Regular Session - April 6, 1994
2195
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9 ALBANY, NEW YORK
10 April 6, 1994
11 12:23 p.m.
12
13
14 REGULAR SESSION
15
16
17
18 SENATOR HUGH T. FARLEY, Acting President
19 STEPHEN F. SLOAN, Secretary
20
21
22
23
2196
1 P R O C E E D I N G S
2 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: The
3 Senate will come to order. Senators will please
4 find their seats. We'll wait just a second;
5 wait for a second for the stenographer.
6 Allegiance to the flag.
7 (The assemblage repeated the
8 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.)
9 In the absence of clergy, we'll
10 bow our heads in a moment of silent prayer.
11 (A moment of silence was
12 observed.)
13 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY:
14 Secretary will begin by reading the Journal.
15 THE SECRETARY: In Senate,
16 Tuesday, April 5th. The Senate met pursuant to
17 adjournment, Senator Kuhl in the Chair upon
18 designation of the Temporary President. The
19 Journal of Monday, April 4th, was read and
20 approved. On motion, Senate adjourned.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Hearing
22 no objection, the Journal will stand approved as
23 read.
2197
1 The order of business:
2 Presentation of Peti...Senator Present.
3 SENATOR PRESENT: Would you
4 recognize Senator Skelos, please.
5 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: I
6 certainly will. Senator Skelos.
7 SENATOR SKELOS: Yes. There will
8 be an immediate meeting of the Aging Committee
9 in the Majority Conference Room.
10 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY:
11 There'll be an immediate meeting of the Aging
12 Committee in Room 332, the Majority Conference
13 Room.
14 Senator Mendez.
15 SENATOR MENDEZ: Yesterday
16 afternoon, I had to step out of this chamber and
17 I would like the record to reflect that if I
18 would have been here, I would have voted no on
19 Calendar Number 405.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: The
21 record will so...
22 SENATOR PRESENT: No objection.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: The
2198
1 record will show that.
2 The order of business. Senator
3 Nozzol... wait a minute, we're not on that.
4 Presentation of petitions.
5 Messages from the Assembly.
6 Messages from the Governor.
7 Reports of standing committees.
8 Reports of select committees.
9 Communications and reports.
10 Motions and resolutions. Senator
11 Nozzolio.
12 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Yes, Mr.
13 President.
14 On behalf of Senator Levy, I wish
15 to star Calendar Number 485, Bill S. 193-A.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Bill is
17 starred at the request of the sponsor.
18 Senator Volker.
19 SENATOR VOLKER: Just standing,
20 Mr. President, thank you.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: O.K.
22 Any other motions on the floor? No other
23 motions. O.K. We have a couple resolutions.
2199
1 Senator Present.
2 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President,
3 I move that we adopt the Resolution Calendar.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: All in
5 favor of adopting the Resolution Calendar, say
6 aye.
7 (Response of "Aye.")
8 Those opposed, nay.
9 (There was no response. )
10 The Resolution Calendar is
11 adopted.
12 SENATOR PRESENT: Would you
13 recognize Senator Larkin, please.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Senator
15 Larkin.
16 SENATOR LARKIN: Mr. President,
17 Resolution Number 3122 commemorates the week of
18 April 30th, 1944 as Town Clerks' Week in the
19 state of New York. Like to open it up for
20 sponsorship by everyone.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY:
22 Resolution on Town Clerks' Week is open to the
23 Senate to sponsor. Please approach the desk.
2200
1 All Republicans. Do you wish all the Democrats
2 to be on it, Senator Gold?
3 SENATOR GOLD: Pardon me?
4 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: On Town
5 Clerks' Week resolution?
6 SENATOR GOLD: Hold on one
7 second. It's a great idea.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: All
9 members of the Senate will be on it. Please
10 approach the desk if you wish not to be.
11 Senator Gold?
12 SENATOR GOLD: Mr. President.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Senator
14 Gold.
15 SENATOR GOLD: I believe there's
16 a privileged resolution at the desk sponsored by
17 Senator Nolan and, if you could read the title
18 and then perhaps people want to co-sponsor it.
19 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: The
20 Secretary will read the title.
21 THE SECRETARY: Legislative
22 Resolution by Senators Nolan, Farley, Stafford,
23 Bruno and Holland, paying tribute to Siena
2201
1 College men's basketball team in recognition of
2 their outstanding regular season and their
3 exceptional post-season performance in the 1994
4 National Invitational Tournament.
5 SENATOR GOLD: Yes. I certainly
6 think that all the Democrats want to be on it
7 and I think all the Republicans with the
8 exception of Senator Skelos.
9 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Senator
10 want to be on it for that great team from the
11 Capital District area.
12 SENATOR PRESENT: I think except
13 those who decline should be on it.
14 SENATOR GOLD: I think the only
15 exception is Senator Skelos. He's voting no.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: All
17 members of the Senate will be on it. Siena
18 certainly had a great, great year and the Senate
19 is very proud to support them. One of the joys
20 of the Capital District.
21 All in favor of adopting the
22 resolution, say aye.
23 (Response of "Aye.")
2202
1 Those opposed nay.
2 (There was no response. )
3 It's unanimously adopted.
4 There's a third resolution here.
5 SENATOR PRESENT: Would you
6 recognize Senator Holland.
7 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Senator
8 Holland.
9 SENATOR HOLLAND: Will you read
10 the title of the resolution?
11 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY:
12 Secretary will read the title of Senator
13 Holland's resolution.
14 THE SECRETARY: Legislative
15 Resolution, by Senators Holland, Nolan, Farley,
16 Stafford and Bruno, honoring and commemorating
17 the success of Rockland County's native son,
18 Mike Deane, head coach of the Siena basketball
19 team.
20 SENATOR HOLLAND: Just want to
21 note that he is a Rockland County native and he
22 did an excellent job. I'd certainly like to
23 open it up to everybody for sponsorship also.
2203
1 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Without
2 objection, I guess all members of the Senate
3 will be on the Mike Deane resolution,
4 outstanding coach who is now heading off to a
5 bigger and better job, supposedly.
6 All in favor of the resolution
7 say aye.
8 (Response of "Aye.")
9 Those opposed nay.
10 (There was no response. )
11 The resolution -- the resolution
12 is adopted. All members will be on it without
13 objection.
14 Senator Present.
15 SENATOR PRESENT: I think we're
16 ready for the non-controversial calendar.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY:
18 Secretary will read non-controversial.
19 THE SECRETARY: On page 5,
20 Calendar Number 233, by Senator Holland, Senate
21 Bill Number 2839-B, an act to amend the Social
22 Services Law, in relation to the use of a
23 fingerprint matching identification system.
2204
1 SENATOR GOLD: Lay it aside.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Lay the
3 bill aside.
4 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President.
5 THE SECRETARY: Senator Present.
6 SENATOR PRESENT: In order to
7 accommodate a couple of members, can we have the
8 last section of that read and allow them to
9 vote.
10 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Clerk
11 will read.
12 SENATOR GOLD: Who are our
13 members?
14 SENATOR PRESENT: Senator -
15 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
16 act shall take effect immediately.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT FARLEY: Call
18 the roll.
19 (The Secretary called the roll. )
20 SENATOR PRESENT: Call Senator
21 Sears' name.
22 THE SECRETARY: Senator Sears.
23 SENATOR SEARS: Aye.
2205
1 SENATOR PRESENT: And Senator
2 Skelos.
3 SENATOR GOLD: Have to check
4 that.
5 THE SECRETARY: Senator Skelos.
6 SENATOR SKELOS: Aye.
7 SENATOR GOLD: Hold on.
8 SENATOR PRESENT: Withdraw the
9 roll call and lay the bill aside.
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Roll call
11 is withdrawn, and the bill is laid aside.
12 THE SECRETARY: On page 11,
13 Calendar Number 480, by member of the Assembly
14 DiNapoli, Assembly Bill Number 9307, Education
15 Law, in relation to the estimated expenses of
16 school districts.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
18 section.
19 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
20 act shall take effect immediately.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
22 roll.
23 (The Secretary called the roll. )
2206
1 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 39.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
3 is passed.
4 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
5 481, by Senator Present, Senate Bill Number
6 6943, authorize the payment of transportation
7 aid to Dansville Central School District.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: There's a
9 local fiscal impact note at the desk. Last
10 section.
11 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
12 act shall take effect immediately.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
14 roll.
15 (The Secretary called the roll. )
16 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 39.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
18 is passed.
19 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
20 482, by Senator Cook, Senate Bill Number 2836,
21 an act to amend the General Municipal Law.
22 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
23 section.
2207
1 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
2 act shall take effect immediately.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
4 roll.
5 (The Secretary called the roll. )
6 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 41.
7 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
8 is passed.
9 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
10 484, by Senator Levy, Senate Bill Number 81-A.
11 SENATOR GOLD: Lay it aside.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Lay the
13 bill aside.
14 Senator Leichter.
15 SENATOR LEICHTER: Yes. May I
16 ask that we reconsider the vote by which
17 Calendar 482 just passed and ask that that bill
18 be laid aside, please?
19 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: 482, is
20 it here? It's here. Call the roll on
21 reconsideration.
22 (The Secretary called the roll on
23 reconsideration. )
2208
1 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 41.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
3 is laid aside.
4 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
5 487, by Senator Tully, Senate Bill Number
6 2539-A, an act to amend the Vehicle and Traffic
7 Law.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
9 section.
10 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
11 act shall take effect immediately.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
13 roll.
14 (The Secretary called the roll. )
15 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 41.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
17 is passed.
18 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
19 488, by Senator Sears, Senate Bill Number 6805,
20 an act to amend the Highway Law, designating a
21 portion of the state highway system as the
22 Aluminum Workers' Memorial Highway.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
2209
1 section.
2 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
3 act shall take effect immediately.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
5 roll.
6 (The Secretary called the roll. )
7 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 41.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
9 is passed.
10 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
11 493, by Senator Lack, Senate Bill Number 6964,
12 Estates, Powers and Trusts Law.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
14 section.
15 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
16 act shall take effect immediately.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
18 roll.
19 (The Secretary called the roll. )
20 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 41.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
22 is passed.
23 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
2210
1 498, by Senator Volker, Senate Bill Number 931,
2 an act to amend the Penal Law, in relation to
3 increasing penalties for crimes of conspiracy.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
5 section.
6 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
7 act shall take effect immediately.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
9 roll.
10 (The Secretary called the roll. )
11 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 43.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
13 is passed.
14 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
15 499, by Senator Volker, Senate Bill Number 2627,
16 an act to amend the Penal Law, in relation to
17 authorized dispositions in certain felony
18 cases.
19 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
20 section.
21 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
22 act shall take effect immediately.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
2211
1 roll.
2 (The Secretary called the roll. )
3 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 42, nays
4 one, Senator DeFrancisco recorded in the
5 negative.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
7 is passed.
8 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
9 506, by Senator Saland, Senate Bill Number 4417,
10 Criminal Procedure Law and the Family Court
11 Act.
12 SENATOR GOLD: Will you hold for
13 Senator Galiber, please.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Lay the
15 bill aside.
16 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
17 507, by Senator Volker, Senate Bill Number 4829,
18 Criminal Procedure Law, in relation to issuance
19 of search warrants.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
21 section.
22 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
23 act shall take effect immediately.
2212
1 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
2 roll.
3 (The Secretary called the roll. )
4 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 43.
5 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
6 is passed.
7 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
8 510, by Senator Stafford, Senate Bill Number
9 6845, an act to amend Chapter 266 of the Laws of
10 1981, amending the Civil Practice Law and
11 Rules.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
13 section.
14 SENATOR GOLD: Lay it aside,
15 please.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Lay the
17 bill aside.
18 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
19 513, by -
20 SENATOR GOLD: Lay it aside.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Lay the
22 bill aside.
23 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
2213
1 518, by Senator Cook.
2 SENATOR GOLD: Lay it aside,
3 please.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Lay the
5 bill aside.
6 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
7 519, by Senator Johnson, Senate Bill Number
8 5073-A, Environmental Conservation Law.
9 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
10 section.
11 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
12 act shall take effect immediately.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
14 roll.
15 (The Secretary called the roll. )
16 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 44.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
18 is passed.
19 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
20 520, by Senator Trunzo, Senate Bill Number 6560,
21 an act to amend the Environmental Conservation
22 Law.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
2214
1 section.
2 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
3 act shall take effect immediately.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
5 roll.
6 (The Secretary called the roll. )
7 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 45.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
9 is passed.
10 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
11 521, by Senator Johnson, Senate Bill Number
12 7029, Environmental Conservation Law.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
14 section.
15 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
16 act shall take effect immediately.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
18 roll.
19 (The Secretary called the roll. )
20 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 46.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
22 is passed.
23 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
2215
1 523, by Senator Levy, Senate Bill Number 1003-A,
2 an act to amend the Vehicle and Traffic Law.
3 SENATOR DOLLINGER: Lay aside.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Lay the
5 bill aside.
6 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
7 524, by Senator Levy, Senate Bill Number 1114,
8 an act to amend the Vehicle and Traffic Law, in
9 relation to suspension pending prosecution.
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
11 section.
12 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
13 act shall take effect immediately.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
15 roll.
16 (The Secretary called the roll. )
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Announce
18 the results.
19 THE SECRETARY: Those recorded in
20 the negative on Calendar Number 524 are Senators
21 Daly, DeFrancisco, Farley, Holland, Kuhl,
22 Present, Rath, Saland, Spano, Stachowski,
23 Velella and Wright. Ayes 34, nays 12.
2216
1 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
2 is passed.
3 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
4 525, by Senator Levy, Senate Bill Number 1310,
5 an act to amend the Vehicle and Traffic Law, in
6 relation to limiting options for plea bargaining
7 for repeated DWI offenders.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
9 section.
10 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
11 act shall take effect immediately.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
13 roll.
14 (The Secretary called the roll. )
15 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 44, nays 2,
16 Senators DeFrancisco and Kuhl recorded in the
17 negative.
18 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
19 is passed.
20 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
21 526, by Senator Marino, Senate Bill Number 7239.
22 SENATOR GOLD: Lay aside,
23 please.
2217
1 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Lay the
2 bill aside.
3 Senator Present, that completes
4 the non-controversial calendar. What's your
5 pleasure?
6 SENATOR PRESENT: Would you
7 recognize Senator Saland?
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
9 Saland.
10 SENATOR SALAND: Mr. President, I
11 request unanimous consent to be recorded in the
12 negative on Calendar Number 499.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Without
14 objection, so ordered.
15 Senator DeFrancisco.
16 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: I'd ask
17 unanimous consent to be recorded in the negative
18 on 487, please.
19 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Without
20 objection, so ordered.
21 Senator Present.
22 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President,
23 let's take up the controversial calendar,
2218
1 please.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Clerk
3 will read the controversial calendar.
4 THE SECRETARY: On page 5,
5 Calendar Number 233, by Senator Holland, Senate
6 Bill Number 2839-B, Social Service Law, in
7 relation to the use of fingerprint matching
8 identification system for home relief benefits.
9 SENATOR GOLD: Explanation.
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
11 Holland, an explanation has been asked for.
12 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes, Mr.
13 President.
14 I think everyone knows really
15 what the problem is, and I think most of us
16 believe, however well, that fingerprinting
17 should be a part of the solution. It will save
18 us an awful lot of money and restore credibility
19 to the system. With fingerprinting we have, of
20 course, an opportunity to return credibility,
21 responsibility and integrity to a system which
22 is widely perceived by the public as being a red
23 tape bureaucracy which is absolutely riddled
2219
1 with fraud.
2 The problem is -- some of the
3 problems, welfare is growing at 12, 15, 20, 30
4 percent a year. In this year's budget, Medicaid
5 and welfare is approximately $24 billion of the
6 $63 billion total budget, or 38 percent of the
7 budget, and the people are telling us and, in
8 fact, begging us to clean up the system. The
9 people are hating and mistrusting anyone on
10 welfare, mistrusting anyone who needs help, not
11 because they need help because I think most of
12 us want to help them, but because of the limited
13 number of thieves who are stealing from the
14 system.
15 You've all heard the testimony,
16 testimony before my committee, testimony before
17 other committees, from all over the state and
18 all over the nation that fraud and abuse in the
19 Medicaid and welfare system is five percent of
20 that $24 billion, is ten percent of that $24
21 billion, and it's even been suggested it's 25
22 percent of that $24 billion, but realistically
23 if it's five percent, then we are being ripped
2220
1 off, the taxpayers of this state and we're
2 allowing it, if it's five percent, $1.2 billion
3 dollars. It's more likely that it's near 10
4 percent and that means we're allowing the
5 taxpayers of this state to be ripped off for
6 approximately $2.4 billion a year.
7 Now, some people say that the
8 system is degrading. I certainly don't think
9 so, but we need to improve the system. We need
10 to tighten up the management. We need to offer
11 better management tools to clean up the system
12 and every time we do it there's another reason
13 why we shouldn't be able to do that. In the
14 meantime, as we said, the taxpayers are being
15 ripped off for $2 billion a year and we can not
16 agree on a solution.
17 Some people say that only
18 criminals are fingerprinted. Now, you know -
19 you know that isn't true. I have a list here of
20 80 different groups that require fingerprinting
21 in this state, and I'll be glad to read it for
22 you if you want. But some of them are police,
23 military personnel, anybody who works for a
2221
1 museum, anybody who works for an art gallery,
2 anybody who works for the school system for the
3 city of New York, the Governor's staff, and on
4 and on and on.
5 And people don't mind being
6 fingerprinted; and somebody will say, well, it's
7 not voluntary, but if you recall a few years ago
8 when people went into the military it wasn't
9 voluntary then either, but they still had their
10 fingerprints taken. Therefore, people who need
11 help should be willing to have their finger
12 prints taken and, in fact, they are.
13 We've done a state study. The
14 Department of Social Services has done a state
15 study, and they found in that study that 93 or
16 94 percent of the people, the clients, the
17 people who need help, do not mind having their
18 fingerprints taken and, in fact, you've probably
19 done the same thing I've done, you've gone into
20 other offices and asked or on the street and
21 asked those people if they mind -- minded.
22 You've watched them on TV. They do not mind if
23 they need assistance. The honest people on the
2222
1 system do not mind. It is the thieves that mind
2 having their fingerprints taken.
3 In a 1993 letter, Commissioner
4 Shepard of New York City Department of
5 Investigation cited a major welfare fraud scheme
6 involving fraudulent I.D.s. This case you've
7 heard over and over and over again. There were
8 115 welfare recipients in the city of New York
9 that ripped off the system for $45 million, a
10 system that should have caught these people
11 stealing from the system, but it was $45 million
12 that they took out of the system very, very
13 easily. And recently you've seen in the paper
14 where people from different states are coming
15 into our state, and they're getting home relief
16 in New Jersey, in New York. They found 425
17 people who were collecting in New Jersey and New
18 York, and I believe that's only the tip of the
19 iceberg. Then they decided to check Jersey City
20 and they pulled ten people from the home relief
21 rolls. Guess how many were collecting in both
22 states? Eight out of the ten. This is a
23 terrible uncontrolled system that is ripping off
2223
1 the taxpayers.
2 In the study done by DSS in
3 Rockland County and Onondaga County, two
4 counties that are very far apart and rural
5 counties which only have one entry point, but
6 the city of New York has 39 entry points, the
7 department of -- DSS, the Department of Social
8 Services found that the savings in those two
9 counties for the year approached $700,000, and
10 they projected for an expense of 10 million to
11 $13 million dollars, we could save statewide $46
12 million a year, and that doesn't count -- that's
13 only home relief. That doesn't count Medicaid.
14 That doesn't count food stamps. If we put all
15 of that in, we could save approximately $100
16 million a year for an expense of 10- to $13
17 million.
18 According to Comptroller McCall
19 in a report issued -- a release in December of
20 1993, as much as $39 million dollars in home
21 relief payments in 1991 were actually over
22 payments for a variety of reasons. In that same
23 report, Comptroller McCall recommended that the
2224
1 Department of Social Services establish local
2 quality control safeguards to prevent over
3 payments.
4 In its response, the Department
5 of Social Services said that finger imaging
6 could be employed as a more cost-effective
7 safeguard against over-payments. And people
8 will bring up California. I have spoken to some
9 Senators from Los Angeles County in the NCSL.
10 That system saved approximately $5.2 million
11 just for the city of Los Angeles in one year -
12 or six months, rather, and they estimate that,
13 if it went statewide, the state of California
14 would save $750 million in the first year and
15 they are looking -- California is now looking at
16 expanding to the surrounding counties around Los
17 Angeles.
18 I want to tell you a little bit
19 more about Los Angeles, because I know that will
20 be coming up. A total of 3,263 recipients and
21 applicants were either denied or terminated for
22 failing to comply with finger imaging
23 requirement within the first six months of the
2225
1 study. Among the applicants, 80 percent of whom
2 received general assistance previously, there
3 were 29 matches made and 213 refused to be
4 fingerprinted. Among the recipients, there were
5 11 matches made and over 3,000 refused to be
6 fingerprinted.
7 Now, there must be a reason why
8 they refused to be fingerprinted. I told you
9 about the savings in Rockland County, and I told
10 you that there -- they stand far apart. I would
11 like to tell you a few comments from some people
12 you may recognize their names.
13 Comptroller McCall, who on Monday
14 endorsed fingerprinting, I think you all know
15 that, said "we must take steps to combat the
16 perception that welfare is rampant with fraud,
17 and fingerprinting will do that. It will bring
18 back credibility to the system and not the hate
19 that people have out there for people on
20 welfare."
21 Governor Cuomo last week admitted
22 to the press that finger imaging could "give the
23 welfare system the much needed credibility it
2226
1 now lacks with the taxpayers." The Governor
2 said, "The more I hear the arguments against it,
3 the more convinced I'm right. This is not a
4 stigma. I don't understand any suggestion that
5 it is."
6 People in support of the system
7 besides the people on this side of the aisle,
8 New York City Mayor Giuliani wants to expand it
9 and bring it out as quickly as possible; the
10 Governor, the Comptroller, most county
11 executives if not all, probably 80 percent of
12 the taxpayers, the people that we represent.
13 You also heard about Judge Weinstein who had a
14 case of fraud, two women from the Dominican
15 Republic, and he said in his opinion that
16 fingerprinting -- the state is making a huge
17 mistake by not implementing finger imaging right
18 away.
19 And, of course, the Department of
20 Social Services. My colleagues, the people want
21 it, and you know, you talk to them, they want
22 it. It's a proven money saver, and the honest
23 clients do not object to having their finger
2227
1 image taken. Why don't we join together and do
2 this for the taxpayers of this state as soon as
3 possible.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
5 Waldon.
6 SENATOR WALDON: Thank you very
7 much, Mr. President.
8 Would the learned gentleman yield
9 to a question or two?
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
11 Holland, do you yield?
12 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The
14 Senator does.
15 SENATOR WALDON: Senator Holland,
16 I believe I heard you -
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
18 Present.
19 SENATOR PRESENT: Yes, Mr.
20 President. Would you recognize Senator Cook.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
22 Cook.
23 SENATOR COOK: My apology, but
2228
1 there's an Education Committee meeting scheduled
2 for 1:00 o'clock. I think we'll move that into
3 the conference room, the Majority Conference
4 Room rather than downstairs, so we will be
5 available for votes here.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: There
7 will be a Senate Education Committee meeting in
8 the Conference Room scheduled for 1:00 o'clock
9 which is now.
10 Thank you, Senator Cook; thank
11 you, Senator Waldon for your indulgence.
12 SENATOR PRESENT: Thank you,
13 Senator Waldon.
14 SENATOR WALDON: Thank you, Mr.
15 President, and thank you, Mr. President.
16 Senator Holland, I believe I
17 heard you say that people who wish to receive
18 this aid from the state do not object to
19 receiving -- do not object to being finger
20 printed.
21 It is difficult to know people
22 unless you walk in their own shoes. Can you
23 tell me where you conducted the surveys which
2229
1 gave you that information?
2 SENATOR HOLLAND: You know,
3 Senator, the survey was done in Rockland and
4 Onondaga Counties where the system has been
5 implemented for over a year, but there have been
6 other pieces on TV, just reviewing one this
7 morning, where the TV cameras go out and ask the
8 clients in the welfare offices, because I was
9 there, if they minded and they said absolutely
10 not, because they were honest people who just
11 needed help.
12 SENATOR WALDON: The people that
13 you interviewed in the two counties in question,
14 I will, if the President permits me, I will get
15 to that momentarily. But did you conduct any
16 surveys in Bedford-Stuyvesant?
17 SENATOR HOLLAND: Personally? No,
18 sir.
19 SENATOR WALDON: Did anyone?
20 SENATOR HOLLAND: Not to my
21 knowledge.
22 SENATOR WALDON: Did anyone
23 conduct any surveys in South Jamaica or in the
2230
1 Auburn-Edgemere section of the Rockaways?
2 SENATOR HOLLAND: I will give you
3 the fact that the only surveys that I know were
4 done were in Rockland and Onondaga County. It
5 won't be necessary to go through every county in
6 the state of New York.
7 SENATOR WALDON: So what you're
8 saying is that, if I understand -- Mr.
9 President, may I continue?
10 What you're saying, if I
11 understand correctly, is that you're projecting
12 the results of the survey conducted upstate
13 across the state of New York, the eighteen and a
14 half million people of the state of New York
15 have projected upon them the results of the
16 survey you conducted in the two counties of the
17 state, is that correct?
18 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes, sir, but I
19 don't think that people in the city of New York
20 are really any different than the people in
21 Rockland and Onondaga. People who are in need
22 are the same whether they are in Onondaga County
23 or Queens or wherever.
2231
1 SENATOR WALDON: I'm not sure
2 that I agree with that.
3 Mr. President, may I continue?
4 May I continue?
5 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Please
6 do, Senator.
7 SENATOR WALDON: Senator Holland,
8 even looking at the survey that was conducted
9 upstate, the information that you gave doesn't
10 seem quite accurate. My information -- and
11 correct me if it's wrong -- says that there were
12 4,772 applicants in both districts; only 19
13 refused to be fingerprinted, is that correct?
14 SENATOR HOLLAND: There were -
15 yes, sir, I believe that's correct, and there
16 were none in Rockland County who refused to be
17 fingerprinted. They sat the individuals down
18 prior to their being fingerprinted, explained
19 the system to them, and absolutely none refused
20 to be fingerprinted.
21 SENATOR WALDON: Further my
22 information states, Senator Holland, that 495 of
23 the 3,344 existing cases called in for finger
2232
1 printing were closed, with only 145 otherwise
2 unexplainable closings; is that fairly accurate?
3 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes, sir.
4 SENATOR WALDON: And isn't that
5 what you based the cost savings upon?
6 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes, sir, and I
7 also gave the information from Los Angeles
8 County where 3,000 people, applicants, didn't
9 show up in the first six months to have their
10 fingerprints taken. Yes, sir, that's where the
11 savings come from and if we project that
12 statewide, the Department says we will save $46
13 million, not counting Medicaid and food stamps.
14 SENATOR WALDON: Mr. President,
15 may I continue.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Please
17 continue.
18 SENATOR WALDON: Senator, we
19 debated Los Angeles last year for a long time.
20 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes, sir and I
21 (talking over/unintelligible) constituents with
22 you.
23 SENATOR WALDON: And we're having
2233
1 this conversation again.
2 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes.
3 SENATOR WALDON: Very politely, I
4 may add.
5 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes.
6 SENATOR WALDON: But there is
7 room for error in your analysis because what
8 you're saying is the fact that people refuse to
9 be fingerprinted, ergo, therefore, means there's
10 a dollar cost savings but we don't really know
11 why the people refused.
12 If I understood what you said,
13 you said they willingly came forth and were
14 fingerprinted, but some, for reasons unknown,
15 refused to be fingerprinted, and I ask you
16 again, was there any survey conducted in Harlem;
17 was there any survey conducted in the barios of
18 the city of New York, in regard to whether
19 people would willingly want to be fingerprinted?
20 SENATOR HOLLAND: No, sir. But,
21 again, I say I don't think the people in Harlem
22 or the barios or wherever are any different than
23 Onondaga or Rockland County.
2234
1 SENATOR WALDON: Senator -- Mr.
2 President, may I continue?
3 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
4 continues to yield, yes.
5 SENATOR WALDON: Thank you,
6 Senator. I beg to differ with you, but we'll
7 get to that momentarily. Were you in the
8 military, Senator?
9 SENATOR HOLLAND: In the United
10 States Marine Corps, Senator.
11 SENATOR WALDON: Did you
12 willingly go into the military?
13 SENATOR HOLLAND: I did when I
14 was a Senior in high school.
15 SENATOR WALDON: I also willingly
16 went into the military. I don't know if you're
17 aware of that, I joined for three years, I left
18 the corner of Patkin Avenue and Putnam and
19 Jefferson, those corners, and came back a man
20 three years later, but I wanted to be in the
21 military.
22 When I became a police officer, I
23 wanted to be a police officer. When I was a
2235
1 member of the postal department, I wanted to be
2 a member of the post office, and even beyond the
3 wildest imagination, when I became a member of
4 this Senate, I wanted to be a member of the
5 Senate. Might fool you, this information, but
6 it is true. But in each of those situations I
7 enlisted, and your term in the military it was
8 done willingly, voluntarily, it was something
9 that both you and I wanted.
10 People who are on welfare for the
11 most part, are they not women and children?
12 SENATOR HOLLAND: There are men,
13 women and children, Senator, yes.
14 SENATOR WALDON: But aren't the
15 bulk of them -- (talking over)
16 SENATOR HOLLAND: Let me go back
17 -- let me go back to the draft. There were
18 people who were drafted in the military who
19 fought on Iwo Jima, who may not have wanted to
20 go. Some of them even ran away, went to Canada,
21 you know some of those people. They're people
22 who didn't want to go; there were people who
23 were drafted to go to Inchon, Mecong Delta. They
2236
1 were drafted; they didn't want to go. They
2 didn't have to have their fingerprints taken,
3 but they did anyway. So everybody wasn't like
4 you and I, they did not want to go.
5 SENATOR WALDON: Thank God there
6 were those like you and I, because the country
7 still remains free and the flag still flies
8 high.
9 But getting back to the point I'm
10 trying to make, are you aware that we are now
11 beginning to duplicate the computer system in
12 New Jersey and New York with Social Security
13 numbers in order to identify those who may
14 perform fraud upon both the state of New Jersey
15 and the state of New York?
16 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes, sir, and
17 that -- that information has been available to
18 both states for years, and we haven't done it.
19 It took something like this 425 people from
20 Newark to bring it up. Yes, that's an excellent
21 idea, but you also know, Senator, that you can
22 go into the city of New York, probably any place
23 else and purchase a Social -- any illegal Social
2237
1 Security number for about $200, and that's how
2 these 115 women stole $45 million from the
3 system.
4 Fingerprints are different,
5 imaging is different. You take that with you
6 wherever you go. You don't need a card. You
7 don't need a Social Security number. You just
8 simply put it in the machine and the machine
9 says you were here before or you weren't.
10 SENATOR WALDON: Wouldn't the
11 Social Security number, computer capability, Mr.
12 President -- if I may continue.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Please
14 do.
15 SENATOR WALDON: -- do the same
16 thing with regard to the numbers?
17 SENATOR HOLLAND: I think it
18 would do a good job, Senator, if it was closely
19 managed and controlled, maybe not quite as good
20 but it would do a good job.
21 SENATOR WALDON: When one
22 retires, Senator Holland, how are your Social
23 Security checks determined in terms of amount
2238
1 and who they are sent to? Is it by your finger
2 print or is it by your Social Security number.
3 SENATOR HOLLAND: No, sir, but
4 that's done over a 40-month or 40-quarter period
5 or more, and they have time in that period to
6 check to find out if you are, in fact, who you
7 say you are. They don't when you come into the
8 office for 10 or 15 minutes.
9 SENATOR WALDON: If I may
10 continue, Mr. President.
11 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Please
12 do, Senator.
13 SENATOR WALDON: If tomorrow,
14 Senator Holland, you were to have some
15 revelatory experience which said you no longer
16 want to be in the Senate, but you want to go
17 into a different walk of life and you made a job
18 application, would you necessarily have to be
19 fingerprinted no matter what the job?
20 SENATOR HOLLAND: Would I
21 necessarily have to be finger -- I don't know.
22 SENATOR WALDON: But would you
23 necessarily have to give them your Social
2239
1 Security number?
2 SENATOR HOLLAND: Probably.
3 SENATOR WALDON: Without a doubt.
4 SENATOR HOLLAND: For a check,
5 paycheck, yes, you're right.
6 SENATOR WALDON: Absolutely. So
7 the determining factor as to where money goes
8 and where money comes in this country is a
9 Social Security number; is that something we can
10 agree on?
11 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes.
12 SENATOR WALDON: Now, for the
13 last time on this issue, Senator Holland, did
14 anyone conduct a survey, to your knowledge, in
15 Buffalo, the area that Arthur Eve serves, or in
16 the South Bronx, the area that Senator Espada
17 serves, or in Cambria Heights, Queens; St. Al
18 bans, Springfield Gardens, Laurelton, Rochedale
19 Village, Rosedale, Queens Village where I serve?
20 SENATOR HOLLAND: I'll give you
21 all of that, no.
22 SENATOR WALDON: Beg pardon?
23 SENATOR HOLLAND: I give you all
2240
1 of that, no, Senator. But, on the other hand,
2 it's a $24 billion Medicaid and welfare budget
3 and the DSS says, if we implement a system
4 statewide for only $10 million of a $63 billion
5 budget, we can potentially save $100 million the
6 first year. You telling me that you don't want
7 to invest $10 million to save a hundred -
8 potentially save $100 million?
9 SENATOR WALDON: Well, Senator, I
10 would -
11 SENATOR HOLLAND: And not hurt
12 the people who really need assistance.
13 SENATOR WALDON: Well, even
14 though I was asking the questions, I will
15 respond to your question.
16 SENATOR HOLLAND: O.K., I'm
17 sorry, go ahead.
18 SENATOR WALDON: We are a
19 collegial body, and I understand the need to be
20 cooperative.
21 One, I question the savings.
22 Two, I question the rationale when people will
23 be stuck for life with the stigmata of being
2241
1 fingerprinted because they are in a situation
2 they do not wish to be in and they are forced to
3 be fingerprinted as the means of achieving
4 sufficient food for their children, sufficient
5 clothing for their children and even a place for
6 their children to lie down at night. I really
7 don't understand the need to stick them with
8 that stigmata.
9 If I may, Mr. President, on the
10 bill, and I thank you very kindly.
11 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
12 Waldon on the bill.
13 SENATOR WALDON: Mr. President,
14 my colleagues, Senator Holland and I have
15 debated this issue before, and we are at
16 variance this year as we were last year.
17 Senator Holland most graciously came to my
18 district on another matter, and we went all over
19 Queens and Brooklyn, gathering information that
20 would help he and I in our deliberations here.
21 Unfortunately, no valid survey
22 has been conducted in the state in regard to
23 home relief recipients or other people who come
2242
1 to the public dole and are in need to determine
2 their mind set. Do they really voluntarily give
3 their fingerprints?
4 I would like to say this, that in
5 the African American community and the Caribbean
6 American community and the Latino American
7 communities that I represent, and if the Senator
8 wishes to question me I will yield to his
9 questions -
10 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Mr. President.
11 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
12 Nozzolio, why do you rise?
13 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Will the
14 Senator yield?
15 SENATOR WALDON: Certainly.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The
17 Senator yields.
18 SENATOR WALDON: I can't hear,
19 Mr. President. I'm sorry. It's not Senator
20 Nozzolio; he speaks very clearly and very loudly
21 but I can't hear with the cacaphony in the
22 background.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Can you
2243
1 hear now?
2 SENATOR WALDON: Yes.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
4 Nozzolio.
5 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Thank you, Mr.
6 President.
7 Senator, are you suggesting that
8 you would volunteer in order to provide adequate
9 data that you are asking this house to have
10 relative -- relative to the communities in New
11 York City, are you suggesting, Senator, that
12 your community should be a volunteer to have a
13 pilot program to examine this before accepting
14 this proposal?
15 SENATOR WALDON: I have no
16 reservations about that, Senator. I think any
17 way that we can gather valid data is a way that
18 we, as a legislative body, should go. Let me
19 remind you that my district might not
20 necessarily be a good pilot project because
21 there are many homes there which cost $500,000
22 and in the area of Cambria Heights, Rosedale,
23 Springfield Gardens, the average house costs
2244
1 about $250,000.
2 To conduct a valid survey, you
3 would have to go to the South Jamaica district
4 which I no longer serve, although it's in my
5 Assembly District and Congressional District,
6 and go out to the Rockaways, but I would say
7 that the people in my area trust me sufficiently
8 that, if I suggest to them that we have a valid
9 survey which would help the people of the state
10 of New York and this legislative body in its
11 deliberations, that we should have it, they
12 would submit to it.
13 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Senator, if
14 you would continue to yield.
15 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
16 Waldon continue to yield? He does.
17 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Thank you. If
18 we make this applicable to the entire borough,
19 if not the entire city, and if that's the case
20 then, yeah, not make it applicable to the entire
21 state because that's what we're suggesting.
22 SENATOR WALDON: I would have no
23 reservations about that if it were cost
2245
1 effective and I have no reservations about any
2 survey which is fair and equitable which does
3 not single out a certain people, which does not
4 stigmatize a certain people and which, when the
5 results are collated, gives a valid
6 determination as a result of the data
7 gathering.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
9 Waldon, you still have the floor.
10 SENATOR WALDON: Thank you, Mr.
11 President and thank you, Senator Nozzolio, for
12 your questions.
13 I believe that the stigma placed
14 upon people who are forced to be fingerprinted
15 is perhaps beyond the feeling level of many of
16 my colleagues. Simply because I have been black
17 all my life, I have lived and worked in these
18 communities all of my life. I can recall my
19 experiences as the Deputy Commissioner of Human
20 Rights where the subleties of discrimination
21 ruined lives, ruined people in a psychological
22 sense, but perhaps more importantly and validly,
23 my recollection is as a young police officer
2246
1 when I saw people put through the trials and
2 tribulations of racism in this state, not always
3 was the case being that every action that I
4 viewed, and I'm not talking about police actions
5 necessarily, was racism but I can tell you, my
6 brothers and sisters in spirit and in fact, that
7 there are people who tremble in their boots when
8 they have to submit to a fingerprint, not
9 because they've done something wrong but because
10 the history of racism in this country has caused
11 them to know that to be fingerprinted is to be
12 the same as someone who is a criminal and to
13 have that kind of name to accompany them for the
14 rest of their lives.
15 I think we can do it better. I
16 think we can do it with the computerization
17 capability that we have today and just the
18 utilization of Social Security numbers. Also,
19 if the projections were valid, meaning if it
20 were a survey even upstate that actually found
21 people who were fraudulently defrauding the
22 state of New York, I might be inclined to go
23 along with it. But I believe the data shared
2247
1 here today was somewhat skewed, that it was not
2 valid in terms of the money that would actually
3 be saved, and last year you may remember,
4 Senator Holland, I had great disagreement with
5 you regarding the data from Los Angeles. It was
6 not, from my awareness of the information I
7 received, valid and I say the same thing is
8 existent today.
9 I don't know why we have a need
10 to punish a mother who happens to be in a
11 difficult situation and her children by finger
12 printing them. I think we can do it better. I
13 believe that, as a state, we're better than
14 that. I don't see the need to fingerprint
15 people because like when I was a police officer
16 and I willingly locked up many people, I was a
17 very active cop for those who did the wrong
18 things, but their fingerprints and their mug
19 shots remain forever, and this little finger
20 print of a mother on welfare trying to take care
21 of her children will remain with her forever,
22 and I think we can do better than that.
23 Thank you, Mr. President.
2248
1 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
2 Holland.
3 SENATOR HOLLAND: You know that
4 this is confidential and only within this
5 system, not to be shared with anybody else. You
6 know that?
7 SENATOR WALDON: Senator, I read
8 the information on the bill, and I do know that
9 there are fingerprints of a person only when
10 you've committed a crime and to law enforcement
11 agencies is supposedly confidential, and yet
12 everybody has access to them. If this country
13 were fair in that regard, it wouldn't be a
14 problem, but historically it has been unfair.
15 Thank you, Mr. President.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The Chair
17 recognizes Senator Libous.
18 SENATOR LIBOUS: Thank you, Mr.
19 President.
20 I rise to support Senator
21 Holland's effort today and would wish to talk a
22 little bit about this issue because I think
23 Senator Holland is on the right track and for
2249
1 the life of me, I can't understand why, when we
2 have a program that is actually going to cut
3 down on fraud, that a social program where we're
4 trying to help people cannot be implemented in
5 this state.
6 You know, the statistics are
7 there, and I respect the fact that Senator
8 Waldon has some question with the various
9 statistics but there are statistics and proof
10 that we can talk within our Social Services
11 Department now, and they talk about fraud. Let
12 me just cite a couple to you.
13 You know, they tell you stories
14 of how an individual just recently had a picture
15 on an identification card and used that person's
16 same name and was receiving benefits from two or
17 three different outlets in New York City and
18 they still kept the same picture on the card,
19 but they changed the name each time they went
20 in, and the system continued to produce
21 benefits. If finger imaging -- and I stress
22 finger imaging -- was in place, finger imaging
23 would have prevented that.
2250
1 There's the case where the woman
2 several years ago, there were several women who
3 actually, I believe, took us to the tune of
4 about $7 million who were actually coming up and
5 had different types of Social Security numbers,
6 so the Social Security number system, although
7 we use it for everything in our state and in our
8 country, is not fool-proof.
9 I believe the fingerprinting
10 would be much more fool-proof because I think it
11 is much more difficult to duplicate one's
12 fingerprints, and the whole concept of finger
13 printing, I think people just are relating to
14 the -- to the ink blotter and putting your thumb
15 on an ink blotter and putting that print on a
16 piece of paper.
17 This is electronic imaging. This
18 is a scan, no different than what they do in a
19 grocery store when the package comes through and
20 they put the electronic scanner over it. It is
21 just hard for me to understand that, while we're
22 trying to develop a system, where they're trying
23 to help people and in many cases some of these
2251
1 people cannot help themselves, that if we can
2 save money, as Senator Holland is talking about
3 of up to $100 million, why we don't do it,
4 because why should we allow those who are
5 committing fraudulent acts and committing fraud
6 to continue to do it in our system?
7 The taxpayers of this state work
8 very hard, the working people work very hard,
9 put dollars into the coffers. They pay the
10 taxes that are imposed upon them in this state
11 and all they're asking us to do is lookit, if we
12 have to have social service programs, and we do
13 and I support many of them, then let's make sure
14 those who are cheating the system are taken off
15 of the system. I don't think that's an unfair
16 request. I don't think that's an unfair request
17 at all.
18 I agree with Senator Waldon when
19 he says that many of these people did not choose
20 to be in the situation, but I also disagree when
21 I believe that some of those people choose to be
22 in a situation they'd just as soon be on public
23 assistance and defraud the system and cheat the
2252
1 system and those are the people we want to go
2 after. I don't want to go after an individual
3 who needs public assistance to feed his or her
4 family, that needs public assistance to take
5 care of the children, but I do want to go after
6 the person who is cheating the government and is
7 taking additional supplemental aid out of those
8 pockets of the people who need it and deserve
9 it.
10 This is the real issue here.
11 We're going after frauds. We're going after
12 people who cheat the system. That's the issue.
13 Now, my children were fingerprinted when they
14 were in first and second grade because they said
15 that this would be a good way, God forbid, in
16 case anything ever happened to them kidnapping
17 or abduction, that they could track them down,
18 that they would have some assistance in finding
19 them.
20 We did it. We didn't worry about
21 it. We didn't question it. We knew that those
22 fingerprints would be kept confidential. Again,
23 I strongly disagree with that whole concept. I
2253
1 don't think it's degrading to be fingerprinted.
2 I don't see the problem in it. And again it's
3 electronic imaging. It's an electronic scan
4 that is literally going to keep those people
5 from coming back who are cheating our system.
6 That's the real issue here, and I
7 would just want to conclude my comments by
8 saying that this is something that I know the
9 majority of the people of this state want. I
10 know that this house has worked very hard and
11 passed it last year and hopefully will do it
12 again today, and I only wish that the Assembly
13 would at least put the bill on the floor so that
14 it could be discussed because the real issue
15 here is going after fraud. It's not taking
16 benefits away from people who need it.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: For the
18 members' information, the Chair is keeping a
19 list. There is currently seven Senators who
20 have requested to speak. The list is as
21 follows: Senator DeFrancisco, Senators Padavan,
22 Nozzolio, Galiber, Gonzalez, Smith and
23 Leichter.
2254
1 Senator DeFrancisco.
2 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: Thank you,
3 Mr. President.
4 The debate on this bill is much
5 the same as it was last year, and there appears
6 to be an attempt to make it sound like the
7 people on this side of the aisle are somewhat
8 mean-spirited. The poor, the women, children,
9 those who don't have the ability to stand on
10 their own and they need some support from the
11 community, are the targets of this bill.
12 You know, nothing can be further
13 from the truth. There is simply no way that
14 this state can continue to fund the social
15 services programs with the escalating costs that
16 have been occurring over the past several
17 years. Just four years ago, 27 to 28 percent of
18 every dollar spent in the state of New York was
19 spent on social services. This year some four
20 years later, it's 38 percent, approaching 40
21 percent. If that continues without something -
22 without something occurring that's effective,
23 those women and children that we are all
2255
1 concerned about simply are going to have to get
2 less benefits, less assistance and, quite
3 frankly, less people will be eligible because
4 there's only so many dollars.
5 That being the case, we are also
6 concerned about those other needs in the state
7 at that same time, education went from 27 to 28
8 percent in those four years down to 20 percent,
9 education spending in this state, and all of us
10 have the education communities coming to us and
11 demanding more funds so that we can resolve the
12 problem on the front end by education rather
13 than on the back end by providing support for
14 the uneducated.
15 There simply are insufficient
16 funds, so if we are truly concerned about those
17 who are truly in need, we've got to protect
18 those assets that we have and it's as simple as
19 that. I'm not going to say that taking an image
20 off a finger of someone, a photograph that's
21 used in the scanner system is not an impingement
22 on someone's rights. Some people may feel it's
23 wrong, some people may be offended. Some people
2256
1 may, in some way, feel that this is just not the
2 right way that a civilized society should
3 operate.
4 Well, everyone has their opinions
5 on everything, but in every one of these situa
6 tions, it's always the question of balancing,
7 balancing what we gain by it against what we
8 lost by it, and I think the balance is clearly
9 on the side of this process, a finger image, not
10 a fingerprint, to protect the monies that are
11 there to fund those who are truly in need.
12 It's the best system that we can
13 derive so far, and I think it's a system that
14 should go statewide. Being from one of the
15 counties that have had the experimental system
16 in place now, I can state with certainty that
17 those people in Department of Social Services
18 want this to continue; in fact, I've been called
19 many times asking what if the statewide bill
20 doesn't run. Are we going to be able to
21 continue our pilot program next year? We have
22 to know. We're saving money. You at the state
23 won't take over all of our funding of these
2257
1 programs. Therefore, we've got to know because
2 we're losing it in our counties, and I assure
3 them that some form for Onondaga County would
4 take place, and I would certainly hope that the
5 same would be true throughout the state.
6 The momentum is building. The
7 Governor is even talking about it this year.
8 The Comptroller, a cross-section of people that
9 maybe are starting to jell towards the thought
10 that the benefits outweigh whatever of detriment
11 there might be in this particular program.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
13 Gold, why do you rise?
14 SENATOR GOLD: I just wanted to
15 know if the gentleman would yield to a question.
16 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: Yes.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
18 yields.
19 SENATOR GOLD: Senator, just one
20 comment or question really. Crime is a problem
21 in this state. Everybody acknowledges that, and
22 don't you think it might help us dealing with
23 crime in general if we had a fingerprint bank
2258
1 that encompassed everybody in the state and
2 might help in the investigative processes?
3 Would you be opposed to fingerprinting every
4 citizen? That way, I'm sure the good citizens,
5 the innocent people certainly wouldn't care
6 about giving up their fingerprints if it helped
7 the general issue. But would you support
8 fingerprinting every citizen if we had that bill
9 available?
10 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: Well, if a
11 bill was on the floor for that particular issue
12 I would need to see the wording of it, study it
13 and make a decision on it. The issue in this
14 particular case is whether we are going to
15 support this particular proposal.
16 First, fingerprinting everyone
17 wouldn't offend me, wouldn't offend my family to
18 have their fingerprints taken. I had them taken
19 when I went into the military. I was one of
20 those patriotic individuals such as Senator
21 Waldon and Senator Holland that volunteered and,
22 believe me, it hasn't changed my life at all
23 and, if that were proven by studies like we've
2259
1 had in this particular case that this is an
2 effective deterrent, I would consider it, but
3 since it hasn't been placed in a bill form,
4 since it hasn't been studied carefully, I can't
5 give you a definitive answer.
6 SENATOR GOLD: Will you yield to
7 just one more question?
8 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: Sure.
9 SENATOR GOLD: Will you consider
10 sponsoring or co-sponsoring a bill that would
11 require everyone in the state to be finger
12 printed?
13 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: I would
14 support any bill that would support a situation
15 where law enforcement officials would be
16 benefited and we could cut the crime rate. Now,
17 whether I would support that bill I'd have to
18 see the exact wording of the bill, I'd have to
19 study the bill and then I'd give you an exact
20 answer on that like any other bill.
21 And may I ask you a question,
22 Senator Gold; would you yield?
23 SENATOR GOLD: No.
2260
1 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
2 DeFrancisco has the floor.
3 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: O.K. I'll
4 wait until he has the floor.
5 So, in conclusion, I would
6 strongly urge all of us to vote in a bipartisan
7 manner so that there will be sufficient funds
8 for those truly in need, not only in public
9 assistance but also in the other programs that
10 all of us want to fund in this state and support
11 this finger imaging bill statewide.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The Chair
13 recognizes Senator Padavan.
14 SENATOR PADAVAN: Thank you, Mr.
15 President.
16 Late last year or during calendar
17 year 1993, the Cities Committee undertook an
18 initiative involving immigration. Our primary
19 goal was to determine the economic impact on the
20 state, city of New York and its political sub
21 divisions, particularly the city of New York,
22 with regard to this issue. Much of that time
23 centered about four major categories, one of
2261
1 which involved social services.
2 During the course of our work, we
3 conducted a number of hearings and on one
4 particular day we had the benefit of the
5 presence of the Welfare Inspector General, Mr.
6 Elmer Toro, who came before our committee to
7 talk about immigration and its impact on the
8 social services system. His testimony largely
9 dealt with illegal immigration, and I would like
10 to share with the members of this body some of
11 the specific points and conclusions reached by
12 this man whose responsibility is wholly and
13 entirely to deal with welfare fraud. I can't
14 nor would I take the time to read all of what he
15 had to say, but again I'd like to share with you
16 certain parts which I think are pertinent to our
17 discussion this afternoon.
18 It is very, very simple to obtain
19 American documentation, an I.D., thereby facili
20 tating entry into our welfare system. Welfare
21 applicants are seldom investigated. The system
22 is not set up to do this. There was a recent
23 case, Mr. Toro tells us, and I think Senator
2262
1 Holland referred to this, in New York City. 112
2 people were indicted on a major $45 million
3 fraud here in New York City. I believe that up
4 to now 77 have been arrested. All of them were
5 foreign-born. Five of them were illegal aliens,
6 and here's the part I want you to pay attention
7 to. They had in their possession all fraudulent
8 identifications, Social Security cards,
9 licenses, birth certificates, and so on, all of
10 them.
11 So I think the case is made very
12 concisely here that what Senator Holland and
13 others are telling us is that we have a
14 significant problem in the city of New York and
15 other parts of the state where you can get any
16 document you want and, according to the Welfare
17 Inspector General, tap into our social services
18 system without any effort.
19 Now, regard to the specific
20 issue, and again Mr. Toro talked about, I quote,
21 "They're entitled to welfare, Medicaid, so on.
22 A person is home free because most of the time
23 the intake person is not really qualified to
2263
1 read that documentation and to tell whether that
2 person should be investigated and, of course, we
3 don't have the investigative bodies in place.
4 "Last year," and here is the
5 part that I think is particularly pertinent,
6 "through the efforts of the Senate, we received
7 what is called finger imaging, a permanent
8 identification system, and we're in the process
9 of implementing that. We must be able to have a
10 system in place that most applicants -- elimin
11 ating the very, very obvious -- should be
12 investigated because what happens is they can go
13 to Bronx County today, they can go to Rockland
14 County, to Nassau -- Nassau-Suffolk the next day
15 and open up three different cases by just
16 putting a deviation of the name, the spelling or
17 just changing one digit in a Social Security
18 system. If we had fingerprinting in place, I
19 believe that would eliminate that almost
20 entirely."
21 Now, again, I repeat, this is
22 input from a state office, from an appointee who
23 does a job that we put him in place to do and
2264
1 these are his conclusive observations. INS
2 tells us there are a half a million illegal
3 immigrants in New York State, 80 percent of them
4 in the city of New York, and the Inspector
5 General is telling us, citing just one case,
6 that all of them have fraudulent documents from
7 A to Z and all of them tapped into the system
8 with ease and that finger imaging would, I
9 quote, "entirely eliminate that problem."
10 It seems to me that faced with
11 that kind of input and all the other things that
12 Senator Holland has worked so hard to generate,
13 the reports from other jurisdictions, that we
14 have no choice but to do this, because if we
15 don't, we deny all of the people of the state,
16 those who legitimately are in need of public
17 assistance, our educational system, all of the
18 various areas which we now at this point in time
19 are struggling to respond to with limited
20 resources, we have an obligation, I think, to
21 see that illegal aliens and others are not
22 ripping us off, ripping off the taxpayers and
23 taking those funds and using them in a fashion
2265
1 that we do not wish them to be used for.
2 Thank you, Mr. President.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
4 Mendez.
5 SENATOR MENDEZ: I was wondering
6 if he would yield for a question.
7 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Will you?
8 Would you yield to Senator Mendez?
9 SENATOR PADAVAN: Yes.
10 SENATOR MENDEZ: Senator Padavan,
11 you mentioned that there are 500,000 immigrants
12 in -
13 SENATOR PADAVAN: Illegal
14 immigrants.
15 SENATOR MENDEZ: -- New York
16 City.
17 SENATOR PADAVAN: New York
18 State.
19 SENATOR MENDEZ: In New York
20 State, and 80 percent of these illegal aliens
21 are in the city of New York. You had also
22 mentioned that there were, in the case that you
23 mentioned there were about a hundred and -- a
2266
1 hundred and -- or so illegal aliens, so that the
2 percentage -- wouldn't you say that the
3 percentage of illegal aliens in this instance in
4 the city of New York as compared to the total of
5 80 percent of $500,000 is very small, wouldn't
6 you say?
7 SENATOR PADAVAN: Senator, no, I
8 don't. I mean we have a city of roughly seven
9 and a half million people and by -- and again
10 that information was provided to our committee
11 by the Immigration & Naturalization Service, as
12 a very conservative estimate. There are other
13 estimates that far exceed 500,000, go even
14 beyond that, but take the very conservative
15 estimate and if 400,000 of them are in the city
16 of New York, which is roughly four out of five,
17 80 percent, out of a city population of seven
18 and a half million, I would say that's a
19 significant number.
20 SENATOR MENDEZ: No, but,
21 Senator -
22 SENATOR PADAVAN: Now, but what
23 Mr. Toro -- just to answer your question fully,
2267
1 Senator, what Mr. Toro referred to was 112 that
2 were caught, but the instructive part of what he
3 provided here was that they all had fraudulent
4 documents, Social Security cards, birth
5 certificates. You may have read in the paper
6 just last month where they arrested nine
7 individuals in Queens who had a factory in a
8 house where they were churning out all of these
9 documents, the printing operation, selling them
10 for hundreds of dollars to individuals who were
11 using them for a variety of reasons, including
12 social service applications.
13 SENATOR MENDEZ: But, Senator,
14 the one I'm referring to is, if there are 120 or
15 so illegal immigrants who were caught with
16 fraudulent papers and who have abused the
17 welfare system, 129 from 500,000, that is a
18 small percentage.
19 SENATOR PADAVAN: No, Senator, I
20 have to correct you. You're wrong.
21 SENATOR MENDEZ: That is a -
22 SENATOR GALIBER: Point of order,
23 Mr. President. Point of order, Mr. President.
2268
1 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
2 Galiber, why do you rise?
3 SENATOR GALIBER: I'd like to
4 hear the debate, but if the question is asked
5 and the person not given the opportunity to
6 answer it and vice versa, without interruptions,
7 we're missing a very important part of this
8 debate.
9 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The point
10 is well taken, Senator Mendez.
11 Senator Mendez, would you run
12 your questions and answers through the Chair,
13 please?
14 SENATOR MENDEZ: Yes.
15 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
16 Padavan continues to yield.
17 SENATOR MENDEZ: Yes. The
18 question is a very simple one. Now, you can
19 answer it yes or no. The question is, would you
20 say that 129 people who are illegal aliens and
21 were caught with false documents, 129 out of
22 500,000, wouldn't you say that that is a small
23 percentage?
2269
1 SENATOR PADAVAN: Senator, I
2 tried to correct your question because I can't
3 answer it in the manner which you presented it.
4 I -- I presented -- shared with you the
5 testimony from Mr. Toro. There were 112 people
6 arrested. Five of them were illegal aliens,
7 O.K. 112 people arrested for fraudulent
8 applications for social services totalling $45
9 million. Five of them were illegal aliens, but
10 what Mr. Toro tells us is that the illegal
11 aliens had in their possession fraudulent
12 documents.
13 You see, the point of the matter
14 here is that of the 112, all but five were not
15 illegal aliens, they were residents, but they
16 were participating in fraud. That's what
17 Senator Holland was sharing with you, and I
18 pointed out based on his input that five of them
19 were illegal aliens, but the significant part of
20 that testimony is that they all were able to
21 obtain fraudulent documents from Social Security
22 cards to birth certificates without any trouble
23 at all.
2270
1 SENATOR MENDEZ: Thank you.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
3 Mendez, are you asking Senator Padavan to
4 continue to yield?
5 SENATOR MENDEZ: No, he didn't
6 satisfy my question but anyhow, I think that the
7 reason why -
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
9 Mendez, there are other people -
10 SENATOR MENDEZ: Mr. President.
11 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: -- who
12 are on the list. If you'd like to speak, I'd
13 like to put you on the list.
14 SENATOR MENDEZ: Just let me
15 mention something: The reason that I asked that
16 question is that there is a rebirth of
17 nativistic feelings, and illegal aliens as well
18 as immigrants of any -- of any country are being
19 viewed upon in the wrong light, so that we shall
20 speak about that at a later point.
21 But nevertheless the percentage
22 of those illegal aliens that are using the
23 system in the wrong way, 112 out of 500 illegal
2271
1 aliens, that is a very small percentage.
2 Thank you, Mr. President.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Thank
4 you, Senator Mendez.
5 The Chair recognizes Senator
6 Nozzolio.
7 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Thank you, Mr.
8 President.
9 On the bill. Mr. President, my
10 colleagues, I rise in support of Senator
11 Holland's bill to establish a finger imaging
12 program in an effort to ferret out welfare fraud
13 and abuse.
14 What this bill does not do should
15 be emphasized at the beginning. This bill is
16 not meant in any way, shape or form to be
17 punitive. It's not meant to stigmatize. It's
18 not meant to punish. It's not meant to
19 embarrass.
20 What it is meant to do is to
21 bring a handle on a welfare system that has
22 already been discussed during the course of this
23 debate as being far out of whack. What this
2272
1 bill does do is focus on one single program of
2 welfare, and that is the home relief program, a
3 program that New York still maintains, the
4 taxpayers of this state still subsidize, a
5 program that most states have already
6 eliminated.
7 Of those states that do have home
8 relief, all of the states but New York have put
9 a limit on the home relief program. Connecticut
10 says a nine-month limit. Minnesota, New Jersey
11 and Ohio say six-month limits. Pennsylvania
12 says three-month limits. New York says you can
13 be on home relief for your entire life.
14 We're focusing on one single
15 aspect of the welfare system, one program, home
16 relief, and asking each of our colleagues to
17 come together and support a program that will
18 provide proper identification, will be able to
19 ferret out those who are defrauding the system,
20 who, even under our very liberal standards,
21 allow fraud and abuse to take place. Senator
22 Holland mentioned those, mentioned those with
23 eloquence, in detail.
2273
1 I'm not going to amplify that,
2 but I would like to talk about the issue of
3 fingerprinting, an issue that many who oppose
4 finger imaging for those participating in
5 welfare, stated that it stigmatizes and
6 punishes.
7 I think the facts state the
8 contrary. I counted up in our laws of the state
9 of New York, there are approximately a hundred
10 incidents in our own laws that require finger
11 printing for identification purposes, at least a
12 hundred statutes in our body of law that require
13 people participating in various activities of
14 this state to participate in.
15 First, in order to obtain a
16 license or a benefit or a profession, they are
17 to participate first after identifying
18 themselves through finger imaging. I think it
19 is extremely telling that, in one section of our
20 law we actually require those mothers and new
21 born infants who supply identification, section
22 10 (c) of the New York Code 405.21 requires the
23 footprints of every child born in this state to
2274
1 be supplanted on the birth certificate in order
2 to identify.
3 There's no stigma in that use of
4 identification, and there's no punitive intent.
5 It simply is an identification tool. Hundreds
6 of other elements resulting in over a million
7 people each year being voluntarily finger
8 printed in this state. We need to remove the
9 political stigma that those who don't want any
10 change in the welfare system are trying to
11 establish.
12 I believe you're well
13 intentioned. I believe you're sincere in your
14 characterizations, in your own mind, but I don't
15 believe you're doing any service to the
16 taxpayers or to those who are receiving welfare
17 because those who are receiving welfare should
18 be doing it only under honest procedure. If
19 those who are receiving welfare are doing so
20 dishonestly, I would hope that you would be the
21 first to tell them to get off the welfare roll
22 so that those who are on the roll can ensure
23 that they'll receive continued benefit.
2275
1 Ladies and gentlemen of this
2 house, we need desperately to reform the welfare
3 system. There are many, many ways to reform
4 that system. There are many proposals that
5 Senator Holland, as chairman of the Social
6 Services Committee, has recommended of. We will
7 debate those throughout the course of this year
8 in an effort to bridle the costs of the largest
9 single growing program in this state budget from
10 26 percent of the state resources five short
11 years ago to 42 percent of our state resources
12 today -- an unconscionable growth, one that you
13 all must recognize needs reform. A way to stop
14 some reforms -- to stop some abuses in one part
15 of the program is to support Senator Holland's
16 bill, a bill that takes a good step in the right
17 direction of ferreting out fraud and abuse. Not
18 to punish, not to stigmatize but to kick out
19 those who are trying to cheat the system.
20 How could you vote against this
21 bill? How could you favor cheaters taking
22 welfare money away from those who truly need it
23 and truly deserve it?
2276
1 Mr. President, that's why I
2 support this measure and urge my colleagues to
3 do the same.
4 Thank you very much.
5 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Ladies
6 and gentlemen, the chair continues to have a
7 list. We're an hour in the debate. There are
8 seven people remaining who have asked to speak:
9 Senators Galiber, Gonzalez, Leichter, Hoffmann,
10 Wright, Smith and Rath.
11 The Chair recognizes Senator
12 Galiber.
13 SENATOR GALIBER: Thank you, Mr.
14 President.
15 I listened very carefully to this
16 debate last year and certainly this year, and I
17 think there is a sense of need for reform. I
18 don't think anyone within the sound of my voice
19 would say no, we don't want reform. We've been
20 trying to do this for some time, and those who
21 would suggest that those on this side are
22 liberals -- and I'm not quite sure what that
23 means any more, these labels that we talk about
2277
1 -- but let me step back in history just a bit
2 and talk about an occasion, Senator Holland,
3 when I worked with W. T. Smith when we had the
4 temporary commission on welfare -- social
5 services/welfare because it wasn't even social
6 service in those days.
7 We went out to a place called
8 Lansing, Michigan, and they had a computerized
9 system out there where everyone had a number for
10 whatever the services may be, food, whatever,
11 and third-party beneficiaries were paid in 90
12 days. People were not cheating because they had
13 an identification number. They called it into a
14 central area so that fraud, little as it is or
15 great as it may have been, was avoided.
16 We came back and then Governor
17 Rockefeller was the governor of this great state
18 of ours, and we suggested that he look into the
19 possibility of computerizing, and those of us on
20 this side from the city of New York, persons,
21 volunteered and suggested -- not volunteered,
22 suggested to the Governor that to use New York
23 City as an example, and the Governor agreed and
2278
1 somewhere along the line, interestingly enough,
2 I have an old expression if it's only 57 people
3 in the world that live long enough, they're
4 going to come back, and he had a contract or an
5 agreement with a fellow named Perot in Texas -
6 same guy -- he was going to set up the
7 computerized system in the city of New York or
8 state of New York. From here to there something
9 happened, and it was canceled out.
10 We are willing to reform. What
11 has suggested -- been suggested here and in this
12 report that you have, we don't have enough time,
13 we don't have enough time. We've had this
14 experiment and there's been recommendations made
15 to extend it for another period of time. That
16 seems reasonable. This was back in 1973 when we
17 wanted, in the city of New York to go on
18 computers.
19 So to suggest to some of us that
20 we are soft on cheats, soft on fraud, soft on
21 those persons who will beat the system, not so,
22 not so. We are as concerned, Senator, as you
23 are.
2279
1 It's the state of mind that's
2 involved here, and that's why we can't come to
3 any agreement because it's a state of mind. Why
4 do you want to do this? In your heart's heart
5 are you talking about the few cheats that you
6 found if they were cheats?
7 Can we speculate and say, because
8 people don't show up, that they, if they had
9 showed up, there would be cheats? And the
10 answer is no.
11 Can we suggest that some believe
12 in America, believe in the Constitution, believe
13 in basic -- basic rights and are offended -
14 offended by asking them to be fingerprinted?
15 There are an awful lot of people in that
16 category, Senator, and the recommendations that
17 you have read them as I have, suggested that we
18 need some more time on this, and I know of your
19 sincerity, and I don't have to massage you to
20 get my point across because I know where you're
21 coming from.
22 The point of the matter is that
23 we do not have a valid test. We've had some
2280
1 experiences in California; you've got the
2 reports, you know them better than I do. I read
3 them all; you know them because it's part of
4 your study, and you've done a great job in
5 studying them, with little results.
6 We're talking about people who,
7 because of the unemployment, may no longer need
8 it and because they don't show up doesn't mean
9 that they're cheats. It means that the indexes
10 have changed, the employment rates have changed,
11 so there's that possibility.
12 Senator, it's a state of mind,
13 and we can't change that. We can change
14 practices, but not states of mind.
15 We know of a horrible, horrible,
16 horrible historical occasion in Germany during a
17 horrible, horrible, horrible regime where they
18 put yellow arm bands on people to identify them
19 and they suggested this is not too bad, it's
20 only for this particular purpose. History has
21 recorded what happened in those instances.
22 We have wrapped, as I have said,
23 yellow ribbons around trees here in America to
2281
1 bring our youngsters back home who fought so
2 valiantly for this great country of ours. State
3 of mind, Senator.
4 What are you really after? Not
5 you personally. What are you trying to get at?
6 You save six hundred-and-some-odd thousand
7 dollars or six hundred-and-some-odd thousand,
8 six hundred-and-some-odd thousand dollars in an
9 experimental program. That's merely a member
10 item, merely a member item.
11 SENATOR SMITH: I'll take it.
12 SENATOR GALIBER: For someone on
13 your side of the aisle. And I would quickly
14 take it if I had the opportunity on my side of
15 the aisle.
16 Why do we want to go through this
17 by suggesting because we think we have saved six
18 hundred-and-some-odd dollars -- six hundred-and
19 some-odd thousand dollars, that those persons
20 are cheats and we're going to save $100
21 million? $100 million. The state of mind,
22 Senator, what I'm making reference to.
23 Senator Moynihan and I are very
2282
1 good friends, and he got into some difficulty
2 some years ago along with another fellow that
3 wrote MELTING POT and talked about "benign
4 neglect", not about all those persons who came
5 to this great country, came to this great
6 country and merged into a system without the
7 technology.
8 Now, we see we have technology
9 and somebody came over with false credentials.
10 Do I justify it? The answer is no, but the
11 melting pot became part of people coming into
12 this country and the cheats that we're talking
13 about are few in number. We want them as bad as
14 you do. But let me tell you what you do.
15 You do a political thing on us.
16 You suggest now that if you don't vote for my
17 piece of legislation which hasn't been truly
18 tested, has not been truly tested, that you are
19 in favor of those persons who are cheating the
20 system. All of a sudden, I hear from your side
21 of the aisle that you want to increase the
22 benefits of those persons who have not been -
23 their benefits have not been increased for a
2283
1 good six or seven or eight years.
2 Concerned about it. These
3 cheats, this six hundred-and-some-odd thousand
4 dollars that we've allegedly saved, you know how
5 far that would go to increase the benefits of
6 those persons who are on social service? That's
7 where you're coming from, Senator, with this,
8 your side of the aisle, and I'm suggesting to
9 you that this certainly is not the way to go.
10 We certainly have to go in the
11 right direction. Senator Moynihan, as I
12 mentioned before, in 1993 or '94, is not as bad
13 a guy as he used to be as far as his position
14 was concerned. Some understood, some
15 misunderstood wherever he's coming from.
16 The fact of the matter is that we
17 have been saying for a long, long time, that we
18 need this kind of reform. But they're
19 recommending here, give it another year. You'll
20 be back next year, I'm sure of that. Give it
21 another year. Follow the recommendations.
22 Someone said, well, fingerprinting, what
23 difference does it make? Want to fingerprint us
2284
1 all? I agree with you so let's all get
2 fingerprinted.
3 Now, the state of mind, but once
4 there's hesitation in saying "let me read the
5 bill." Don't read the bill, all of us be
6 fingerprinted. No objection. It's a state of
7 mind. What is your intent?
8 And that's the problem. I have a
9 wife, Senator, and we've been married 47 years.
10 She may be listening, and may not be listening.
11 She said, "I'm a provider, I worked 30 years in
12 the social service department, fingerprint me.
13 What's wrong with them being fingerprinted?" We
14 have a difference of opinion as to how we should
15 approach this. State of mind.
16 You want the cheats caught, yes.
17 I want them? Yes. Do we want them? Yes. No
18 question about it. We object to the process.
19 We object to not being fair. We object to you
20 not giving an opportunity to see whether it
21 really works. This thing can wind up the cost
22 administratively, can cost more ultimately than
23 the benefits.
2285
1 Now, if you want to create some
2 jobs, and we're saying, Well, we can't build any
3 more prisons, but if you want to create some
4 jobs, let's pass this piece of legislation.
5 Let's fingerprint. Let's look for the cheats.
6 Let's look to go back to the old system. Let's
7 go into people's houses, look and see whether
8 there's bedroom slippers underneath the bed.
9 Let's go through that whole process again.
10 We got rid of it. It's a simple
11 proposition, Senator. All we have to do is go
12 by the recommendations and study it. One more
13 time, note ad infinitum, another occasion. One
14 more six months, one more year. No problem. No
15 one is hurt by it as far as the fingerprinting
16 is concerned.
17 I agree with Senator Gold, say
18 let's all get fingerprinted, let's all get
19 fingerprinted. No problem, but to fingerprint
20 again is dangerous -- dangerous when you start
21 isolating, and someone said, Well, it will only
22 be used for social service purposes.
23 That's not so, Senator. That's
2286
1 your intent. That's what you believe, but
2 that's not so. Any fingerprinting, any
3 technology attached to it, goes in a central
4 file in Washington, never to be returned; never,
5 never to be returned, whatever the case may be.
6 So, Senator, I'm voting against
7 this bill and I'm saddened somewhat because the
8 inference being that if we vote against this
9 bill that somehow we go back to our districts
10 and they'll say you're soft on the social
11 service people.
12 I haven't got that concern. I
13 haven't got a courage badge with oak leaf
14 clusters. I just believe in certain things as
15 you do, and the state of mind here, I suspect,
16 is not the proper state of mind. It's not the
17 yellow ribbon wrapped around a tree, but it's a
18 yellow ribbon wrapped around a country for
19 identification purposes.
20 That, in my judgment, is the
21 state of mind. I think there's another way to
22 do it, and I think this is a bad piece of
23 legislation, well intended, but we can go back
2287
1 and study it for another term as was
2 recommended.
3 Senator, will you yield for just
4 one question?
5 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
6 Holland, do you yield?
7 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The
9 Senator does.
10 SENATOR GALIBER: Waiting for
11 direction.
12 SENATOR HOLLAND: O.K.
13 SENATOR GALIBER: Senator, I've
14 been advised that we were going to ask for
15 a -
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
17 Holland, he's reconsidered his thought.
18 SENATOR GOLD: Mr. President.
19 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
21 Present.
22 SENATOR PRESENT: Can I request
23 of the Minority, we're going to recess for one
2288
1 half hour until 2:35. I would ask that the
2 Chair retain the list, if Senator Galiber would
3 like to be first on the list when we start.
4 SENATOR GALIBER: I wouldn't have
5 it any other way.
6 SENATOR GOLD: Mr. President.
7 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
8 Gold, do you have an announcement?
9 SENATOR GOLD: Yes. I just want
10 to be very candid. I mean, Senator Present,
11 everybody will agree not to quote me on this,
12 has been an absolute delight to work with but up
13 to -- and I don't want to mislead anybody, we're
14 breaking for the purpose of a conference. I
15 don't know how long it will be. I hope we can
16 be within the half hour, but I don't want it
17 coming back at me that I somehow committed the
18 Minority Leader to a half hour.
19 So I appreciate that we're
20 breaking for the conference, Senator. We'll do
21 it as quickly as we probably can.
22 SENATOR PRESENT: All right.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The
2289
1 Senate stands in recess for one half hour.
2 SENATOR PRESENT: Until 2:35.
3 (Whereupon at 2:06 p.m., the
4 Senate recessed.)
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
2290
1 ... At 4: 31 p.m....
2 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The Chair
3 recognizes Senator Present.
4 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President,
5 I would like to announce we're about to
6 reconvene the session.
7 Senator Galiber will have the
8 floor, and I would urge all members to head
9 towards the chambers so we can get started.
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The
11 Senate will come to order.
12 Senator Present.
13 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President,
14 we recessed at about 2:05, started out for a
15 half hour. We extended that now a considerable
16 length of time, so I would suggest we start the
17 session and take up the bill we left in the
18 middle of a debate and read off the names who
19 you have on your list in the order that you've
20 taken them, and any additional ones that may
21 have been added.
22 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Thank
23 you, Senator Present.
2291
1 The Chair would would remind the
2 members that we are currently debating Calendar
3 Number 233. That debate started at 12:50, and
4 was adjourned temporarily at 2:05 so we're an
5 hour and 15 minutes into the debate.
6 Senator, when we recessed,
7 Senator Galiber was on the floor. I would call
8 on Senator Galiber but I don't see him here. We
9 still have one, two, three, four, five, six,
10 seven people on the list that the Chair is
11 running.
12 The next would be Senator
13 Gonzalez. Not seeing Senator Gonzalez, Senator
14 Smith. Senator Smith not being here, Senator
15 Hoffmann.
16 SENATOR HOFFMANN: Thank you, Mr.
17 President.
18 I'm happy to rise in support of
19 Calendar 233, and I'd like to take the
20 opportunity to just share briefly with my
21 colleagues the perception as one central New
22 Yorker.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
2292
1 Hoffmann.
2 SENATOR HOFFMANN: I'm sorry.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: May I
4 interrupt you, please?
5 SENATOR PRESENT: May I interrupt
6 you, Senator, just for a moment?
7 Mr. President, may I have the
8 last section of this bill read and allow Senator
9 Goodman to vote?
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The Clerk
11 will read the last section.
12 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
13 act shall take effect immediately.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
15 roll.
16 (The Secretary called the roll. )
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
18 Goodman.
19 SENATOR GOODMAN: Aye.
20 SENATOR PRESENT: Withdraw the
21 roll call and continue with the debate.
22 Thank you.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The roll
2293
1 call is withdrawn.
2 Senator Hoffmann, thank you for
3 your indulgence.
4 SENATOR HOFFMANN: You're very
5 welcome, Senator Present.
6 One of the two counties involved
7 in the experiment of the finger imaging project
8 is Onondaga County which I represent, along with
9 Senator DeFrancisco, and I would just like to
10 share with my colleagues the very positive
11 reaction that the people in Onondaga County who
12 were involved with this project experienced.
13 There were a large number of
14 people who chose not to become re-certified for
15 their benefits rather than go through finger
16 imaging. Although, there can be no clear
17 explanation in each one of the instances why the
18 individuals chose to voluntarily withdraw from a
19 program, the assumption has been made by
20 Onondaga County officials that some individuals
21 who were involved in fraudulent activities
22 recognized that the finger imaging would have
23 very definitely exposed them, and that rather
2294
1 than go through the process of exposure and the
2 subsequent criminal charges, they simply faded
3 quietly off into the distance of the night.
4 I think this shows an advantage
5 for several reasons: First of all, it
6 eliminated those fraudulent individuals from the
7 welfare roll in this instance. It also
8 alleviated the need for a protracted
9 investigation of welfare fraud. Again, a
10 considerable savings in tax dollars for the
11 people of Onondaga County. We're used to
12 reading in the newspapers and seeing on
13 television about once a year or once every 18
14 months, a big herding up of people who are
15 arrested for various types of welfare fraud.
16 There's usually a dollar figure associated with
17 the amount of money that has been allegedly
18 stolen from the taxpayers through this
19 procedure, and umpteen individuals are herded
20 through the criminal justice system. Their
21 pictures are flashed across the 6:00 o'clock
22 news in the evening and eventually some of them
23 are sentenced to jail or are subject to other
2295
1 criminal sanctions before their being -- before
2 they are ultimately removed from their number of
3 welfare programs.
4 All of this costs the taxpayers
5 money. All of it is a drain on the whole legal
6 process. All of it wastes resources which could
7 be better applied in other areas in terms of
8 investigations, in terms of criminal justice
9 and, obviously in terms of the welfare process
10 itself.
11 Now, I know that many people have
12 mistakenly used the phrase "fingerprinting"
13 instead of finger imaging, and I would like to
14 make my position absolutely clear where
15 fingerprinting is concerned. I believe I owe
16 that to the people of the 48th District and for
17 the enefit of a few of my colleagues who may
18 still be debating in their own minds how they
19 would like to pursue this issue.
20 I have a very strong position
21 against the use of fingerprints as a routine way
22 of maintaining track of American citizens or any
23 sub-category of American citizens for the
2296
1 purpose of making those citizens suspects in a
2 criminal activity, and I emphasize the use of
3 the word "routine" because I know that there are
4 several instances where people have been
5 fingerprinted for a specific purpose, gun
6 registrations being one, the draft being
7 another, now the volunteer military service, of
8 course, having replaced it, but I am very
9 concerned whenever I hear about a large category
10 of individuals simply being routinely
11 fingerprinted so that they can be regarded as
12 suspects without ever having been in any way
13 linked to a criminal activity.
14 For that reason, I have voted
15 against a number of measures when they were
16 brought to this floor, such as fingerprinting
17 school bus attendants. I think it's an
18 imposition to small towns in my district which
19 hire school bus attendants, many of them senior
20 citizens, housewives, people who are temporarily
21 unemployed from other positions or people who
22 have the ability to do a part-time position in
23 addition to their other full-time work. I think
2297
1 it's very unfair to people who apply for a job
2 to be routinely cast in the light of suspects in
3 a criminal activity and subjected to
4 fingerprinting on having their fingerprints go
5 into a major computer operation, hooked in
6 possibly nationally, where they will routinely
7 be screened every time a crime is committed and
8 fingerprints are scanned, and they, in effect,
9 are suspects. I don't think that that's right.
10 I do not believe in stigmatizing
11 any category of people and charging them of a
12 criminal activity or suspecting them of a
13 criminal activity for no just cause.
14 The situation with the finger
15 imaging situation is very different. The finger
16 imaging, first of all, is non-invasive. It has
17 none of the stigma of the five prints on your
18 right hand, five prints on your left hand in ink
19 on paper. It has none of the historic
20 association with criminal fingerprinting. It is
21 no ink. It is a simple scan. The analogy has
22 been made with the bar code scanner in the
23 grocery store, and I think that's very
2298
1 applicable. There is nothing that leaves a
2 person who has been through finger imaging with
3 any reminder on his or her anatomy that they
4 have been subjected to something that we
5 associate with criminal activity, namely, the
6 old-fashioned ink style fingerprinting, nor are
7 those fingerprints part of a national data bank
8 which would then be used in scanning for
9 suspects for crime.
10 The purpose of the finger imaging
11 is limited to the protection of the welfare
12 system to prevent fraud in the welfare system,
13 and thereby to ensure that the maximum amount of
14 resources available in this state to people who
15 are in need go to those people in need and not
16 be allowed to be diverted by fraudulent
17 activities to people who are not in need.
18 I don't think that this is a
19 tremendous infringement on the rights of people
20 who collect welfare in one form or another in
21 New York State, and I can tell you that in
22 Onondaga County we have not had any widespread
23 opposition to the experiment. Most people are
2299
1 proud of the fact that we have now demonstrated
2 a savings in Onondaga County of approximately
3 $500,000 during six months of the experiment
4 with an additional uncalculable amount in
5 avoided costs because of people who chose not to
6 apply for welfare benefits in Onondaga County
7 knowing that they would have been detected for
8 being fraudulent.
9 I read a number of years ago an
10 interesting book called "King of the Gypsies",
11 and it described how in the 1970s or the '60s, a
12 particularly creative family that knew a great
13 deal about criminal activity, had managed to
14 utilize the welfare system to a multi-million
15 dollar benefit by having members of that family
16 simultaneously apply for welfare benefits in
17 several different cities and in several
18 different states, and with great detail, the
19 whole procedure was described whereby women,
20 usually young women with several children, would
21 apply simultaneously in Boston and New York, in
22 one or more boroughs, in Philadelphia, Trenton,
23 Newark, other cities, and then they would fly
2300
1 around to these cities, sometimes on first class
2 seats, they would fly around on a designated
3 date for the re-certification process and during
4 that time, they would go through whatever was
5 routinely required of them to maintain their
6 certification, and they would collect hundreds
7 of thousands of dollars a month in illegal
8 welfare benefits.
9 Now, granted, those cases may be
10 few and far between, but when they occur, they
11 sometimes occur with that degree of violation of
12 the system, and the commensurate violation of
13 needs of the people who should truly be getting
14 welfare benefits.
15 I believe that if we can continue
16 to protect a diminishing source of funds in this
17 state -- our pot of money is not bottomless and
18 it is being pressed in all directions at all
19 times -- our responsibility is to those people
20 who truly need welfare benefits in this state.
21 If we can protect our ability to meet those
22 needs by preventing people from taking
23 fraudulent advantage of that system, I believe
2301
1 we should do that, and since we are able to do
2 that very clearly without violating the rights
3 of welfare recipients by not doing anything that
4 casts any criminal aspersion on them, that I
5 believe we have that obligation. To do any less
6 than that, becomes an unfair statement to the
7 taxpayers of this state. We cannot continue
8 taxing people of this state and not take
9 reasonable and prudent actions to protect our
10 ability to serve the needs of those who truly
11 need it and to prevent other people from taking
12 unfair advantage of the system.
13 Thank you, Mr. President.
14 SENATOR GOLD: Mr. President.
15 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Yes,
16 Senator Gold, why do you rise?
17 SENATOR GOLD: Mr. President, we
18 had broken for a conference, and while I
19 understand and was here, Senator Present
20 indicated it would be a half hour. I indicated
21 at that point just as respectfully, that I could
22 not guarantee the half hour.
23 Now, this matter is a -
2302
1 obviously has budget implications. It's part of
2 the budget process. We are in the middle of
3 that process, so I'm told. I read in the
4 newspapers that last Friday, there was a big
5 announcement that the budgets were -- were
6 completed and I expected to come up here Tuesday
7 smiling, vote and go home and do some business
8 in the district, but apparently it's going on
9 and -- right now, and I don't know whether
10 there's any urgency to push forward with this
11 debate, but I can say quite accurately, that the
12 conference that my -- that the Democrats were
13 involved in deals specifically with this issue.
14 We are not asking you to wait upon us because we
15 are discussing other matters, and I would
16 respectfully ask my distinguished colleague from
17 Jamestown to once again put us at recess so we
18 can conclude this conference.
19 It is specifically dealing with
20 this issue. I would not like to have to, you
21 know, engage in other tactics because we -- I
22 think Senator Present and I have been able to
23 operate on a level that makes me proud to work
2303
1 with him, but, I mean, I cannot be in a position
2 where I have to be out here holding the fort
3 down while other things are happening within my
4 conference.
5 Now, we do not control or
6 regulate the Majority conferences, and I'm
7 asking for the courtesy to be able to conclude
8 what we are doing in our conference with regard
9 to this issue.
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
11 Present.
12 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President,
13 I have just been advised that somebody higher
14 than either of us have reached an agreement so
15 we'll stand at ease for another ten minutes.
16 SENATOR GOLD: I want the record
17 to indicate that nothing has changed. Senator
18 Present is still the ultimate gentleman.
19 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The
20 record will so reflect, Senator Gold. Thank you
21 for placing it there.
22 The Senate will stand at ease for
23 ten minutes until five minutes of 5:00.
2304
1 (Whereupon, the Senate stood at
2 ease. )
3 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
4 Present.
5 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President,
6 a few moments ago, approximately ten minutes
7 ago, I announced that the leaders had agreed for
8 another ten-minute recess. The ten minutes has
9 elapsed, so we will start no later than five
10 minutes after five.
11 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Stand in
12 recess momentarily.
13 (Whereupon, the Senate stood at
14 ease. )
15 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The
16 Senate will come to order. The Chair will
17 remind the members that we're continuing the
18 debate on Calendar Number 233. We have spent
19 about an hour and 25 minutes of time on debate.
20 There are currently three members who have
21 indicated a desire to speak, Senator Leichter
22 and Senator Rath at this point, so I would call
23 -- the Chair recognizes Senator Leichter.
2305
1 SENATOR LEICHTER: Well,
2 considering the late hour and knowing that my
3 colleagues' names who succeed me -
4 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
5 Leichter, you waive. Senator Galiber, why do
6 you rise?
7 SENATOR GALIBER: I thought I had
8 something until all this confusion about the -
9 I was in the middle of something when someone
10 called me some place else.
11 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: You did,
12 Senator Galiber. If Senator Leichter would like
13 to yield the floor to you again, I'll recognize
14 you.
15 SENATOR LEICHTER: Yes.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
17 Galiber to pick up the debate where he left
18 off.
19 SENATOR GALIBER: Mr. President,
20 I was just prepared to ask a question, and I
21 think it's all been said. One question for
22 Senator Holland and then we can go back.
23 Will Senator Holland yield to a
2306
1 question?
2 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
3 Holland, will you yield?
4 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes.
5 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
6 does.
7 SENATOR GALIBER: I think on page
8 3, at the top, it starts off, I'd guess at the
9 bottom of page 2 on this question of sanctions
10 imposed unless the local service -- social
11 service district has verified the results of
12 automated fingerprint identification system by
13 means of a manual, I'm not sure, conducted by a
14 person who is qualified to perform that
15 identification.
16 Was that taken out for some
17 reason or the other?
18 SENATOR HOLLAND: I don't know
19 the answer to the question, Senator. Can you
20 rephrase it?
21 SENATOR GALIBER: In other words,
22 there was some verification. They printed them
23 and then we had to verify it and then there was
2307
1 some, I guess, structure set up for that verifi
2 cation, and there was a cost factor. I'm not
3 concerned about the cost factor as much as you
4 were checking for identification purposes
5 inasmuch as it wasn't a perfect identification
6 system, and someone indicated that portion was
7 taken out of the bill.
8 SENATOR HOLLAND: I don't know.
9 Let me find out for you.
10 SENATOR GALIBER: All right,
11 that's fine. Thank you, Mr. President.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
13 Leichter.
14 SENATOR LEICHTER: Mr. President,
15 having heard everything that I ever wanted to
16 know about this bill and more, I'm going to
17 yield in the hope that others will agree with me
18 that the hour is late. Thank you.
19 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
20 Leichter passes. Senator Wright.
21 SENATOR WRIGHT: Mr. President, I
22 rise in support of finger imaging. I think the
23 issue is restoring the integrity and credibility
2308
1 of the social service system that we're talking
2 about this afternoon.
3 Clearly, the people of this state
4 have lost confidence in our ability to maintain
5 the credibility of that system. Each day and
6 each time you see new headlines, you see stories
7 documenting the fraud and abuse, it's simply
8 greater documentation that this system does not
9 work, and I think that's well recognized not
10 only in this state and throughout the state, but
11 is being recognized nationally in terms of the
12 call for reform of the social service system.
13 New York State ought to be in the
14 lead of doing the same thing because unfortun
15 ately, as these cases of fraud and abuse
16 continue to be identified, continue to be
17 documented, they end up calling into question
18 the legitimate programs that we're delivering in
19 this state, the individuals who have legitimate
20 needs, and I think that's become the area,
21 unfortunately, that we're losing our focus on.
22 We need to focus on people and
23 individuals with legitimate needs and make sure
2309
1 that we're rendering credible cost-effective
2 programs to meet those needs.
3 Finger imaging is a way of
4 maintaining the credibility and restoring the
5 credibility that the taxpayers who are paying
6 the bills demand of the system. We're now at a
7 point that the chief auditor, if you will, the
8 Comptroller of this state, has acknowledged that
9 the fraud is so rampant that there are
10 additional controls needed. The same applies in
11 terms of the Inspector General.
12 In my conversations with local
13 officials, and we've taken the opportunity to
14 sit down with our local elected officials, be
15 they elected or be they the individuals who are
16 appointed to administer the program, and all of
17 them indicate there is a need, a compelling need
18 for greater integrity in the system.
19 We need to restore the confidence
20 of the people who are paying the bills for
21 this. Finger imaging is but one step in that
22 right direction. As a result, I call on all of
23 my colleagues this afternoon to take a step
2310
1 forward to reform the social services program
2 and support finger imaging.
3 Thank you, Mr. President.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The Chair
5 recognizes Senator Rath.
6 SENATOR RATH: Yes, Mr. Chairman.
7 I rise also in support of the finger imaging
8 bill. The debate this afternoon has gone much
9 as we could have anticipated and all of the
10 points are extraordinarily valid, particularly
11 the point that we want to have the dollars
12 available for the people who truly do need
13 public assistance.
14 But take a walk with me, if you
15 will, back through the calendar pages several
16 months ago. Two national magazines had some
17 messages across the front pages of those
18 magazines about New York State, MONEY Magazine
19 first, Forbes Magazine second. None of us liked
20 the messages that came across the front pages of
21 those magazines, and now I ask you, my
22 colleagues: Can we afford to send another
23 message across the pages of any of the
2311
1 publications in this country when we are looking
2 so hard to restore New York State to the status
3 that it once held? Can we afford to send a
4 message that we are willing to allow fraud in a
5 New York State system of public welfare?
6 38 percent of the state's -- 38
7 percent of the state budget is used for this
8 system, 38 percent of our $62 billion. A
9 conservative estimate says that the savings
10 could be between one and a half and two and a
11 half billion dollars. That's a lot of money.
12 Public assistance clients, it's
13 been testified all afternoon, the numbers have
14 been pointed out, 93 percent of them don't
15 care. They think it's fine. Well, if they
16 don't care if they have finger imaging, I don't
17 know why we would be as concerned.
18 Public assistance clients have
19 always had to identify themselves one way or the
20 other. They have a contract with the state of
21 New York and with the taxpayers. The contract
22 is, we help them out while things aren't going
23 so well for them in their life. Everyone has a
2312
1 contract with the state of New York for a
2 driver's license. We have a photograph taken
3 when we have a driver's license submitted to us
4 and we have a contract. We're responsible for
5 the laws of the state of New York when we drive
6 the roads of the state of New York, and I would
7 submit to you that the people that we give
8 dollars to when things aren't going well in
9 their personal and private lives, that for a
10 contract with them to have a finger -- a picture
11 of their finger, that is not something that's
12 unnecessarily intrusive.
13 I think we need to have this good
14 faith contract. I think the message needs to be
15 not a message that will shatter the public
16 confidence in the state of New York regarding
17 our willingness to continue a circumstance that
18 has proven to be fraudulent, but the message
19 needs to be New York means business. We mean
20 business not only for business, but we mean
21 business for the people who need our help. We
22 legitimize their needs and we take the fraud out
23 and save billions of dollars.
2313
1 Thank you.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Is there
3 any other member wishing to speak on this
4 particular matter before Senator Holland closes?
5 Senator Smith, Senator Montgomery do.
6 Senator Smith.
7 SENATOR SMITH: Thank you, Mr.
8 President.
9 Would Senator Holland yield to a
10 few questions?
11 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
12 Holland, do you yield? The Senator does.
13 SENATOR SMITH: Thank you. Could
14 you give me a profile of a home relief
15 recipient?
16 SENATOR HOLLAND: I don't think
17 so, Senator. Could be, usually, they're without
18 children, could be male or female, could be -
19 could be in good physical shape, might not be,
20 might have an abuse problem, might not.
21 SENATOR SMITH: Well, would you
22 say that we know that they're without children?
23 SENATOR HOLLAND: Most of them
2314
1 are, the vast majority.
2 SENATOR SMITH: But they are
3 receiving aid for themselves and not for the
4 children because for children it's AFDC, am I
5 correct?
6 SENATOR HOLLAND: Correct, yes.
7 SENATOR SMITH: Thank you. Could
8 you give me an estimate of how many -- approxi
9 mately how many home relief recipients there are
10 through the state of -- throughout the state of
11 New York?
12 SENATOR HOLLAND: From a report
13 dated November 1993, 310,864.
14 SENATOR SMITH: How many AFDC
15 clients do we have throughout the state?
16 SENATOR HOLLAND: Approximately
17 80 percent of those home relief recipients are
18 from the city of New York, also.
19 SENATOR SMITH: You said
20 approximately 88 percent of the home relief
21 recipients are from the city of New York, but I
22 asked how many AFDC recipients do we have in the
23 state of New York?
2315
1 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yeah, I'm
2 sorry. I was concentrating. Ask me once more.
3 SENATOR SMITH: How many home -
4 AFDC recipients do we have in the state of New
5 York?
6 SENATOR HOLLAND: Approximately
7 1.5, 1.2 million.
8 SENATOR SMITH: So this is a very
9 small percentage of the public assistance rolls?
10 SENATOR HOLLAND: It's about a
11 quarter.
12 SENATOR SMITH: I'm -- I
13 apologize for not being in the chamber earlier
14 when you were giving some of your statistics, so
15 I'd like to know when they did the original
16 survey, how many recipients were there initially
17 in each of the counties of home relief?
18 SENATOR HOLLAND: In both
19 counties, Senator, there were 4772.
20 SENATOR SMITH: 4742?
21 SENATOR HOLLAND: And '-72.
22 SENATOR SMITH: Thank you. Could
23 you tell me at the end of this little survey or
2316
1 whatever you want to call it, or test, how many
2 did we have on record?
3 SENATOR HOLLAND: Do you know the
4 numbers, so I don't have to research them?
5 SENATOR SMITH: No, I don't have
6 any of this. I wouldn't ask you a question if I
7 had the answer.
8 SENATOR HOLLAND: The only thing
9 I can tell you, Senator, is the report says that
10 146 cases were closed in Onondaga.
11 SENATOR SMITH: 146 out of how
12 many?
13 SENATOR HOLLAND: 41-something,
14 41-something.
15 SENATOR SMITH: You know that
16 percentage?
17 SENATOR HOLLAND: 4772, four
18 percent.
19 SENATOR SMITH: So that's also a
20 small percentage?
21 SENATOR HOLLAND: It's smaller
22 than 25 percent, a lot smaller.
23 SENATOR SMITH: Thank you very
2317
1 much, Senator.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
3 Montgomery.
4 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Thank you,
5 Mr. President.
6 I just want to make a very brief
7 statement. I think that this bill that Senator
8 Holland has introduced is certainly his answer
9 in an attempt to address what is a major crisis,
10 I think, for us as it relates to services to
11 poor people, and that is the perception that
12 there is fraud and the actuality that there is
13 fraud, and consequently the loss of support for
14 those programs, and so we want to rebuild that
15 support with the public, especially the tax
16 paying public, and I support that. I'm in total
17 agreement with it and, in fact, one of my heroes
18 in government is the DSS Investigator Kuriansky
19 because every time he exposes and closes a
20 Medicaid mill in my district, I am extremely
21 pleased, and it's especially pleasing when I see
22 the figures that are saved for taxpayers, and my
23 assumption is that when we save money in that
2318
1 way we can expect that the return will be that
2 those dollars can go, hopefully, for legitimate
3 services, especially health care, quality health
4 care for people in my district.
5 So, Senator Holland, I certainly
6 compliment you along those lines. I do,
7 however, worry that we mislabel this particular
8 attempt as welfare reform, and I would not want
9 my constituents to think that I voted for
10 legislation under the misimpression that I'm
11 doing welfare reform, because I think that
12 welfare reform has to be related to employment.
13 We can not reform a welfare
14 system in this state or nation unless there is
15 an employment reform in the sense that we have
16 to be engaged in generating jobs that people who
17 are currently on welfare can, in fact, access
18 and we need to include with welfare reform an
19 educational component. Access to education is
20 the avenue that will mean for many people who
21 are on welfare right now, it will mean for them
22 in four or five years or less that they can move
23 up and off of welfare permanently, and it means
2319
1 child care because the majority of people who
2 are on welfare have children, are parents of
3 children.
4 That is essentially for welfare
5 clientele, that we hopefully want to spend more
6 time looking at in terms of our response to
7 changing the system, improving it and, in fact,
8 moving people off of welfare permanently.
9 So I will, while I definitively
10 support an attempt -- any attempt to remove
11 fraud from the system because I think that it
12 hurts poor people more than anybody to have
13 service dollars misdirected and used fraud -
14 fraudulently or otherwise for things unrelated
15 to service, including real estate and a whole
16 host of other ways that we see social service
17 and health dollars siphoned off.
18 So I'm supporting this in
19 principle. I'm not going to vote for it because
20 I think that there is a larger statement that
21 needs to be made and we need to be very clear
22 about that statement, and that is we want to
23 empower people to get beyond the need for
2320
1 depending on the state for their existence.
2 It's demeaning. It's stigmatizing and in the
3 climate that we live in today in our state and
4 nation, it is politically incorrect to be on
5 welfare, and I more than anybody else have that
6 sense and that feeling for the people who are.
7 There may be a small percentage of people who do
8 not expect to move off, but most people, in
9 fact, do.
10 So, Senator Holland, I applaud
11 you. I understand what you're trying to do, but
12 I must say to you that it is very disappointing
13 and I certainly cannot support this body making
14 this statement in that small way which, in my
15 mind, undercuts what the overall intent is and
16 that is to move people from -- from dependence
17 permanently.
18 Thank you, Mr. President.
19 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The Chair
20 recognizes Senator Dollinger.
21 SENATOR DOLLINGER: Mr.
22 President, I'll be very brief in view of the
23 long debate that's already transpired and the
2321
1 number of comments which have been made, many of
2 which I agree with.
3 Just to offer a philosophical
4 view to my colleagues, when I went to law school
5 about a decade and a half ago, I can remember
6 those old discussions about a man's word is his
7 bond, and that lasted, I guess, for the most
8 part from probably 10,000 B.C. up until maybe
9 the mid-15th century, and then we all of a
10 sudden got enamored with signatures. We signed
11 documents with signatures and your signature
12 became your bond. And then for the last 35 or
13 40 years, your Social Security number became
14 your bond, the number that identified you. I
15 guess now we're moving into that age when finger
16 imaging and bar codes and scanners will identify
17 all of us at some time in the future, and I
18 think in many ways you see a sense of this is
19 that we long for that time long ago when a
20 signature or your word could be your bond when
21 you applied for welfare benefits as well. I
22 recognize that that time is gone.
23 I also recognize that this bill
2322
1 and the finger imaging that's encompassed in it
2 may have some purpose of discouraging people
3 from applying for welfare benefits. I regard
4 that as a real tragedy, but it also seems to me
5 it has some value based on the study that's been
6 done in Onondaga and Rockland County in
7 deterring fraud, and I agree that that's a
8 laudable purpose. When I voted against this
9 bill last year, I did so because I didn't think
10 it would deter fraud. I'm now convinced that
11 there's some minor value, some benefit that
12 could be gained by going to this system, but I
13 stand here to offer just two other
14 observations.
15 One is I'm really tired of
16 hearing the argument that we have to restore the
17 credibility or the integrity of programs that we
18 have for the poor. It's my view that those
19 programs for the poor are no more dotted with
20 fraud, frankly, than our programs for the
21 wealthy or income tax returns or S & L crises.
22 The concept of fraud is not something that is
23 solely confined to those who are poor, in
2323
1 poverty.
2 The credibility of this system,
3 in my judgment, the lack of credibility in this
4 system is only partly due to fraud. It's also
5 due to the fact that politicians, for the last
6 20 years, have been going around and saying, we
7 ought to beat up on poor people. We're going to
8 take -- we're going to say that the system
9 doesn't work, that it can't work, that the poor
10 are more distrustful than the rest of the
11 population, that the war between taxpayers and
12 the poor has been fanned by politicians for
13 political advantage. I think that that's
14 absolutely outrageous.
15 It also seems to me, and I
16 welcome the thoughts from the other side of the
17 aisle about the concept of welfare reform. I'd
18 simply point out that this side of the aisle has
19 been trying to reform a whole bunch of other
20 things that are desperately in need of reform
21 that we haven't taken a good look at in the last
22 20 years, things that we should reform right in
23 this chamber, right in the way we organize
2324
1 ourselves and the way we function.
2 My hope is that the wind of
3 reform that seems to blow so pervasively with
4 respect to the welfare reform will also be a
5 part of the wind of reform in this chamber as
6 well.
7 I'm convinced that this bill
8 accomplishes in some small way a reduction of
9 fraud and, for that reason, based on the fact
10 that the study demonstrates that there has been
11 a reduction in fraud, I'm going to change my
12 vote this year and vote in favor of this bill
13 but I also hope that the types of programs that
14 Senator Montgomery talked about, I hope that we
15 look at those programs, look at a broader way in
16 which we can deal with the poor and hopefully
17 allow the poor to do the one thing that we all
18 want, which is to rise into the middle class and
19 become a part of the American dream.
20 The solution lies in a
21 complicated way and not simply by asking them
22 for their fingerprint but giving them the
23 education, the character and the integrity as
2325
1 human beings so that they can become a part, a
2 true part of our society.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The Chair
4 recognizes Senator Markowitz.
5 SENATOR MARKOWITZ: Thank you.
6 Thank you very much.
7 First off, I want to compliment
8 Senator Montgomery. I believe Senator Holland
9 approached the issue the way that it ought to be
10 viewed, and that is that all of us from the most
11 liberal Democrat to the most conservative
12 Republican are all united in eliminating waste
13 and fraud, not only in public financing
14 programs, welfare programs but, frankly, in
15 every program in which state taxpayer dollars
16 are being used. None of us are in favor of
17 fraud and abuse.
18 Having said that, there are few
19 members of the state Senate that can actually
20 say that they lived on welfare. I can say I did
21 many years ago, not the 1990s for sure, but I
22 know, and I think, Senator Holland, one has to
23 be sensitive to the fact that people that are on
2326
1 welfare, by and large, the great majority of
2 them, don't do so voluntarily, don't do so
3 voluntarily, and for many, it's the end of the
4 road. Frankly, it's the end of the road.
5 Where we have failed in our
6 system is to not recognize that those that are
7 at the end of the road that we have an
8 obligation to bring them back, to give them
9 hope, to give them a chance to rebuild their
10 lives or build their lives for the first time so
11 that they can become fully productive members of
12 our society.
13 I would eagerly vote for a finger
14 imaging program if the Senate Majority would
15 come back to this chamber and also offer finger
16 imaging for food stamp providers, finger imaging
17 for Medicaid doctors and health delivery
18 providers, anywhere where the state monies are
19 being provided by the recipient and the
20 provider.
21 If finger imaging was done to
22 eliminate the fraud and to target in on tax
23 returns, especially on tax returns in those
2327
1 industries and corporations, health care, that
2 we know according to the state Tax Department
3 have a higher incidence of fraud and abuse, then
4 for some of us, we would be able to go back to
5 the districts we serve and be able to tell poor
6 people that we are not just isolating them for
7 finger imaging, but rather the state Legislature
8 is beginning a massive attempt at eliminating
9 fraud across the board.
10 I would eagerly want to vote a
11 bill like that, Senator Holland, I really really
12 would, and I'm hoping yet that a bill will come
13 to the chamber for us to support. Until that
14 time, until there's a bill that really balances
15 it out, I really am still constrained to have to
16 vote no on this not because we want to see fraud
17 continue, but rather because we want to see
18 fraud minimized and eliminated to the greatest
19 degree possible by all those that abuse it.
20 Thank you.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The Chair
22 recognizes Senator Gonzalez.
23 SENATOR GONZALEZ: Thank you, Mr.
2328
1 President.
2 I think that coming also from a
3 poor district and being poor, I think that as I
4 stand here before you today, that my Ph.D. is
5 poverty, hunger and desperation from the streets
6 of my district, and the one thing is that always
7 welfare recipients are the target of everything
8 when it comes down to the budget since I've been
9 here since '89. We've always had cuts and
10 always they're the targets of whatever it comes
11 down to money. I think that this bill, to me
12 right now, we're in a matter of negotiations,
13 the leadership is under negotiations. I find
14 this bill as a one-house bill.
15 There is language that should be
16 in this bill, language that pertains that if we
17 do say how do we make training programs or jobs
18 available with the money that we save for the
19 people that are on welfare, so that will be
20 welfare reform. So it needs a few more add-ons
21 to the bill so that it could be comprehensive
22 and we could call it a first step to welfare
23 reform and, in that vein, I don't have a problem
2329
1 with fingerprinting. I'd rather fingerprint for
2 jobs. I don't have a problem with finger
3 imaging, but I think that we have to do a little
4 bit more comprehensively, not just a patch
5 Band-Aid approach, and with that I will vote no
6 on this bill, but I will vote for a bill that
7 will have all the things that I have suggested
8 that comes with the balance, with the training
9 programs, for the jobs to get them off welfare
10 and make them work fair, and that's where I
11 would stand.
12 Thank you, Mr. President.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Is there
14 any other member wishing to speak on this bill
15 before Senator Holland closes? Hearing none,
16 the Chair recognizes Senator Holland.
17 SENATOR HOLLAND: Mr. President,
18 I just want to reiterate that there's no one, I
19 don't think, in this chamber certainly on this
20 side and the other side as well, I know, who
21 wants to take anything away from people who need
22 assistance. The clients are not even -- this is
23 not trying to take anything away from the
2330
1 clients. New York State has the most
2 progressive social services program, the most
3 expensive social services program in the nation
4 and there has been no discussion about taking
5 anything away from anybody except the crooks,
6 and that's what we're trying to do.
7 If we can get them off the rolls,
8 just the bad guys, not the people who need
9 assistance, we can take that hundred million
10 dollars or whatever it is, five million, a
11 hundred million, whatever it is, and give it
12 back to the taxpayers of this state and/or give
13 it to the clients if that's where you or we
14 think it should go.
15 I just want to tell you two more
16 things. First, I have a documentation
17 examination, Investigator's Guide to False
18 Documentation, put out by the Human Resources
19 Administration, Bureau of Fraud and
20 Investigation, the city of New York. First page
21 reads: People -- "many use false identification
22 for some of the following reasons: To conceal
23 their status as illegal aliens, to commit
2331
1 welfare fraud by making identity and/or
2 misrepresenting identity factors, to issue bad
3 checks, to hamper identification of law
4 enforcement agencies." Four issues: Welfare
5 fraud is number two. Then it goes on to to say
6 that "it is estimated by the permanent
7 subcommittee on investigations that the impact
8 of false identification on the United States
9 economy is $24 billion annually, and the state
10 of New York is one-twelfth of that
11 approximately."
12 We talked a little bit with
13 Senator Waldon about Social Security card
14 numbers. On the fourth page, they say, "the
15 Social Security card has become a widespread
16 means of identification in New York State. As
17 its use as an identifier has grown, so has the
18 opportunity for its misuse often to fraudulently
19 obtain unauthorized benefits. The social
20 service -- the Social Security card was never
21 intended to be an identification document," and
22 that's put out by the city of New York.
23 This is -- this is the opinion of
2332
1 Judge Jack Weinstein on the cases that we talked
2 about earlier, and I just want to read you a
3 little bit of it. He starts out with, "These
4 cases involve poor people, primarily women, from
5 the Dominican Republic who stole from the
6 federal government by using false names to open
7 fraudulent welfare cases. In its identification
8 the government uncovered some one thousand such
9 false cases." One thousand. Though each case
10 was identified individually and has its own file
11 number, the matter is properly considered as a
12 single event for the purposes of public policy.
13 So viewed, it is the largest criminal case in
14 terms of numbers of defendants ever brought and
15 processed in this district.
16 "The U. S. Attorney and his
17 staff as well as the city Department of
18 Investigations has done what they could to
19 encourage structural change within the state
20 institution that administers the stolen funds in
21 order to prevent further abuse. Nonetheless,
22 there is little indication that this effort has
23 ended the threat of welfare fraud in this city.
2333
1 The selection of roughly one hundred individual
2 wrongdoers for federal prosecution in a city
3 where, according to the 1990 census, over 13
4 percent of households received public assistance
5 from funds administered by city, state and
6 federal government, is a poor substitute for
7 meaningful reforms of the public institutions
8 that permitted the theft.
9 "The authorities in charge
10 implemented no adequate procedures by which
11 identities could be verified. False
12 identification documents such as birth
13 certificates were readily obtainable. The
14 government offices to which these fraudulent
15 papers were submitted did not even ascertain
16 whether a given Social Security number, in fact,
17 corresponded to a given name. Welfare
18 recipients can be readily fingerprinted by
19 automatic photographic methods to prevent the
20 use of false identities to open fraudulent cases
21 as is now done in Los Angeles."
22 I could go on and on. This is a
23 great opinion by Judge Weinstein. You should
2334
1 read it. Just let me say finally, we're not
2 trying to take anything away from poor people
3 who need assistance. We are trying to take the
4 thieves out of the system. This finger I.D.
5 will do that.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The clerk
7 will read the last section.
8 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
9 act shall take effect immediately.
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
11 roll.
12 SENATOR GOLD: Slow roll.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Slow roll
14 call has been requested. Are there five
15 Senators in agreement with this? There are.
16 Clerk will call the roll slowly.
17 THE SECRETARY: Senator Babbush.
18 SENATOR BABBUSH: No.
19 THE SECRETARY: Senator Bruno.
20 (There was no response. )
21 Senator Connor.
22 SENATOR CONNOR: No.
23 THE SECRETARY: Senator Cook.
2335
1 SENATOR COOK: Yes.
2 THE SECRETARY: Senator Daly.
3 SENATOR DALY: Yes.
4 THE SECRETARY: Senator
5 DeFrancisco.
6 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: Yes.
7 THE SECRETARY: Senator DiCarlo.
8 SENATOR DiCARLO: Yes.
9 THE SECRETARY: Senator
10 Dollinger.
11 SENATOR DOLLINGER: Yes.
12 THE SECRETARY: Senator Espada.
13 (There was no response. )
14 Senator Farley.
15 SENATOR FARLEY: Vote aye.
16 THE SECRETARY: Senator Galiber.
17 (There was no response. )
18 Senator Gold.
19 SENATOR GOLD: Mr. President,
20 have my name called.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
22 Gold to explain his vote.
23 SENATOR GOLD: Mr. President, I
2336
1 believe that there are a lot of legitimate
2 legislative issues that may or may not become
3 law but which are entitled to a forum. Where I
4 disagree with the Majority is the issue or the
5 manner in which you create a forum.
6 There is a committee system which
7 is really not used for anything but politics in
8 this house, where we could have that forum.
9 There are hearings we could use. When it came
10 to "three strikes you're out" debate a few weeks
11 ago, I indicated how it was incredible to me
12 that that issue was not receiving hearings or
13 some attention.
14 We broke today for a rather
15 substantial conference for this side of the
16 aisle, and it was a conference which indicated
17 to me something I already knew and that is that
18 people on this side of the aisle are very, very
19 serious about the issue of welfare reform for
20 many reasons, the least of which is not -- I get
21 that two double negatives -- that credibility
22 among the public is very important.
23 There are people in need in this
2337
1 state, and we should be helping them and not
2 making them the scapegoat, the enemy, the
3 strawman in every debate that comes up when it
4 comes to money. Unfortunately, that's what
5 happens. Rather than having an open forum on
6 what you do to help needy people in this state,
7 we have debates such as this.
8 Now, we are in the middle of a
9 budget process. We voted last week to take care
10 of state purposes and the next day after we went
11 home, I read in the newspapers that there was a
12 legislative agreement, so I said to my wife and
13 kids, I guess we're going to have an easy week
14 next week, I'll go up Tuesday morning, by noon
15 we'll be voting upon this agreed-upon package,
16 I'll see you for dinner Tuesday, and I'll be
17 back at work in my office at work on Wednesday.
18 What happened? All I heard since
19 I've been up here, that there's bickering over
20 this, but this one is not getting this piece of
21 this, but there was an agreement, but this one
22 has got to get a little bit of this, and the
23 answer is there is no agreement, there are no
2338
1 bills.
2 So why are we talking about this?
3 Why are we talking about this? I will tell you
4 that, if we have a budget which does as it's
5 supposed to do, first of all, give the $60
6 million slush fund back to the people and do
7 some other things, and that as part of that
8 process, we have reform, as part of that process
9 we have Medicaid take-over which is the real
10 issue here -- it's the real issue, and it will
11 help every one of the counties and towns and
12 cities throughout this state -- then I will tell
13 you that the concept of imaging I do not
14 necessarily find as offensive.
15 Matter of fact, a couple weeks
16 ago, we had a printing bill and to the eyebrow
17 raising of some of my colleagues, I voted for
18 that bill. I don't find that offensive as and
19 of itself, but what is offensive is in the
20 middle of a budget debate to spend hours picking
21 on the poorest people in our society and those
22 in the greatest need, because at some point
23 again, they will be the scapegoat of all the
2339
1 problems of this state.
2 So, Mr. Speaker, I am not going
3 to participate in that. It's unfair. I couldn't
4 look myself in the mirror tomorrow when I shave
5 and I'm not prepared to go to the doctor with
6 all the blood there would be if I don't look in
7 the mirror. So, Mr. President, I am voting no.
8 I tell you that, if this comes
9 back to us as part of a budget plan, a plan that
10 is really here now, with money for the city of
11 New York that is necessary for our Republican
12 mayor -- I don't say yours, I say our Republican
13 mayor -- and we take care of the needs of the
14 towns and counties in Medicaid take-over, and if
15 this is part of an intelligent program, I might
16 be able to support it, but I'm not getting
17 involved in the cheap nonsense politics of a
18 majority party putting out these bills that they
19 think are going to posture them through to some
20 election victory in November. It's not the way
21 to operate this city and the government.
22 I vote no.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
2340
1 Gold in the negative.
2 THE SECRETARY: Senator
3 Gonzalez.
4 SENATOR GONZALEZ: No.
5 THE SECRETARY: Senator Goodman
6 voting in the affirmative earlier today.
7 Senator Hannon.
8 SENATOR HANNON: Yes.
9 THE SECRETARY: Senator
10 Hoffmann.
11 SENATOR HOFFMANN: Explain my
12 vote.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
14 Hoffmann to explain her vote.
15 SENATOR HOFFMANN: The date on my
16 calendar says Wednesday, April 6th. The people
17 in my district realize that we were supposed to
18 have a budget in place on April 1st. Very
19 difficult to justify why we would have spent
20 this entire afternoon debating and voting on a
21 one-house bill when we obviously have much more
22 pressing business at hand.
23 I've not been involved in a
2341
1 single committee meeting today, Finance or any
2 of the other committees on which I sit, to
3 discuss substantive matters of concern to the
4 taxpayers of this state that deal with the
5 budget.
6 I'll be hearing from county
7 executives asking questions about the Medicaid
8 take-over. I'll be hearing from the mayors of
9 Syracuse and Rome asking about the enhancement
10 of revenue sharing. I will be hearing from
11 people asking about business tax cuts, all of
12 which they will have read something about in the
13 newspaper, and yet there are no open discussions
14 going on on any of these subjects in this
15 Capitol today.
16 I will vote for this measure. I
17 believe that it's an appropriate first step to
18 eliminating much welfare fraud. I don't think
19 it's invasive to the people who are in the
20 welfare system, because it is finger imaging,
21 not fingerprinting. I make that distinction
22 because I will continue to oppose measures which
23 screen large numbers of people and treat them as
2342
1 supposed criminals by demanding their
2 fingerprints at the time they apply for jobs or
3 their departments subject them to such
4 fingerprinting, and I mention specifically
5 school bus attendants which was a bill that has
6 come up in this house several times, and I
7 believe will probably come up in the future.
8 But I will vote on this one not because I like
9 the process that we're engaged in but because I
10 believe the issue has some merit.
11 I just wish I didn't have to be
12 embarrassed once again to go back to my district
13 and tell them how we have wasted our time and
14 squandered their money.
15 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
16 Hoffmann in the affirmative.
17 THE SECRETARY: Senator Holland.
18 SENATOR HOLLAND: Explain my
19 vote.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
21 Holland to explain his vote.
22 SENATOR HOLLAND: One thing
23 Senator Gold said there were no hearings and
2343
1 Social Services has held hearings all over the
2 state of New York including the city of New York
3 asking people what they think about finger
4 imaging and other Medicaid and welfare reforms.
5 The people believe this will save them money and
6 take the bad guys off the system. We have had
7 hearings.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: How do
9 you vote?
10 SENATOR HOLLAND: Yes.
11 SENATOR GOLD: Mr. President.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Why do
13 you rise, Senator Gold?
14 SENATOR GOLD: Mr. President, I
15 don't know what point I'm making, a point of
16 this or that, but I want the record clear that
17 whatever my comments were I did not mean any -
18 anything personal about Senator Holland who I
19 believe has a sincere interest in the issue and
20 may have done the work necessary.
21 I was talking about a budget
22 process and I just wanted that clear on the
23 record.
2344
1 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Thanks,
2 Senator Gold.
3 Continue the roll.
4 THE SECRETARY: Senator Johnson.
5 SENATOR JOHNSON: Aye.
6 THE SECRETARY: Senator Jones.
7 SENATOR JONES: Yes.
8 THE SECRETARY: Senator Kruger.
9 SENATOR KRUGER: Yes.
10 THE SECRETARY: Senator Kuhl.
11 SENATOR KUHL: Yes.
12 THE SECRETARY: Senator Lack.
13 SENATOR LACK: Aye.
14 THE SECRETARY: Senator Larkin.
15 SENATOR LARKIN: Explain my
16 vote.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
18 Larkin to explain his vote.
19 SENATOR LARKIN: For about the
20 past four and a half hours off and on we've been
21 debating this bill. It's a bill we talked about
22 last year. It's a bill that's been talked about
23 all over the state. Talked by the Governor,
2345
1 talked about by the mayor of the city of New
2 York, talked about by county executives across
3 the state.
4 Joe Holland has given us a lot of
5 leadership in this not to hurt anybody as it
6 seems some people on the other side of the aisle
7 want to carry this bill as, something to hurt
8 somebody. This bill is not carved out to hurt
9 anybody. This bill is to address an issue, and
10 the issue is to make sure that those individuals
11 who are to receive dollars in assistance are
12 truly eligible and have been validated.
13 Mr. Waldon said earlier some
14 hours ago that he talked about identification
15 and about the service. That's an excuse for
16 what we really want to be doing is addressing an
17 issue. I've heard every excuse here of why not
18 to do this bill today from last year's budget to
19 this year's budget to this good to that bad.
20 Why don't we stop fooling around
21 with it? It's an issue that will help us. It's
22 an issue that Commissioners of Social Services
23 want. It's an issue that people who are
2346
1 legitimate and who want to get public assistance
2 don't feel ashamed of. Some people have said,
3 you want to move people off AFDC. You will put
4 people off home relief. How will you put them
5 off unless they're ineligible?
6 It was already talked today about
7 the $45 million fraud in November 1992. That
8 fraud would not have occurred had we had finger
9 imaging. So I think what we ought to do is to
10 stop all of this bashing about when it really
11 means that some of us don't want to address the
12 issue and don't want to cooperate in helping us
13 streamline the public assistance issue and maybe
14 recapture dollars and ensure that the dollars
15 that we provide truly go to those in need and
16 not the greedy.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: How do
18 you vote, Senator Larkin?
19 SENATOR LARKIN: I vote yes.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
21 Larkin, yes. Continue the roll.
22 THE SECRETARY: Senator LaValle.
23 SENATOR LAVALLE: Aye.
2347
1 THE SECRETARY: Senator
2 Leichter.
3 SENATOR LEICHTER: No.
4 THE SECRETARY: Senator Levy.
5 SENATOR LEVY: Aye.
6 THE SECRETARY: Senator Libous.
7 SENATOR LIBOUS: Aye.
8 THE SECRETARY: Senator Maltese.
9 SENATOR MALTESE: Mr. President,
10 to explain my vote.
11 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
12 Maltese to explain his vote.
13 SENATOR MALTESE: As Senator
14 Larkin has indicated, for the last number of
15 hours at a time when we're considering a budget
16 very important to the people of our state we've
17 spent discussing an issue that seems
18 self-evident to the constituents we represent.
19 Is it any wonder that people back
20 in the districts think that in some cases when
21 they hear what goes on in the Legislature they
22 use the phrase that the inmates have taken over
23 the asylum? It's amazing that Wednesday at this
2348
1 stage in our state's fiscal crisis, in our
2 state's taxing and overburdening the citizens of
3 the state, rather than alleviating their burden,
4 can spend this much time on a program that has
5 already proven itself and, Mr. President, we
6 didn't need the pilot program in Onondaga and
7 Rockland to prove that this program works.
8 Common sense dictates that it works. Common
9 sense and experience indicates that people are
10 going to defraud a system. There are some
11 people who will try to get away with whatever
12 they can and what belongs to others.
13 Now, are we penalizing those
14 persons who are compelled by virtue of their
15 economic circumstances to subject themselves to
16 finger imaging? I do not believe so, Mr.
17 President.
18 I have many persons eligible for
19 home relief and public assistance in my
20 district. To this moment, I have not received a
21 single communication evidencing any problem with
22 this bill or with the system. I commend Senator
23 Holland for leading this fight. I believe this
2349
1 is what the people in my district and the people
2 in New York State have elected us to do is to
3 save money and to have those monies go to the
4 people that deserve them.
5 Mr. President, I vote aye.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
7 Maltese votes yes.
8 Continue the roll.
9 THE SECRETARY: Senator Marchi.
10 SENATOR MARCHI: Aye.
11 THE SECRETARY: Senator Marino.
12 (Affirmative indication.)
13 THE SECRETARY: Aye.
14 Senator Markowitz.
15 SENATOR MARKOWITZ: Explain my
16 vote. Senator Maltese....
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
18 Markowitz to explain his vote.
19 SENATOR MARKOWITZ: Senator
20 Maltese, I want you to know that I concur and I
21 think most of us do here. Most of us that are
22 voting no on this bill concur with what you're
23 saying. What we want to do is, rather than
2350
1 begin only in one category of fraud, all that at
2 least I'm suggesting is to extend this program
3 to various categories of potential fraud.
4 Rather than isolate one group, let's look at the
5 major areas and the state Tax Department knows
6 all too well that are involved with fraudulent
7 use of state monies and let's put into place not
8 only the finger system that you're suggesting
9 but other safeguards to really, really prevent
10 to the greatest degree possible abuse of our
11 monies and, because you're right, Senator, there
12 are people and corporations and individuals that
13 will steal any opportunity they can. There's
14 not a question about it. Unfortunately, that
15 exists too much in our society. Our job in
16 government is to eliminate in every possible way
17 that potential among some people, and I believe
18 we have it within our ability.
19 We have the technology; all we
20 need is the will to do it beyond just this one
21 subject, but across the board. So until that
22 bill comes here, I vote no.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
2351
1 Markowitz in the negative.
2 Continue the roll.
3 THE SECRETARY: Senator Mendez.
4 SENATOR MENDEZ: No.
5 THE SECRETARY: Senator
6 Montgomery.
7 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: No.
8 THE SECRETARY: Senator Nanula.
9 SENATOR NANULA: Yes.
10 THE SECRETARY: Senator Nolan.
11 (There was no response. )
12 Senator Nozzolio.
13 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Mr. President,
14 to explain my vote.
15 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
16 Nozzolio to explain his vote.
17 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Mr. President,
18 I spoke on this bill about four hours ago.
19 Don't wish to repeated myself but wish to
20 address comments made by Senator Markowitz.
21 Senator, I agree with you that we
22 should be looking at all aspects of the delivery
23 system. We should be looking at doctors, we
2352
1 should be looking at dentists. We should be
2 looking at nurses. We should be looking at
3 those who are participating in the delivery
4 system to present a balanced process.
5 All those professions now require
6 fingerprinting, Senator, according to New York
7 State statute.
8 Now, that's just another reason
9 why I believe this measure is fair, honest,
10 direct and comprehensive, and I applaud Senator
11 Holland for bringing it to the floor for our
12 consideration today.
13 I vote in the affirmative.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
15 Nozzolio in the affirmative.
16 Continue the roll.
17 THE SECRETARY: Senator
18 Ohrenstein.
19 (Negative indication. )
20 THE SECRETARY: No.
21 Senator Onorato.
22 SENATOR ONORATO: Aye.
23 THE SECRETARY: Senator
2353
1 Oppenheimer.
2 SENATOR OPPENHEIMER: Yes.
3 THE SECRETARY: Senator Padavan.
4 SENATOR PADAVAN: Yes.
5 THE SECRETARY: Senator Pataki.
6 SENATOR PATAKI: Yes.
7 THE SECRETARY: Senator
8 Paterson.
9 SENATOR PATERSON: No.
10 THE SECRETARY: Senator Present.
11 SENATOR PRESENT: Yes.
12 THE SECRETARY: Senator Rath.
13 SENATOR RATH: Yes.
14 THE SECRETARY: Senator Saland.
15 SENATOR SALAND: Mr. President,
16 explain my vote.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
18 Saland to explain his vote.
19 SENATOR SALAND: Mr. President, I
20 have heard some of those who have spoken in
21 opposition to this bill make reference to the
22 fact that this has been a rather lengthy and in
23 ordinately long debate, a debate which they feel
2354
1 really serves little or no purpose.
2 I would suggest to them that, if
3 my recollection is correct, two and a half to
4 three of the hours that have kept us here on
5 this floor have been to accommodate the
6 conference which was called by our colleagues on
7 the other side of the aisle in order to discuss,
8 assumedly, I believe the representation was the
9 respective merits of this bill.
10 I've also heard some people who
11 have said amongst other things that while they
12 embrace the concept embodied here it isn't broad
13 enough. I think that's a disingenuous as the
14 argument at least in some respects perhaps as
15 the argument about us being responsible for a
16 lengthy debate here.
17 The reality is that were we to
18 have come forward with a bill as broad as
19 perhaps many if not most of us would like we
20 would have been accused of being insensitive and
21 how could we, particularly with regard to ADC
22 have contemplated such a cruel and heartless
23 thing when we were dealing with the likes of
2355
1 women and children.
2 This isn't a matter of picking on
3 the poor. This isn't a matter of trying somehow
4 or other to harp on those in the greatest of
5 need. This is a matter which is basically one
6 of fairness. The real issue that could be
7 debated subsequently is the issue of what will
8 we do with the money that we save by denying
9 benefits to those who set out with intention to
10 cheat the system, intention to make sure that
11 those who are in need don't get their full
12 benefits.
13 That's a legitimate debate. Do
14 we use that money for real property tax relief
15 because 50 percent of this money that's being
16 spent is being spent in our localities by our
17 local governments, so when the state Social
18 Service Department talks about a $46 million
19 saving you're talking a $92 million savings to
20 the taxpayers of the state of New York.
21 Legitimate issue. You want to
22 argue whether it should be saved and given back
23 in tax relief or whether additional benefits?
2356
1 That's the issue, but please don't becloud the
2 issue with sloganeering. This is not cheap
3 posturing. This is an issue that's supported by
4 this house, the Majority in this house. The
5 Governor has said he supports it. The
6 Comptroller has provided some form of
7 endorsement to this.
8 The only people holding out
9 basically the Assembly Majority, the Democrats
10 in the Assembly and this is a policy statement
11 that would be endorsed by the overwhelming
12 people, overwhelming number of people in this
13 state whether they are receiving assistance or
14 not.
15 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: How do
16 you vote, Senator Saland?
17 SENATOR SALAND: I vote in the
18 affirmative.
19 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
20 Saland in the affirmative.
21 Continue the roll.
22 THE SECRETARY: Senator
23 Santiago.
2357
1 SENATOR SANTIAGO: No.
2 THE SECRETARY: Senator Sears
3 voting in the affirmative earlier today.
4 Senator Seward.
5 SENATOR SEWARD: Yes.
6 THE SECRETARY: Senator Skelos
7 voting in the affirmative earlier today.
8 Senator Smith.
9 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
10 Smith to explain her vote.
11 SENATOR SMITH: At first blush I
12 was tempted to vote for this bill, but after
13 listening to all of my colleagues debate the
14 issue and after asking many questions, I don't
15 believe that the test that was taken in Onondaga
16 and Rockland County is a true representation of
17 the state of New York nor do I believe that 147
18 people represent an entire state. There is a
19 need for reform, and I believe that those of us
20 in the African-American community and in the
21 Puerto Rican and Latino communities believe that
22 stronger than anyone else and I'm tired of
23 hearing that it is our people that are the
2358
1 recipients of welfare because it is not. Look
2 at the statistics, and after carefully listening
3 to especially Senator Nozzolio talk about the
4 requirements for doctors and dentists to be
5 fingerprinted, those things are not happening in
6 our state and until we start to take -- to take
7 care of those issues of those who are really
8 ripping off the system, then I don't feel that
9 we should do it on the backs of the little guy
10 who can not help themselves.
11 Once again we're throwing out the
12 baby with the bath water.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
14 Smith, how do you vote?
15 SENATOR SMITH: In the negative.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
17 Smith in the negative.
18 Continue the roll.
19 THE SECRETARY: Senator Solomon.
20 (There was no response. )
21 Senator Spano.
22 SENATOR SPANO: Aye.
23 THE SECRETARY: Senator
2359
1 Stachowski.
2 SENATOR STACHOWSKI: Yes.
3 THE SECRETARY: Senator Stafford.
4 Senator Stafford.
5 SENATOR STAFFORD: Aye.
6 THE SECRETARY: Senator
7 Stavisky.
8 SENATOR STAVISKY: No.
9 THE SECRETARY: Senator Trunzo.
10 SENATOR TRUNZO: Yes.
11 THE SECRETARY: Senator Tully.
12 SENATOR TULLY: Mr. President, to
13 explain my vote.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
15 Tully to explain his vote.
16 SENATOR TULLY: Thank you, Mr.
17 President.
18 As chairman of the Health
19 Committee and chairman of the Council on Health
20 Care Financing, I can tell my colleagues quite
21 candidly that there are many, many things that
22 are being requested of me and of you as members
23 in this state right now that would very much
2360
1 help those deserving poor and needy in our
2 state.
3 One thing I think of immediately
4 that comes to mind is the case mix cap that's
5 been imposed by the Department of Health on our
6 hospitals which will cost them somewhere in the
7 area of $250 million if it's allowed to stand.
8 And who will it hurt the most, Mr. President? It
9 will hurt the people in New York City the most
10 in the sense that the bulk of those people who
11 need it are in New York City.
12 It doesn't take a lot, Mr.
13 President, to resolve this problem. I'm told
14 that for something like $20 million with a lift
15 cap in the Senate and half in the Assembly, we
16 can solve that problem. Well, back in 1991 when
17 this legislation was proposed, I supported it
18 with Senator Holland, and I said it should be
19 statewide and, Mr. President, we weren't allowed
20 to have that statewide program developed. We
21 were forced to accept a demonstration project in
22 two counties, Onondaga and Rockland, and when
23 one of my colleagues earlier said Senator
2361
1 Dollinger -- he's not in the chamber now but he
2 did say that in some small way finger imaging
3 has led to a reduction in fraud.
4 Well, I don't know what he thinks
5 is small, but even in Long Island where I come
6 from, if one county can save one million
7 dollars, Mr. President, that's not small, that's
8 big, and we have 62 counties in this state and
9 yes, we did ask in 1991 to do this statewide
10 because we knew there was fraud, Mr. President,
11 and again, we weren't allowed to do it and we're
12 back today. It's not small.
13 The Commissioner of Social
14 Services of Onondaga County told my staff today
15 that it's one million dollars in that county
16 that has such a small amount of people on
17 welfare.
18 This bill is timely and it's not
19 partisan, cheaply partisan as Senator Gold said,
20 and I notice he's not in the chamber either, but
21 it is the right thing to do, Mr. President.
22 Statutory authority for these demonstrations
23 expired April 1st. That's one of the reasons
2362
1 for this bill, because this bill will correct
2 that, and we would have saved millions of
3 dollars, millions of dollars. We could have
4 solved that case mix cap problem without a doubt
5 if this bill -- this legislative proposal of
6 Senator Holland in 1991 was allowed. He cites
7 38 percent of the budget is now Medicaid and
8 welfare.
9 If it's allowed to continue, this
10 state will be bankrupt. This is a step in the
11 right direction. The people, 93 percent of the
12 people who have received this in those counties
13 said they had no problem with finger imaging.
14 This bill is timely, and it should be adopted
15 and I vote for it.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
17 Tully in the affirmative.
18 Continue the roll.
19 THE SECRETARY: Senator Velella.
20 SENATOR VELELLA: Yes.
21 THE SECRETARY: Senator Volker.
22 SENATOR VOLKER: Yes.
23 THE SECRETARY: Senator Waldon.
2363
1 (Negative indication.)
2 THE SECRETARY: No.
3 Senator Wright.
4 SENATOR WRIGHT: Aye.
5 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The
6 Secretary will call the absentees.
7 THE SECRETARY: Senator Bruno.
8 SENATOR BRUNO: Yes.
9 THE SECRETARY: Senator Espada
10 excused.
11 Senator Galiber.
12 SENATOR GALIBER: Have my name
13 called very briefly.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
15 Galiber to explain his vote.
16 SENATOR GALIBER: Senator Tully,
17 I recall that in 1991 also and what we were
18 saying then and apparently we have forgotten,
19 was that we were interested in the fraud aspect
20 of it. We're talking about 600-and-some-odd
21 thousand dollars in one particular area.
22 There's a recent, and some of us
23 said why don't we go after Medicaid fraud, where
2364
1 the big bucks are? And this is just a recent
2 case from the New York Law Journal in which
3 state is awarded a million regarding Medicaid
4 fraud plea. It was a plea bargain situation,
5 five hundred, half a million dollars there's a
6 plea bargain, and with triple damages it comes
7 up to a million-point-five.
8 And some of us said in 1991 this
9 is the direction we should be going in, not
10 after those persons who are the small fry and
11 those of us who suggest on this side of the
12 aisle that we should be doing a little bit more
13 such substantive matters, I recognize we went
14 through a charade the other night, and call it
15 what you want, descriptive adjectives,
16 ridiculous almost, $700 million in tax cuts, and
17 we're doing the same thing here tonight. We're
18 talking about people and a state of mind I
19 mentioned before.
20 Why don't we go after the major
21 frauds which is the fraud in Medicaid. Why
22 don't we go after that instead of suggesting
23 that there is fingerprinting or whatever the
2365
1 case may be? I would ask you to put it over for
2 a while and there shouldn't be any problem along
3 those lines. You're insistent on going
4 forward. You know it's a one-house bill.
5 You talk about wasting whether we
6 were extended a conference as far as our
7 conference is concerned, it works both ways,
8 reciprocity over the years. The fact of the
9 matter, you know, in your heart's heart it's a
10 one-house bill, and you're going after the wrong
11 person, very frankly. We should have spent our
12 time in 1991 going after the big guys.
13 No, I'm making a statement that
14 we should have been going after those big guys
15 from the very beginning in 1991 and we wouldn't
16 be wasting our time. That's what we're doing
17 here and you're putting some good people in some
18 awkward positions. That's the design. That's
19 what the design is, Senator.
20 You don't know the complete
21 story, but that's the political design to put
22 people in a position where you say, are you
23 opposed to finding the cheats in our system and
2366
1 the answer certainly we want to find out but
2 this is not welfare reform. That's what we
3 need. We should be going after the big guys,
4 not chipping away in this fashion.
5 I vote no.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
7 Galiber in the negative. Continue the roll.
8 THE SECRETARY: Senator Nolan.
9 (There was no response. )
10 Senator Solomon.
11 (There was no response. )
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Announce
13 the results.
14 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 43, nays
15 15.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
17 is passed.
18 The clerk will continue the non
19 -- or the controversial calendar. Senator
20 Present, we have a couple motions. Do you mind
21 if we return to motion and resolutions?
22 SENATOR PRESENT: Let's get them
23 out of the way.
2367
1 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: All
2 right. Senator Libous.
3 SENATOR LIBOUS: All right, Mr.
4 President. First I'd like to star my bill
5 Calendar Number 489, please.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Sponsor's
7 star on Calendar 489.
8 SENATOR LIBOUS: And also, Mr.
9 President, I move that the following bill be
10 discharged from its respective committee and be
11 recommitted with instructions to strike the
12 enacting clause: Senate Bill 439.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: O.K.,
14 Senator Present, that takes care of motions and
15 resolutions. Can we return to standing
16 committees for a report? Clerk will read.
17 THE SECRETARY: Senator Cook,
18 from the Committee on Education, reports the
19 following bill directly for third reading:
20 Senate Bill Number 7293, by Senator Padavan and
21 others, Education Law, in relation to the number
22 of community school districts.
23 Also Senator Skelos, from the
2368
1 Committee on Aging reports the following bill
2 directly for third reading: Senate Bill Number
3 7238-A, by Senator Skelos and others, Executive
4 Law, in relation to the elderly pharmaceutical
5 insurance coverage programs.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Without
7 objection, so ordered.
8 Senator Santiago, Santiago,
9 excuse me.
10 SENATOR SANTIAGO: I would
11 request if the record indicated I would have
12 voted in the negative on Calendar 405 had I been
13 in the chamber yesterday.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: All
15 right. The record will so indicate.
16 Regular order, clerk will read.
17 THE SECRETARY: On page 11,
18 Calendar Number 482, by Senator Cook, Senate
19 bill Number 2836, General Municipal Law.
20 SENATOR LEICHTER: Explanation?
21 SENATOR GOLD: Last section.
22 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
23 section.
2369
1 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
2 act shall take effect immediately.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
4 roll.
5 (The Secretary called the roll. )
6 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 60.
7 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
8 is passed.
9 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
10 484, by Senator Levy, Senate Bill Number 81-A,
11 in relation to requiring the Commissioners of
12 Motor Vehicles, Transportation and Education to
13 develop a uniform definition.
14 SENATOR GOLD: Last section.
15 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
16 section.
17 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
18 act shall take effect immediately.
19 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
20 roll.
21 (The Secretary called the roll. )
22 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 60.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
2370
1 is passed.
2 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
3 506, by Senator Saland, Senate Bill Number 4417,
4 Criminal Procedure Law and the Family Court
5 Act.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
7 section.
8 THE SECRETARY: Section 5. This
9 act shall take effect immediately.
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
11 roll.
12 (The Secretary called the roll. )
13 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 59, nays
14 one, Senator Galiber recorded in the negative.
15 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
16 is passed.
17 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
18 510, by Senator Stafford, Senate Bill Number
19 6845, amends Chapter 266 of the Laws of 1981
20 amending the Civil Practice Law and Rules.
21 SENATOR GOLD: Excuse me.
22 Tomorrow, please.
23 SENATOR PRESENT: Lay it aside.
2371
1 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Lay the
2 bill aside.
3 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
4 513, by Senator Padavan, Senate Bill Number
5 128-A, an act to amend the Executive Law.
6 SENATOR GOLD: Could we -
7 Senator Padavan wanted this starred?
8 SENATOR PRESENT: No.
9 SENATOR GOLD: All right,
10 tomorrow.
11 SENATOR PRESENT: Lay it aside,
12 please.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Lay the
14 bill aside.
15 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
16 518, by Senator Cook, Senate Bill Number 2632
17 A, Environmental Conservation Law.
18 SENATOR GOLD: Lay aside,
19 please. (Pause) Were you prepared for it
20 today?
21 SENATOR COOK: Yes.
22 SENATOR GOLD: Last section.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The clerk
2372
1 will read the last section.
2 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
3 act shall take effect immediately.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
5 roll.
6 (The Secretary called the roll. )
7 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 60.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
9 is passed.
10 THE SECRETARY: Excuse me. Ayes
11 59, nays one -- ayes 60.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
13 is passed.
14 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
15 523, by Senator Levy, Senate Bill Number 1003-A,
16 an act to amend the Vehicle and Traffic Law.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
18 section.
19 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
20 act shall take effect immediately.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
22 roll.
23 (The Secretary called the roll. )
2373
1 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 60.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
3 is passed.
4 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
5 526, by Senator Marino, Senate Bill Number 7239,
6 an act to amend the General Municipal Law.
7 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Last
8 section.
9 SENATOR GOLD: Last section.
10 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
11 act shall take effect immediately.
12 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Call the
13 roll.
14 (The Secretary called the roll. )
15 THE SECRETARY: Ayes 60.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: The bill
17 is passed.
18 Senator Present.
19 SENATOR PRESENT: Clear?
20 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
21 Present.
22 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President,
23 for the benefit of the members, there will be a
2374
1 session tomorrow at the usual time, a session on
2 Friday at the regular time and Senator Marino
3 would like the members to know that the Senate
4 will continue to work until we have a budget in
5 place.
6 SENATOR GOLD: You mean work day
7 by day, you don't mean -
8 SENATOR PRESENT: Mr. President,
9 there being no further business, I move that -
10 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senator
11 Present, I'm being asked to recognize Senator
12 Hoffmann. Senator Hoffmann.
13 SENATOR HOFFMANN: Thank you, Mr.
14 President. I'd like to be recorded in the
15 negative on Calendar Number 523.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Without
17 objection, so ordered.
18 Senator Present.
19 SENATOR PRESENT: Now, Mr.
20 President, there being no further business, I
21 move that we adjourn until tomorrow at 11:00
22 a.m.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL: Senate
2375
1 stands adjourned until tomorrow at 11 a.m.
2 (Whereupon at 6:14 p.m., the
3 Senate adjourned.)
4
5
6
7