Regular Session - January 6, 1999

                                                              1



                           NEW YORK STATE SENATE





                          THE STENOGRAPHIC RECORD







                             ALBANY, NEW YORK

                             January  6, 1999

                                12:05 p.m.



                              REGULAR SESSION





                 LT. GOVERNOR MARY O. DONOHUE, President

                 STEVEN M. BOGGESS, Secretary



















                                                          2



                           P R O C E E D I N G S

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senate will now

                 come to order.

                            I ask that everyone present please

                 rise and recite with me the Pledge of

                 Allegiance.

                            (Whereupon, the assemblage recited

                 the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The invocation

                 today will be given by the Most Reverend

                 Howard J. Hubbard, Bishop of the Roman

                 Catholic Diocese of Albany.

                            BISHOP HUBBARD:    Let us pray.  O

                 gracious and eternal God, this new year of

                 1999 brings us ever closer to the year 2000

                 and challenges us to a vigorous renewal of our

                 efforts towards securing peace and justice for

                 all Your people, so many still torn by

                 violence, diversion and oppression.

                            Bless us, we pray, O faithful God,

                 who have gathered here for the opening day of

                 the 1999 session of the New York State Senate.

                 In Your caring providence, O God, of us all,

                 You have emboldened and enabled leaders in

                 every generation to respond to the people's





                                                          3



                 needs, dreams and concerns through wise and

                 courageous leadership and in accordance with

                 the principles of just and compassionate

                 government.  The unchanged purpose of this

                 gathering is the reaffirmation and renewal by

                 our elected representatives, first, of their

                 service of the dignitary needs and aspirations

                 of all of the people of New York State and,

                 secondly, of steadfast stewardship, both of

                 which are central to the responsibilities of

                 public servants.

                            You have endowed our leaders, O

                 God, with diverse gifts, such as those of

                 wisdom, foresight, imagination, compassion,

                 integrity, common sense and a saving sense of

                 humor.  Thus we pray, the gifts that our

                 Governor, Lieutenant Governor, our Legislators

                 bring to the public service of our people.

                            Enable those in government to pool

                 their very gifts and to channel their efforts

                 and energies to address courageously the

                 issues and serious concerns of so many people,

                 including homelessness, hunger, unemployment,

                 substance abuse, violence and the ongoing

                 deterioration of the environment.





                                                          4



                            Embolden, we pray, our governmental

                 leaders and representatives to strive together

                 for the common good and for a realistic

                 response to the special needs of those who

                 suffer deprivation in various forms.

                            We pray, O God, that You will bless

                 us all with increasing reverence for and

                 support of the integrity and the strength of

                 the diverse racial, ethnic, religious and

                 socioeconomic backgrounds and cultures of the

                 people of this, our great Empire  State.

                            And for all this we pray, O caring

                 God of us all, in praise of Your loving

                 providence and in Your sacred name, You who

                 live and reign both now and forever and ever.

                 Amen.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Thank you.  Thank

                 you very much.

                            The Chair now hands down a message

                 from the State Board of Elections, being the

                 official certification of the duly elected

                 members of the Senate and directs that the

                 same be filed.

                            So ordered.

                            I'd like to ask if there are any





                                                          5



                 Senators present who have not yet taken their

                 oaths of office.

                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

                 will now call the roll to ascertain a quorum.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Alesi.

                            SENATOR ALESI:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Balboni.

                            SENATOR BALBONI:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Bonacic.

                            SENATOR BONACIC:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Breslin.

                            SENATOR BRESLIN:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Connor.

                            SENATOR CONNOR:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator DeFrancisco.

                            SENATOR DeFRANCISCO:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Dollinger.

                            SENATOR DOLLINGER:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Duane.

                            SENATOR DUANE:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Farley.

                            SENATOR FARLEY:    Here.





                                                          6



                            SECRETARY:    Senator Fuschillo.

                            SENATOR FUSCHILLO:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Gentile.

                            SENATOR GENTILE:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Gonzalez.

                            (No response heard.)

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Goodman.

                            SENATOR GOODMAN:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Hannon.

                            SENATOR HANNON:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Hevesi.

                            SENATOR HEVESI:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Hoffmann.

                            SENATOR HOFFMANN:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Holland.

                            SENATOR HOLLAND:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Johnson.

                            SENATOR JOHNSON:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Kruger.

                            SENATOR KRUGER:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Kuhl.

                            SENATOR KUHL:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Lachman.

                            SENATOR LACHMAN:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Lack.





                                                          7



                            SENATOR LACK:    Here.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Larkin.

                            SENATOR LARKIN:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator LaValle.

                            SENATOR LAVALLE:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Liebell.

                            SENATOR LIEBELL:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Libous.

                            SENATOR LIBOUS:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Maltese.

                            SENATOR MALTESE:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Marcellino.

                            SENATOR MARCELLINO:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Marchi.

                            (No response heard.)

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Markowitz.

                            (No response heard.)

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Maziarz.

                            SENATOR MAZIARZ:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator McGee.

                            SENATOR McGEE:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Meier.

                            SENATOR MEIER:    Present.

                            SECRETARY:    Senator Mendez.

                            SENATOR MENDEZ:    Present.





                                                          8



                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Bruno, a

                 quorum is present.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Thank you, Madam

                 President.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Majority Leader

                 Bruno, Minority Leader Connor, members of the

                 New York State Senate and guests who have

                 joined us here today, I welcome you and wish

                 you all a happy and healthy new year as we

                 begin, we commence right now, the 222nd

                 session of the New York State Legislature.

                            As your new Lieutenant Governor,

                 I'm truly honored and enthusiastic about the

                 opportunity the people of the State of New

                 York have given me.  I am also very pleased

                 and honored to be working with our Governor,

                 George Pataki, to continue to make New York

                 State the best that it could be.

                            As elected officials, it is not

                 only our duty but our responsibility to

                 represent and empower each and every citizen

                 of New York State.  Let's right now commit to

                 work together to make 1999 a grand finale, a

                 magnificent finale for this century as well as

                 a promising and inspiring entrance into the





                                                          9



                 21st Century.

                            Thank you.

                            The Chair now hands down a

                 communication from the Governor.  The

                 Secretary will read.

                            SECRETARY:    "Dear Madam

                 President, I would appreciate the privilege of

                 appearing before your honorable bodies in

                 joint session on January 6, 1999 at one p.m.,

                 or as soon thereafter as may be convenient, to

                 personally deliver my annual message to the

                 Legislature.  Sincerely, George E. Pataki."

                            THE PRESIDENT:    To be filed in

                 the Journal.

                            Senator Stafford.

                            SENATOR STAFFORD:    Madam

                 President, I hand up -

                            (Laughter.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Thank you, sir.

                            So received, Senator.

                            SENATOR STAFFORD:    Madam

                 President, I am -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    I see I'll be

                 right at home here, Senator.

                            SENATOR STAFFORD:    Madam





                                                          10



                 President, I am honored to hand up the

                 following resolution and move its adoption.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

                 will read.

                            SECRETARY:    By Senator Stafford,

                 Senate Resolution providing for the election

                 of Joseph L. Bruno as Temporary President of

                 the Senate for the years 1999 through 2000.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Paterson.

                            SENATOR PATERSON:    Madam

                 President, my resolution is already at the

                 desk, showing the greater preparation and -

                            (Laughter.)

                            SENATOR PATERSON:    -- and

                 responsibility that we would like to bring

                 upon the Senate as I nominate Senator Martin

                 Connor, the Minority Leader, to become

                 majority leader for these sessions, 1999 and

                 the year 2000.

                            Senator Connor has been an

                 outstanding legislator for 20 years, he has

                 served as a minority leader for four years and

                 I think it's time for a promotion.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Paterson,

                 the Secretary will read the resolution at this





                                                          11



                 time, sir.

                            SECRETARY:    By Senator Paterson,

                 Senate Resolution providing for the election

                 of Martin Connor as Temporary President of the

                 Senate for the years 1999 through 2000.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Paterson,

                 for remarks.

                            SENATOR PATERSON:    On the

                 substitute resolution, Madam Chair, I was just

                 going to say that I thought it was time for

                 Senator Connor to get a promotion, and this is

                 without any disrespect to the current Majority

                 Leader, Senator Bruno, who served with

                 distinction.  I think he deserves a promotion

                 as well.  And I'm sure that -

                            (Laughter.)

                            SENATOR PATERSON:    -- and I'm

                 sure that all of you will think of something,

                 but for the time being, I would like to offer

                 Senator Connor's name, most respectfully, in

                 nomination.  I think he'd be a fine

                 administrator and leader for the Senate.

                            And just in case this resolution

                 fails, as have all of the resolutions I have

                 offered since I've ever been here, I'd just





                                                          12



                 like to say that we look forward very much to

                 working with all of our colleagues this

                 session.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    On the substitute

                 resolution offered by Senator Paterson, all

                 those in favor, signify by saying aye.

                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed.

                            (Response of "Nay.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The nays have it.

                 The resolution is defeated.

                            Senator Stafford.

                            SENATOR STAFFORD:    Madam

                 President, thank you.  Your Excellency, my

                 colleagues, when I said, after I was asked to

                 do this, that I could just submit my remarks

                 that I made the last two times, both the

                 Leader and the good staff people said, "Do

                 that and sit down."  So I'll do it very, very

                 quickly.  But what I say, I'm very serious.

                            Four years ago, we saw this State,

                 we were all very, very concerned.  Our Leader,

                 Joe Bruno, together with Joe Patak -- excuse

                 me -- George Pataki and the Legislature,

                 leading the Legislature, turned this State





                                                          13



                 around.  Before that, four years ago, we had

                 lost hundreds of thousands of jobs.  Now we

                 have gained hundreds of thousands of jobs.

                            As one who understands welfare

                 personally, personally -- those of you who

                 know me, know what I'm talking about -- we had

                 to make some changes.  They've been made.

                 Hundreds of thousands less on welfare.

                 Together with our Governor, our Leader, who

                 came here, who had established values when he

                 came here, he stood by them and he sat right

                 back there and he stood up and said what he

                 believed.  Sometimes when it wasn't the most

                 popular thing to do.  And that's why he's

                 where he is today and that's why he's going to

                 be our leader for 1999 and 2000.

                            Charles Evans Hughes was born in

                 Glens Falls.  And our Leader was born in Glens

                 Falls.  Charles Evans Hughes was Governor for

                 two terms, Secretary of State, Chief Judge of

                 the Supreme Court and he said the following:

                 "We do not expect that the activities of

                 government will merely be an organ to do all

                 for people.  We hope it will secure a basis of

                 peace and order essential to individual





                                                          14



                 liberty and opportunity and also we hope it

                 will maintain the collective rights which

                 cannot otherwise be safeguarded.  But our

                 dependence for progress is not upon

                 governmental agencies but upon the virtues of

                 industry, thrift and moderation found among

                 our people."

                            A great man from Glens Falls said

                 that.  A great man from Glens Falls also says

                 that, believes it.  And, by the way Glens

                 Falls is in the 45th Senatorial District, just

                 in case anyone does not know that.

                            And with that, it is a pleasure and

                 an honor for me to hand up the resolution

                 electing Joseph Bruno, President Pro Tem,

                 Majority Leader of the New York State Senate

                 for 1999-2000.

                            Thank you.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Thank you.

                            The question is on the resolution.

                 All those in favor, signify by saying aye.

                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is





                                                          15



                 adopted and the Chair states for the record

                 that Senator Joseph L. Bruno has been elected

                 Temporary President of the Senate for the

                 years 1999 and 2000.

                            (Applause.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Bruno,

                 would you please raise your right hand and be

                 sworn in as Temporary President of the Senate?

                            Please repeat after me.

                            I do solemnly swear -

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    I do solemnly

                 swear -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- that I will

                 support the Constitution of the United States

                 of America -

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    -- that I will

                 support the Constitution of the United States

                 of America -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- and the

                 Constitution of the State of New York -

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    -- and the

                 Constitution of the State of New York -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- and that I

                 will faithfully discharge the duties of -

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    -- and that I





                                                          16



                 will faithfully discharge the duties of -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- the office of

                 Temporary President of the Senate of the State

                 of New York -

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    -- the office of

                 Temporary President of the State of New

                 York -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- to the best of

                 my ability -

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    -- to the best of

                 my ability.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Ladies and

                 gentlemen, our Temporary President of the

                 Senate.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Thank you.

                 Thanks very much.

                            (Applause.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Thank you very

                 much, Madam President.  Bishop Howard Hubbard,

                 thank you very much for joining us and for

                 that very appropriate and beautiful opening

                 prayer.  And to my good friend of a lot of

                 years, Senator Ron Stafford, who represented

                 me in the Senate before I was here, I thank





                                                          17



                 you for your friendship and for your very

                 gracious and kind remarks.  And I certainly

                 thank my colleagues for their confidence and

                 for their support in these past several years

                 and going into this next century.

                            And I want to, before I move too

                 far along, welcome and congratulate very, very

                 dear and close friend, our Lieutenant

                 Governor, Mary Donohue.  You can already see

                 that our new Lieutenant Governor has a keen

                 sense of hearing and she can hear when the

                 majority speaks, and she has an equal sense of

                 sight when hands go up.  This Lieutenant

                 Governor knows that the majority represents

                 democracy.

                            (Laughter.)

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    And so we look

                 forward, Governor, to this next year and two

                 with you as a partner in the things that we do

                 with our great Governor, George Pataki.  And

                 we're proud that we do the things that we have

                 done together.

                            And I want to extend my very best

                 wishes to our new Minority Leader, Senator

                 Marty Connor, and I want to assure him that we





                                                          18



                 will do everything that we can to support him

                 in his position as long as he's here.

                            (Laughter.)

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Senator Stafford,

                 you notice, was a little overwhelmed with

                 emotion when he first stood up and, actually,

                 I think for a second didn't recognize why he

                 was on his feet.

                            (Laughter.)

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    But he rose to

                 the occasion.  And, again, thank you.

                            But I want to thank our leadership

                 here in the Senate.  You have been just so

                 great.  And all of the things that we have

                 done we really have done together.  There

                 isn't anything that happens in this State that

                 doesn't happen because we in this chamber take

                 a positive action.  There isn't anything that

                 can happen.

                            We have some new members, and those

                 new members we welcome most hardily.  You are

                 joining one of the greatest deliberative

                 bodies in the whole world.  And we welcome you

                 here and we congratulate you here.

                            Senator McGee that's here, Senator





                                                          19



                 Bonacic and, the newest addition to the right

                 side of the aisle, Senator Nancy Lorraine

                 Hoffmann, we welcome those new members.

                            I also want to bid a very hearty

                 welcome to Senator Tom Duane, a newly elected

                 member, and Senator Schneiderman, newly

                 elected, and welcome -- and there is one

                 other -- and Dan Hevesi, who  follows in his

                 very accomplished father's footsteps.  We

                 welcome you here.

                            They just keep getting better and

                 better looking.

                            Now, you will notice that I wasn't

                 as familiar with the last three names, but

                 that will change.  But we welcome you all.

                            And there is one message that's

                 here.  That we have differences of opinion in

                 this chamber, but it's healthy.  When we do

                 things, we do them together.  And when we go

                 forward, whether we have agreed or not, when

                 we go forward, and laws change and good things

                 happen for this State, we have done that

                 together.  And we can elect as we see fit and

                 how we project out, but there isn't anything

                 that happens that we don't do together.  And





                                                          20



                 we can all be proud that we have worked

                 together, that we have in the last four years,

                 taken this State to the great heights that the

                 people in this State presently enjoy and that

                 we have built a platform with this great

                 Governor, that we will step forward into this

                 next century much better people, much better

                 off than we were five and six and eight years

                 ago.

                            So my thank you to all of you, to

                 my family, who have been supportive, as your

                 families are supportive.  And for all of the

                 good things that have happened in my life, I

                 just thank the good Lord and I thank you.

                            And there are some good things that

                 we don't want to lose sight of that happened

                 just a few weeks ago that makes for a better

                 new year for all of us, and I'm speaking of,

                 of course, charter schools, budget reform,

                 dairy compact and there were some other

                 incidental things.

                            (Laughter.)

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    And let me just

                 share with you that I don't want to treat that

                 lightly, because there isn't a person in the





                                                          21



                 Legislature or in government that doesn't

                 deserve all of the recognition that they get

                 because, if anyone doesn't recognize, they

                 should start to recognize that we, you, are

                 elected to one of the highest offices in this

                 State and you are deserving of all of the

                 recognition, all of the praise, all of the

                 rewards that come from representing such a

                 large constituency, individually and

                 collectively.

                            So we go forward, I think with

                 great vision, empowered that we will help

                 improve the quality of life for all New

                 Yorkers.

                            Thank you, Madam President, and

                 thank you.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Thank you.  Thank

                 you, Senator Bruno.

                            (Applause.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Chair will

                 acknowledge that we have also received a

                 communication from the Senate Democratic

                 Conference that Senator Martin Connor was

                 elected as the Minority Leader of the State

                 Senate.





                                                          22



                            Senator Connor.

                            SENATOR CONNOR:    Thank you, Madam

                 President.  And let me, on behalf of my

                 colleagues on this side of the aisle, welcome

                 you as our presiding officer and we look

                 forward to serving with you in the coming

                 years.

                            Senator Bruno, congratulations.  If

                 I couldn't beat you, well, there's only about

                 24 other members here who I would rather see

                 as Majority Leader than you.  But other than

                 that, I think you're great.

                            You know, I know this from the

                 history books, Senator Stafford, and I know it

                 from -- I don't know how many of you were here

                 many years ago when my grandparents visited us

                 in this chamber and, as you know, my

                 grandmother passed away at 99, just three

                 years ago.  And she was active in politics in

                 New Jersey and Woodrow Wilson was from her

                 home county and she knew Mr. Wilson, and as a

                 young woman worked in his campaign.  And she

                 recounted to me how that gentleman from Glens

                 Falls, Hughes, went to bed being called, "Good

                 night" -- being told, "Good night, Mr.





                                                          23



                 President."  This was a true story.  And woke

                 up the next morning and wondered where, where

                 were they all, I'm not Mr. President anymore

                 because the vote came in from California at

                 about eleven o'clock in the morning and beat

                 him.  So as Senator Stafford was speaking, I

                 was thinking, "Gee, you know, are we going to

                 get an outcome like this?"  As he compared you

                 to Hughes, I thought, am I going to wake up

                 tomorrow morning and find out I got the Wilson

                 result?  And we'll see when tomorrow morning

                 comes.

                            But I am delighted, certainly, to

                 continue to serve as Minority Leader.  I am

                 humbled by the faith my colleagues on this

                 side of the aisle have placed in me.  I look

                 forward to a year where, certainly, in

                 preliminary stages, we are not hearing a lot

                 of the partisan rhetoric that we've all

                 suffered from and with in these past years,

                 not just in this Legislature but it seems to

                 have been the tenor across the country.  There

                 are probably some, I suspect there's some city

                 south of here on the Potomac that hasn't yet

                 got the message.  But I think we all got the





                                                          24



                 message from our voters this year, that they

                 want mainstream, moderate politics, they want

                 people to talk about issues, not

                 personalities.  And that's a good thing.  It's

                 a good thing for all of us.  It's a good thing

                 for the people we serve.  So I look forward to

                 that.

                            I join in welcoming our new

                 senators, Senator Bonacic, Senator McGee and,

                 my own favorites, Senator Bruno, Senator Duane

                 and Senator Schneiderman and Senator Hevesi.

                 And you notice what I did is I gave him credit

                 for all of his father's seniority in the

                 Legislature, so he's sitting there in that

                 seat now.

                            But be that as it may, I look

                 forward to, hopefully, a productive year.  The

                 things we did accomplish just a few weeks ago

                 I think will go a long way towards starting us

                 off on the right foot this year in a spirit of

                 cooperation.  And, hopefully, we will be able

                 to restore what once prevailed in this House,

                 a greater spirit of bipartisan cooperation.

                            Thank you, Madam President.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Thank you.





                                                          25



                            Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Madam President,

                 we are handing up a resolution, ask that the

                 title be read and moved for the immediate

                 passage.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

                 will read.

                            SECRETARY:    By Senator Bruno,

                 Senate Resolution, that Steven M. Boggess of

                 Sand Lake, New York, be and he hereby is

                 elected Secretary of the Senate or the years

                 1999 through 2000.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    All right.  The

                 question is on the resolution.  All those in

                 favor, signify by saying aye.

                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

                 adopted and the Chair states for the record

                 that Steven M. Boggess has been elected

                 Secretary of the New York State Senate for the

                 years 1999 and 2000.

                            Mr. Boggess, be sworn in.

                            Raise your right hand, please, and





                                                          26



                 repeat after me.

                            I, Steven M. Boggess -

                            SECRETARY BOGGESS:    I, Steven M.

                 Boggess -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- do solemnly

                 swear -

                            SECRETARY BOGGESS:    -- do

                 solemnly swear -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- that I will

                 uphold the Constitution of the United

                 States -

                            SECRETARY BOGGESS:    -- that I

                 will uphold the Constitution of the United

                 States -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- and the

                 Constitution of the State of New York -

                            SECRETARY BOGGESS:    -- and the

                 Constitution of the State of New York -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- and that I

                 will faithfully discharge the duties of the

                 office of -

                            SECRETARY BOGGESS:    -- and that I

                 will faithfully discharge the office of -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- Secretary of

                 the New York State Senate -





                                                          27



                            SECRETARY BOGGESS:    -- Secretary

                 of the New York State Senate -

                            THE PRESIDENT:    -- to the best of

                 my ability.

                            SECRETARY BOGGESS:    -- to the

                 best of my ability.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Congratulations,

                 Steve.

                            SECRETARY BOGGESS:    Thank you,

                 Mary.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Ladies and

                 gentlemen, our Secretary.

                            (Applause.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Madam President,

                 I believe there's another resolution at the

                 desk.  I would ask that the title be read and

                 moved for its immediate adoption.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

                 will read.

                            SECRETARY:    By Senator Bruno,

                 Senate Resolution, that Mary Louise Stasolla

                 be and she hereby is elected the official

                 stenographer of the Senate for the years 1999

                 through 2000.





                                                          28



                            THE PRESIDENT:    On the record.

                 On the resolution, all in favor, signify by

                 saying aye.

                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

                 adopted.

                            Ladies and gentlemen, our

                 stenographer.

                            (Applause.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Madam President,

                 we will hand up another resolution, ask that

                 the title be read and moved for its immediate

                 adoption.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

                 will read.

                            SECRETARY:    By Senator Bruno,

                 Senate Resolution, that William C. Martin be

                 and he hereby is elected Sergeant-At-Arms of

                 the Senate for the years 1999 through 2000.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    On the

                 resolution, all in favor, signify by saying

                 aye.





                                                          29



                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

                 adopted.

                            Our Sergeant-At-Arms, ladies and

                 gentlemen.

                            (Applause.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Madam President,

                 I believe there are several resolutions at the

                 desk and I would ask that their titles be read

                 and moved for their immediate adoption.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

                 will read.

                            SECRETARY:    By Senator Bruno,

                 concurrent resolution of the Senate and

                 Assembly providing for a joint assembly for

                 the purpose of receiving a message from the

                 Governor.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The question is

                 on the resolution.  All in favor, signify by

                 saying aye.

                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.





                                                          30



                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The concurrent

                 resolution is adopted.

                            The Secretary will read.

                            SECRETARY:    Senate Resolution

                 Number 7, by Senator Bruno, Senate Resolution,

                 resolved that the President appoint a

                 committee of two to inform the Governor of the

                 election of Joseph L. Bruno as Temporary

                 President of Senate for the years 1999 through

                 2000 and that the Senate is organized and

                 ready to proceed with business and will meet

                 with the Assembly in the Assembly Chamber at

                 one p.m. to receive the Governor's message.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The question is

                 on the resolution.  All those in favor,

                 signify by saying aye.

                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

                 adopted.

                            The Chair appoints Senators McGee

                 and Schneiderman to wait upon the Governor

                 that the Senate is ready to proceed.





                                                          31



                            The Secretary will read.

                            SECRETARY:    By Senator Bruno,

                 Senate Resolution Number 8, resolve that the

                 President appoint a committee of two to wait

                 upon the Assembly and inform the body of the

                 election of Joseph L. Bruno as Temporary

                 President of the Senate for the years 1999

                 through 2000 and that the Senate is organized

                 and ready to proceed with business and will

                 meet jointly with the Assembly in the Assembly

                 Chamber at one p.m. to receive the Governor's

                 message.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The question is

                 on the resolution.  All those in favor,

                 signify by saying aye.

                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

                 adopted.

                            The Chair appoints Senators Bonacic

                 and Hevesi to wait upon the Assembly that the

                 Senate is ready to proceed.

                            Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Madam President,





                                                          32



                 we hand up another resolution, ask that the

                 title be read and moved for its immediate

                 adoption.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

                 will read.

                            SECRETARY:    By Senator Bruno,

                 Senate Resolution Number 9, providing that the

                 rules for the Senate for the years 1999 -- '8,

                 as last amended, be adopted as the rules of

                 the Senate for the years 1999 through 2000.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The question is

                 again on the resolution.  All those in favor,

                 signify by saying aye.

                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

                 adopted.

                            Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Madam President,

                 we hand up another resolution, ask that that

                 title be read and moved for its immediate

                 adoption.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

                 will read.





                                                          33



                            SECRETARY:    By Senator Bruno,

                 Senate Resolution Number 10, providing for the

                 hours of meeting by the Senate for the years

                 1999 through 2000, resolve that unless

                 otherwise ordered, the hours of meeting of the

                 Senate shall be as follows:  Mondays and

                 Tuesdays at 3 p.m., Wednesdays and all other

                 days 11 a.m.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The question is

                 on the resolution.  All those in favor,

                 signify by saying aye.

                            (Response of "Aye.")

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

                            (No response.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

                 adopted.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Madam President,

                 can we, at this time, recognize Senator

                 Paterson?

                            SENATOR PATERSON:    Thank you,

                 Madam President.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Paterson.

                            SENATOR PATERSON:    Thank you,

                 Madam President.

                            Pursuant to the passage of the





                                                          34



                 resolution just a couple moments ago relating

                 to the adoption of the rules of the Senate, I

                 would like to make record of the fact that,

                 pursuant to our agreement with the Majority,

                 that the Minority reserves the right to amend

                 the rules at the Senate, of the Senate, at a

                 later time.

                            Thank you.

                            SENATOR CONNOR:    To move to

                 amend.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The record will

                 so indicate, Senator.

                            Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Madam President,

                 at this time, we are awaiting the Assembly,

                 because the Senate has, as usual, finished its

                 work in a record time and we are waiting for

                 the Assembly to notify us that they are

                 similarly organized.  So we will stand at

                 ease.  And that's the bottom line.  We are

                 organized.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Senate will

                 stand at ease.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Thank you, Madam

                 President.





                                                          35



                            (Whereupon, at this time, 12:35

                 p.m., the Senate stood at ease.)

                            THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Bruno.

                            SENATOR BRUNO:    Upon business

                 being finished, I would ask that we all

                 assemble, that we move to the Assembly chamber

                 to hear the Governor's State-of-the-State

                 Message and our business be finished for the

                 day.

                            I move that we stand adjourned

                 until Monday at 3 p.m., intervening days to be

                 legislative days.

                            THE PRESIDENT:    The Senate will

                 now proceed to the Assembly chamber for the

                 Governor's message, after which the Senate

                 stands adjourned until Monday, January 11th at

                 3 p.m., intervening days being legislative

                 days.

                            (Whereupon, at 12:49 p.m., the

                 Senate adjourned.)