3
    Powers and functions, assignment
      and change.........................  5                3
    Reduction of number..................  5                3
State enumeration, when to be made.......  3                4
State thruways (see "State thruway
  corporations" under Legislature. Powers").
Statutory revision bills not subject to
  certain restrictions...................  3               21
Subsidies for housing purposes
  (see "Housing").
Support, certain persons,
  power to provide.......................  7                8
Supreme court (see also "Supreme Court"
  under "Powers" and "Restrictions").
  Justices,
    Increase of number, limitation.......  6             6(d)
    Reapportionment in altered
      judicial districts.................  6             6(b)
    Removal from office for cause........  6            23(a)
    Retirement for disability............  6            22(a)
    Temporary, during military service
      of elected justices................  6         20(b)(1)
Surrogates' courts (see "Surrogates' court"
  under "Powers" and "Restrictions").
Swamp or agricultural lands, drainage,
  authorization by general law...........  1                7
Tax limitation on realty, detemination of
                             -- 45 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  local indebtedness.....................  8               11
Taxation (see also "Taxation and taxes"),
  Supervision, review and equalization
    of assessments......................  16               2
  Taxes, laws imposing, continuing or
    reviving,
    Nature and object of tax to be
      distinctly stated..................  3               22
    Prohibition against fixing tax or
      object by reference to existing
      law................................  3               22
    Quorum, three-fifths, required
      for passage........................  3               23
  Tax revenue stabilization fund,
    authorization........................  7               17
Temporary president, senate to choose....  3                9
Temporary state commissions(see "State
  Commissions").
Term, legislative, commencement.......... 13                4
Three-fifths quorum required for
  passing certain bills..................  3               23
Thruway corporations (see "State
  thruway corporations" under
  "Legislature Powers").
Time of assembly each year............... 13                4
Time to act following notification by
  court on the judiciary.................  6            22(e)
Town courts (see "Town courts" under
  "Duties" and "Powers").
Town officers, election..................  2                7
Towns (see also "Towns"),
  Creation of new, unaffected by
    restrictions on assembly districts...  3                5
  Division, unaffected by restrictions
    on assembly districts................  3                5
  Payments to certain institutions,
    authorization........................  8                1
Transportation of school children........ 11                3
Treason, pardon, commutation or
  reprieve after conviction..............  4                4
University of the state of New York,
  powers................................. 11                2
Vacancy in office (see "Vacancy in
  Office").
Village courts (see "Village courts"
  under "Duties" and "Powers").
Villages (see "villages").
Vote required for action,
  Majority vote, ordinary quorum,
    Assembly, power of impeachment.......  6               24
                             -- 46 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    Bills, generally.....................  3               14
    Constitutional amendments,
      concurrent resolutions proposing... 19                1
  Majority vote, three-fifths quorum,
    Appropriations of public money or
      property, bills making,continuing
      or reviving........................  3               23
    Debt or charge against state, bills
      creating...........................  3               23
    Claim or demand of state, bills
      releasing, discharging or commuting  3               23
    Taxes, bills imposing, continuing or
      reviving...........................  3               23
  Two-thirds vote, ordinary quorum,
    Appropriations for local or private
      purposes...........................  3               20
    Court of appeals, judges, concurrent
      resolutions removing from office...  6            23(a)
    Court for trial of impeachments,
      conviction.........................  6               24
    Items of appropriation disapproved,
      passage over veto..................  4                7
    Local governments, special bills
      affecting..........................  9             2(b)
    New York city, certain bills relating
      to certain county offices.......... 13            13(c)
  Supreme court, justices, concurrent
    resolutions removing from office.....  6            23(a)
    Vetoed bills, passage on
      reconsideration....................  4                7
  Workers' compensation, system, laws....  1               18
  Yeas and nays to be taken on final
  passage of bills.......................  3            14,23
Libel:
Criminal prosecutions or indictments,
  Acquittal, when required...............  1                8
  Jury, determination of law and fact....  1                8
  Truth may be given in evidence.........  1                8
Liberty (see also "Rights and Privileges"):
Conscience, not to excuse certain
  acts and practices.....................  1                3
Freedom of speech and press guaranteed...  1                8
Guaranty against deprivation without
  due process of law.....................  1                6
Religious worship and belief, guaranty...  1                3
Licentiousness:
Liberty of conscience not to excuse
  acts of................................  1                3
Lieutenant-Governor (see also
Lieutenant-Governor-Elect"):
                             -- 47 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Absence from state, temporary
  president of senate to act               4                6
Absence or impeachment, temporary
  president to preside                     3                9
Acting governor, when to serve...........  4                5
Compensation.............................  4                6
Election,
  Jointly, with governor.................  4                1
Single vote, applicable to both
    governor and lieutenant-governor.....  4                1
  Time...................................  4              1,6
Eligibility for office, qualifications...  4                6
Governor,
  Duties when performed by lieutenant-
    governor.............................  4                5
  Election jointly with lieutenant-
    governor.............................  4                1
Impeachment,
  Court for trial, not to serve as
    member...............................  6               24
  Temporary president of senate to act...  4                6
Inability to discharge powers and duties
  of governor, temporary president of
  senate to act..........................  4                6
Qualifications for office,
  Age....................................  4              2,6
  Citizenship requirement................  4              2,6
  Residence in state.....................  4              2,6
Senate, president, to serve,.............  4                6
  Casting vote only......................  4                6
Succession to office.....................  4                6
Term of office...........................  4                1
Vacancy in office,
  Governor and lieutenant-governor,
    temporary president of senate to act.  4                6
  Governor and lieutenant-governor,
    vacancies to be filled for
    unexpired terms......................  4                6
  Temporary president of senate to act...  4                6
  Votes, highest number to determine
    election.............................  4                1
Lieutenant-Governor-Elect:
Death of governor-elect prior to assuming
  office, lieutenant-governor
  elect to serve.........................  4                5
Life:
Guaranty against deprivation without due
  process of law                           1                6
Loans:
Counties, money and credit for private
                             -- 48 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  purposes prohibited, exceptions........  8                1
Counties to villages, advancement of
  taxes,authorization                     16                2
Low rent housing, authorization.......... 18                2
Municipal corporation, money and credit
  for private purposes prohibited,
  exceptions.............................  8                1
Municipalities,
  Legislature's duty to restrict powers..  9                9
  Low rent housing, authorization........ 18                2
Savings banks and institutions, interest
  of director or trustee prohibited...... 10                3
School district, money and credit for
  private purposes prohibited,
  exceptions.............................  8                1
State,
  Housing,
    Conditions........................... 18                6
    Subsidies to avoid municipal default,
      prohibition against................ 18                5
  Low rent housing, authorization........ 18                2
  Money for private purposes prohibited,
    exceptions...........................  7                8
  Nursing home accommodations,
    authorization........................ 18                2
  Power to borrow money..................  7                9
  Public housing corporation,
    liability of municipality............ 18                5
  Towns, money and credit for private
    purposes prohibited, exceptions......  8                1
  Villages, money and credit for private
    purposes prohibited, exceptions......  8                1
Local Bills (see "Bills,"
"Local Laws," "Special Laws").
Local Finances (see also "Municipalities"):
General provisions relating to...........  8             1-12
Local Government (see also "Municipalities"
and specific headings):
Existing consistent laws continued.......  9             3(b)
General provisions relating to...........  9              1-3
Local Laws (see also "Bills,"
"Special Laws"):
Adoption and amendment, power
  of local governments...................  9             1(a)
  .......................................                2(c)
Cases in which private or local
  bills are not authorized...............  3               17
City of New York, abolition of certain
  county offices.........................  9                8
Existing consistent laws, continuation...  9               13
                             -- 49 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Limitation to one subject to
  be expressed in title,.................  3               15
Statutory revision bills excepted........  3               21
Statutory revision bills not
  subject to certain restrictions........  3               21
Title, subject to be expressed...........  3               15
Lotteries:
Authorization for operation by state.....  1                9
Lottery Tickets:
Authorization for sale of certain........  1                9
LOTTO:
Conduct authorized, subject to certain
  limitations............................  1                9
LOW RENT HOUSING (See "Housing").
MAGISTRATES' COURT:
New York city,
  Abolished..............................  6            35(a)
  Actions and proceedings, transferred
    to city-wide court of criminal
    jurisdiction.........................  6            35(f)
  Appeals, where taken...................  6            35(m)
  Documents, disposal thereof............  6            35(a)
  Judges, to be judges of city-wide
    court of criminal jurisdiction.......  6            35(d)
  Papers, disposal thereof...............  6            35(a)
  Personnel, non-judicial, assigned to
    certain courts.......................  6            35(1)
  Records, disposal thereof..............  6            35(a)
  Seal, disposal thereof.................  6            35(a)
MAJOR-GENERAL (see "Militia").
MAJORITY VOTE (see "Legislature").
MANDATES:
Courts, service and execution............  6             1(c)
MANUFACTURING PLANTS:
Rehabilitation,
  Indebtedness, guaranty by state........ 10                7
  Loans by state, authorized.............  7                8
MAYORS:
New York city, mayor and local
  legislative body may request merger
  of city-wide courts of civil and
  criminal jurisdiction..................  6             1(a)
  .......................................               15(a)
Special laws, requests...................  9            11,16
MECHANIC'S LIENS:
Jurisdiction in foreclosure,
  County courts..........................  6            11(a)
  District courts........................  6            16(d)
  New York city-wide court of civil
                             -- 50 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    jurisdiction.........................  6            15(b)
MENTAL DEFECTIVES:
State to provide for care and treatment.. 17               4
MENTAL HYGIENE, DEPARTMENT OF:
Head of department,
  Appointment and removal................  5                4
  Visitation of institutions............. 17                4
Institutions not subject to inspection
  by social welfare board................ 17                2
MENTALLY ILL:
Education, power of legislature to
  provide................................  7                8
Support, legislative power to provide....  7                8
MILITARY FORCES (see "Militia").
MILITIA:
Legislature, to provide for maintenance
  and regulation......................... 12                1
Maintenance and regulation, legislative
  duty to provide........................ 12                1
MINORS (see "Children").
MISDEMEANORS:
Prosecution by indictment, legislature
  may grant jurisdiction thereof to
  city-wide court of criminal
  jurisdiction, New York city............  6       7(a),15(c)
MONEY (see also "State Moneys"):
Action for recovery thereof,
  County court, limitation...............  6           11(a)
  District court, limitation.............  6           16(d)
  New York city-wide court, civil
    jurisdiction, limitation.............  6           15(b)
Bills appropriating, passage.............  4               7
Location for purposes of taxation........ 16               3
Rate of interest not to be regulated by
  private or local bill..................  3              17
MOTOR VEHICLES, DEPARTMENT OF:
Head of department, appointment and
  removal................................  4               4
MULTIPLE DWELLINGS:
Loans for rehabilitation................. 18               2
MUNICIPAL CORPORATIONS (see
"Municipalities").
MUNICIPAL COURT:
New York city,
  Abolished..............................  6            35(a)
  Actions and proceedings, transferred to
    city-wide court of civil jurisdiction  6            35(e)
  Appeals, where taken...................  6            35(m)
    Documents, disposal thereof..........  6            35(a)
  Judges, to be judges of city-wide court
                             -- 51 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    of civil jurisdiction for remainder
    of term..............................  6            35(c)
  Papers, disposal thereof...............  6            35(a)
  Personnel, non-judicial, assigned to
    certain courts.......................  6            35(l)
  Records, disposal thereof..............  6            35(a)
  Seal, disposal thereof.................  6            35(a)
MUNICIPALITIES (see also specific titles,
"Cities," "Towns," etc.):
Accounts, supervision by state
  comptroller............................  5                1
Advances by counties to towns and school
  districts..............................  8                1
Agencies, payments to certain private,
  authorized.............................  8                1
Assessed valuation of real property,
  limitations based on, housing.......... 18                4
Assessments, cities, towns and villages,
  legislative power to restrict..........  8               12
Assessments, state comptroller's powers..  5                1
Average full valuation of real property
  as basis for tax limitation............  8               10
Bingo may be authorized by certain.......  1                9
Bridges, building, authorization by
  private or local bill..................  3               17
Bonds (see also "Indebtedness" under
  "Municipalities"),
  Amortization, payment of interest and
    principal............................  8                2
  Ownership in private corporation
    prohibited...........................  8                1
  Pension or retirement system,
    limitation of indebtedness...........  8                5
  Redemption, appropriations.............  8                2
Charitable institutions, payments
  authorized.............................  8                1
Civil service, appointments and
  promotions.............................  5                6
Compensation of public officers subject
  to taxation............................ 16                5
Correctional institutions,
  Funds for privately operated,
    authorized...........................  8                1
  Indebtedness for maintenance and
    education of inmates.................  8                1
Creation (see also "Organization" under
  "Municipalities"),
   Certain municipal corporations,
   restrictions..........................  8                3
  Prohibition against special laws
                             -- 52 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    inapplicable......................... 10                1
Drainage systems,
  Common or excess, authorized...........  8              2-a
  Indebtedness, exclusion from debt
    limitation...........................  8              2-a
  Revenues, restrictions on use..........  8              2-a
Election, indebtedness...................  8                1
Eleemosynary institutions, payments to...  8                1
Employees,
  Salaries and hours, provision..........  9             2(c)
  Welfare and safety, provision..........  9             2(c)
Existing laws to continue until changed,
  exceptions.............................  9             3(b)
Expenditures, taxes excluded from tax
  limitation of certain..................  8               11
Family homes, indebtedness for
  maintenance and education..............  8                1
Finance (see "Indebtedness" under
  "Municipalities").
Firefighters, retired, pensions may be
  increased..............................  8                1
Forest lands, construction etc.,
  of reservoirs.......................... 14                2
Gift of money or credit for private
  purposes prohibited, exceptions........  8                1
Grade crossing elimination,
  liability for proportion...............  7               14
Health service for children,
  authorization..........................  8                1
Housing (see also "Housing"),
  Corporations, indebtedness, guaranty
    of payment, authorization............ 18                2
  Loans for rehabilitation............... 18                2
  Multiple dwellings, owners of
    existing, loans prohibited........... 18               10
Indebtedness,
  Action to compel setting apart funds
    for payment..........................  8                2
  Advances to towns and school districts
    by counties for unpaid taxes.........  8                1
  Amount, determination..................  8                4
  Appropriation for payment..............  8                2
  Children, education and care
    authorized...........................  8                1
  County within or co-terminous
    with city............................  8                9
  Creation of debt by public
    corporations, consent required.......  8                3
  Drainage purposes, exclusion
    from limitation......................  8              2-a
                             -- 53 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    .....................................  8             5-7a
  Exclusions from debt limitation........ 18              4,5
  Exclusions from tax limitation.........  8               11
  Family homes, maintenance
    and education........................  8                1
  Fiscal officer, setting apart
    money for payment....................  8                2
  Housing (see "Housing").
  Legislature may limit power of levying
    taxes or incurring indebtedness......  8               12
  Limitations............................  8              2,4
  Loans by state to public housing
    corporations, liability.............. 18                5
    City, exclusion of liability
      from debt limit.................... 18                5
  Mental defectives, care authorized..... 17                4
  Needy, care authorized.................  8                1
  New York city (see "New York City").
  Payment, provisions, exception.........  8                2
  Pension and retirement systems,
    exclusion from limitation............  8                5
  Period for which contracted
    or refunded..........................  8                2
  Pledge of faith and credit for
    payment,.............................  8                2
    Housing projects..................... 18                4
  Power to contract,
    Counties, where power ceases.........  8                9
    Limitations and restrictions.........  8             1-12
      ...................................  8            3-7a,
    Manner of ascertainment..............                9,12
  Prior indebtedness not affected
    by constitutional limitations........  8                8
  Public corporations....................  8                3
  Public improvements and services,
    exclusion from debt limitation,
    Amount, methods of determination.....  8                5
    Annual net revenue, condition,
      determination......................  8                5
    Average net revenue, power of
      legislature........................  8                5
    Conditions, limitations and
      restrictions.......................  8                5
    Drainage purposes, exclusion
      from limitation....................  8              2-a
    Excess revenues, use.................  8                5
    Existing exclusions unaffected.......  8                5
    First year of operation..............  8                5
    Legislature, powers..................  8                5
    Net revenue, methods
                             -- 54 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
      of determination...................  8                5
    Other exclusions granted by
      constitution unaffected............  8                5
    Revenues, application and use........  8                5
    Sewage purposes, exclusion
      from limitation....................  8            2-a,5
    State comptroller to make
      determination, legislature
      may provide........................  8            2-a,5
    Supreme court, jurisdiction to
      determine amount, power to confer..  8                5
  Purposes for which contracted..........  8                2
  Refunding, conditions..................  8                2
  Sewage purposes, exclusion
    from limitation......................  8              2-a
  Short term certificates,
    exclusion from debt limitations......  8                5
  Tax limitation on real property........  8            10-12
  Validity of certain not affected.......  8                8
  Void when contracted in excess
    of limitations, exceptions...........  8                4
  Water supply, exclusion from limitation  8                5
    Institutions, payment to certain,
    authorized...........................  8                1
  Joint municipal facilities or services,
    Municipalities may join
    together to provide..................  8                1
  Indebtedness, joint or several,
    may be contracted therefor...........  8                1
  Taxes and charges may be imposed
    therefor.............................  8                1
  Laws relating to government, reservation
    of legislative power.................  9             2(c)
Loans,
  Credit, legislature to restrict powers.  8               12
  Multiple dwellings, low rent projects,
    public corporations.................. 18                2
  Nursing homes, accommodations
    for persons of low income............ 18                2
  State,
    Housing project, subsidy to
      avoid default prohibited........... 18                5
    Public housing corporation,
      liability.......................... 18                5
Lotto may be authorized by certain.......  1                9
Municipal public utility services
(see also "Public improvements and
services" under "Municipalities"):
  Fair returns on property used..........  3               18
  General municipal purposes,
                             -- 55 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    use of profits.......................  3               18
  Operating costs and reserves,
    earnings above not prohibited........  3               18
  Operation, certain restrictions on
    legislative power....................  3               18
  Refund to consumers, use of profits....  3               18
  Revenues and profits, use not
    subject to certain legislative
      restrictions.......................  3               18
  Taxes, amounts equivalent to,
    right to earn........................  3               18
Nursing homes, loans to corporations
  authorized............................. 18                2
Officers (See also "Public Officers"),
  Election when no constitutional
    provision............................  9             1(b)
  Extra compensation prohibited..........
  Legislative power......................  8               12
Organization (see also "Creation"
  under "Municipalities"),
  Cities, provision......................  9             2(a)
  Counties, provision....................  9             2(a)
  Towns, provision.......................  9             2(a)
  Villages, provision....................  9             2(a)
Orphan asylums, payments to..............  8                1
Pensions not subject to taxation......... 16                5
Pension and retirement systems, debts
  excluded in computing limitation.......  8                5
Pledge of faith and credit,
  Low rent housing projects.............. 18                4
  Payment of indebtedness,...............  8                2
    Public corporations..................  8                3
Police officers, retired, pensions may be
  increased..............................  8                1
Prison labor, may benefit from work done
  by or receive products of .............  3               24
Private corporations or associations,
  ownership of stocks or bonds prohibited  8                1
Public corporations (see also "Public
  Corporations"),
  Acquisition of properties and payment
    of indebtedness...................... 10                5
    Creation, consent required...........  8                3
    Inclusion in debt limitation.........  8                3
  Liability for obligations prohibited... 10                5
Public health, protection, provision..... 17                3
Public improvements and services (see
  also "Municipal public utility
  services" under "Municipality"),
  Exclusion from debt limitation.........  8           2-a, 5
                             -- 56 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Expenditures, certain, exclusion from
    tax limitation of certain............  8               11
  Revenues of certain, application and
    use,.................................  8             10-a
  Water supply, restrictions
    inapplicable to......................  8             10-a
Public work, employees...................  1               17
  .......................................  9             2(c)
Railroad crossing elimination, liability
  for expense............................  7               14
Reformatories, payments to...............  8                1
Refunding indebtedness, conditions.......  8                2
Reservoirs, cost of operation and
  improvements, how apportioned.......... 14                2
Retirement system, debts excluded in
  computing limitation...................  8                5
Revenue producing services...............  8          5, 10-a
School district, advances by county for
  unpaid taxes...........................  8                1
Sewage systems,
  Common or excess, authorized...........  8              2-a
    Indebtedness, exclusion from debt
    limitation...........................  8              2-a
  Revenues, restrictions on use..........  8              2-a
Social welfare, provision................ 17                1
State social welfare board,
  Inspection of institution, agency or
    home.................................  8                1
  Visitation of institution.............. 17                2
Stock, ownership in private corporations
  prohibited.............................  8                1
Taxes and assessments,
  Appropriations for redemption of
    certain evidence of indebtedness.....  8                2
  Average assessed valuation, manner of
    determining for debt limit purposes..  8                4
  Average full valuation, manner of
    determining for tax limit purposes...  8               10
  Cities, counties, towns and villages,
    legislature to restrict powers.......  8               12
  Education purposes, exclusion from tax
    limit of certain.....................  8               10
  Expenditures, certain, exclusion from
    tax limitation.......................  8               11
  Limitation of power....................  8               12
  Public corporations, certain, consent
    to contract indebtedness.............  8                3
  Real property, power to levy,
    limitations, exclusions..............  8               3,
      ...................................               10-12
                             -- 57 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Redevelopment projects................. 16                6
  State comptroller's powers.............  5                1
  Towns, advances by county for unpaid
    taxes................................  8                1
  Water supply,
    Common, authorized...................  8              2-a
  Excess, authorized.....................  8              2-a
  Indebtedness, exclusion from debt
    limitation...........................  8           2-a, 5
  Revenues, restrictions on use
    inapplicable.........................  8             10-a
NAMES OF PERSONS:
Change by private or local bill
  prohibited.............................  3               17
Nassau County:
District court, continued................  6            16(a)
Indebtedness, limitation, exceptions.....  8                4
National Guard (see "Militia").
Naval Forces (see also "Militia"):
Governor to be commander-in-chief........  4                3
Navigation:
Voting residence of persons engaged in...  2                4
Needy (see also "Social Welfare"):
.........................................  7                8
Aid, care and support....................  8                1
  ......................................  17                1
Neglected Children (see also "Children"):
Aid and support, power to provide........  7                8
Family court, jurisdiction...............  6         13(b)(1)
State board of social welfare, visitation
  of institutions........................ 17                2
New Trial:
Appeal from order of appellate division
  granting...............................  6          3(b)(3)
Appellate court may grant................  6             5(a)
New York Authority, Port of (see "Port of
New York Authority")
New York City (see also "Cities"):
Acquisition of land for docks, financing.  8                2
Appointment and removal of county clerks. 13            13(a)
Appointment or election of county
  officers when not provided by
  constitution........................... 13            13(c)
Bonds,
  Debts excluded in computing limitation.  8             5, 7
    .....................................                  7a
  Financing..............................  8                2
Capital improvements, exclusion from tax
  limitation.............................  8               11
Certificates of indebtedness, debts
                             -- 58 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  excluded from limitation...............  8            5, 7,
  .......................................                  7a
City-wide courts (see "City-Wide Courts,
  New York City").
  Council thereof, to have powers of local
    legislative body.....................  9             2(e)
Counties in city,
  Abolition of certain offices and
    assignment of functions.............. 13            13(c)
  District attorney, election and removal 13            13(a)
  Election or appointment of officers
    not provided by constitution......... 13            13(c)
  Elective officers to continue in office 13            13(c)
  Existing laws to continue.............. 13            13(c)
  Legislative power over................. 13            13(c)
  Real estate, limitation of taxes.......  8               10
  Taxes on real estate, limitation.......  8               10
County clerks (see also "County Clerks"),
  Appointment and removal................ 13            13(a)
  Assignment of duties to city officers.. 13            13(c)
County courts (see specific counties).
  County offices,
    Abolition of certain, assignment of
    duties to city officers.............. 13            13(c)
  Elections.............................. 13                8
  Term of office of certain.............. 13            13(c)
Court of general sessions
  (see "General Sessions").
District attorney (see also "District
  Attorney),
  Election and removal................... 13            13(a)
  Term of office......................... 13            13(c)
Docks,
  Debts excluded from limitation.........  8                7
  Financing by bonds.....................  8                2
Domestic relations court(see "Domestic
  Relations Court").
Election or appointment of county officers
  when not provided by constitution...... 13            13(c)
Fiscal officer, exclusion of certain
  indebtedness from tax limitation.......  8               11
General sessions (see "General Sessions").
Grade crossing elimination, amount of
  state money to be segregated...........  7               14
Hospitals, indebtedness, amount excluded
  in computing limitation................  8                7
Improvements, certain, debts excluded
  from limitation .......................  8                7
Indebtedness,
  Contribution to sinking fund for
                             -- 59 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    payment..............................  8                2
  Debts excluded from limitation.........  8             5,7,
    .....................................                  7a
  Financing by bonds.....................  8                2
  Limitation.............................  8                4
  Payment for certain improvements.......  8                2
Installments, payment of
  indebtedness...........................  8                2
Legislature,
  County officers or clerks, passage of
    laws affecting....................... 13            13(c)
  Message from governor required on laws
    affecting certain county officers.... 13            13(c)
  Two-thirds vote required on laws
    affecting certain county officers.... 13            13(c)
Local laws, abolition of certain
  county officers........................ 13            13(c)
Magistrate's court (see "Magistrate's
  Court").
Pensions, benefits, increase
  authorized for dependents of certain
    employees............................  8                1
Railroads,
  Debts excluded in computing limitation.  8             7,7a
  Financing by bonds.....................  8                2
  Grade crossing elimination, amount
    of state money to be segregated......  7               14
Rapid Transit (see "Railroads under
  "New York City").
Schools, certain debts excluded
  from limitation........................  8                7
Sheriffs (see "Sheriffs").
Special sessions (see "Courts Of Special
  Sessions")
Subways, debts excluded in computing
  limitation.............................  8             7,7a
Supreme Court (see "Supreme Court").
  Taxes,
  Limitation on annual, on real estate...  8               10
  Real estate, annual, limitation........  8               10
  Valuation affecting limitation of
    indebtedness.........................  8                7
  Valuation limiting indebtedness........  8                4
Water supply, financing by bonds.........  8                2
NEW YORK Colony:
Common law, acts and resolutions
  constituting law of state..............  1               14
NEW YORK COUNTY:
Court of general sessions,
  Abolished..............................  6            35(a)
                             -- 60 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Actions and proceedings, transferred
    to supreme court.....................  6            35(b)
  Appeals, where taken...................  6            35(m)
  Documents, disposal thereof............  6            35(a)
Court of general sessions-(Concluded)
  Judges, to be justices of supreme court
    for remainder of term................  6            35(b)
  Papers, disposal thereof...............  6            35(a)
  Personnel, non-judicial, assigned to
    certain courts.......................  6            35(l)
  Records, disposal thereof..............  6            35(a)
  Seal, disposal thereof.................  6            35(a)
NEW YORK PORT AUTHORITY (see "Port of New
York Authority").
NEW YORK STATE BAR ASSOCIATION:
Court on the judiciary, request by
  majority of executive committee to
    convene..............................  6            22(d)
NON-JUDICIAL PERSONNEL:
Abolished courts, assignment thereof.....  6            35(l)
NON-PROFIT CORPORATIONS:
Tax exemption not to be altered
  or repealed............................ 16                1
NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATIONS:
Bingo or lotto, conducted by certain,
  authorized.............................  1                9
NURSING HOMES:
Accommodations for persons of low income,
   legislature may provide............... 18                1
Contracts,
  State subsidies, legislature
    may provide.......................... 18                2
  Subsidies to corporations authorized... 18                2
Loans, authorization..................... 18                2
Subsidies, legislature may provide....... 18                2
OATH OR AFFIRMATION:
Court for trial of impeachments, members
  to take................................  6               24
Public officers to take.................. 13                1
Search and seizures,
  Telephone and telegraph communications,
    warrant for interception to be
    supported............................  1               12
  Warrant to be supported................  1               12
OBLIGATION OF DEBT:
Preservation.............................  1               15
OFFENSES:
Certain, jurisdiction of family court....  6         13(b)(7)
OFFICE:
                             -- 61 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Duration, not provided by constitution... 13                2
OFFICERS (see "Public Officers").
OLD AGE:
Legislature, power to provide protection
  against hazards........................  7                8
ONEIDA COUNTY:
Special county judge, office abolished,
  judge to be judge of family court for
    remainder of term....................  6            35(g)
OPINIONS:
Attorney general, constitutional
  amendment.............................. 19                1
ORDERS:
Habeas Corpus............................  1                3
Interception of telephone and
  telegraph communications, conditions
  for issuance...........................  1               12
ORGANIZATION:
Labor, right.............................  1               17
ORPHAN ASYLUM (see also"Charitable
Institutions").
Municipalities, authorization of
  indebtedness...........................  8               1
OSWEGO CANAL (see also "Canal"):
Disposition, prohibition against......... 15               1
Exceptions............................... 15               2
PAPERS:
Abolished courts, to be deposited with
  clerk of county in which courts are
  located................................  6           35(a)
PARDONS:
Communications of each case
  to legislature by governor.............  4               4
Governor, power to grant, exceptions.....  4               4
Treason, power of legislature
  to grant after conviction..............  4               4
PARENT AND CHILD (see "Children").
PARI-MUTUEL BETTING:
Horse races, authorization...............  1               9
Revenue, derivation......................  1               9
PARKS:
Condemnation of property, excess taking..  1               7
PARKWAYS (see "Highways").
PAROLE:
Children, religious persuasion
  to control.............................  6              32
Legislature to provide system............ 17               5
PASSENGERS, RAILROAD (see "Port of New York
Authority").
PATERNITY:
                             -- 62 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Establishment, jurisdiction of
  family court...........................  6        13(b)(5)
PEACEMAKER COURTS:
Continued................................  6              32
Judiciary article inapplicable...........  6              32
PENITENTIARIES (see "Correctional
Institutions," "Prisons," "Reformatories").
PENSIONS AND RETIREMENT SYSTEMS:
Benefits not to be
  diminished or impaired.................  5               7
Cities, local laws, amendment or
  repeal.................................  9            1(a)
  .......................................               2(c)
  Schools, legislative power over........  9            3(c)
  Pensions of retired police officers
    and firefighters, may be increased...  8               1
  Police officers and firefighters,
    retired, pensions may be increased...  8               1
  Firefighters and police officers,
    retired, pensions may be increased...  8               1
Counties,
  Pensions of retired police officers
    and firefighters may be increased....  8               1
  Police officers and firefighters,
    retired, pensions may be increased...  8               1
  Firefighters and police officers,
    retired, pensions may be increased...  8               1
Municipalities,
  Debts excluded in computing limitation.  8               5
  Retired police officers and fire
    fighters, pensions may be increased..  8               1
Pensions may be increased................  7               8
  Police officers and fire fighters,
    retired, pensions may be increased...  8               1
State employees, exemption from taxation. 16               5
  Teachers retirement system,
    Pensions payable to widow, widower
    or beneficiary of retired member
    may be increased.....................  7               8
Towns,
  Pensions of retired police officers and
    firefighters, may be increased.......  8               1
  Police officers and firefighters,
    retired, pensions may be increased...  8               1
  Firefighters and police officers,
    retired, pensions may be increased...  8               1
Villages,
  Pensions of retired police officers and
    firefighters, may be increased.......  8               1
  Police officers and firefighters,
                             -- 63 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    retired, pensions may be increased...  8               1
  Firefighters and police officers,
    retired, pensions may be increased...  8               1
PEOPLE (see also "Persons," "Rights and
Privileges"):
Definition, local government.............  9            3(c)
PERMANENT REGISTRATION (see also "Elections"):
Systems, authority to enact laws.........  2               6
PERQUISITES OF OFFICE:
Constitutional officers, prohibition
  against receiving...................... 13               7
PERSONAL INJURIES:
Damages, amount not to be limited
  in case of death.......................  1              16
Right of action not to be abrogated in
  case of death..........................  1              16
PERSONAL PROPERTY (see also "Property"):
Liens, jurisdiction to foreclose,
  County courts..........................  6           11(a)
  District courts........................  6           16(d)
New York city-wide court
  of civil jurisdiction..................  6           15(b)
Taxation,
  Excise tax prohibited, exception....... 16               3
  Intangibles not taxed ad valorem....... 16               3
  Place where deemed located............. 16               3
PERSONNEL:
Non-judicial, abolished courts,
  assignment thereof.....................  6           35(1)
PERSONS (see also "People," "Rights and
Privileges"):
Due process, deprivation of life, liberty
  or property prohibited.................  1               6
Exclusive privilege, immunity or
  franchise  by private or local bill
  prohibited.............................  3              17
Laying railroad tracks, privilege
  by private orlocal bill prohibited.....  3              17
Name, change, private or
  local bill prohibited..................  3              17
Searches and seizures, protection against
  unreasonable...........................  1              12
PETE GAY MOUNTAIN:
Forest preserve, construction of certain
  ski trails authorized.................. 14               1
PETIT JURY (see "Jury"):
PETIT LARCENY:
Indictment by grand jury unnecessary.....  1               6
PETITION:
                             -- 64 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Right guaranteed.........................  1               9
PHYSICALLY HANDICAPPED:
Education and support,
  legislature to provide.................  7               8
PLACES OF VOTING:
Designation by private or local
  bill prohibited........................  3              17
POLICE OFFICERS, RETIRED:
Pensions, right of municipalities
  to increase............................  8               1
POLITICAL PARTIES (see also "Elections"):
Party positions, primary elections
  may be waived in certain cases.........  1               1
Sex, rules may provide for equal
  representation on committes............ 13               1
POLITICAL SUBDIVISIONS (see also "Cities, "
"Counties," "Municipalities,"etc):
Accounts, supervision by comptroller.....  5               1
Health, protection and promotion......... 17               3
Needy, aid, care and support............. 17               1
Officers and employees, salaries
  subject to taxation.................... 16               5
Pensions, exemption from taxation........ 16               5
Schools, denominational, religious,
  state aid prohibited................... 11               3
POLITICAL YEAR:
Commencement............................. 13               4
POOL-SELLING (see also "Gambling"):
Prohibition against authorization........  1               9
POOR (see also "Social Welfare"):
Municipalities, authorization of
  indebtedness to support................  8               1
Legislature, power to provide............  7               8
POPULATION (see "Federal Census"):
Port of New York Authority:
Railroad passenger facilities,
  Lease of, to railroads................. 10               7
  Liabilty of state for obligations
    issued to purchase................... 10               7
  Obligations for certain, guaranty
    by state............................. 10               7
  Purchase and lease, authority.......... 10               7
  State, liability for certain
    obligations.......................... 10               7
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE:
Legislature, may delegate power to
  regulate...............................  6              30
PREAMBLE OF CONSTITUTION................... Page 12
PREFERENCE:
Housing, occupancy of low rent projects,
                             -- 65 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  restrictions........................... 18               6
Religious worship, prohibition against...  1               3
PRESIDENT OF SENATE:
Absence or impeachment of lieutenant-
  governor, temporary president to
  discharge duties of office.............  4               6
Court for trial of impeachments,
  member.................................  6              24
Lieutenant-governor acting as
  governor, temporary president to
  discharge duties of office.............  4               6
Lietenant-governor to be.................  4               6
Notification of removal charges before
  court on the judiciary.................  6           22(e)
PRESS:
Freedom guaranteed.......................  1               8
PREVAILING RATE OF WAGE
(see "Public Work").
PRINTING:
Bills, requirement.......................  3              14
PRISONS (see also "Correctional
Institutions," "Reformatories"):
Labor,
  Contract system abolished and
    prohibited...........................  3              24
  Political subdivisions may benefit
    from work done or products...........  3              24
  Products or profits not to benefit any
    person or corporation................  3              24
  Public institutions may benefit from
    work done or products................  3              24
  State may benefit from work done or
    products.............................  3              24
Legislature to provide for support and
  maintenance............................ 17               5
Occupation and employment of prisoners...  3              24
Voting residence unaffected while
  confined...............................  2               4
PRIVATE AND LOCAL BILLS (see "Bills,"
"Local Laws," "Special Laws").
PRIVATE PROPERTY (see "Property").
PRIVATE ROADS:
Benefits, payment........................  1               7
Opening, jury to determine necessity and
  amount of damage.......................  1               7
PRIVILEGES (see "Rights and Privileges").
PROBABLE CAUSE:
Warrents for search and seizure..........  1              12
PROBATE OF WILLS:
                             -- 66 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Surrogate's court, jurisdiction..........  6           12(d)
PROBATION:
Legislature to provide system............ 17               5
PROCESSES:
Courts, service and execution............  6            1(c)
PRODUCE:
Offices for weighing, etc., abolished....  5               5
PROFITS:
Housing; loans to certain corporations... 18               2
Non--profit organizations, alteration or
  repeal of tax exemptions prohibited.... 16               1
Savings banks; trustees to have no
  interest in profits of corporation..... 10               3
Undistributed, taxation prohibited....... 16               3
PROPERTY (see also "Lands"):
Condemnation for public use..............  1               7
Due process, deprivation prohibited......  1               6
Exemption from taxation by private or
  local bill prohibited..................  3              17
Private property, compensation when taken
  for public use.........................  1               7
Real property, comptroller's powers
  respecting assessment and taxation.....  5               1
PROSECUTION:
Capital or infamous crimes, by indictment
  of grand jury, exceptions..............  1               6
PUBLIC AGENCIES (see "Public
Corporations").
PUBLIC AUTHORITIES (see "Public Corporations").
PUBLIC CORPORATIONS (see also specific titles,
"Cities," "Towns," etc.):
Accounts subject to supervision.......... 10               5
Bridges, building, authorization by
  private or local bill..................  3              17
Comptroller to supervise accounts........ 10               5
Creation,
  Prohibition against certain, exception.  8               3
  Special act only, exceptions........... 10               5
Drainage systems, excess or common,
  authorization..........................  8             2-a
Municipalities may contract
  indebtedness...........................  8             2-a
Employment,
  Indebtedness, guaranty by state........ 10               7
  Loans by state, unauthorized...........  7               8
Housing,
  Acquisition of property................ 18               9
  Definition............................. 18               2
  Eminent domain authorized.............. 18             2,9
  Excess property, acquisition and use... 18               3
                             -- 67 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Indebtedness, liability, how computed,. 18               7
    Payment, guaranty by muncipality..... 18               2
  Loans authorized,...................... 18               2
  Municipal liability for repayment
    to state............................. 18               5
  Subsidies authorized................... 18               2
  Subsidy to avoid default on state loan
    prohibited........................... 18               5
Indebtedness,
  Payment by state or political
  subdivision............................ 10               5
  Restrictions on power to contract......  8               3
Industrial plants, rehabilitation,
  Indebtedness, guaranty by state........ 10               7
  Loans by state, authorized.............  7               8
Manufacturing plants, rehabilitation,
  Indebtedness, guaranty by state........ 10               7
  Loans by state, authorized.............  7               8
Obligations,
  Liability of state or political
  subdivisions prohibited, exception..... 10             5,6
Powers when created pursuant to
  interstate compact..................... 10               5
Powers to be limited, exceptions......... 10               5
Property, acquisition by state or
  political subdivisions................. 10               5
Sewage systems, excess or common,
  authorization..........................  8             2-a
Municipalities may contract
  indebtedness...........................  8             2-a
Special act for creation, exceptions..... 10               5
Thruways,
  Bonds, liability of state.............. 10               6
  Canal lands, use....................... 10               6
  Obligations, liability of state........ 10               6
Water supply, excess or common,
  authorization..........................  8             2-a
Municipalities may contract
  indebtedness...........................  8             2-a
PUBLIC HEALTH (see "Health and Safety").
PUBLIC HOUSING (see "Housing").
PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS (see "Improvements,"
"Municipalities").
PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS:
Prison labor, may receive work
  done or products.......................  3              24
Visitation and inspection................ 17             2-6
Voting residence unaffected while
  confined at certain....................  2               4
PUBLIC OFFICE:
                             -- 68 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Disqualification of certain judges and
  justices from holding other............  6        20(b)(1)
Duration when not otherwise provided..... 13               2
Duties, succession during certain
  emergencies, legislature to provide....  3              25
Forfeiture,
  Refusal to sign waiver of immunity in
    certain cases........................  1               6
  Refusal to testify concerning conduct..  1               6
Impeachment,
  Removal from office and
    disqualification.....................  6              24
Inquiry into conduct by grand jury.......  1               6
Judges, removal by court on the
  judiciary, disqualification............  6           22(c)
Powers, succession during certain
  emergencies, legislature to provide....  3              25
Primary elections, waiver authorized in
  certain cases..........................  1               1
Refusal of public officers to testify or
  waive immunity, disqualification from
  holding other public office or
  employment.............................  1               6
Succession to powers and duties, periods
  of certain emergencies, legislature to
  provide................................  3              25
PUBLIC OFFICERS (see also specific
officers):
Assembly members, extra compensation
  prohibited.............................  3               6
Attorney general to institute suit for
  forfeiture of office...................  1               6
Bribery, expense of investigation or
  prosecution state charge............... 13           13(b)
Compensation (see also "Compensation"),
  Change during term prohibited.......... 13               7
  Constitutional officers................ 13               7
  Taxation, subject to................... 16               5
Constitutional provisions relating to.... 13             1-7
Duration of office when not provided by
  constitution........................... 13               2
Election, certain........................ 13               8
Fees,
  Constitutional officer................. 13               7
  Increase or decrease during term by
    private or local bill prohibited.....  3              17
Forfeiture of office.....................  1               6
Immunity, penalty for failure to sign
  waiver.................................  1               6
Impeachment, majority vote required,.....  6              24
                             -- 69 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
  Liability to indictment and punishment
    unaffected...........................  6              24
Indictment or information, power of
  grand juries...........................  1               6
Legislature, members ineligible for
  certain other public offices...........  3               7
Limitation upon test..................... 13               1
  Local, method of selection when not
  otherwise provided.....................  9            1(b)
Member of legislature, extra
  compensation prohibited................  3               6
Misconduct in office, power of grand
  Jury not to be impaired................  1               6
Oath of office........................... 13               1
Pension or retirement systems, benefits
  not to be diminished...................  5               7
Pensions not subject to taxation......... 16               5
Power of grand jury to investigate not
  subject to suspension or impairment....  1               6
Proceedings involving, appeals to court
  of appeals.............................  6         3(b)(5)
Refusal to testify or waive immunity,
  disqualification from holding other
  public office or employment............  1                6
Removal from office (see also "Removal
from Office"),
  Failure to sign waiver of immunity
    in certain cases.....................  1                6
  Failure to testify before grand jury
    concerning official duties...........  1                6
  Misconduct or malversation, vacancies.. 13                5
 Salaries (see "Compensation" under
"Public Officers").
Senators, extra compensation prohibited..  3                6
Sex, equal representation on committees
  of political parties................... 13                1
State officers (see also specific state
  officers),
  General provisions.....................  5              1-7
  Legislature of assign functions........  5                3
  Rules and regulations, filing and
    publication..........................  4                8
  Term of office, duration when not
    provided by constitution............. 13                2
  Vacancies in office,................... 13                6
    Declaration when not provided by
      constitution....................... 13                6
  Filling................................ 13              3,5
PUBLIC SAFETY:
                             -- 70 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
Suspension of writ of habeas corpus......  1                4
PUBLIC SCHOOLS (see "Schools").
PUBLIC SERVICE, DEPARTMENT OF:
Head of department, appointment and
  removal................................  5                4
PUBLIC USE (see "Eminent Domain," "Lands,"
"Property").
PUBLIC UTILITIES (see also
"Municipalities"):
Municipal operation, profits,
  restriction on legislative power.......  3               18
PUBLIC WELFARE (see "Social Welfare").
PUBLIC WORK:
Collective bargaining....................  1               17
Days of labor, limitation, exception.....  1               17
Employees, rights generally, legislative
  power..................................  9             2(c)
  ....................................... 13               14
Hours of labor, limitation, exception....  1               17
Wages, prevailing rate to be paid........  1               17
PUBLIC WORKS, DEPARTMENT OF:
Head of department, appointment and
  removal................................  5                4
PUBLICATION:
Legislature, journal of proceedings......  3               10
Rules and regulations of state
  departments and officers...............  4                8
PUNISHMENTS:
Cruel and unusual, prohibition against...  1                5
PUPILS (see "Schools").
QUEENS COUNTY:
County court,
  Abolished..............................  6            35(a)
  Actions and proceedings, transferred
    to supreme court.....................  6            35(b)
  Appeals, where taken...................  6            35(m)
  Documents, disposal thereof............  6            35(a)
  Judges, to be justices of supreme
    court for remainder of term..........  6       6(d),35(b)
  Papers, disposal thereof...............  6            35(a)
  Personnel, non-judicial, assigned to
    certain courts.......................  6            35(l)
  Records, disposal thereof..............  6            35(a)
  Seal, disposal thereof.................  6            35(a)
QUORUM:
Constitutional convention................ 19                2
Court of appeals.........................  6             2(a)
Legislature,
  Majority of each house to constitute...  3                9
  Three-fifths required for passing
                             -- 71 --
                               INDEX
                                           Art.            Sec.
    certain bills........................  3               23
Supreme Court,
  Appellate division.....................  6             4(b)
  Appellate term.........................  6             8(c)
  Discrimination in civil rights
    prohibited...........................  1               11
                             -- 72 --