Regular Session - January 30, 1995

                                                                  496

         1

         2

         3

         4

         5

         6

         7

         8

         9                       ALBANY, NEW YORK

        10                       January 30, 1995

        11                          3:03 p.m.

        12

        13

        14                       REGULAR SESSION

        15

        16

        17

        18       LT. GOVERNOR BETSY McCAUGHEY, President

        19       STEPHEN F. SLOAN, Secretary

        20

        21

        22

        23











                                                              497

         1                      P R O C E E D I N G S

         2                      THE PRESIDENT:  The Senate will

         3       come to order.  Would everyone please rise and

         4       repeat with me the Pledge of Allegiance.

         5                      (The assemblage repeated the

         6       Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.)

         7                      The invocation today will be

         8       given by our guest, Dr. Evelyn Ross John of the

         9       New Life Center of Truth in Brooklyn, New York.

        10                      DR. JOHN:  With the rising of

        11       God's yearly presence and yearly pull in our

        12       midst, we ask to take complete control of what

        13       is being done this day.

        14                      Loving Father/Mother God, we give

        15       Thee thanks for this beautiful day.  We give

        16       Thee thanks for these people here of this Senate

        17       who have come to dedicate their lives to

        18       building a better and a more beautiful nation.

        19       We ask You now, our God, that you take complete

        20       control of their mind, their body and all their

        21       affairs.  We ask, dear Father, that You have

        22       them to focus on that goal so that whatever they

        23       do, they will do it for the good of the nation











                                                              498

         1       and they will help people and build people and

         2       relive the life that we are all accustomed to.

         3       O Father, take complete control of this Senate

         4       right now.  Bless every sound, every word; bless

         5       every message; bless every conviction that is

         6       made this day.  See that we are dedicated, God,

         7       in Your presence so that we will work for the

         8       good of this great nation and we will know that

         9       it will work for the highest good of all the

        10       people everywhere upon this great earth.  So we

        11       ask You, dear God, to take complete control but

        12       we ask it in Your other name, but through the

        13       name and the power of Jesus Christ.

        14                      Thank you.

        15                      THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you.

        16                      The Secretary will read the

        17       Journal, please.

        18                      THE SECRETARY:  In Senate,

        19       Friday, January 27th.  The Senate met pursuant

        20       to adjournment, Senator Bruno in the Chair.  The

        21       Journal of Thursday, January 26th, was read and

        22       approved.  On motion, Senate adjourned.

        23                      THE PRESIDENT:  Without











                                                              499

         1       objection, the Journal stands approved as read.

         2                      Presentation of petitions.

         3                      Messages from the Assembly.

         4                      Messages from the Governor.

         5                      Reports of standing committees.

         6                      The Secretary will read.

         7                      THE SECRETARY:  Senator Velella,

         8       from the Committee on Insurance, reports the

         9       following two bills directly for third reading:

        10                      Senate Bill Number 18, by Senator

        11       Velella, an act to amend the Insurance Law, in

        12       relation to allowing insurers to make available

        13       multi-tier program.

        14                      Also Senate Bill Number 19, by

        15       Senator Velella, an act to amend the Insurance

        16       Law, in relation to certain insurance premium

        17       reductions.

        18                      Also Senate Bill Number 22, by

        19       Senator Velella and others, an act to amend the

        20       Insurance Law, in relation to the reduction of

        21       homeowners insurance rates in certain

        22       instances.

        23                      All bills reported directly for











                                                              500

         1       third reading.

         2                      THE PRESIDENT:  Without

         3       objection, all bills direct to third reading.

         4                      Report of select committees.

         5                      Communications and reports from

         6       state officers.

         7                      Motions and resolutions.

         8                      Oh, Senator DiCarlo, I'm sorry.

         9                      SENATOR DiCARLO:  Yes, Madam

        10       President.  On behalf of Senator Holland, on

        11       page 4, I offer the following amendments to

        12       Calendar Number 13, Senate Print 20, and ask

        13       that said bill retain its place, Third Reading

        14       Calendar.

        15                      THE PRESIDENT:  So ordered.

        16                      Senator Bruno.

        17                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Madam President,

        18       I call a meeting of Rules immediately off the

        19       floor in Room 332.

        20                      THE PRESIDENT:  There will be an

        21       immediate meeting of the Rules Committee in Room

        22       332.

        23                      Oh, Senator Wright, sir.











                                                              501

         1                      SENATOR WRIGHT:  Madam President,

         2       I move that the following bills be discharged

         3       from their respective committees and be

         4       recommended with instructions to strike the

         5       enacting clause:  Senate Print Numbers 126, 127,

         6       128, 129, 130, 131, 132, 133, 134 and 135.

         7                      THE PRESIDENT:  The bills are

         8       recommitted, the enacting clauses stricken.

         9                      Senator Bruno?  Oh, Senator Kuhl,

        10       sorry.

        11                      SENATOR KUHL:  Madam President,

        12       would you place a sponsor's star on Calendar

        13       Number 4, Senate Print 516, please.

        14                      THE PRESIDENT:  The bill is

        15       starred.

        16                      SENATOR KUHL:  Thank you.

        17                      Senator Bruno.

        18                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Madam President,

        19       I would like to take up the non-controversial

        20       reading of the calendar at this time.

        21                      THE PRESIDENT:  The Secretary

        22       will read.

        23                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number











                                                              502

         1       5, by Senator Lack, Senate Bill Number 496-A.

         2                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Lay aside,

         3       please.

         4                      THE PRESIDENT:  Lay it aside,

         5       please.

         6                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

         7       17, by Senator Holland, Senate Bill Number 136.

         8                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Lay aside,

         9       please.

        10                      THE PRESIDENT:  Lay it aside,

        11       please.

        12                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        13       18, by Senator Holland, Senate Bill Number 313,

        14       an act to amend the Social Services Law.

        15                      THE PRESIDENT:  Read the last

        16       section, please.

        17                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        18       act shall take effect -

        19                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Lay it aside,

        20       please.

        21                      THE PRESIDENT:  Oh, lay it aside,

        22       please.

        23                      SENATOR CONNOR:  What number is











                                                              503

         1       that?

         2                      THE PRESIDENT:  Calendar 18.

         3                      SENATOR CONNOR:  I'm sorry.

         4                      THE PRESIDENT:  Oh, read the last

         5       section.

         6                      SENATOR CONNOR:  I want 18 laid

         7       aside.

         8                      THE PRESIDENT:  Well, I'm -- lay

         9       it aside, please.

        10                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        11       19, by Senator Maltese, Senate Bill Number 491,

        12       an act to amend the Social Services Law, in

        13       relation to access to criminal history records.

        14                      THE PRESIDENT:  Read the last

        15       section, please.

        16                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        17       act shall take effect immediately.

        18                      THE PRESIDENT:  Call the roll,

        19       please.

        20                      (The Secretary called the roll. )

        21                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 44.

        22                      THE PRESIDENT:  The bill is

        23       passed.











                                                              504

         1                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

         2       25, by Senator Stafford.

         3                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Lay aside,

         4       please.

         5                      THE PRESIDENT:  Lay it aside,

         6       please.

         7                      Senator Bruno, that completes the

         8       non-controversial reading of the calendar.

         9                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Madam President,

        10       may we now have the controversial reading of the

        11       calendar.

        12                      THE PRESIDENT:  The Secretary

        13       will read.

        14                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        15       5, by Senator Lack, Senate Bill Number 496-A, an

        16       act to amend the Judiciary Law, in relation to

        17       audio-visual coverage of judicial proceedings.

        18                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Explanation,

        19       please.

        20                      THE PRESIDENT:  Explanation is

        21       requested, please.

        22                      SENATOR LACK:  Madam President.

        23                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Lack.











                                                              505

         1                      SENATOR LACK:  Thank you.

         2                      Madam President, this would

         3       extend the current authority for cameras in the

         4       courtroom, which expires as of February 1st of

         5       this year, for two and a half years.

         6                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Thank you, Madam

         7       President.

         8                      In past years -- in past years,

         9       this bill has come before us.  I remember the

        10       first time it came before us when Senator

        11       Anderson brought it out under his sponsorship,

        12       and there was a big debate on the floor, and I

        13       led the debate against the then version of the

        14       bill, and it was defeated on the floor and in

        15       subsequent years it's been renewed.  It was

        16       allowed to expire.

        17                      I've voiced my opposition to this

        18       bill, but I have had an opportunity now to

        19       observe the cameras in the courtroom in action,

        20       to review a report that, while not perfect, is

        21       finally an evaluation.  I think the first

        22       experimental bill round, we all felt and many of

        23       us felt the kind of report and evaluation we got











                                                              506

         1       was not truly a good view of how the experiment

         2       had worked.

         3                      So basically, in view of where we

         4       are today, Senator, I do intend to support this

         5       bill, although, of course, it is one of those

         6       bills on which members have diverse opinions and

         7       it is a matter of conscience, but I just wanted

         8       to convey that to you.

         9                      Senator Hoffmann?

        10                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator

        11       Hoffmann.

        12                      SENATOR HOFFMANN:  Madam

        13       President, I believe I have an amendment at the

        14       desk.

        15                      THE PRESIDENT:  There is an

        16       amendment at the desk.

        17                      SENATOR HOFFMANN:  Could we have

        18       it read.

        19                      THE PRESIDENT:  Would you read

        20       the amendment, please.

        21                      SENATOR HOFFMANN:  I'd like to

        22       call that amendment now, please.

        23                      THE PRESIDENT:  Would you like to











                                                              507

         1       waive the reading of the amendment and explain

         2       it?

         3                      SENATOR HOFFMANN:  Please.

         4                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator

         5       Hoffmann.

         6                      SENATOR HOFFMANN:  Thank you.

         7                      The amendment at the desk would

         8       provide several changes in the bill, and I would

         9       like to just say at the outset that over the

        10       last decade the issue of cameras in the

        11       courtroom has gone through a very interesting

        12       evolution in New York State, and I've watched

        13       with -- with some pleasure the degree of

        14       interest that has been put forth in this house

        15       to some areas which a decade ago were not really

        16       very well considered at all, and I want to

        17       compliment the sponsor for having addressed some

        18       of the concerns that I had raised initially back

        19       in 1986 and felt like a rather lonely voice, but

        20       at that time the bill was put aside and because

        21       of the lack of unanimity on its concept, the

        22       lack of concern -- lack of unanimity on its

        23       evaluation component, we didn't have a bill at a











                                                              508

         1       point in time when there was an expectation that

         2       it would go through with very little discussion

         3       at all.

         4                      So it's one area where the

         5       involvement of this legislative body in earnest

         6       discussions, has made a difference and, while we

         7       may not find a final solution today, I hope we

         8       will come a little closer to a meeting of the

         9       minds about what is really important when we

        10       address the issue of cameras in the courtroom.

        11                      Is the paramount issue here the

        12       public's right to know, or is the paramount

        13       issue the practice of justice in New York State?

        14       And I would submit that we must still remain

        15       absolutely dedicated to the practice of justice

        16       as our number one goal and concern and recognize

        17       that a second constitutional right in this

        18       country, namely, the public's right to know, is

        19       already guaranteed.  The free press and the free

        20       trial provisions are more than adequately

        21       recognized by the open courtrooms that we have

        22       in this state.  Any of us are quite capable of

        23       going and sitting and listening to a trial.











                                                              509

         1                      We're also able to read the

         2       newspaper accounts.  But simply because we now

         3       have electronic news media as a fact of life in

         4       our homes and our bars and restaurants and

         5       legislative halls, does not mean that everything

         6       that happens in a courtroom must be or should be

         7       televised.

         8                      There are three distinct

         9       provisions within this amendment that would

        10       alter, not significantly, but would alter the

        11       bill that Senator Lack has introduced today.

        12                      One would make it very clear that

        13       a crime victim in a sex crime would have

        14       absolute veto power over cameras in the

        15       courtroom if that is the choice of that crime

        16       victim.

        17                      Another one would require that

        18       the review committee would have a representative

        19       from the Crime Victims Board so that, when we go

        20       back at the end of this evaluation period, we

        21       will have the benefit of people who are familiar

        22       with crime victims, in analyzing whether or not

        23       it has been a sensibly drawn bill and it has











                                                              510

         1       been well planned and executed in this addition

         2       al, I guess, third or fourth trial period.

         3                      And finally, and I wonder why

         4       this has to be written in at all, but yet -- and

         5       yet it does -- and finally, the amendment would

         6       include that there would be videotape repository

         7        -- a videotape repository available where all

         8       of the videotapes could be placed -- would be

         9       evaluated through the review process and would

        10       obviously be available then for the public for

        11       any further scholarly study as well as by the

        12       Legislature in ascertaining whether or not the

        13       experiment has been well conducted.

        14                      Now, why do we want these three

        15       provisions in? There is very clear anecdotal

        16       evidence, and some scattered scientific evidence

        17       to indicate that rape victims are reluctant to

        18       prosecute crimes and are most reluctant to go

        19       into a courtroom to see their attacker

        20       prosecuted if they fear there is even the

        21       slightest possibility that their own identity

        22       would be disclosed.

        23                      We have to recognize our











                                                              511

         1       responsibility here to the victims of those

         2       crimes and not put rape victims and child

         3       victims of sex crimes through any additional

         4       horror.  We should give them the right to say,

         5       "No, I do not want this trial televised."

         6       There are examples where testimony has taken

         7       place and simply inadvertently the victim's

         8       identity has been broadcast, or enough

         9       information about the victim through her place

        10       of residence, her attire, the circumstances

        11       under which the attack took place, to make it

        12       extremely evident to people who she knows,

        13       people with whom she works, other people who are

        14       simply aware of who she is, that she, in fact,

        15       was a victim of a crime.

        16                      This is another abuse heaped upon

        17       an already suffering individual, and we should

        18       allow any woman in New York State the right to

        19       say, "No, I do not want cameras in the courtroom

        20       for this trial."

        21                      Now, if she has that right, what

        22       would happen next?  All trials involving sex

        23       crimes would be closed to cameras?  No, not











                                                              512

         1       necessarily.  It would mean then that the ball

         2       is actually in the victim's court, and she would

         3       have some validity through her attorney to

         4       negotiate the circumstances under which the

         5       camera would be in the court, not be told that

         6       she would be protected by the presence of the

         7       blue dot on the screen because, as we all know,

         8       that blue dot does not always offer adequate

         9       protection.  She would then know through her

        10       attorney under which circumstances the cameras

        11       could be in the courtroom.  Possibly for some of

        12       the time, possibly for none of the time,

        13       possibly with a narrowly trained camera so that

        14       none of the courtroom would be panned because

        15       she did not want the presence of her friends and

        16       relatives panned in the courtroom to trigger

        17       what her identity is; but at the present time

        18       there is no guarantee for the victim of a rape

        19       crime that any of those conditions will be met.

        20                      The only guarantee, the only

        21       protection she has under the current measure is

        22       that her permanent identity would be protected.

        23       Inadvertent exposure, trivial aspects of her











                                                              513

         1       life, miscellaneous aspects of testimony which

         2       could lead to further humiliation are completely

         3       beyond her control and are sufficient reason for

         4       women in this state to say, "No, I will not

         5       prosecute my attacker.  I would rather let him

         6       go free, commit similar rapes against other

         7       women and children in this state rather than

         8       endure any more humiliation myself."

         9                      In the interest of justice to

        10       every rape victim in this state, we owe the

        11       right to the absolute guarantee that there will

        12       be no cameras or cameras only in a manner that

        13       are acceptable to her and in the greater

        14       interest of justice in prosecuting rapists by

        15       allowing such women to feel comfortable or at

        16       least to feel some measure of comfort in a

        17       courtroom, we should further consider the

        18       importance of this particular issue.

        19                      Judicial discretion, that's the

        20       standard phrase that's used.  The initial bill

        21       that came up in 1986 was -- was very bold and

        22       said that the judge would have judicial

        23       discretion to decide when in other circumstances











                                                              514

         1       the cameras should be taken out of the

         2       courtroom; but the phrase "judicial discretion"

         3       has come to be a very hollow one to many women

         4       who have been exposed to something lacking in

         5       discretion on the part of many judges.

         6                      We've all seen those well

         7       publicized cases where one judge, not in this

         8       state, told the -- told the public and told the

         9       jury that the -- that the victim deserved the

        10       attack because she was dressed provocatively or

        11       appeared in a provocative manner.  The victim

        12       was a minor child in that particular national

        13       scandal.  Judicial discretion was not very

        14       comforting in that instance.

        15                      There have been other cases where

        16       judges have provided comic relief at the expense

        17       of the victim, made inappropriate comments about

        18       the victim's previous sexual activities, all of

        19       which are supposedly not to be allowed in a

        20       court of law, but occasionally will happen and

        21       there is very often little sanction readily

        22       available and any abuse that takes place at the

        23       expense of the victim, if it's addressed at any











                                                              515

         1       point in the future, will not obviate the need

         2       for some remedial action right at that moment.

         3                      There is no provision in this

         4       bill to deal with the kind of inadvertent

         5       exposure of the victim's identity which could

         6       occur and, in fact, has occurred.  We had an

         7       example in New York State out in Amherst, New

         8       York during an arraignment, even while this last

         9       provision was in effect, the last trial period.

        10       We were supposed to have a guarantee that there

        11       would be no disclosure of any rape victims'

        12       names.  A victim's name and address was

        13       broadcast on the 6:00 o'clock news during an

        14       arraignment.

        15                      There's an assumption made that

        16       the broadcast industry will police itself and

        17       will follow these provisions carefully.  I don't

        18       know why people would make that assumption,

        19       because the nature of broadcasting does not

        20       include in it a -- a daily ethic course for

        21       cameramen.  It does not include in it any kind

        22       of a procedure in which every piece of videotape

        23       that is going to be shown in the 6:00 o'clock











                                                              516

         1       news in every jurisdiction in the United States

         2       or in New York State is going to be subject to

         3       careful evaluation by anybody to see whether

         4       it's complying with the standards of the test

         5       measure.

         6                      In fact, there are no sanctions

         7       against the broadcasting industry on the whole

         8       or in any individual broadcast outlet should

         9       they violate the provisions of this bill.  If

        10       they make a mistake, if they violate the privacy

        11       of a rape victim, there is no penalty for them.

        12       The only penalty available is the penalty we

        13       hold in our hands today by refusing to continue

        14       the experiment, and yet it appears that there

        15       are more than enough legislators in this state

        16       who are willing to continue the experiment for

        17       another two years.

        18                      But recognizing that the

        19       experiment has not been a one hundred percent

        20       success for the victims of sex crimes, can't we

        21       continue the experiment by allowing them the

        22       right to have cameras excluded if, in fact, that

        23       is what they desire?  And don't we have a











                                                              517

         1       responsibility to insist that, at the very

         2       least, a member of the sex crime board be

         3       included in the evaluation procedure to give all

         4       victims of sex crimes an opportunity to have

         5       their concerns addressed before we make this a

         6       permanent measure as it may some day become?

         7                      And finally, don't we have a

         8       responsibility to all of the above individuals

         9       and to ourselves as legislators, to insist that

        10       we not have only printed reports but that we

        11       maintain the actual videotape.  We are, after

        12       all, talking about broadcasting.  Isn't it a

        13       little bit ironic to have only a printed report

        14       evaluating a broadcast experiment?  Don't we

        15       have an obligation to keep in a most scientific

        16       manner the actual form of the -- of the

        17       broadcast experiment that was used so that it

        18       can then be evaluated objectively either by us

        19       or by other people who have an interest in

        20       seeing whether it continues or does not

        21       continue?

        22                      So for all of these reasons, my

        23       friends, I would ask you to consider the











                                                              518

         1       importance of this amendment and ask whether we

         2       would want to ever have to explain why, in the

         3       interest of broadcast access, any of us allowed

         4       a rape victim in this state to be subjected to

         5       greater humiliation than was absolutely

         6       necessary by permitting cameras in a courtroom

         7       over her objections.

         8                      I will continue to support the

         9       concept of cameras in the courtroom.  I'm aware

        10       of the -- the ridicule that some of us have

        11       faced through the broadcast and the print media,

        12       they're allies in opposing the greater measure

        13       of cameras in the courtroom.  I believe that

        14       cameras have a place in the courtroom in New

        15       York State.  I would like to be able to support

        16       a cameras in the courtroom bill that will

        17       address the needs of all people in New York

        18       State, but I can not support this bill unless we

        19       can pass the amendment that I presented to the

        20       desk today.

        21                      Thank you, Madam President.

        22                      THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you,

        23       Senator Hoffmann.











                                                              519

         1                      Senator Lack on the amendment.

         2                      SENATOR LACK:  Thank you, Madam

         3       President.

         4                      Senator Hoffmann, I assume you

         5       have good intentions, but the way your amendment

         6       is worded right now, it says "provided, how

         7       ever," and then it goes on and it only applies

         8       to a victim who is testifying in the case.  This

         9       is your wording, so it doesn't apply in those

        10       cases where a victim wouldn't be testifying.

        11                      As such, quite frankly, I refer

        12       you to Section 218, 7. (g) of the Judiciary Law

        13       which says:  "No audio-visual coverage shall be

        14       permitted of the victim in a prosecution for

        15       rape, sodomy, sexual abuse or other sex offense

        16       under article one hundred thirty or section

        17       255.25 of the Penal Law."  There's then a semi

        18       colon that's following that.  That's limiting,

        19       not required.  No coverage is allowed, period,

        20       even if coverage for anything else has been

        21       given.  Yes, the judge can then throw it all

        22       out.  There's no blue dot involved; there's no

        23       anything else.  When a victim of a sex crime is











                                                              520

         1       testifying at a trial, there is no coverage in

         2       New York State, period, under existing law.  No

         3       amendments to it are necessary.

         4                      As to why victims might want to

         5        -- quite frankly, we had a memorandum from

         6       Justice for All, a group of victims that

         7       supports victims having the choice if they so

         8       choose, for whatever reason a victim might want

         9       to choose to allow those proceedings to be

        10       televised; and there are victims, those who are

        11       part of Justice for All, who submitted this

        12       memorandum, who want proceedings or at least

        13       want the option to have proceedings televised as

        14       long as there's an option for the victim not to,

        15       and that's what this is all about.

        16                      So to put in an absolute

        17       prohibition, quite frankly, runs counter in some

        18       cases to some victims wanting the ability for

        19       whatever reason, they want to have it publicized

        20       what happened to them, and to want that on

        21       television.  Now, that is just as much their

        22       right, quite frankly, as is the -- as is the

        23       prohibition.











                                                              521

         1                      As to the rest of your

         2       amendments, obviously any videotapes that were a

         3       part of a report, there is a -- already a duty

         4       in law that that which goes into a report which

         5       is filed with us, particularly a committee that

         6       is formed by the chief judge of the state of New

         7       York, they're going to keep their exhibits.  We

         8       really don't have to tell the chief judge to

         9       make sure her appointees keep exhibits of

        10       audio-visual materials they've used to evaluate

        11       whatever we're requiring them to file with us,

        12       and I think it would be a little presumptuous

        13       for us to try to give that kind of instruction

        14       to the chief judge.  She knows far better than

        15       we do the kind of material that has to be kept

        16       in a report.

        17                      So, quite frankly, we already

        18       have in law what you've been asking for in your

        19       amendment.

        20                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Paterson,

        21       on the amendment, please.

        22                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Based on what

        23       Senator Lack has presented us, I would like to











                                                              522

         1       look at section 218, 7. (g) to see that that's

         2       actually the case and, if it is, Senator Lack,

         3       then I stand corrected.

         4                      What I think the point of the

         5       amendment was, was to try to relieve some of the

         6       jurisdiction from the judge in these specific

         7       cases and to transfer part of it to that of the

         8       victim, the understanding being in the amendment

         9       that the lack of complaint about cameras in the

        10       courtroom would not necessarily be the grounds

        11       for sustaining the notion that it's a good thing

        12       and that people like it because the problem that

        13       victims of sexual offenses have always had, is

        14       that there is no disclosure.  There's no desire

        15       to come forward.  There's no reason to let

        16       anyone know that this abuse is taking place and

        17       that's the most diabolical effect of sexual

        18       offenses in the first place, that they are the

        19       types of crimes that put the victim in the

        20       position of being as much on trial as the

        21       perpetrator.  And so we don't know what the

        22       effects of cameras in the courtroom have been on

        23       individuals who have been victimized, but we do











                                                              523

         1       know that individuals who've been victimized

         2       have often not come forward, whether we have

         3       cameras in the courtroom or not.

         4                      The fact is that you don't have

         5       to be a rape victim not to want your personal

         6       business discussed in court.  That's why in 1898

         7       we closed the family courts, and the family

         8       courts were not closed to protect children; they

         9       were closed to protect the actions of adults in

        10       many cases.

        11                      I'm in favor of opening the

        12       family courts.  I'm in favor of putting cameras

        13       in the courtroom.  I voted against this

        14       legislation in 1986.  I voted against it up to

        15       1992.  But I think I'm beginning to see that the

        16       openness of proceedings is really the best

        17       course for us to take in our society even though

        18       it may often be seen as absurd, even though it

        19       may be poignantly displayed as it may in some of

        20       our television coverage, such as on CNN and

        21       Court TV.  They go into a great detail and we

        22       can actually see the opposite of it in some of

        23       the television tabloid journalism programs.











                                                              524

         1                      But the fact is that the framers

         2       of the Constitution wanted our judicial proceed

         3       ings to be open, and we should abide by it.  But

         4       when it comes to very specific situations, it

         5       would seem to me that we would try to understand

         6       that it is the victim that has more to lose even

         7       than the analysis of the judicial official,

         8       whether it be the chief judge or the sitting

         9       judge in those particular situations.

        10                      Ancillary testimony at these

        11       kinds of proceedings can produce the identity or

        12       certain habits or certain information about a

        13       victim that the victim does not want to know.

        14       In addition, I would just want to point out that

        15       Section 1, Article 130 of section 255.25 does

        16       not include all of the sexual offenses that

        17       exist in the Penal Law, including those of child

        18       sexual abuse which we think are also relevant to

        19       the spirit of Senator Hoffmann's amendment, that

        20       these would be some protections that would be

        21       added to the legislation.

        22                      And finally, I just ask this

        23       question of the media more than even the











                                                              525

         1       proponents of the legislation:  If we can put

         2       cameras in the courtroom, if we can try to bring

         3       sunshine to these proceedings, why is it so

         4       necessary that we know every single thing about

         5       these types of crimes when we know the damage

         6       that these types of crimes has held in the past?

         7       Why do we have to know?  There's a difference

         8       between the public right and the public query.

         9       We, as a public, become very interested in

        10       particular types of cases.  But when we balance

        11       the value of our interest with the value of the

        12       injury, shouldn't we at least add some extra

        13       protections to make sure that a victim of a

        14       crime that wants to come forward, which is a

        15       major step in the first place, does not have to

        16       even suffer from the perception that there will

        17       be an additional injury that would take place

        18       after the physical injury and would be actually

        19       the emotional harm of even the perception that

        20       their identity is going to be exposed.  The

        21       identity and the persona and the psychological

        22       welfare should be the main objective of victims

        23       and, when victims want to exercise these











                                                              526

         1       situations in such a fashion that they would

         2       disclose or come forward, they should certainly

         3       have that option.  When they do not want to, we

         4       feel that they should have that option as well.

         5       Otherwise, the bill is one that I will support.

         6                      THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you,

         7       Senator Paterson.

         8                      Senator Leichter, on the

         9       amendment.

        10                      SENATOR LEICHTER:  I think we

        11       make a serious mistake with this amendment and

        12       I've listened very carefully to Senator Hoffmann

        13       and Senator Paterson, and I know the good

        14       concerns and well intention of Senator Hoffmann

        15       in moving forward this amendment.  But let's

        16       just back up for a moment.

        17                      New York State has the most

        18       restrictive law of all the 47 states which allow

        19       cameras in the courtroom as far as making these

        20       proceedings public.  Many states have had these

        21       for many, many years.  We've had it under

        22       somewhat restricted circumstances for seven

        23       years.  In those seven years, there has been no











                                                              527

         1       complaint.  No complaint.  No victim rights

         2       group has come and said, "You are placing in

         3       jeopardy the well-being of a victim of a sexual

         4       crime."

         5                      We have set up two commissions

         6       that have carefully looked into how cameras in

         7       the courtroom work in this state.  Both of them

         8       have overwhelmingly recommended that the system

         9       be continued, and I believe I'm correct, that

        10       the latest recommendation was that the system be

        11       made permanent.  I certainly favor making it

        12       permanent.

        13                      It was the most thorough analysis

        14       that was made.  The last commission or task

        15       force was headed by Justice Burton Roberts.

        16       There's no more knowledgeable person of our

        17       criminal justice system, no tougher prosecutor,

        18       nobody who would be more concerned if

        19       prosecutions were hindered because witnesses did

        20       not come forward.  There's been not one reported

        21       case where somebody refused to make a complaint

        22       because she or he were concerned or afraid that

        23       their identity would be compromised at a trial.











                                                              528

         1                      The last time we renewed cameras

         2       in the courtroom, we put in very specific

         3       protections for victims of rape, victims of

         4       sexual crimes to protect their identity.

         5       Senator Lack has rightly pointed out that

         6       Senator Hoffmann's amendment doesn't do what she

         7       says it's going to do because, first of all, it

         8       only talks about a crime victim of sexual crime

         9       who testifies.  Many of them don't testify, so

        10       it wouldn't even apply in those cases, Senator

        11       Hoffmann, and, if you would read it, all it says

        12       is that that proceeding would not be televised

        13       or subject to the audio-visual publication, but

        14       "proceeding" as written in there seems to refer

        15       to the testimony of the crime victim.

        16                      But let's assume for the moment

        17       that your amendment says what you believe that

        18       it says.  Why is it that no victim rights group

        19       came before us or came before the Justice

        20       Roberts task force and said, "You're not

        21       protecting the victims of sexual crimes?"  On

        22       the contrary, two victim rights organizations

        23       testified and pleaded for the continuation of











                                                              529

         1       cameras in the courtroom, and I think that the

         2       victims of crimes understand maybe better than

         3       we do the importance of the public knowing and

         4       understanding what they went through, the

         5       importance of the public understanding the whole

         6       criminal justice system, and that's why our

         7       forefathers, in their brilliance -- and it

         8       certainly was brilliance -- in molding our

         9       Constitution, provided that all trials ought to

        10       be public, and "public" means that you can go in

        11       there.  "Public" means the press can report it.

        12       "Public" also should mean that the way that

        13       people learn these days about public events,

        14       which is through television, be one that the

        15       media use to show what is going on in the

        16       trial.

        17                      Senator Hoffmann said, and I

        18       quote her, this "clear anecdotal evidence".

        19       Senator, we don't proceed or should not proceed

        20       on anecdotal evidence.  If you have evidence,

        21       that's fine, but for seven years we've had no

        22       evidence.

        23                      My good friend, Senator Paterson,











                                                              530

         1       says we don't know the effect.  Senator, we do

         2       know the effect.  If, for seven years, nobody

         3       has complained, no prosecutors, no victim rights

         4       organizations, no women's group has said this

         5       law doesn't work, this law doesn't protect

         6       victims, we do know the effect, and I submit

         7       that it's those who say that there's something

         8       wrong with cameras in the courtroom who have an

         9       obligation to give us more than anecdotal

        10       evidence, even "clear anecdotal evidence" or to

        11       tell us, Well, I don't know what the effect is

        12       and, therefore, there must be an effect.  We do

        13       know the effect, and the effect is that it has

        14       served the public interest.

        15                      I think the best step against

        16       crime, the best step that we can take is to have

        17       an informed public, and that means to have

        18       cameras in the courtroom.

        19                      I finally want to say that, if

        20       you -- if you accept this sort of an amendment,

        21       I think it's a slippery slope and next year

        22       we'll be back and somebody says, Well, these

        23       sort of crimes really, we shouldn't -- we











                                                              531

         1       shouldn't televise them and then we'll call up

         2       another exception and more.

         3                      47 states have cameras in the

         4       courtroom.  None of them seem to have the

         5       problems that have been the source of the

         6       concerns that Senator Hoffmann has raised, and

         7       seven years we haven't had that problem.  I

         8       don't know why we manufacture these problems and

         9       I -- and I realize, Senator Hoffmann, you have

        10       very great concern for the welfare of victims of

        11       all crimes, I know, and particularly of sexual

        12       crimes, and you're right, they deserve not only

        13       our sympathy, they deserve our protection, but I

        14       respectfully submit to you that this really does

        15       not provide protection.  I think it takes away

        16       what is needed and that is to let the public

        17       know what happens in the courtrooms and to let

        18       the public know what steps are being taken or

        19       not being taken to deal with crime.

        20                      I urge the defeat of this

        21       amendment.  I think Senator Lack, who's worked

        22       very hard on this issue, worked to put together

        23       a bill with the Assembly, if we don't pass it











                                                              532

         1       and pass it today, we're going to end up without

         2       cameras in the courtroom, and I think it would

         3       be the shame of New York State if that happens.

         4                      THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you,

         5       Senator Leichter.

         6                      Senator Abate on the amendment.

         7                      SENATOR ABATE:  I, too, applaud

         8       Senator Lack.  I support fully cameras in the

         9       courtroom, and -- but I'd like to speak a little

        10       bit about beyond anecdotal.

        11                      I was the chair of the Crime

        12       Victims Board in the '80s, and at that time

        13       victims groups were very concerned about cameras

        14       in the courtroom, and we went throughout the

        15       state.  Now they are very comfortable, but I

        16       think it's a misconception to suggest that

        17       victims and citizens don't feel that crime

        18       victims who have been victimized by sex

        19       offenders, should not be treated in a different

        20       category.

        21                      There is still -- I made some

        22       calls today.  There is still concern among

        23       victims groups, particularly women who have been











                                                              533

         1       victimized by these heinous crimes, that many of

         2       them will not come forward and report those

         3       crimes to the police.  It is not anecdotal.  If

         4       you go to police departments throughout the

         5       state, the most under-reported crime are crimes

         6       of sex offenses.

         7                      That's because it's a very

         8       personal crime.  It's an invasion of one's

         9       privacy.  Because the crime is so misunderstood,

        10       many victims feel shamed.  They feel guilt.

        11       They feel that they've done something wrong,

        12       even though it's not a crime of passion, it's a

        13       crime of control.  It's a crime of violence.

        14                      We, in our society, have to do

        15       better in terms of educating the public.  I

        16       believe we have an opportunity the next two

        17       years if we're more restrictive today vis-a-vis

        18       these kinds of crime victims.  We can learn from

        19       this experience.  We extend the law, let's see

        20       what we learn, but I believe victims of sex

        21       offenses are unique.  There's a particular

        22       sensitivity that's involved with this kind of

        23       crime, and I think we should pay attention to











                                                              534

         1       it.

         2                      But I applaud it.  I will support

         3       cameras in the courtroom.  I've advanced in my

         4       thinking.  Years ago I objected to it.  We've

         5       seen through the experience, it is worthwhile.

         6       It is something that we should protect, but on

         7       the other hand, I think there's a vital interest

         8       in terms of crime victims vis-a-vis sex offenses

         9       that needs to be protected.

        10                      THE PRESIDENT:  The question is

        11       on the amendment.  All those in favor signify by

        12       saying aye.

        13                      (Response of "Aye.")

        14                      All those opposed say nay.

        15                      (Response of "Nay.")

        16                      In the opinion of the Chair, the

        17       nays have it.  The amendment is not agreed to.

        18                      Read the last section, please.

        19                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        20       act shall take effect immediately.

        21                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  If I may,

        22       Madam President.

        23                      THE PRESIDENT:  Yes, Senator











                                                              535

         1       Dollinger, please.

         2                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Madam

         3       President, on the bill.

         4                      I commend Senator Lack as well

         5       for his work in continuing New York's experiment

         6       with cameras in the courtroom, and I guess what

         7       I'm always amazed at is that we in this country,

         8       when motion picture cameras first came into

         9       prominence in American justice, really happened

        10       to coincide with the Lindbergh trial, which some

        11       of you remember was held in the state of New

        12       Jersey, in which there was large and widespread

        13       movie coverage of the Lindbergh trial in the

        14       late 1920s and early 1930s.  That raised

        15       concerns about defendants and the impact of

        16       cameras in courtrooms upon defendants, but I

        17       certainly think we've come a long way from the

        18       star chambers of the past and have opened up our

        19       courtrooms, made them public trials.

        20                      I think it's also interesting,

        21       when you look at the effect of the O.J. Simpson

        22       trial and the public television coverage of

        23       that, I hear a lot more on the news about the











                                                              536

         1       concept of jury sequestration, jury selection,

         2       jury tampering -- there's an article in The Wall

         3       Street Journal today about it -- all of those

         4       issues relating to juries, I think the greater

         5        -- have created a greater public understanding

         6       of juries, public questioning of juries, public

         7       information, public education of juries because

         8       they are the focal point of the televised

         9       coverage of the Simpson case.

        10                      I think all of that education of

        11       the public about the jury system which, for

        12       those of us as lawyers who are familiar with it,

        13       understand how it works, I think it serves a

        14       tremendous public benefit for more and more

        15       people who are non-lawyers to see that side of

        16       of both the criminal and the civil justice

        17       system.

        18                      And I would just add one other

        19       thought.  I happened to read "Bleak House" over

        20       the Christmas holidays, and I sometimes wondered

        21       if there had been cameras in the courtroom when

        22       Jaryndice against Jaryndice occurred, maybe they

        23       wouldn't have had to wait 30 or 40 years for a











                                                              537

         1       resolution.

         2                      It's getting the cameras in the

         3       courtroom to look at both your civil and

         4       criminal justice system that will bring out

         5       changes not only in this chamber but in the mind

         6       of the public as well.  This legislation is a

         7       continuing step in that direction.  I applaud

         8       it.  I'll vote in favor of it.

         9                      THE PRESIDENT:  The Secretary

        10       will read the last section, please.

        11                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        12       act shall take effect immediately.

        13                      SENATOR HOFFMANN:  On the bill.

        14                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator

        15       Hoffmann.

        16                      SENATOR HOFFMANN:  I feel

        17       compelled to speak once again on the bill now,

        18       Madam President, just to clarify a couple of

        19       things.

        20                      I chose not to ask anybody to

        21       yield for a question and engage in protracted

        22       debate on this measure, but I am troubled by -

        23       by one exchange that occurred a few moments ago











                                                              538

         1       here, and I would just like to take a moment and

         2       put in perspective the apparent contradiction.

         3                      My good colleague, Senator

         4       Leichter, on the one hand, took great exception

         5       to the use of the phrase "anecdotal evidence"

         6       that I mentioned, I referenced, and Senator

         7       Abate expanded somewhat on that and then he went

         8       on at great length to use a very broad brush

         9       approach to say that the 47 states that have

        10       cameras in the courtroom have had no problems at

        11       all, and I doubt very much whether Senator

        12       Leichter or Senator Lack or any other member of

        13       this chamber has been personally in touch with

        14       every one of the other states that have engaged

        15       in any portion of an experiment with cameras in

        16       the courtroom to speak with that degree of

        17       certainty about each aspect of it.

        18                      But that seems to be the standard

        19       by which we sometimes operate.  Those who

        20       maintain the information that is about to be

        21       passed are given a little bit more latitude or

        22       perceive their right to speak in much more

        23       definitive terms about their inherent grasp of











                                                              539

         1       right, and those of us who do not have piles of

         2       strict doctrinaire evidence are somewhat

         3       suspect.

         4                      I would just like my colleagues

         5       to remember that we are a representative

         6       democracy, a representative Legislature, and

         7       there are those of us who perhaps are more

         8       familiar with -- are more conversant with rape

         9       victims, with people who have been through the

        10       experience on a personal basis of a sex crime

        11       and we may know from a very personal vantage

        12       point, as legislators and as women, that there

        13       is, in fact, a chilling effect of cameras in the

        14       courtroom that compels us to want an amendment

        15       to this measure that would guarantee the

        16       protection that victims of rape trials have

        17       asked for.  If they have not asked as vocally as

        18       have the broadcasters asked, then perhaps they

        19       are negligent in their responsibilities to us as

        20       legislators.

        21                      But let's be reasonable.  We are

        22       talking about rape victims.  They do not make a

        23       towering mass of lobbyists on the steps of the











                                                              540

         1       Capitol.  They speak to us one at a time and

         2       quietly.  They have no vested interest that will

         3       enrich them personally.  They have no profit

         4       motive, and they have already been stigmatized,

         5       but some of us do hear them and we want them to

         6       know that we have taken their concerns into

         7       consideration and, as much as I support the

         8       concept of cameras in the courtroom until their

         9       needs are addressed, not just their personal

        10       right to be excused from coverage individually,

        11       but until all of their concerns have been

        12       addressed and they are allowed the absolute

        13       knowledge that there will be no camera in a

        14       courtroom in a trial in which they are once

        15       again forced to relive their sex crime, then I

        16       will have to vote against this measure.

        17                      Thank you.

        18                      THE PRESIDENT:  Would you please

        19       read the last section.

        20                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        21       act shall take effect immediately.

        22                      (The Secretary called the roll. )

        23                      THE PRESIDENT:  Results.











                                                              541

         1                      THE SECRETARY:  Those recorded in

         2       the negative on Calendar Number 5 are Senators

         3       Babbush, Cook, Daly, DiCarlo, Hoffmann, Holland,

         4       Johnson, LaValle, Leibell, Levy, Maltese,

         5       Onorato, Padavan, Present, Santiago, Sears,

         6       Solomon, Stachowski and Volker.  Ayes 35, nays

         7       18.

         8                      THE PRESIDENT:  The bill is

         9       passed.

        10                      Senator Bruno.

        11                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Madam President,

        12       I ask that we return to reports of standing

        13       committees, and I believe that there is a report

        14       from the Rules Committee at the desk.

        15                      THE PRESIDENT:  A report of the

        16       standing committees.  The Secretary will read.

        17                      THE SECRETARY:  Senator Bruno,

        18       from the Committee on Rules, reports the follow

        19       ing resolution:

        20                      Concurrent Resolution Number 260

        21       of the Senate and Assembly, proposing an

        22       amendment to the permanent joint rules of the

        23       Senate and Assembly in relation to authorizing a











                                                              542

         1       joint committee on conference to consider and

         2       report upon substantially similar but not

         3       identical legislation that has passed each

         4       house.

         5                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Bruno.

         6                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Madam President,

         7       I move that we accept the report of the Rules

         8       Committee.

         9                      THE PRESIDENT:  All those in

        10       favor.

        11                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Madam

        12       President.  Is this -

        13                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Connor?

        14                      (There was no response.)

        15                      All those in favor of adopting

        16       the Rules report, signify by saying aye.

        17                      (Response of "Aye." )

        18                      Those opposed signify by saying

        19       Nay.

        20                      (Response of "Nay." )

        21                      The ayes have it.  The report is

        22       adopted.

        23                      Senator Bruno.











                                                              543

         1                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Madam President,

         2       I move that we adopt the resolution of the Rules

         3       Committee and that it be read presently in its

         4       entirety.

         5                      THE PRESIDENT:  Please read.  The

         6       Secretary will read.

         7                      THE SECRETARY:  Concurrent

         8       Resolution Number 260, by Senator Bruno:

         9                      Concurrent Resolution of the

        10       Senate and Assembly proposing an amendment to

        11       the permanent joint rules of the Senate and

        12       Assembly, in relation to authorizing a joint

        13       committee on conference to consider and report

        14       upon substantially similar but not identical

        15       legislation that has passed each house.

        16                      RESOLVED, if the Assembly concur,

        17       that the permanent joint rules of the Senate and

        18       Assembly are amended by adding a new joint Rule

        19       II to read as follows:

        20                      Joint Rule II.  Section 1.

        21       Committee on Conference.  The Temporary

        22       President of the Senate and the Speaker of the

        23       Assembly may jointly convene a joint committee











                                                              544

         1       on conference to consider and report upon

         2       substantially similar but not identical

         3       legislation that has passed each house of the

         4       Legislature.

         5                      Such committee shall be

         6       constituted by the filing of a joint certificate

         7       by the Temporary President of the Senate and the

         8       Speaker of the Assembly, with the Secretary of

         9       the Senate and the Clerk of the Assembly and

        10       shall consist of the same number of members from

        11       each house.

        12                      Unless otherwise provided in the

        13       certificate, there shall be five members of such

        14       committee from each house to be appointed by the

        15       Temporary President of the Senate who shall

        16       appoint the members from the Senate and the

        17       Speaker of the Assembly shall appoint the

        18       members from the Assembly; provided, however,

        19       that of each house's delegation at least one

        20       member shall represent the minority in each

        21       house.  The Temporary President of the Senate

        22       and the Speaker of the Assembly shall each

        23       appoint a co-chairperson of the committee and











                                                              545

         1       such co-chairpersons shall convene and recess

         2       meetings of the committee.  Meetings jointly

         3       convened by the co-chairpersons shall be subject

         4       to the provisions of Article VII of the Public

         5       Officers Law.  The committee shall file a

         6       written report setting forth the joint

         7       recommendations of the majority of each house's

         8       delegation with the Secretary of the Senate and

         9       the Clerk of the Assembly or such other

        10       committees or officers as may be set forth in

        11       the certificate, and such report may include

        12       specific bill language that would implement the

        13       joint committee's recommendations.

        14                      No report shall be filed except

        15       upon the affirmative vote of a majority of the

        16       members of each house's delegation on the

        17       committee.

        18                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Bruno.

        19                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Madam President,

        20       on the resolution.

        21                      We have talked in this house

        22       about many very worthwhile reforms, and I think

        23       this is a landmark in that we join most of the











                                                              546

         1       other states in the United States in now going

         2       forward with a conference committee concept, and

         3       I have agreement with the Speaker in the other

         4       house, and I want to thank him for his

         5       conferring in good nature and all the others

         6       that have been involved -- Senator Lack, who has

         7       been active at the national level.  There are

         8       many good things whose time will come this

         9       year.

        10                      Conference committee's time has

        11       come.  It moves the legislative process

        12       forward.  There is flexibility in this

        13       resolution that is before us.  It allows us to

        14       do the kinds of things that are necessary to

        15       move forward with good government, giving

        16       flexibility in terms of minority participation

        17       as well as majority participation, and that

        18       participation in those issues would be selected

        19       by the leaders in the respective houses as we

        20       would file joint statements when we saw the need

        21       to create a conference committee.

        22                      Again, the intent of this is to

        23       move the agenda of reform and good government











                                                              547

         1       forward.

         2                      Thank you, Madam President.

         3                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator

         4       Paterson.

         5                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Madam

         6       President, I have an amendment at the desk.  As

         7       a matter of fact, to show our contribution, we

         8       marked the amendment ourselves.

         9                      We first want to commend the

        10       Majority Leader and all those -

        11                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator

        12       Paterson.

        13                      SENATOR BRUNO:  May I just ask a

        14       point of order.  Senator, Madam President, I

        15       don't believe that you can amend the

        16       resolution.  I believe the proper format might

        17       be to do a substitution, if that's what the

        18       intent is.

        19                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Bruno's

        20       point is well taken.  It would not provide for

        21       the amending of the rules.

        22                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Thank you,

        23       Madam President.











                                                              548

         1                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator

         2       Paterson.

         3                      SENATOR PATERSON:  What I'll just

         4       do, rather than even substituting a resolution,

         5       is perhaps I'll just ask the Temporary President

         6       about the resolution and maybe we can just come

         7       to an agreement.

         8                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Bruno.

         9                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Yes, Madam

        10       President.

        11                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Senator, first

        12       of all, we would like to congratulate you and

        13       all of you who worked on this for this kind of

        14       an effort.  It is definitely going to bring to

        15       public attention a great deal of information

        16       about bills that are passed in both of the

        17       houses, particularly in this state and in this

        18       forum in which we work and is going to allow us

        19       to negotiate together more in public and

        20       commensurate with the way that the public would

        21       like.

        22                      And so we strongly support your

        23        -- your resolution.  As a matter of fact, the











                                                              549

         1       reason that we were thinking of amending it

         2       which we now understand would have been achieved

         3       better through substitution, would be just the

         4       number of individuals who are on the actual

         5       committee, and on page 2, line 6 and 9, the

         6       delegation or delineation between the

         7       conferences of those members.

         8                      Now, we understand that, in small

         9       groups, quite often the change of the position

        10       of one member of the group could actually

        11       influence the end result.  So what we were

        12       proposing was to take a number of members of the

        13       committee, from 5 to 7, splitting those two

        14       additional members between the Majority and the

        15       Minority, giving the Majority a number that

        16       would be five and the Minority a number being

        17       two.  This would then give the Minority 28

        18       percent of the votes at the committee, but we

        19       understand that there can be no conclusion that

        20       is reached that does not meet with the approval

        21       of the Majority in both houses.  So, in other

        22       words, regardless of how there is a vote, it

        23       would have to be agreed to by the -- by the











                                                              550

         1       Majority.

         2                      So, therefore, what we're asking

         3       is not more power in the proceedings, in other

         4       words not the capacity to influence the

         5       proceedings, but just more membership to assist

         6       the distribution of information and to better

         7       equalize the percentage of members as there

         8       would be with the percentage of the whole

         9       house.  That's something that I'm asking be

        10       added to the resolution.

        11                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Madam President,

        12       if I understand correctly, then we don't have

        13       anything formal on the floor, but a suggestion

        14       that we expand the participation of the

        15       committees, the conference committees as we go

        16       forward.

        17                      THE PRESIDENT:  That is correct,

        18       Senator Bruno.

        19                      SENATOR BRUNO:  And let me share

        20       with you, as a matter of record, that I think

        21       that makes a lot of sense, and the language in

        22       this resolution allows the leaders in the

        23       respective houses not to do four and one but to











                                                              551

         1       agree on a number, and that is the Speaker's

         2       interpretation as well as mine and our counsel.

         3       So I can tell you, I talked to the Speaker this

         4       morning, and we're open to, you know, four for

         5       some committees and two, sometimes five and

         6       two.

         7                      So rather than try and be

         8       specific with new numbers, there's enough

         9       flexibility there, but our intent would be to

        10       have that Minority participation and that it be

        11       in substantive issues more than one.

        12                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Connor.

        13                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Madam President,

        14       if Senator Bruno would yield just for a couple

        15       of questions that I have.

        16                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Bruno.

        17                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Yes, Madam

        18       please.

        19                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Thank you, Madam

        20       President.

        21                      Senator Bruno, as I read this,

        22       and again, it's -- as you pointed out, it's

        23       flexible.  I could read this rule and say, aha!











                                                              552

         1       Let's create a super Rules Committee, you know,

         2       you could have one committee conference

         3       representing leadership, for example, conference

         4       all the major bills on which there are

         5       differences, or you could turn around and have

         6       for each issue area which you and the Speaker

         7       wish to have conferenced, a different conference

         8       committee, and I was wondering just to get a

         9       sense of intention, what the intention is with

        10       respect to that.

        11                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Bruno.

        12                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Madam President,

        13       the intent is that on each issue, that we

        14       establish an individual conference committee,

        15       not one major committee covering a number of

        16       areas, but address each subject individually

        17       with a committee, with a chair appointed for

        18       that discussion, and it would be my intent to

        19       appoint people on the committee that would be

        20       supportive of the legislation so that you ensure

        21       that there be at least a continuity of interest

        22       as they go forward.

        23                      SENATOR CONNOR:  If I may, Madam











                                                              553

         1       President, one further question.  Senator Bruno,

         2       I notice the resolution says that the Majority

         3       Leader shall appoint the Minority members,

         4       member or members, and I would just like your

         5       assurance that while the rules, of course, allow

         6       the Majority Leader, the Temporary President, to

         7       make all committee appointments, it is the

         8       unvarying custom of this house that Minority

         9       appointments by the Majority Leader are upon the

        10       recommendation of the Minority Leader.

        11                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator Bruno.

        12                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Yes, Madam

        13       President.  We intend to go forward in the same

        14       spirit as you've just reflected with the normal

        15       standing committees in the conference committees

        16       taking the recommendation from the Minority

        17       Leader.

        18                      SENATOR CONNOR:  Thank you, Madam

        19       President.

        20                      THE PRESIDENT:  On the

        21       resolution, all those -- I'm so sorry, Senator

        22       Leichter.

        23                      SENATOR LEICHTER:  Yes, Madam











                                                              554

         1       President, it -- I think it's appropriate to get

         2       up and just note, because I think it deserves to

         3       be emphasized and underscored what a very

         4       significant step this is, and I want to commend

         5       Senator Bruno for it.  Obviously it would not

         6       have happened except for his leadership.

         7       Obviously, I commend the Speaker and you said

         8       Senator Lack was involved, and I think that

         9       Senator Paterson and Senator Connor have

        10       clarified this, and I think have made it

        11       somewhat more workable and I think fairer.

        12                      I just hope that we really use

        13       this system, which is obviously at the

        14       discretion of the Majority Leader and the

        15       Speaker, and there well may be a temptation to

        16       go back to a system that has stood us in such

        17       poor stead for so long, and I understand the

        18       pressures that come up and sometimes, as we all

        19       know, democracy can be somewhat frustrating, but

        20       I really think that, if we proceed on this,

        21       we're going to become a more effective

        22       legislative body in carrying out the wishes and

        23       the needs of the people of this state.











                                                              555

         1                      So it's -- it's really -- it's a

         2       terrific milestone.  It's something, as you

         3       know, that this Minority has urged for many

         4       years, something I've spoken about, I feel very

         5       strongly about, because my aim and my desire is

         6       really to make this the sort of legislative body

         7       that I think we can be and the sort of

         8       legislative body that the people of this state

         9       need, and I think it is a real red letter day

        10       for the Senate and the Assembly of the state of

        11       New York that we're -- that we have this

        12       resolution before us.

        13                      THE PRESIDENT:  Senator

        14       Dollinger.

        15                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  I'll be very

        16       brief, Madam President.

        17                      I join my colleague, Senator

        18       Leichter, in his comments with respect to the

        19       Minority and the Majority Leader for this

        20       particular issue, given the clarifications that

        21       have been made to Senator Paterson and Senator

        22       Connor about how the conference committees are

        23       going to operate.  I think that addresses some











                                                              556

         1       of the concerns that we had.

         2                      I think there are two other names

         3       that ought to be mentioned, two of my colleagues

         4       and perhaps others who have been at the fore

         5       front of this issue over the last couple of

         6       years, but certainly Senator Leichter and

         7       Senator Hoffmann have talked about the

         8       importance of conference committees and pushed

         9       the concept of conference committees in the

        10       past.  I would be remiss if I didn't recognize

        11       their contribution in making this happen as

        12       well.

        13                      I agree with Senator Bruno, I

        14       think this is something that the entire Senate

        15       can take gratitude in recognizing and putting

        16       into effect.  My hope is that it will achieve

        17       the real goal that we're all here, and that is

        18       better serve the people of this state.  Let's go

        19       forward.

        20                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The Chair

        21       recognizes Senator Lack on the resolution.

        22                      SENATOR LACK:  Thank you, Mr.

        23       President.











                                                              557

         1                      I, too, would like to add my

         2       congratulations to Senator Bruno who was more

         3       than receptive when this -- when this was

         4       suggested and has worked very hard to reach

         5       agreement with the -- with the Assembly and come

         6       out with, I think, a good set of regulations

         7       with respect to the conference committees.

         8                      Just to allay any fears, every

         9       state in the country, and that's really every

        10       state in the country that has conference

        11       committees, either has a set membership of three

        12       members or five members, and I think Senator

        13       Bruno, by adopting the flexibility standard that

        14       he has, I've been able to assure that we've been

        15       able to establish conference committees on a

        16       case-by-case basis as the -- as the issue might

        17       merit, so that if three members are needed for

        18       whatever the bill might be, it will be three

        19       members.  If it's five members, it can be five

        20       members.  It can be any number, but just

        21       recognize, of course, that five members on each

        22       side, including the Minority plus staff on all

        23       four sides, starts to add up to a fairly big











                                                              558

         1       number of people actually negotiating the bill

         2       and in any event, the end product always comes

         3       back to each house that has to be repassed as a

         4        -- in the same format as the original bill

         5       passed before it can go to the Governor of this

         6       state and become law.

         7                      So my congratulations also to

         8       Senator Bruno.  I think this is an excellent

         9       movement forward and one that certainly has been

        10       necessary in this house for a long period of

        11       time.

        12                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The Chair

        13       recognizes Senator Hoffmann.

        14                      SENATOR HOFFMANN:  Thank you, Mr.

        15       President.

        16                      As we are two days away from

        17       receiving the budget -- the budget -- it is

        18       probably very appropriate that once again we are

        19       showing in this chamber our complete sense of

        20       flexibility about numbers.

        21                      Under your leadership, Senator

        22       Bruno, you have once again demonstrated, to the

        23       admiration of us all, your remarkable commitment











                                                              559

         1       to true democracy, with a small "d", a great

         2       sense of egalitarian leadership and farsighted

         3       ness that has been missing in this chamber for

         4       many, many years, and I know in my heart that

         5       this is just one more step on that long road to

         6       true open meetings in the interest of the best

         7       possible government in New York State, and this

         8       is a proud day for all members of the New York

         9       State Senate under your leadership, Senator

        10       Bruno.

        11                      Thank you.

        12                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Is there

        13       any other Senator wishing to speak on the

        14       resolution?

        15                      Hearing none, the question is on

        16       the resolution.  All those in favor signify by

        17       saying aye.

        18                      (Response of "Aye.")

        19                      Opposed nay.

        20                      (There was no response. )

        21                      The resolution is adopted.

        22                      Senator Bruno, what's your

        23       pleasure?











                                                              560

         1                      SENATOR BRUNO:  Mr. President, I

         2       think it's time to return to the controversial

         3       calendar and proceed.  Thank you.

         4                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Secretary

         5       will proceed to the controversial calendar and

         6       continue reading in order.

         7                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

         8       17, by Senator Holland, Senate Bill Number 136,

         9       an act to amend the Social Services Law.

        10                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        11       Holland, an explanation has been asked for by

        12       Senator Paterson.

        13                      SENATOR HOLLAND:  Mr. President,

        14       this is a bill that passed last year 57 to zero,

        15       and simply requires the local -- the state DSS

        16       to offer waivers and look for innovative

        17       programs, both from the local DSS offices as far

        18       as home relief clients go.  We are trying to

        19       encourage the local offices of DSS to develop

        20       innovative programs, then give them to us so we

        21       can run them statewide and, if they develop an

        22       innovative program, we will give them 60 percent

        23       reimbursement for that program instead of 50











                                                              561

         1       percent.

         2                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Secretary

         3       will read the last section.

         4                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

         5       act shall take effect immediately.

         6                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

         7       roll.

         8                      (The Secretary called the roll. )

         9                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 54.

        10                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

        11       is passed.

        12                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        13       18, by Senator Holland, Senate Bill Number 313,

        14       an act to amend the Social Services Law.

        15                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Explanation.

        16                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        17       Holland, an explanation has been asked for by

        18       Senator Paterson.

        19                      SENATOR HOLLAND:  Mr. President,

        20       if a client refuses a requirement of the

        21       Department of Social Services, they have an

        22       option of going in for conciliation.  This bill

        23       basically reduces that time limit for











                                                              562

         1       conciliation from 44 days to 30 days.

         2                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

         3       Secretary will read the last section.

         4                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

         5       act shall take effect immediately.

         6                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

         7       roll.

         8                      (The Secretary called the roll. )

         9                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 54.

        10                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

        11       is passed.

        12                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        13       25, by Senator Stafford, Senate Bill Number 619,

        14       an act to amend the Highway Law, prohibiting

        15       abandonment of Crane Pond Road in the town of

        16       Schroon.

        17                      SENATOR OPPENHEIMER:

        18       Explanation, please.

        19                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        20       Stafford, we're on Calendar Number 25.  Your

        21       Senate Bill is 619.  Explanation has been asked

        22       for by Senator Oppenheimer.

        23                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  Yes, Mr.











                                                              563

         1       President.  I apologize for the delay.  We were

         2       talking about subcommittees.

         3                      This, again, is a Crane Pond Road

         4       bill which we have all heard about, and the road

         5       has been there and it was decided it should be

         6       closed due to being near a wilderness area.

         7                      I have explained to all of you

         8       for a number of years I've appreciated the bill

         9       passing.  This wilderness area, you can stand in

        10       the middle of it and hear the cars on the

        11       Northway.  So I suggest maybe we're not in the

        12       wilderness that we're talking about.  We are

        13       not.  This will allow people to be in -- to get

        14       into this area, people who could not get in

        15       otherwise if the road does not remain open.

        16                      And I assure you, Mr. President,

        17       that it certainly makes sense, and it makes

        18       sense for the people who live in the area and

        19       those who can enjoy the area from other parts of

        20       the state.

        21                      SENATOR OPPENHEIMER:  Madam

        22       President.

        23                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Chair











                                                              564

         1       recognizes Senator Oppenheimer.

         2                      SENATOR OPPENHEIMER:  Oh, Mr.

         3       President.

         4                      We've discussed this in past

         5       years, and I think it's the precedent here that

         6       has us most disturbed who are interested in

         7       preserving the wilderness of the Adirondacks.

         8       The Pharaoh Mountain area, which is the area

         9       we're talking about, is classified as wilderness

        10       in the State Land Master Plan; and, therefore,

        11       it doesn't allow within this area any motorized

        12       vehicles.

        13                      Approximately half of the forest

        14       preserve land in the Adirondacks is considered

        15       wild forest; and in wild forests, motor vehicles

        16       are permitted.  In this area, the State Master

        17       Plan says that wilderness areas should have no

        18       vehicles.  That's why they're wilderness areas.

        19       We're attempting to protect our wilderness

        20       areas.

        21                      By permitting the motorized

        22       intrusion, what we are doing is we are just

        23       flaunting -- flaunting the law, the law that











                                                              565

         1       says that in the State Land Master Plan -- in

         2       that plan, there should be no motorized vehicles

         3       in specific areas, and so I would urge all of

         4       you to vote against this as it is against our

         5       very law.

         6                      Thank you.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The Chair

         8       recognizes Senator Stafford.

         9                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  Thank you, Mr.

        10       President.  Senator Oppenheimer and I are having

        11       our annual visit.

        12                      This has nothing to do with your

        13       position, Senator.  It is misclassified by

        14       someone who sat there at a desk and said this is

        15       a wilderness area, and I suggest a mistake has

        16       been made.  People have driven in the area for

        17       years.  The town maintains the road.

        18                      And when I suggest to you that -

        19       again, I emphasize -- you can stand in the

        20       middle of this area, and I have many times, and

        21       hear the cars on the Northway, this isn't what

        22       wilderness area is all about; and we are

        23       correcting the situation by passing this











                                                              566

         1       legislation.

         2                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Chair

         3       recognizes Senator LaValle.

         4                      SENATOR LAVALLE:  Thank you, Mr.

         5       President.

         6                      Senator Stafford has been before

         7       this house with this legislation and tried to

         8       represent a point of view of the people back

         9       home; and as he said, where at one point this

        10       road was misidentified, what he is trying to do

        11        -- and it's really a shame that he has to go

        12       through the legislative process to make this

        13       accommodation.

        14                      And I chose to rise today to

        15       speak on this bill because having passed the

        16       Pine Barrens Preservation Act and the fact that

        17       back home, we have established a process that

        18       allows people to -- back home in the county of

        19       Suffolk -- to sit around a table and to speak to

        20       one another about how they can accommodate

        21       protection of the environment but at the same

        22       time accommodate reasonable uses of land by the

        23       people who live in and around it.











                                                              567

         1                      And so, I hope that during the

         2       session that we take a look at and spend our

         3       energies at protecting our environment but at

         4       the same time not putting our heads in the sand

         5       to turn away from practical, reasonable uses of

         6       the land that the good Lord gave to us.

         7                      And what I believe we're doing is

         8       setting the pace back in the county of Suffolk

         9       and breaking through some new, to use a pun,

        10       territory in terms of land use policy; and

        11       hopefully, maybe some of those methodologies and

        12       techniques that we're using in Suffolk County

        13       might be brought up to the Adirondacks to allow

        14       for more reasonable debate to take place between

        15       those who live in and around the land and those

        16       who want to protect it.

        17                      It's a shame that those of us who

        18       have as a high priority the environment might be

        19       judged through some rating process on whether we

        20       favor our environmentalists or not on this

        21       vote.  But I am going to vote with Senator

        22       Stafford on this because I think that processes

        23       have been used and abused and I think we really











                                                              568

         1       need to bring people together to have a

         2       reasonable dialogue on this.  So I'm going to

         3       support you, Senator Stafford.

         4                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Chair

         5       recognizes Senator Paterson.

         6                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Mr.

         7       President.  Would Senator Stafford yield for a

         8       question?

         9                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        10       Stafford, do you yield to Senator Paterson?

        11                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  (Indicating

        12       yes.)

        13                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        14       yields.

        15                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Senator

        16       Stafford, first of all, as an old friend of

        17       mine, I hope you will take me to the Crane Pond

        18       Lake some time, to Crane Pond Road, because -

        19                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  We will take

        20       you right in the area, and we'll go to the

        21       Crane, Goose, Oxshoe, Bird, Horseshoe and Crab

        22       pond, and I hope you will enjoy it.

        23                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Senator, I











                                                              569

         1       also hope you'll assure me that I'm coming back.

         2                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  We'll make

         3       sure that we'll come back because we will have

         4       the right clothing, and we'll also have a guide.

         5                      SENATOR PATERSON:  My question,

         6       Mr. President, for Senator Stafford is that the

         7       Joint Legislative Committee on Natural Resources

         8       who basically authored the Environmental Land

         9       Master Plan, their prerogative in this case was

        10       to declare this area a wilderness area, and

        11       should it be that they have erred in that

        12       judgment, Senator Stafford -- and we have an

        13       individual case that we're discussing right now,

        14       but I also notice that Calendar Number 27

        15       relates to a bill that you are submitting which

        16       is really the generic form of this bill in which

        17       I would imagine you are trying to protect this

        18       problem from occurring before; that where a town

        19       voices an objection -

        20                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  Right.

        21                      SENATOR PATERSON:  -- to a road

        22       that runs through the town, you want it not to

        23       be closed if the town is actually objecting.











                                                              570

         1                      So my question is, then how can

         2       we have viable environmental planning, how can

         3       we have land use planning policy as it would be

         4       set forth in a plan as has been issued in the

         5       Environmental Land Master Plan if we're going to

         6       circumvent it in all individual cases where a

         7       local town is objecting?

         8                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  That's an

         9       excellent question, and I would share with all

        10       of my colleagues that the interesting point -

        11       and I think even Senator Leichter will have to

        12       agree with me.  When we sit down with the people

        13       of the Adirondacks and really talk with them,

        14       explain various points of view, do your best to

        15       have reason prevail, sometimes your people

        16       living there will be even stricter -

        17       interestingly enough, stricter than some of the

        18       plan is now but maybe have differences like this

        19       here today, have differences and want it

        20       changed.

        21                      I would suggest that going back

        22        -- and I remember when this master plan was

        23       passed, and I have to share this with you











                                                              571

         1       because we're all people.  That's how things

         2       pass.  You put up a plan.  It depends on the

         3       ability of people, those who can lobby, and I

         4       know the two people who lobbied for this to be

         5       wilderness -- and many, many people were against

         6       this; they said that it should be wild forest -

         7       and they prevailed.  We said they were wrong

         8       then.  We say they are wrong now.

         9                      But I would share with you -- I

        10       would share with you one of the biggest mistakes

        11       that was made back in 1971 and '72 was that the

        12       people really weren't consulted enough.  These

        13       people really believe in the area they live in.

        14       Interestingly enough, they don't want a lot of

        15       people coming around into these areas, and you

        16       can really talk with them; and I would hope that

        17       sometime, when we have a revision of the master

        18       plan, that the local people will have much more

        19       of a say in what is now in use or in law.

        20                      I could name about ten areas that

        21       can be debated.  Now, some of you are going to

        22       be shocked to hear this.  I can name over ten

        23       areas that should be wilderness that aren't,











                                                              572

         1       which is very interesting, but they felt they

         2       couldn't do it then.  So, again, it's reason, to

         3       sit down and communicate; and the people in

         4       Schroon Lake that live on Route 9, they have a

         5       beautiful lake there.  I might add -- I know

         6       it's getting late, but that's a lake that I have

         7       seen come back.  When I was here my first year

         8        --  I no longer mention the number of years.

         9       It was a number of years ago -- I tried to swim

        10       one time on the way home and you couldn't.  You

        11       couldn't swim in Schroon lake, and now you can.

        12       That's an example of some of the things we've

        13       done.

        14                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Thank you,

        15       Senator.

        16                      SENATOR LEICHTER:  Mr. President.

        17                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The Chair

        18       recognizes Senator Leichter.

        19                      SENATOR LEICHTER:  Senator

        20       Paterson, would you yield to me for just one

        21       minute, please, because Senator Stafford

        22       mentioned my name, and I want to -- I want to

        23       bear witness to what he said.  He spoke about











                                                              573

         1       the reasonable people in the Adirondacks, and I

         2       have been fortunate to have a home there, and I

         3       want to say they are extremely reasonable.  They

         4       are just wonderful, fine, fair-minded people,

         5       and I want to say their representative is

         6       eminently reasonable, but even reasonable people

         7       sometimes, being fallible, can make a mistake,

         8       which I think is the case now, but it in no way

         9       detracts from the fact that the people there are

        10       reasonable and their representative is eminently

        11       reasonable.

        12                      Thank you.

        13                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Is there

        14       any other Senator wishing to speak on the issue?

        15                      Senator Oppenheimer.

        16                      SENATOR OPPENHEIMER:  This is a

        17       question for Senator Stafford.

        18                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        19       Stafford, do you yield?

        20                      The Senator yields.

        21                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  Thank you.

        22                      SENATOR OPPENHEIMER:  Senator

        23       Stafford, you are an eminently reasonable man,











                                                              574

         1       and you have just said some reasonable things;

         2       and prior to that, some other things have been

         3       said.  We who consider ourselves environment

         4       alists do not want to be perceived as anti

         5       economic development, obviously.  We need jobs

         6       as well as we need protection of the

         7       environment.

         8                      What you said that interested me

         9       very much was that you had thought of some areas

        10       that could be called wilderness, where certain

        11       areas, you think, like this limited road, are

        12       prime for not being wilderness.  But what do you

        13       think the possibility is of sitting down and

        14       discussing perhaps a give and a take, this for

        15       that?

        16                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  I think we

        17       should.  By all means, we should discuss.  I

        18       would say this, that when I had "torts" in law

        19       school, Judge McGruder was our professor, and he

        20       was from Harvard, and we discussed for one hour

        21       what the reasonable man was.  When we left, no

        22       one knew.  So it just shows we can all differ,

        23       but I certainly will be glad to go over some of











                                                              575

         1       these with you.

         2                      SENATOR OPPENHEIMER:  Thank you,

         3       Senator.  I think it's something that we might

         4       be able to see if there is any avenue that could

         5       be pursued at this time; and I think on the side

         6       of Hunter College on Park Avenue and 68th

         7       Street, it's written, "We may at different times

         8       in different conditions disagree; however, it

         9       can always be said that we are at heart trying

        10       to arrive at the truth."  So it is true that

        11       while we disagree, there certainly is a lot of

        12       commonality there and a lot of honesty there

        13       even though there is disagreement.

        14                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The Chair

        15       recognizes Senator Dollinger.

        16                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Again through

        17       you, Mr. President, just one short question of

        18       Senator Stafford.

        19                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        20       Stafford, do you yield to Senator Dollinger?

        21                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  By all means.

        22                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        23       Senator yields.











                                                              576

         1                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  I voted

         2       against this in the past.  I guess my question

         3       is why can't the state land management plan be

         4       changed to exclude this area?  What is the

         5       process?  Is there a process for doing that?

         6                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  It would have

         7       to change the plan; and we're, in effect,

         8       changing the plan with this law.

         9                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  But is -

        10       again, through you, Mr. President.

        11                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  Sure.

        12                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Is there

        13       another process by which -- obviously that

        14       process in the early 1970s resulted in a

        15       wilderness declaration.  Is there some process

        16       by which that could be repealed now other than

        17       through this legislative body?

        18                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  Good

        19       question.  It would be possible for -- and,

        20       again, it's all changed now, but it used to be

        21       the Bureau of Lands and Forests, but I don't

        22       know exactly what that's called in DEC now, but

        23       periodically they review it, and they can come











                                                              577

         1       up with suggestions.  But, again, we would have

         2       to change the plan or if we passed a new plan,

         3       you know.

         4                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  I guess my

         5       suggestion is, Mr. President -- for procedural

         6       reasons, I will continue to vote against this,

         7       but if the town of Schroon in that wonderful

         8       part of this state was wrongfully classified as

         9       a wilderness, there is obviously a different

        10       person on the second floor now.  I assume there

        11       may be different people in certain parts of the

        12       state bureaucracy who may be interested in

        13       looking at amendments to the wilderness plan,

        14       and they could re-examine the logic out at

        15       Pharaoh Lake, and the logic which I've heard

        16       here today may be eminently persuasive when they

        17       hear and, as a consequence, we may not have to

        18       do it here.  It could be done through the

        19       process by which the initial wilderness

        20       designation was put on; it could then be

        21       repealed.

        22                      I would encourage the Senator to

        23       take his advocacy there rather than have us











                                                              578

         1       intervening in the process at this stage.

         2                      SENATOR STAFFORD:  I compliment

         3       you on your perceptiveness, because it was on

         4       the western side of the Adirondacks where there

         5       are many, many people from Rochester who have

         6       homes and I mean large tracts of lands like the

         7       Braniff tract, many of them are reasons why it

         8       changed on the second floor.  So I think they

         9       are going to be hearing.

        10                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        11       Dollinger on the bill.

        12                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  I'd just

        13       encourage Senator Stafford to take that advocacy

        14       on behalf of my constituents and Senator Jones'

        15       constituents.  Certainly those changes may bring

        16       about the kind of change that the Senator seeks

        17       without going through this body.

        18                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        19       Secretary will read the last section.

        20                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        21       act shall take effect immediately.

        22                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        23       roll.











                                                              579

         1                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

         2                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Announce

         3       the results when tabulated.

         4                      Chair recognizes Senator

         5       Oppenheimer to explain her vote.

         6                      SENATOR OPPENHEIMER:  Thank you,

         7       Mr. President.  That took some doing.

         8                      I just want to say that I

         9       certainly don't want to turn a deaf ear.  I feel

        10       there are areas that can be discussed.  I just

        11       feel that as long as the law is the law and we

        12       have wilderness areas declared in our State Land

        13       Master Plan that we have to -- as long as the

        14       law is written as it is, we must vote against

        15       this now, but there are alternatives, and I am

        16       looking forward to exploring them.

        17                      I vote no.

        18                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        19       Secretary will announce the results.

        20                      THE SECRETARY:  Those recorded in

        21       the negative on Calendar Number 25 are Senators

        22       Abate, Connor, Dollinger, Espada, Goodman,

        23       Jones, Leichter, Levy, Onorato, Oppenheimer,











                                                              580

         1       Stachowski, also Senator Leibell.  Ayes 42, nays

         2       12.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

         4       is passed.

         5                      Senator Johnson.

         6                      SENATOR JOHNSON:  Mr. President.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  That

         8       completes the controversial calendar, sir.

         9                      SENATOR JOHNSON:  Any

        10       housekeeping at the desk, Mr. President?

        11                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Secretary

        12       indicates there is none.

        13                      SENATOR JOHNSON:  Mr. President,

        14       then there being no further business, I move we

        15       adjourn until Tuesday, January 31st, 1995, at

        16       3:00 p.m.

        17                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Without

        18       objection, the Senate stands adjourned until the

        19       last day of January, tomorrow, at 3:00 p.m.

        20                      (Whereupon, at 4:35 p.m., the

        21       Senate adjourned.)

        22

        23