Regular Session - March 12, 1997

                                                                 
1529

         1

         2

         3

         4

         5

         6

         7

         8                       ALBANY, NEW YORK

         9                        March 12, 1997

        10                           11:05 a.m.

        11

        12

        13                        REGULAR SESSION

        14

        15

        16

        17       SENATOR JOHN R. KUHL, JR., Acting President

        18       STEPHEN F. SLOAN, Secretary

        19

        20

        21

        22

        23

        24

        25







                                                             
1530

         1                      P R O C E E D I N G S

         2                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

         3       Senate will come to order.  Ask the members to

         4       take their places, the staff to take their

         5       places.  I'd ask everybody in the chamber to

         6       rise and join with me in saying the Pledge of

         7       Allegiance to the Flag.

         8                      (The assemblage repeated the

         9       Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.)

        10                      In the absence of clergy, may we

        11       bow our heads in a moment of silence.

        12                      (A moment of silence was

        13       observed.)

        14                      The reading of the Journal.

        15                      THE SECRETARY:  In Senate,

        16       Tuesday, March 11th.  The Senate met pursuant to

        17       adjournment.  The Journal of Monday, March 10th,

        18       was read and approved.  On motion, the Senate

        19       adjourned.

        20                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Hearing

        21       no objection, the Journal stands approved as

        22       read.

        23                      Presentation of petitions.

        24                      Messages from the Assembly.

        25                      Messages from the Governor.







                                                             
1531

         1                      Reports of standing committees.

         2                      The Secretary will read.

         3                      THE SECRETARY:  Senator Maltese,

         4       from the Committee on Elections, offers up the

         5       following bills:

         6                      Senate Print 1167, by Senator

         7       Lack, an act to amend the Election Law, in

         8       relation to polling places;

         9                      1440, by Senator Maltese, an act

        10       to amend the Election Law, in relation to

        11       political committees;

        12                      1474, by Senator Maltese, an act

        13       to amend the Election Law, in relation to

        14       cancellation of registration;

        15                      2069, by Senator Johnson, an act

        16       to amend the Election Law, in relation to the

        17       transmitting of certain information;

        18                      2651, by Senator Farley, an act

        19       to amend the Election Law and the State Finance

        20       Law.

        21                      All bills directly for third

        22       reading.

        23                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Without

        24       objection, hearing no objection, the bills are

        25       ordered directly to third reading.







                                                             
1532

         1                      Reports of select committees.

         2                      Communications and reports from

         3       state officers.

         4                      Motions and resolutions.

         5                      Senator Skelos, we have a

         6       substitution at the desk.  Can we take that up.

         7                      SENATOR SKELOS:  Make the

         8       substitution.

         9                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        10       Secretary will read the substitution.

        11                      THE SECRETARY:  Senator Libous

        12       moves to discharge from the Committee on Health

        13       Assembly Bill 4394 and substitute it for the

        14       identical Senate Bill 1913.

        15                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        16       substitution is ordered.

        17                      Senator Skelos.

        18                      SENATOR SKELOS:  Mr. President,

        19       at this time if we could have a reading of the

        20       non-controversial calendar.

        21                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        22       Secretary will read the non-controversial

        23       calendar.

        24                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        25       36, by Senator Velella, Senate Print 355-A, an







                                                             
1533

         1       act to amend the General City Law and the Penal

         2       Law, in relation to creating the crimes of

         3       urinating in public.

         4                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Lay it aside.

         5                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Lay the

         6       bill aside.

         7                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

         8       110, by Senator Present, Senate Print 765, an

         9       act to amend the State Administrative Procedure

        10       Act, in relation to compliance requirements.

        11                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        12       Secretary will read the last section.

        13                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        14       act shall take effect on the first day of

        15       October.

        16                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        17       roll.

        18                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        19                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 34.

        20                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

        21       is passed.

        22                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        23       150, by Senator Cook, Senate Print 366, an act

        24       to amend the Education Law, in relation to

        25       defining non-residents of a district for







                                                             
1534

         1       purposes of admission.

         2                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Lay it aside.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Lay the

         4       bill aside.

         5                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

         6       206, by Senator Present, Senate Print 909-A, an

         7       act authorizing the Belmont Central School

         8       District name change.

         9                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        10       Secretary will read the last section.

        11                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        12       act shall take effect on the 30th day.

        13                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        14       roll.

        15                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        16                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 34.

        17                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

        18       is passed.

        19                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        20       238, by Senator Hannon, Senate Print 1499, an

        21       act to amend the Public Health Law, in relation

        22       to reimbursement of city or county medical

        23       expenses.

        24                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        25       Secretary will read the last section.







                                                             
1535

         1                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

         2       act shall take effect immediately.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

         4       roll.

         5                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

         6                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 36.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

         8       is passed.

         9                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        10       239, by Senator Seward, Senate Print 1943, an

        11       act to amend the Public Health Law, in relation

        12       to authorizing the provision of Hospice.

        13                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        14       Secretary will read the last section.

        15                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        16       act shall take effect immediately.

        17                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        18       roll.

        19                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        20                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 36.

        21                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

        22       is passed.

        23                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        24       247, by Senator Skelos, Senate Print 310, an act

        25       to amend the Executive Law, in relation to the







                                                             
1536

         1       search of criminal history records.

         2                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

         3       Secretary will read the last section.

         4                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

         5       act shall take effect on the first day of

         6       November.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

         8       roll.

         9                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        10                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 36.

        11                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

        12       is passed.

        13                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        14       252, by Senator Farley, Senate Print 2144, an

        15       act to amend the Banking Law and the Criminal

        16       Procedure Law, in relation to the regulation of

        17       licensed transmitters of money.

        18                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        19       Secretary will read the last section.

        20                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 4.  This

        21       act shall take effect immediately.

        22                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        23       roll.

        24                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        25                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 36.







                                                             
1537

         1                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

         2       is passed.

         3                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

         4       253, by Senator Farley, Senate Print 2145, an

         5       act to amend the Banking Law, in relation to

         6       money transmitters.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

         8       Secretary will read the last section.

         9                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 6.  This

        10       act shall take effect on the 90th day.

        11                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        12       roll.

        13                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        14                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 38.

        15                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

        16       is passed.

        17                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        18       279, by Senator Rath, Senate Print 2396, an act

        19       to amend the Village Law.

        20                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        21       Secretary will read the last section.

        22                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

        23       act shall take effect immediately.

        24                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        25       roll.







                                                             
1538

         1                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

         2                      THE SECRETARY:  Ayes 38.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

         4       is passed.

         5                      Senator Skelos, that completes

         6       the reading of the non-controversial calendar.

         7                      SENATOR SKELOS:  Take up the

         8       controversial calendar, please.

         9                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        10       Secretary will read the controversial calendar,

        11       beginning with Calendar Number 36, by Senator

        12       Velella.

        13                      THE SECRETARY:  On page 4,

        14       Calendar Number 36, by Senator Velella, Senate

        15       Print 355-A, an act to amend the General City

        16       Law and the Penal Law, in relation to creating

        17       the crimes of urinating in public.

        18                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Explanation.

        19                      SENATOR SKELOS:  Lay it aside

        20       temporarily.

        21                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Lay the

        22       bill aside temporarily.

        23                      The Secretary will continue to

        24       read the controversial calendar.

        25                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number







                                                             
1539

         1       150, by Senator Cook, Senate Print 366, an act

         2       to amend the Education Law, in relation to

         3       defining non-residents of a district for

         4       purposes of admission.

         5                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Explanation,

         6       please.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         8       Cook, an explanation of Calendar Number 150 has

         9       been requested.

        10                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President,

        11       this bill permits a school district to charge

        12       tuition for students who are residing in tax

        13       exempt properties.

        14                      With the problems that we have of

        15       trying to fund schools adequately, when we have

        16       large establishments within school districts

        17       which are sending substantial numbers of

        18       students to the school district and are

        19       contributing absolutely nothing toward the cost

        20       of educating those students, it simply shifts

        21       the burden to everybody else who resides there.

        22                      In one particular school

        23       district, the assessed value of that particular

        24       property is over $1 million that is off the tax

        25       rolls.  Conversely, there are 30 students







                                                             
1540

         1       attending school -- the Fallsburg School from

         2       one particular property at a cost of at least

         3       $100,000 per year to all the other taxpayers in

         4       the school district and those students are

         5       contributing absolutely nothing toward the cost

         6       of their education and the property is

         7       contributing nothing toward the general budget

         8       of the school district.

         9                      So this is an attempt to remedy

        10       that situation by permitting the school district

        11       to charge tuition to those students who reside

        12       in that type of property.

        13                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        14       Paterson.

        15                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Thank you, Mr.

        16       President.

        17                      If Senator Cook will yield for a

        18       question.

        19                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        20       Cook, do you yield?  Senator Cook yields.

        21                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Thank you,

        22       Senator.

        23                      I can certainly understand the

        24       public policy of trying to make sure that any

        25       students that use our public schools share in







                                                             
1541

         1       the cost, or at least that their families share

         2       in the cost and that with the difficulty funding

         3       schools, that large sums of money that would be

         4       not operable because individuals are living on

         5       poverty that's not taxed is -- would be a

         6       significant issue.

         7                      My question to you is do you see

         8       this legislation as the only remedy?  Wouldn't

         9       an impact fee or some kind of use tax that might

        10       be applied more to the entity, not to the

        11       individuals who are using the school, achieve

        12       the same purpose and not in any way penalize

        13       children from getting their education?

        14                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President, I

        15       don't disagree with that statement.

        16       Unfortunately, we have had numerous bills

        17       through the years that have attempted to take

        18       that type of approach to this problem.

        19                      We've had bills that, for

        20       example, limit a -- the tax exemption to only

        21       the portion of the property that's actually used

        22       for the exempt purpose which would mean all the

        23       residential portions of those properties where

        24       people simply live would have been taxable just

        25       like everyone else.  That's one example.







                                                             
1542

         1                      A second bill that we've

         2       attempted to get passed limits the acreage to a

         3       limited numbers of acres, except that the

         4       property owner is able -- if they are able to

         5       prove that additional acreage is utilized for

         6       the exempt purpose, that that can be added to

         7       the acreage.  We have never been able to get

         8       that passed as well.

         9                      We are attempting a third effort

        10       now in a different direction because the first

        11       two don't seem to meet the approval of the

        12       members of the Legislature for -- or at least

        13       the mechanism by which these bills get passed.

        14       We have been able to get the bills out onto the

        15       floor in the Senate on several occasions.  Never

        16       even been able to get them out of committee in

        17       the Assembly.  In the meantime, the other

        18       taxpayers in the district where the property

        19       taxes continue to escalate are paying the cost

        20       of educating these students who live and are

        21       getting a totally free education.

        22                      The irony is that people who

        23       attend private schools are both paying taxes to

        24       the school district and paying tuition in the

        25       private schools but these people are living on a







                                                             
1543

         1       religious property and attending the public

         2       schools and paying nothing and getting the

         3       benefit of the education.  So it's actually the

         4       flip side of what the folks are who attend

         5       private schools.  So it's really trying to

         6       remedy a problem in a very narrowly crafted way.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         8       Paterson.

         9                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Mr. President,

        10       if Senator Cook would continue to yield.

        11                      SENATOR COOK:  Yes.

        12                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Mr. President,

        13       I'm wondering if this bill is not in many ways

        14       over-reaching because, while I can understand a

        15       large entity, some religious institution having

        16       a number of residents on it, they're using the

        17       public schools, as you said and pointed out, I

        18       think very aptly, when their neighbors are not

        19       only paying school taxes but maybe sending their

        20       children to private school, does seem as if

        21       there is a pretty severe inequity but, Senator

        22       Cook, what about the local minister who just

        23       lives where the religious institution is, who

        24       lives next door to the church and it's on the

        25       church's property?  Because of the way this bill







                                                             
1544

         1       is laid out, it's at least my understanding that

         2       that minister and his family may be charged for

         3       the education of his children when their service

         4       to the community may never really be repaid even

         5       by the fact that the location in which they

         6       reside allows them not to have to pay the school

         7       taxes.

         8                      So what I'm saying is I think

         9       this legislation is going too far and is not

        10       specific, what you're probably trying to

        11       address, which are those large institutions and

        12       would you consider finding a way to scale the

        13       legislation down so that it would coincide with

        14       the entities that you're trying to address?

        15                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President, the

        16       difficulty, Senator, as you fully recognize, is

        17       the equal protection requirement.  You simply

        18       cannot pick out one religious organization

        19       simply because they happen to have a large

        20       number of students who are attending a school

        21       and charge them tuition, whereas someone else

        22       who maybe only has one child attending a school

        23       is exempt.  So, in fact, you are correct.

        24                      If the school district chooses to

        25       charge that tuition, they do have to charge it







                                                             
1545

         1       to everyone who lives on an exempt property in

         2       the district.  That being the case, I would

         3       indicate parenthetically that it is increasingly

         4       the practice, at least among Protestant

         5       denominations -- and generally Catholics don't

         6       have children so we don't have that problem

         7       there -- that they pay housing allowances and

         8       the pastors actually own their own properties

         9       and pay taxes on them anyway.  So I think that's

        10       getting to be less of a differentiation than

        11       originally it was.

        12                      However, you are correct, of

        13       course, that if a school district chose to

        14       charge tuition to the students in this

        15       particular institution that I'm discussing, they

        16       would have to charge taxes on all the other

        17       properties -- charge tuition to students

        18       residing in all the other exempt properties in

        19       the district.

        20                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Mr. President,

        21       if the Senator would continue to yield.

        22                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        23       Cook, do you continue to yield to Senator

        24       Paterson?

        25                      SENATOR COOK:  Yes, Senator







                                                             
1546

         1       Paterson.

         2                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

         3       Senator continues to yield.

         4                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Senator Cook,

         5       I'm actually in a way disappointed that you

         6       agreed with my statement, and the reason is

         7       because I think that the issue that you're

         8       trying to address does identify a real inequity

         9       and had it been the case that perhaps some of

        10       the local ministers that just live on the

        11       properties of their churches -- you know, had

        12       been a way to exempt them, perhaps this

        13       legislation would be more appealing to me, and

        14       you're probably right about the equal protection

        15       clause as it would extend to those ministers,

        16       which is why the nature of the bill concerns me

        17       to a great degree.

        18                      Therefore, what I'm suggesting

        19       takes us back to my original question which is

        20       there's got to be some kind of substitution,

        21       some kind of use tax or impact statement that

        22       could be assessed to the entity rather than the

        23       individuals, whereby the government would

        24       collect what it needs and the children would not

        25       be in any way punished, because my fear is that







                                                             
1547

         1       you're going to be assessing tuition to

         2       individuals who can't pay them and certainly

         3       their families are extending a great service to

         4       the local community.

         5                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President, I

         6       fail to see how, for example, the bill -- the

         7       other bill I mentioned which said that only the

         8       portion used for the tax-exempt purpose would be

         9       exempt.  That, of course, would also include the

        10       residents of the clergy member as taxable

        11       property.  In fact, it would be even more so

        12       because it would even include people who do not

        13       have -- who are not sending children to school

        14       because it would be a tax on the property.

        15                      Senator, let me just tell you, we

        16       have been trying to deal with this problem for

        17       more than a decade.  We had a meeting -- and I'm

        18       going into ancient history here, but we had a

        19       meeting in which we called all the religious

        20       organizations of the state, the Catholic

        21       bishops, the Catholic churches, the Jewish

        22       organizations.  We had representatives of the

        23       city of New York and we said to them, you know,

        24       you tell us what you think would work.  Their

        25       response was, yes, we will try to get back to







                                                             
1548

         1       you and find a solution to this problem.  The

         2       response after all these years has been

         3       absolutely nothing because they have felt that

         4       they have been able to successfully so far

         5       stonewall the issue and not get any action taken

         6       by this Legislature.

         7                      In the meantime, we have folks

         8       out there who are suffering under the burden of

         9       property taxes who probably are less able to pay

        10       the property taxes and the very people that

        11       you're trying to protect in your statement and

        12       who have no choice except to pay the taxes,

        13       whereas the other folks are getting a free

        14       ride.

        15                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        16       Paterson.

        17                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Mr. President,

        18       I want to thank Senator Cook for, I think, a

        19       pretty thorough explanation.

        20                      Speaking on the bill -

        21                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        22       Paterson, on the bill.

        23                      SENATOR PATERSON:  My concern

        24       over this legislation is the precedent that it

        25       may set.  If the religious institution rents out







                                                             
1549

         1       the property, would we then be charging the

         2       renter a tuition that they might not be able to

         3       pay to send their children to the public

         4       school?

         5                      In the situation of the minister,

         6       where the salary of the minister already assumes

         7       that the minister is not paying any property

         8       taxes because the entity, the religious

         9       institution is paying them, now we're going to

        10       assess the minister a tuition cost.  There are a

        11       lot of ministers who serve almost at the

        12       pleasure and don't really collect large sums of

        13       money from their churches.  So I think that the

        14       problem that Senator Cook is trying to address,

        15       interestingly enough, is better addressed by the

        16       other pieces of legislation that he referred to

        17       earlier which really would create the scenario

        18       whereby the government would be collecting what

        19       it certainly provides in services going around

        20       what would be the -- certainly the tax exemption

        21       in certain situations, but in the current piece

        22       of legislation that's before us, I think it

        23       would open up the door and make it very

        24       difficult for a number of outstanding ministers

        25       and other clergy in our institutions from







                                                             
1550

         1       serving us particularly well in an attempt to

         2       stop a process that does need to be stopped.  I

         3       just think that we're going to have to find a

         4       better way.

         5                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         6       Lachman.

         7                      SENATOR LACHMAN:  Would the

         8       distinguished Chairman of the Education

         9       Committee continue to yield?

        10                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        11       Cook, do you yield to Senator Lachman?

        12                      SENATOR COOK:  Well, I'll send

        13       out and ask him if he would come in.

        14                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        15       Senator yields.

        16                      SENATOR LACHMAN:  Senator Cook,

        17       how many children approximately are involved in

        18       this?

        19                      SENATOR COOK:  In this particular

        20       property, it's 30 -- about 30 children.

        21                      SENATOR LACHMAN:  About 30

        22       children.

        23                      SENATOR COOK:  It varies a little

        24       bit because, interestingly enough, to give a

        25       little bit of the scenario, these are often







                                                             
1551

         1       children of very wealthy, out-of-state people

         2       who simply come to this place and stay there for

         3       a period of time and attend the local schools.

         4       So it's sort of a changing population.

         5                      SENATOR LACHMAN:  I'll be

         6       discussing that on the bill in a few minutes.

         7       Will you continue to yield for another question

         8       or two?

         9                      SENATOR COOK:  Yes.

        10                      SENATOR LACHMAN:  Do you know of

        11       any precedent in this county or in the state of

        12       New York where children -- or the parents of

        13       children have to pay money even though they're

        14       residing in buildings which are tax-exempt,

        15       thereby denying them resident status and

        16       charging their children to attend the public

        17       schools of the district in which they live?

        18                      SENATOR COOK:  Senator, I don't

        19       believe that's possible under present law.

        20       That's what this law would -- what this bill

        21       would do is change the law so that would

        22       conceivably be possible.

        23                      SENATOR LACHMAN:  So what you're

        24       saying is that this is a precedent bill that

        25       would change the law, not only in your district







                                                             
1552

         1       in reference to 30 children but would change the

         2       law for the entire state of New York.

         3                      SENATOR COOK:  That's correct,

         4       Senator.  I would indicate, however, Senator,

         5       that the bill is a local option.  In other

         6       words, the district does not -- is not mandated

         7       to charge tuition.  It's their choice.

         8                      SENATOR LACHMAN:  I know that you

         9       have checked the constitutional issue, Senator

        10       Cook, because you are a very meticulous and

        11       intelligent person, but has the issue of

        12       constitutionality of establishing such a

        13       precedent in the state of New York arisen in

        14       your deliberations regarding this bill?

        15                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President, the

        16       issue of constitutionality is always raised

        17       whenever any of these tax exemption bills comes

        18       before us and, again, that is why in this case

        19       we believe we have responded to that because

        20       we're not taxing the exempt property, per se.

        21       We're putting -- to use Senator Paterson's

        22       words, we're really charging a service charge to

        23       the persons who reside on those properties.

        24                      SENATOR LACHMAN:  On the bill,

        25       Mr. Chairman.







                                                             
1553

         1                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         2       Lachman, on the bill.

         3                      SENATOR LACHMAN:  I understand

         4       Senator Cook's frustrations and the people who

         5       live in South Fallsburg in Sullivan County

         6       because this bill is even more complex than

         7       perhaps the Senator realizes and my colleagues

         8       realize.

         9                      It touches upon basic

        10       constitutional rights and it also impacts upon

        11       not only religious groups but what has been

        12       called by the New York -- the publication, The

        13       New Yorker, a group that might not necessarily

        14       be defined in the normative terms of religion

        15       but has been called by researchers a cult group.

        16                      Now, we are discussing a group

        17       known as Syda, S-y-d-a, Syda Yoga Dam, which is

        18       a multi-million-dollar complex in South

        19       Fallsburg, and if I'm wrong, Senator Cook,

        20       please correct me.  There are ashrams now in the

        21       hotel -- former hotels known as Brickman's,

        22       Gilbert's and I believe the Windsor and, at any

        23       one time, there could be 3,000 people at a

        24       particular ashram.

        25                      Now, in a recent article in The







                                                             
1554

         1       New Yorker magazine, as well as other articles

         2       that have appeared in Time Magazine and the

         3       Village Voice, this group was discussed, and I

         4       think the discussion impacts upon the

         5       educational issue we have before us.

         6                      The founder -- if I may for five

         7       minutes -- of Syda Yoga Dam or home of Syda Yoga

         8       was Swami Muktananda who died in October of

         9       1992.  He came to America in 1970 and founded

        10       this group.  According to his will, he was

        11       supposed to be succeeded by a sister and brother

        12       whose names are Gurumayi and Nityananda.

        13                      There was a violent split between

        14       these siblings, between the sister and brother

        15       and the sister came out on top.  Both sides have

        16       accused the other side of using brainwashing,

        17       sexual and physical abuse of women and children

        18       and the focusing of veneration upon an

        19       individual rather than a deity.  Both sides,

        20       according to The New Yorker article, have called

        21       the other group a cult group and not a religion,

        22       and that is a major issue because if it is

        23       accurate, it might not have tax exemption.  Some

        24       have even called this group a destructive cult.

        25                      Now, there is an agency in New







                                                             
1555

         1       York State known as the Interfaith Coalition of

         2       Concern About Cults which consists of

         3       Protestants, Catholics, Jews, people of Eastern

         4       Orthodox faith, Muslims and others and they have

         5       defined the destructive cult with three

         6       characteristics:

         7                      1.  A cult is a self- -- has a

         8       self-appointed Messianic leader who focuses his

         9       or her follower's veneration upon him or her

        10       claiming divine selection and exercising

        11       autocratic control over members;

        12                      2.  The use of deception and

        13       misrepresentation for the purposes of

        14       recruitment, retention and fund-raising;

        15                      3.  Using techniques aimed at

        16       controlling individuals' thought and personal

        17       privacy that frequently lead to coerced

        18       reconstruction of personality which means simply

        19       brainwashing.

        20                      Some have said in articles that I

        21       have read that this group falls within at least

        22       two if not all three criteria of a cult group.

        23                      Now, the bill before us proposes

        24       to punish children and parents residing in these

        25       buildings which are tax-exempt by denying them







                                                             
1556

         1       resident status and charging them to attend the

         2       public schools of the district where they

         3       reside.

         4                      I agree with NYSUT that this

         5       would be unfair, if not unconstituional.  Now,

         6       NYSUT recommends a use tax or impact fee upon

         7       the group's properties that are tax-exempt.

         8       Now, I have problems with that and I have

         9       discussed it with the NYSUT representatives.

        10                      A use tax in this nation is

        11       usually if not always used on a voluntary basis,

        12       usually for water and rarely, if ever, for

        13       education.  Since the tax on the building could

        14       be in violation of the First Amendment and the

        15       tax on the children and the parents would, as

        16       NYSUT states, violate the tradition of free

        17       public education, I would recommend that an

        18       exception be made for these 30 youngsters

        19       without taxing their parents and without taxing

        20       the buildings, and I recommend an exception

        21       because of all the children in the state of New

        22       York.  If these articles that I have read are to

        23       be believed, these are the children that need a

        24       free public education with free inquiry and free

        25       thought.  That is the American way.







                                                             
1557

         1                      I would, therefore, have to

         2       oppose this legislation.  Thank you.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The Chair

         4       recognizes Senator Dollinger.

         5                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Will the

         6       sponsor yield to a couple questions, Mr.

         7       President?

         8                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         9       Cook, do you yield to Senator Dollinger?

        10                      SENATOR COOK:  Yes, Mr.

        11       President.

        12                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        13       Senator yields.

        14                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Senator,

        15       could you just tell me, would this bill apply to

        16       children that are in group homes in a school

        17       district if that group home is owned by the

        18       state of New York?

        19                      SENATOR COOK:  Senator, I don't

        20       believe that under the definition of exempt

        21       properties, municipally-owned properties, that

        22       they would be liable.  However, it could apply

        23       to properties that are owned by non-profit

        24       organizations.

        25                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Okay.  We







                                                             
1558

         1       have a group home -- again, through you, Mr.

         2       President, if the sponsor would continue to

         3       yield.  We have a group home in the community I

         4       live in which is run by DFY.  The property is

         5       actually owned by the state of New York.  It is

         6       tax-exempt because it's owned by another

         7       municipal government.  There are about a dozen

         8       young men that live in that facility, are

         9       educated in the Brighton School District.  How

        10       would they pay tuition?

        11                      SENATOR COOK:  Well, as I

        12       indicated, Mr. President, those particular

        13       students, because they are living in a state

        14       owned property, would not be but -- because of

        15       other sections of law, the state simply doesn't

        16       -- isn't taxable, but I will not beg your

        17       question because there are certainly properties

        18       that are owned by non-profit organizations where

        19       they do have people attending schools, but I

        20       would indicate, Mr. President, that, in fact,

        21       there would be a tuition due the district and,

        22       in fact, this is a problem as well because,

        23       again, we are facing increasing opposition in

        24       the placement of group homes in school districts

        25       because that burden is, in fact, then absorbed







                                                             
1559

         1       by the local school district and the school

         2       district has no means of recouping any costs -

         3       any of its costs relative to those students.

         4                      So even though it's not the

         5       intent of this bill to address that particular

         6       problem, I think that it would -- it would, in

         7       fact, apply or could apply to those cases but

         8       it, in fact, may also be a remedy for a

         9       different problem that we have which is a matter

        10       of the communities that are getting saturated by

        11       group homes that are imposing costs upon local

        12       school districts for whom there's -- for which

        13       there is no reimbursement.

        14                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Through you,

        15       Mr. President.  In some of those cases, those

        16       group homes involve children who are wards of

        17       the particular local social service district or,

        18       in some cases, actually wards of the

        19       not-for-profit entity that places them in those

        20       homes.  Is it your intention that they would

        21       have to pay tuition?

        22                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President, I

        23       would assume that if someone is financially

        24       responsible for the bills of a particular child

        25       and there is a bill that -- charges levied







                                                             
1560

         1       against that child, that whoever is financially

         2       responsible for that child, indeed, becomes

         3       financially responsible for the charge, yes.

         4                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Again through

         5       you, Mr. President, if Senator Cook would

         6       continue to yield.  Is there anything in this

         7       bill that prevents the local school district

         8       from charging a tuition that would reflect the

         9       actual cost of educating a child who has

        10       enormous special needs that requires their

        11       placement in a group home?  As you know and I'm

        12       sure well aware, that cost would be many, many

        13       multiples of the tuition charge that a school

        14       district would otherwise set.  Is there anything

        15       that prevents the school district from charging

        16       the actual cost of special education for those

        17       special disabled populations?

        18                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President, I

        19       believe that the present law which permits

        20       school districts to charge aid tuition to

        21       students from other school districts -- and that

        22       already exists in law -- provides that it be a

        23       uniform tuition large, and I would indicate,

        24       Senator, as you know, that the school district

        25       does receive excess cost aid and various kinds







                                                             
1561

         1       of things from the state which help pay some of

         2       those costs.

         3                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  May

         4       ameliorate some of the costs.  Again through

         5       you, Mr. President, if the sponsor would

         6       continue to yield.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         8       Cook, do you continue to yield?  The Senator

         9       continues to yield.

        10                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  How would

        11       this apply in the case of a graduate student

        12       dormitory?  Again, I represent a community -

        13       the University of Rochester has a very

        14       substantial graduate student housing complex in

        15       one of my school districts.  There are many

        16       young children who are picked up by the buses

        17       every single day.  I assume, and I should add,

        18       that I'm not 100 percent sure, but I believe

        19       those apartment buildings are all tax-exempt as

        20       part of the university property.  Would they be

        21       included as well?

        22                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President,

        23       those properties could be included and, again,

        24       if the folks who reside and own homes in those

        25       school districts are picking up the cost of







                                                             
1562

         1       educating those students, I see no reason why

         2       those students shouldn't be required to pay a

         3       tuition cost.  It is, after all, a burden upon

         4       the other taxpayers in the district who are, in

         5       effect, subsidizing them.

         6                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Again through

         7       you, Mr. President.  Senator, are you familiar

         8       with the programs that are sponsored by DHCR and

         9       other entities that create a reduction in taxes

        10       for new homeowners in special property

        11       developments where they are exempt from all real

        12       property taxes for the first two years as an

        13       incentive for home ownership and, therefore,

        14       they phase in their school taxes over time so

        15       theoretically you could buy a house and not pay

        16       any real property taxes in the very first year;

        17       would this bill say to those people who are

        18       trying to be first-time buyers of homes, that

        19       instead of paying your property taxes for the

        20       schools, you have to go out and tuition finance

        21       the education of each of your children in that

        22       first year?

        23                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President,

        24       that is correct.  If the people are living in a

        25       tax-exempt property and they're sending children







                                                             
1563

         1       to the public school, they are, again,

         2       responsible for paying the cost of that

         3       education for the children, and I don't see how

         4       that violates the principle of helping people

         5       buy their property.  You know, we give that as a

         6       benefit, but I don't see where it's a right that

         7       we necessarily owe it to them.

         8                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Just a final

         9       question, Mr. President.  What does this do to

        10       the concept of the old vicarage, that is, in the

        11       Protestant churches, the home that is purchased

        12       usually on the church grounds, I assume, Senator

        13       -- and I don't know for a fact -- but I assume

        14       it's part of the tax-exempt status, that it

        15       doesn't pay real property taxes.  It's a benefit

        16       that's given to the vicar of the church so he

        17       can live in a property that is part of his

        18       salary.  They reduces his salary, he gets

        19       housing.  Would his children have to pay tuition

        20       as well?

        21                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President, if

        22       the school district were to impose that cost

        23       upon the -- were to impose a fee, that, indeed,

        24       would be the case, but let me also indicate, if

        25       I happen to live in a school district -- and I







                                                             
1564

         1       have a number of them in my area -- where the

         2       only such residences would be occupied by

         3       Protestant ministers, then why should I expect

         4       the Catholic residents and the Jewish residents

         5       to, in fact, subsidize the pastor of a

         6       Protestant church, which is basically what

         7       they're doing under the present law.

         8                      SENATOR DOLLINGER:  Thank you,

         9       Mr. Chairman.

        10                      I appreciate the candor of the

        11       Chairman of the Education Committee, but I'm

        12       going to oppose this bill.  I think that there

        13       are many obstacles to be faced in achieving

        14       access to public education.

        15                      I'm concerned because there are a

        16       number of things which I have tried to

        17       highlight, areas that we may not necessarily

        18       think of as tax exempt for a year but

        19       nonetheless are.  It would seem to me that if we

        20       were encouraging home ownership in my community,

        21       both in the city of Rochester, the town of

        22       Brighton, the town of Greece that I represent,

        23       and what we're doing is we're asking DHCR to

        24       come in with very innovative programs to allow

        25       the working poor to buy homes and as part of







                                                             
1565

         1       those programs, we absolve them from the

         2       obligation to pay real property taxes in the

         3       first year of ownership and phase in their

         4       payment of those taxes so that after a period of

         5       five years they are then at full assessment and

         6       are paying their full share, that's an incentive

         7       for them to own a home.

         8                      If what we do is say to those

         9       parents, we're going to give you an incentive to

        10       buy the house but, oh, by the way, you've got to

        11       come up with $8,000 or $6,000 or 5- -- and I

        12       believe in the communities that I represent, the

        13       going tuition rate is in excess of $6,000 -

        14       it's far more than what they would pay in real

        15       property taxes for schools.  So we end up in a

        16       situation where we give them an incentive to buy

        17       a home and then we immediately force them to go

        18       and pay tuition if their local school board

        19       decides that's appropriate.

        20                      I'm concerned about the vicarage,

        21       the fact that there's a church somewhere that

        22       has bought property for its minister to live in,

        23       that he or she has children and that suddenly a

        24       school district says we're now going to assess

        25       tuition on you even though you live in our







                                                             
1566

         1       school district.

         2                      Lastly, I'm concerned about the

         3       issue of group homes.  There's been a group home

         4       experiment in my community involving youths from

         5       DFY.  There are a dozen kids that live in that

         6       house.  It's right across from the Brighton Town

         7       Hall.  They've done a very good job in the

         8       Brighton School District in trying to bring them

         9       into the school district, to mainstream them, to

        10       make up for educational deficiencies.  The

        11       school district has done it, I believe without

        12       the payment of tuition.  I think what we ought

        13       to be doing is encouraging school districts to

        14       live up to their responsibilities so that

        15       everybody gets a free public education.

        16                      I'm concerned that the tuition

        17       costs will be far more than what they would

        18       otherwise pay in real property taxes and for

        19       those reasons -- I'm also concerned about the

        20       college dormitory.  I think that's another huge

        21       problem.  We should be encouraging people to

        22       take advantage of free public education.

        23                      This bill steps away from that.

        24       I understand why the New York State United

        25       Teachers oppose it.  I would urge my colleagues







                                                             
1567

         1       to do the same.

         2                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         3       Waldon, do you wish to speak on the bill?

         4       Senator Waldon?  Senator Waldon, I know you're

         5       having a wonderful conversation.

         6                      SENATOR WALDON:  I had had a

         7       discussion with the Majority Leader in regard to

         8       being permitted to vote no on Bill Number 36

         9       because there's a hearing of Racing and Wagering

        10       that I need to attend, Mr. President.  I don't

        11       know if that's appropriate at this moment.

        12                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  I would

        13       like to finish debate on this bill.

        14                      SENATOR WALDON:  That's fine.  I

        15       had that discussion and that was what I thought

        16       would happen.

        17                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  We'll

        18       move to Senator Stavisky.  We'll be back to take

        19       your vote in a moment then, Senator Waldon.

        20                      SENATOR STAVISKY:  Mr. Speaker, I

        21       heard the artful presentation of Senator

        22       Lachman, Senator Dollinger, and I do not wish to

        23       duplicate the points that they have raised.

        24                      In my district, the district that

        25       I represent for many years, was a military







                                                             
1568

         1       establishment known as Fort Totten located in

         2       Bayside and at Fort Totten, there were many and

         3       are still many military personnel who live

         4       there, who have families.

         5                      I would like to ask the sponsor

         6       of the legislation if he would yield.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         8       Cook, do you yield to Senator Stavisky?  The

         9       Senator yields.

        10                      SENATOR STAVISKY:  Senator Cook,

        11       are you suggesting that the military personnel

        12       who are at a place such as Fort Totten would be

        13       required to pay tuition for their children's

        14       education?

        15                      SENATOR COOK:  Mr. President, two

        16       responses to the Senator's question.  I would

        17       see nothing wrong with those military residents

        18       paying some tuition because, after all, it is, I

        19       assume, the city of New York then or the city of

        20       New York school district that is absorbing the

        21       cost of educating those students and most of

        22       those folks being military personnel probably

        23       aren't New York -- New York residents anyway,

        24       but the other side of the issue, Senator, is I

        25       would believe that since it's a federally-owned







                                                             
1569

         1       property, that probably we wouldn't be able to

         2       enforce this on the federally-owned property, I

         3       guess.

         4                      SENATOR STAVISKY:  Mr. Speaker,

         5       on the bill.

         6                      We have a problem here.  The

         7       problem is the failure of the United States

         8       government to pay for the cost of the education

         9       of the children since the United States

        10       government is exempt from the imposition of

        11       school property taxes.

        12                      I think that those of you who

        13       have a concern for military personnel whose

        14       salaries are not usually very great, would be

        15       forewarned not to vote for this bill which would

        16       cause a soldier, any military personnel living

        17       at Fort Totten who has children and they do

        18       attend the public school to pay tuition.  I

        19       think this is a very dangerous precedent that

        20       does a great disservice to those people who are

        21       serving our nation.  The nation should pay the

        22       tax.  The nation should pay in lieu of taxation

        23       but not the individual family, and for that

        24       reason and the others that have already been

        25       stated, I would hope the members of this body







                                                             
1570

         1       would defeat this bill.

         2                      Thank you.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Is there

         4       any other Senator wishing to speak on the bill?

         5                      (There was no response.)

         6                      Hearing none, the Secretary will

         7       read the last section.

         8                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 2.  This

         9       act shall take effect on the first day of

        10       September.

        11                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        12       roll.

        13                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        14                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Announce

        15       the results when tabulated.

        16                      SENATOR STAVISKY:  I'm going to

        17       explain my vote, Mr. Speaker.

        18                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        19       Stavisky, to explain his vote.

        20                      SENATOR STAVISKY:  I do not wish

        21       to limit my presentation to Fort Totten.  Think

        22       of what it would do to the people at West Point,

        23       the families living at West Point whom we honor

        24       here regularly with resolutions.  Think of

        25       that.







                                                             
1571

         1                      There are many other

         2       installations, federal installations, military

         3       installations throughout the state but think of

         4       West Point, and do you want to tax the parents,

         5       the service people who live at West Point with a

         6       school tax?  I think that would be, again, a

         7       very serious error.

         8                      I vote in the negative.

         9                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        10       Stavisky will be recorded in the negative.

        11       Announce the results.

        12                      THE SECRETARY:  Those recorded in

        13       the negative on Calendar Number 150, Senator

        14       Abate, Breslin, Connor, Dollinger, Gentile,

        15       Kruger, Lachman, Leichter, Markowitz, Mendez,

        16       Montgomery, Onorato, Paterson, Rosado, Sampson,

        17       Santiago, Seabrook, Smith, Stavisky and Waldon.

        18       Ayes 36, nays 20.

        19                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

        20       is passed.

        21                      Excuse me, Senator Leichter.

        22                      Senator Waldon.

        23                      SENATOR WALDON:  With unanimous

        24       consent, Mr. President, I would like to be

        25       recorded out of order in the way we're







                                                             
1572

         1       considering bills on Calendar Number 36 in the

         2       negative.  You have to read the last section.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         4       Alesi.

         5                      SENATOR ALESI:  Mr. President,

         6       would you please call Calendar 36.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

         8       Secretary -- before we do that, Senator

         9       Leichter, why do you rise?

        10                      SENATOR LEICHTER:  May I, before

        11       we get in the debate on that bill, have

        12       unanimous consent to be recorded in the negative

        13       on Calendar 110.

        14                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Without

        15       objection.

        16                      SENATOR LEICHTER:  Thank you.

        17                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Hearing

        18       no objection, Senator Leichter will be recorded

        19       in the negative on Calendar Number 110 -- 110.

        20                      SENATOR ALESI:  Mr. President,

        21       Calendar Number 36.

        22                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  That

        23       completed the calling of the controversial

        24       calendar's first reading.  Would you like to

        25       take up Calendar Number 36?







                                                             
1573

         1                      SENATOR ALESI:  Yes, Mr.

         2       President.  Would you please read the last

         3       section so that Senator Waldon may have the

         4       opportunity to vote.

         5                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Why don't

         6       we get the bill before the house, Senator

         7       Alesi.  We'll do that.

         8                      The Secretary will read the title

         9       to Calendar Number 36.

        10                      THE SECRETARY:  Calendar Number

        11       36, by Senator Velella, Senate Print 355-A, an

        12       act to amend the General City Law and the Penal

        13       Law, in relation to creating the crimes of

        14       urinating in public.

        15                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Read the

        16       last section.

        17                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 7.  This

        18       act shall take effect on the first day of

        19       November.

        20                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        21       roll.

        22                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        23                      SENATOR WALDON:  No.

        24                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        25       Waldon, you vote in the negative?







                                                             
1574

         1                      SENATOR WALDON:  In the negative.

         2                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The roll

         3       call is withdrawn.  We'll return to debate on

         4       Calendar Number 36.  We're on debate on Calendar

         5       Number 36.

         6                      Senator Montgomery.

         7                      SENATOR MONTGOMERY:  Yes, Mr.

         8       President.  I am not going to ask the sponsor to

         9       answer any questions because I think the bill is

        10       self-explanatory, although we have -- several

        11       members have indicated that there are other

        12       titles of this legislation, none of which can be

        13       stated in the record.

        14                      However, I would like to just

        15       reiterate what my comments were last year in

        16       relationship to this bill.  It seems to

        17       establish a criminal penalty for such behaviors

        18       as begging and urinating in public as well as, I

        19       believe urinating and begging and defecating, I

        20       believe is also included in this bill.

        21                      As I said last year, there is an

        22       attempt with the legislation to address a major

        23       social crisis which is essentially homelessness,

        24       I believe, by establishing criminality and

        25       criminal penalties for these behaviors, such







                                                             
1575

         1       that a person who is sleeping on the streets or

         2       a person who has no facility to relieve

         3       themselves appropriately, in an appropriate

         4       place, or a person who is attempting to receive

         5       charity by asking as an individual on the street

         6       with a cup in their hand, can now be sanctioned

         7       with a Class B misdemeanor charge.

         8                      All of those behaviors, we know,

         9       are abhorrent to all of us in this room and I

        10       believe to all of our neighbors and people -

        11       civilized people who live in our cities across

        12       the state, but I don't believe any of us would

        13       like to see the social -- the social problem of

        14       homelessness addressed by trying to criminalize

        15       them.  We know that we've tried these kinds of

        16       remedies in other instances and they have not

        17       worked, and so to try and address a symptom of a

        18       major social problem by establishing criminality

        19       just does not work and we may, in fact, end up

        20       with an increase in the population that we're

        21       trying to address in reducing that population,

        22       mainly prison population, by adding to it with

        23       these kinds of petty behaviors, behaviors that

        24       are really not criminal but are indications of a

        25       social breakdown.







                                                             
1576

         1                      So, Senator Velella, I certainly

         2       must oppose your legislation, not because I'm

         3       opposed to what you would like to see happen,

         4       and that is you would like to see people not be

         5       begging on the street and not be sleeping on the

         6       street and not be urinating in your front yard

         7       perhaps and mine, but because I think that we

         8       need to look for other means of remedying these

         9       problems and not to make criminals of them and,

        10       in fact, you indicate at one point -- just to

        11       read one little part of the bill -- you want to

        12       order them to perform community service if they

        13       can't pay the penalty of $50 which you would

        14       establish in the legislation, and so they're

        15       already homeless, penniless and you are also

        16       going to require of them community service.  I

        17       don't know how that's going to work, who is

        18       going to have them work and where would you have

        19       them perform the community service and who would

        20       likely be pleased to have these people

        21       performing community service?  They need

        22       treatment, obviously.  They need a home.  They

        23       need a lot more of what we have not been

        24       providing for them but certainly they don't need

        25       to be charged with a crime.







                                                             
1577

         1                      So I'm voting no on this, Mr.

         2       President.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Is there

         4       any other Senator wishing to speak on the bill?

         5                      (There was no response.)

         6                      Hearing none, the Secretary will

         7       read the last section.  Oh, I'm sorry.  Senator

         8       Seabrook.

         9                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Will the

        10       sponsor yield for a couple of questions?

        11                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator?

        12                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Certainly.

        13                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        14       Senator yields.

        15                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Senator, just

        16       a quick question, if you could possibly just

        17       define two things for me.  What is considered

        18       this urban commercial zone and how is that

        19       defined and who dictates what that zone is?

        20                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Well, the

        21       person -- the entity that would dictate the

        22       commercial zone under the guidelines set in the

        23       bill would be the local government.  So, in your

        24       case and in mine, for example, we both represent

        25       the city of New York and we both represent the







                                                             
1578

         1       city of Mount Vernon.  That local government

         2       would decide what would be these commercial

         3       zones that people would not be allowed to lie

         4       down in the streets in front of commercial

         5       establishments and we have a safety valve on

         6       that that no more than 15 percent of the streets

         7       of the City could be set aside as these critical

         8       commercial zones.

         9                      I would hope that you would read

        10       the bill rather than listen to what our

        11       distinguished colleague from Brooklyn has said

        12       because apparently the lapse of time from last

        13       year's debate to this year's debate has clouded

        14       her mind, and I would suggest she goes back and

        15       reads the bill because everything she said is

        16       absolutely wrong.

        17                      We do not mandate B misdemeanors

        18       in this bill.  We say it's a violation and, if

        19       you repeat it again, like we do in all the

        20       criminal laws and all the statutes, if you

        21       repeat the crime, it elevates it to the next

        22       level, a battery of things which she chose not

        23       to ask me questions but if you would like to, I

        24       would be happy to explain.  She's just dead

        25       wrong on what she said.







                                                             
1579

         1                      It is not about social problems.

         2       It's about quality of life issues and about

         3       cleaning up our communities and making people

         4       behave in a socially responsible matter -

         5       manner and not to have people begging and put

         6       people in fear of imminent bodily harm that, if

         7       they don't respond to a beggar in an aggressive

         8       manner, they might be injured in some way.  That

         9       is what we're talking about.

        10                      I agree with it.  There are a lot

        11       of social problems, things that we need to

        12       address and we will address, but one of the

        13       things that we need to address is the quality of

        14       life in our cities.  Mayor Dinkins, when we had

        15       the Democratic National Convention, made a very

        16       aggressive stand on cleaning up the streets down

        17       in Manhattan, so that the Democratic delegates

        18       across the City, across the country wouldn't see

        19       the people lying in the streets, the people

        20       interfering with delegates from across the

        21       country.  We had Manhattan -- it was a jewel.  I

        22       would like to see that all over, even in our

        23       borough, and I think this is a law that we would

        24       follow Mayor Dinkins' pattern.  We would say

        25       we're not going to tolerate that kind of







                                                             
1580

         1       behavior.  We didn't want the rest of the

         2       country to see it.  Dave Dinkins didn't want to

         3       have the rest of the country see it.  I don't

         4       want the rest of the country -- I don't want my

         5       constituents to see that kind of behavior,

         6       defecating in the streets, urinating in the

         7       streets, threatening people that, if they don't

         8       give you money, they might have some kind of

         9       danger, interfering with our commercial

        10       establishments.  Those are all things that bring

        11       our city down, whether it be Mount Vernon,

        12       whether it be New York City or whether it be any

        13       city.

        14                      We ought to follow Dave Dinkins'

        15       lead, and I think he has a pretty strong social

        16       conscience.  I think he did a pretty good thing

        17       in setting that example.  I want to follow his

        18       lead.  People who break those laws ought to be

        19       punished and, if they can't afford to pay a

        20       fine, maybe we ought to let them do community

        21       service.  Do what?  Clean up after themselves.

        22       They're making the messes in the streets,

        23       community service.  Let them clean up after

        24       themselves.  That's what the bill is about,

        25       Senator.







                                                             
1581

         1                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Would the

         2       Senator yield?

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         4       Velella, do you continue to yield?

         5                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Yes.

         6                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

         7       Senator yields.

         8                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Just a -

         9                      SENATOR VELELLA:  I know that

        10       wasn't a very direct answer but I had to get it

        11       in.

        12                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Just because

        13       -- some clarification.  A person who has to

        14       relieve themselves is a natural act so it's

        15       going to take place either in a proper place or

        16       an improper place.  What proper places are

        17       available in the districts in which we

        18       represent, in the Bronx and in Mount Vernon,

        19       that's public accessible in the Bronx and Mount

        20       Vernon, even if someone has to put a coin in?

        21                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Senator, off

        22       the top of my head, we have facilities that the

        23       parks department has available.  We have

        24       restaurants.  We have establishments.  We have

        25       many places where, when you're walking through







                                                             
1582

         1       the streets of Manhattan, when you're walking

         2       through the streets of our district, when you're

         3       walking up in Mount Vernon in our district, if

         4       you have to go to the men's room or have to

         5       relieve yourself naturally, I don't believe

         6       under any circumstances you would relieve

         7       yourself on the streets of Manhattan, the

         8       streets of Mount Vernon or the streets of the

         9       Bronx.  You would find a proper place to do it,

        10       and that's all I'm asking the rest of these

        11       people to do.  Find a proper place, whether it

        12       be a public facility like a park where we have

        13       park rest rooms.  We have them in Mount Vernon.

        14       We have them in the Bronx.  We have them in

        15       various places.  There are public facilities.

        16       We don't have enough but we all manage to follow

        17       the social behavior of not doing it in the

        18       street.  You wouldn't do it.  I wouldn't do it,

        19       and I don't think anybody else should do it.

        20       That's all I'm saying.  Whatever the problem is

        21       that when you have that emergency, you find a

        22       place to go to, I'm asking them to perform to

        23       the same level.

        24                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Well, Senator,

        25       I think that in some cases -- I don't know about







                                                             
1583

         1       you, but there have been times on various roads

         2       on a number of occasions that I've witnessed

         3       other people do it when they didn't have access

         4       but nature made its call and it was done, but in

         5       terms of the parks that you raised an issue, the

         6       majority of the parks -- I would say that the

         7       overwhelming majority of the parks in New York

         8       City and in the Bronx, in particular, you don't

         9       have access to the public bathrooms.

        10                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Some you do,

        11       some you don't.

        12                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  In the

        13       majority of the cases where those people who

        14       actually are residing -- then there are also

        15       signs that says "rest rooms for patrons only",

        16       that if you aren't eating here, you aren't

        17       drinking here, then you can't use the facility.

        18       So basically these are people who, if you don't

        19       have any money, you can't go in.  There's no

        20       access.  There's not one paid public toilet in

        21       your district or my district that the public

        22       actually have access to.  Maybe a few in

        23       Manhattan but not in your district or my

        24       district.

        25                      SENATOR VELELLA:  I disagree with







                                                             
1584

         1       that, Senator.

         2                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Can you name

         3       one and show me where?

         4                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Oh, I know

         5       several parks that have park attendants there

         6       during the day and the facilities are open.

         7                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  No.  I said

         8       public paying toilets -- public paying toilets.

         9                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Oh, public

        10       paid?

        11                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Right.

        12                      SENATOR VELELLA:  I'm sorry.

        13       No.  I don't know of any paying toilets.  I know

        14       of free ones.

        15                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Well, if you

        16       could -- you know of free ones that's available

        17       in your district right now?

        18                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Yes, sir.  I

        19       could name you several parks that have open

        20       toilet facilities where they have park personnel

        21       during the day for people who have to relieve

        22       themselves in public.

        23                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  You're

        24       probably right.  In your district, you're

        25       probably right.  You're absolutely correct.







                                                             
1585

         1       That's true, but in a place where a lot of the

         2       homeless people are, they have actually

         3       padlocked the parks.  So what I'm saying -- and

         4       I agree with some portions of the bill in terms

         5       of a person, but if we gave people access and

         6       options that they would not have to urinate on

         7       the streets, but in New York City, in Manhattan,

         8       there are paid public toilets that people can

         9       actually pay and have access to go to so that

        10       they would not urinate.

        11                      In the Bronx, there is not one

        12       paid public toilet that people actually have

        13       access to go in to relieve themselves, so they

        14       do it wherever.  Subway stations that used to

        15       have access to this have actually padlocked all

        16       of their rest rooms unless you're in Grand

        17       Central Station or Penn Station that you have

        18       access to that.

        19                      So what I'm saying, if we're

        20       talking about not allowing people just as, you

        21       know, I have seen people decide to allow -- to

        22       release themselves on the New York State

        23       Thruway, couldn't make a rest stop, decided to

        24       relieve themselves, some in perfect business

        25       attire.  The majority of them aren't homeless







                                                             
1586

         1       because they couldn't get a car.  So they are

         2       basically using whatever when nature makes that

         3       call.

         4                      What I'm saying is that

         5       opportunity, if we were to provide in those

         6       areas that you're talking about, those

         7       commercial zoned areas, public access to rest

         8       rooms, then I would say that this would be a

         9       good bill, but if we're telling a person, we're

        10       not going to provide you with -- you look very

        11       bad.  You can't come into the facility because

        12       you don't have the monies, now you make a

        13       decision where you want to release yourself.

        14       Nature calls, it's any place.  I'm saying that

        15       if we're going to talk about commercial zones

        16       and we're going to develop these places, then we

        17       should have people having access to public

        18       facilities in some capacities so that would

        19       allow them to do that.  Other than that, it's a

        20       very punitive thing for a natural thing that is

        21       going to happen if you don't have access to a

        22       rest room or facility.

        23                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Is that a

        24       question?

        25                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Yeah.  I asked







                                                             
1587

         1       you in reference to the commercial zone by

         2       saying that, if these provisions would dictate

         3       that if you're going to have a commercial zone

         4       area, then they should have -- at least have

         5       public bathrooms available in those zones so

         6       that a person would have an option and an

         7       opportunity.

         8                      SENATOR VELELLA:  In response,

         9       Mr. Chairman -- Mr. President, through you.  The

        10       bill doesn't only require that you not go to the

        11       bathroom and defecate or urinate in a commercial

        12       zone.  It says anywhere in the city.  The

        13       question of lying in doorways and sleeping on

        14       doorways is for commercial zones.  So this would

        15       be citywide or statewide in any city where you

        16       urinate or defecate on the public streets, you

        17       would be subject to a fine.

        18                      Now, I agree with you.  It

        19       becomes very difficult.  I am sure you have in

        20       your lifetime been in a situation where you had

        21       to relieve yourself and had to seek out a

        22       bathroom, and I am sure ultimately you found one

        23       some way, some how.  I don't believe that we

        24       ought to set a social policy in this state that

        25       says, if you can't find the right place, just do







                                                             
1588

         1       it anywhere you want.

         2                      Now, that is the problem that we

         3       have.  We have people that are using our

         4       streets, especially in the city of New York, as

         5       public rest rooms.  We've got to stop that and

         6       we've got to try to tell these people that you

         7       don't do that and, if you do do it, you're

         8       breaking the law.

         9                      Now, I can't envision anybody

        10       wanting to say that if you really have to go bad

        11       enough, go ahead and go on the sidewalk.  Go

        12       ahead and go any place you want.  We have to

        13       have some degree of civil concern about the

        14       health and safety and propriety in our

        15       communities and we cannot tolerate people going

        16       to the bathroom on the public streets, whether

        17       they're homeless -- the areas you spoke about,

        18       they have homeless shelters.  They can go to the

        19       homeless shelter.  Be a little bit responsible

        20       about your personal concern for your fellow

        21       man.  Just because you're poor, it doesn't mean

        22       you have to act like a pig and pigs go in the

        23       street.  You know, unless there's an emergency

        24       -- and this is an intentional act.  We are

        25       trying to tell people we will not tolerate this







                                                             
1589

         1       kind of behavior.  It's unhealthy.  It's

         2       anti-social and it's wrong and whether you're

         3       rich, poor or middle class, you shouldn't be

         4       going in the street, and that's all I'm saying.

         5                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         6       Seabrook.

         7                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Yes, on the

         8       bill.

         9                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        10       Seabrook, on the bill.

        11                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  I think that

        12       the bill, as it is, doesn't deal with the

        13       problems in terms of saying that there are

        14       options and opportunities for people who have a

        15       desire.  I dare say that if we did not have the

        16       facilities here, then all of us in our attire

        17       would do just what a homeless person would do

        18       and some might do worse if the facilities were

        19       not made available.

        20                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Would Senator

        21       Seabrook yield to a question?

        22                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Absolutely.

        23                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        24       Seabrook, do you yield?  The Senator yields.

        25                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Senator, are







                                                             
1590

         1       you telling me that, if the bathrooms in this

         2       building were closed and you had to go to the

         3       men's room, you would go anywhere you can in

         4       this building?

         5                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  If nature made

         6       that call, it would dictate where I would go.

         7                      SENATOR VELELLA:  You'd go right

         8       here in the middle of the floor of the Senate?

         9                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  If nature made

        10       that call, it would dictate where you and I

        11       would go.

        12                      SENATOR VELELLA:  I will do

        13       everything in my power, Senator, to see that we

        14       protect you from yourself and keep the bathrooms

        15       in this building open at all times because I

        16       wouldn't go in here on the floor.  Maybe you

        17       might.

        18                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Did you

        19       have another question, Senator?

        20                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Yeah.  The

        21       question that I have for Senator Velella is that

        22       I would certainly like to see -

        23                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        24       Velella, do you yield?

        25                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Yes.







                                                             
1591

         1                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  He

         2       yields.

         3                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Senator

         4       Velella, I would just like to ask how you would

         5       certainly supersede natural calling, but since

         6       you have that ability and capability, I would

         7       hope that we would pass a resolution that we

         8       would eliminate all of the rest rooms from here

         9       to New York City and Senator Velella will show

        10       us how not to do what we are supposed to do when

        11       nature calls.

        12                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        13       Seabrook, would you mind the interpretation?

        14       Senator Paterson is waving like he has a natural

        15       calling.  (Laughter)

        16                      Senator Paterson, why do you

        17       rise?

        18                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Well,

        19       actually, Mr. President, Senator Abate has to

        20       leave immediately for a very similar reason.  We

        21       would like to know if she could relieve herself

        22       of voting before she relieves herself.

        23                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        24       Alesi.

        25                      SENATOR ALESI:  Mr. President,







                                                             
1592

         1       would you please call the last section in order

         2       to accommodate Senator Abate.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

         4       Secretary will read the last section.

         5                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 7.  This

         6       act shall take effect on 1st first day of

         7       November.

         8                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

         9       roll.

        10                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        11                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        12       Abate, how do you vote?

        13                      SENATOR ABATE:  No, and I wish I

        14       could speak on the bill but I cannot, but for

        15       the reasons I stated last year, I agree with the

        16       intent and not the wording of this bill.  Too

        17       vague and too broad.  I look forward to working

        18       with the Senator to correct that language.

        19                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        20       Abate will be recorded in the negative.

        21                      SENATOR ABATE:  Thank you.

        22                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The roll

        23       call is withdrawn.  We're back on debate.

        24       Senator Seabrook, you had the floor.

        25                      Senator Leichter, why do you







                                                             
1593

         1       rise?

         2                      SENATOR LEICHTER:  Before you

         3       withdraw the roll call, would you call my name,

         4       please?

         5                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  I already

         6       did.

         7                      Senator Alesi.

         8                      SENATOR ALESI:  No objection, Mr.

         9       President.

        10                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        11       Secretary will read the last section.

        12                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 7.  This

        13       act shall take effect on the 1st day of

        14       November.

        15                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        16       roll.

        17                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        18                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        19       Leichter, how do you vote?

        20                      SENATOR LEICHTER:  Thank you, Mr.

        21       President.

        22                      Edifying as this debate is and

        23       the high level that it's reached, I'm sorry to

        24       have to leave.  For reasons unrelated to the -

        25                      SENATOR SKELOS:  Mr. President.







                                                             
1594

         1                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         2       Skelos.

         3                      SENATOR SKELOS:  We're trying to

         4       accommodate people that have urgent business to

         5       go back to their district.  If they want to

         6       vote, they can vote, but a lot of people are

         7       staying here listening to the debate.  We know

         8       it's a getaway day.  We understand that, but I

         9       would ask if we're going to make accommodations

        10       on voting, vote and please conduct your

        11       business.

        12                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        13       Leichter, how do you vote?

        14                      SENATOR LEICHTER:  Thank you.

        15       It's a fair statement.  I vote in the negative.

        16                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        17       Leichter will be recorded in the negative.

        18                      Senator Paterson.

        19                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Mr. President,

        20       I would just like to agree with the Deputy

        21       Majority Leader.  Whatever the urgencies are

        22       that people have to leave this chamber and as

        23       urgently as they make it sound when they come

        24       over here and ask me, it would seem to me that a

        25       simple no vote would suffice.







                                                             
1595

         1                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Thank

         2       you.  Points are both well taken.

         3                      The roll call is withdrawn.

         4       We're back on debate.

         5                      Senator Seabrook.

         6                      SENATOR SEABROOK:  Mr. President,

         7       I won't belabor this too long because I have to

         8       make a stop myself.  So I'm going to be very,

         9       very quick and make sure that it would not be in

        10       this room, Senator Velella, but I would hope

        11       that people would -- when we decide to do these

        12       things and that Senator Velella would look about

        13       putting a lot more public accessibility to

        14       facilities so that people would do that, and I

        15       agree with him in terms of the intent of what

        16       he's trying to do, but I'm saying that there

        17       should be some options and opportunities for

        18       people, and I'm certain that they will

        19       understand the necessity of doing it in the

        20       proper place.

        21                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Is there

        22       any other Senator wishing to speak on the bill?

        23                      (There was no response.)

        24                      Hearing none, the Secretary -

        25                      SENATOR VELELLA:  Just to close







                                                             
1596

         1       debate -- I would like to speak briefly on the

         2       bill in closing the debate.

         3                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         4       Velella.

         5                      SENATOR VELELLA:  I would just

         6       like to point out to my colleagues, Senator

         7       Seabrook said he would like to cut the debate a

         8       little short because he has to make a stop on

         9       the way.  Senator Abate had a personal matter

        10       that had to be attended to.  All this shows is

        11       that where there is a will, there is a way, and

        12       I say that if we can do it, everybody else can

        13       do it and this bill is a good, solid bill.

        14                      Thank you.

        15                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        16       Secretary will read the last section.

        17                      THE SECRETARY:  Section 7.  This

        18       act shall take effect on the 1st day of

        19       November.

        20                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Call the

        21       roll.

        22                      (The Secretary called the roll.)

        23                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Announce

        24       the results when tabulated.

        25                      THE SECRETARY:  Those recorded in







                                                             
1597

         1       the negative on Calendar Number 36, Senators

         2       Abate, Breslin, Connor, Gonzalez, Leichter,

         3       Montgomery, Paterson, Sampson, Santiago,

         4       Seabrook, Smith, Stavisky and Waldon.  Also

         5       Senator Mendez.  Ayes 44, nays 14.

         6                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The bill

         7       is passed.

         8                      Senator Oppenheimer.

         9                      SENATOR OPPENHEIMER:  With

        10       unanimous consent, I would like to be recorded

        11       in the negative on Calendar 150.

        12                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Without

        13       objection, hearing no objection, Senator

        14       Oppenheimer will be recorded in the negative on

        15       Calendar Number 150.

        16                      Senator Gonzalez.

        17                      SENATOR GONZALEZ:  Mr. President,

        18       may I be recorded in the negative on Calendar

        19       Number 150.

        20                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Without

        21       objection.

        22                      SENATOR GONZALEZ:  Thank you.

        23                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Hearing

        24       no objection, Senator Gonzalez will be recorded

        25       in the negative on Calendar Number 150.







                                                             
1598

         1                      Senator Marcellino.

         2                      SENATOR MARCELLINO:  Mr.

         3       President, I recently read in the paper that one

         4       of our colleagues, who I will not name, has

         5       decided not to seek another office and has

         6       decided to remain part of this body and I, for

         7       one, am glad that that individual did that

         8       because I don't think this body would be the

         9       same without him and I'm pleased that he or she,

        10       because I won't identify him, has decided to

        11       remain.

        12                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        13       Alesi.

        14                      SENATOR ALESI:  Mr. President,

        15       may we return to the order of motions and

        16       resolutions, please.

        17                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  We'll

        18       return to the standing order of motions and

        19       resolutions.

        20                      SENATOR ALESI:  Mr. President,

        21       there is a privileged resolution at the desk by

        22       Senators Bruno and Rath.  May we please read the

        23       title and move its immediate adoption.

        24                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  The

        25       Secretary will read the title.







                                                             
1599

         1                      THE SECRETARY:  By Senators Bruno

         2       and Rath, Legislative Resolution commending the

         3       women of New York State government in

         4       designating them for honor in conjunction with

         5       the celebration of Women's History Month, March

         6       1997.

         7                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

         8       Rath.

         9                      SENATOR RATH:  Mr. President, I

        10       would like to invite all my colleagues to join

        11       me on this resolution, as I'm sure all of us are

        12       willing and anxious, enthusiastic about

        13       commending the women of New York State

        14       government in Women's History Month.

        15                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Are there

        16       any members who would like to co-sponsor the

        17       resolution?

        18                      Senator Marchi, everybody?

        19                      Senator Alesi, if it's okay with

        20       you, standard procedure, we'll put everybody on

        21       the resolution with Senator Rath excepting those

        22       people who indicate to the desk that they don't

        23       wish to co-sponsor, if they would do so.

        24                      Senator Paterson, why do you

        25       rise?







                                                             
1600

         1                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Mr. President,

         2       just a note of inquiry.  Is Senator Marcellino

         3       on that resolution?

         4                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  He is

         5       now.

         6                      SENATOR PATERSON:  Oh, good.  I

         7       would be pleased to be on it because there's no

         8       one harder working in government than Senator

         9       Marcellino.

        10                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Senator

        11       Alesi.

        12                      SENATOR ALESI:  Mr. President, is

        13       there any housekeeping at the desk?

        14                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  All has

        15       been taken care of, Senator Alesi.

        16                      SENATOR ALESI:  Thank you.

        17                      There being no further business,

        18       I move we adjourn until Monday, March 17th, at

        19       3:00 p.m., intervening days being legislative

        20       days.

        21                      ACTING PRESIDENT KUHL:  Without

        22       objection, hearing no objection, the Senate

        23       stands adjourned until Monday, March 17th, at

        24       3:00 p.m. in the afternoon, all intervening days

        25       to be legislative days.







                                                             
1601

         1                      (Whereupon, at 12:19 p.m., the

         2       Senate adjourned.)

         3

         4

         5

         6

         7

         8

         9

        10