Regular Session - March 31, 2005
1582
1 NEW YORK STATE SENATE
2
3
4 THE STENOGRAPHIC RECORD
5
6
7
8
9 ALBANY, NEW YORK
10 March 31, 2005
11 11:16 a.m.
12
13
14 REGULAR SESSION
15
16
17
18 LT. GOVERNOR MARY O. DONOHUE, President
19 STEVEN M. BOGGESS, Secretary
20
21
22
23
24
25
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1583
1 P R O C E E D I N G S
2 THE PRESIDENT: The Senate will
3 please come to order.
4 I ask everyone present to please
5 rise and repeat with me the Pledge of
6 Allegiance.
7 (Whereupon, the assemblage recited
8 the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.)
9 THE PRESIDENT: In the absence of
10 clergy, may we bow our heads in a moment of
11 silence, please.
12 (Whereupon, the assemblage
13 respected a moment of silence.)
14 THE PRESIDENT: Reading of the
15 Journal.
16 THE SECRETARY: In Senate,
17 Wednesday, March 30, the Senate met pursuant
18 to adjournment. The Journal of Tuesday,
19 March 29, was read and approved. On motion,
20 Senate adjourned.
21 THE PRESIDENT: Without
22 objection, the Journal stands approved as
23 read.
24 Presentation of petitions.
25 Messages from the Assembly.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1584
1 Messages from the Governor.
2 Reports of standing committees.
3 Reports of select committees.
4 Communications and reports from
5 state officers.
6 Motions and resolutions.
7 Senator Fuschillo.
8 SENATOR FUSCHILLO: Thank you,
9 Madam President.
10 On behalf of Senator Libous, on
11 page number 26 I offer the following
12 amendments to Calendar Number 379, Senate
13 Print Number 1820, and ask that said bill
14 retain its place on Third Reading Calendar.
15 THE PRESIDENT: The amendments
16 are received, and the bill will retain its
17 place on the Third Reading Calendar.
18 Senator Bruno.
19 SENATOR BRUNO: Madam President,
20 can we at this time adopt the Resolution
21 Calendar.
22 THE PRESIDENT: All in favor of
23 adopting the Resolution Calendar please
24 signify by saying aye.
25 (Response of "Aye.")
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1585
1 THE PRESIDENT: Opposed, nay.
2 (No response.)
3 THE PRESIDENT: The Resolution
4 Calendar is adopted.
5 Senator Bruno.
6 SENATOR BRUNO: Madam President,
7 I believe that there are three resolutions at
8 the desk by Senator Morahan. I would ask that
9 the titles be read and move for their
10 immediate adoption.
11 THE PRESIDENT: The Secretary
12 will read.
13 THE SECRETARY: By Senator
14 Morahan, Legislative Resolution Number 1172,
15 honoring Natalie and Mel Harbinger upon the
16 occasion of being named "Members of the Year"
17 by the Montebello Jewish Center on April 3,
18 2005.
19 By Senator Morahan, Legislative
20 Resolution Number 1173, honoring Barbara
21 Etelson upon the occasion of being named
22 "Community Service Member of the Year" by the
23 Montebello Jewish Center on April 3, 2005.
24 And by Senator Morahan, Legislative
25 Resolution Number 1174, congratulating Sister
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1586
1 Fran Gorsuch upon the occasion of being named
2 "Special Honoree" by the Montebello Jewish
3 Center on April 3, 2005.
4 THE PRESIDENT: The question is
5 on the resolutions. All in favor please
6 signify by saying aye.
7 (Response of "Aye.")
8 THE PRESIDENT: Opposed, nay.
9 (No response.)
10 THE PRESIDENT: The resolutions
11 are adopted.
12 Senator Bruno.
13 SENATOR BRUNO: Madam President,
14 can we at this time have the noncontroversial
15 reading of the calendar.
16 THE PRESIDENT: The Secretary
17 will read.
18 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
19 270, Senate Budget Bill, Senate Print 551B, an
20 act making appropriations for the support of
21 government: Legislature and Judiciary Budget.
22 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Lay it
23 aside.
24 THE PRESIDENT: The bill is laid
25 aside.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1587
1 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
2 277, Senate Budget Bill, Senate Print 553E, an
3 act making appropriations for the support of
4 government: Education, Labor and Family
5 Assistance Budget.
6 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Lay it
7 aside.
8 THE PRESIDENT: The bill is laid
9 aside.
10 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
11 278, Senate Budget Bill, Senate Print 554E, an
12 act making appropriations for the support of
13 government: Health and Mental Hygiene Budget.
14 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Lay it
15 aside.
16 THE PRESIDENT: The bill is laid
17 aside.
18 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
19 320, by Senator DeFrancisco, Senate Print 42,
20 an act to amend the Real Property Law, in
21 relation to allowing an assignment.
22 THE PRESIDENT: Read the last
23 section.
24 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
25 act shall take effect on the 30th day.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1588
1 THE PRESIDENT: Call the roll.
2 (The Secretary called the roll.)
3 THE SECRETARY: Ayes, 55.
4 THE PRESIDENT: The bill is
5 passed.
6 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
7 337, by Senator Meier, Senate Print 2323, an
8 act to amend the Penal Law, in relation to the
9 permitting.
10 THE PRESIDENT: Read the last
11 section.
12 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
13 act shall take effect on the first of January.
14 THE PRESIDENT: Call the roll.
15 (The Secretary called the roll.)
16 THE SECRETARY: Ayes, 55.
17 THE PRESIDENT: The bill is
18 passed.
19 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
20 344, by Senator Farley, Senate Print 3142, an
21 act to amend the Penal Law, in relation to
22 increasing the penalty for robbery.
23 THE PRESIDENT: Read the last
24 section.
25 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1589
1 act shall take effect on the first of
2 November.
3 THE PRESIDENT: Call the roll.
4 (The Secretary called the roll.)
5 THE SECRETARY: Ayes, 55. Nays,
6 1. Senator Duane recorded in the negative.
7 Excuse me. Excuse me. Ayes, 54.
8 Nays, 2. Senators Duane and Montgomery
9 recorded in the negative.
10 THE PRESIDENT: The bill is
11 passed.
12 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
13 395, by the Senate Committee on Rules, Senate
14 Print Number 3667, an act to amend the Labor
15 Law.
16 THE PRESIDENT: Read the last
17 section.
18 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Lay it
19 aside.
20 THE PRESIDENT: The bill is laid
21 aside.
22 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
23 396, by the Senate Committee on Rules, Senate
24 Print 3668, an act to amend the Public Health
25 Law.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1590
1 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Lay it
2 aside.
3 THE PRESIDENT: The bill is laid
4 aside.
5 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
6 399, by the Senate Committee on Rules, Senate
7 Print 3671, an act to amend the Tax Law and
8 others.
9 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Lay it
10 aside.
11 THE PRESIDENT: The bill is laid
12 aside.
13 Senator Bruno, that completes the
14 noncontroversial reading of the calendar.
15 SENATOR BRUNO: Madam President,
16 before we take up the controversial calendar,
17 can we ring the bell and alert the members
18 that they ought to be in the chamber to vote
19 on very important issues in their lives and
20 their constituents' lives.
21 THE PRESIDENT: The Secretary
22 will ring the bell, and the members should
23 take their seats in the chamber.
24 Senator Skelos.
25 SENATOR BRUNO: Madam President,
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1591
1 we're at this time going to be calling up
2 Calendar 277, which deals with the educational
3 part, the education part of our budget.
4 But I just wanted to make an
5 observation and a comment, that today is
6 March 31st. It is the end of our fiscal year.
7 And we have six bills before us, language and
8 appropriation bills, that, when enacted in
9 this house and in the other house, will
10 complete the budget process for the people of
11 New York State. And the discussions that we
12 are continuing to have with the Assembly, with
13 the Executive, with members, will continue.
14 But, Madam President and
15 colleagues, we fully intend and expect that
16 we're completing the budget process here over
17 these next several hours or whatever amount of
18 time it takes. And each of you are to be
19 commended, in this house and in the other
20 house.
21 And I don't want to be premature in
22 being congratulatory here in this chamber, but
23 I think it's appropriate because this has been
24 a team effort, it has been a partnership to
25 get us where we are. And where we are is
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1592
1 truly in the best interests of the people of
2 New York State.
3 So, Madam President, I would ask
4 that 277 be called.
5 THE PRESIDENT: The Secretary
6 will read.
7 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
8 277, Senate Budget Bill, Senate Print 553E, an
9 act making appropriations for the support of
10 government: Education, Labor and Family
11 Assistance Budget.
12 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN:
13 Explanation.
14 THE PRESIDENT: Senator Saland,
15 an explanation has been requested.
16 SENATOR SALAND: Thank you, Madam
17 President.
18 This bill is the bill which deals
19 with the subject of K-12 education and other
20 education-related funding. And what it does
21 is it provides some $848 million amongst its
22 other provisions -- I will deal with the
23 education portion of this bill -- some
24 $848 million over and above what school
25 districts throughout this state received by
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1593
1 way of funding in their last school fiscal
2 year.
3 This $848 million is an increase
4 over the $526 million that the Governor
5 proposed in his budget, an increase,
6 obviously, of more than $320 million. And
7 what we do in the course of providing this
8 funding is we restore the expense-based aids
9 that had been cut in the Governor's proposed
10 budget.
11 Those expense-driven aids dealt
12 primarily with -- the cuts dealt primarily
13 with BOCES aid and with private excess cost
14 aid or special education aid. That
15 restoration means somewhere in the area of
16 about $205 million on school year.
17 We expanded operating aid,
18 increased it to the tune of some $180 million.
19 That particular form of aid is the aid which
20 is the one which is most sought and most
21 desired by school districts because it
22 provides them the greatest flexibility.
23 We increased funding for high needs
24 and rural districts to the tune of
25 approximately $355 million. We incorporated
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1594
1 the Governor's SBE pot of $325 million and
2 added some additional $30 million dealing
3 both, again, with high-needs districts and
4 also attempting to address the unique needs of
5 rural districts as well.
6 We increased the building aid ratio
7 in 207 high-needs districts. Those 207
8 districts are the districts defined as such by
9 Regents. That includes the City of New York
10 and obviously a host of others. We increased
11 that formula by some 5 percent.
12 And in addition, we added
13 additional building aid enhancements to the
14 New York City building aid formula in
15 recognition of unique circumstances they have
16 with regard to issues such as demolition and
17 other, more unique types of issues that the
18 city has to deal with when it engages in
19 construction or rehabilitation.
20 For a number of school districts,
21 somewhere in excess of 200 in our state, there
22 was a problem that was created by a ruling --
23 by the so-called GASB ruling. And don't ask
24 me what the acronym stands for, but it has to
25 do with the accounting entity that has
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1595
1 oversight over certified public accountants,
2 and they issued a ruling administratively
3 that, on one of those rare occasions,
4 presenting a problem for school districts that
5 at least you could safely say was not of any
6 doing by either the Legislature or the
7 Governor.
8 But that ruling basically required
9 the booking of payments of pensions in the
10 same school fiscal year. So both the
11 liability as it was incurred to pay the
12 pension and the payment of the pension was
13 required to occur in the same year.
14 Well, some 200-plus districts were
15 on a system in which the liability would
16 occur, for example, in '04-'05 and then would
17 be paid in '06. Failure to address this issue
18 would have resulted in adverse consequences to
19 those school districts in terms of things such
20 as their bond ratings, their ability to secure
21 financing at more reasonable rates.
22 What we've done is a blend of what
23 was both the Senate and the Assembly approach
24 to dealing with that issue. We have
25 effectively said that those school districts
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1596
1 that have this problem have the ability to, as
2 a book entry, to book the asset, the ability
3 to offset the liability, by in effect a paper
4 transfer, the ability to draw down on next
5 year's school aid. Which obviously they will
6 not receive until that following year.
7 That, we believe, resolves the
8 issue. To the extent that it does not resolve
9 the issue for a particular school district, we
10 have given those districts the ability to
11 borrow. And that would require them getting a
12 waiver from the Commissioner of Education to
13 do that.
14 Many of us heard, from our
15 libraries, concerns about restoration of
16 library funding. This bill restores library
17 funding to the tune of approximately
18 $4.5 million; I think it's something like
19 $4.475 million.
20 Also, in the Article VII language,
21 there will be provision for a uniform budget
22 revote, and that will occur on the third
23 Tuesday in June, and that will occur effective
24 2006.
25 Clearly, this house has always
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1597
1 concerned itself with the priority of
2 education. It's been a priority for certainly
3 this conference, this Majority conference, as
4 long as I've been a member and long before I
5 got here.
6 What this attempts to do is to
7 balance the needs of providing a quality
8 education and at the same time, as part and
9 parcel of our ability now to close this
10 process down in a timely fashion, also enables
11 school districts, independent school districts
12 that rely on property levies to know exactly
13 where they stand. And these dollars
14 certainly, additional dollars will mitigate
15 the potential tax increases that they might
16 otherwise be faced with.
17 We begin the process here of
18 enhanced funding for high-needs districts, to
19 the extent that we've incorporated the
20 Governor's SBE money and also enhanced those
21 dollars. And to the extent that there were
22 other provisions that the Governor had in his
23 budget regard with regard to accountability,
24 those issues were not addressed in the
25 agreed-upon budget that we have -- we now have
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1598
1 before us. Those -- many of the provisions
2 were not concurred in.
3 We believe that this $848 million
4 is certainly one of the richest education
5 packages that the state will ever have the
6 good fortune of enacting or having seen
7 enacted. And certainly it is, I think, a
8 great improvement over what the Governor had
9 offered us.
10 With that, Madam President, I
11 certainly am prepared to yield if anybody has
12 any questions.
13 THE PRESIDENT: Senator
14 Schneiderman.
15 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN: Thank you,
16 Madam President. Briefly on the bill.
17 THE PRESIDENT: You may proceed
18 on the bill.
19 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN: There is,
20 as Senator Saland indicated, I believe,
21 some -- there are some very good things in
22 this bill.
23 Unfortunately, this is a situation,
24 and we talked about a few of them yesterday,
25 where I believe that this house is not leading
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1599
1 the way towards a fairer school funding
2 formula.
3 In fact, it becomes evident after
4 this year's budget process that the obstacle
5 in the state government to a fair funding
6 based on need, to a fair funding that
7 recognizes the needs of our high-needs school
8 districts, the opposition really lies here.
9 And I'm sorry to say that, because
10 of the problems of distribution of school aid,
11 I'm not going to be able to vote for this
12 bill. I'm particularly sorry because, as
13 Senator Saland mentioned very briefly, but I
14 think it deserves more emphasis, this budget
15 bill represents a breakthrough in terms of
16 capital aid, a really extraordinary
17 accomplishment. And I know this is
18 something -- I've spoken to Assemblyman
19 Sanders, the chair of the Assembly Education
20 Committee, and this has been a commitment that
21 he's made for some time.
22 It's not just that this increases
23 the building ratio for New York City.
24 New York, as many people know, gets far less
25 reimbursement from the state for building
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1600
1 schools than most parts of the state -- maybe
2 33, 35 percent, 36 percent. We can say now,
3 after the passing of this bill, that the state
4 will pay for at least half and probably more
5 than half of the capital costs of the city's
6 current five-year plan for schools. That's an
7 extraordinary breakthrough.
8 It's not just changing the ratio,
9 but it's eliminating these artificial caps
10 that limited the amount a district can get for
11 site acquisition, for materials. That is a
12 huge breakthrough, and I think credit goes to
13 both our education chair and certainly to
14 Assemblyman Sanders, who I know has been
15 fighting for this.
16 The difficulty I have here comes in
17 the area of operating aid. And I would urge
18 all my colleagues from the City of New York
19 and from other high-needs districts that it
20 has clearly been demonstrated in this process
21 that Governor Pataki, in his proposal for a
22 sound, basic education fund, wanted a
23 distribution formula based on need, wanted to
24 give more money to the high-needs districts as
25 required by the CFE opinion. The Assembly's
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1601
1 resolution was a sound, basic education
2 proposal based on need, consistent with the
3 CFE opinion. The amendments offered by our
4 conference were a sound, basic education
5 proposal to drive more funds to high-needs
6 school districts, including the City of
7 New York.
8 The only group here that is
9 insisting on maintaining the old share system,
10 which is the obstacle to decent funding for
11 our poorer school districts, is the Majority
12 in this house. That's out in the open now.
13 Even the Governor is no longer sticking with
14 the shares. And I have to credit him for his
15 $325 million sound, basic education fund.
16 In order to make things come up in
17 the old manner, consistent with the shares
18 that have discriminated against the City of
19 New York and other districts for decades, what
20 this house has insisted on, I'm sorry to say,
21 is redoing the legislative add to essentially
22 make it a low-needs district fund. So that
23 the Governor's good funding formula combines
24 with our additional bad funding formula to
25 produce essentially the same old shares that
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1602
1 are the obstacle to progress on this issue.
2 This is not something that
3 stonewalling is going to solve. This is not
4 something that further appeals are going to
5 solve. This is something that has to be
6 resolved by people in good faith, recognizing
7 that hundreds of thousands of children getting
8 a lousy education is bad for everyone in this
9 state, even if it's not in your district. If
10 you're just an investment banker totally
11 interested in return on your investment, you
12 should be investing in the schoolchildren of
13 the state. They are our economic future.
14 This budget takes a move backwards
15 as far as the Senate's role is concerned in
16 operating aid. I'm sorry to see that. I know
17 that the Assembly has now committed to passing
18 the CFE bill that mandates full funding for
19 all the high-needs districts. I do recognize
20 the fact that they haven't identified the
21 funding source for that, which to many is a
22 problem. But they have expressed a further
23 commitment, as they did in their resolution,
24 to changing once and for all the funding
25 formula that leaves hundreds of thousands of
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1603
1 children behind.
2 And the fact that the President
3 thought it was enough of a public relations
4 priority to name his education policy "No
5 Child Left Behind" -- without discussing the
6 merits of his particular program -- indicates
7 the depth of feeling on this issue. And yet
8 the Senate today is saying, We're sticking
9 with the shares even if it means leaving
10 hundreds of thousands of children behind.
11 That's wrong.
12 I wish we had done on operating aid
13 what we did on building aid. In the absence
14 of that, I have to say I'm going to stand with
15 the plans offered by the Assembly resolution,
16 the Governor, and Senator Paterson. I'm going
17 to vote against this bill. And we will
18 revisit this issue later this session, I hope,
19 of fair funding for all of the city's children
20 in New York and for Buffalo, Rochester,
21 Syracuse, Yonkers, other districts around the
22 state. I may not leave out Albany.
23 Thank you, Madam President.
24 THE PRESIDENT: Senator Serrano.
25 SENATOR SERRANO: Thank you,
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1604
1 Madam President. On the bill.
2 THE PRESIDENT: You may proceed
3 on the bill.
4 SENATOR SERRANO: I'm concerned
5 with the portion of the bill that deals with
6 the funding for the State Council on the Arts.
7 This house proposed an additional
8 $2 million which unfortunately is not in this
9 bill. So we see ourselves at a cut of
10 15 percent since the year 2000-2001, which is
11 really moving in the wrong direction when you
12 consider what the arts bring to the state of
13 New York and all of the localities as far as
14 economic development and education.
15 We need to be fully cognizant all
16 the time of the fact that the state of
17 New York houses the cultural center of the
18 world, and New York needs to -- our funding of
19 the arts need needs to reflect that. The
20 investment in the arts is an investment in our
21 children, it's an investment in education, and
22 it's an investment economically for the growth
23 of our state and for our localities. And I
24 hope that, going forward, the state will do
25 better in its funding of the arts.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1605
1 Thank you.
2 THE PRESIDENT: Senator Krueger.
3 SENATOR LIZ KRUEGER: Thank you,
4 Madam President. On the bill.
5 THE PRESIDENT: You may proceed
6 on the bill.
7 SENATOR LIZ KRUEGER: Thank you.
8 This bill deals with a variety of
9 very distinct program areas, and so there is a
10 great deal we can agree or disagree on.
11 I share my colleague Senator
12 Schneiderman's concerns about our failure to
13 address in almost any way the obligations of
14 the Legislature on CFE and a fair funding
15 formula for the high-needs school districts.
16 And I appreciate his comments on the capital
17 money, but I would argue that I have heard
18 that it's simply $20 million more per year for
19 the high-needs school districts for capital,
20 and that is a drop in the bucket compared to
21 where we need to be in capital funds for
22 schools.
23 And so I am extraordinarily
24 disappointed that this is where the
25 Legislature ends up on March 31st regarding
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1606
1 education funding and the continuing pattern
2 of decades of failing to address fair funding
3 formulas for the schools in the state of
4 New York.
5 And that ties me into other mixed
6 feelings about this budget. The good news is
7 we put $4.47 million back in for libraries,
8 which we all know are so important. And the
9 irony is all we have done is brought them back
10 to the funding level they were at in the year
11 2002-2003, because we have cut them between
12 then and now. So we define it as a victory
13 when we put our libraries back to where they
14 were at a previous point in time, recognizing
15 that was inadequate, and costs continue to
16 grow.
17 And it ties directly into education
18 and schools, since in fact, at least in
19 New York City, many of our elementary and
20 junior high schools don't have libraries in
21 their schools. There's no room for them,
22 because we don't have enough room in our
23 schools to teach our children. And so the
24 importance of our public libraries being open
25 and available and having the books that they
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1607
1 need becomes even more critical to the
2 education of our children. And so I have to
3 say we have not gone far enough.
4 And I appreciate the comments of my
5 colleague Senator Serrano when he talked about
6 our failure to increase money for the arts.
7 Because in fact of course that also is an
8 issue of economic generation, but also for the
9 quality of the lives of our people and the
10 education of our children.
11 And again, one of the differences
12 between the school systems in underserved
13 areas and the rest of the state, my
14 understanding is that in many parts of the
15 state we still have arts education in our
16 schools, we still have certified teachers for
17 arts education in our schools. But if you
18 check with most New York City schools, you
19 will learn that we don't have those programs,
20 we don't have those teachers.
21 And therefore ensuring that there
22 is some money out there to expand arts
23 programs and to encourage arts institutions to
24 work with school facilities to provide arts
25 education in our schools becomes more and more
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1608
1 critical. So I would argue that we didn't do
2 justice to the arts community or to our
3 children there.
4 But I'd like to raise issues that
5 haven't been raised yet that concern me the
6 most about this bill, the fact that we still
7 have $1.1 billion in TANF funding floating
8 around out there yet to be dealt with. I
9 recognize the constitutional problems we have,
10 given the Governor's proposals to block-grant
11 this money into a flexible funding for family
12 services program.
13 But the truth is, with passage of
14 this bill today, we haven't addressed any of
15 the concerns of the endless category of
16 service programs out there for poor families
17 with children that right now are in limbo
18 about what happens with funding. We're
19 talking about daycare programs, we're talking
20 about child welfare, we're talking about
21 after-school programs, we're talking about job
22 training programs for women with children who
23 are living in poverty.
24 And we face very real concerns with
25 what happens or doesn't happen with this money
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1609
1 at two levels: One, the fact that we're
2 passing budget bills that don't answer those
3 questions within the context of the current
4 TANF money; and, two, the broader context that
5 as we work here in Albany to try to get a
6 budget done on time, our colleagues in
7 Washington have been moving forward with
8 legislation, through both the U.S. House and
9 the U.S. Senate, that would radically reduce
10 monies to the State of New York for these
11 programs over the next five years.
12 And in fact this week the U.S.
13 House of Representatives passed a budget bill
14 that in fact, if it was implemented, would
15 reduce in $4.5 billion less coming to New York
16 State over the next five years in programs for
17 low-income New Yorkers. The House bill cuts
18 funds to the State of New York ten times more
19 than the U.S. Senate Bill.
20 And so we have the short-term
21 complication of how are we resolving the TANF
22 block-grant question in the context of this
23 year's budget, but we have the longer-term
24 issue of the federal government continually
25 attempting and perhaps being successful in
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1610
1 drying up the funding that we have been
2 fighting over how we distribute here in
3 New York and yet may not have that money to
4 even deal with these programs.
5 And that is a critical concern for
6 every one of our districts, because there is
7 no district, there is no county that does not
8 find themselves in a situation where they are
9 underfunded for their social services and
10 their human services.
11 And in fact, within this bill,
12 because of confusion over the block grant and
13 TANF, we've actually cut about $26 million in
14 aid to localities out of the Office of
15 Children and Family Services, where I believe,
16 when this was agreed upon, we thought that
17 that $26 million would somehow be rolled into
18 the TANF flexible funding block grant debate.
19 But since that debate is off the
20 table for the moment, and yet we've still cut
21 $26 million out of aid to localities -- we
22 talk a lot in this house about the concerns
23 around health care and the costs at the local
24 level. But we should not be silent on the
25 fact that this Legislature continues, year in
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1611
1 and year out, to go along with proposals by
2 the Governor to reduce aid to localities to
3 fund the administrative costs of these
4 programs.
5 And we need the programs, and we
6 need our counties to be able to afford to run
7 them. And we keep shifting more and more of
8 the costs of those onto the backs of our
9 counties. I know the City of New York thinks
10 that under the flexible funding agreement --
11 that may or may not ever go anywhere right
12 now -- that they would be about $150 million
13 short compared to the previous year.
14 And so because of our failure to
15 address what we need to in education funding,
16 our failure to address the questions on social
17 services and human services, our failure to go
18 far enough in protecting other key programs
19 such as libraries and the arts -- I suppose
20 the one thing in this budget no one has
21 mentioned, because people seem to be
22 relatively happy with it at the moment, is the
23 restorations we made for the CUNY and SUNY
24 system.
25 So again, I am pleased with certain
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1612
1 parts in this budget. I am pleased that we
2 did not do more damage to higher ed. But
3 again, we didn't move them forward, we just
4 kept -- basically, we protected the programs
5 for the most vulnerable students, particularly
6 TAP.
7 We have to do better, and so I'll
8 be voting no on this budget.
9 Thank you, Madam President.
10 THE PRESIDENT: Senator Maltese.
11 SENATOR MALTESE: Madam
12 President, if I may, I would like to direct my
13 remarks to the statement by my colleague
14 Senator Serrano.
15 I had a discussion with Senator
16 Serrano, and we in the conference committee on
17 higher ed, where the culture and arts grants
18 are discussed and handled, had an increase of
19 $2 million for the New York State Council on
20 the Arts. And despite the best efforts of our
21 chairman, the chairman of the Higher Education
22 Committee, Kenneth LaValle, and his cochairman
23 from the Assembly side, Assemblyman Ron
24 Canestrari -- and other people on the
25 committee, both Democrat and Republican,
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1613
1 Minority and Majority, including the ranking
2 Minority member on the Senate side, Senator
3 Stavisky -- had lobbied very extensively for
4 an increase of $2 million for the New York
5 State Council on the Arts, and that was to be
6 an amount that was matched by the Assembly.
7 And if a lesser amount was to be appropriated,
8 it was to be also matched by the Assembly.
9 Unfortunately, as I say, despite
10 the best efforts of Democrat and Republican
11 Assembly members of that particular committee,
12 and Senate members, the Assembly leadership
13 chose not to match that amount.
14 At the same time, we have not given
15 up for the future to try to increase those
16 amounts. I fully share Senator Serrano's
17 thoughts and remarks following up on his
18 efforts in the City Council as chair of
19 culture and tourism, that the New York State
20 Council on the Arts should indeed receive
21 additional funding for their very laudatory
22 efforts and projects.
23 And unfortunately, the decrease of
24 what would have been $4 million will be
25 reflected in many, many worthwhile endeavors
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1614
1 across the state. But hopefully -- this is,
2 after all, a compromise budget, and it is
3 something that had to be agreed by both houses
4 and the Executive. And despite the efforts of
5 all concerned in our house and on the
6 Executive side, that amount was not matched.
7 And we're hopeful in the future
8 that we can increase those amounts at least to
9 the extent of the $2 million, which would be
10 matched and come to a total of $4 million.
11 So I plan to vote aye. I think
12 it's the best that could be obtained under the
13 circumstances. But we have not -- we will
14 continue our best efforts to get increased
15 funding for the New York State Council on the
16 Arts.
17 THE PRESIDENT: Does any other
18 member wish to be heard?
19 Then the debate is closed.
20 The Secretary will ring the bell.
21 Read the last section.
22 THE SECRETARY: Section 4. This
23 act shall take effect immediately.
24 THE PRESIDENT: Call the roll.
25 (The Secretary called the roll.)
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1615
1 THE PRESIDENT: Senator
2 DeFrancisco, to explain your vote.
3 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: Yes. The
4 comments that I have on this bill really apply
5 to all of the bills that we will be voting on
6 today as far as the budget is concerned.
7 You know, there's been some
8 criticism by some of various parts of this
9 bill, and there will be criticism of other
10 bills. But as a practical matter, none of
11 these bills are totally acceptable to any of
12 us. But the important thing is that we
13 reached a reasonable compromise in order to
14 get a budget that is a good budget in a timely
15 fashion.
16 So I certainly understand some of
17 the criticism; I have my own concerns. But as
18 a practical matter, we're doing what the
19 Constitution tells us to do in a timely
20 manner, and that should apply to each one of
21 these bills that we are going to be voting on
22 today.
23 I vote aye.
24 THE PRESIDENT: Senator Skelos.
25 SENATOR SKELOS: Please recognize
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1616
1 Senator Sabini.
2 THE PRESIDENT: Senator Sabini.
3 SENATOR SABINI: Thank you, Madam
4 President. To explain my vote.
5 I am voting in the affirmative on
6 this. While I concur with many others who
7 have spoken earlier that the funding formulas
8 still are not right for the City of New York,
9 this is an agreed-upon bill. And I wish we
10 would have seen more harder bargaining on the
11 other side of the building on behalf of
12 New York City's schoolchildren.
13 However, on the whole, the aid to
14 the city -- which has been unfair up until
15 now -- on school construction is modified in
16 the city's favor. I think that's important.
17 As someone who chaired the committee that
18 constructed schools when I was on the City
19 Council, I know that the money is just not
20 there for the city right now. And we still
21 have needs. My district is still among the
22 most overcrowded in the state.
23 And also I want to note the fact
24 that a piece of legislation that was carried
25 by Assemblyman Klein in the Assembly for a
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1617
1 long time, and by myself in this body, will in
2 effect be funded to give scholarships,
3 $29 million, to a number of different
4 programs, including World Trade Center
5 victims. But the bill we carried was for sons
6 and daughters of Flight 587 victims in the
7 particularly hard-hit Dominican-American
8 community, where the need for assistance in
9 higher education is very important. And
10 that's in this bill.
11 So on the whole, while I don't
12 think that it goes far enough, I'm going to
13 support the bill and vote in the affirmative.
14 Thank you.
15 THE PRESIDENT: You will be so
16 recorded as voting in the affirmative.
17 Senator Saland, to explain your
18 vote.
19 SENATOR SALAND: Thank you, Madam
20 President. To explain my vote.
21 Certainly everybody is aware that
22 in the aftermath of the Court of Appeals
23 decision in June of '03 dealing with CFE,
24 there is an even greater concern with regard
25 to the needs of not only New York City but
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1618
1 other high-needs districts. Clearly, to date,
2 we've been unable to secure any type of
3 negotiated agreement.
4 However, I think it's important to
5 note that there was nothing in that court
6 decision or any other court decision that says
7 that we have to limit funding to any
8 particular school district or any other type
9 of school district.
10 And the fallacy in the eyes of many
11 is rarely will you find districts that are
12 uniformly wealthy. And in many instances, you
13 will not have districts that are necessarily
14 uniformly poor.
15 Using my district, for example,
16 perhaps one of the wealthiest communities in
17 my district is a community that has wealth
18 because it has many people who don't
19 necessarily live full-time in my area, who
20 live in these marvelous estates, who don't
21 have children in the school system.
22 The people -- the mere mortals who
23 live in the community really suffer under
24 enormous tax burdens simply because the
25 district is viewed as wealthy. And were they
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1619
1 to be treated consistently, as they generally
2 are, as a wealthy district, it's an enormous
3 burden for them to overcome.
4 There's nothing wrong nor has there
5 been anything said in any court decision that
6 you can't raise all of the ships. What we
7 have done in the context of this, as I
8 mentioned before on this budget bill, is to
9 say, yes, we adopt the Governor's SBE proposal
10 to deal with high-needs districts; we enhance
11 that proposal to the tune of somewhere in the
12 area of an additional nearly 10 percent; we
13 enhance the capital side by providing
14 additional building aid to high-needs school
15 districts.
16 There is no lack of recognition of
17 dealing with issues pertaining to high-needs
18 school districts. There may be issues of
19 quantum, but certainly not issues of dealing
20 with the needs of high-needs school districts.
21 I vote in the affirmative, Madam
22 President.
23 THE PRESIDENT: Senator Stavisky.
24 SENATOR STAVISKY: Thank you,
25 Madam President. To explain my vote.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1620
1 I agree with what Senator Saland
2 said if you consider that in the entire state
3 every child is entitled to the same sound,
4 basic education that the children in New York
5 City are entitled to.
6 And that unfortunately is lacking,
7 I think, in this bill. We do not have a
8 statewide formula based upon the needs of each
9 individual school district and the children
10 who go to school in that school district.
11 Secondly, I too am disappointed
12 with the lack of an increase for the State
13 Council on the Arts. I think each one of us
14 has a cultural institution in our district
15 which benefits from appropriations from the
16 State Council on the Arts. I certainly have
17 them in my district, and I regret that
18 unfortunately -- and I served on that
19 conference committee -- that we did not
20 increase the appropriation by the $2 million
21 or the $4 million amount.
22 And lastly, I am delighted that
23 this bill does not include a tuition increase
24 for the students at CUNY and SUNY. We did
25 increase the base aid to cover the cost of --
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1621
1 to cover the increases by about -- I don't
2 mean base aid, I'm sorry -- operating aid,
3 5.9 percent for the students at CUNY and a
4 similar amount, I understand, for SUNY.
5 And because of that fact and the
6 fact that it is an improvement over previous
7 years, I vote aye.
8 THE PRESIDENT: You will be so
9 recorded as voting in the affirmative, as will
10 Senator Saland.
11 Senator Brown.
12 SENATOR BROWN: Thank you, Madam
13 President. To explain my vote.
14 I also have some concerns about
15 this bill, as other members have expressed.
16 But I too am going to be voting in the
17 affirmative.
18 One of the concerns that I have is
19 with respect to the school aid formula. And
20 this conference had advocated a school aid
21 formula that more mirrored what the CFE
22 advocates were looking for in terms of school
23 aid. And under that formula, the high-needs
24 school district that I represent in Buffalo
25 would have fared even better than it is going
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1622
1 to fare under what we have agreed to in the
2 budget.
3 I am pleased, though, that the
4 district in Buffalo is going to receive a
5 7.5 percent increase, or almost an additional
6 $30 million, so that is good news for our
7 school district. Buffalo is looking at a
8 funding gap this year of about $30 million.
9 So this additional aid, even though it is not
10 as much as I would have liked to have seen,
11 and even though this conference would have
12 advocated more money, it will be enough money
13 to close the gap in Buffalo.
14 I also am very pleased at the work
15 that every member of the Senate has done in
16 terms of pushing aggressively this year for an
17 on-time state budget. When I was elected and
18 came into the Senate in 2001, I was a fierce
19 advocate for on-time budgets and have
20 advocated for an on-time budget every year
21 since I've been in the Legislature, which is
22 five years now. And certainly want to
23 congratulate all of my colleagues in the
24 Senate for all of your hard work in making
25 sure that we do have an on-time budget this
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1623
1 year for the first time in 21 years.
2 I vote in the affirmative, Madam
3 President. Thank you.
4 THE PRESIDENT: You will be
5 recorded as voting in the affirmative,
6 Senator.
7 Senator Malcolm Smith.
8 SENATOR MALCOLM SMITH: Thank
9 you, Madam President. To explain my vote.
10 Clearly the education issue is
11 probably one of the paramount things that are
12 of interest to the people of the City of
13 New York and obviously the state. I just rise
14 very briefly to add my voice to the chorus
15 that you've heard from many colleagues on my
16 side of the aisle with regards to the CFE
17 decision and adequate funding for schools in
18 the City of New York.
19 As one who represents a district
20 where you can walk into a classroom and
21 literally see 40 or 50 students in one room,
22 you can see some desks that are basically, I
23 would just say, in conditions that one should
24 not be sitting in, where some don't have
25 adequate books, where even the physical plant
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1624
1 is in dire need of repair, it just makes it
2 very difficult for us to, while being
3 appreciative of this particular budget bill,
4 and it coming somewhat on time -- there is
5 still a great deal of need in the City of
6 New York. And we cannot rest and will not be
7 able to rest until adequate funding for the
8 City of New York schools are there.
9 There are a number of advocates who
10 are continually calling our office, who are
11 continually asking us to please make sure
12 adequate funding is there. And it is just
13 very difficult, while we are voting on this
14 package -- $840 million or $830 million, while
15 it sound likes a decent number, clearly is
16 woefully short of what the City of New York
17 needs. The fact that there's no money in
18 there for capital improvements is pretty
19 horrendous.
20 And while we are going to be
21 supporting this bill and while I do support
22 this bill -- there are some good things in
23 here, obviously around the tuition increase,
24 no tuition increase. Obviously from a more
25 parochial standpoint, I know Senator Padavan
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1625
1 is also appreciative of the fact that there is
2 the $3 million in there for the Queensborough
3 Community College for the Holocaust Center,
4 which is something that we hope the Governor
5 will not veto this year.
6 There are some things in there that
7 while we can appreciate the dedication and the
8 thoughtful process that went into putting this
9 package together, we must be on record
10 indicating that it is not adequate enough for
11 the City of New York, which also means it's
12 not adequate for the high-need districts
13 around the state as well as some of the larger
14 cities around the state.
15 I will be voting aye, but I do want
16 my colleagues to understand that we have much
17 work that still needs to be done in this
18 regard.
19 Thank you.
20 THE PRESIDENT: You will be
21 recorded as voting in the affirmative,
22 Senator.
23 Senator Parker.
24 SENATOR PARKER: Yes, Madam
25 President, to explain my vote.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1626
1 THE PRESIDENT: You may proceed
2 to explain your vote.
3 SENATOR PARKER: I really
4 appreciate that we're on the verge of getting
5 a budget on time this year. I think it's a
6 great thing. I think that all of the work
7 that people around the state, the advocates
8 and the citizens did, around reform of this
9 legislative body, has really made a
10 difference, and I'm excited to see that.
11 But I am still disappointed about
12 some of the outcomes that we're still getting.
13 And I'm voting no today on this bill because
14 it does not deal with much of the issues that
15 we need in terms of education generally, but
16 particularly the CFE matter.
17 For us to pass a budget once again
18 in the face of a court ruling that has ordered
19 us to act in a certain way, and for us to
20 continue to act like that court order doesn't
21 exist, that it's not relevant, that it's not
22 germane, I think is criminal.
23 And I think that we owe the
24 1.1 million schoolchildren who are going to
25 school in New York City right now, as we
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1627
1 speak, we owe them an opportunity to get a
2 sound, basic education. And right now, by
3 passing this bill, we are denying them that
4 and we're telling them that they are not worth
5 every other child in this state. And that is
6 wrong.
7 I think we have an opportunity to
8 not just do something here good for New York
9 City but to deal with all of the high-needs
10 districts throughout the state. And this is
11 not the first time I've said this. I said it
12 last year when we had this debate as well. We
13 have an opportunity to help every single
14 high-needs district in the state, from Buffalo
15 to Brooklyn, but we refuse to do it.
16 And so for that reason I'm voting
17 nay.
18 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
19 Parker will be recorded in the negative.
20 Senator Montgomery, to explain her
21 vote.
22 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Yes, very
23 briefly, Mr. President, I just would like to,
24 on a particular area of this budget that we're
25 passing today, say a word of gratitude,
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1628
1 especially to Senator Farley, and of course
2 all of the members of his committee and the
3 people on that panel who saw fit to support
4 the libraries in our state.
5 Certainly each time that I'm in one
6 of the branch libraries in my district or in
7 the central library in Brooklyn and I see
8 hundreds of young people there utilizing the
9 library and all of its offerings to them, I am
10 reminded how much it is a cultural,
11 educational institution that we should be
12 supporting.
13 I am very happy that my colleagues
14 saw the wisdom to keep the cultural, the
15 libraries and the cultural institutions as
16 part of the education system, because indeed
17 they are. And I thank my colleagues for the
18 vision to maintain a level of support that
19 will allow these institutions to continue to
20 support the main education of young people by
21 being there to give them an opportunity to
22 have a hands-on experience in every single
23 way.
24 So I'll be voting yes on this
25 budget, for that and many other reasons.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1629
1 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
2 Montgomery will be recorded in the
3 affirmative.
4 Senator Bonacic, to explain his
5 vote.
6 SENATOR BONACIC: Thank you, Mr.
7 President.
8 First of all, I would like to
9 congratulate Senator Bruno, Speaker Sheldon
10 Silver and our Governor, who worked very hard
11 to get us all to this point.
12 I want to thank my colleagues here,
13 because we always fight about the amount of
14 money in education, pushing that number higher
15 and higher. And then we get involved with our
16 regional politics in the distribution
17 problem -- how much should go to the city, how
18 much should go upstate.
19 I want to tell you something. I
20 represent the Catskills and the Hudson Valley,
21 and I care as much about the children in
22 New York City as I do in my district when it
23 comes to excellence in education and whether
24 they're getting the proper education, whether
25 they're being challenged so they can compete
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1630
1 when they get out of school.
2 So I support the money allocation
3 because we pushed it up. But I will ask you
4 this question. Will we monitor, every one of
5 us, the excellence in education for our
6 children as we keep pumping money into these
7 school districts? Keep in mind, now, we give
8 more per pupil than any state in the country.
9 And when we make that kind of money
10 commitment, we should ask and demand
11 accountability that our students are at the
12 top in excellence in education, from Buffalo
13 to Syracuse, to my district, to every district
14 in New York City.
15 And I would ask each of us to
16 monitor the excellence in education after
17 you've won the battle, collectively, on
18 raising the money commitment.
19 So I support this budget. I
20 support the education amount for our children.
21 But I still think we all have a lot of work to
22 do to improve the efficiency, the
23 accountability in raising the excellence of
24 education for all of the children of the State
25 of New York, and I ask that we monitor that
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1631
1 always.
2 Thank you, Mr. President.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
4 Bonacic will be recorded in the affirmative.
5 Senator Little, to explain her
6 vote.
7 SENATOR LITTLE: Thank you, Mr.
8 President. To explain my vote.
9 Today, as we are concluding our
10 budget votes, we tend to look at the words
11 "allocation" and "appropriation" for the money
12 that we are designating for certain
13 departments in our state budget.
14 I tend to look at our money for
15 education not as an appropriation or an
16 allocation, but as an investment, because I
17 think it's the most important investment that
18 we can make in New York State with the money
19 that we are dealing with.
20 Helping our schools address the
21 needs that they have throughout New York
22 State, in all the varying sizes and varying
23 problems, is truly important. Today our
24 schools have health insurance increases, they
25 have pension cost increases, as well as the
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1632
1 many demands put upon them by the State
2 Education Department.
3 I represent 53 school districts in
4 the State of New York. Considering there are
5 only 750 school districts, that's quite a
6 share. Some, a couple, are dealing with
7 expanded growth, but most of my school
8 districts are dealing with a reduction and
9 declining enrollment. And yet the expenses
10 for class of 12 are pretty much the same as
11 for a class of 22 or 25 or 30.
12 Therefore, additional investment
13 and funds for these schools is truly
14 important. And I thank everyone for their
15 contributions, for their working together to
16 come up with a budget that is fair and
17 equitable in New York State, and I thank you.
18 I vote in the affirmative. Thank
19 you.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
21 Little will be recorded in the affirmative.
22 The Secretary will announce the
23 results.
24 THE SECRETARY: Those recorded in
25 the negative on Calendar Number 277 are
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1633
1 Senators Duane, L. Krueger, Parker and
2 Schneiderman.
3 Ayes, 57. Nays, 4.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The bill
5 is passed.
6 Senator Skelos.
7 SENATOR SKELOS: Mr. President,
8 would you please call up Calendar Number 278.
9 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The
10 Secretary will read Calendar 278.
11 THE SECRETARY: In relation to
12 Calendar Number 278, Senator Johnson moves to
13 discharge, from the Committee on Finance,
14 Assembly Bill Number 554C and substitute it
15 for the identical Senate Bill Number 554E,
16 Third Reading Calendar 278.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER:
18 Substitution ordered.
19 The Secretary will read.
20 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
21 278, Assembly Budget Bill, Assembly Print
22 Number 554C, an act making appropriations for
23 the support of government: Transportation,
24 Economic Development and Environmental
25 Conservation Budget.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1634
1 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN:
2 Explanation.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
4 Hannon, an explanation has been requested of
5 Calendar 278.
6 SENATOR HANNON: Thank you, Mr.
7 President.
8 What we have before us is, in major
9 part, the health appropriation bill. Later on
10 today we will be dealing with the Article VII
11 language bill.
12 This is the measure which
13 incorporates the collective actions in regard
14 to the Executive proposal concerning
15 hospitals, nursing homes, home health care,
16 managed care, Family Health Plus, HCRA, public
17 health, aging, substance abuse, alcoholism,
18 and the related appropriate actions concerning
19 the funds and the subfunds and the revenue
20 funds therein.
21 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The
22 Secretary will sound the bells.
23 Senator Montgomery, I'm sorry.
24 Senator Montgomery, you're recognized.
25 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Yes, Mr.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1635
1 President, just very briefly.
2 I would be remiss if I did not
3 express my frustration that we do not have
4 enough funding in this budget for school-based
5 health clinics.
6 We should be absolutely ashamed as
7 a state that we have abandoned our young
8 people in terms of their health care needs,
9 health and mental health, in their schools
10 where they are, mostly. And it could be done
11 so efficiently and so effectively and serve
12 the needs of our young people. We have high
13 rates of suicide among our young people,
14 especially upstate. We have high rates of HIV
15 infection occurring in young people in this
16 state. We have no access to mental health
17 crisis intervention services for them in their
18 schools or, in most instances, nor in their
19 communities.
20 So it really is -- we have left out
21 our young people, especially early teens, high
22 school and middle school young people.
23 So while I know that there is
24 funding, and certainly appreciate that Senator
25 Hannon has been supportive of this -- but we
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1636
1 just have not seen fit to invest in the health
2 care needs and mental health needs of our
3 young people through those centers,
4 school-based health clinics that could serve
5 them where they are, both in the rural areas
6 of this state as well as in the urban areas,
7 all of our children. It doesn't have any
8 income test required or associated with it.
9 It is all children, all young people in this
10 state need access to school-based health
11 clinics.
12 And I certainly hope that some time
13 in the very near future we're going to see fit
14 to add this kind of funding so that we create,
15 as part of our health delivery system, a means
16 of providing health and mental health services
17 to our young people.
18 Thank you, Mr. President.
19 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
20 Hannon.
21 SENATOR HANNON: I would just say
22 that, with the other house, we have tried to
23 have an appropriate level of funding for this.
24 We have moved monies into the school-based
25 health centers to replace monies otherwise not
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1637
1 available through the TANF funds. And we
2 believe there has been an appropriate level to
3 maintain where we've been in previous years.
4 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Any
5 other Senator wish to be heard on the bill?
6 Debate is closed, then.
7 The Secretary will sound the bells.
8 Members are asked to return to the
9 chamber for a vote.
10 Read the last section.
11 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
12 act shall take effect immediately.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Call the
14 roll.
15 (The Secretary called the roll.)
16 THE SECRETARY: Ayes, 61.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The bill
18 is passed.
19 Senator Skelos.
20 SENATOR SKELOS: Mr. President,
21 will you please call up Calendar Number 270.
22 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The
23 Secretary will read Calendar 270.
24 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
25 270, Senate Budget Bill, Senate Print 551B, an
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1638
1 act making appropriations for the support of
2 government: Legislature and Judiciary Budget.
3 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN:
4 Explanation.
5 SENATOR JOHNSON: This bill is
6 the legislative budget, and judiciary, for the
7 year, total of $208 million.
8 We concur with the Judiciary
9 Committee's request, with the following
10 modifications: Reduced without prejudice,
11 nonpersonal service and maintenance
12 undistributed by $10 million, and general
13 state charges by $17.3 million, to cover the
14 Executive's request to allow quarterly
15 reimbursement to the Office of Court
16 Administration from the Indigent Legal
17 Services Fund up to $6.25 million per quarter.
18 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
19 Schneiderman.
20 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN: Thank you,
21 Mr. President. On the bill very briefly.
22 This is the legislature and
23 judiciary appropriation language bill. It is
24 improved from the Senate one-house bill that
25 came before us a few weeks ago, because that
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1639
1 bill contained a $30 million cut to the
2 judiciary. This bill only contains a
3 $10 million cut to the judiciary.
4 I think that that is unfortunate.
5 Those of us who actually practice in the
6 courts and are familiar with the extraordinary
7 overburdening in many jurisdictions,
8 particularly in poorer communities, have to
9 look with great sadness on a bill that for
10 such -- deals really so disrespectfully with
11 another branch of government.
12 I think that we should be expanding
13 the funding of the judiciary. I think that
14 having equal access to justice requires them
15 to have adequate funding. And I think it is
16 extraordinarily irresponsible of us to be
17 cutting their budget at all, although it is
18 certainly a tribute to the conference process
19 and our colleagues in the Assembly, I guess,
20 that it's gone from a $30 million cut in the
21 first draft of the Senate bill to a
22 $10 million cut here.
23 But I do think it's unfortunate as
24 a matter of public policy and is something I
25 hope we will reverse in the days and weeks to
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1640
1 come.
2 Thank you, Mr. President.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
4 DeFrancisco.
5 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: Yes. The
6 $10 million deduction or reduction in the
7 judiciary budget has been fully explained to
8 the Chief Administrative Judge and the Chief
9 Judge of the Court of Appeals. They have
10 indicated they can easily absorb that budget.
11 They have indicated that it is not going to
12 cause a problem with them with respect to the
13 performance of the duties of the judiciary.
14 There are some who believe that the
15 judiciary could use some streamlining in view
16 of the fact that there is a huge bureaucracy
17 that has developed, I know at least in my
18 lifetime, called the Office of Court
19 Administration, that doesn't deal with justice
20 at the grassroots effort but that needs some
21 type of streamlining.
22 So that, I believe, explains why
23 there was a compromise of $10 million. It was
24 something the judiciary could deal with and
25 deal with effectively without hurting the
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1641
1 local administration of justice or any of the
2 administration of justice. And also it took
3 into account some of the concerns of some
4 members of both houses, I believe, as well as
5 the Governor.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
7 Malcolm Smith.
8 SENATOR MALCOLM SMITH: Thank
9 you, Mr. President.
10 It is true that the -- I guess what
11 Senator DeFrancisco has indicated in terms of
12 being able to absorb the $10 million.
13 Obviously Judge Lippman and Judge Kaye have
14 indicated they have that ability to do so
15 without basically hurting services.
16 However, what I would hope is that
17 it's not the beginning of a practice, that as
18 we see fit to give them a $10 million decrease
19 in their support services dollars that they
20 need, that we don't look to the year 2007-2008
21 and begin to say: Well, we can continue to do
22 this.
23 While we did change it from
24 $30 million to $10 million, I hope we don't go
25 forward talking about we still owe another
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1642
1 $10 million for the next two years.
2 More importantly, it does have an
3 impact indirectly on some of the poorer
4 neighborhoods, as you will find Family Courts
5 in many of our neighborhoods are bursting at
6 the seams. And it would be hopeful that we'll
7 make sure that the judiciary budget stays in
8 place, if not increased. I truly believe the
9 judges need an increase in salary, but I guess
10 we'll save that for another time.
11 But I do want to rise just to
12 indicate that I hope this is not the beginning
13 of a practice to have some onslaught on the
14 judicial budget in the State of New York.
15 Thank you.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Does any
17 other Senator wish to be heard on the bill?
18 Debate is closed, then.
19 The Secretary will sound the bells.
20 Members are asked to return to the
21 chamber for a vote.
22 Read the last section.
23 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
24 act shall take effect immediately.
25 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Call the
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1643
1 roll.
2 (The Secretary called the roll.)
3 THE SECRETARY: Ayes, 60. Nays,
4 1. Senator Schneiderman recorded in the
5 negative.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The bill
7 is passed.
8 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
9 395, by the Senate Committee on Rules, Senate
10 Print Number 3667, an act to amend the Labor
11 Law and others.
12 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN:
13 Explanation.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Can we
15 have some order in the chamber.
16 Senator Johnson.
17 SENATOR JOHNSON: Mr. President,
18 this is the language bill which goes along
19 with the bill that's been explained previously
20 by Senator Saland, the Education, Labor and
21 Family Assistance Budget for the 2005-2006
22 state fiscal year.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Any
24 other Senator wish to be heard on the bill?
25 Debate is closed, then.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1644
1 The Secretary will sound the bells.
2 Members should return to the
3 chamber for a vote.
4 Read the last section.
5 THE SECRETARY: Section 9. This
6 act shall take effect immediately.
7 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Call the
8 roll.
9 (The Secretary called the roll.)
10 THE SECRETARY: Ayes, 59. Nays,
11 2. Those recorded in the negative are
12 Senators L. Krueger and Schneiderman.
13 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The bill
14 is passed.
15 The Secretary will continue to
16 read.
17 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
18 396, by the Senate Committee on Rules, Senate
19 Print Number 3668, an act to amend the Public
20 Health Law and others.
21 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN:
22 Explanation.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
24 Johnson.
25 SENATOR JOHNSON: Mr. President,
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1645
1 this is the provisions of the law for changes
2 necessary to be implemented in order to put in
3 place the 2005-2006 health and mental health
4 budget.
5 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
6 Montgomery.
7 SENATOR MONTGOMERY: Mr.
8 President, I want to thank Senator Johnson for
9 that explanation. It's satisfactory to us.
10 (Laughter.)
11 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Well,
12 thank you for being satisfied, Senator
13 Montgomery.
14 Senator Winner.
15 SENATOR WINNER: Thank you, Mr.
16 President.
17 I want to rise in support of this
18 measure, particularly as it relates to some of
19 the provisions that are designed to help our
20 local governments in dealing with the Medicaid
21 crisis.
22 I want to commend Senator Hannon
23 and Senator Bruno for recognizing the
24 difficulty that our counties are in with
25 respect to meeting these Medicaid obligations.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1646
1 And this provision contains a
2 long-sought-after cap on local government
3 expenditures for Medicaid as well as other
4 measures that will reduce some of the local
5 governments' concerns that have caused
6 double-digit property tax increases, not only
7 in my district but throughout most of upstate
8 New York and Long Island.
9 These tax increases are related
10 directly to the ever-burgeoning costs of
11 Medicaid. And this provision speaks out very
12 directly and forcefully to curtailing those
13 levels of expenditures. And I'm very pleased
14 to support it, because now trying to get the
15 Medicaid burden under control will be
16 something that is within sight and will
17 provide for some more confidence in the
18 Medicaid system throughout New York.
19 Certainly the provisions of this
20 bill involving the cap, the preferred drug
21 list, the efforts at more disease management
22 control and other measures of cost containment
23 will provide the relief to the counties and
24 relief to the State of New York as we try to
25 go forward to tame the Medicaid burden that
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1647
1 we're all facing.
2 This burden, at $44 billion or
3 $45 billion and growing, is consuming an ever,
4 ever increasing percentage of all of our
5 resources that are then crowding out the
6 provision of support for many other programs
7 that we all hold near and dear.
8 So therefore, Mr. President, I
9 thank you for the opportunity to speak on this
10 pleasure and look forward to working in the
11 future with a lot more efforts to bring
12 Medicaid under control and provide for relief
13 for our local counties.
14 Thank you. I vote aye.
15 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
16 Rath.
17 SENATOR RATH: Thank you,
18 Mr. Chairman.
19 The efforts of the health budget
20 conference committee were wonderful, a true
21 bipartisan effort to sort out what has become
22 a chief cost center in the State of New York,
23 not only for us but for the counties. And not
24 only the State of New York; the discussion is
25 not only in our chamber here but, I'm sure, in
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1648
1 senate and assembly chambers all across the
2 country as to how do we move forward in
3 consideration of the spiraling costs of health
4 care.
5 We have made a very good start here
6 today. There's a lot more work to be done.
7 The phrase "cost containment," the phrase
8 "reform, restructure," will be on this floor
9 for the next ten years, I would bet, before we
10 get to a point where we're all comfortable
11 with what costs are in relation to what the
12 traffic will bear in terms of our taxpayers in
13 New York State.
14 Whether they're business taxes or
15 whether they're the property taxes, Senator
16 Winner has pointed out they're going to be
17 relieved with this cap. Or whether it's sales
18 tax -- which my home county, Erie County,
19 absolutely refused to move on sales tax to
20 support the cost of Medicaid. So I think if
21 you have been reading the press, you know what
22 the circumstances are there.
23 So, thankfully, we have begun a
24 very long road. And I'm hopeful that as this
25 legislative session proceeds, there will be
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1649
1 full debate in both houses of the Legislature
2 on what we need to do by way of restructure so
3 that we can get on with providing services for
4 people who need the services but not spending
5 more money than we can afford to spend.
6 Thank you, and I will be voting
7 aye.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Any
9 other Senator wish to be heard on the bill?
10 Debate is closed, then.
11 The Secretary will sound the bells.
12 Members should return to their
13 seats for a vote.
14 Read the last section.
15 THE SECRETARY: Section 2. This
16 act shall take effect immediately.
17 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Call the
18 roll.
19 (The Secretary called the roll.)
20 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
21 Bonacic, to explain his vote.
22 SENATOR BONACIC: Yes. First of
23 all, I'd like to thank Senator Hannon and
24 Senator Meier for their work on Medicaid
25 reform and cost containment.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1650
1 And many of the speakers standing
2 up talked about how it was going to help
3 property tax owners where the savings with the
4 cap would be passed on to the counties. I
5 would suggest to you that if we're concerned
6 with the taxpayers, and I know we all are, now
7 that the budget is behind us we have a bigger
8 problem with the rising school taxes,
9 especially on Long Island, all of the Hudson
10 Valley, coming up.
11 And I think if we are serious of
12 alleviating the burden, we should be
13 concentrating on school taxes in two areas.
14 One, we should be thinking of reforming tax
15 exempts. There's billions of dollars being
16 lost by abusers that are abusing the tax
17 system and avoiding property tax, passing it
18 on to families that are struggling to keep up
19 the payment of the taxes and their mortgage to
20 save their house.
21 The other thing that we should be
22 thinking about -- and I don't have the answer
23 yet -- and that is we should find an alternate
24 way of financing public education other than
25 the demand on property taxes.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1651
1 We will be having legislative
2 hearings throughout the state of New York. I
3 welcome your input, your wisdom in shaping
4 that. And we can now have three months to
5 four months that we're here, we're not
6 distracted by the budget, and we can now work
7 on policy, legislation. And alleviating
8 school taxes should be one of our top
9 priorities.
10 Thank you, Mr. President.
11 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
12 Bonacic will be recorded in the affirmative.
13 Senator Skelos, to explain his
14 vote.
15 SENATOR SKELOS: To explain my
16 vote.
17 I'm going to support this
18 legislation. And I want to congratulate you
19 and Senator Hannon for the fine work that you
20 have done on this whole issue of Medicaid.
21 There's more to be done at this
22 point, though. The cap is very positive for
23 our counties, but the counties now do have a
24 responsibility -- two responsibilities, in my
25 opinion.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1652
1 Number one, to watch utilization.
2 So that if they turn their back on their
3 responsibilities as gatekeepers, the cost of
4 their program, our program, is going to be
5 shifted to the state, and we'll see a burden
6 put on the taxpayers of the state that we will
7 not be able to fund other programs.
8 The second challenge to the
9 counties, now, with this burden being
10 alleviated, there is absolutely no reason for
11 them to raise property taxes. I can speak for
12 my county, and I think we can speak for most
13 counties: with this accomplishment of the
14 cap, there will be no reason for them to raise
15 county real property taxes.
16 One other open problem is fraud.
17 And I believe the Senate, we will be
18 addressing the issue of fraud, which, as many
19 of us know, can reach 10, 15, 20 percent of
20 the Medicaid program. And if we put that in
21 perspective, a $50 billion program, if just
22 10 percent is fraud, we're talking about
23 $5 billion, which is a lot of money.
24 So I congratulate both Senator
25 Hannon, you, Senator Meier, for the great work
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1653
1 that you've done. But again, there is a lot
2 more to do in terms of cost containment and
3 the elimination of fraud within the Medicaid
4 program.
5 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
6 Skelos will be recorded in the affirmative.
7 Senator Oppenheimer, to explain her
8 vote.
9 SENATOR OPPENHEIMER: I would
10 like to just respond to a couple of things
11 that have just been said.
12 While I certainly am very
13 appreciative that the county share, the county
14 property tax will not really be escalating
15 that much, hopefully, in the future, because
16 the main driving force was the Medicaid -- but
17 I would like to pick up on what my colleagues
18 said about the property tax, which is the
19 largest -- the largest piece of our property
20 tax, which is the funding of our schools.
21 And I think we will have to be
22 looking at some point in the future, and I
23 would like it to be sooner rather than later,
24 to alternative mechanisms for funding schools.
25 We know that the county property tax is maybe
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1654
1 20 percent of all the taxes we pay on
2 property. We know that schools are somewhere
3 between 55 and 65 percent of what we pay in
4 our property tax.
5 I think we have seen or heard
6 anecdotally so many people that have moved
7 away from our areas because they can no longer
8 afford the property tax and then they feel,
9 you know, very negatively about our schools
10 and about passing budgets. And it becomes
11 more and more difficult each year.
12 I think that a more progressive
13 tax, such as the personal income tax, should
14 be looked at closely and perhaps in some way
15 phased in over the next decade so that it
16 shares part of this burden of paying for our
17 school systems.
18 The property tax in many of our
19 counties is simply overburdened, and you
20 really can't do very much more with that. Yet
21 we don't want to deprive our schools. And
22 therefore I think the more progressive tax,
23 which is, of course, the personal income tax,
24 is the one that we should be looking at. And
25 perhaps just starting with 5 percent of the
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1655
1 cost being personal income tax and just moving
2 it higher as we go along.
3 It's something that I think we
4 should be talking about. I think for the
5 future of our state and of our children we
6 really have to discuss this.
7 I'll be voting yes on this bill.
8 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
9 Oppenheimer will be recorded in the
10 affirmative.
11 Senator Fuschillo, to explain his
12 vote.
13 SENATOR FUSCHILLO: Thank you,
14 Mr. President.
15 I will vote in the affirmative.
16 But, just briefly, I want to just congratulate
17 you and Senator Hannon on the fine work that
18 you have done on the task force and the
19 recommendations that have finally been
20 implemented.
21 But there's an opportunity here,
22 and it's been stated on this floor, that for
23 the county executives that have been crying
24 for this, to give it back now.
25 Now, my colleague Senator Winner
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1656
1 got up and explained how the property taxes
2 have increased. I think some county
3 executives have used that as an excuse. In
4 one of my counties, the Medicaid expenditure
5 is less than 10 percent of the budget, and he
6 cries that the sales tax is eating it all up.
7 It's not. The sales tax in Nassau County
8 raises nearly a billion dollars. Medicaid
9 expenditures are about $250 million.
10 When you equate that to the real
11 property taxes -- and Senator Balboni has
12 demonstrated this day after day back home --
13 it's less than 1 percent of the real property
14 taxes.
15 So where's the relief? I wish we
16 had a measure tied into this that we should
17 call publicly on our county executives to
18 provide a CPR program, County Property/Tax
19 Relief program. Give it back to the
20 taxpayers. Provide them with real meaningful
21 relief.
22 We're spending millions and tens of
23 millions of dollars on this Medicaid relief
24 program. We should now be calling on them to
25 give it directly back to the taxpayers.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1657
1 I vote aye.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
3 Fuschillo will be recorded in the affirmative.
4 Senator Marcellino, to explain his
5 vote.
6 SENATOR MARCELLINO: I would like
7 to add my voice to my colleagues'. Senator
8 Skelos and Senator Fuschillo have said it very
9 eloquently. I do believe it's time for the
10 counties to take a look at cost containment,
11 make sure that they maintain the fact that,
12 when we take over the cap, that the benefits
13 of taking over the cap on the state are not
14 lost to the taxpayers.
15 The taxpayers of the counties must
16 get some relief at this point in time, and
17 it's up to the county executives to hold the
18 line and to make sure that these taxes are not
19 raised. In fact, if they are cut, it would be
20 all to the good.
21 With respect to the property tax
22 shift maybe to an income tax, Senator
23 Oppenheimer, I would suggest be careful what
24 you ask for. The income tax is not the
25 fairest tax. It may be progressive, but it's
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1658
1 also a tax that lands very heavily on the
2 middle class. The rich, the very wealthy can
3 hide money. Foundations, other tax-exempt tax
4 shelters and a whole bunch of mechanisms can
5 be used by these people, whereas the middle
6 class does not have these capabilities. If we
7 don't watch it, they will pay an inordinate
8 percentage of that tax.
9 So while it's something we could
10 look at, we should study it very carefully.
11 Because otherwise we could be buying into an
12 even more unfair system. So I suggest we take
13 care.
14 In fact, the STAR program is the
15 beginnings of a shift from the property tax to
16 the income tax. We're doing that now. Let's
17 not go jumping willy-nilly into something that
18 would be even worse without very good study
19 and extensive study on this particular issue.
20 It's not as good as it sounds.
21 I vote aye, sir.
22 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
23 Marcellino will be recorded in the
24 affirmative.
25 Announce the results.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1659
1 THE SECRETARY: Ayes, 60. Nays,
2 1. Senator Parker recorded in the negative.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The bill
4 is passed.
5 The Secretary will continue to
6 read.
7 THE SECRETARY: Calendar Number
8 399, by the Senate Committee on Rules, Senate
9 Print Number 3671, an act to amend the Tax
10 Law.
11 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN:
12 Explanation.
13 SENATOR JOHNSON: Mr. President,
14 this bill enacts into law major components of
15 the legislation relating to taxes and revenues
16 which are necessary to implement the state's
17 fiscal plan for the 2005-2006 fiscal year.
18 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
19 Balboni.
20 SENATOR BALBONI: Mr. President,
21 on the bill and on the budget.
22 Back on February 20th of 1990, John
23 Bonacic and I were elected to the New York
24 State Assembly. Back then, this is the way we
25 did the budgets: Three men in a room would
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1660
1 work, white smoke would appear, mammoth
2 documents would appear on the desks as
3 unintelligible as Egyptian hieroglyphics, we'd
4 get a couple of hours at best to review them,
5 we'd vote in the dead of the night. And it
6 was always late.
7 This year we have a budget
8 negotiated in public by the members of the
9 Legislature, then led by five men in a very
10 public room. It's been on our desks for three
11 days. We have debated it in the light of day,
12 and it is before the end of the fiscal year.
13 What a difference.
14 But this year's budget that was
15 decided by the conference committees leads us
16 to a discussion as to how could this situation
17 have persisted for so long. We always look
18 back on that. How could it be 20 years
19 without a budget on time? I found an answer
20 which I would like to proffer to you in a book
21 that I just completed by Paul Grondahl. It's
22 called I Rose Like a Rocket, and it's about
23 the time that Theodore Roosevelt spent in
24 Albany.
25 And in 1887, they had so much
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1661
1 confusion and chaos they couldn't even decide
2 on who the Speaker should be. For several
3 months, they did nothing in Albany. And you
4 know why? Because of the diversity, the
5 geopolitical challenges of the state, and the
6 economic differences. Sound familiar? That's
7 where we are today. The same exact issues,
8 but exacerbated.
9 So we have reached a consensus
10 today because of who we are. And let me be
11 clear on this. We're here today now, at this
12 time, not because of certain self-serving,
13 disingenuous local politicians or editorial
14 boards or so-called reform groups. We are
15 here today because of people: people in this
16 institution, the staffs who have worked so
17 incredibly hard, both in this chamber and the
18 other chamber and on the second floor, and the
19 advocates who have been roaming the halls for
20 months.
21 And we are here today because of
22 the people in this body, who for the last ten
23 years at least have said that an on-time
24 budget is the priority for the state. This
25 year we got partners.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1662
1 But let's also be clear about
2 something else. This cannot be the end. This
3 must be the beginning. The people we
4 represent, who have really been the people who
5 have moved this process, desire a good budget
6 and an on-time budget, and they deserve no
7 less. And we can do it. With all the
8 diversity and all the challenges, we can get
9 together.
10 And, you know, it's been a tough
11 couple of years for this Legislature as a
12 whole. We've been denigrated in the press.
13 I'm here to say you know what, this isn't our
14 crowning achievement. This is our job. But
15 I'm proud to be a member of this Legislature,
16 working together, moving forward. That's what
17 it's about.
18 I'm going to vote aye on this one.
19 Thank you.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
21 Diaz.
22 SENATOR DIAZ: Thank you, Mr.
23 President. On the bill.
24 This is my third year in this
25 chamber. I'm here in part thanks to my
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1663
1 colleague Senator Connor. And I will always
2 be grateful to Senator Connor for helping me
3 become an elected official in this body as a
4 state senator.
5 But when I came here three years
6 ago, I came on under new leadership, a
7 minority leader named David Paterson. And I
8 have been here for three years. And since I
9 got here, I've overheard people saying, The
10 budget is never on time. They're always
11 criticizing us.
12 And yesterday, yesterday I read in
13 the Daily News a quote made by a state
14 senator, my colleague Eric Senator
15 Schneiderman. In that quote he said that
16 everybody -- more or less, he said that we're
17 all trying to get the glory for passing a
18 budget on time. And if I recall right, in
19 that quote he also said: My colleagues, don't
20 think, my colleagues, that this will make them
21 golden boys.
22 Well, when I came here three years
23 ago, as I said before, I came under the
24 leadership of Senator Paterson. In that first
25 year, in that first year, Senator Paterson was
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1664
1 able to join together with Senator Bruno and
2 for the first time in many, many years, we got
3 together and we had a unanimous Senate voting
4 to override the Governor's veto. That first
5 year of Senator Paterson's leadership.
6 In the second year of Senator
7 Paterson's leadership, my second year of me
8 being here, there was another override. Last
9 year, Senator Paterson obtained three more
10 members to our conference.
11 And this year, under Senator
12 Paterson's leadership, and Senator Bruno, we
13 are passing a budget on time for the first
14 time in 20 years. And Senator Balboni just
15 said that this time we did it not three men
16 locked in a room, but publicly, that everybody
17 could see.
18 So, my colleagues, referring to the
19 quote of Senator Schneiderman in the Daily
20 News, if all those achievements under Senator
21 Paterson and Senator Bruno in the last three
22 years doesn't make Senator Paterson a golden
23 boy -- well, let me tell you, to me, Senator
24 Paterson is a golden boy in the last three
25 years I have been here.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1665
1 So you need a golden boy to take
2 credit for what we have done? There's a
3 golden boy.
4 And I'm voting yes. Thank you.
5 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
6 Farley.
7 SENATOR FARLEY: Thank you, Mr.
8 President.
9 I rise on this very happy occasion
10 to say that we will be having an on-time
11 budget. I was here for a number of years, as
12 a few of my colleagues, where we passed
13 on-time budgets. We used to stop the clock
14 occasionally because we were running a little
15 bit over.
16 But, you know, I was pleased to see
17 a brand-new process where the Minority in both
18 houses also participated in open forums.
19 And let me just pay tribute to our
20 Majority Leader on this side of the aisle, who
21 kept us informed the entire way and in my
22 judgment was the moving force to get an
23 on-time budget. He was relentless in that
24 pursuit, as was our conference almost
25 unanimously.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1666
1 As somebody that chaired a
2 conference committee, I found in the other
3 house every single member of our conference
4 committee, on both sides of the political
5 spectrum, were committed to an on-time budget.
6 And it can happen. And of course
7 the big thing that we have to do is make sure
8 it happens next year when all of you good
9 people are running for reelection. Because
10 we've started an on-time situation, and I
11 think we've got the things in place. We have
12 to do more.
13 But my congratulations to my
14 colleagues, but a particular congratulations
15 should go to the Majority Leader of this house
16 because he was really the major force in
17 pushing this, in pushing everybody towards
18 getting a budget, possibly because those of us
19 in the Capital District feel the heat of a
20 late budget as badly as anybody in the state.
21 Thank you, Mr. President, and
22 congratulations to all my colleagues.
23 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
24 DeFrancisco.
25 SENATOR DeFRANCISCO: Yes. On
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1667
1 this side of the aisle we may not have a
2 golden boy, but we certainly have a very
3 distinguished silver-haired man -- who anyone
4 who knows the process fully has understood for
5 the last several years that the mediator
6 between the respective parties in the budget
7 process has always been Joe Bruno.
8 And I think what Senator Farley
9 said is right on the money. In order to make
10 this happen, there has to be somebody that's a
11 mediator. Not just someone who's willing to
12 stick on a specific philosophical point, but
13 an individual who's able to get people
14 together.
15 And he was good enough to have the
16 minority leaders of each house participate
17 this year. And that made things happen, I
18 think, as well, the fact that everyone
19 participated.
20 So we don't have our golden boy,
21 but we have the silver-haired distinguished
22 gentleman that has moved this body and this
23 process more than anyone else has, at least in
24 my time in the New York State.
25 Thank you.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1668
1 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
2 Liz Krueger.
3 SENATOR LIZ KRUEGER: Thank you,
4 Mr. President. On the bill.
5 Before we complete our assignment,
6 as it's been described, to finish our work on
7 the budget, this revenue bill is the bill we
8 should be spending an enormous amount of time
9 talking about. And that we did not in the
10 conference process.
11 But I was delighted to hear so many
12 of my colleagues today already talk about
13 their interest in dealing with tax policy.
14 Senator Bonacic, who raised his concerns about
15 property taxes and paying for schools. The
16 issues raised about the relationship between
17 what we did in Medicaid and what the tax rate
18 at the county level might be. The point of
19 Senator Marcellino that be careful when you
20 assume a progressive tax is in fact that, when
21 you look at the loopholes that certain
22 individuals can take.
23 And that starts me off again with
24 delight that having a budget done on time,
25 maybe we will actually this year attempt to
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1669
1 bite into the extraordinarily complex set of
2 issues that is New York State tax policy and
3 our failure to address so many of these
4 issues.
5 Our fight, as always, in the budget
6 is where do we get the money and how do we
7 prioritize spending it. But to be honest, we
8 don't look at where we get the money very
9 often. And in fact, in this house for many
10 years we have not done the job we ought to to
11 evaluate New York State tax policy, what its
12 equity is, what its progressive versus
13 regressive outcomes are, what the relationship
14 is between what we decide to do at the state
15 level and what our localities can and cannot
16 do.
17 What was not said here today, but
18 we all know is true, one of the reasons that
19 our counties are so aggravated and the people
20 in our counties are so aggravated about their
21 property tax rates is because it's one of the
22 only taxes they control at home. We control
23 tax policy here in Albany. And frankly, we
24 don't do our homework on it.
25 So when I evaluate this budget, and
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1670
1 I've spoken several times in this week about
2 it, I evaluate both what we don't have money
3 for and then how we're spending that money.
4 But this is the only opportunity, I think, in
5 the context of the tax and revenue bill to
6 raise, again, some very serious questions
7 about the money we don't collect in taxes and
8 what that outcome is for individuals in our
9 districts and also for businesses.
10 Because in fact what we
11 consistently do in New York State tax policy
12 is to favor large corporations, large
13 multinational and multistate corporations over
14 small businesses, despite the fact that small
15 businesses are in fact the creators of the
16 greatest number of jobs in New York State.
17 And so when you look at our tax
18 expenditure reports, you can add up that we
19 give in this year's budget $465 million in
20 special depreciation, exemptions and credits,
21 primarily to large corporations. And we
22 should ask the question, what if that money
23 was available for education instead? What if
24 that money was available for transportation
25 without having to do as much borrowing as we
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1671
1 have approved earlier this week for
2 transportation?
3 And that budget includes
4 $2.15 billion for corporate franchise
5 exclusions of interest, dividends, capital
6 gains from subsidiary capital. Again,
7 primarily large corporations. Small
8 businesses can't take advantage of those
9 expenditures and loopholes.
10 Or the fact that while we have
11 changed Empire Zones -- and I will get to that
12 in a little bit -- we project in the
13 expenditure budget $437 million in exemptions
14 and tax credits for businesses in Empire
15 Zones.
16 So it's both the questions of
17 Empire Zones and how we oversee them and how
18 we're going to decide what happens in the
19 future through this bill, but also the lost
20 revenue to the State of New York, money that
21 is not available for education, is not
22 available for transportation, is not available
23 for health care or social services because we
24 have made -- I question whether a conscious
25 decision, but we have made the decision to
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1672
1 exempt certain subsidiary types of businesses
2 from paying taxes.
3 And again, and I've used these
4 examples, but I want to highlight them, if I
5 buy a gold ring or a gold necklace or silver
6 earrings in the state of New York, I pay sales
7 tax. If I buy the raw bullion of gold or
8 silver or coins, I don't pay sales tax. And
9 that means the State of New York loses,
10 according to this budget, $108 million a year
11 in tax revenue.
12 What would you do with $108 million
13 more? We might disagree about it, but what's
14 the justification?
15 And we exempt the cable television
16 industry from $140 million in sales tax and
17 $80 million in corporate tax reductions for
18 cable TV. There's always the question in
19 business about what kind of taxes drive a
20 company away from a state or locality. But
21 cable TV? Can you ignore the New York market,
22 simply say: We don't like the taxes, we won't
23 do cable television in the state of New York?
24 I think not.
25 And I personally like having cable
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1673
1 television. It lets me watch Bravo and watch
2 the reruns of "West Wing." And yet I wonder
3 why that's a tax-free option.
4 And we're continuing to underwrite
5 historic barns. And maybe that's a terrific
6 use of taxpayer dollars, but again I will ask,
7 $75 million in tax exemptions for historic
8 barns, is that a priority in the tax policy of
9 your communities and your counties?
10 And we don't decouple from federal
11 tax policy on a variety of issues that we
12 should be asking hard questions about. And so
13 I'm very glad that Senator Marcellino raised
14 that question about personal income tax versus
15 other types of taxation, because he's right.
16 Wealthier New Yorkers figure out how to avoid
17 taxation because they've got more money to
18 protect and they've got accountants.
19 So this year in our tax budget we
20 will lose, because we haven't decoupled from
21 federal policy, we'll lose $749 million
22 because of our rules around capital gains at
23 death. And that's for wealthy New Yorkers.
24 And we will lose $483 million in
25 revenue from the exclusion of interest on life
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1674
1 insurance and annuities. And it's only
2 high-income New Yorkers who are in fact
3 choosing to make investment decisions to
4 reduce their taxes through annuities. And in
5 fact, that number has grown, has over doubled
6 between 1998 and 2005 as loss of revenue to
7 the State of New York because people do make
8 financial decisions as individuals based on
9 where they can avoid taxes.
10 But again, who's able to do that?
11 And does it skew the tax base for the State of
12 New York?
13 And we're making more mistakes this
14 year in this budget, rather than sitting down
15 and answering some of the questions I've
16 raised that were decisions made in previous
17 years' budgets. Why are we passing a single
18 sales factor tax credit this year? It is
19 estimated that this will be a tax cut of
20 $130 million when fully implemented. But if
21 you do the research from other states that
22 have passed this type of law, the assumption
23 actually is it will cost us far more.
24 And there's reports, huge numbers
25 of reports coming out for states that have
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1675
1 implemented single sales tax factors. And
2 some of the points that they make, very
3 powerfully, is that while it decreases the
4 taxes for large multistate and multinational
5 corporations, it actually increases taxes on
6 small business in relationship and in
7 competition.
8 And the states that have passed
9 these taxes are wondering about why they've
10 done this and whether they should continue
11 them. A report that just came out this month
12 talks about the issue of the single sales tax
13 factor in the Intel Corporation in several
14 southwestern and western states. And their
15 conclusion is that in fact the single sales
16 factor changes did not increase, for
17 corporations -- even though they're the ones
18 who lobbied to have it in all these states, it
19 did not increase the amount they invested in
20 single sales factor states versus states
21 without this tax exemption. And in fact, they
22 disproportionately continued to invest in
23 non-SSF states.
24 And that it did not increase jobs
25 and in fact appears to have reduced jobs,
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1676
1 because there's no direct association with
2 this tax and an obligation of the company to
3 increase jobs, a test we should always use in
4 tax policy.
5 And so, again, why would we pass a
6 new tax exemption for large corporations worth
7 $130 million when there's not one person in
8 this chamber who would say that everything
9 they thought was a priority for the State of
10 New York or their constituents got into this
11 budget?
12 And why are we passing an expansion
13 of the CAPCO program, another questionable, at
14 best, model for tax exemptions, a model that
15 allows insurance companies to invest in
16 venture capital and reduce their taxes?
17 Private companies should choose to
18 invest in venture capital. That's the market.
19 Why should the State of New York choose to
20 subsidize, through tax policy, certain types
21 of businesses' ability to have surplus cash
22 and invest it in venture capital? We don't
23 get a win out of this; we lose tax dollars.
24 And there have been studies done
25 around the country about the fact that CAPCOs
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1677
1 usually go unnoticed but rarely have proved to
2 be effective in any way.
3 And on the Empire Zones, it's a
4 dilemma, because I think we all recognize that
5 the way we've been running Empire Zones has
6 not worked. And there are some improvements
7 in the agreement that has been made to
8 increase oversight on Empire Zones and to
9 require reporting and to, in theory, have the
10 authority to throw companies out of their
11 Empire Zone agreements if they fail to meet
12 new tests we will place on them.
13 Except it doesn't change the fact
14 that the research does not prove that the
15 enormous amount of money we're losing through
16 Empire Zones is not in fact increasing the
17 number of jobs being created.
18 And ironically, if you look at the
19 details Empire Zone to Empire Zone, what we
20 have done in the state of New York is make our
21 towns and our villages and our counties and
22 our cities all compete with each other to see
23 who can have a race to the bottom of claims
24 they've got the lower tax package than the
25 town next to them or figure out a way to get
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1678
1 the zone lines moved.
2 And that in fact at the end of the
3 day there's not evidence that we're really
4 increasing jobs, we're just moving the people
5 around the map of the state of New York, so
6 that a job that might have been in Senator
7 Meier's district last week would move into
8 Senator Libous's district this week. But that
9 doesn't increase the number of jobs.
10 We are losing huge amounts of tax
11 revenue. And I don't believe it is smart for
12 regional planning or for local planning that
13 we have trapped our localities in this
14 scenario.
15 So while I will say that the Empire
16 Zone proposals this year are significantly
17 better than what we have had up until today, I
18 am not convinced that this will lead us down
19 the road of a more successful model. I am
20 convinced this will extend these programs
21 until the year 2015. And again, who's doing
22 the homework? Who's asking the questions?
23 Who's even evaluating the reports that are
24 coming in?
25 Again, my theme is an attempt to
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1679
1 argue that we have to do a serious job of
2 evaluating tax policy in the state of
3 New York. We have to remember that our budget
4 is not just the budget we talk about as
5 revenue and expenses, but also the tax
6 expenditure budget that comes out each year,
7 that every year grows and grows and grows by
8 the billions. And I don't believe either
9 house of this Legislature is doing our
10 homework or asking the right questions.
11 And when we go home and we say to
12 our constituents we got a budget done on time,
13 it was full of compromises, we're happy about
14 some things, we're not happy about others, the
15 fundamental question is was it the best budget
16 we could do.
17 And unless we're prepared to really
18 evaluate and analyze how we're spending our
19 money and how we're raising and who we're
20 exempting from having to pay their fair share
21 of taxes in the state of New York, we can't
22 sincerely say that we passed the best budget
23 we could.
24 So I will vote against this bill,
25 because I think it goes down the wrong road on
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1680
1 single sales factor, on CAPCO. And while I
2 give 50 percent points for the Empire Zone
3 efforts, I don't believe at the end of the day
4 it will meet the needs of the state.
5 And again, I hope that now that our
6 budget, in theory, will be done today,
7 tomorrow, soon, that the members who got up
8 today to speak about their own recognition of
9 tax policy problems in their own communities
10 and their own counties, or on fundamental
11 issues such as education and health care, will
12 be willing to take a serious look and spend a
13 healthy amount of time evaluating the New York
14 State tax code and where we ought to be going
15 in the 21st century.
16 Because maybe this tax code worked
17 in the 20th century, but it will not solve our
18 problems for the 21st century. And today
19 we've increased some of them with this bill.
20 Thank you, Mr. President. I'll
21 vote no.
22 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
23 Johnson.
24 SENATOR JOHNSON: Mr. President
25 and my colleagues, I'd like to of course
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1681
1 extend my congratulations to Senator Joseph
2 Bruno -- and of course David Paterson, who
3 worked with him in this house -- for his
4 initiative in getting a resolution of the late
5 budget problem by helping initiate public TV
6 sessions with the Governor and the other
7 house, sitting together; for putting together
8 the conference committee process, which we
9 used last year to try to get a budget reform
10 bill which this house passed, that one house
11 passed.
12 I want to thank Senator Neil
13 Breslin, my ranking Minority member on the
14 Senate Finance Committee, for his help in
15 helping to expedite this process.
16 And of course I can't say enough
17 about the Senate staff. Mary Louise Mallick
18 and her staff, day and night working. We have
19 all sorts of trying to work this out, trying
20 to that out, give us another draft. This has
21 been going on for quite a period of time, as
22 you know, and they eventually put it all
23 together.
24 We've even had the cooperation of
25 the other house this year, which of course
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1682
1 helped to make this all possible.
2 So we have a -- some people say, I
3 always wanted an on-time budget. Well, I
4 think everyone in here can say the same thing,
5 because we've all wanted an on-time budget.
6 We never could get around to the formula that
7 would magically put it all together.
8 But I think this year we've
9 accomplished it, collectively. So we can
10 thank ourselves, thank the leadership, thank
11 the Governor that he played a role in this as
12 well.
13 And if this budget is the final
14 budget, it's done as much as we can do for the
15 people that we represent, economically but
16 also timely, which we never could get the
17 formula together to have it timely and the
18 right budget. We always had to delay until we
19 got what we needed to take home. I think
20 everybody's got what they need to represent
21 their people adequately.
22 So let's all congratulate each
23 other, and thank you all for your support.
24 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
25 Robach.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1683
1 SENATOR ROBACH: Yes, Mr.
2 President. On the bill.
3 I rise to support this and the
4 entire budget package. First and foremost,
5 it's been said before, but I think it's
6 critically important, for the first time in
7 20 years we are getting this budget done. And
8 to many people, not only in this room but in
9 our districts, that is an important thing. It
10 has come to symbolize the gridlock and the
11 lack of compromise that's gone on for far too
12 long for a myriad of reasons.
13 And I want to say that oftentimes
14 we don't need political rhetoric to get a
15 budget done, we really need more compromise
16 and statesmanlike men and women striking
17 compromise to get it done. And I think this
18 has happened this year, and I applaud
19 everyone.
20 Interestingly enough, I found
21 something that I was reading that my father
22 had said to a reporter some twenty years ago
23 when his frustration started with the late
24 budget, who I followed into the Assembly. And
25 he said to the reporter, he said: "You know,
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1684
1 without compromise, the only way I know how to
2 do a budget is if I could provide more and
3 better services for less money."
4 Well, we know that's not going to
5 occur. So this year what allowed us, without
6 the ability to do that, the impossible, what
7 allowed this to happen was compromise.
8 And I would say that this budget,
9 while not perfect, really meets the needs of
10 New Yorkers in education, higher education,
11 health care, roads, bridges, public safety and
12 other things. And that is good. It is good
13 for a number of ways. And what allowed us to
14 get to those good compromises was utilization
15 of the conference committees.
16 So while I want to applaud everyone
17 in every house, both leaders here and even in
18 the other house, I want to say it is a great
19 day that this year's process resulted in a
20 reasonable budget that meets the needs of
21 New Yorkers. But I would concur with my
22 colleague Senator Balboni, while our work is
23 done on the budget, on the process it is not
24 done yet.
25 The measures that were passed in
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1685
1 this house, in a bipartisan measure, to
2 utilize conference committees as though normal
3 operating procedure for doing a budget,
4 accepting the Comptroller's revenue
5 estimate -- and I would even go one step
6 further. I think the bill on a contingency
7 budget, very, very important.
8 If we can now take this timely
9 budget process and get the other house to act
10 on those measures that we have already passed
11 in this house, this will not become the
12 exception for the rule getting the budget done
13 on time, striking reasonable compromise -- it
14 will become the rule. And we should make it
15 the rule. That's what our constituents want.
16 I know that's what I want. And I believe that
17 that's what most of the people in this chamber
18 want. And hopefully we will continue down
19 this road.
20 But let me say not only will I vote
21 for this portion of the budget, the whole
22 thing. And in all sincerity, I say thank you
23 to the people who were smart enough, in
24 response to their constituents, to publicly be
25 engaged, the everyday members of these
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1686
1 conference committees, and strike compromises
2 to merge timeliness and content to get this
3 budget done.
4 I thank all my colleagues and vote
5 in the affirmative.
6 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
7 Sabini.
8 SENATOR SABINI: Thank you, Mr.
9 President. On the bill.
10 I think there is some merit and
11 congratulations to be given that we have
12 achieved a work product at this point in time.
13 It's been referred to in past years that a
14 long time ago they used to stop the clock. I
15 wasn't eager to see whether or not the
16 Majority Leader had the power, as he had said
17 he would get us out in daylight, to stop the
18 sun. That would really be impressive if he
19 could do that.
20 But I do want to say one thing and
21 take exception to an earlier speaker. Before
22 we spread all the praise that we should on
23 staff and the leadership of the two houses --
24 and to some extent to the Governor, for
25 becoming engaged toward the end -- but before
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1687
1 we hurt ourselves from patting ourselves on
2 the back, I want to take exception to
3 something that was said earlier.
4 I don't believe that this process
5 happened because we were all imbued with this
6 new sense of responsibility. So I do want to
7 thank the editorial boards and the civic
8 groups, who don't have a vested financial
9 interest in us getting our job done, for
10 forcing us to do our job on time.
11 I'll take you back to last year
12 when, after April 1st, we were here two days
13 out of the next 17. We're going to be here
14 after April 1st whether or not we pass this
15 budget, and that's a good thing, because
16 that's what we're supposed to do.
17 But if anyone thinks that all this
18 happened without public pressure, without a
19 targeted Assembly race in Nassau County,
20 without people losing their seats here, think
21 about this. Twenty-one years went by, people
22 were born and have now graduated college in
23 that period of time, during the time we didn't
24 have on-time budgets. There were members of
25 this body and of the Assembly that came into
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1688
1 the body, became committee chairs, and have
2 left since then.
3 The last time we had an on-time
4 budget, the Islanders were a decent hockey
5 team and won Stanley Cups. Now the NHL
6 doesn't even play.
7 So things have changed a lot in
8 21 years. And if you believe that this just
9 happened because we're all imbued with this
10 sense of honor all of a sudden, we're not only
11 kidding ourselves, you know, I guess there's a
12 bridge in Senator Connor's district we could
13 sell you if you believe that.
14 I don't believe that. I believe
15 that the attention that was given to the
16 process up here was long overdue. We all felt
17 it. Many of us knew it all along. And the
18 fact that we're actually doing what we're
19 supposed to be doing is a good thing, but
20 let's not kid ourselves. We're doing it
21 because people have held our feet to the fire
22 collectively. And I congratulate those people
23 for doing that. And if they were not part of
24 the process, I don't believe this would be
25 happening today.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1689
1 I'm going to be voting in the
2 affirmative.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
4 Nozzolio.
5 SENATOR NOZZOLIO: Thank you, Mr.
6 President. On the bill.
7 Mr. President and my colleagues,
8 what we are doing today is not simply enacting
9 a budget on time, but we are restoring
10 integrity in the budget process and, in so
11 doing, restoring accountability in
12 budget-making for our taxpayers.
13 Our taxpayers deserve this type of
14 government, a government that runs its budget
15 process in an efficient manner, in an on-time
16 manner, in an open manner, in a bipartisan
17 manner.
18 Each and every one of those who
19 participated in making this budget can be
20 proud of their efforts. But we have more to
21 do. We need to ensure that, in law, these
22 steps are taken and taken each and every year.
23 What we are doing here is not an
24 end, it's a beginning, a beginning to launch a
25 reform of the budget process, a beginning to
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1690
1 continue to fight for not simply an on-time
2 budget but a budget that achieves reform of
3 the welfare system and attacks welfare fraud,
4 a welfare fraud across this state that costs
5 the taxpayers billions of dollars.
6 Make government more effective and
7 efficient, but, most importantly, make
8 government more accountable to the people it
9 is designed to serve.
10 Mr. President, I'm supporting this
11 measure and, in doing so, I think taking a
12 giant step towards achieving the
13 accountability that our taxpayers deserve.
14 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
15 Oppenheimer.
16 SENATOR OPPENHEIMER: I just
17 wanted to second -- thank you, Mr. President.
18 I just wanted to second what Senator Johnson
19 said, that there are so much people,
20 particularly staff, that have really put
21 themselves out in this process. And half of
22 them are sleepwalking still because they
23 haven't had sleep in many weeks.
24 But particularly to the leader of
25 this house, and to my leaders, I want to thank
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1691
1 them.
2 And I want to say that I think I
3 can speak for Senator Montgomery and myself
4 that there is probably nobody that is happier
5 than she and me, and pleased with this
6 process. And I will tell you why.
7 We both got elected in 1984. That
8 was the last year there was an on-time budget.
9 Many people have been telling us that it is
10 because of she and me that we have not had an
11 on-time budget in the last 20 years. So as we
12 are now in our 21st year, we are very proud to
13 say we have at last accomplished the right
14 thing, done the right thing by our citizens.
15 And fortunately, the leadership of this house
16 and the other house have helped us a great
17 deal.
18 So thank you very much. I'm voting
19 yes on this bill.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
21 Klein.
22 SENATOR KLEIN: Mr. President, I
23 believe there's an amendment at the desk. I
24 ask that the reading of the amendment be
25 waived and ask to be heard on the amendment.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1692
1 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The
2 amendment is at the desk, the reading is
3 waived, and you're recognized for the purpose
4 of explaining the amendment.
5 SENATOR KLEIN: Thank you, Mr.
6 President.
7 This amendment provides for the
8 distribution of 11 percent from the video
9 lottery terminals, otherwise known as VLTs, at
10 racetracks to support education in the
11 municipalities which host these racetracks.
12 Several weeks ago I rose and spoke
13 in favor of the VLT proposal we had. While at
14 the same time I don't think the only source of
15 revenue to fund our schoolkids should be
16 gambling, it clearly is a very quick and
17 needed infusion of cash.
18 I also believe, and I said at that
19 time, I have Yonkers Raceway within my Senate
20 district, which also is in need of cash and
21 presently in tremendous disrepair.
22 There doesn't often come a time
23 where we can help several different groups by
24 advocating one specific proposal. But this is
25 certainly the case, because the money that we
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1693
1 would gain from VLTs would not only help the
2 tracks that are hosting these racinos around
3 the state but will also help education
4 throughout the state and would also help the
5 racing industry. So we're actually able to
6 use these monies, I think, for very, very
7 important purposes.
8 I'd like to take it one step
9 further. I think that the racetracks which
10 actually host the VLTs should also get a
11 larger share. You know, when we think about
12 it for a moment -- and I can certainly speak
13 for an example of Yonkers Raceway. Hopefully
14 this is going to take off and it's going to
15 generate a lot of money for the state. I'm
16 hopeful it's going to bring 40,000 to 42,000
17 people to Yonkers Raceway, like there used to
18 be years and years ago.
19 That requires more police service,
20 that requires more sanitation, that requires
21 better roads and access to and from the track.
22 So clearly the City of Yonkers in this case is
23 going to have to shoulder some of the burden.
24 And I think in turn not only
25 Yonkers Raceway but the seven tracks around
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1694
1 the State of New York should be able to share
2 specifically in the amount of money that's
3 generated by the VLTs. And I think they
4 deserve to get a portion, and that money
5 should be specifically earmarked for
6 education.
7 You know, since I got elected three
8 months ago I heard a lot about Yonkers. And
9 Yonkers, unfortunately, is facing very, very
10 difficult fiscal times. And what's happening
11 right now is the kids are suffering. You
12 know, they're talking about laying off
13 teachers, closing schools -- nothing that
14 would certainly benefit the youngsters of
15 Yonkers.
16 I think it's incumbent upon us as
17 leaders in this legislative body to generate a
18 quick infusion of cash for that education
19 system. You know, we can talk about school
20 aid formulas, we can talk about bringing a
21 CFE-like decision on behalf of the schoolkids
22 of Yonkers. But I think the time has come to
23 figure out a way that we can get some money to
24 Yonkers now.
25 So I urge my colleagues to support
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1695
1 this amendment.
2 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
3 Spano.
4 SENATOR SPANO: On the amendment.
5 I'd like to point out that it's
6 interesting the Minority is offering an
7 amendment that would allocate 11 percent of
8 the money raised by VLTs to all of the -- to
9 the school districts that have -- or to the
10 districts that host the racetracks in the
11 state. I think that's a good idea. Seems to
12 be a bit inconsistent with some of Senator
13 Schneiderman's earlier comments, but it's a
14 good idea.
15 I'm glad to see that you are
16 willing to take money away from a lot of your
17 school districts to give to school districts
18 like the City of Yonkers. And I thank you for
19 that.
20 I would say that if you are serious
21 about this proposal and it's not just a
22 political charade that we're in, as some might
23 suggest, that you go across the hall of the
24 Capitol, talk to the Assembly, and get them on
25 board. Get them on board my bill and my
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1696
1 proposal that we have been pursuing very
2 actively that would bring a substantial amount
3 of money back to the host communities.
4 I agree conceptually with this
5 proposal, glad that we're moving forward on an
6 on-time budget, and would not do anything on
7 the floor of this house today that would put
8 in danger of that on-time budget, certainly
9 with a proposal that the Assembly has already
10 dismissed.
11 But glad that if you are in fact
12 serious, glad to work with you to have your
13 continued cooperation and acknowledgement of
14 the problems that the City of Yonkers has, and
15 glad to take money that might be going to
16 other school districts across the state and
17 give it to the City of Yonkers.
18 Thank you for raising that issue
19 today.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
21 Skelos.
22 SENATOR SKELOS: Thank you very
23 much, Mr. President.
24 I just would like to point out
25 we've heard a lot of comments today about an
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1697
1 on-time budget. And we will have an on-time
2 budget today.
3 But I should point out to those who
4 would support this hostile amendment that,
5 under the rules of the Senate, a successful
6 nonsponsor motion to amend the bill shall
7 cause the bill to be recommitted to the
8 committee of origin for further study for a
9 minimum of ten days.
10 So my assumption is that anybody
11 that would support this amendment are saying
12 they do not want an on-time budget because we
13 could not bring this up for another 10 days.
14 So I follow up what Senator Spano
15 said, this is nothing but a political charade.
16 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: On the
17 amendment, those Senators in agreement please
18 signify by raising your hands.
19 THE SECRETARY: Those recorded in
20 agreement are Senators Andrews, Breslin, Diaz,
21 Dilan, Duane, Gonzalez, Hassell-Thompson,
22 Klein, L. Krueger, Montgomery, Onorato,
23 Oppenheimer, Parker, Paterson, Sabini,
24 Sampson, Schneiderman, Serrano, Stachowski and
25 Stavisky.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1698
1 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: The
2 amendment is not agreed to.
3 Senator Schneiderman, to close for
4 the Minority.
5 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN: Thank you,
6 Mr. President. I will speak very briefly.
7 This revenue bill, which
8 concludes -- I think everyone, including
9 critics, will say that this was an
10 extraordinary process this year. It led to
11 many breakthroughs, both in process and I
12 think it's fair to say in substance.
13 But I have to come back to a
14 comment that Senator Balboni made when he
15 opened the closings, as it were, that passing
16 a budget on time and debating openly and
17 trying to get the best budget we can is just
18 our job, and echo Senator Robach, who said,
19 you know, this is just the beginning, we have
20 a lot more work to do.
21 I respectfully submit that the most
22 delightful thing that has happened today is
23 that a debate broke out on the Senate floor
24 about tax policy for the first time since I've
25 been here. Senator Bonacic started it up.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1699
1 I would note, my colleagues, that
2 there's a gap in our system of conference
3 committees that we should address. There is
4 no conference committee that deals with tax
5 policy. There is no public debate about
6 whether we should continue on the path the
7 state has been on for the past decade of
8 becoming more and more regressive as we seek
9 new revenues from sales taxes, from fees.
10 Passing this bill increases title
11 applications for mobile homes from $25 to
12 $125. Can't get much more regressive than
13 that.
14 Whether we should continue on that
15 path or whether we should, as Senator Bonacic
16 pointed out, look for new ways, rely more on
17 the income tax. As Senator Krueger said, plug
18 the massive loopholes that have led fiscal
19 experts to describe our state tax code as
20 Swiss cheese.
21 Senator Marcellino pointed out that
22 some rich people seek to hide their incomes.
23 It's our job to close loopholes and make it
24 harder.
25 We're never going to get
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1700
1 everything, but I tell you, ladies and
2 gentlemen, one of the other unfortunate things
3 that this bill does is that it allows a
4 temporary increase in the personal income tax
5 on our wealthiest taxpayers to expire, and
6 that's costing the state $3 billion. So
7 obviously some wealthy taxpayers haven't
8 succeeded in hiding all of their money.
9 I would suggest that an open debate
10 over whether or not we should have a more
11 progressive tax system, an open debate over
12 whether we should close the corporate
13 loopholes that Senator Paterson proposed last
14 year and proposed this year that would
15 generate hundreds of millions of dollars by
16 simply adopting corporate tax laws that are
17 applicable in other states.
18 That's the debate we should have.
19 And I would suggest that if we go back through
20 this process next year, a conference committee
21 to actually debate tax and revenue policy
22 would be appropriate.
23 So I don't like some of the things
24 in this particular piece of legislation, and
25 for the same reasons as Senator Krueger
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1701
1 articulated in detail. And I have my concerns
2 with the continued reliance on more regressive
3 forms of revenue generation from regressive
4 taxes like the property tax, to gambling. I
5 have a problem with our economic development
6 programs that don't generate jobs, don't
7 produce and give us the return on our
8 investment we should seek.
9 But I think it's time to open that
10 debate up. This year we are coming up with
11 ideas -- and they're embodied in some of these
12 budget bills -- that have just never been
13 tried before. We have to address the issue of
14 revenue. We have to address the issue of
15 taxation.
16 We are just starting here today,
17 we're just starting here today on what I hope
18 will be a new process. If we just stop after
19 this and go back to the same old gridlock, we
20 haven't done our job.
21 But I'm sure that's not going to
22 happen. I'm sure that's not going to happen.
23 Now, now, now. If I lose my way, I have to
24 start all over again.
25 (Laughter.)
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1702
1 SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN: So I think
2 that the issue of taxation has been raised
3 here. I look forward to debating it. I look
4 forward to taking up Senator Bonacic's bill.
5 I look forward to dealing with issues that
6 were raised by Senator Klein's amendment.
7 Let's not stop here. Let's get the issue of
8 taxes on the table with everything else when
9 we reconvene.
10 Thank you, Mr. President.
11 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Debate
12 is closed, then.
13 The Secretary will ring the bells.
14 Members are asked to come to the
15 chamber.
16 Senator Bruno.
17 SENATOR BRUNO: Are you calling
18 members back into the chamber to make sure
19 everyone's here to vote on this very important
20 bill?
21 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Yes, we
22 are, Senator Bruno.
23 SENATOR BRUNO: You know, we're
24 hearing, while we're waiting to close debate
25 here, suggestions, thoughts, observations,
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1703
1 what can be criticisms. And anyone here can
2 do that.
3 Fact of the matter is, we're
4 completing a budget process here for the first
5 time in 21 years. And we are finishing this
6 budget process presently at about ten minutes
7 to 2:00. Would have been twenty of 2:00 if
8 people were shorter, but they weren't.
9 (Laughter.)
10 SENATOR BRUNO: But whatever.
11 Whatever works. Okay?
12 But the fact of the matter is that
13 we are still talking with the Executive,
14 talking with the Assembly, because there are
15 some issues that while we are acting on them,
16 that are still open for debate, negotiation,
17 and potential compromise. So that everyone in
18 government, with the Executive, with the
19 Assembly, with the Senate, has as much input
20 to this open, public process as is required,
21 necessary, or anyone wants.
22 So while we close this formal part
23 of what we have agreed on, we have a completed
24 budget, a balanced budget, contrary to some of
25 the observations that may be made. This
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1704
1 budget will total presently, as it stands, in
2 the neighborhood of $105 billion.
3 And there are some issues that have
4 been laid aside that are not critical to
5 having a complete, balanced budget. We're
6 going to be in session until the middle of
7 June, and we're going to be governing. And
8 when this process completes, we're going to be
9 doing other appropriations, we're going to be
10 doing supplementals, we're going to be
11 governing.
12 So that's the process that we're
13 all elected to, and that's what you are part
14 of. So while you can take a look and say this
15 glass is 9/10 full or it's 1/10 empty, that's,
16 you know, your selection. Fact of the matter
17 is, we are here, we got this done, we got it
18 done while the sun is shining, and that's a
19 credit to everybody in the process.
20 It's also a credit to everyone that
21 we continue the process, with the Executive,
22 to refine and improve any part of anything
23 that we have done and any part of anything
24 that we haven't done.
25 Keep talking about some of the HCRA
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1705
1 that was set aside. We'll get that done. We
2 can do it today, we can do it Monday, we can
3 do it attitude. We'll get it done. EPA?
4 We'll get it done. Today or next week or the
5 week after. Okay?
6 SENATOR PATERSON: Okay.
7 SENATOR BRUNO: Mr. President --
8 okay? Did I hear okay?
9 (Laughter.)
10 SENATOR BRUNO: Okay, thank you.
11 Mr. President, do we have people
12 here prepared to vote on this last of the
13 budget bills?
14 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: It
15 appears the members are in their seats,
16 Senator Bruno.
17 SENATOR BRUNO: Thank you, Mr.
18 President. I would suggest we move to the
19 roll call.
20 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Read the
21 last section.
22 THE SECRETARY: Section 3. This
23 act shall take effect immediately.
24 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Call the
25 roll.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1706
1 (The Secretary called the roll.)
2 THE SECRETARY: Those recorded in
3 the negative on Calendar Number 399 are
4 Senators Duane, L. Krueger, Parker, Savino and
5 Schneiderman.
6 Ayes, 56. Nays, 5.
7 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
8 Bruno, the bill and, therefore, a budget for
9 the State of New York is passed.
10 (Extended applause.)
11 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
12 Bruno.
13 SENATOR BRUNO: Mr. President,
14 given some of the discussions that are going
15 on, I'm going to suggest that we recess until,
16 say, 3:00 and ask for an immediate meeting of
17 the Majority conference in the conference room
18 and at that time determine where, if anywhere,
19 we are with some of the other business that we
20 might want to take up, and either take it up
21 or, sometime by 4:00 or 4:30, be adjourned.
22 That's the intent, that's the plan,
23 and hopefully that's the way it all goes.
24 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
25 Paterson.
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1707
1 SENATOR PATERSON: Mr. President,
2 I don't know what to do with myself.
3 (Laughter.)
4 SENATOR PATERSON: We will call a
5 conference of the Minority at 2:45. In the
6 interim, we'll take all the Majority's
7 suggestions that are being discussed.
8 But in all seriousness, Mr.
9 President, I'd just like to add to what
10 Senator Bruno said, that in this year I really
11 got the impression that the change in our
12 process -- the leader said the other day that
13 this was a process that was done almost
14 entirely openly. There are always
15 conversations that will be somewhat
16 confidential.
17 But in the end, I think everybody
18 leaves this room, staff and members and
19 observers, knowing that when we tried this
20 process that it went a lot smoother, that we
21 worked together a lot better and that the
22 spirit of cooperation was a lot greater than
23 any of us expected. And I was just very proud
24 to work among all of you during this period.
25 So we will, with Senator Gonzalez's
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1708
1 permission, have a Minority conference at
2 2:45.
3 And in the interim, Mr. President,
4 if any of the Majority members would like to
5 get up and suggest what I do with myself, I'm
6 all ears.
7 (Laughter.)
8 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER:
9 Immediate Majority conference; Minority
10 conference at 2:45 p.m.
11 The Senate will stand in recess
12 until 3:00 p.m.
13 (Whereupon, the Senate stood at
14 ease at 1:56 p.m.)
15 (Whereupon, the Senate reconvened
16 at 3:01 p.m.)
17 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: Senator
18 Skelos.
19 SENATOR SKELOS: Mr. President,
20 is there any further business to come before
21 the Senate?
22 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: There is
23 no further business, Senator.
24 SENATOR SKELOS: There being no
25 further business, I move we adjourn until
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910
1709
1 Monday, April 4th, at 3:00 p.m., intervening
2 days being legislative days.
3 ACTING PRESIDENT MEIER: On
4 motion, the Senate stands adjourned until
5 Monday, April 4th, at 3:00 p.m., intervening
6 days being legislative days.
7 (Whereupon, at 3:02 p.m., the
8 Senate adjourned.)
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
(518) 371-8910