Public Hearing - August 8, 2012
1 BEFORE THE NEW YORK STATE SENATE STANDING COMMITTEE
ON INVESTIGATIONS AND GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS
2 ------------------------------------------------------
3 PUBLIC HEARING
4 TO EXAMINE THE CURRENT LAWS AND REGULATIONS ON
BOATING SAFETY IN NEW YORK STATE, AND WHETHER CHANGES
5 ARE NECESSARY TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC ON OUR WATERS
6 ------------------------------------------------------
7 Town of Oyster Bay
54 Audrey Avenue
8 Town Board Hearing Room, Town Hall East
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
9
August 8, 2012
10 11:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m.
11
12 PRESIDING:
13 Senator Carl L. Marcellino
Chair
14
15 SENATE MEMBERS PRESENT:
16 Senator Kenneth P. LaValle
17 Senator Jack Martins
18
19 ASSEMBLY MEMBERS PRESENT:
20 Assemblywoman Sandra Galef
21 Assemblyman David McDonough
22 Assemblyman Michael Montesano
23
24
25
2
1 SPEAKERS: PAGE QUESTIONS
2 Michael Della 9 16
Attorney and Partner,
3 Gruenberg, Kelly, Della
Testifying on behalf of
4 Paul and Lisa Gaines
5 Rose Harvey 18 24
Commissioner
6 Brian Kemp
Director, Bureau of Marine Services
7 NYS Office of Parks, Recreation, and
Historic Preservation
8
Sgt. John T. Owen 45 49
9 Deputy Commanding Officer
Nassau County Police Dept. Marine Bureau
10
District Commander Lawrence Postel 59 75
11 District 3 - Long Island
Larry Weiss
12 NYS Legislative Liaison
U.S. Power Squadrons
13
Chris Squeri 96 108
14 Executive Director
NYS Marine Trades Association
15
Jackie Martin 122 132
16 Commodore
Greater Huntington Council of
17 Yacht and Boating Clubs
18 Vincent Archdeacon 122 132
Commodore
19 Huntington Yacht Club
20 Justin McCaffrey 143 169
Commissioner of Public Safety
21 Town of Oyster Bay
22 Ed Carr 143 169
Director, Maritime Services
23 Harry Acker, Sr.
Harbor Master
24 Mark Cuthbertson
Councilman
25 Town of Huntington
3
1 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Could we all rise for
2 the Pledge of Allegiance, please.
3 (The Pledge of Allegiance was recited.)
4 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Good morning.
5 My name is Senator Carl Marcellino, and I am
6 the Chairman of the New York State Senate Committee
7 on Investigations and Government Operations.
8 We are here this morning to have a public
9 hearing on boating safety and the laws that affect
10 boating on the waters around and in New York State.
11 I am joined today by my colleagues,
12 Senator Jack Martins, to my right;
13 Assemblyman Michael Montesano of the 15th Assembly
14 District, to his right; and to my left,
15 Assemblyman David McDonough of the --
16 I believe 19th Assembly District, David?
17 -- the 19th Assembly District.
18 If others -- we expect a couple of others.
19 Senator LaValle had indicated that he would be here,
20 and Assemblywoman Sandra Galef had said she would
21 attend. As they come, we will invite them up and
22 introduce them as they're here.
23 As I said earlier, the purpose of this
24 hearing --
25 And the people who are testifying, by the
4
1 way, was by invitation only.
2 -- we're here to discuss boating safety and
3 the laws that affect it in New York State.
4 We are not here to discuss or investigate any
5 particular accident that occurred in the waters.
6 I do, and I will say to you, that the impetus
7 for this hearing, of course, was the incident, the
8 accident, that occurred on the 4th of July,
9 resulting in the deaths of three children. That
10 certainly sparked our interest, and it certainly
11 stimulated the hearing that we're holding here
12 today.
13 But we're not police, and we're not equipped
14 or capable of investigating the cause of that
15 accident at all.
16 What we are looking at -- and hopefully,
17 we'll get good information and good testimony from
18 people who are experts in the field, we're looking
19 at the laws that exist in our state.
20 Are they comprehensive?
21 Do they effectively cover the boating public?
22 Do they provide for a safe experience when
23 people are on the water?
24 Are they enforceable?
25 Do they need to be modified; do they need to
5
1 be changed?
2 Totally, completely, redo the whole thing?
3 I mean, I've heard comments from everybody,
4 from one extreme to the other, on this issue.
5 I personally have -- and this Committee has
6 not supported or sponsored any particular piece of
7 legislation.
8 Many have been put forward in recent days
9 and weeks since the incident, and some before.
10 We decided some time ago to wait, one, for
11 the results of this hearing; and, two, the
12 results of the investigation that's going on in
13 the incident. Want to hear what the cause was, to
14 find out if there's anything we can do to actually
15 impact and affect what goes on out there on the
16 water.
17 We've invited a number of speakers, and one
18 of which was the Coast Guard, and they've declined
19 to testify. And I'm really sorry about that,
20 because they're the ones who write the laws;
21 they're the ones who set the limits and the
22 parameters. But they don't feel it's their --
23 that they should do this.
24 I disagree.
25 However, respectfully, there's been no animus
6
1 between us, and I don't have any animus in that
2 respect, so that we're -- we're more than willing to
3 work with them in the future, and continue to work.
4 To that end, they've sent me a book of
5 statistics. Boating statistics in New York and
6 the United States in 2011.
7 It's somewhat interesting. It's relatively
8 thick, a lot of pages, and it has a lot of boating
9 statistics.
10 Sandra, come on up.
11 Come on up. There's a seat for you.
12 There's Assemblywoman Galef. We're gonna let
13 her come up and join us at the table, at the dais.
14 Pick a side, or, you can sit next to Dave, or
15 anyone you want.
16 As I said, we're not talking about individual
17 laws; we're talking about the whole package as a
18 situation.
19 Let me give you some background.
20 New York State is a leader in the number of
21 vessels registered. There are almost 468,000 --
22 more than 468,000 registered boats, and many other
23 vessels that do not require registration.
24 New York State Office of Parks and Recreation
25 and Historic Preservation, along with the
7
1 United States Coast Guard Auxiliary and the
2 United States Power Squadron, provides boaters of
3 New York State with approved boating education
4 courses that are recognized in all 50 States and
5 Canada.
6 New York State annually educates
7 18,000 boaters on boating safety.
8 Last year, there were 28 deaths in boating
9 accidents in the state of New York.
10 4,588 boating accidents nationwide last
11 year, resulting in 758 people losing their lives.
12 3,081 were injured in those incidents.
13 Nationally, the fatality rate was
14 6.2 deaths per 100,000 registered recreational
15 vessels.
16 89 percent of the deaths incurred [sic] in
17 boats where the operator had not received boating
18 safety instruction.
19 Let me repeat that: "89 percent of the
20 deaths occurred on boats where the operator had
21 not received boating safety instruction."
22 Operator inattention, improper lookout -- I
23 guess that means not looking where you're going --
24 operator inexperience, excessive speed, and
25 machinery failure rank as the top five primary
8
1 contributing factors to accidents.
2 The primary contributing factor to death on
3 the water, is alcohol. Is alcohol use.
4 So, we have, as you can see, a lot of data.
5 This book contains a huge amount.
6 We're gonna process that. My staff will be
7 crunching numbers for quite a while when we make
8 our recommendations eventually for, and it will be
9 as expeditiously as we possibly can, towards any
10 legislation that we think we want to deal with.
11 As I said, we haven't promoted, nor will we
12 as a Committee, without -- promote any legislation
13 without hearing first from the experts and the
14 witnesses who can give us good testimony and good
15 input.
16 We have invited the -- Paul and Lisa Gaines,
17 who very tragically lost their daughter in the
18 incident, in the accident, on July 4th in the
19 waterways at Oyster Bay Harbor.
20 Michael Della is their attorney.
21 And I assume, Michael, will you speak for the
22 family?
23 MICHAEL DELLA: Yes.
24 SENATOR MARCELLINO: And we do wish the
25 family all the best, and our prayers are with you,
9
1 especially at this time of your grief and your loss.
2 Michael.
3 MICHAEL DELLA: Thank you very much.
4 Thank you very much, Senator.
5 On July 4, 2012, 7-year-old Victoria Gaines
6 was tragically killed when the boat that she was in
7 capsized on its way back from watching the Dolans'
8 family fireworks show in Oyster Bay Harbor.
9 Victoria would have celebrated her
10 8th birthday just two days later.
11 She was a beautiful child with an amazing
12 smile and an engaging spirit.
13 She is survived by her father who's sitting
14 beside me today, as well as her mother, Lisa, and
15 brother, Ryan, both of whom were on that boat on the
16 4th of July.
17 The entire family, needless to say, is
18 devastated by the loss of Victoria.
19 In addition, two other children died that
20 evening.
21 This incident caught the attention of local
22 and national news, and rightfully so, not only
23 because of the catastrophic loss of life of these
24 three beautiful children, but because this could
25 have, and should have, been prevented.
10
1 Numerous mistakes were made that night, and
2 the Gaines family refuses to accept that her death
3 will have been in vain.
4 They are determined to see changes that are
5 made in all laws, so that such accidents never
6 happen again, and so that no other family will have
7 to experience the pain that they are going through.
8 The public outpouring has been overwhelming.
9 I received calls and e-mails from
10 hundreds of people, thanking me and the Gaines
11 family for trying to create change.
12 Every one of these concerned citizens had a
13 different story, about the laws being so lax on
14 the waterways, and wished our representatives
15 would act to create laws that can better protect
16 us on the water.
17 Quite frankly, the public is scared. I can't
18 tell you how many other people have come up to me
19 and said that they'd never go on a boat again.
20 And that's a shame, considering where we live
21 on Long Island, surrounded by water.
22 If ever there was a time to act, it is right
23 now.
24 Encouraging, is that these changes are
25 limited and don't restrict boaters from enjoying
11
1 themselves.
2 Will there be a little resistance? Maybe,
3 but the added safety of our community far
4 outweighs any inconvenience felt by the boaters.
5 If we can save one life, we have done our
6 job.
7 Similar to the evolution of the vehicle and
8 traffic laws, boating laws must change with the
9 times.
10 When motor vehicles became popular, and
11 more and more cars were on our roads, the
12 government designed safer roadways; implemented
13 speed limits; had stop signs, yield signs
14 implemented; and there were licensing
15 requirements.
16 Additionally, DWI laws were more strictly
17 enforced, and more policemen were employed to
18 control the use of our roads.
19 Countless lives were saved because of those
20 changes.
21 On the water, we need similar changes.
22 The waterways are becoming more and more
23 populated, and the roadways need to be safer for
24 everyone, to be better policed.
25 Our goal is to make laws, not proposals.
12
1 The most glaring issues that stand out from
2 that fateful night were as follows:
3 Number one: Occupancy limits.
4 While we are not going to rush to judgment,
5 as the investigation of the 4th of July incident is
6 still ongoing, we are pushing for maximum occupancy
7 limits and weight restrictions for every
8 pleasure boat, not just ones under the size of
9 20 feet.
10 Such limits and restrictions should be
11 clearly and conspicuously posted on the vessel so
12 that anyone boarding it could readily see it.
13 While this may seem like common sense to an
14 experienced boater, beginners may have no idea of
15 a boat's capacity. Not everyone is a boater, just
16 like less of us are pilots.
17 Would anyone here know how many people or the
18 amount of weight that could be on a certain plane?
19 Of course not.
20 This small restriction to boating is
21 absolutely necessary, and will cause boaters little
22 to no inconvenience.
23 Number two: Safety courses.
24 Right now, there are no safety training or
25 licensing requirements for boaters.
13
1 You need a license to operate personal
2 watercrafts, such as jet skis and WaveRunners,
3 yet you don't need one for a boat.
4 That does not make sense.
5 As Senator Marcellino pointed out, of the
6 89 percent of all boating fatalities last year, the
7 operators did not undergo a safety training
8 course.
9 That is unacceptable.
10 Currently, anyone without any experience or
11 training may buy a boat and just drive it away
12 without any knowledge on how to operate it. They
13 are not required to know anything about buoys, how
14 to dock, how to drop an anchor, how fast you can go,
15 how close you can be to another boat, how close you
16 can be to a swimmer.
17 Does anyone buy a car before passing a road
18 test and obtaining a license?
19 The safety course should be on the actual
20 water and a certain amount of hours with an
21 experienced boater should be required.
22 As for people who have been boating all their
23 lives, a test should be conducted, and if passed,
24 they can forgo that safety course.
25 Again, this should not be heavily objected to
14
1 from an experienced boater, since they want safe
2 waterways just as much as anybody.
3 And, finally, boat-traffic control:
4 When there's an event, like a maritime
5 fireworks display, a concert at Jones Beach, or,
6 Hemstock in Hemstock Cover -- or in Hemlock Cove, I
7 apologize, which took place a few weeks ago on the
8 Great South Bay, it is common knowledge that many
9 boaters will attend.
10 There should be a requirement that proper
11 security is in place to direct traffic and to
12 enforce all other boating rules and regulations.
13 Whether it should be the responsibility of
14 the event planner, the town, the county, or the
15 U.S. Coast Guard, someone must make sure that every
16 boater can get into and out of a congested waterway
17 where an event takes place.
18 Not only have I received calls from
19 strangers on that issue, but I have read in the
20 newspapers, about people waiting an hour after an
21 event to start up their engines, because for
22 everyone to try and exit at the same time is a
23 recipe for disaster.
24 At Yankee Stadium, at a concert, we all have
25 ushers standing by every exit way, to make sure
15
1 the flow of traffic is proper and that no one gets
2 trampled.
3 On the east end, at a celebrities' Hamptons
4 party, there's police officers stationed at the
5 end of the block, to make sure that only the
6 invitees or people that live on the block are able
7 to go down that roadway, because of safety.
8 These three points make up what the Gaines
9 family is trying to employ as "Victoria's Law," in
10 the memory of their lost daughter.
11 I just want to take this final opportunity to
12 applaud Senator Fuschillo, who we have met with, and
13 who has dealt with boating safety in the past for
14 years, and has proposed more changes to make us
15 safe.
16 I also want to thank Senator Schumer, who
17 we've also met, with who seems to be trying to put
18 in place some occupancy-limits changes as well.
19 And, I do look forward to Senator Marcellino,
20 his input here, and thank him very much for holding
21 this hearing in the first place.
22 And, I would also like to thank
23 Paul and Lisa Gaines, who have gone through this
24 tragedy, and, after the first couple of days, they
25 made it their mission to try to create change. And,
16
1 they just have outstanding bravery for coming here
2 in front of you elected officials, and meeting with
3 all types of different politicians; not just
4 sitting back and allowing this to ever happen again.
5 They've taken a very proactive approach, and
6 they should be commended for that.
7 Victoria will not die in vain.
8 This Gaines family is determined, but they do
9 need the help of our community, and our government.
10 Thank you very much.
11 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you very much.
12 Any questions?
13 Okay, thank you.
14 And I will state, that I do appreciate the
15 fact that you have made it your mission to make sure
16 that your daughter did not die -- and the other
17 children that died that night, did not die in vain.
18 We appreciate that, and we will look forward
19 to assisting you in any way we can, in any way
20 that's appropriate.
21 And I do believe you ought to be commended
22 with your courage in speaking, and especially
23 speaking to politicians. That's not an easy thing
24 to do.
25 So, I appreciate the fact that you've come,
17
1 and that you've been to many different events.
2 I know you were in Huntington last night at
3 their hearing.
4 Many different levels of government have
5 been holding Boating Safety evenings and
6 instruction periods, and so forth, throughout the
7 Long Island, and throughout the state, as a result
8 of this incident.
9 We think that's a positive thing. But, we
10 wanted to make sure that -- and I'm sure you agree,
11 that it goes on all the time, and not just one time,
12 and disappears and dissipates.
13 So, we want to keep the interest going.
14 But, we look forward to working with you, and
15 we will keep you informed every step of the way.
16 And we would appreciate the same from
17 yourselves as well.
18 Thank you very much for your testimony, and
19 your hearing today.
20 MICHAEL DELLA: Thank you very much,
21 Senator.
22 MR. GAINES: Thank you, Senator.
23 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Anyone who would like to
24 see this, by the way, just to announce to the
25 public, that this hearing is being live broadcast by
18
1 the Senate video operations.
2 So, that anyone who's out there, and we did
3 promote this through e-mail, and so forth, that this
4 is a live broadcast.
5 And if anyone would like to see this and hear
6 it repeated, they can view it on the New York Senate
7 website, which is:
8 New YorkSenate.gov/committee
9 /investigationsandgovernmentoperations.
10 You can put that on. It will be re-broadcast
11 as frequently as you wish. It will be up there for
12 quite a while.
13 The next speaker will be the commissioner of
14 the New York State Office of Parks and Recreation
15 and Historic Preservation, Commissioner Rose Harvey.
16 Commissioner?
17 Commissioner, would you introduce your
18 co-speaker.
19 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Thank you.
20 Good morning, and thank you for inviting us,
21 and we're glad to participate in this hearing.
22 And, I'm Rose Harvey, and I'm Commissioner of
23 Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation.
24 And I have with me Brian Kemp, who's director
25 of our Bureau of Marine Services, and has been there
19
1 for many, many years, and could help answer some
2 questions.
3 I also just want to express my deepest
4 condolences to the Gaines family, and thank them
5 for their bravery and courage to come forward and
6 try to make a difference.
7 Boating is a major recreational activity in
8 New York State.
9 Currently, New York State ranks seventh in
10 the nation in the number of watercrafts, with
11 468,000 registered boats, plus a large number of
12 small crafts, such as canoes and kayaks that do
13 not require registration.
14 Millions of people participate in boating
15 on waters across the state, providing outdoor
16 recreational activities and making a significant
17 economic contribution to local communities.
18 Parks administers boating safety
19 initiatives through our Bureau of Marine Services.
20 The agency is also responsible for a number of
21 regulatory functions upon those waters which the
22 federal government has no authority, primarily
23 inland and lake waters.
24 We inspect and license commercial
25 passenger-carrying vessels;
20
1 Replace and maintain navigational aids on
2 several major inland lakes and waterways;
3 We issue permits for regattas and floating
4 objects;
5 We administer the State Financial
6 Reimbursement Program to counties enforcing state
7 navigation laws;
8 And, finally, we administer the Boater
9 Education Program that the State requires of youth
10 and personal-watercraft operators.
11 So let me just give you a brief overview of
12 each of these programs.
13 With respect to safe-boating education
14 programs, 1959, New York State launched the
15 earliest boating education program in the country.
16 It's in partnership with the United States
17 Coast Guard Auxiliary and the United States
18 Power Squadron.
19 New York provides nationally recognized
20 courses of boating safety instruction. Participants
21 are required to complete an 8-hour course and pass a
22 proctored written exam in order to receive boating
23 safety certificates.
24 The boating education is required of youths,
25 age 10 to 18, to operate a motor boat; and all
21
1 operators of any age, of personal watercraft.
2 That's, essentially, jet skis.
3 Our certified instructors teach nearly
4 20,000 boaters annually, the fundamentals of safe
5 boating.
6 Over the past 12 years, more than
7 250,000 people have participated in the safe-boating
8 courses, and we rank sixth in the nation in the
9 number of students that take boating safety
10 courses each year.
11 In addition to boating education, Parks'
12 Marine Services' staff make presentations at boating
13 events across the state, provide safety
14 information on its website, and we partner with
15 organizations, like the National Safe Boating
16 Council and Brookfield Renewable Power to air
17 public-safety advertisements.
18 With respect to the New York State navigation
19 law, over the last two decades, New York has taken a
20 number of steps aimed at improving the state's
21 navigation laws.
22 I'll mention just a few.
23 Beginning in 1995, New York was the first --
24 one of the first states to require children under
25 the age of 12 to wear a life jackets.
22
1 In 1998, New York became one of the first
2 states to require that all personal-watercraft
3 operators take an improved course in boating
4 safety.
5 In 1998, the State passed a zero-tolerance
6 law prohibiting the consumption of alcohol by those
7 less than 21 years of age on mechanically driven
8 vessels.
9 In 2009, New York became the first state in
10 the nation to require wearing life jackets on any
11 vessel less than 21 feet, between the cold-water
12 months of November and May 1st.
13 With respect to marine law enforcement, a
14 number of state, county, town, and village agencies,
15 including, also, parks, State police, and DEC,
16 provide law-enforcement services.
17 These marine patrols provide a valuable
18 service to the boaters, through education,
19 compliance, and as first responders.
20 Parks sponsors a number of training
21 programs for these marine law-enforcement
22 personnel.
23 We also administer a State-funded financial
24 assistant program that reimburses up to 50 percent
25 of eligible marine law-enforcement expenses
23
1 incurred by the counties and municipal agencies for
2 patrolling the waters.
3 Continued support of all these agencies is
4 critical to ensure a safe boating environment.
5 Finally, with result to boating safety --
6 boating safety results, New York's efforts in
7 boating education, safety laws, and enforcement,
8 combined with federal laws and requirements,
9 have improved the safety of our waterways.
10 Over the past 30 years, the number of
11 reported recreational boating accidents has
12 decreased, and the number of boating fatalities has
13 dropped by one-half.
14 Despite having the seventh-largest number of
15 registered vessels, last year New York accounted
16 for 3.4 percent of boating-related fatalities in the
17 United States.
18 Parks tracks detail statistics on the
19 types and causes of boating accidents in New York,
20 and reports that information in an annual
21 recreational-boating report.
22 The 2011 report is available online right
23 now. I mean -- yes, it is online right now.
24 Here, in New York, we will continue to
25 promote and advance our boater safety training
24
1 programs, our public-education efforts, our
2 law-enforcement support, to enhance the safety in
3 New York's waterways.
4 We appreciate the Committee's active role in
5 convening this hearing.
6 We look forward to hearing from our federal
7 and local partners, as well as boating
8 organizations, on ideas for further promoting boat
9 safety in New York State.
10 Thank you very much for asking me to testify.
11 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you, Commissioner.
12 Just a couple of quick questions, and I'll
13 turn it over to some of my colleagues who may have
14 some follow-ups.
15 In your opinion, are our laws and regulations
16 in New York State strong enough?
17 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: New York State has
18 always been very focused on boating safety, and we
19 worked very well with the Legislature to promulgate
20 laws with respect to boating safety.
21 And, we will continue to look, consider, work
22 with you and all our partners, to think about
23 further laws, further regulation, further
24 legislation.
25 SENATOR MARCELLINO: In your opinion --
25
1 Let me put you on the spot a little bit. I'm
2 sure you're used to it.
3 You heard the testimony from the attorney
4 representing the Gaines family.
5 Boating safety courses: If -- and there are
6 many bills out there right now that would require
7 an expansion of the "boating safety course"
8 provision in the state law right now.
9 -- are we equipped, currently, to give
10 everybody -- or, require everyone who has a boat or
11 buys a boat, to take a boating safety course?
12 Do you have enough people to do it?
13 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Right now, as you
14 know, in New York State, it's mandatory, from 10 to
15 18, and then all operators of jet skis. And, we
16 do everything we can to make sure, to even provide
17 them with courses. And, also, to make all boaters
18 aware of the courses so that they're -- those that
19 volunteer.
20 And, we're sixth right now in the number of
21 students that attend both voluntary and required.
22 So, you -- everything is -- it's a very
23 complex interrelated area and issue. And it all --
24 everything is in the details, and we would have to
25 look at everything, and consider it, to know whether
26
1 we are equipped.
2 But --
3 SENATOR MARCELLINO: The other aspect of the
4 testimony that we heard, was about licensing.
5 We don't currently require it in the state.
6 How would you implement something like that?
7 That's been a question that's been rattling
8 around in my head: How would you do that?
9 I understand how we do it with motor
10 vehicles, and so forth. There's a written test,
11 and then there's a road test.
12 How would you do it on the water with:
13 Different boats; sail, motor, different
14 sizes?
15 Different conditions; marine, lakes,
16 rivers?
17 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Jurisdictions.
18 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Different
19 jurisdictions -- crossing jurisdictions, and so
20 forth?
21 How would we deal with that?
22 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: It would be very
23 difficult and very complex, and would require a lot
24 of thought. It would be very hard.
25 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Okay.
27
1 Gentlemen?
2 Jack?
3 SENATOR MARTINS: Good morning. How are you?
4 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Good. Good.
5 SENATOR MARTINS: Thank you.
6 Just to follow up on that last question:
7 Right now, we do have different types of licensing,
8 or licenses, for different motor vehicles, don't
9 we? Tractor-trailers, passenger vehicles,
10 motorcycles.
11 And it is complicated.
12 And we do have different types of
13 watercraft.
14 Can we not, sort of follow the model that's
15 already been established for automobiles, in terms
16 of licensing, and the requirements for different
17 size boats, and required training as a result,
18 commensurate with the type of boat or watercraft
19 that a person be using?
20 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Again, the boating
21 issues' environment are very different. And, I
22 think it would be very complex.
23 And, I don't have the answers. I don't know.
24 And, we would, you know, need to look at all
25 of this, and think about it in context of all the
28
1 many jurisdictions, all of the -- that have
2 enforcement, and don't have enforcement, and so
3 forth and so on.
4 SENATOR MARTINS: You mentioned --
5 You mentioned that --
6 SENATOR MARCELLINO: You've got to point your
7 microphones down, I'm told.
8 No, just point the microphones down.
9 The microphones, point them down.
10 SENATOR MARTINS: I'll try again.
11 SENATOR MARCELLINO: We're still getting the
12 feedback, guys.
13 SENATOR MARTINS: I'll go with that. Thank
14 you.
15 You mentioned that there are currently
16 20,000 boaters, annually, that take some sort of
17 course -- safety course.
18 I assume that those include youngsters,
19 10 to 18, as well as those who use personal
20 watercrafts, like jet skis.
21 What's the breakout?
22 Out of those 20,000, how many are boaters,
23 10 to 18, and how many are people actually, just,
24 recreational crafts, like jet skis?
25 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: We can -- unless
29
1 Brian knows it, I think we can get back to you and
2 give you that.
3 SENATOR MARTINS: And we require, I guess,
4 safety instruction, up to 18. But that first day
5 after the 18th birthday, that person no longer has
6 to take a class.
7 And so, yet, we still require it for people
8 who are on jet skis out on the water, and not
9 power boats.
10 Do you see that as a possible avenue towards
11 expanding safety on the waterways, just as a
12 simple point, and that sometimes these age
13 restrictions may be arbitrary?
14 Is that possible?
15 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Well, again, we
16 promote boater safety courses and education, and go
17 out and actively encourage everybody to take them.
18 And awareness of their importance is a huge part of
19 it.
20 And, we'll give you the breakdown of how many
21 are -- or those not required by law.
22 And that is -- we're very focused on it. We
23 do PSAs. And more awareness of the importance of
24 it, the more participation you will get.
25 But we, again, welcome working with the
30
1 Legislature, to look at other proposals, and, you
2 know, anything that can further enhance and improve.
3 SENATOR MARTINS: No, I appreciate that.
4 You know, I'll just relay a quick experience,
5 my own personal experience.
6 I have a person I know who decided, in his
7 thirties, to buy a boat.
8 So, decided to buy a boat.
9 Found one in Massachusetts. Never having
10 actually owned a boat, or piloted a boat, bought the
11 boat; drove to Massachusetts, got on the boat, and
12 piloted it back to Long Island, not ever having
13 taken a course.
14 And there's something just inherently wrong
15 about that.
16 And when you consider it, and, you know, the
17 rules, regulations, or laws that make that
18 possible. And, I think a lot of what we're
19 discussing here today bring that into stark contrast
20 with some of the other requirements that we have on
21 the road.
22 I did just want to point out, I noticed that,
23 for boats that are less than 20 feet -- 21-feet
24 long, between the months of November and May, that
25 people have to wear life vests. But, after May,
31
1 and before November, they don't.
2 Yet, I would think that the risks
3 associated with wearing the life vests between
4 those months are still there, between May and
5 November, during, you know, the nicer months; yet,
6 the need for those life vests are foregone.
7 So, I do appreciate the testimony, I
8 appreciate the details, but I think that they also
9 raise some valid points for discussion as we go
10 forward.
11 Chairman, thank you.
12 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you very much,
13 Senator.
14 Before we take a -- or go any further, I
15 would just like to thank the Town of Oyster Bay and
16 Supervisor Vanditto and the Town Board for providing
17 us the use of the hall. They've been very
18 cooperative with their staff and the people, in
19 using the facilities.
20 So, we do appreciate their time.
21 Assemblywoman, do you have some questions?
22 Senator?
23 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Thank you very much,
24 and it is a pleasure to be here.
25 And thank you, Senator.
32
1 I don't think I've ever been to Oyster Bay.
2 I live in Westchester County.
3 But I must say, you know, it was very
4 important that the Gaines family was here.
5 And, we also lost somebody in our area, that
6 was at City Island, but lived in Ossening, in a
7 boating accident too.
8 So, it's an issue around all of our waterways
9 among the Hudson River.
10 One of the things that really bothers me, is
11 that the State of Connecticut and the State of
12 New Jersey do require boat safety courses. And it
13 just --
14 SENATOR MARCELLINO: We do have a chart over
15 there on the side, that --
16 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Oh, you do? Okay.
17 SENATOR MARCELLINO: -- this, New York's
18 requirements, and -- with respect to the courses,
19 and whatever.
20 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Right, and our
21 neighboring --
22 SENATOR MARCELLINO: As is with New Jersey
23 and Connecticut.
24 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Right, and our
25 neighboring states.
33
1 It just seems -- I mean, because so many of
2 our waterways kind of go between, you know -- I
3 don't know about Massachusetts, but, you know,
4 coming through all these waterways and having
5 different rules and regulations, and I don't quite
6 understand that.
7 The other aspect of the testimony, actually,
8 that was given by the attorney for the Gaines
9 family, about the boaters that are out there, even
10 if we start with the process of getting -- you know,
11 our younger people getting boat certificates, and
12 so on, what do we do about the older boaters that
13 have been out in the field?
14 And I know I've spoken to a lot of people.
15 Could we do anything with insurance like we
16 do with cars?
17 We were talking before about having
18 something, kind of, tracking our automobiles.
19 If people were to take preventive courses,
20 even though they've been boaters for a very, very
21 long time, that they would get a discount.
22 I know some insurance companies do that, but
23 could we require something like that, so, you know,
24 that we can encourage more people to do this?
25 You know, it sounds like your department is
34
1 limited in how many people we can get taking all of
2 these courses, you know, at this point, but is there
3 another approach to getting others?
4 It isn't all the new people. It's reminding
5 people, again and again, about, you know, not
6 drinking, as you've said, and what to do, you know,
7 when you're on the side of the -- I mean, we had
8 somebody in New Rochelle, coming from Connecticut,
9 and went right into a stone wall, you know. And
10 some of this you don't understand, but some have
11 been boaters before.
12 Any comments on this?
13 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Again, we agree
14 with you that awareness of the issues of boater
15 safety is paramount, and we need to educate.
16 And, we spend a lot of time with PSAs, and
17 promotional, and bringing people into our education
18 courses.
19 And with -- and, again, we're completely open
20 to all of the ideas that you all are putting
21 forward. And we just -- you know, we're going to
22 need to consider it in context of our ability to
23 implement, our ability to enforce, and, you know,
24 with respect to the multi-jurisdictional nature of
25 all of this.
35
1 But, we appreciate all of these ideas, and
2 look forward to further discussions on them.
3 SENATOR MARCELLINO: David?
4 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Thank you, Senator,
5 and thank you for holding the hearing.
6 And thank you, Commissioner, and Mr. Kemp,
7 for being here today.
8 Are you -- we've talked about a couple of
9 neighboring states.
10 Are you familiar with any of the larger
11 boating states, like Florida and California? Does
12 Florida have -- do you know, Mr. --
13 Is it, Kemp?
14 BRIAN KEMP: Yes.
15 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: -- do you know,
16 Mr. Kemp, does Florida have a strong boating law, or
17 stronger than ours?
18 BRIAN KEMP: I can tell you that California
19 has no requirements at all for education.
20 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: None at all.
21 BRIAN KEMP: Florida recently implemented
22 mandatory education, and they're in the process of
23 phasing that in.
24 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Could you speak up a
25 little bit. I don't think -- I couldn't hear you,
36
1 barely. I'm sure they --
2 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: You said Florida
3 recently introduced --
4 BRIAN KEMP: Florida recently introduced
5 legislation, to get everybody into a boating safety
6 course.
7 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Okay. I spent a lot
8 of my years growing up in south Florida, and I --
9 the boating there is, you know, just -- even bigger
10 than it is here.
11 I represent the 19th Assembly District, which
12 is the south shore of Nassau County, and covers
13 most of Jones Beach. So, there's a lot of
14 watercraft --
15 BRIAN KEMP: Oh, yeah.
16 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: -- in the
17 waterways, just -- you know, as well as in the
18 ocean, so, there are many accidents.
19 All boaters have to be licensed in
20 New York State. You see that; on every boat you see
21 the license number, I believe. You see it on
22 sailboats. I've seen it on other crafts.
23 BRIAN KEMP: There's a little confusion
24 between the terminology.
25 "Licensing," is really registration.
37
1 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Registration?
2 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Registration.
3 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: So you know who
4 the --
5 BRIAN KEMP: The motor vehicle, that's the
6 registration process.
7 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: So the State of
8 New York, then, whether it's Parks or -- the State
9 knows who the owners of every boat are?
10 BRIAN KEMP: That's correct.
11 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Okay, and that's all
12 they've to do, is register their boat; right?
13 BRIAN KEMP: In the case of most boaters,
14 yes.
15 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: And most boaters?
16 Why would it not be --
17 BRIAN KEMP: If they're youthful operators,
18 or if they're personal-watercraft operators, which
19 are boats as well --
20 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Right.
21 BRIAN KEMP: -- they have to be registered,
22 and they also have to be certificated.
23 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Well, at that age,
24 from the personal watercraft, under 18, or any
25 personal watercraft --
38
1 BRIAN KEMP: All personal-watercraft
2 operators.
3 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: But, as I understand
4 from the commissioner's testimony, and what we know,
5 is that nobody has to be registered to operate a
6 larger boat, over 18 years of age.
7 BRIAN KEMP: Again, the boat has to be
8 registered and/or documented through the
9 Coast Guard, and the operator does not have a
10 requirement that he be certified to operate the
11 boat.
12 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Okay, so we really
13 need -- Commissioner, you and I talked about this,
14 we really need legislation, don't we? Something?
15 I mean, we can talk about the funding for it
16 in a minute, but, don't we need some type of
17 legislation?
18 We've got two or three things that New York
19 has done already, insofar as the age we just talked
20 about, but, do we need some legislation, just like
21 we do with DMV, where you must have some training in
22 order to get a driver's license?
23 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Again, I -- we
24 have worked -- New York State actually has led
25 the -- many of the states in some of its
39
1 legislation, and its concern for boater safety.
2 And, we look forward to continuing to work
3 with you in considering it. But, what the -- we
4 need to review what the legislation is, and take
5 it -- take into consideration the issues of our
6 ability to enforce, to deliver, and all, again, the
7 multi-jurisdictional aspect of this.
8 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Okay, well, I'm the
9 ranking member on the Transportation Committee in
10 the New York State Assembly. And I understand what
11 you're saying about the local jurisdictions. But
12 if we have some State requirements, as you do for
13 the personal watercraft, and stuff like that, that
14 trumps any local jurisdiction. Correct?
15 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Correct.
16 And then there's federal.
17 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Different state.
18 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: And there's federal
19 also, which --
20 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Which trumps
21 State.
22 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Right, okay.
23 So, it's not unreasonable to hope that we
24 could get some type of legislation at a state level,
25 that would require the training courses, whether
40
1 it -- now, the funding of it, obviously, could be
2 through the fees.
3 I don't know what the registration fee is,
4 Mr. Kemp.
5 Do you know what the registration fee is for
6 a boat, just the registration?
7 BRIAN KEMP: It does vary. It's a three-year
8 registration. There's also a surcharge on that.
9 But I believe it ranges, anywhere from $18
10 for a boat under 16 feet, to somewhere around $60
11 for a larger vessel, for the three-year
12 registration.
13 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Costs a heck of a lot
14 more to get a driver's license, too.
15 BRIAN KEMP: Probably does.
16 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Right?
17 Isn't that amazing.
18 So, if we were able to get something like
19 that, of course, the first thing the State would be
20 thinking about, is how do we pay for these training
21 courses? Who pays for it?
22 The operator of the boat would have to pay
23 for it, I believe.
24 And, in order to get a license to operate a
25 boat. Just like, these younger people, and anybody
41
1 operating a personal watercraft, they have to pay
2 for their training course -- well, no, actually, I
3 think the Coast Guard Auxiliary gives those for
4 free. Right?
5 BRIAN KEMP: There's a combination of
6 courses.
7 We have free courses; we have instructors
8 that teach at the proprietary level, and they charge
9 for those courses; and the Coast Guard Auxiliary and
10 the Power Squadron also offer free courses of
11 training.
12 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: In response to
13 Assemblywoman Galef's remarks, I believe that there
14 is some discount from insurance companies, if you've
15 taken the boating safety course. Just like --
16 BRIAN KEMP: Yes.
17 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: -- we get a discount
18 on our driver's license if we take that safe-driving
19 course, and you get points reduction, and it gets
20 down on your insurance.
21 BRIAN KEMP: That's in the statute.
22 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: But there is some.
23 BRIAN KEMP: Yes.
24 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: You agree with me, I
25 think there is. Right.
42
1 And, of course, we've DWI laws. And, we
2 don't have strong enough BWI laws, I believe. Not
3 as strong as our DWI laws.
4 And that's something I know that
5 Senator Marcellino and Senator Martins and
6 Senator Fuschillo have been working on,
7 strengthening those laws.
8 You had an accident some years ago on
9 Lake George, which was a licensed operator. That
10 was a terrible accident, where a boat capsized.
11 So, there's much of this happens in State
12 parks; right?
13 Not just in our waterways, but you have all
14 of the lakes, and all of that, you have a lot of
15 boating accidents.
16 BRIAN KEMP: Yes.
17 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: We had a fatality
18 just prior to this accident on July 4th, where a
19 boat, literally, ran over another boat because of
20 DWI [sic].
21 Okay, well --
22 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Last question.
23 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: -- we're going to
24 work for more legislation, to help you.
25 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Assemblyman Montesano?
43
1 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: No, I'm okay. Thank
2 you.
3 Thanks.
4 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Commissioner, I
5 appreciate your coming. I know you came a long way
6 to be here, and thank you for your testimony.
7 And I understand your department has to work
8 with, in cooperation with other agencies, and on
9 multiple levels. And I think that's where the
10 confusion can be, as to which level is going to pass
11 what bill, and what law is going to -- supersedes
12 other laws, and when a New York boater crosses the
13 Sound and floats into Connecticut waterways,
14 could be impacting other sets of rules and
15 regulations as well.
16 So, we want to make sure that whatever is
17 done is coordinated.
18 Has there been any -- just one last question:
19 Has there been any thought to setting up some type
20 of meeting with the powers that be in Connecticut,
21 New Jersey, and surrounding jurisdictions, so that
22 we can have a uniform set of boating rules and
23 regulations, especially on a place like
24 Long Island Sound, where we share the waterway with
25 more than one state?
44
1 ASSEMBLYMAN McDONOUGH: Who knows?
2 BRIAN KEMP: We are members of the
3 National Association of State Boating Law
4 Administrators, and we do collaborate on different
5 things. We do exchange information, and we compare
6 laws and, we develop model acts, many of which
7 have found their way into state law.
8 So, we do that at a national level, and to
9 some extent, at a regional level as well. We're
10 aware of what different states are doing.
11 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Being aware, and us
12 having the same law, is what I'm getting at.
13 I mean, we're aware there are differences.
14 What I'm trying to get to is, I'd like to see
15 some movement in the direction of some type of
16 uniform set of rules and regulations, so the boater
17 who goes out there, knows the rules, assuming
18 they've taken, or read the books; and that
19 enforcement agencies -- police, Coast Guard,
20 auxiliary -- whoever's out there, knows there's
21 one set of rules, no matter where they are, that
22 can be enforced, so we don't have this hodgepodge.
23 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: We will always
24 work to coordinate. And we can work harder, and we
25 can be more deliberate.
45
1 And, also, our boating courses are all --
2 they're the same course materials that are used by
3 all the states.
4 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Yeah, that's true.
5 The boating safety program is accepted
6 everywhere, including Canada --
7 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Right. Right.
8 SENATOR MARCELLINO: -- so that we've that
9 commonalty, as far as the educational things.
10 However, the laws and the enforcement
11 varies from place to place, and in some cases.
12 So I think we're going to have to take a
13 long -- a hard look at that and see what we can do
14 with that, and how we can better coordinate on that
15 basis.
16 But I do appreciate you coming, and I thank
17 you. And thank Governor Cuomo for, hopefully,
18 reimbursing you on your expenses.
19 COMMISSIONER ROSE HARVEY: Thank you.
20 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Next speaker will be
21 Sergeant John T. Owen, Deputy Commanding Officer of
22 the Nassau County Police Department Marine Bureau.
23 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Good afternoon, State
24 Senator Marcellino, members of the Senate Standing
25 Committee on Investigations and Government
46
1 Operations, ladies and gentlemen.
2 My name is Sergeant John T. Owen. I've been
3 a member of the Nassau County Police Department
4 since 1986. I have been assigned to supervisor in
5 the Department's Marine and Aviation Bureau since
6 2001.
7 In addition to my normal patrol duties, I
8 have taken part in the recovery efforts of
9 TW Flight 800, during July of 1996; and I have taken
10 part in the immediate response and recovery
11 efforts at the World Trade Center on September 11,
12 2001, and during the weeks that followed.
13 Additionally, I've completed the Department's
14 comprehensive five-week marine law-enforcement
15 training program, which are all approved by the
16 New York State Division of the Criminal Justice
17 Services.
18 I am a certified boating-accident
19 investigator, by the National Association of Boater
20 Law Administrators.
21 My police colleagues and I have more than
22 ample experience with regional marine law
23 enforcement and the many issues regarding
24 recreational boating safety.
25 The Nassau County Police Department continues
47
1 to take a focused approach to marine law enforcement
2 and recreational boating safety in New York State's
3 marine district.
4 In 2011, the Nassau County Police Department
5 connected more than 30,000 hours of marine law
6 enforcement.
7 Since 2002, official statewide statistics
8 indicate that there's been nearly a 12 percent
9 decline in registered recreational vessels in
10 New York. Nevertheless, regional marine
11 law-enforcement statistics provides for an
12 important facts.
13 Official statewide statistics for 2011
14 indicate that nearly 7 percent of New York State's
15 recreational vehicles are registered in
16 Nassau County, and Nassau County is but one of
17 62 statistical counties in New York State.
18 Nearly 9 percent of all boating
19 safety-enforcement cases prosecuted in
20 New York State were conducted in Nassau County in
21 2011.
22 Official statewide statistics for 2011
23 further indicate that more than 12 percent of the
24 reported boating accidents in New York State
25 occurred in Nassau County, and 10 percent of the
48
1 arrests made for boater-while-intoxicated were
2 made by the Nassau County Police Department.
3 As a side note, I am proud to report that, to
4 date, the Nassau County Police Marine Bureau has
5 made 5 BWI arrests in 2012.
6 Marine law-enforcement recreational-boating
7 safety seems to be a very important policing issue
8 in the Long Island region. Clearly, the Nassau
9 County Police Department has 80 years of broad
10 professional experience in the area of marine law
11 enforcement and recreational boating safety.
12 The marine patrol experience of this
13 department has generally indicated that educated
14 operators are smarter and safer boater
15 operators. Education appears to be the key
16 component of safer boating.
17 At the present time, operators of
18 recreational vessels, as we spoke before, between
19 the ages of 10 and 18, must attend an approved
20 boater safety course, and must be boater-safety
21 certified in New York.
22 All operators of personal watercraft in
23 New York must attend an approved boater safety
24 course, and must be boater-safety certified, in
25 order to lawfully operate personal watercraft on
49
1 New York waters.
2 Official statewide statistics have
3 indicated that reported personal-watercraft
4 accidents have declined by half over the last
5 ten years.
6 And I think it's due to the education.
7 Again, education appears to be key
8 components of safer boating. Safer boating
9 equates to less injuries and less fatalities on
10 New York State waterways.
11 Needless to say, public safety is the number
12 one concern of our department.
13 And I'm grateful for the opportunity to
14 address the Committee on behalf of the
15 Nassau Community Police Department, especially in
16 relation to the important regional issue of
17 recreational boat and safety.
18 Thank you.
19 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Sergeant, thank you very
20 much.
21 Let me ask you the question I asked the
22 commissioner to open up with: In your opinion, are
23 our laws and regulations strong enough in
24 New York State?
25 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: I think the laws are --
50
1 they're very -- you know, the laws are fine, with
2 regard to, you know, the number of them, and the
3 scope of them.
4 The problem is the follow-up.
5 Right now, my associates in the town of
6 Oyster Bay can write a boater seven or eight NAV
7 tickets, navigational tickets. We can write
8 somebody seven or eight navigational tickets.
9 That same boater can go down to the town of
10 Hempsted and be cited again.
11 There's no -- there's no -- each one -- every
12 agency keeps track of their own tickets. There
13 is no State database where the tickets are
14 recorded. More importantly, BWIs are not recorded
15 under DMV.
16 So you can have a BWI, and when it's not
17 recorded anywhere, with regard to, you know, your
18 driving record, I understand it's a separate issue,
19 but, a person who boats while intoxicated, I would
20 say, wouldn't have a -- would be likely also to
21 drive while intoxicated.
22 So this is something that --
23 SENATOR MARCELLINO: He's got to get home.
24 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Pardon?
25 SENATOR MARCELLINO: He's got to get home.
51
1 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Yes, sir.
2 Also with regard to, you know, the laws --
3 the NAV laws that are in place, on the end, it's
4 just like I said, each agency takes -- keeps
5 track of their own tickets.
6 Same thing with BWIs. You know, there's no
7 end -- there's no depository, where the town of
8 Oyster Bay or the Nassau County Police or the
9 New York City Police can say: Well, this guy is a
10 horrible operator. He shouldn't be --
11 SENATOR MARCELLINO: When you give
12 John Q. Public, or Jane Q. Public, to be politically
13 correct, a ticket, and Jane seems to be under the
14 influence, that ticket stays within your agency?
15 There is no centralized database, so nobody else
16 knows that you gave that person a ticket but your
17 department?
18 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: No. If we were to lock
19 someone up for BWI, that person, all they have to do
20 is, go -- if they were on the north shore in Oyster
21 Bay, they would go down to the south shore, there's
22 no way for the Coast Guard or the Town of Hempsted
23 Bay Constables to know that that person has a
24 previous arrest for BWI. It's not recorded
25 anywhere.
52
1 SENATOR MARCELLINO: I see what you're
2 saying. Okay.
3 Because it's -- in the case of a driver, it
4 would be on his license. The points, then they
5 could look it up in the DMV and they would know
6 everything, so that there would be -- there's a
7 common area to pin it to, so you could follow it
8 there.
9 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Also, with regard to
10 driving, you know, with a certain number of
11 tickets, there's Scoff laws. And, you know, if
12 you don't pay your tickets, you know, they come
13 and boot your car, or impound your car.
14 Not so with -- you can have numerous
15 tickets, and you could still boat. There's no --
16 right now, there's no mechanism to discourage
17 people.
18 You know, they go to court, they dispense
19 of -- with the fines, but they can continue to
20 rack them up -- rack tickets up, and operate a
21 vessel. There's nothing -- there's no end -- you
22 know, there's nothing on end, to say, you know, if
23 you get X amount of tickets, or you're cited by,
24 you know, the town of -- I'm using the town of
25 Oyster Bay because we work closely with them -- but,
53
1 if you're cited by the Town of Oyster Bay, you're
2 cited by the police, after X number of tickets,
3 we're going to impound your boat. We're going to
4 take away your -- you know, I understand they're
5 registered, and so we have -- we can easily do that.
6 I mean, we know who owns the boats.
7 So, that would be something that maybe your
8 Committee could look into, with regard to the --
9 SENATOR MARCELLINO: So if some way, the --
10 that wouldn't necessarily tell you who was driving
11 the boat, because people do lend their boats to
12 others, or, the person driving the boat might not
13 be the owner of the boat, as was the case on the
14 4th, apparently, and -- in that accident where the
15 children died.
16 If you applied the tickets to the
17 registration, the boat registration, at the very
18 least, you'd be able to track that boat?
19 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Yes.
20 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Not necessarily who was
21 operating the boat at that given time?
22 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: That's correct.
23 If -- if -- say, for instance, I was
24 operating my friend's boat, and my friend had -- was
25 a reckless operator and had gotten a number of
54
1 tickets on a number occasions from different
2 agencies, and it was some -- and we ran it, you
3 know, we were able to check either through DMV or
4 some other, you know, interconnected database, then,
5 either the Town of Oyster Bay, the police
6 departments, or whoever, would be able to impound
7 that vessel until either the owner paid the
8 tickets.
9 If -- you know, right now, I don't believe
10 there's a very strong impetus to pay NAV tickets.
11 You know, and I don't think the fine schedule is,
12 you know, really cumbersome.
13 I'm not familiar with them, but I know it's
14 not like Vehicle and Traffic Law tickets.
15 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Okay. So if -- all
16 right, you've opened up an area, frankly, I hadn't
17 even thought about: the inability to track, or, to
18 keep, and get handle on, who's a scofflaw, and isn't
19 in sharing the database.
20 So, we need some type of sharing of
21 information.
22 That's interesting. That's -- you've taught
23 me something today, Sergeant. I appreciate that.
24 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: You're welcome.
25 SENATOR MARCELLINO: In your opinion, and if
55
1 I'm putting you on the spot, you can decline to
2 answer: Is there enough enforcement capability out
3 there on the water?
4 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Yes, there is.
5 SENATOR MARCELLINO: There is enough
6 enforcement capability?
7 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Yes, there is.
8 SENATOR MARCELLINO: In your departments,
9 towns, counties, whatever, you feel it's adequate?
10 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Yes.
11 SENATOR MARCELLINO: We've been joined by my
12 colleague in the New York State Senate,
13 Senator Ken LaValle, from the 1st District, who
14 deals with both points, both forks, of
15 Long Island.
16 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: How are you, Senator?
17 SENATOR MARCELLINO: If you would like --
18 okay, Assemblyman Montesano.
19 Thank you, Sergeant. Appreciate your time.
20 The Assemblyman has some questions for you.
21 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: Sergeant, I just
22 wanted to ask you: One of the things that came up
23 earlier in some of the testimony, is the safety-vest
24 issue, that, for so many months out of the year, I
25 believe, November to May, they have to wear safety
56
1 vests under a certain age on boats, and then the
2 other six-month period they don't.
3 Could you explain that to me, why they might
4 have such a regulation?
5 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: I'm unfamiliar with
6 the -- I -- if it's -- it's a year-round -- I
7 believe it's a year-round requirement that -- I
8 don't know, I'm not sure of the ages off the top of
9 my head, they have to wear -- if they're aboard a
10 vessel they'd have to wear it. It doesn't -- it's
11 not a month-to-month thing.
12 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: I know, because the
13 commissioner of Parks had indicated, that if the
14 vessel is less than 21 feet, then, between the
15 cold-water months of November 1st to May 1st, it's
16 not mandatory to wear a life jacket.
17 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Well, I'm not familiar
18 with that.
19 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: Okay. All right.
20 And the other question is: What's your
21 opinion of the fact that people over the age of 18
22 do not need a boater safety certificate to operate
23 boats?
24 You know, do you have an opinion based on
25 your years of experience?
57
1 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Well, I could tell you
2 from my own experience: Years ago, when I first
3 purchased a boat, I took a Power Squadron boater
4 course in Massapequa. It was excellent.
5 Also, I also attended, the Nassau County
6 Police Department gives a boater safety
7 certificate. I attended that. And it was
8 excellent.
9 Along with my other training.
10 It never hurts to, the information. I
11 mean, we got a lot of good people out there. Like I
12 said, you got the Coast Guard Auxiliary, you got the
13 Power -- various Power Squadrons. These are very
14 dedicated people, dedicated to, you know, safe
15 boating. And it can't be overlooked -- that
16 resource can't be overlooked.
17 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: Okay, thank you very
18 much.
19 Thank you, Chairman.
20 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Senator Martin?
21 SENATOR MARTINS: There's a common theme, I
22 think, in what we've heard so far, and that's,
23 education is key.
24 And I think you testified to that yourself.
25 I have seen some -- perhaps some arbitrary
58
1 distinctions between different age groups,
2 different types of vehicles.
3 Is it fair to say that requiring some level
4 of education, as a basic condition to operating
5 watercraft, would make a tremendous difference in
6 terms of boater safety?
7 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: I'd have to -- based on
8 my experience, I'd have to agree with that.
9 Like Mr. Della had said, you can go,
10 tomorrow, to any boat, and buy whatever boat you can
11 afford, register it, put it in the water, and go.
12 That's -- that seems to be problematic.
13 SENATOR MARTINS: I appreciate that. Thank
14 you.
15 No further questions.
16 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Senator LaValle, would
17 you like to --
18 SENATOR LaVALLE: (Shakes head.)
19 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Assemblywoman?
20 SENATOR MARTINS: No.
21 I learned a lot about the lack of
22 connections with all of this ticketing, which is
23 very interesting.
24 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Ticketing and the BWI
25 and, like -- like the end result, there's nothing to
59
1 discourage somebody from doing that.
2 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Okay. Thank you very
3 much, Sergeant. Appreciate your time.
4 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Thank you, Senator.
5 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Our next speaker would
6 be District Commander Lawrence Postel of the
7 U.S. Power Squadrons, District 3 - Long Island.
8 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Good
9 afternoon. My name is Lawrence Postel --
10 SENATOR MARCELLINO: No, it's good afternoon,
11 I'm sorry.
12 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Oh.
13 [Laughter.]
14 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: I was
15 hoping to be first.
16 [Laughter.]
17 SENATOR MARCELLINO: It's about twenty after
18 twelve. We've got to be specific.
19 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: My name is
20 Lawrence Postel, and I'm representing United States
21 Power Squadrons, "USPS," not to be confused with the
22 United States Postal Service who is also "USPS."
23 Some personal background: I've been boating
24 for over 30 years.
25 I am a life member of the United States
60
1 Power Squadrons, which means I have had 25 years of
2 service, and at least one merit mark for each of
3 those years, making it 25. And you get one merit
4 mark for each year, for providing significant
5 service to the organization.
6 I carry the grade of Senior Navigator, which
7 means I've taken every advanced-grade course,
8 including celestial navigation, and six elective
9 courses offered by the organization.
10 I equate this accomplishment to a Ph.D. in
11 boating safety.
12 I have not pursued a captain's license
13 because my boat and I are not for hire, but I do
14 volunteer my time to teaching safe boating for the
15 organization.
16 Currently, I am the commander of District 3,
17 and responsible for overseeing the 18 squadrons on
18 Long Island, covering the area from Brooklyn to
19 Montauk Point.
20 Who, and what, is the "United States
21 Power Squadrons"?
22 It's still the best-kept secret.
23 It's a national organization covering the
24 entire United States, including Puerto Rico and
25 Hawaii. It's made up of 33 districts, with
61
1 District 3 being one.
2 Our mission is to teach safe boating,
3 starting with the basic ABC course, and later
4 followed by advanced-grade and elective courses.
5 Our ABC course is both
6 U.S. Coast Guard-approved and National Safe
7 Boating -- National State Boating Law
8 Administrator-approved.
9 I have -- we have signed an "MOU," a
10 memorandum of understanding, with the State of
11 New York, and we are one of three organizations
12 qualified to issue the certificate of completion,
13 recognizing that a student has taken a safe-boating
14 course.
15 Initially, we only offered our ABC course to
16 the public. You had to become a member of the
17 organization to take further courses.
18 Recently, the USPS changed its philosophy,
19 and opened some of our advanced-grade and elective
20 courses to non-members. This change was brought
21 about to fulfill an identified need to further our
22 public education offerings.
23 We've also developed an on-the-water training
24 class, featuring classroom sessions and hands-on
25 environment aboard a vessel.
62
1 Any member of USPS is teaching a public
2 course, must be certified by the United States
3 Power Squadrons. They must maintain this
4 certification by attending recertification classes
5 on a regular basis.
6 Why did USPS make these changes to offer
7 more public courses?
8 It came to our attention, while the USPS
9 ABC course is a premier course offering tremendous
10 value to the student, it only offers the basics,
11 and you need more than that to be a competent, safe
12 boater.
13 To support this concept, I will compare
14 piloting a boat to driving a car.
15 The traffic lanes are not marked and easily
16 viewed white lines, but by a buoy system that can
17 have significant distance between successive
18 buoys.
19 I've tried to paint those white lanes each
20 time I go out, but they constantly disappear.
21 There are no entrance and exit lanes to enter
22 or leave a lane -- traffic lane.
23 There are no traffic lights to control the
24 traffic.
25 Boaters depend upon rules of the road,
63
1 common sense, and courtesy to prevail.
2 There are no shoulder lanes to pull off, to
3 wait out sudden storms or fog which may pop up at
4 any moment due to sudden weather changes.
5 There are no street lights to light the way
6 for night boating.
7 There are no headlights on boats.
8 While search lights are available, they are
9 not used while on the way. If someone uses a search
10 light constantly, you will blind other boaters.
11 Boaters depend on moonlight, ambient light,
12 and vessel-markings' light to navigate the
13 waters.
14 While we cover these basics in our
15 above-basic boating course, we cannot get into
16 detailed lectures on these topics.
17 The United States Power Squadrons fully
18 supports all efforts to mandate that every
19 boater take at least the basic boating class.
20 We further suggest that New York State
21 consider some combination of at-home computer
22 learning, augmented by the classroom instruction, as
23 part of the 8-hour classroom requirement currently
24 required by the State.
25 We would like to offer our CD we provide to
64
1 each student with the ABC course material as an
2 example of this computer learning.
3 We recommend that the implementation of any
4 legislature [sic] receive careful consideration as
5 to instructor and material availability.
6 The last thing we would like to see is
7 legislation passed and services not being able to be
8 provided.
9 Please do not legislate anything that will
10 allow individuals to fill their pockets with
11 money, and send people out on the water with a false
12 sense of security, to satisfy a mandated
13 requirement. This will not accomplish the intent of
14 the educating boaters to reduce the needless
15 accidents and death.
16 The United States Power Squadrons stands
17 ready to help and design and implement a process
18 that will be viable to meet the demand and meet the
19 requirements of educating the public.
20 I would like to thank Senator Marcellino
21 for -- and the State Senate Committee, for the
22 opportunity to voice our opinion on boater
23 education, and help in any way we can.
24 I would like to add, there were a couple
25 little comments:
65
1 I would like to see that there be -- there is
2 an insurance incentive for taking a safe-boating
3 class. It usually is about 10 percent offered by
4 insurance companies.
5 We would also like to see, if you take
6 advanced courses, that number increase. That would
7 encourage people to take more and more education.
8 As an example: My boat is insured by the
9 New York State Power Squadrons' insurance company,
10 and, because I have the senior navigator, I'm
11 receiving a 45 percent discount in my premiums.
12 And, they augment, and go up, the more and more I
13 learn.
14 There is no more for me to learn, so I can't
15 get any bigger discount.
16 I did notice some things here, that some
17 people were confusing registration with licensing.
18 You must register a boat in New York State in
19 order -- as long as it has a motor on it.
20 That is not a license to operate it. That's
21 just a way of tracking that there is a boat on the
22 water, and paying New York State a fee. And those
23 fees do change by the size of the boat.
24 My registration fee just came up. It's for
25 three years, it was $95.
66
1 Okay?
2 So that covered a three-year period.
3 No, it does not run commensurate with that
4 registering my automobile, which is much, much more.
5 All right?
6 The other thing that was mentioned by the
7 State, in that, the various laws, the State does
8 trump federal requirements.
9 Federal requirements say that you have to
10 be 14 years of age. If you are 14 years of age,
11 or younger, on a boat, you must wear a life jacket
12 while contained in a cabin.
13 New York State mandates 12. That law
14 trumps federal law.
15 All right?
16 So, in New York State, when we teach the
17 courses, we say you must be 12 and -- if you're 12,
18 and under, you must have a jacket on.
19 Okay?
20 SENATOR MARCELLINO: A jacket is worn inside
21 a cabin, and outside?
22 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: There is --
23 according to the law, the way it reads: If a child
24 is riding within the cabin of a cabin boat, they do
25 not have to wear the life jacket.
67
1 If they are outside the cabin -- in the
2 cockpit area or up on a fly bridge -- or any part of
3 the open boat -- then you must wear that life
4 jacket.
5 So, inside the cabin, it is not mandatory.
6 I'm not going to get into it, and I'm not
7 allowed to give my personal opinion on that, but, a
8 life jacket is a life jacket, okay, and a child is a
9 child.
10 Sitting alongside of me is Larry Weiss, who
11 is the representative of -- New York State
12 legislative representative for the Power Squadron.
13 I know he has a couple of other points to
14 make.
15 If any of you would like to question me,
16 please shoot your questions at me.
17 SENATOR MARCELLINO: We're going to hear
18 Mr. Weiss first, before you do that.
19 And he is the New York State Legislative
20 Liaison to the U.S. Power Squadron.
21 So, Mr. Weiss?
22 LARRY WEISS: Okay.
23 I have submitted some very extensive written
24 testimony. I'm not going to go through all of that.
25 I just want to make a couple of points.
68
1 SENATOR MARCELLINO: God bless you.
2 LARRY WEISS: Thank you.
3 So -- but, first of all, in addition to other
4 qualifications, I need to say that, my family and
5 I boat right here in Oyster Bay. I'm the past
6 commander of Oyster Bay Power Squadron. This is our
7 community.
8 We were out at the fireworks show that
9 night, July 4th, and I'm sure as the emergency
10 operations were going on.
11 And, I have to tell you that this community
12 is still reeling from this tragedy. It is talked
13 about every day, and a lot of people are very
14 concerned.
15 And from that place, on behalf of
16 United States Power Squadrons, and my family, and
17 myself, and fellow boaters here in Oyster Bay, I do
18 wish to extend our most sincere condolences to
19 anyone and everyone who has experienced a loss due
20 to a boating tragedy, whether recently or in years
21 past.
22 These accidents deeply touch all of us who
23 enjoy the water, but we can only imagine the pain
24 and anguish one must feel upon suddenly losing a
25 loved one who was simply engaged in the enjoyment of
69
1 what is otherwise one of New York State's most
2 delightful recreational experiences.
3 So, I currently serve as United States
4 Power Squadrons' New York State legislative liaison.
5 I report to the national United States Power
6 Squadrons' Government and Partner Relations
7 Committee.
8 It's my responsibility to provide
9 United States Power Squadrons' resources,
10 information, and guidance to any state legislator
11 who's exploring or involved with any legislation
12 that might be related to recreational boating.
13 My job also includes working closely with
14 any legislator interested in boating safety and
15 education, and to report any state legislative
16 activities that may be related to recreational
17 boating back to my committee, the Government and
18 Partner Relations Committee.
19 To this end, I would like all of you to know
20 that I am at your disposal, and through me, the
21 resources of United States Power Squadrons.
22 I want to cover a couple of points from
23 United States Power Squadrons and our Committee,
24 much of it reiterates what Commander Postel talked
25 about, but I want to elaborate on a couple of
70
1 things.
2 United States Power Squadron members
3 support state mandatory recreational boater
4 education, that at the very least, meets "NASBLA"
5 standards; National Association of State Boating Law
6 Administrators. And that includes proctored
7 examinations.
8 We say "at the very least," because
9 NASBLA-approved courses barely scratch the surface
10 of education truly needed to operate a vessel in a
11 safe and confident manner.
12 United States Power Squadrons encourages
13 every recreational boater to continue their
14 education on an ongoing basis, gaining knowledge in,
15 if not mastering, seamanship, piloting, navigation,
16 handling, weather, electronics, engine
17 maintenance, and more.
18 Boats and boat operations are complicated,
19 far more so than automobiles. There are many
20 aspects to safe boating. They simply cannot all
21 be covered in a basic 8-hour NASBLA-approved course.
22 And all of these aspects are important for the safe
23 operation of a recreational boat.
24 United States Power Squadron members are
25 concerned about the manner in which mandatory
71
1 education is introduced to the public.
2 If not carefully phased in over time, and
3 you've heard this already, the sudden demand could
4 very well overwhelm the current available resources
5 of the Power Squadron, the Coast Guard Auxiliary,
6 Parks Department, and other teaching organizations.
7 We have to do this very carefully.
8 United States Power Squadron members
9 believe that any state licensing of recreational
10 boat operators should be based on strong
11 educational requirements.
12 U.S. Power Squadron members are not in favor
13 of recreational boat-operator licensing as a revenue
14 generator for the state. That should not be the
15 purpose of doing this.
16 USPS members will continue to provide
17 education support in all states of the
18 United States.
19 About BUI: Beyond agreeing that boating
20 under the influence is a very serious matter, and we
21 certainly take it very seriously, United States
22 Power Squadron members do not take a position on
23 the specific determination or penalty aspects of
24 boating under the influence. These are
25 state-by-state issues.
72
1 However, and we teach this in our basic
2 safe-boating class, we would advise this Committee,
3 and all State legislators, to be aware that drugs
4 and alcohol can affect boaters in ways that they
5 might -- in more ways than they might affect
6 others who are not on the water.
7 Not only can alcohol and drugs affect
8 judgment, clear thinking, and reflexes, they can
9 also affect one's ability to survive if he or she
10 falls overboard, or otherwise finds him or herself
11 in the water.
12 It can also make much worse a phenomenon
13 known as "boater's fatigue." This is a drunk-like
14 condition that research shows can result from
15 overexposure to noise, vibrations, sun glare,
16 wind, and water motion that one would normally
17 experience on the water.
18 United States Power Squadron members
19 believe wearing personal flotation devices should be
20 mandatory for everyone age 12 and under.
21 That is the rule here in New York State, and
22 we're glad for that.
23 USPS members further support requiring the
24 wearing of PFDs while underway, drifting, or at
25 anchor, for everyone on board small open boats, thus
73
1 potentially increasing a person's chances of
2 surviving small-boat accidents, to death by
3 drowning.
4 The rest of my testimony you have.
5 I would like to cover -- make two very quick
6 points:
7 We do not necessarily believe that
8 safe-boating courses should be taught in one 8-hour
9 sitting.
10 Most of these courses, at least the basic
11 8-hour course, is designed to be taught over four
12 2-hour sessions, giving opportunity for students
13 to do homework, read the text, absorb the material.
14 Sitting through one long 8-hour course,
15 I mean, we're sitting through a couple-of-hour
16 hearing today, and it's going to get tiring.
17 Imagine sitting through a full day of this
18 stuff, trying to absorb it, and then go boating.
19 We encourage that these classes be taught
20 over many sessions.
21 The other piece, which is a slight tangent,
22 but it needs to be mentioned: It's my
23 understanding, based on a report from the Boat U.S.
24 organization -- Boat Owners Association of
25 United States -- that among the top ten boating
74
1 states, all of them, except New York State,
2 earmark for boating purposes, taxes collected on the
3 sale of boat fuel.
4 As I understand it, fuel taxes paid by
5 New York State boaters go to a general fund that
6 covers highway improvements, even though boats
7 don't run on highways.
8 And we would like to suggest that monies
9 collected by New York State from taxes on boat fuel,
10 may be even sales taxes on boat purchases and marine
11 supplies, go to be earmarked for a fund for boating
12 purposes. Such a fund could pay for the
13 administration of the types of mandatory education
14 that we're talking about.
15 It could also provide grants to increase
16 boating safety, such as providing new boats and
17 staffing for marine police bureaus,
18 bay constables, fire departments, dive teams,
19 plus new pump-out facilities, launch ramps,
20 environmental aspects, and more.
21 So, we just want to make you aware of that;
22 there's funding right now in the boating world
23 that's going to the highway world, that might be
24 better served taking care of the issues that we're
25 discussing today.
75
1 And I want to thank all of you for hearing
2 us, and hearing what the United States Power
3 Squadrons has to say.
4 SENATOR MARCELLINO: I thank you both.
5 Just to emphasize one of your points,
6 according to the Coast Guard statistics that I
7 referred to earlier:
8 Only 11 percent of the deaths occurred on
9 boats where the operator had received boating safety
10 instruction.
11 Only 7 percent of the deaths occurred on
12 vessels where the operator had received boating
13 safety instructions from a NASBLA- -- or the
14 National Association of State Boating Law
15 Administrators- -- approved course provider.
16 So, obviously, it is a very effective program
17 in protecting lives and property.
18 Let me, if I might, just ask you the same
19 question I asked the sergeant and the commissioner
20 and people before you: In your opinion, are the
21 laws strong enough?
22 The laws that exist today, are they strong
23 enough to protect the public?
24 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: The laws
25 that we currently have are State-mandated laws, and
76
1 the Power Squadron really can't comment on those.
2 But, as a State person, I will say the laws are
3 not strong enough.
4 Okay?
5 That's my personal opinion.
6 LARRY WEISS: I would add, that
7 New York State has extensive boating regulations,
8 and --
9 SENATOR MARCELLINO: They're expensive too.
10 LARRY WEISS: Yeah. Sometimes, yeah.
11 But the issue, really, is not so much about
12 the boating regulations, following this -- you know
13 this rule or that rule, about how to conduct one's
14 self on the water. The issue is about boaters
15 understanding, being aware of, and following those
16 regulations.
17 In addition, there's something we call the
18 "three Cs," when we teach our boating course:
19 courtesy, caution, and --
20 Oh, my goodness, my brain just fried.
21 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Common
22 sense.
23 LARRY WEISS: -- and common sense.
24 Thank you.
25 SENATOR MARCELLINO: At least you didn't say
77
1 "Oops."
2 [Laughter.]
3 LARRY WEISS: Right. Yeah, that's right.
4 Courtesy, caution, and common sense: You
5 can't legislate courtesy, caution, and common sense,
6 and we can try to teach it in a class, but we can't
7 instill it. That's a societal thing, and it seems
8 to be getting weaker and weaker. And, we see it on
9 the water as boaters get a little crazier and
10 crazier.
11 SENATOR MARCELLINO: One more question, the
12 enforceability: Do you feel that there is adequate
13 enforcement capability out there on the water today?
14 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Personally?
15 No.
16 There is -- I think what we need to do, is
17 take a look at the number of boats that are
18 registered in New York State, and compare that to
19 the number of officers, or different form. You
20 have the bay constables out there, the towns
21 have State constables out there, and, the county
22 and -- there's actually the two counties, Suffolk
23 and Nassau, both have people out there on the
24 boats.
25 But it is not -- if you look at a per-capita
78
1 basis, it's nowhere near the number of officers that
2 are patrolling the roads.
3 Okay?
4 And an officer did tell me, at one point in
5 time, you cannot just stop a boat for any old reason
6 and ask to do an investigation. There has to be a
7 reason.
8 They have to either see no registration on
9 the boat, possibly erratic operation of the boat, or
10 doing something totally wrong.
11 But you just can't ride along the water, and
12 say: You, I want to board the boat and take a look
13 at it.
14 Okay?
15 So, we need to look at some of those things.
16 And, again, that the Power Squadron can't get
17 involved in that because we're a national
18 organization, and these are state-regulated things.
19 So --
20 LARRY WEISS: I willed add, here in
21 Nassau County, we have a couple of police boats that
22 are responsible for the north shore of
23 Nassau County. That's from the Queens line, to
24 Huntington.
25 It can take an hour, hour and a half, to get
79
1 from one end to the other.
2 If someone's in distress, it takes a long
3 time, sometimes, for those involved in public safety
4 to arrive on the scene.
5 We encourage boaters to also stand by. I
6 think we've a -- sort of a rule about -- a
7 Good Samaritan-type rule, that, we must come to the
8 aid of boaters in distress, as long as it does not
9 endanger anyone on our boat or our vessel, because
10 it can take a lot of time for help to arrive
11 sometimes.
12 It would be nice if some of that help was a
13 little closer by.
14 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Senator Martins?
15 SENATOR MARTINS: No. Thank you.
16 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Let Kenny go.
17 Ken, go ahead.
18 SENATOR LaVALLE: Thank you.
19 Two points, if you could react to it:
20 Do we have the educational infrastructure to
21 meet a demand should the Legislature mandate an
22 education requirement?
23 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: It would
24 have to be ramped up, I believe.
25 Okay?
80
1 It depends upon us -- that's why I said, we
2 would love to be part of the implementation plan, so
3 that both the State and us, and the other
4 instructors that could do it is the Coast Guard
5 Auxiliary, that between us, that we could determine:
6 Will we have this?
7 Because the last thing you want to do is
8 mandate something that we can't officiate and make
9 happen.
10 So, I -- I cannot answer the question
11 definitively, but I will say, I think we could be
12 lacking, if it was implemented too quickly, and too
13 fast, to meet it.
14 And that has happened in other states. I
15 will not mention the states, but, there were other
16 states that implemented things, and they did not
17 have the forces to teach the people in time, and
18 there was screaming, ranting, and raving.
19 SENATOR LaVALLE: You would need a couple of
20 years?
21 Two years? Three years? Five years? --
22 to --
23 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: I would say
24 a couple of years. But, again, what we need to do
25 is look at the demographics of what we're going to
81
1 try and do, where we're going to do it.
2 I'm here on Long Island. But you do this for
3 the state, you got to realize that covers the
4 lakes, the rivers, throughout New York State.
5 So, Lake George, and all of the other lakes, would
6 be covered by this.
7 Again, that has to be looked at: What is it
8 like in that area?
9 I can speak for Long Island, for this area,
10 but I'm not too sure about the other areas.
11 So I think a working committee is also
12 important to getting the legislation passed.
13 SENATOR LaVALLE: Mr. Weiss mentioned
14 something, and I chuckled, because I underlined it,
15 and I wanted to just ask your reaction.
16 Commander Postel, you made a point; you said:
17 Boaters depend on rules of the roading, common
18 sense, and courtesy to prevail.
19 You reinforced that, your remarks.
20 So, what are we looking at?
21 Do most people follow rules of the road,
22 are courteous, use common sense?
23 Or, is it just a bunch, a small percentage of
24 cowboys out there?
25 Mr. Weiss mentioned something that I think
82
1 is dead on; that our society now is at a point where
2 people seem -- rules of the road are not as
3 important as they once were in other society.
4 So, what are we dealing with?
5 A small percentage or a large percentage?
6 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: We're
7 dealing, a small percentage of the people out there,
8 and you heard it.
9 I will tell you, that 10 percent of the
10 boaters that are on the waters have taken a
11 safe-boating class.
12 Without having taken a safe-boating class,
13 you've got no knowledge of rules of the road. You
14 don't know what it is.
15 Which way do you pass, meeting vessels? --
16 things like that, are all things that you need to
17 understand when you're operating a boat.
18 And only 10 percent of the people on the
19 water know that.
20 And I'll tell you, of the rest of the people
21 out on the water, there's probably zero common
22 sense.
23 All right?
24 LARRY WEISS: Or less.
25 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Or less.
83
1 Common sense does not prevail.
2 And there is a -- like an unwritten rule,
3 which is kind of ridiculous, but, bigger is
4 mightier.
5 Okay?
6 A bigger boat always appears to be mightier
7 than a smaller boat.
8 So when I come up against a big huge ferry,
9 there's no way I'm going to challenge what he's
10 doing. Whether he's right or wrong, I'm backing
11 down.
12 There are people out there that won't back
13 down.
14 SENATOR LaVALLE: I know that firsthand,
15 because my craft is 14 1/2 feet. It's called a
16 "kayak." And, so, I know that firsthand.
17 Thank you, Senator Marcellino.
18 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Senator LaValle has the
19 only powered kayak in the state.
20 [Laughter.]
21 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Senator Martins.
22 SENATOR MARTINS: Thank you.
23 Just to follow up on a question that
24 Senator LaValle just posed, or a comment: I sense
25 that education is a key component to what you're
84
1 advocating today. As a basic, even if it's just an
2 8-hour course, it's better than nothing. And,
3 certainly, the status quo with no education is not
4 an option.
5 Would that be fair?
6 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Yes.
7 LARRY WEISS: Yes.
8 SENATOR MARTINS: Commander, you mentioned
9 that you've been boating for 30 years.
10 And, I would expect that over the last
11 30 years, there's been a dramatic increase in
12 number of boats and boaters on the waters,
13 especially around -- in and around Long Island.
14 Would that be fair?
15 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Yes.
16 SENATOR MARTINS: So, with the accessibility
17 of boats, with more and more people purchasing a
18 boat and using it, besides adding an educational
19 component or a licensing component, are there any
20 other recommendations that we should be focusing on
21 in terms of providing for safety?
22 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: I can't
23 really think of any at the moment.
24 But I would like to say, that what we were
25 saying about insurance, and things like that, to
85
1 make people want to take more courses, because you
2 got to put a little bait on the hook.
3 Okay?
4 And if you -- once you hook them, then you
5 can try to say: Well, if you take more courses, we
6 can get a -- you could receive a reduction from your
7 insurance company.
8 So, the State needs to work with the
9 insurance companies, to provide that.
10 And as I said, the Power Squadrons offers
11 me a 45 percent discount for taking all of the
12 courses that I did, over someone who did not take
13 any courses.
14 SENATOR MARTINS: You know, we are -- I am
15 loath to creating another layer of infrastructure,
16 another State mandate, requiring people to do
17 certain things and restricting people's abilities to
18 do certain things.
19 But this seems, to use your own phrase,
20 common sense; that, you know, the equivalent and
21 alternative in our world, for most of us here, is to
22 give the keys to your car to, you know, your
23 16-year-old, or 17-year-old, and say:
24 Congratulations, you just turned 16. Here are the
25 keys, go.
86
1 Not understanding the rules of the road,
2 not understanding the basics of stopping,
3 starting, lane mergers, lane changes; just, "Here
4 are the keys, and go."
5 And it appears very much, like, the rules
6 and regulations currently in place, and the
7 structure currently in place, for boating, is very
8 much that way; without there being any requirements
9 for proper education, formal education, learning the
10 rules of the road, and, making sure that people
11 have a basic understanding, to the extent that there
12 isn't common sense, to the extent that there isn't
13 common courtesy, a basic understanding of what they
14 should be doing out there.
15 Fair?
16 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Yes.
17 LARRY WEISS: Yes.
18 SENATOR MARTINS: Thank you.
19 LARRY WEISS: There is something to add to
20 that, if I may --
21 SENATOR MARTINS: Sure.
22 LARRY WEISS: -- is that, a very big
23 difference between operating a boat, operating a
24 car.
25 SENATOR MARTINS: Of course.
87
1 LARRY WEISS: As Commander pointed out, you
2 know, driving an automobile, you have roadways,
3 you have traffic lights. You have, if need be,
4 police directing traffic. It's easy to do, because
5 cars stay on the road and follow the lanes.
6 It's very easy to direct.
7 On the water, it's very hard to communicate
8 what is needed, from law enforcement to a large
9 group of boaters.
10 It's very hard to direct traffic, or redirect
11 traffic, or detour traffic.
12 A boat is kind of an isolated little world.
13 And, the operator of a boat, or the captain of the
14 boat, if you will, has a tremendous responsibility
15 to everyone else on the water, to the safe operation
16 of everybody else on the water, to everybody that is
17 on board their boat.
18 And, that responsibility requires that they
19 know what to do, because it's very hard for law
20 enforcement, or any other type of safety rule that
21 you guys might want to put into law, it's very
22 hard to communicate to that, to an individual.
23 Once they're out on their boat, they're on
24 their own.
25 SENATOR MARTINS: And that just highlights
88
1 the need.
2 LARRY WEISS: Yeah.
3 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Thank you.
4 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Sandra? Mike?
5 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Just -- yes, just two
6 quick questions, one of which was brought to my
7 attention, that, maybe, within the 8-hour
8 boat-safety course, that there might be, if you're
9 going to be using your boat, particularly in the
10 New York City area, and so on, that maybe there's a
11 different highlight within that course, than
12 something you might use elsewhere.
13 Do we do that in our course?
14 Do we think about where the boater is maybe
15 going to spend most of their time boating, and the
16 course is tailored to those kinds of needs, which
17 might be a little different?
18 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: In general,
19 as you teach throughout, we'll say, [unintelligible]
20 course, you're teaching at various different points
21 on Long Island, so you're addressing students that
22 come from that area.
23 But one of the main questions that I always
24 ask is: Where are you going to boat?
25 And a prime example is, the difference
89
1 between the north shore and the south shore.
2 On the south shore, you're boating in very,
3 very shallow waters, but it's only a sandy bottom.
4 And if you ground the boat, you're not going to do a
5 lot of damage.
6 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Right?
7 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: You go up
8 on the north shore, and you go anywhere near the
9 rocks, you're going to put a big hole in the boat.
10 So, there is a difference as to where you're
11 boating, and that.
12 If you're boating in New York City -- I've
13 been around Long Island four times -- and you get
14 into Manhattan, there's a whole different traffic
15 situation. I mean, you're dealing with barges and
16 huge ships coming in and coming out of -- under
17 the Verrazano Bridge.
18 So, that is something, you know, we do teach
19 it, but, until you see it, it's a very difficult
20 thing to understand.
21 LARRY WEISS: There are also differences in
22 laws. We were talking before about state trumping
23 federal, trumping local.
24 New York State law, for example, requires
25 that vessels operate at a no-wake speed within
90
1 100 feet of a dock, the shore, swimming areas,
2 another boat that's anchored, for example.
3 In the town of Oyster Bay, the law is
4 200 feet.
5 And, so, when we teach in Oyster Bay Power
6 Squadron here, we need to remind boaters that it's
7 200 feet.
8 So, it does get tailored.
9 And we also have something called the
10 "U.S. Navigation Aid System," and the
11 "Inland Waterways Navigation System."
12 We don't teach inland waterways extensively
13 here on Long Island, because we're using the main
14 navigational aids.
15 But in Lake George, or some of the other
16 inland waters, they might teach the different
17 navigational-aid systems with emphasis.
18 So, there are differences.
19 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Right. Okay, thank
20 you.
21 My other question is actually about
22 Lake George, and other places.
23 What do we do with the tourism industry?
24 As I was working on crafting legislation, one
25 of the issues is: Okay, tourism. Lakes, people
91
1 go to Lake George for the week, and they want to go
2 out on a boat, and so on.
3 And how do we deal with people having to have
4 boat safety courses in situations like that?
5 Are there other states that have good
6 examples of what they've been able to accomplish?
7 I'm sure people go to Florida and go out
8 on a boat without some experience.
9 What do you suggest?
10 LARRY WEISS: Well, there are a couple of
11 aspects.
12 The first is, the accident we had on
13 Lake George was a commercial operation, which
14 United States Power Squadron doesn't really
15 involved. We're more involved with recreational
16 boating.
17 However, as far as recreational boats go,
18 if anyone is to rent a boat -- whether you're on
19 Lake George, as a tourist, you can rent a boat right
20 here in Oyster Bay and go fishing -- the person who
21 is renting the boat has the responsibility, right,
22 to make sure that there are enough life jackets on
23 the boat, that the boat is meeting all of the
24 requirements.
25 And, in this case, if education is mandated,
92
1 that would be part of the mandate: The person
2 renting the boat needs to have that certification.
3 That's what we would recommend.
4 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Where
5 that -- actually, where that also falls into very
6 quickly, is these personal watercrafts.
7 All right?
8 If you go to rent a personal watercraft, it's
9 the obligation of the renter to check to see that
10 you have had a safe-boating course.
11 And if you haven't had one, they are
12 obligated to give you one. It might be a four-hour,
13 quick, one, two, three, class in, but they are
14 obligated to give you one before you can actually
15 rent that boat.
16 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Senator?
17 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: Thank you, Senator.
18 I just want to ask, you touched on a moment
19 ago, about the navigational aids, and things of that
20 nature.
21 So, not being a boater, if you could explain
22 to me: So, you educate people who operate in the
23 waters here. On Long Island and New York City,
24 you said has its own situation, with cruise ships
25 coming in and out, cargo ships.
93
1 But, are the rules of the waterways the
2 same, whether it be a river, the ocean, or anything?
3 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Yes.
4 Well, the rules are basically the same for
5 the buoy system, okay, within the inland waters.
6 Okay?
7 Red, right, return; which way are you going?
8 Returning from sea, going to sea?
9 Those are all things that you need to
10 understand, and those are the lane dividers of how
11 a boat is run.
12 These markers do change in color. There
13 are different things. There are yellow markers
14 meaning something different. White markers
15 meaning something different.
16 No clamming, no fishing, doing things like
17 that, there are restrictive-type markers out
18 there.
19 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: But -- so what
20 situation would we've to address?
21 Because you indicated that places like
22 Lake George, and other places up in north country,
23 may have different situations.
24 So, we have to create a course that's going
25 be universal throughout the state?
94
1 LARRY WEISS: It is universal.
2 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: It's
3 universal.
4 But what I was referring to, I think, was
5 that I cannot attest to what is -- how many
6 instructors are available in Lake George area, what
7 was the material that would be available. I'd have
8 to even -- that's outside of Long Island, so I'd
9 have to see whether the United States Power
10 Squadrons has a district that covers Lake George.
11 LARRY WEISS: We do have a Lake George --
12 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: But suffice it to
13 say, though, the basic 8-hour course would apply to
14 a boater, even if he gets certified here in Nassau,
15 and he goes somewhere in upstate New York, he could
16 still operate, and the rules would be the same?
17 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Yes. Yes.
18 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: Thank you, Senator.
19 LARRY WEISS: The material is there. We just
20 made place in the classroom, extra emphasis on
21 what's going on locally, because it's where boaters
22 are going to boat.
23 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: Right. Thank you.
24 Thank you, Senator.
25 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you, gentlemen.
95
1 Appreciate your time, and appreciate your coming up
2 for the testimony.
3 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: And before
4 I leave, I have a present for you. I will leave it
5 with you.
6 This is a little flyer, with a picture of
7 Long Island, showing where all the squadrons are.
8 On the back, it's our advanced-grade courses.
9 This is the material that we teach.
10 Okay?
11 I'm giving you a divider and a plotter.
12 In addition to the base course, which is
13 8 hours, we offer another 4 hours worth of
14 teaching, to show you how to plot courses on a piece
15 of paper.
16 And today what's happened is, the world has
17 become electronic. And they suddenly think: Oh, I
18 got my GPS, I got my chart plotter.
19 But they forget one little thing: The fuse
20 blows, you got nothing.
21 LARRY WEISS: Right.
22 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Okay?
23 So we teach you how to plot that on a piece
24 of paper, so that if something happens, you can get
25 back home.
96
1 SENATOR MARCELLINO: I'll accept it for the
2 Committee as long as it's not worth more than $25.
3 [Laughter.]
4 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: I paid it.
5 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you very much.
6 DIST. COMMANDER LAWRENCE POSTEL: Thank you.
7 SENATOR MARCELLINO: The next speaker will be
8 Chris Squeri, the executive director of the
9 New York State Marine Trades Association.
10 CHRIS SQUERI: Good afternoon,
11 Chairman Marcellino, Senator Martins,
12 Assemblyman Montesano, Assemblywoman Galef, and
13 Senator LaValle.
14 My name is Chris Squeri. I am the executive
15 director of the New York Marine Trades Association.
16 On a personal note, I am a lifelong boater.
17 Been on a boats since I'm two years old. I was
18 taught the rules of the road by my father, and,
19 friends and family have learned the water. I live
20 on the water, and I enjoy the water very much.
21 So, I practice what I preach.
22 And I can answer that "under 21 feet"
23 question with the life jackets for you, when you're
24 ready, so...
25 The NYMTA was founded in 1928, and is the
97
1 oldest marine trade association in the country. We
2 represent marine businesses, from Montauk, to
3 Staten Island, to Westchester. We operate the
4 Long Island Boat Show and Tobay Beach In-Water Boat
5 Show.
6 The NYMTA is also a member of the
7 Empire State Marine Trade Association, which is also
8 called "ESMTA."
9 Our mission is to promote the general welfare
10 of the marine industry, and to advance the safe and
11 proper use of boats, marine accessories, and
12 facilities through any and all means consistent
13 with the public interest and welfare.
14 At NYMTA shows, we provide free space to both
15 the U.S. Power Squadron and the U.S. Coast Guard
16 Auxiliary to promote safe boating and education.
17 The NYMTA, along with the ESMTA, has worked
18 with the Legislature in proved boating safety,
19 compel increased use of life jackets and flotation
20 devices, and to establish stiff penalties for BWI,
21 and, leaving the scene of a boating accident.
22 In this regard, we have supported several
23 pieces of legislation in these areas, many of
24 which have become law.
25 I appreciate the opportunity to testify
98
1 today, about the current laws and regulations on
2 boating safety in New York State.
3 New York is a safe-boating state.
4 As the hearing notice indicates, recreational
5 boating has, and continues to be, an important part
6 of New York State's recreational landscape.
7 New York is among the states with the highest
8 number of vessels, with about 470,000 registered
9 boats, and many other vessels, like canoes,
10 kayaks, and rowboats, that do not require
11 registration.
12 22 percent of the total registrations, or
13 about 105,000 vessels, are in Nassau, Suffolk, and
14 New York City.
15 Registration fees and surcharges for
16 motorized vessels generate about 6 million in
17 revenue to State each year, with a portion of those
18 collections going to localites for marine and law
19 enforcement.
20 In 2011, more than 2.1 million was provided
21 to 45 counties, 6 municipalities, and the
22 Lake George Park Commission for marine law
23 enforcement.
24 It is to be noted that that money is capped,
25 per county, at, I believe, 200,000 now.
99
1 So, even though a county may have a bulk of
2 the registrations, they still get capped, so, they
3 have to do more in those counties.
4 Nassau and Suffolk are the ones -- Suffolk is
5 number one in registrations; Nassau, number two.
6 So, those counties are capped. Meanwhile,
7 they're -- you know, they get shortchanged a little
8 bit on that funding.
9 While some media reports indicate
10 Long Island County Marine Enforcement Bureau's
11 resources are stretched and may be understaffed, it
12 is important to note that these agencies are not the
13 only ones paroling the waters.
14 In addition to the county marine bureaus,
15 there are also town bay constables, U.S. Coast
16 Guard, and State DEC officers, and in some cases,
17 New York State Park Police and/or local village
18 police that also engage in marine enforcement.
19 So, there is -- it is common for a boater to
20 be stopped two or three times in a day to get
21 checked.
22 I have been checked for no cause whatsoever,
23 and, you know, checked for safety. Make sure I have
24 my life jackets, my flares, my horn, you know,
25 all the devices that we need to have on a registered
100
1 vessel.
2 U.S. Coast Guard and New York boating
3 statistics demonstrate that recreational boating
4 has an exemplary safety record, and that over time,
5 boating accidents, injuries, and fatalities have
6 all steadily decreased, even when the number of
7 recreational vessels has increased.
8 These statistics also show that New York
9 ranks among the top states with the best boating
10 safety records, despite being among those states
11 with the highest boat registrations per capita.
12 In the last four years that data is
13 available, New York has averaged less than
14 12 boating-related deaths per year.
15 Also, it is to be noted, from 1980 to 2011,
16 we have -- from 1980 to 2011, boating registrations
17 have increased 50 percent. It was about 320,000 in
18 1980, to -- in 2011, we were at 470.
19 At one time, in 2006, we were at 530,000.
20 Okay?
21 In that same time period, between 1980 and
22 2011, boating fatalities per 100,000 registrations
23 decreased 75 percent. Went from about 20 to about
24 5.
25 So, we've increased our registrations
101
1 50 percent in 31 years, but we've decreased our
2 fatalities 75 percent. It's a big -- you know,
3 that -- those numbers jump out at you.
4 We've done a lot of work, and we've done a
5 lot of good things here.
6 It is also to be known, in 2006, when
7 registrations hit an all-time high of 530,000, we
8 only had 14 deaths in New York State. That's a
9 record low.
10 While serious boat accident and fatality
11 numbers continue to remain low, when you consider
12 that about half of these fatalities involve
13 non-registered vessels, including rowboats,
14 canoes, kayaks, paddle boats, et cetera, the
15 safety record of motorized boating in New York is
16 remarkable.
17 Okay?
18 In 2011, for example, 12 of the 26 fatalities
19 were on these non-motorized watercrafts.
20 In 2010, 11 of the 24 were on the type of
21 vessels. Out of those 24, 3 of the deaths were
22 due to carbon-monoxide poisoning on a
23 non-operational houseboat in Huntington.
24 In 2009, 5 out of 21.
25 In 2008, 10 out of 21.
102
1 So almost 50 percent of deaths, fatalities,
2 on the water each year, are -- you know, are
3 boating-related, but yet they're not non-registered
4 boats -- they're non-registered boats. So 50 --
5 boating takes a hit, the registered boats.
6 You know, all these canoes, kayaks,
7 rowboats. You know, we had a City Island issue a
8 couple of years ago, where four kids got on a
9 little rowboat and tried to row to an island, they
10 wound up drowning. Those are not registered
11 vessels.
12 They're -- so, one of the issues that we have
13 is, is -- you know, and it's a law-enforcement issue
14 as well, because we find a canoe or a kayak upside
15 down somewhere, what it does mean to us?
16 It either means that it fell off someone's
17 dock, or, someone fell over and there's someone
18 missing.
19 So, now, law enforcement has to look around,
20 has to, you know, spend resources and time, and do a
21 search, to see if there is; whereas -- because
22 there's no way to identify the vessel because
23 there's no registration on it.
24 So, 50 percent of the deaths every year are
25 because of these vessels.
103
1 Okay?
2 How do we reach out to them?
3 How do we make sure that they're done?
4 How do we know that -- you know, we're
5 missing half of the deaths because we have no way
6 to reach these people. You know, there's no way to
7 make them aware of the issues and concerns.
8 So, I believe that is an issue that we do
9 need to address, moving forward.
10 While collisions between two or more
11 vessels is still the most common type of boating
12 accident and results in the most injuries, there
13 were no deaths from boat-to-boat collisions in 2011.
14 In fact, the majority of fatalities in 2011
15 were due to capsizing.
16 These are -- these statistics and state
17 law -- these are amazing statistics, and state
18 lawmakers are to be commended for enacting laws that
19 have been so effective in protecting the public on
20 the water.
21 NYMTA believes that these current laws
22 address the primary contributing factors of
23 accidents, injuries, and deaths, as identified by
24 the Coast Guard and the Office Parks, Recreation,
25 and Historic Preservation.
104
1 Boating safety certificates: Currently,
2 anyone between the ages of 10 and 18 wishing to
3 operate a mechanically propelled vessel without
4 adult supervision, or anyone who is 14 or older
5 wishing to operate a personal watercraft in
6 New York State, must first obtain a boating safety
7 certificate from the Office of Parks, Recreation,
8 and Historic Preservation, the U.S. Power Squadron,
9 or the U.S. Coast Guard Auxiliary.
10 While NYMTA and other marine-industry
11 organizations support mandatory education for
12 youthful and most personal-watercraft operators,
13 NYMTA encourages all adult boaters to voluntarily
14 take a safe-boating course.
15 To the right here -- my right, you see that
16 neighboring states, Connecticut and New Jersey,
17 according to New York State Office of Parks,
18 Recreation, and Historic Preservation --
19 Say that a couple of times, you know.
20 -- our neighbor states do have mandatory
21 education.
22 Our fatality rates in New York, according
23 to the State, is better than theirs.
24 So, you know, we need to really look at, what
25 is going to help us reduce more deaths?
105
1 What's going to help us reduce fatalities,
2 and get the numbers lower than what they are right
3 now?
4 So, just to say mandatory education is going
5 to solve it is not always the answer, because our
6 neighboring states have it, and it doesn't prove
7 that it's true.
8 BWI laws and enforcement: New York has
9 some of the toughest BWI laws in the country, and
10 the State Legislature has regularly acted in
11 enhanced penalties so that they remain commensurate
12 with DWI laws.
13 NYMTA and ESMTA have supported these
14 efforts.
15 State Parks also conducts an
16 impaired-boater recreation program -- recognition
17 program for law enforcement, which is similar to the
18 training received by highway patrols for
19 recognizing intoxicated operators. Participants
20 are taught the standard sobriety test for
21 determining if a subject is intoxicated, as well as
22 tests that were specifically designed for use on
23 boats.
24 In 2011, there were 14 vessel accidents
25 caused by alcohol. Two of these accidents were
106
1 fatal which resulted in five deaths. Four of
2 these deaths were due to the boat hitting a fixed
3 object.
4 The NYMTA supports reasonable legislation to
5 improve boater safety.
6 Education: Responsible marine-industry
7 organizations support legislation to improve boating
8 safety, that is well thought out, and takes into
9 consideration the instructive accident and fatality
10 statistics that are compiled by the Office of
11 Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation, the
12 U.S. Coast Guard, and other such agencies.
13 Voluntary education efforts, sponsored by
14 the U.S. government, New York's departments and
15 agencies, organizations like NYMTA and ESMTA, and
16 private-sector marinas and boat dealers, is a strong
17 ingredient to a safer boating environment.
18 We in the industry will continue to work with
19 you, our elected officials, to find ways to enhance
20 education efforts without unduly burdening the
21 boater or creating impediments to boat ownership, or
22 fishing, recreational, and vacation rentals.
23 BWI: NYMTA, and ESMTA support bills to
24 enhance penalties for drinking while operating a
25 boat. These include making certain, convictions for
107
1 operating a boat while under the influence
2 predicates for other operating-under-the-influence
3 convictions, and requiring anyone convicted of a
4 watercraft-related alcohol-related offense to
5 complete a boating safety course.
6 Okay?
7 NYMTA, ESMTA, also support a bill to increase
8 the penalties for persons leaving the scene of a
9 boating accident.
10 That was done several years ago by
11 Assemblyman Sweeney.
12 Conclusion: The marine industries, like most
13 others businesses, are struggling to survive the
14 recession. Many of our members are mom-and-pop
15 family businesses that continue to struggle from
16 tight credit, reduced consumer demand, development
17 purchasers of waterfront properties that restrict
18 boater access, increased environmental and other
19 government relations, and higher energy, real estate
20 taxes, and other costs of doing business.
21 That is why we are so appreciative of the
22 strong working relationship we have with you,
23 Chairman Marcellino, and other state and local
24 elected officials here on Long Island and throughout
25 the state.
108
1 It is through this cooperative approach that
2 we've been able to make great strides in improving
3 boater safety in New York, while minimizing negative
4 impacts on the marine industries that are
5 responsible for providing jobs, recreational, and
6 tourism opportunities that benefit all
7 New Yorkers.
8 We -- please continue to look to NYMTA as a
9 resource, as you seek ways to improve the safety of
10 boating in New York.
11 Thank you for your time today.
12 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Chris, thank you for
13 your testimony.
14 Let me just ask the same question I've asked
15 of the others: With respect to the strength of
16 the laws in New York State, what is your
17 organization's opinion, or personal opinion, as to
18 the ability of the laws of New York State to make
19 boating a safe hobby or a safe practice?
20 CHRIS SQUERI: We work hand-in-hand with the
21 State Office of Parks, Historic -- Recreation, and
22 Historic Preservation. They do an outstanding job.
23 Brian Kemp, who was here earlier, does an
24 outstanding job. I communicate with Brian all the
25 time.
109
1 I believe the Legislature, in working with
2 that department, and all of the agencies, and
3 boaters, have done a very good job.
4 I believe New York is a leader in boating, in
5 terms of registrations, and, also, providing as much
6 safety as possible.
7 The agencies do a very good job. We're very
8 fortunate to have a lot of -- even on the local
9 level, the towns are very proactive.
10 We are very fortunate, especially on
11 Long Island, to have some really good departments,
12 such as, the Oyster Bay department that handles the
13 waterways in; the Town of Hempsted, they -- they do
14 a phenomenal job; Town of Babylon...I could probably
15 go on and on...but there are some, really, that do a
16 phenomenal job.
17 And I believe that we have been at the
18 forefront, and we will continue to help make sure
19 that we are at the forefront.
20 SENATOR MARCELLINO: What do you perceive as
21 the main hazard to safe boating?
22 CHRIS SQUERI: The main hazard to safe
23 boating?
24 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Yeah.
25 CHRIS SQUERI: BWI.
110
1 Boat -- you know, "boating while intoxicated"
2 is probably the number one issue that we have to
3 deal with. It's not -- it's not necessary. It's,
4 just, it's a major issue, and words cannot express
5 that something has to happen.
6 And just as it is with drunk driving, it's
7 just -- it's -- it's unneeded, it's uncalled for.
8 It's, just -- it's something that shouldn't be
9 happening, and it does every day.
10 And, you know, it gives everyone, whether
11 we drive -- we need to drive every day, so, you
12 know, drunk driving is there.
13 Boating is a recreation. It's not -- we
14 don't need it to go to work -- some people do need
15 it to go to work every day. But, not everyone, it's
16 not their primary thing, so, it's a recreation, it's
17 discretionary. And it just -- so it gets
18 highlighted more than some of the other
19 drunk-driving accidents.
20 But it's -- boating is safer than driving.
21 Sometimes it's safer than walking. Pedestrian
22 accidents are probably more common than, you know
23 per 100,000, than they are for boating.
24 So, we could look at the numbers and we could
25 talk all day about, you know, where we're at, but,
111
1 boating is still a family activity that can be safe
2 if done right.
3 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Does there need to be
4 stronger enforcement?
5 CHRIS SQUERI: I think enforcement, I think
6 communication between agencies, and working
7 together, there are several that work together.
8 I do believe that we do have enough on the
9 water. Like I said, sometimes, in some areas, you
10 have six or seven different agencies patrolling the
11 area.
12 You know, I boat out of Freeport, New York.
13 I have the Coast Guard in my backyard. I have, the
14 Village has a police boat. I have the town of
15 Hempsted Bay Constables. I have the
16 Nassau County. I have the DEC Police around all the
17 time. And I have, near Jones Beach, New York State
18 Park Police.
19 So, I have six agencies that are in the area,
20 you know, that I could be stopped by at any time.
21 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Michael?
22 Thanks, Chris.
23 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: I'll get the answer
24 to my life-vest question.
25 CHRIS SQUERI: Yes. That bill was initiated
112
1 by State Parks Department, and, we had discussed
2 it.
3 What happens is, is that, as we can see, when
4 we looked at the boating report that the Senator
5 referred to earlier, from 2011, that's issued every
6 year by Brian and the State Parks.
7 And when we look at it -- I decipher it every
8 year. And we look it, we notice trends.
9 And what we noticed was, is during the winter
10 months, on small crafts, we saw an uptick in
11 some of the -- or, some unneeded deaths, because
12 what happens is, between those months of October
13 and May, the water temperatures are much, much
14 colder.
15 So what happens is, guys that are sitting
16 there in duck boats, guys that are just using
17 regular finishing boats, that winter fish up and
18 near the bridges, and stuff like that, they would go
19 out on small crafts. And, if they fell in the
20 water, the water temperature was so cold, that
21 hypothermia would set in a lot quicker.
22 We give them a -- and because there's less
23 activity on the water during those times, it's not
24 as easy for them to be found quicker.
25 But if they were wearing a life jacket, the
113
1 studies show that hypothermia will not set in as
2 quick.
3 So, we give them more of a chance to survive
4 if they have a life jacket. So, we add a couple
5 more minutes, hopefully, so we can find them and
6 get to them.
7 So, it was a way to increase, you know,
8 hopefully avert, you know, losing anymore lives
9 during those times because of the hypothermia, it
10 was the main issue, because when you fall in the
11 water -- in the cold water, you know, you panic, you
12 try and swim in the cold water. It just -- it
13 restricts you so much quicker.
14 So at least the life jacket, you don't have
15 to exert as much energy and it offsets hypothermia.
16 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Okay.
17 SENATOR LaVALLE: Chris, in your conclusion,
18 you say, "Marine industries, like most of the
19 businesses, are struggling to survive the
20 recession."
21 In my Senate district, as you know, marine
22 industries/tourism, it's a big part of our economy.
23 Are you suggesting that increased education
24 requirements, or having education requirements,
25 would affect these businesses?
114
1 CHRIS SQUERI: It's possible, yes.
2 SENATOR LaVALLE: And in what way?
3 CHRIS SQUERI: People that may not want to
4 buy a boat, because it's another detraction, it's
5 another -- it's another hurdle to purchase that
6 boat.
7 You know, right now, we go through a lot of
8 issues, especially with credit. You know, it
9 just -- during these times, it's, just, I watched
10 several businesses close in the last three years,
11 guys that have been in business for a long time,
12 some in your district. And, you know, we saw a drop
13 of 530, to 470, registrations in New York, so, we
14 dropped 60,000 registrations in a matter of almost
15 three to four years.
16 We've seen, especially in Long Island, I
17 believe almost 25 percent reduction in
18 Nassau County. And I believe Suffolk County is not
19 as drastic, but I believe the number for
20 Suffolk County went from 76 to 70 in registrations,
21 off the top of my head.
22 SENATOR LaVALLE: But isn't that just because
23 of the economy, having nothing to do with --
24 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: Oh, yes, it has ever
25 everything to do with the economy right now. We
115
1 just feel that, right now, another hurdle to buy the
2 boat would be tough on -- most of our dealers do
3 provide on-hand experience.
4 I own a marina in Freeport as well. A
5 customer comes in, they just bought a boat. We send
6 the captain out with them, to teach them the
7 waterways, we show them the ways.
8 You know, just like I was taught rules of the
9 road -- red, right, return -- we do the same thing
10 for our customers. You know, we offer that
11 assistance.
12 A lot of our dealers have programs like
13 that.
14 Staten Island Yacht Sales has a -- you
15 know, they provide a captain for two or three hours,
16 to take them out on the water and show them the
17 water.
18 This -- the experience that we give them is
19 hands-on. We go out on the boat with them. It's
20 not a classroom thing, where we sit for 8 hours.
21 I've always been a believer, in that, you
22 learn more by actually doing something than
23 actually -- you know, not to detract, but I worked
24 for a Hall of Fame basketball coach in college. And
25 I learned more on that court, about life, and
116
1 business, and everything else, than I probably did
2 in most of my classrooms. And I use that
3 experience every day.
4 There's nothing more than, experience will
5 trump everything. And that's what we provided for a
6 lot of our customers.
7 SENATOR LaVALLE: Also, were you suggesting
8 that we register canoes, kayaks, paddle boats?
9 CHRIS SQUERI: That has been a discussion
10 between me and State Parks for a long time. And I
11 believe that that is something that should be
12 investigated. I believe that's something should be
13 looked into.
14 Whether -- it will be tough to actually
15 register them, only because they don't have a hull
16 number.
17 In order to register, you need a VIN number
18 or HIN number. Boat-wise, it's a "HIN number,"
19 Hull Identification Number.
20 We were thinking more along the lines of a
21 user registration, or a user sticker, so, that way,
22 if do you find a canoe or a kayak floating upside
23 down, you can -- the law enforcement can grab it, go
24 to it, and there's, like, a user number on it. We
25 don't have to put all the registration numbers, but
117
1 the registration number, or a regular sticker, just
2 like we put on documented boats.
3 Documented boats from the U.S. Coast Guard do
4 not get registration numbers, but they do have to
5 put their New York State registration sticker on
6 there.
7 So, we put the registration sticker on there,
8 there's still a way to track it, and law enforcement
9 can then utilize, and say: All right, it belongs to
10 Joe Smith at 395, you know, Smith Street.
11 You know, and then we can find out if there
12 is someone missing, and, do we need to send out a
13 search and rescue?
14 It would save valuable time and effort. And
15 not only that, those users do utilize our law
16 enforcement, they do utilize ramps, docks, and
17 other resources that are paid for other -- by
18 registered vessels today.
19 SENATOR LaVALLE: My wife put campaign bumper
20 stickers on both of our kayaks. Everyone would
21 know --
22 CHRIS SQUERI: It's yours.
23 SENATOR LaVALLE: -- well, at least, call
24 LaValle to find out if --
25 Thank you.
118
1 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Do I get a question?
2 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Sandy?
3 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: In your testimony, the
4 only place you really, I think, suggested having the
5 safety courses, when it's BUI.
6 I think that's what I got --
7 CHRIS SQUERI: Yeah, well, we --
8 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: -- out of your
9 testimony, and then to require it.
10 All right, but if we were to go in our state,
11 and require everybody, like Connecticut and
12 New Jersey, to have a safety course, an 8-hour,
13 whatever, how could we structure it?
14 Because you want to sell boats. And you
15 don't want somebody, I guess, to have to go take the
16 safety course before they go and purchase the boat,
17 because that's too-far-ahead thinking. Right?
18 So -- so, you go -- you know, you decide,
19 you're sitting home, and you want to go get the
20 boat, and you go that weekend and you get it.
21 Could there be a time frame within which a
22 boat safety course could be taken?
23 You know, allow the people to get the boat.
24 Maybe the captain, you know, comes in and gives that
25 2-hour session.
119
1 Could there be a time frame within which
2 would be -- would accommodate this, so that we
3 wouldn't -- you know, this is the same issue,
4 probably at Lake George, when people are renting.
5 You know, how do we deal with the people, to
6 get them into the process, and not require too much
7 right away, but still get as many people as we can
8 with safety courses?
9 I don't know.
10 Do you have any input for me?
11 SGT. JOHN T. OWEN: That's -- you know,
12 selling boats is one thing, but actually making a
13 difference is another.
14 And I -- this is why I brought up New Jersey
15 and Connecticut. You know, they have mandatory
16 education for everyone. Our fatality numbers are
17 better than theirs.
18 You know -- you know, I mean, and it
19 sounds -- I hate the way that sounds, because, you
20 know, no fatality number is good. I think it's --
21 you know, I -- you know, I get chills, you know,
22 just thinking about the incidents that happened over
23 the last two months, you know, one on the south
24 shore, one on the north shore.
25 And, you know, it -- how should I say that?
120
1 I don't want to -- I want to use a word that I can't
2 right now.
3 But, it stinks.
4 And, you know, we need to come up with
5 something that's going to make a difference.
6 You know, sitting someone down in a classroom
7 for 8 hours, obviously, according to New Jersey
8 and Connecticut, has not shown to be as effective as
9 they would think.
10 So, how do we actually, you know -- you know,
11 we can make change for the sake of change. And if
12 we get no difference in results, what have we
13 accomplished?
14 So, we really need to look at, what is going
15 to make a difference?
16 Obviously, like I said, you know, I'm a
17 numbers guy, I'm a statistics guy. I mean, you
18 know, the fact that, you know, we've increased the
19 amount of traffic -- as was said before, earlier, we
20 have more and more boats out on the water. We've
21 increased the amount of traffic on New York
22 waterways, 50 percent, from between 1980 and
23 today -- and 2011; but, yet, we decreased -- we
24 decreased fatalities 75 percent.
25 I think that we need to go back and look at:
121
1 Well, ell, how did that happen?
2 How did we accomplish that?
3 And what did we do right?
4 And maybe take that as a step to move
5 forward, to say: All right, what have we done in
6 the last 31 years? And maybe, like, let's examine
7 what steps were taken, and then continue to work
8 on those, and increase those.
9 You know what I mean?
10 Because, those numbers do speak volumes.
11 I mean, you know, 50 percent jump up, and
12 75 percent decrease. You know, that's -- I mean, I
13 don't know what other areas that you can see those
14 numbers, but we've done it.
15 So, maybe there's -- maybe we need to look
16 back, and say: What have we done in last 31 years?
17 Okay, let's maybe look at doing that, or, taking
18 those steps, forward.
19 ASSEMBLYWOMAN GALEF: Okay, you don't have an
20 answer for me, though --
21 CHRIS SQUERI: No, I believe it needs more
22 discussion, because, to be honest with you, up until
23 I did those numbers last night, when I looked at
24 the numbers, actually, those numbers come right
25 from the report in 2011. There's a chart, from
122
1 1980 to 2011, and it basically shows the curves.
2 And one goes up this way, and one goes up
3 this way.
4 And, that really struck me. That really hit
5 me, and said, well, what -- you know, 24 hours
6 hasn't given me enough time to sit there, and go:
7 What have we done in 31 years to do this?
8 So, I would need more time, and I would work
9 with Brian Kemp, to say: What have we done to make
10 that continue?
11 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you, Chris. I
12 appreciate your time, and your testimony.
13 CHRIS SQUERI: Thank you very much.
14 SENATOR MARCELLINO: The next speaker is,
15 two: Jackie Martin, Commodore, Greater Huntington
16 Council of Yacht and Boating Clubs; and
17 Commodore Vincent Archdeacon, from the -- who's the
18 commodore of the Huntington Yacht Club.
19 JACKIE MARTIN: Good morning -- or, good
20 afternoon, I should say, Senator Marcellino, and
21 members of the Committee.
22 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Good afternoon.
23 JACKIE MARTIN: My name is Jackie Martin. I
24 am the commodore of the Greater Huntington Council
25 of Yacht and Boating Clubs.
123
1 Before I begin my testimony, two things:
2 I have with me, and it's certainly less than
3 $25, a pamphlet for you, and it's a little
4 information about the Boating Council, a copy of our
5 incident report inside, and also a list of our
6 member clubs.
7 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you.
8 We'll get it later. Just leave it there.
9 Thank you.
10 JACKIE MARTIN: Just as a little background,
11 because I've now had the opportunity to listen to
12 several of our speakers, and I've found their
13 comments extremely interesting and enlightening:
14 My husband and I own a sailboat. We have
15 been sailing the boat for -- well, we're on our
16 third sailboat, but, we've been sailing our boats
17 for 20 years.
18 Prior to that, we were friends of -- very
19 good friends of power boaters, and kind of got our
20 feet wet with them on their power boat.
21 We pretty much decided to buy a sailboat,
22 after sailing once on friend's boat, and saying:
23 Gee, this is different than power boating. We'd
24 like to start boating. We'd like to own our own
25 boat, and we'd like to have a sailboat.
124
1 Prior to purchasing the boat, we did take the
2 United States Power Squadron basic boating course,
3 and passed it.
4 And, throughout the entire first summer that
5 we owned our boat, we mentored with other very
6 experienced sailors, taking them out on our boat
7 with us, showing us everything.
8 So, it was a lot of hands-on training on our
9 own boat, strictly on a voluntary basis by my
10 husband and myself, and, also, the Power Squadron
11 course.
12 Since that time, I have joined the
13 National Women's Sailing Association, and been to
14 several of their conferences and seminars.
15 My husband and I have both taken a coastal
16 navigation course.
17 And I have taken the suddenly-in-command
18 course given by the United States Power Squadron.
19 I also am certified in CPR first-aid, the use
20 of AED and oxygen.
21 So, my testimony.
22 By way of introduction, the
23 Greater Huntington Council of Yacht and Boating
24 Clubs was founded 27 years ago, to act as a
25 liaison between organizations with a boating and
125
1 waterfront interest, and federal, state, and local
2 governments.
3 Our mission includes, promoting and
4 protecting the sport of recreational boating, and
5 advocating safe-boating practices.
6 Our membership is limited to the areas of
7 Cold Spring Harbor and the Greater Huntington Bay
8 Complex. We represent 21 member organizations,
9 including several yacht clubs,
10 waterfront-community organizations with boating
11 members, recreational fishing clubs, a rowing
12 club, a lighthouse preservation society, and a Sail
13 and Power Squadron.
14 At present, we estimate our membership to be
15 about 4,500 people. We meet ten times a year with
16 each member organization represented to the council
17 by a club representative and an alternate. Our
18 officers are elected on an annual basis, and all our
19 officers' club representatives and committee
20 members serves on a volunteer basis.
21 During the past 27 years, these are some of
22 the things that we have advocated for:
23 Police patrol seven days a week;
24 The designation of marine emergency pickup
25 stations;
126
1 Establishment of night enforcement patrols on
2 the water;
3 Additional marine patrols in Cold Spring
4 Harbor;
5 The implementation of a 5-mile-an-hour zone
6 north of the Huntington Lighthouse;
7 Establishment and monitoring of maritime
8 incident reports;
9 Dredging of Centerport Harbor, establishing a
10 channel to the Gold Star pump-out facility;
11 Implementation of two free pump-out
12 vessels;
13 Donation of atrial-defibrillation device
14 equipment to both the Huntington Harbor Master and
15 the Coast Guard Auxiliary rescue boat;
16 We have lobbied for the continued operation
17 of the Eatons Neck Coast Guard station;
18 Lobbied for the installation of lighted
19 flashing entrance buoys for North Port, Centerport,
20 and Cold Spring Harbor;
21 We have a decal identification program for
22 dingys, canoe, and other small craft, in cooperation
23 with the Town of Huntington and the Coast Guard.
24 And just let me say something about that:
25 And that addresses abandoned small
127
1 watercraft. It is a sticker program. The owner of
2 the vessels put a contact telephone number in
3 indelible ink on the stickers, attach them to the
4 dingys. And if they are found by either a passerby,
5 Coast Guard member, auxiliary member, or one of the
6 town harbor masters, or bay constables, that
7 number can be called, to see if the dingy or small
8 kayak canoe has just merely floated away, or if
9 there was perhaps a person that should have been
10 attached to that vessel.
11 We have sponsored boating safety programs
12 with the -- with presentations by Suffolk County
13 Police, the United States Coast Guard, the
14 Coast Guard Auxiliary, Huntington Harbor Master's
15 Office, Centerport Fire Department, and Neptune Sale
16 and Power Squadron, most recently last evening.
17 And I want to thank the Huntington Town Board
18 for that, Councilman Cuthbertson, and, Harry Acker,
19 our harbor master.
20 We have also tried to broaden our membership
21 by outreaching past member organizations, and
22 offering affiliate-memberships' status to boaters
23 who are not members of any of our participating
24 clubs.
25 Here are our observations on boating safety:
128
1 Many opinions have been expressed to the
2 council, both in a formal and informal way,
3 regarding the status of maritime safety in our area
4 waters.
5 Many of our members are experienced
6 yachtmen with a lifetime on the waterways.
7 Ideas have been shared with several of our
8 flag officers by fellow members, local
9 legislators, and town officials.
10 It is difficult to get a true consensus at
11 the present time, although, all of our club
12 members seem to approve of some sort of boater
13 education for improved boating safety.
14 Whether or not it should be mandatory for
15 all, is not an opinion that can be expressed by the
16 this organization at this time, as we have had --
17 not had an opportunity to formally discuss this
18 matter at length, nor have been any proposals made
19 to our group as a whole, by any elected official
20 from the State or the County.
21 Initially, the idea of implementing mandatory
22 education for an entire population of boaters in
23 just Suffolk County alone will need careful review
24 and planning. The content of the classes given and
25 number of hours of training will need to be
129
1 reviewed as well.
2 There have been suggestions about the idea of
3 planning, of -- excuse me -- of phasing in those of
4 a younger age and less experienced into the boating
5 safety program.
6 Does that omit a first-time boat owner of
7 more maturity with less experience?
8 The idea of a certificate of course
9 completion before an owner can register his boat,
10 may phase in boaters to a program, but a demographic
11 study would need to be conducted to determine the
12 number of boaters who would become eligible for
13 safety courses in any one year.
14 High-water alarms have also been suggested
15 as a standard operating equipment on boats, but how
16 does that relate to the recreational kayaker or the
17 operator of a vessel without a bilge?
18 The use of mandatory life jackets at all
19 times on board a vessel is another suggestion, to
20 make sure that boaters stay safe in case of an
21 accident.
22 Increased presence of law enforcement on our
23 harbors and waterways has also been mentioned.
24 You can educate the boating public, but you
25 can't change behavior. Unfortunately, the increase
130
1 in boating population has brought with it the kinds
2 of behaviors seen behind the wheel of
3 automobiles, and vessel operators who have little
4 regard for the rules of the road and common
5 courtesy.
6 Vessels operating at a higher speed should
7 be responsible for their own wake and the damage it
8 may cause.
9 The proliferation of kayaks, paddle
10 boards, canoes, and other small craft also
11 raises the question of: How much do their
12 operators understand what the rule is -- or, what
13 their role is in navigable waters?
14 In conclusion, I would like to say that,
15 personally, I think it would be an excellent idea to
16 have boaters present a boater-safety certificate
17 when they register or renew their registration. It
18 is an effective way to enforce the needed education,
19 and allows a phase-in.
20 I think that it is a better alternative to
21 licensing, which can cumbersome and expensive for
22 the State, or mandating, all at once, that all
23 boaters have a boating certificate.
24 Our neighboring states, in New Jersey and
25 Connecticut, already require safe-boating
131
1 certificates, as do other states.
2 As for the continued renewal, perhaps, once a
3 course is completed, others should be recognized
4 as further education, thus allowing for a further
5 insurance reduction to the boat owner. These
6 courses would be completed on a voluntary basis.
7 Since New York State provides all the
8 agencies with boating-safety course material, it
9 should take the lead in passing legislation on the
10 implementation of regulations regarding mandatory
11 courses.
12 To reduce the impact, the implementation
13 needs to be phased in, and planned.
14 New York State would need to study
15 statistics about the number of boaters to be
16 educated, when, and where, so that the planning can
17 begin.
18 The educational organization could then
19 render an opinion on the implementation. Unless the
20 implementation is properly phased, there could be a
21 shortfall in instructors and facilities.
22 Our organization, the Greater Huntington
23 Council of Yacht and Boating Clubs, would like to
24 assist in any way possible, in crafting any
25 legislation, or requirements, and assisting and
132
1 supplying information to our membership.
2 Thank you for your interest in boating
3 safety, and I would be happy to answer any questions
4 that you might have.
5 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Jackie, thank you for
6 your testimony.
7 And, Vince, thank you for coming, and being
8 available as a resource.
9 Jackie, I would suggest that your
10 organization begin now, a serious look at that
11 educational requirement.
12 I would rather hear input from you and your
13 organizations, and what you think makes sense,
14 working with the Power Squadrons and others who
15 are actually on the water involved in boating, who
16 do it, and -- than have people who really may not
17 have your expertise, draw up these laws and draw up
18 these requirements.
19 That may happen, unless you provide input
20 now.
21 So, I mean, there are several different
22 bills already beginning to circulate about
23 educational requirements.
24 You hear me asking the question constantly,
25 you know: Can we do it? Is there money?
133
1 Assemblywoman Galef said the same thing: How
2 could you do it? Could you do it right away?
3 Excuse me.
4 These are questions that have to be answered,
5 but -- and your organizations have the expertise,
6 and the knowledge of the water. And the boating
7 communities' interests, are your interests, and
8 all of our interests, obviously, but, you have
9 invaluable information that could be imparted to us.
10 So I would strongly suggest that you start
11 now. Get your organizations to meet and discuss
12 these things, and put a proposal out there, if you
13 want to. I mean, obviously, it's a request.
14 JACKIE MARTIN: I think we'd be interested in
15 doing that.
16 SENATOR MARCELLINO: I think that would be
17 something that would be extremely helpful to me, and
18 to my colleagues, in the future.
19 Your opinion on laws and regulations: Are
20 they strong enough now as they exist?
21 JACKIE MARTIN: No, I don't -- personally,
22 no, I don't think so.
23 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Do you think there is
24 sufficient enforcement?
25 JACKIE MARTIN: No. Unfortunately, no, I
134
1 don't think there is.
2 I think one of the issues that we have, is
3 we have a lot of jurisdictions in many areas of
4 our state. And we have incorporated villages which
5 have harbor patrols, but, probably are not doing
6 as good of a job as they could.
7 SENATOR MARCELLINO: So, basically what --
8 and, Vince, chime in -- what should the State be
9 doing, or what more should we be doing, to improve
10 safety on the water?
11 VINCENT ARCHDEACON: Excuse me.
12 I'm Vince Archdeacon, the commodore of
13 Huntington Yacht Club.
14 I have somewhat of a dissenting opinion, but
15 I -- and the club supports the Greater Huntington
16 Council Yacht and Boating Clubs, and what they stand
17 for.
18 I have been on the water and around boats
19 all of my life. My initial training came in the
20 Navy, seamanship and navigation. I have a pilot's
21 license, which added to that.
22 I have been a recreational boater for
23 26 years.
24 And, I firmly believe -- as a matter of fact,
25 I was getting concerned that I had chosen an
135
1 inherently dangerous pastime, until Chris Squeri
2 made his comments, and I suddenly felt much relieved
3 that I was not doing something inherently dangerous.
4 And I can tell you, in those 26 years, the
5 only time I felt concern was in bad weather.
6 And I'm mindful of the fact that you cannot
7 legislate away lack of judgment, stupidity.
8 I also agree that boating while intoxicated
9 is probably the most significant thing.
10 Most of the boaters I'm aware of are very
11 responsible, and have taken it upon themselves to
12 get the training.
13 And I have taken all of the courses; and,
14 especially, when my wife got involved with boating,
15 for her sake.
16 I think that we do have enough enforcement.
17 When you think about it, most of the problems
18 occur when boats are in close proximity to each
19 other.
20 Now, I can't speak too much about south shore
21 boating, but I would think that's probably the more
22 dangerous area, because you have shallow water, so
23 that you're boating basically in channels, and,
24 they have a lot more boats down there.
25 On the north shore of Long Island Sound, when
136
1 I'm out cruising, I'm rarely within half a mile of
2 another boat.
3 I'm also mindful that courtesy and common
4 sense should prevail.
5 I think, and it's been said before, that one
6 of the main concerns I have as a boater, not only
7 from my standpoint in creating one, is a wake. It
8 can cause an awful lot of damage and an awful lot of
9 grief. So I am always very mindful when I'm going
10 in close proximity to other boats and objects, to
11 slow down and take it easy.
12 But, as far as enforcement goes, I think we
13 have a lot, because most of that enforcement is
14 around the areas that are congested. And I see
15 the -- by the lighthouse of Huntington, I see the
16 Lloyd Harbor Police, I see the Suffolk Police, I see
17 our harbor master's boat out there, especially in
18 those times when it is most congested, people
19 leaving for the day, and then coming back in
20 afternoon.
21 I would think that it would be extremely
22 difficult to implement a licensing for boating, such
23 as taking a test and then having a hands-on, like
24 a driving test. I don't think that that's practical
25 at all. Every boat is different. All of the
137
1 conditions that you could possibly boat under are
2 changeable, every single day.
3 I think that the best way that somebody can
4 learn is by experience.
5 And, so, I'm a firm believer, though, in
6 incentive. And I would like to suggest that one of
7 the things that you all might want to look at, is to
8 create greater incentive for people to educate
9 themselves, such as working with the insurance
10 companies, to give them, you know, a greater break
11 on their rates, that they do that, and other
12 things along those lines.
13 That's my opinion. And, I would be very
14 happy to answer any particular questions.
15 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Anybody?
16 Okay.
17 SENATOR LaVALLE: No --
18 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Go ahead.
19 SENATOR LaVALLE: -- I like your suggestion
20 of tying boater safety to the insurance. That's a
21 good suggestion.
22 SENATOR MARCELLINO: It seems to be a common
23 theme. That seems to have been a common theme
24 amongst the speakers; that the linking of an
25 insurance incentive out there, that would make some
138
1 sense.
2 Your points about the "legislating common
3 sense," if we could wave a wand and make people
4 think, we would be happy to do it. But when you
5 think about what I read just the other day, on, what
6 is, I don't know, the front page of "News Day," I
7 think, or on the second page, whatever it was, a
8 photograph of a gentleman who was stopped, driving
9 while intoxicated, allegedly, in a 21-foot
10 Grady-White. He had 16 children on that boat.
11 Now, I don't know how you do that. I don't
12 know how you put 16 children on a 21-foot boat.
13 The Grady-White, I know the boat. It is a
14 relatively narrow boat. It isn't very wide abeam,
15 but it is a common boat around in these waters.
16 But, still, 16 children on this boat. This
17 man had, according to the police who stopped him,
18 more to drink than he should have.
19 I don't know what law stops him from doing
20 that.
21 The night -- last Sunday night, one of the
22 local fire departments also to respond to a call --
23 an emergency call, to rescue some boaters who were
24 out, I believe off Bayville, who were in trouble,
25 and they were out in the storms.
139
1 Now, what they were doing out there, is
2 anybody's guess. I've no idea. That storm was as
3 about well advertised as you could possibly know.
4 They were talking about it for the last week, that
5 we could expect bad weather this week, and then,
6 specifically, Sunday afternoon and Sunday evening.
7 Yet, there was a boater out there who put,
8 not only himself and herself, whoever it was, at
9 risk, but the people who had to go out and protect
10 them, and bring them back in safely. Those were
11 people at risk.
12 So, that's what I think we're looking for,
13 some kind of help, and something that will educate
14 the public. And I -- the theme of education makes
15 sense to me, and I'm a former school teacher, so I
16 like it when those things ring -- you're ringing my
17 bell when you talk like that.
18 But, this idea of making people have some
19 kind of common sense, and be aware of the rules of
20 the road, I don't know how you would enforce common
21 sense, but, making them at least aware of the
22 rules of the road makes sense to me.
23 Any other -- go ahead.
24 VINCENT ARCHDEACON: I would like to make one
25 brief comment, when we were talking about
140
1 enforcement, and kind of a remark directed towards
2 the 4th of July incident.
3 I have been, in years past, present at that
4 display, and there was no enforcement. And right
5 after the display was over, people were bailing out
6 just as fast as they can.
7 And the main problem is the boat wakes.
8 Now, you don't need a very large boat to
9 create a boat wake. When you get a small boat
10 that's powering up and getting up on plane, it can
11 throw out a significant wake. And you can't see
12 those wakes in the dark.
13 I'm reminded, also, that I have attended the
14 fireworks displays up in Boston on the
15 Charles River. I was on land, not on a boat. And
16 that Charles River was packed with hundreds of
17 boats, but the police presence was incredible.
18 There must have been 30 or 40 police boats.
19 And after the display was over, they were
20 able the process an orderly departure down the
21 Charles River back into Boston Bay.
22 And I would think that, in the future, for
23 something like this at Morgan Park, that -- and more
24 of a police presence, especially one in the daylight
25 while they're starting to raft up and drop their
141
1 anchors, you see a boat coming with so many
2 people, you can take that matter in hand then.
3 But, especially when they are departing, if a
4 police presence, or an authoritative presence, can
5 help an orderly departure, would be most helpful.
6 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Just one more: What
7 have about the lighting on a boat?
8 I mean, you're out there at night, especially
9 in that particular occurrence, but there are other
10 situations when you're out there.
11 I have sat at the club, for dinner, and we
12 watched the boats coming in and out in the
13 evenings. Some boats have one light at the bow,
14 and that's about it. You don't see too much more
15 unless the cabins are lit up.
16 But other boats, you know, they're lit up
17 like Christmas trees.
18 Should there be some kind of standard?
19 Is there a standard?
20 I don't know.
21 VINCENT ARCHDEACON: There is a standard.
22 And the --
23 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Is it enough?
24 VINCENT ARCHDEACON: -- Power Squadron, and
25 the Coast Guard --
142
1 Yeah.
2 -- and the rules of the road, mandate what
3 kind of lights that you have on a boat at night.
4 And an educational process will tell you what
5 that means, when you see a red light and a green
6 light and a white light, or don't. It will tell you
7 what that boat is doing in proximity to you; whether
8 it's going away, coming at you, or any different
9 angle.
10 That is part of the educational process, that
11 is part of the rules of the road. And, that's
12 been in place, like, essentially forever.
13 But, proper lighting on a boat is necessary,
14 and you need the educational process to understand
15 what that means.
16 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Is there a standard
17 illumination level for these lights?
18 VINCENT ARCHDEACON: As far as luminosity --
19 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Everybody's nodding yes.
20 That's okay.
21 VINCENT ARCHDEACON: And there's, also, the
22 red and green lights can only be seen, essentially,
23 from a forward angle on the boat.
24 So if you see a red and green light, the
25 center of that boat is coming at you.
143
1 If just see a white light, that means,
2 essentially, the boat is going away from you.
3 And combinations thereof.
4 But, I do believe that in the educational
5 process.
6 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you very much.
7 Appreciate your time. Thank you for being so
8 patient.
9 The last group of speakers:
10 Justin McCaffrey, Commissioner of Public Safety,
11 the Town of Oyster Bay; Ed Carr, Director of
12 Maritime Services, Town of Huntington;
13 Harry Acker, Sr., Harbor Master, Town of Huntington;
14 and Councilman Mark Cuthbertson, Town of Huntington.
15 Since we're in Oyster Bay, and we're in
16 Oyster Bay Town Hall, Commissioner, you can lead
17 off.
18 COMMISSIONER JUSTIN McCAFFERY: Good
19 afternoon, Senator Marcellino, and other officials.
20 Thank you for the opportunity to testify before this
21 Committee.
22 My name is Justin McCaffrey. I'm the
23 commissioner of Public Safety for the town of
24 Oyster Bay.
25 Part of my responsibilities is the direct
144
1 oversight of the town's Marine Enforcement,
2 Bay Constable Division.
3 As you know, the town of Oyster Bay is only
4 one of two towns on Long Island that have a north
5 and south shore within its jurisdiction.
6 Our bay constables patrol over 65 miles
7 of waterways, enforcing New York State, Town of
8 Oyster Bay, laws and safety regulations.
9 The town's 22 bay constables are all
10 New York State Peace Officers who have the
11 authority to issue summonses, make arrests.
12 The Town's mission of the bay constables is
13 to work closely with our law-enforcement partners
14 from New York State, Nassau County, and the
15 U.S. Coast Guard, to provide a safe and responsible
16 boating environment for our residents and visitors.
17 Our goal is to minimize the loss of life,
18 personal injury, and property damage, while
19 maximizing the enjoyment of Oyster Bay waters.
20 Town of Oyster Bay waters are used by many
21 residents and visitor alike, with various
22 activities, including recreational boaters on jet
23 skis, power boats, sailboats, canoes, kayaks,
24 as well as commercial fishermen and ocean-going
25 tankers.
145
1 Our strategy is twofold: to both educate the
2 boating public, and when necessary, enforce New York
3 State and TOB laws and regulations.
4 Education is an essential part of our
5 mission. We try to take the time to educate boaters
6 about rules and regulations and safe-boating
7 practices, as well as the importance of avoiding
8 overcrowding on a vessel.
9 Bay constables, on a daily basis, stress the
10 importance of having proper safety equipment,
11 including life vests for every passenger on board
12 the vessel.
13 According to the U.S. Coast Guard statistics,
14 in 2010, three-quarters of all fatal boating
15 accidents, victims drowned, and of those,
16 88 percent were not wearing a life jacket.
17 In the last three years, Town of Oyster Bay
18 Constables have issued hundred of warnings and
19 numerous summonses for life-preserver violations.
20 Our bay constables regularly inspect
21 vessels for proper safety equipment, such as
22 emergency flares, sound devices, proper lighting,
23 and fire extinguishers.
24 We work closely with the local
25 Power Squadrons and the Coast Guard Auxilliary who
146
1 regularly perform free courtesy safety inspections
2 at town launching sites. These free courtesy
3 inspections and examination for safety equipment
4 that is required by the Coast Guard and local
5 laws. These vessel examiners will identify any
6 problems, as well as take the opportunity to
7 discuss boating safety-related issues with the
8 boaters.
9 According to the National Safe Boating
10 Council, 50 percent of boating accidents that
11 result in death can be traced to alcohol impairment.
12 The bay constables, along with our
13 law-enforcement partners, have strictly enforced BWI
14 laws.
15 Bay constables also strictly monitor and
16 enforce dangerous boating violations. Careless,
17 reckless, or excessive speed has been determined to
18 be a major factor in most boating accidents.
19 In the last three years, bay constables
20 have issued over 200 summonses for unsafe boating
21 violations, which include excessive speed,
22 dangerous wakes, and reckless operation.
23 For those that don't know, reckless operation
24 includes boats weaving through congested boating
25 or swimming areas without regard for other
147
1 boaters, persons, posted speed, and wake
2 restrictions, as well as operating at speeds that
3 may cause danger, injury, and unnecessarily crossing
4 the path or wake of another vessel.
5 Town bay constables have also terminated
6 over a dozen voyages due to unsafe conditions.
7 As Commissioner of a department with
8 ever-changing demands, I know the importance of
9 taking a fresh look and re-evaluating any given
10 scenario.
11 When it comes to boat safety, in light of the
12 recent tragedy, hearings like this one today play
13 an important role in helping to establish a fresh
14 perspective.
15 While many recommendations have been handed
16 forth today, it's important to caution against any
17 conclusions being drawn on the best cost to move
18 forward until the investigation by various agencies
19 have been completed.
20 Boating education is essential to a safe
21 environment out on the water.
22 Additionally, I feel that the safe-boating
23 organizations, such as the Coast Guard Auxiliary and
24 the Power Squadrons play a vital role, and would
25 benefit greatly from grants to help step up their
148
1 efforts. These organizations are volunteer
2 groups who have traditionally been well organized,
3 but, unfortunately, underfunded when it comes to
4 boater safety campaigns.
5 Providing greater awareness to these
6 organizations would go a long way towards helping,
7 specifically, through such programs as
8 informational classes, dealing with safe boating.
9 An increase in advertising, along with public
10 service announcements for classes hosted by these
11 groups, would also be beneficial.
12 Additionally, informational signage regarding
13 safe-boating practices, with tips and reminders,
14 could be placed at marinas and boat-launching
15 facilities. These, along with safe-boating
16 materials and instructional DVDs could also be
17 provided to libraries, government buildings, or
18 other easily accessible locations for boaters to
19 take advantage of.
20 In the effort to make our waterways safer
21 for boaters, enforcement is key.
22 Recently, New York State
23 Senator Charles Fuschillo introduced two pieces of
24 legislation to the Senate regarding boater safety,
25 one of which would raise the penalties of BUI
149
1 offenses, as well as link driving, boating, and
2 snowmobiling under-the-influence offenses, making
3 it possible to charge violaters as repeat
4 offenders.
5 According to the New York State Office of
6 Parks and Recreation and Historic Preservation,
7 alcohol contribute to 1 in 5 fatal boating accidents
8 in New York State in 2011.
9 The other bill would require all boaters to
10 complete a boating safety course in order to operate
11 a vessel unsupervised.
12 Currently, 23 states require boat operators
13 to have boating-safety certificates before they
14 can go out on the water.
15 Federal and state grant money for increased
16 enforcement of safety and BWI violations is
17 another avenue that could be explored.
18 To help crack down on unsafe boating
19 practices, currently, grant money is provided to
20 police departments for overtime, for HOV, and
21 speeding enforcement on major roadways.
22 This program could possibly be expanded to
23 include increased patrols on our waterways, in the
24 interest of boater safety.
25 Finally, providing additional equipment and
150
1 training opportunities for marine-enforcement
2 officers would go a long way towards maximizing
3 boater safety on our waterways.
4 In fact, later this month, Town of Oyster Bay
5 Constables will be hosting a five-day marine
6 patrol officers class, which is sponsored by the
7 New York State Naval Militia. 30 police officers,
8 Coast Guardsmen, bay constables, and members of
9 the New York State Naval Militia will attend
10 training on boarding procedures, BWI enforcement,
11 navigational rules, marine-theft investigations,
12 and water-survival techniques.
13 This training is provided through a New York
14 State grant, and it's courses like this that I
15 consider absolutely integral to upholding the high
16 standards of safety enforcement that our bay
17 constables set out for themselves for each and
18 every day.
19 There is nothing that we hold in higher
20 regard in the town of Oyster Bay than the safety and
21 well-being of our town residents.
22 Boater safety is an important issue that
23 deserves to be brought to the forefront of the
24 conversation, especially during this busy time of
25 year, when more residents and visitors than ever
151
1 will be planning to spend some of their time on the
2 water.
3 It is our belief that education and awareness
4 is the key to providing the safety and -- safest and
5 most enjoyable environment for all.
6 Thank you again for this opportunity.
7 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Appreciate it.
8 The three gentlemen from the town of
9 Huntington, I guess.
10 Councilman, you?
11 COUNCILMAN MARK CUTHBERTSON: Senator, I want
12 to thank you for hosting these hearings.
13 You and I have attended probably dozens of
14 boating events together over the years, and I know
15 of your concern for the safety of boaters and your
16 love of the water.
17 I'm here on behalf of the Town Board and the
18 Supervisor.
19 Boating safety is something that, obviously,
20 the Town of Oyster Bay takes seriously, as do we
21 in the town of Huntington, and all of our towns on
22 Long Island. And I want to provide with you a sense
23 of the Town's efforts to promote boater safety and
24 boater education, which has been a constant theme
25 today.
152
1 Beginning in the year of 2002, the Town has
2 partnered with the Centerport Fire Department, to
3 sponsor an 8-hour New York State safety boating
4 course.
5 Over the past ten years, we have an
6 increasing numbers of attendees.
7 The first year we had the course, we had
8 about 50 people sign up and attend.
9 This year we had over 120.
10 Following the recent tragedy, the Town
11 received enough inquiries from concerned
12 residents, that we scheduled a boating safety
13 forum that was held last night at town hall. This
14 also was attended by over 120 residents.
15 And, prior to that meeting, for about an
16 hour, Supervisor Petrone and I visited with Lisa and
17 Paul Gaines, and heard firsthand how this tragedy,
18 the loss of their daughter, Victoria, has impacted
19 their lives.
20 And, I will tell you that I was so encouraged
21 by their -- their commitment to boating safety and
22 boating education.
23 And, we, at town hall last night, a number of
24 issues were raised during the hearing that we held.
25 And, in sort of order of priority, those
153
1 were:
2 The need for boater education, the need for
3 boating licenses, in New York State;
4 The danger of wakes, which I think was just
5 commented upon, from large vessels, and all
6 types of vessels;
7 The need for vessel-occupancy-guidelines;
8 Controlled boat departures at the
9 conclusion of large events, like fireworks
10 displays;
11 And, the need for boat inspections.
12 So, an increasing number of people are
13 telling us in the town, and told us last night, that
14 they want action. And I think that's good news.
15 The bad news is, that we have over
16 5,000 boaters using the Huntington Northport Bay
17 Complex, which means only a small fraction of the
18 people who are on the water are participating in the
19 boating safety classes that we had.
20 I believe, and I think our Town's position
21 is, the State is right to consider legislation that
22 would require basic safe-boater training for all
23 vessel owners, given the number of boats that are
24 now on the water.
25 The cost to the Town of Huntington to run our
154
1 New York State boater safety course has been
2 relatively small, given the number of
3 participants. And our use of the town's senior
4 harbor master, who you'll hear from, and
5 bay constables, as instructors.
6 The challenge, should the State mandate that
7 all boaters take this or similar safety course, will
8 be to evaluate the logistics and costs of scaling
9 programs like this, up by a factor of 20, 30, or
10 40 times.
11 So, assuming the State were to turn to the
12 towns and the villages to help with this, there are
13 a number of considerations, like physical space,
14 class size, number of classes, that would be very
15 important.
16 Courses being offered, five or six times a
17 year, are likely to be necessary.
18 Furthermore, for us to assist in this, I
19 think the optimal time for classroom studies and
20 lecture is during the winter, when our
21 Maritime Services Division are less strapped, and,
22 certainly, trying to stay away from the summer when
23 they are on the water doing what they're supposed to
24 be doing, which is, devoting their time to
25 protecting the safety of boaters.
155
1 In addition, we believe that a phase-in
2 period that would allow boaters to earn a boating
3 safety card, or whatever the certificate is, in
4 waves over a few years might be a good idea, to
5 really prevent a crush of people coming and seeking
6 out these courses.
7 So, we have some suggestions when it comes
8 to boating education.
9 We wanted to convey what we heard last night
10 in our town, because I know it's an important part
11 of your Senate district.
12 And, we appreciate the opportunity.
13 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you.
14 I apologize for the lack of microphones,
15 but, we don't own the facility.
16 DIRECTOR ED CARR: Thank you, Senator.
17 My name is Ed Carr. I'm the director of
18 Maritime Services for the Town of Huntington.
19 I wanted to give you a brief overview on the
20 town's maritime resources, and highlight some of the
21 challenges that we face.
22 Town of Huntington has 60 miles of
23 coastline, that extends from Cold Spring Harbor in
24 the west, to Fort Salanga in the east.
25 This speaks to our greatest challenge of
156
1 enforcement; namely, having a limited staff --
2 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Between the two
3 towns -- excuse me.
4 But between the two towns, am I right, if I
5 heard you right, correctly, we're talking about
6 130 miles --
7 DIRECTOR ED CARR: Yeah.
8 SENATOR MARCELLINO: -- approximately?
9 DIRECTOR ED CARR: Yes.
10 This speaks to our greatest challenge to
11 enforcement; namely, having a limited staff who are
12 responsible for such a large geographic area of open
13 water.
14 And we're not alone in that. Our staffing
15 levels are consistent with other Long Island
16 townships.
17 In the off-season, we have one patrol boat on
18 duty during the daylight hours only.
19 During the summer season, that's Memorial Day
20 to Labor Day, we have coverage day and night.
21 On summer weekends and holidays, we have
22 a second boat deployed during the daytime only. And
23 that's, really, in the Cold Spring Harbor area.
24 Given our geographical size, and resources
25 available, it is impossible for bay constables to
157
1 be everywhere at once; therefore, having a boating
2 public that is educated, and competent, is essential
3 to mitigate risk.
4 Councilman Mark Cuthbertson highlighted the
5 Town's efforts to educate the boating public.
6 And, statistics provided on the U.S. Coast
7 Guard website, in 2011, a staggering 89 percent of
8 fatal accidents involved boaters who had no
9 boating safety instruction.
10 So, the thrust of my testimony, is to
11 encourage State lawmakers to consider some form of
12 legislation that would mandate boater-safety
13 instruction for recreational operators, since the
14 towns and villages will never have sufficient
15 enforcement resources to be at all places at all
16 times, given the enormous geographic area that
17 needs to be covered.
18 And I would like to now introduce
19 Harold Acker.
20 Harry is our Senior Harbor Master. He's my
21 immediate past predecessor in the director's job.
22 He has 38 years of experience on the
23 Huntington waterfront, and he's going to share with
24 you some of the lessons learned and best practices
25 gleaned from his experience.
158
1 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: Thank you.
2 Thank you, Senator.
3 The beauty of going last, is I can be a
4 little more candid than my predecessors.
5 SENATOR MARCELLINO: And brief.
6 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: First of
7 all, I want to say --
8 [Laughter.]
9 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: Exactly.
10 So you want me to be quick; right?
11 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Yeah.
12 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: I submitted
13 my testimony to you, plus my qualifications.
14 SENATOR MARCELLINO: I appreciated that.
15 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: And I also
16 just wanted to applaud you, for one thing, is that
17 you stated that you're not jumping into legislation
18 right now.
19 Right now, as you said, because of a tragic
20 accident and the loss of life of three children,
21 everybody's coming up with legislation. They're
22 going to actually muddy the waters and make it
23 worse.
24 I applaud your approach, to take our time. I
25 think other legislatures should sit back a little,
159
1 because, as far as boating education, that is the
2 responsibility of the State, and they should let the
3 State do it.
4 They certainly could support it with a
5 home rule message, that that's what, let's say,
6 Suffolk County wants to say, but it's really for you
7 guys to do it.
8 And I just want to bring up what your own
9 agency can't tell you -- but, you know, you're not
10 the administrator, you're the legislators -- is
11 that, the boating safety program for New York State
12 is run by two people, the administration part of it.
13 So you can see, is if you do something
14 immediate, you only have two people to administer
15 right now. So I think they're pretty taxed doing
16 what they do now.
17 So, that has to be looked at on the State
18 level before any education.
19 SENATOR MARCELLINO: By title, who are they?
20 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: Huh?
21 SENATOR MARCELLINO: By title, who are they?
22 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: One is
23 Ro Woodard. And I don't know who the other woman
24 is.
25 There's two women up there that actually do
160
1 the, physically, administration.
2 When you need the books, they're the ones
3 you contact. They get all of the paperwork back.
4 They're a very small office. We work with
5 them. And, actually, we -- Mark and the Supervisor
6 sponsor the State Marine Patrol Vessel Operator
7 courses annually, so they can be brought down to
8 Long Island, because they're given up at
9 Lake George.
10 So we offer that to the State, annually. We
11 work very close with them. They're a very small and
12 efficient agency, but, again, very small.
13 If you're going to put a lot, you're going to
14 tax a lot of boating education to them. You know,
15 you have to make a plan.
16 And I'll get to that point.
17 The most critical themes I'll be presenting
18 for you today, are boating education reform,
19 legislation, and enforcement.
20 First, and foremost, I believe the main focal
21 point today is the need for boating-education
22 reform.
23 Second, legislation that would be a necessary
24 step to decreasing the hazards on the waterway, the
25 goal would be to establish legislation to decrease
161
1 penalties, and broaden the scope of violations.
2 More specifically, increasing legislation with
3 regard to operating a boat while impaired or
4 intoxicated, and reckless operation, and damage
5 caused by excessive wakes, which you've all heard
6 from other people today.
7 The third focus today would be discussing the
8 authority of the State, county, and local
9 enforcement, including expanded authority of the
10 New York State Coast Guard, to enforce State boating
11 laws.
12 I will expand on each of these issues.
13 Boating education: New York State lags
14 behind its neighboring states requiring
15 operators of power boats to have successfully
16 completed an approved boater-education course.
17 The current legislation requires completion
18 of a safety course for those operating a personal
19 watercraft. Current legislation only requires
20 those between the ages of 10 and 18 years old to
21 have a safety certificate to operate without
22 supervision.
23 The current legislation has absolutely no
24 requirements for any person over 18 to operate a
25 boat.
162
1 The present law is so vague, that even a
2 10-year-old can operate a power boat by the
3 themselves with a boating safety certificate, that
4 goes 100 miles an hour.
5 Ridiculous, but legal.
6 A two-year-old can operate a boat pulling a
7 skier, with an adult on board. Again, ridiculous,
8 but legal.
9 There is no quick fix, but, to allow me to
10 offer a comprehensive plan to effectively and
11 efficiently address the hazards on the waterways.
12 Please be advised, it is important to
13 understand the majority of boating-education courses
14 are volunteer-based, and offered by boating
15 organizations, such as U.S. Coast Guard Auxiliary
16 and the Power Squadron.
17 The first proposed step would be, develop two
18 courses.
19 The two courses would comprise of a
20 young-boater safety course for those age 10 to 16
21 years of age; and a second, more comprehensive
22 course, for those 16 years and older.
23 Any boater that currently holds an approved
24 boater safety-course certificate, State public
25 vessel operators's license, or U.S. Coast Guard
163
1 merchant license, will be exempt from being required
2 to take one of the newly implemented courses.
3 Additionally, a young boater that obtains a
4 certificate through the young-boater's course will
5 be exempt from being required to take the adult
6 boating-safety course later.
7 The second proposed course of action will be
8 to phase in the requirements, that all operators
9 of power boats and/or sailboats over 22 feet
10 obtain a boating-safety certificate over a four-year
11 period.
12 My example would be, to start in 2014,
13 because you're going to need time to ramp up, and so
14 will the people that offer the courses.
15 So, in 2014, people between the ages of
16 18 and 28 years old would be required to have a
17 boating certificate;
18 2015, 28 to 38 years old;
19 By 2016, 38 to 48 years old;
20 And, by 2017, all would be required to have a
21 boating-safety certificate.
22 As many adults will generally have a
23 driver's license, an option for boating
24 identification would be to include an endorsement,
25 say, Code B, for example, on a State license.
164
1 Any individual without, or not of driving
2 age, will be provided a boating-safety ID, ID that's
3 given now.
4 These options are already available by the
5 State. You know, you're not introducing anything
6 new. You can use the current resources available.
7 Fees collected from boating licenses should
8 have a portion allocated to fund boating safety
9 education and boating-safety announcements, in
10 addition to the current funding.
11 Laws alone will not resolve the increased
12 safety hazards boaters are faced with. No matter
13 how many laws you put on the books, it's not
14 going to stop a boater from violating them.
15 Two examples: One on the south shore, and
16 one which we didn't talk about, which is in
17 Connecticut, only 8 miles from us, another fatality.
18 Both of those fatalities were caused by
19 people violating the laws.
20 The State should consider reclassifying a
21 State driver's license to an operator's license.
22 This would enable violations on land and
23 sea to be admissible, to show the courts the
24 possible pattern of unsafe behavior, and allow for
25 appropriate fines to be assessed.
165
1 One of the problems we have, is that a lot
2 judges are not boating-familiar. You know, they
3 look at something done on a boat as recreation, and
4 not as serious as a driver's licenses.
5 This would also go for snowmobiles, and
6 make your license an operator license.
7 So, you have your safety certificate. It's
8 identified on it. And any violations that you
9 acquire as a -- they stated one of the problems, a
10 Nassau police officer -- is that there's no tracking
11 device.
12 If you do this, you'll be able to track
13 everything.
14 And if a guy is a bad operator on a
15 snowmobile, a bad operator on a car, and a bad
16 operator on a boat, the judges will be able to see
17 these patterns of behavior, and assess the
18 appropriate fines.
19 Boating while intoxicated and impaired: The
20 only person that can be charged with boating while
21 intoxicated are those operating a power boat.
22 If you were sailing a 70-foot sailboat,
23 intoxicated or impaired, with 10 children on board,
24 the operator cannot be charged with BWI; however, he
25 could be charged with reckless operation.
166
1 I propose that the law amended to allow all
2 vessels.
3 Currently, if an individual does not submit
4 to a breathalyzer test who have been convicted of
5 BWI, they may lose their privilege to operate.
6 However, without a licensing, you have little
7 or no tracking. You're not going to know it. When
8 you stop someone in the car or a boat, you're not
9 going know that they have had that violation.
10 Proposed resolution for this issue, is to tie
11 the boating education, being linked to a licensing
12 system, and enforceable regularly.
13 For example: License revocation could be
14 checked through boater's operator's license, which
15 could be restricted if there is an act of violation
16 on the boater's record.
17 Another option would be, to restrict the
18 operator -- operation of a vessel, to outlaw the
19 operation of vessels by individuals with open
20 containers of alcohol.
21 You have to remember, when you have the BWI
22 laws, which are sufficient, it's not like a car,
23 crossing the yellow line, weaving.
24 Okay?
25 You don't have to do that in a boat. As long
167
1 as you're going 5 miles an hour, we have no reason
2 to stop you.
3 If you have everybody sitting there with open
4 container of beer, drinking, and operating the boat,
5 that's not a reason. We cannot stop them.
6 They should have something, where there's an
7 operation of a vessel, that you cannot have any open
8 containers of alcohol while you're operating the
9 vessel. And, it would give a reason to stop the
10 vessel.
11 Restrictions on operators, 10 to 16 years
12 old: With the increased operation of speedboats,
13 the recommended restriction on the size and
14 horsepower of boats operated alone by boaters
15 between the ages of 10 and 16 years.
16 16 years old is the age a violator can be
17 issued a summons.
18 Capacity plates: This is not a State
19 issue, but the State may be able to petition the
20 federal government, through a home rule message, to
21 require boat manufacturers to apply and install
22 capacity plates on all recreational vessels,
23 regardless of size, similar to the vessels under
24 20 feet in length.
25 And, enforcement: One of the things we talk
168
1 about is in enforcement.
2 I don't know if you're aware, again, you're
3 not the administrator; part of is at the -- New York
4 State Police, after building a 19-year-old --
5 19-year marine law enforcement, disbanded it last
6 year in a matter of three days.
7 So, the State Police no longer has their
8 marine unit in force, which was a very active unit.
9 We helped them instruct with that.
10 The CPL: Amend the criminal procedure law to
11 give harbor masters and bay constables the same
12 authority with regards to arrest on warrants as
13 police officers.
14 Grant the U.S. Coast Guard boarding
15 officers the status of peace officer while on duty
16 in New York State waters, and supply peace
17 officers' training to those who quality.
18 This will enable the Coast Guard Office to
19 enforce State law as well as federal law.
20 The procedures to arrest a BWI is difficult
21 under federal law, and their violation procedures
22 are less effective than State procedures.
23 There are certificate -- a significant number
24 of police and peace officers that serve in the
25 reserves who reside in New York. These individuals
169
1 tend to serve in areas for extended periods of
2 time, and would need no additional training to
3 enforce State laws.
4 In closing: It would be a tremendous mistake
5 to close this hearing, make a few recommendations,
6 pat ourselves on the back, and walk away until the
7 next tragedy happens.
8 We would best be served to form advisory
9 councils in Nassau, western Suffolk, and
10 eastern Suffolk Counties, to serve in a capacity to
11 make recommendations to State officials on an annual
12 basis.
13 Thank you very much, Senator.
14 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Thank you very much.
15 Is there any -- before you guys leave --
16 You don't have to switch.
17 UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: The microphone only
18 reaches so much.
19 SENATOR MARCELLINO: That's okay. They can
20 speak up.
21 The talk of coordination before, between
22 different municipalities, and different levels out
23 there on the water, you've got multiplicity of
24 enforcement officials out there doing their thing.
25 Is there a coordinated effort?
170
1 Not every town has enough to cover, not every
2 village has enough to cover, certainly, not every
3 county can cover the entire length of, with what
4 they have. But, certainly, with assistance, working
5 together in some type of coordinated fashion, they
6 might be able to do something.
7 Is there such an activity between the
8 towns, counties, villages?
9 COMMISSIONER JUSTIN McCAFFERY: I think
10 that's why it's so important, like those training
11 classes that I mentioned. It gives us the
12 opportunity to network, and -- you know, besides
13 getting the good training.
14 It's -- I don't know -- so I always say,
15 it's -- you don't want to be exchanging business
16 cards, that -- the day of the emergency.
17 You know, you should have pre-existing
18 relationships and training, and know what
19 organizations can do what capabilities, and --
20 SENATOR MARCELLINO: I'm looking to go one
21 step beyond the training.
22 Excuse me for interrupting, but I'm looking
23 to go one step beyond.
24 Is there, actually, I'll take care of
25 Fort Palm Bay. You take care of X, Y, Z. You take
171
1 care of this location. Between here and here, a
2 Village of such and such has responsibility. We'll
3 work with you here and here. And the County of
4 Suffolk will take this range, because there are no
5 vessels, or there are no villages with the -- you
6 know, townships with the appropriate vessels
7 there.
8 Can -- do we cut it up, so that there's
9 coverage?
10 So, we spread the coverage out, so we
11 actually have a real blanket effect on it?
12 Or are we just out for -- you know, is
13 everybody doing their own thing?
14 COMMISSIONER JUSTIN McCAFFERY: I think it's
15 a pretty informal system, but it works pretty
16 well.
17 We know who does what, who covers what, and
18 who has what equipment and capabilities.
19 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: We have --
20 we meet on a regular basis at Eatons Coast Guard
21 with all the law enforcement, and we discuss our
22 issues. They have law-enforcement organization
23 meetings.
24 To answer your question: No, we -- I can't
25 tell Suffolk County Police where to go, I can't tell
172
1 the Villages where to go, because they're operating
2 under their own jurisdictions.
3 We do, however, work well together.
4 In the winter, we're pretty much the only
5 show in town. The County only mans their police
6 boat on a -- sporadically, and the Villages pull
7 their boats, so, we do the work for them.
8 But we do keep in touch. We do do train --
9 we do train together.
10 The Suffolk County Police Marine Bureau is in
11 our parking lot. Our office is right next to each
12 other, and we do stay in touch. But, again, I don't
13 have the authority, they don't have the authority,
14 to tell another jurisdiction what they should and
15 shouldn't be doing.
16 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Well, I like your
17 comment on the linking the boating violations with
18 the driving violations, to pick out repeat
19 offenders.
20 The only problem with it is, if you don't
21 have a licensing --
22 And we talked about this earlier, I don't
23 know if you heard it, but we were talking about
24 earlier.
25 -- is there some link we can do with the
173
1 registration number on the boat, on the hull of the
2 boat?
3 If you require every boat to have some type
4 of registration. As Chris Squeri talked about,
5 everybody should have some number that identifies
6 the boat. So, if you find a dingy overturned,
7 washed up on a beach, you don't have to send the
8 cops out looking for somebody who may be drowning
9 out there, or may have drowned.
10 You have a number which you can track back to
11 a resident, to an ownership, and say: Look, we
12 found this. Is somebody missing in your family?
13 Have you -- can you account for everybody?
14 That saves a lot of time, and anxiety in
15 that respect.
16 Is there some way to do that, so that we can
17 tie these things in, so that a judge, when
18 Mr. So-and-So, with the 16 kids on the boat,
19 comes before a judge, he can say: Well, look,
20 this guy had, not only this incident, but he had
21 something over here, something over there. My God,
22 we have a repeat offender here?
23 Otherwise, how do they know?
24 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: No, the
25 registration of the boat only identifies the boat
174
1 and who owns it.
2 If I lend my boat to Mark Cuthbertson and he
3 gets a violation, I don't want --
4 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Don't do that.
5 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: No, I
6 wouldn't do that. I wouldn't even invite him on a
7 boat. He's a better golfer than boater, but --
8 [Laughter.]
9 SENATOR MARCELLINO: I heard that.
10 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: -- but, it
11 only identifies who the owner of the boat is. You
12 know --
13 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Well, I understand it
14 would only identify who the -- but if you link the
15 ticket to the boat --
16 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: Yeah, but
17 that --
18 SENATOR MARCELLINO: -- right now, the car
19 links -- if I drive a car, it doesn't matter whose
20 car it is, the ticket goes on my license.
21 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: Right.
22 SENATOR MARCELLINO: So, whatever car I'm
23 driving, it's my license, I get the points.
24 In the other case, if the boat's got a
25 number, put the number on the boat; put the ticket
175
1 on the boat. I don't care who owns it. It goes
2 back to the owner of the boat, so, you might be more
3 careful as to who you lend your boat to.
4 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: Well, maybe,
5 but it's tricky.
6 Like you say, some boats, a 21-foot boat,
7 might be used by multiple people in one family, but
8 registered to one.
9 SENATOR MARCELLINO: I understand.
10 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: You know, I
11 would advocate doing the licensing system, where you
12 actually track the operator of it.
13 And even if, you know, the person is a -- is
14 found in violation --
15 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Hold on one second.
16 They've got to change something.
17 [Pause in the proceeding.]
18 SENATOR MARCELLINO: You were finishing?
19 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: Yes.
20 I would advocate more of a licensing system
21 for the operator, because the violation is caused by
22 the operator, not the boat owner. You know, they
23 might not even be on board.
24 So, I would link any type of boating
25 education to an actual license.
176
1 The registration, as they pointed out, all
2 vessels -- pleasure vessels in New York State must
3 be -- have a New York State registration.
4 But, I disagree with Chris. The ones that
5 are documented, they get the sticker on the front,
6 there's no tracking method if -- you know, on that
7 boat, from that sticker.
8 SENATOR MARCELLINO: All right.
9 Mike?
10 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: Thank you, Senator.
11 For the Commissioner: On the -- out here,
12 now, for Nassau, for the operations here, does the
13 bay constables or Nassau County Police or the
14 Coast Guard, is there any joint communications
15 between them?
16 I know you coordinate your efforts
17 informally, but, when all the vessels are out there,
18 can they communicate with each other
19 [unintelligible]?
20 COMMISSIONER JUSTIN McCAFFERY: Yeah, we can
21 communicate on the different radio frequencies.
22 And, as far as communication goes, we actually share
23 an office. The Nassau County Police share an office
24 and dock space, both at Tappan Beach and here at
25 Roosevelt.
177
1 So, you know, there is daily interaction
2 between the Coast Guard, the police, and --
3 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: Well, I guess what my
4 question is, though, like, we take the incident that
5 happened July 4th, with all those boats in the water
6 and, you know, everybody's on the border line
7 between Nassau and Suffolk, so I'm sure Huntington
8 has their boats out, and all the other agencies
9 have their boats out.
10 If yous wanted to do a coordinated effort
11 that night, can all those vessels on the water
12 talk to each other?
13 COMMISSIONER JUSTIN McCAFFERY: Yes, we can.
14 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: All right.
15 And just getting -- if I can just touch on
16 the issue, whoever may know the answer on the
17 capacity plates, realizing that this might be a
18 federal issue, right now, in the boating industry,
19 is there a standard set by the manufacturers as to
20 what the capacity is on a particular size boat?
21 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: Twenty and
22 under, is mandatory; twenty-six is voluntary; and
23 none after that.
24 And, actually, for the people that have a
25 capacity plate, the weight has been raised from
178
1 160 pounds, to 185, is the average person.
2 So, we run a launch service, we use to carry
3 26 people. We're down to 19.
4 So, that capacity plate that they're looking
5 at on an older boat is going to be incorrect.
6 That's going to be judged at 160.
7 But, no, after that, there is absolutely no
8 requirements to list and --
9 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: So in order for the
10 federal government to even establish this law with
11 capacity plates, they're going have to create an
12 industry -- an industry standard, then?
13 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: Yes, they
14 would have to require any new manufacturers to
15 supply capacity plate on all vessels. That's
16 what -- how to do it.
17 But, again, it's federal, as I say, with the
18 licensing.
19 I know in Suffolk County, there's a move to
20 put licensing in Suffolk County. That is not good.
21 We need the State to take the lead on it, and
22 the County to support it, but don't go passing
23 laws in small jurisdictions on licensing. It's
24 not going to work.
25 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: And my last question
179
1 is, you had touched on it before, about amending the
2 criminal procedure law, to give peace-officer status
3 to the members of the Coast Guard while operating,
4 you know, in New York.
5 So, should I understand that, currently, if a
6 U.S. Coast Guard vessel, if [unintelligible] with a
7 boat on Long Island waters, and they violated any
8 of the State or local -- the State navigation law or
9 local town law, or even boating while intoxicated,
10 they cannot enforce? They can't take enforcement
11 action?
12 HARBOR MASTER HARRY ACKER, SR.: No. No.
13 And, number one, they would have to -- we
14 would have to partner with them.
15 The same as you said, we have to -- when you
16 do your legislation for boating licensings, we have
17 to talk -- Senator, you're right, we have to talk to
18 Connecticut, we have to talk to New Jersey, because
19 we all should get on the same page. We're sharing
20 the same water.
21 The same thing, a perfect example: My son's
22 a New York City police officer. He's also a
23 reservist at Jones Beach. He's completely trained
24 to be able to enforce the State law, but he's
25 restricted, because he can only -- when he's working
180
1 for the Coast Guard, he can only enforce a federal
2 law.
3 ASSEMBLYMAN MONTESANO: Thank you very much.
4 Thank you, Senator.
5 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Gentlemen, thank you for
6 your time and your attention, and coming in.
7 I thank all of the witnesses who have spoken.
8 [Unintelligible], I give you lasting credit,
9 you have fortitude. And -- or else, well-padded
10 bottom.
11 [Laughter.]
12 SENATOR MARCELLINO: Either way, we
13 appreciate the fact that you came. We appreciate
14 your testimony.
15 This Committee will take the testimony, and
16 we -- anyone who wishes to submit it in writing, who
17 was here today, or is watching these things, over --
18 on your computer, or whatever, wishes to submit, we
19 will keep the record open for a period of time.
20 I know -- at least until the end of this
21 month, and we will take that testimony in, and we
22 will be reviewing it as far as recommendations.
23 We will write a report to the Senate, and
24 make recommendations as we see needed, relative to
25 the testimony that came.
181
1 So, again, I appreciate you coming, and thank
2 you.
3 And the meeting is adjourned.
4
5 ---oOo---
6
7 (Whereupon, at approximately 2:10 p.m.,
8 the public hearing held before the New York State
9 Senate Standing Committee on Investigations and
10 Government Operations, concluded, and adjourned.)
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25