Regular Session - February 12, 2007

                                                            477



         1                 NEW YORK STATE SENATE

         2

         3

         4                THE STENOGRAPHIC RECORD

         5

         6

         7

         8

         9                   ALBANY, NEW YORK

        10                   February 12, 2007

        11                       3:31 p.m.

        12

        13

        14                    REGULAR SESSION

        15

        16

        17

        18  LT. GOVERNOR DAVID A. PATERSON, President

        19  STEVEN M. BOGGESS, Secretary

        20

        21

        22

        23

        24

        25


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        478



         1                 P R O C E E D I N G S

         2                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Senate came

         3       to order without a gavel.  That's very good.

         4                  I would ask all assembled to please

         5       rise and join with me in reciting the Pledge

         6       of Allegiance.

         7                  (Whereupon, the assemblage recited

         8       the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.)

         9                  THE PRESIDENT:    Our invocation

        10       today will be delivered by the Reverend Peter

        11       G. Young, of Mother Theresa Community in

        12       Albany.

        13                  REVEREND YOUNG:    Dear God, we

        14       welcome our new Senator to this hall.

        15                  The State Seal that has

        16       demonstrated our loyalty to the state, again,

        17       it was replaced and replacing the crown in

        18       1777 that is above our dais.  It was Lady

        19       Liberty with a peasant cap, representing

        20       democratic rule, with her left foot stepping

        21       on the crown, representing the rejection of

        22       royalty.

        23                  That as citizens of the Empire

        24       State we have been the leader, with our

        25       constitution 12 years before the federal


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        479



         1       Constitution.  As a national leader, You have

         2       given these Senators a great power, O God, and

         3       an enormous responsibility.  So, God, we pray

         4       that they will always work in Your image and

         5       Your honor for all of those that will carry on

         6       this good name.

         7                  We pray too for our Senator who has

         8       been here with us for 23 years, Senator Don

         9       Halperin.  May he be able to rest with peace

        10       now and forevermore.

        11                  Amen.

        12                  THE PRESIDENT:    Thank you, Father

        13       Young, who has delivered invocations to the

        14       Legislature for 48 years.  And as we can close

        15       determine, over 3,000 invocations he's

        16       delivered to us.

        17                  Reading of the Journal.

        18                  THE SECRETARY:    In Senate,

        19       Sunday, February 11, the Senate met pursuant

        20       to adjournment.  The Journal of Saturday,

        21       February 10, was read and approved.  On

        22       motion, Senate adjourned.

        23                  THE PRESIDENT:    Without

        24       objection, the Journal stands approved.

        25                  Senator Skelos.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        480



         1                  SENATOR SKELOS:    Mr. President,

         2       would you please recognize Senator Smith for

         3       an introduction.

         4                  THE PRESIDENT:    Thank you,

         5       Senator Skelos.

         6                  Senator Smith.

         7                  SENATOR SMITH:    Thank you very

         8       much, Senator Skelos.

         9                  To my colleagues, to our friends in

        10       the gallery, to the staff that is here, today,

        11       on February 12th -- which is actually my

        12       daughter's birthday -- there are two reasons

        13       to celebrate.  One obviously is her birthday,

        14       which I am happy to celebrate, and hopefully

        15       she hears this one day.

        16                  But secondly, we recently had an

        17       election in Nassau County, a county where for

        18       a hundred years they had had a particular

        19       representation that was different from that

        20       which they have today.  Many people after this

        21       particular election indicated that they

        22       thought this was a great day for Nassau

        23       County.

        24                  I would only say that while it was,

        25       yes, a great day for Nassau County, it was


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        481



         1       also a great day for each and every one of you

         2       who are in this chamber, each and every one of

         3       you who are in the audience, because it made a

         4       very clear statement and a very clear message

         5       that the people of this state have decided

         6       that they want to see some change this

         7       government, some change in how we proceed, and

         8       that change has a lot to do with reforming the

         9       way we do business as a body.

        10                  There was a young man who took up

        11       the mantle of wanting to place himself, as I

        12       would put it, up for sacrifice.  He put

        13       himself out there as a county legislator, not

        14       knowing what the future would hold.  His wife,

        15       Elizabeth, who is here today, sat with him,

        16       his two sons; they talked about it.  And they

        17       agreed this is something that as a family they

        18       would do.

        19                  All of you who are in public office

        20       know exactly what it means when you make a

        21       decision in the middle of your life, in the

        22       middle of your career, to do something

        23       different.  Running for office is never an

        24       easy thing, especially when you're running for

        25       office in a district that has been challenged


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        482



         1       in a very heavy way for a long-term period.

         2                  This young man and his wife came

         3       together and agreed that he should pursue this

         4       office.

         5                  Craig Johnson is a young man who is

         6       an attorney; he distinguished himself in the

         7       county legislature as chair of Finance.  What

         8       he will bring to this body with regard to

         9       intellect, with regard to someone who in his

        10       heart wants to make sure that the people of

        11       this state get their fair, just due in the

        12       area of tax relief, in the area of healthcare

        13       services, in the area of economic development.

        14                  This young man, who I had the

        15       pleasure of knowing and met during this

        16       season, is a phenomenal young man.  His wife,

        17       his partner, is someone who I have joked with

        18       him about and said, "It's a good thing you ran

        19       and it's a good thing she decided not to,

        20       because it might have been a little bit

        21       difficult for the people."

        22                  He's a young man that Lieutenant

        23       Governor Paterson, who set us on a course two

        24       years ago, is very proud of, someone who he

        25       and I both know will be a great partner in


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        483



         1       this chamber.

         2                  You will find out in a very short

         3       period of time how smart this young man is,

         4       and you will also find out how great his

         5       family is.

         6                  He is joined today by his father,

         7       Stuart Johnson, who is also in the chambers

         8       with us.  He's joined by his sister, Karen

         9       Campbell, who is here.  Where is Karen?  Karen

        10       trying to jump back there.  He is also joined

        11       by his father-in-law -- DeFrancisco, you would

        12       like this -- Judge John Kase, who is also in

        13       the audience, and also his mother-in-law,

        14       Arlene Kase.

        15                  It is a family affair, and it is a

        16       family who is very proud of this young man,

        17       who I will tell you is the face of new

        18       leadership in the State of New York.  I am

        19       proud of him.  Our Governor is very proud of

        20       him, Eliot Spitzer, who we thank for all his

        21       effort and support.

        22                  And I thank all of my colleagues as

        23       well.  Many of you worked very hard, along

        24       with this young man.  Each and every one of

        25       you sacrificed your time.  The staff worked


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        484



         1       very hard, Doug Ferran.

         2                  And to my colleagues even on the

         3       other side of the aisle, I thank you also for

         4       the effort that you placed in this particular

         5       election, which also told the people of this

         6       state that we're serious about what we want

         7       done here.

         8                  And the effort that you put

         9       forward, while it was for a different

        10       individual, it also meant that you know that

        11       when we look to govern, we look to make sure

        12       that we have the best.  And everybody put

        13       their best foot forward in trying to make sure

        14       that that individual came to bear.

        15                  Craig Johnson is the individual who

        16       is sitting in this chamber today.  Craig

        17       Johnson is the young man who is going to be

        18       part of the leadership team of this state.

        19       Craig Johnson is the young man that his wife

        20       and his family is very proud of.

        21                  Craig Johnson is the young man that

        22       I am happy to call our new Senator, our new

        23       colleague, someone joining the phenomenal

        24       Democratic conference in the State Senate of

        25       New York, Senator Craig Johnson.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        485



         1                  (Extended applause.)

         2                  THE PRESIDENT:    Thank you,

         3       Senator Smith.

         4                  On behalf of Senator Bruno, the

         5       leader of the Senate, we welcome Senator

         6       Johnson, his wife Elizabeth, and the rest of

         7       their family to the chamber.

         8                  And Senator Bruno and all of the

         9       Senators wish Senator Johnson well in his

        10       endeavors.

        11                  We will now turn to the order of

        12       business.

        13                  Presentation of petitions.

        14                  Messages from the Assembly.

        15                  Messages from the Governor.

        16                  Reports of standing committees.

        17                  Reports of select committees.

        18                  Communications and reports from

        19       state officers.

        20                  Motions and resolutions.

        21                  Senator Skelos.

        22                  SENATOR SKELOS:    Mr. President,

        23       there's a resolution at the desk, 432, by

        24       Senator Seward.  If we could have it read in

        25       its entirety and move for its immediate


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        486



         1       adoption.

         2                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

         3       will read.

         4                  THE SECRETARY:    By Senator

         5       Seward, Legislative Resolution Number 432,

         6       congratulating the Marathon High School Field

         7       Hockey Team and Coach Karen Funk upon the

         8       occasion of capturing the 2006 New York State

         9       Class C Championship.

        10                  "WHEREAS, Excellence and success in

        11       competitive sports can be achieved only

        12       through strenuous practice, team play and team

        13       spirit, nurtured by dedicated coaching and

        14       strategic planning; and

        15                  "WHEREAS, Athletic competition

        16       enhances the moral and physical development of

        17       the young people of this state, preparing them

        18       for the future by instilling in them the value

        19       of teamwork, encouraging a standard of healthy

        20       living, imparting a desire for success and

        21       developing a sense of fair play and

        22       competition; and

        23                  "WHEREAS, The Marathon High School

        24       Olympians Field Hockey Team are the 2006

        25       New York State Class C champions after


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        487



         1       defeating East Rochester High School 2-1 in

         2       the second sudden-death overtime, to finish

         3       the year with 24-1 record; and

         4                  "WHEREAS, The standout performers

         5       for the Olympians this season were New York

         6       State Public High School Athletic Association

         7       All-Tournament Team members and Section IV

         8       Conference Division III First Team All-Stars

         9       Meghan Dean, Samantha Parker, and Hannah

        10       Griep; Section IV Division III First Team

        11       All-Stars Roni Allen, Kelley Braman and Marta

        12       Malmberg, and Second Team All-Stars Whitney

        13       Stephens and Tessa Knapp; and

        14                  "WHEREAS, The athletic talent

        15       displayed by this team is due in great part to

        16       the efforts of Coach Karen Funk, a skilled and

        17       inspirational tutor, respected for her ability

        18       to develop potential into excellence; and

        19                  "WHEREAS, The team's overall record

        20       is outstanding, and the team members were

        21       loyally and enthusiastically supported by

        22       family, fans, friends, and the community at

        23       large; and

        24                  "WHEREAS, The hallmarks of the

        25       Marathon High School Field Hockey Team, from


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        488



         1       the opening game of the season to

         2       participation in the championship, were a

         3       sisterhood of athletic ability, of good

         4       sportsmanship, of honor and of scholarship,

         5       demonstrating that these team players are

         6       second to none; and

         7                  "WHEREAS, Athletically and

         8       academically, the team members have proven

         9       themselves to be an unbeatable combination of

        10       talents, reflecting favorably on their school;

        11       and

        12                  "WHEREAS, Coach Karen Funk has done

        13       a superb job in guiding, molding and inspiring

        14       the team members toward their goals; and

        15                  "WHEREAS, Sports competition

        16       instills the values of teamwork, pride and

        17       accomplishment, and Coach Karen Funk and the

        18       outstanding athletes of the Marathon High

        19       School Field Hockey Team have clearly made a

        20       contribution to the spirit of excellence which

        21       is a tradition of their school; now,

        22       therefore, be it

        23                  "RESOLVED, That this Legislative

        24       Body pause in its deliberations to

        25       congratulate the Marathon High School Field


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        489



         1       Hockey Team, its members -- Roni Allen,

         2       Brittany Bell, Kaitlyn Bliss, Kelley Braman,

         3       Jessica Burlingame, Meghan Dean, Renee Drake,

         4       Stephanie Fiske, Gabrielle Gates, Hannah

         5       Griep, Nicole Gurewich, Amber Hines, Tessa

         6       Knapp, McKenna Light, Marta Malmberg,

         7       Cassandra Palmer, Samantha Parker, Mallorie

         8       Pendell, Lacey Pitman, Whitney Stephens,

         9       Michelle Stevens -- Scorekeeper Courtney

        10       Mathers and Coach Karen Funk on their

        11       outstanding season and overall team record;

        12       and be it further

        13                  "RESOLVED, That copies of this

        14       resolution, suitably engrossed, be transmitted

        15       to the Marathon High School Field Hockey Team

        16       and to Coach Karen Funk."

        17                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        18       resolution, Senator Seward.

        19                  SENATOR SEWARD:    Thank you,

        20       Mr. President.

        21                  I'm delighted to stand to salute

        22       and congratulate a group of truly outstanding

        23       young women, the Marathon High School

        24       Olympians Field Hockey Team, the 2006 New York

        25       State Class C champions.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        490



         1                  Marathon is a community located in

         2       Cortland County, and we like to say right in

         3       the heart of New York State.

         4                  This is truly an outstanding and

         5       well-rounded group of members of this team.

         6       Obviously they have athletic ability, but they

         7       also represent all the best in good character,

         8       good sportsmanship, teamwork, all of those

         9       fine qualities.

        10                  And also, in addition to all of

        11       this, they're an outstanding group not only of

        12       athletes but student-athletes.  A full

        13       two-thirds of the team have been so designated

        14       as student-athletes, with a team academic

        15       average of 92.

        16                  And certainly a great deal of the

        17       credit for the success of this team belongs to

        18       their coach, Karen Funk, who for the last

        19       33 years has coached the field hockey team at

        20       Marathon.  And in that 33 years, she has

        21       helped produce no fewer than 14 sectional

        22       championship teams and no fewer than seven

        23       state championship teams, this group being her

        24       seventh win at the state level.  So we have a

        25       real dynasty when it comes to field hockey at


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        491



         1       Marathon.

         2                  So, Mr. President, I'm delighted to

         3       sponsor this resolution and salute this group,

         4       who truly does epitomize all the best in the

         5       youth of New York State.  When I look at this

         6       fine group, I have a great deal of confidence

         7       in the future of our state.

         8                  Thank you, Mr. President.  And

         9       congratulations to this great team.

        10                  THE PRESIDENT:    Thank you,

        11       Senator Seward.

        12                  The question is on the resolution.

        13       All those in favor please indicate so by

        14       saying aye.

        15                  (Response of "Aye.")

        16                  THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

        17                  (No response.)

        18                  THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

        19       adopted.

        20                  Karen Funk, coach of the Marathon

        21       High School Field Hockey Team, may all of you

        22       who have been victorious so many times go back

        23       to Cortland County with another victory and

        24       another championship.  In the spirit of

        25       New York, leading the nation in all types of


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        492



         1       sporting endeavors, your contribution to field

         2       hockey has excelled beyond that of really any

         3       other high school, with your tremendous record

         4       over the last few years.

         5                  On behalf of Senator Bruno, the

         6       leader of the Senate, and all Senators here --

         7       and particularly Senator Seward, who sponsored

         8       this resolution -- we congratulate you and

         9       welcome you to the New York State Senate

        10       chamber.

        11                  (Applause.)

        12                  THE PRESIDENT:    The chair

        13       recognizes Senator Skelos.

        14                  SENATOR SKELOS:    Mr. President,

        15       if we could return to the order of reports of

        16       standing committees, there's a report of the

        17       Judiciary Committee at the desk.

        18                  If we could have it read at this

        19       time.

        20                  THE PRESIDENT:    Reports of

        21       standing committees.

        22                  The Secretary will read.

        23                  THE SECRETARY:    Senator

        24       DeFrancisco, from the Committee on Judiciary,

        25       reports the following nomination.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        493



         1                  As associate judge of the Court of

         2       Appeals, The Honorable Theodore T. Jones, Jr.,

         3       of New City.

         4                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator

         5       DeFrancisco, on the nomination.

         6                  SENATOR DeFRANCISCO:    Mr.

         7       President, I'm proud to move the nomination of

         8       Theodore T. Jones, Jr., of New City, as

         9       associate judge of the Court of Appeals.

        10                  This year, as in all years, we

        11       review the qualifications of the various

        12       judges.  In view of the fact of some recent

        13       events not involved with Judge Jones in any

        14       way, he was even looked at with more scrutiny

        15       concerning some recent developments in his

        16       area of the state -- more scrutiny not only on

        17       that, more scrutiny on his decisions, more

        18       scrutiny on everything about his background.

        19                  And I can tell you unequivocally

        20       that he is well-qualified, that he is an

        21       individual of utmost integrity, and that his

        22       decisions are well-reasoned and fair.  He

        23       calls 'em the way he sees 'em.  And we're

        24       happy that Governor Spitzer sent this

        25       nomination here to the full Senate.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        494



         1                  In moving this nomination, I just

         2       want to mention that his wife, Joan Hogans

         3       Jones, is here; his sons, Theodore Jones, III,

         4       and Wesley Jones; and many colleagues and

         5       friends, all of whom are, I'm certain, very

         6       proud of Judge Jones.

         7                  And in moving his nomination, I

         8       simply want to say that this is the best type

         9       of nominee we could possibly have -- an

        10       individual that has tried cases, that has

        11       clerked for a judge, that has been on a

        12       grievance committee reviewing the conduct of

        13       attorneys, and has an overall understanding of

        14       the law second to none.

        15                  So, Mr. President, I'm happy to

        16       move his nomination and request that you call

        17       on Senator Maltese for a second.

        18                  THE PRESIDENT:    The chair

        19       recognizes, on the nomination, Senator

        20       Maltese.

        21                  SENATOR MALTESE:    Mr. President,

        22       I rise today to speak about the American

        23       dream, the realization of the American dream.

        24       In seconding the nomination of Judge Jones,

        25       truly this exemplifies everything that's fine


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        495



         1       and great about our wonderful country.

         2                  Judge Jones grew up in the streets

         3       of Queens County, attended John Adams High

         4       School, 10101 Rockaway Boulevard, which

         5       happens to be in my Senate district.  What a

         6       fine example for the young men and women

         7       attending John Adams, that one of their

         8       graduates could go on to rise as an associate

         9       judge of the Court of Appeals, the highest

        10       court in the State of New York and certainly

        11       recognized as second only to the United States

        12       Supreme Court in Washington, D.C.

        13                  This is the type of individual that

        14       we have before us for nomination to our Court

        15       of Appeals.  A Vietnam veteran, a man who

        16       understands what it is to rise from modest

        17       beginnings and become a judge of the Supreme

        18       Court from Kings County, serving in that

        19       capacity for 15 years without any impugning of

        20       his integrity, a man recognized as calling

        21       them as he sees them.

        22                  Recent decisions of his in

        23       connection with the subway strike were made,

        24       calling it balanced, fair.  And, while during

        25       our judicial committee screenings he was


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        496



         1       subject to many questions, at the same time

         2       described as courageous, but shunning that

         3       appellation, saying that he called it as he

         4       saw it.  He denied being courageous in that

         5       respect.  But during all the hubbub, all the

         6       furor about that decision, not one person

         7       attacked his integrity.

         8                  This is a man of great integrity

         9       who was in private practice for 15 years and

        10       had members of the Bar Association here today

        11       testifying on his behalf, a man who managed

        12       within four short months to receive the

        13       highest awards from the Women's Bar

        14       Association, the Jewish Bar Association, and

        15       the Catholic Lawyers Guild.

        16                  A man who manages, through all the

        17       years and all of his public service, to have

        18       that same fine reputation for integrity.

        19                  Mr. President, certainly his

        20       background in legal aid, his background in

        21       private practice, his 15 years' experience on

        22       the bench have well suited him for this high

        23       judicial office.  I'm proud to second the

        24       nomination of Judge Theodore Jones as an

        25       associate judge of the Court of Appeals of the


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        497



         1       State of New York.

         2                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

         3       nomination, the chair recognizes Senator

         4       Hassell-Thompson.

         5                  SENATOR HASSELL-THOMPSON:    Thank

         6       you, Mr. President.  I rise to support the

         7       nomination of Justice Jones to this high

         8       office.

         9                  This morning we had the opportunity

        10       to ask a series of questions of Justice Jones.

        11       And I have to agree with my colleagues that

        12       while sometimes the questions were very

        13       pointed, at no time did he become ruffled, nor

        14       did he unravel, but, rather, answered the

        15       question that led us to believe that the kind

        16       of justice that he would provide from the

        17       bench would be fair and balanced.

        18                  He has made some very difficult

        19       decisions in his career.  And when asked of

        20       which one he was the proudest, he thought for

        21       a moment and then he responded.  But the pride

        22       came, I think, from his knowledge of law and

        23       how, no matter what the public may have

        24       thought of his decision, he felt that he made

        25       it for the right reasons.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        498



         1                  And so therefore I support my

         2       colleagues in this nomination and I thank the

         3       Governor for putting forth the name of an

         4       exceptional gentleman.  And I don't use that

         5       word often.  In this instance, it is totally

         6       appropriate to put forth the nomination of

         7       Justice Theodore Jones for this Supreme Court

         8       position.

         9                  I thank you, Mr. President.

        10                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        11       nomination, Senator Montgomery.

        12                  SENATOR MONTGOMERY:    Thank you,

        13       Mr. President.

        14                  I rise to join my colleagues in

        15       seconding the nomination of Judge Theodore

        16       Jones.  I will say that out of all the people

        17       that I know, he certainly is one of those

        18       people -- not simply because he does come from

        19       the County of Queens; he has lived in Brooklyn

        20       for many, many years; he was a neighbor for

        21       years; I know his wife and his family.  So --

        22       but that's really not why he would be one of

        23       the people that I would favor most.

        24                  It's because the qualities that he

        25       brings, I think, and his temperament are just


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        499



         1       exactly what we would like to see and the kind

         2       of person that we need as judge in such a high

         3       court.

         4                  So I'm very, very happy to vote for

         5       him, to nominate him, and certainly I

         6       compliment my colleagues and the leaders for

         7       making a very, very wise choice in Judge

         8       Jones.  And I look forward to him sitting in

         9       that position for many years.

        10                  Thank you, Mr. President.

        11                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        12       nomination, Senator Sampson.

        13                  SENATOR SAMPSON:    Thank you very

        14       much, Mr. President.

        15                  I rise in support of this

        16       nomination, but most of all I want to

        17       congratulate the Governor for appointing an

        18       esteemed individual.  I have had the

        19       opportunity to appear before Justice Jones and

        20       have had the opportunity to see how he, as

        21       chief administrator in the County of Kings,

        22       has done an excellent job.

        23                  But this is really a bright day for

        24       Kings County, a bright day for Brooklyn when,

        25       you know -- unfortunately, clouds have been


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        500



         1       cast on our Borough of Brooklyn and our County

         2       of Kings.  And while to some it may seem that

         3       it may be unjust that these clouds have been

         4       cast, but, Justice Jones, you bring a stream

         5       of sunlight to Brooklyn and let everyone know

         6       that out of Brooklyn, great things happen.

         7                  And I want to congratulate you not

         8       only on your impeccable character and

         9       integrity, but you are a person who I believe

        10       you call it as you see it.  And just because

        11       of that, Judge Jones, that's why you are

        12       admired and respected about by all members of

        13       the judiciary.

        14                  Once again, congratulations.  And I

        15       look forward to voting on your nomination to

        16       the Court of Appeals.

        17                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        18       nomination, Senator Perkins.

        19                  SENATOR PERKINS:    Thank you very

        20       much.

        21                  I also want to join in echoing my

        22       support for Judge Jones and his extraordinary

        23       career.  I guess for me what really is most

        24       significant is that he's been tested in fire,

        25       that he has been involved in some of the most


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        501



         1       controversial cases, not the least of which

         2       was the one involving the strike in New York

         3       City of the Transit Authority.

         4                  And whether or not we agree with

         5       the way he ultimately made a decision, one can

         6       feel comfortable that he made it with

         7       integrity, he made it on the basis of his

         8       understanding of the law, that he gave it

         9       fairness, and that he was balanced and

        10       forthcoming as to how he made his decision.

        11                  And so I think that the Governor

        12       should be complimented for having the

        13       foresight to find someone like him to make as

        14       his first choice in this Black History Month.

        15       It has a special significance for some of us

        16       throughout this state, for that matter.

        17                  And I think that we as a body

        18       should feel good that we are going to select

        19       someone that will truly represent the best of

        20       the judicial profession that we can have.  So

        21       thank you very much.  I'm glad to support this

        22       nomination.

        23                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        24       nomination, the chair recognizes Senator

        25       Nozzolio.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        502



         1                  SENATOR NOZZOLIO:    Thank you,

         2       Mr. President.

         3                  Mr. President, I rise as a member

         4       of this house and as a member of the Judiciary

         5       Committee.  And today, as we deliberated upon

         6       the nominee's qualifications, it was very

         7       clear that his broad background of experience

         8       will suit the court extremely well and the

         9       citizens of this state extremely well.

        10                  I wish to also thank Judge Jones

        11       for his service to our nation as a member of

        12       the military and as a participant in the

        13       Vietnam conflict.  For that, we should be

        14       grateful.

        15                  During our conversation, his

        16       testimony, in response to questions, it was

        17       clear to me and I feel assured that his

        18       construction of the law will be in the

        19       strictest sense.  And that he, in past

        20       dealings, some of which were mentioned today,

        21       did not shy away from making a hard decision

        22       if that was in fact the dictate of the law.

        23                  Having respect for the law, having

        24       respect for the legislators in this state in

        25       both this house and the Assembly who make the


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        503



         1       law, was certainly prominent in Judge Jones's

         2       description of his approach to judicial

         3       philosophy.

         4                  We hope that he will continue on

         5       that score and not in effect shy away from

         6       making a hard decision when it in fact is

         7       relevant to a statute that the elected

         8       representatives of the people -- that's the

         9       people in this room and the people down the

        10       hall -- have made as our state policy.

        11                  For that, Judge Jones, we wish you

        12       a long and a very healthy tenure on New York

        13       State's highest court.

        14                  Thank you, Mr. President.  I

        15       support this nomination.

        16                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        17       nomination, Senator Volker.

        18                  SENATOR VOLKER:    Mr. President,

        19       as I told the nominee at the hearing, I've

        20       been through a great many confirmation

        21       hearings over the years.  Over the last --

        22       particularly the last few years, I've been

        23       especially conscious of our responsibility to

        24       review any Court of Appeals judges.  And, you

        25       know, part of I guess is as I've gotten a


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        504



         1       little older, I've felt a responsibility to be

         2       especially careful.

         3                  I have to admit, because of some of

         4       the problems of Kings County -- and I will not

         5       get into it.  I was chided by a couple of

         6       judges from Kings County that maybe I was a

         7       little harsh on Kings County, a little bit on

         8       Brooklyn.

         9                  But I pointed out to them I wasn't

        10       referring to them, I was just referring -- we

        11       know the various problems the county's having.

        12       And that obviously what's happened because of

        13       Brooklyn, frankly, the -- we've had a court

        14       case that changed the system.

        15                  So I admit to you, when I looked at

        16       Judge Jones's background, I kind of was

        17       looking for a smoking gun.  Not only did I not

        18       find the smoking gun -- and I did a rather

        19       extensive dossier on him -- I didn't find

        20       hardly anything uncomplimentary.  And

        21       sometimes for us upstaters, that's a little

        22       frustrating.  But that's okay.

        23                  In all honesty, what I found was

        24       that he has a very solid background.  Now, as

        25       I honestly said, I said probably he's a little


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        505



         1       bit to the liberal of me, but then that would

         2       account for about 90 percent of all the people

         3       in this state -- and that's irrelevant --

         4       including my wife.

         5                  But I have to say that I was

         6       impressed, I was impressed by his testimony, I

         7       was impressed by his background.  And

         8       personally, I think -- and as I say, I had a

         9       few misgivings.  I mean, we are having a few

        10       little problems now with the person that

        11       appointed Judge Jones, but so be it.  It's our

        12       job to give advice and consent.

        13                  And I can't find -- I could find

        14       nothing in Judge Jones's background.  In fact,

        15       I did find something I didn't realize, and

        16       that is that he was with Howard Jones, Judge

        17       Jones, who I knew.  Because remember, I was

        18       there when the Rockefeller Drug Laws were

        19       passed, and Judge Jones I think was one of the

        20       first Court of Claims judges.  The Court of

        21       Claims was set up basically as part of the

        22       drug situation.

        23                  And Howard Jones was a super guy.

        24       I had quite a bit of dealings with him way

        25       back when.  And the fact that this Judge


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        506



         1       Jones -- who is no relation -- was part of his

         2       office and was very close to Judge Jones,

         3       frankly, was a big plus in his favor.

         4                  So my congratulations to you, my

         5       congratulations to the Governor for sending

         6       his first judicial nomination.  I think the

         7       one thing about George Pataki, he had

         8       excellent judicial nominations.  And this is a

         9       good one.

        10                  Congratulations and good luck on

        11       the Court of Appeals.

        12                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        13       nomination, Senator Smith.

        14                  SENATOR SMITH:    Thank you very

        15       much, Mr. President.

        16                  Allow me to also rise to

        17       congratulate my colleagues who are sitting on

        18       the Judiciary Committee -- Senator Ruth

        19       Hassell-Thompson, who is the ranking member,

        20       for her diligent work and effort; to the

        21       committee chair, Senator DeFrancisco, for his

        22       work as well.  But more importantly, let me

        23       thank the Governor for the selection of

        24       Justice Jones.

        25                  I can remember about a year ago,


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        507



         1       when I was ranking on that committee, Justice

         2       Jones came to see me, along with some other

         3       judges, and the subject matter had more to do

         4       with raises.  Well, Judge Jones, while we

         5       couldn't give you a raise today, we did raise

         6       something for you.  We raised the bench which

         7       you are now sitting on.

         8                  But let me also say, to put this in

         9       some historical perspective, in 1846, the

        10       constitutional amendment, was when the Court

        11       of Appeals came about.  In 1847, they sat and

        12       heard their first case.  160 years later,

        13       through 133 judges on the Court of Appeals,

        14       only three were African-American:  Fritz

        15       Alexander, Harold Stevens, and George Bundy

        16       Smith.

        17                  Today we are confirming the fourth

        18       African-American judge in 160 years since that

        19       court has been established.  You need to

        20       understand the significance of what that means

        21       not only to the State of New York, which now

        22       senses that there will be diversity on the

        23       bench, but what it says about the character

        24       and the St. John's Law School intellect of

        25       Judge -- Justice, I should say -- Theodore


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        508



         1       Jones.

         2                  We should be very proud of our

         3       Governor's selection.  We should be very proud

         4       of his 34-year legal career.  He has been, I

         5       would say to many, a pleasure to not only work

         6       with, but he has been someone who had an

         7       impeccable career.  You heard my good

         8       colleague Senator Volker talked about looking

         9       for a smoking gun.  He could not only not find

        10       the gun, he couldn't find no smoke neither.

        11                  (Laughter.)

        12                  SENATOR SMITH:    But this is a

        13       proud day for many of us.  Court of Appeals

        14       Justice Theodore Jones, you should know that

        15       all the people around the State of New York

        16       are not only proud of you today but proud of

        17       also your family for the time and effort that

        18       you put and what you had to deal with as an

        19       individual, as he moved through his career, as

        20       he moved through criticism, and as he moved

        21       through growth as a jurist.

        22                  So it is with great pleasure today

        23       that I stand here on the floor of this body in

        24       the Senate of New York and congratulate his

        25       family and also congratulate you on this


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        509



         1       nomination.

         2                  THE PRESIDENT:    The question is

         3       on the nomination of Justice Theodore T.

         4       Jones, Jr., to the New York State Court of

         5       Appeals.  All those in favor please indicate

         6       so by saying aye.

         7                  (Response of "Aye.")

         8                  THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

         9                  (No response.)

        10                  THE PRESIDENT:    The nomination is

        11       confirmed.

        12                  Judge Jones -- joined today by your

        13       wife, Joan; your sons, Theodore, III, and

        14       Wesley -- we congratulate you and wish you the

        15       greatest service to the New York State

        16       constituency serving on our New York State

        17       Court of Appeals.

        18                  You have already distinguished

        19       yourself with your service in the military, as

        20       a lawyer, as a Supreme Court judge, and most

        21       recently on the appellate division.

        22                  On behalf of Senator Joseph Bruno,

        23       the leader of the Senate, all the Senators

        24       have confirmed you unanimously.  We wish you

        25       well.  And congratulations.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        510



         1                  (Standing ovation.)

         2                  THE PRESIDENT:    The chair

         3       recognizes Senator Skelos.

         4                  SENATOR SKELOS:    Mr. President,

         5       there will be an immediate meeting of the

         6       Rules Committee in the Majority Conference

         7       Room.

         8                  THE PRESIDENT:    There will be an

         9       immediate meeting of the Rules Committee in

        10       the Majority Conference Room, Room 332.

        11                  SENATOR SKELOS:    And if we could

        12       return to the order of motions and

        13       resolutions, there's a Resolution 431 at the

        14       desk, by Senator Volker.

        15                  If we could have it read in its

        16       entirety.

        17                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

        18       will read Resolution 431, sponsored by Senator

        19       Volker.

        20                  THE SECRETARY:    By Senator

        21       Volker, Legislative Resolution Number 431,

        22       mourning the death of The Honorable Donald M.

        23       Halperin, distinguished citizen and devoted

        24       member of his community.

        25                  "WHEREAS, It is with great sorrow


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        511



         1       and deep regret that this Legislative Body

         2       records the passing of The Honorable Donald M.

         3       Halperin, noting the significance of his

         4       purposeful life and accomplishments; and

         5                  "WHEREAS, A graduate of Rutgers

         6       University and Brooklyn Law School, Donald M.

         7       Halperin was a partner in the law firm of

         8       Kantor, Davidoff, Wolfe, Mandelker & Kass, PC,

         9       and represented the shoreline communities of

        10       Brooklyn in the New York State Senate for 23

        11       years; and

        12                  "WHEREAS, The youngest person ever

        13       to be elected to the New York State Senate at

        14       the age of 24, Donald M. Halperin had friends

        15       on all sides of the political spectrum, and

        16       his strong work ethic and dedication to the

        17       people of the State of New York earned him the

        18       respect of all of his colleagues; and

        19                  "WHEREAS, The ultimate

        20       consensus-builder, Donald M. Halperin was a

        21       skilled negotiator who had the uncanny ability

        22       to relate to all people, bringing the most

        23       diverse and opposing factions together to

        24       reach a satisfying resolution to thorny issues

        25       and debates; and


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        512



         1                  "WHEREAS, During his 23-year career

         2       in the New York State Senate, Donald M.

         3       Halperin was the author of the law requiring

         4       Braille and audio signals in elevators to

         5       assist the visually impaired, responsible for

         6       recodifying the Juvenile Justice Code, one of

         7       the original authors of the MTA Capital and

         8       Operating Financing package enacted in 1982,

         9       leader in developing legislation to create a

        10       paratransit system which made mass transit

        11       more accessible to the disabled, a pioneer in

        12       developing legislation to revamp the New York

        13       State Reverse Mortgage Law, and a leading

        14       advocate for child welfare and criminal

        15       justice; and

        16                  "WHEREAS, Furthermore, Donald M.

        17       Halperin was named to the dual positions of

        18       Commissioner of the Division of Housing and

        19       Community Renewal and the cabinet-level

        20       position of Housing 'Czar' in 1993, where he

        21       was responsible for coordinating the

        22       operations of the Division of Housing and

        23       Community Renewal, the Roosevelt Island

        24       Operating Authority, the State of New York

        25       Mortgage Agency, the Housing Finance Agency,


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        513



         1       and the Medical Care Facilities Financing

         2       Corporation; and

         3                  "WHEREAS, Donald M. Halperin is

         4       survived by his wife, Brenda; children, Jeremy

         5       and Rebecca; mother, Gladys; sister and

         6       brother-in-law Susan and Alan Gorman; nephew,

         7       Sam; and son-in-law Joshua Burch; and

         8                  "WHEREAS, Armed with a humanistic

         9       spirit, imbued with a sense of compassion, and

        10       comforted by a loving family, Donald M.

        11       Halperin leaves behind a legacy which will

        12       long endure the passage of time and remain as

        13       a comforting memory to all he served and

        14       befriended; now, therefore, be it

        15                  "RESOLVED, That this Legislative

        16       Body pause in its deliberations to mourn the

        17       death of The Honorable Donald M. Halperin,

        18       distinguished citizen and devoted member of

        19       his community; and be it further

        20                  "RESOLVED, That a copy of this

        21       resolution, suitably engrossed, be transmitted

        22       to the family of The Honorable Donald M.

        23       Halperin."

        24                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        25       resolution, Senator Volker.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        514



         1                  SENATOR VOLKER:    Mr. President,

         2       Don Halperin was a close personal friend of

         3       mine for a very long time.

         4                  And as Mr. President knows, he and

         5       myself and the present Minority Leader were

         6       trying to work out this resolution.  By that I

         7       mean we had agreed that we were going to do it

         8       last year, and for various reasons we could

         9       never work it out.

        10                  Today, by the way, Don's wife,

        11       Brenda, and his family decided that it was

        12       just too much for them to come up for this

        13       because they just didn't feel comfortable

        14       doing it.  I had consulted with former Senator

        15       Montalto and Jeremy Weinstein and several

        16       others about doing this, and we frankly

        17       decided that we should go ahead with it today.

        18       There might be another time that Brenda may

        19       come up, and some of the other family.

        20                  You know, Don Halperin was one of

        21       the most interesting characters that I've ever

        22       met up here.  As you can see in the

        23       resolution, he was the youngest person ever to

        24       serve in the Senate at the time.  We became

        25       very close friends.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        515



         1                  And I will tell you a story that is

         2       not well known.  He had a law partner who was

         3       a very, very prominent judge later, who shall

         4       remain nameless, a Democrat.  And through Don,

         5       I became very close to that Democratic judge,

         6       who ended up on the Court of Appeals.

         7                  That judge had all sorts of

         8       wonderful ideas.  And there was a time when I

         9       was invited over to the Court of Appeals to

        10       have lunch with him on a number of occasions.

        11       And the reason was that -- although I suppose

        12       today it would be considered unethical -- he

        13       had a plan that I was to run for Lieutenant

        14       Governor with Sol Wachler, who was seriously

        15       considering running at the time.  And I'm not

        16       supposed to tell any of these stories now, but

        17       I will anyways.  The statute of limitations is

        18       gone, and who cares.

        19                  We actually had quite a plan, and I

        20       would get the conservative endorsement for

        21       Wachler.  Of course the judge I was talking

        22       about would then become, I believe, the chief

        23       judge of the Court of Appeals.  I'm sure that

        24       had nothing to do with this plan.

        25                  But as you know, I think Governor


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        516



         1       Cuomo sensed there was something up and named

         2       Wachler to be head of the Court of Appeals.  I

         3       strongly suspect he was a little concerned

         4       about Wachler running against him.

         5                  But the only reason I mention that

         6       story is I think it gives you an idea of how

         7       close in many ways we were.  We traveled

         8       together quite a bit at night.  He was a super

         9       guy.  Pretty conservative, really, for a

        10       person from downstate and so forth.  And --

        11       but more than that, he had a wonderful heart,

        12       he was a good man.

        13                  The interesting thing about Don

        14       Halperin, he was a physical -- he was a freak

        15       about health.  I mean, anybody that knows him

        16       knows that he always ate well and very careful

        17       and was amazingly -- he didn't smoke; you

        18       know, nothing -- and yet, in the end, he was

        19       riddled with cancer.  And it was what brought

        20       him down eventually.  Cancer started out, I

        21       believe, in his pancreas or whatever, and

        22       ended up in the brain cancer.

        23                  And in the end, it was pretty

        24       tough.  I spoke to him on many occasions down

        25       in the city.  And I know Joe did, who's here,


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        517



         1       Joe Montalto, and Jeremy and a lot of us.  It

         2       was a difficult ending for a wonderful man,

         3       who later not only was in the administration

         4       but also was a very good lobbyist.

         5                  And I just must say -- and I want

         6       to thank Senator Smith for allowing me to in

         7       effect be the introducer of this.  Because I

         8       said to him, normally speaking, with a

         9       minority Senator, it would be the Minority

        10       Leader to do it.  But as he said, "You go

        11       ahead and do it, and I certainly will be part

        12       of it."

        13                  And when this is done, everybody is

        14       invited to be on, obviously.  And I don't

        15       think we bothered to send it around, because

        16       everybody will be on it.

        17                  But at some point we're going to

        18       work out something else to honor Donald.  But

        19       for the time being, I would say this.  There's

        20       going to be, at the Crowne Plaza tonight at

        21       about 7 o'clock, in case anybody -- because

        22       there's a number of people that are here.  I

        23       saw John Dunne and a number of people.  If

        24       you'd like to go down there and just meet.

        25       Initially we thought that Brenda Halperin


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        518



         1       would be there, but as I say, she didn't feel

         2       up to it.

         3                  So I just want to tell you,

         4       personally I think that of the legislators

         5       I've known over the years, Don was one of the

         6       real class acts.  Don, Joe Galiber, so many of

         7       the people who are gone.  And I miss them

         8       dearly.  And these are wonderful people, and

         9       Don certainly was one of them.

        10                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        11       resolution, Senator Stachowski.

        12                  SENATOR STACHOWSKI:    Thank you,

        13       Mr. President.

        14                  I'd also like to rise and say a few

        15       words about my friend Don Halperin.  Don was

        16       ranking on Finance when I got here, and a very

        17       interesting guy.

        18                  Obviously, most things with Donald

        19       centered around eating.  And for a guy that

        20       was in pretty good shape, I never saw anybody

        21       eat that much food.

        22                  And for those of you that saw the

        23       movie "Harry Met Sally," you know how they

        24       were so picky about how they ordered things?

        25       They would be the average person compared to


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        519



         1       Halperin.  He would make the waitress go

         2       through this whole interrogation.  And then if

         3       he wasn't satisfied with the answers, he would

         4       go in the kitchen and start quizzing the chef

         5       on what he used and what he cooked in and what

         6       kind of oil.  But that was Donald, and that's

         7       the way Donald was.

         8                  Donald also got a group of us

         9       together to take karate lessons, another great

        10       episode.  Eight lessons and everybody quit.

        11       And that's a true story.  Everybody quit.

        12       There were athletic people involved, but we

        13       just didn't want to get up that early.

        14                  Donald was also an integral part of

        15       the softball team, because Donald always

        16       organized where we'd go eat after.

        17                  And one of the great nights -- and

        18       for those of who know John Dunne, you know, a

        19       very proper guy, prim and proper.  Donald

        20       Halperin had John Dunne and everybody else at

        21       Chuckie Cheese, playing all the games that the

        22       kids play.  I mean, that's just Donald.

        23       That's typical of the things he would set up.

        24                  And one of the great events ever

        25       staged here was the time that Donald Halperin


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        520



         1       put together now Judge Marty Solomon's

         2       birthday party.  It was at a little Chinese

         3       restaurant on the other side of the river, a

         4       handful of people.  But Marty Solomon, who

         5       didn't drink -- or at least not often --

         6       decided he was going to try a zombie, at

         7       Donald's suggestion.  And he had a couple of

         8       those.

         9                  And in the process, the evening was

        10       unbelievable and topped off by Marty slamming

        11       a wooden cigar box over Donald's head as he

        12       drove home from the restaurant.  So Donald

        13       showed that out of the eight lessons, he got

        14       the lesson of containing oneself under great

        15       duress, not to be bothered by the fact that

        16       this wooden cigar box just smashed over his

        17       head as he tried to drive.

        18                  Donald's food and everything had

        19       such an effect that when Donald stopped taking

        20       his entourage, Cavaleri's closed.  The

        21       restaurant is gone.  They sold it.  But Donald

        22       used to have his big team meal there all the

        23       time.

        24                  And for those of you that aren't

        25       familiar, a lot of the Halperin team is


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        521



         1       sitting up in the balcony.  And he used to get

         2       everybody together once a year, even after he

         3       left, to go out to dinner and share friendship

         4       and laughs.  And the group is still here, and

         5       they're here today too.  And I think that's

         6       important.

         7                  One of the other highlights -- and

         8       I see Tony Masiello's up there also -- is Tony

         9       and I got Donald and Manny Golden and a couple

        10       of others to come to a Jets-Bills Monday night

        11       game in Buffalo.  Which they came in in a

        12       limousine, and everybody thought it was

        13       important people.  It wasn't.  But Donald

        14       really was touched by it.

        15                  And the thing he liked the most was

        16       the people tailgating would knock on the

        17       window, they'd roll the window down and they'd

        18       hand in a sandwich or whatever they were

        19       grilling.  And Donald ate most of those.

        20                  And he also did a thing that was

        21       very unusual and showed that he wasn't a

        22       regular attender at a football game.  He

        23       started drinking these large beers in the

        24       first quarter.  And the rest of the night was

        25       a blur for him, but it was a wonderful evening


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        522



         1       for everybody else, because he was very

         2       entertaining.  Very, very entertaining.

         3                  So with that, I pay my salute to

         4       Don Halperin, thank him for all the memories,

         5       and close with one last story.  Donald told me

         6       this story, because I wasn't here yet.

         7                  It was his first time to debate.

         8       And in those days, when he first got here, it

         9       was very proper in here.  And all the

        10       reporters sat in the front, they didn't stay

        11       up in the second floor listening on a squawk

        12       box.  And everybody was speaking, and he was

        13       one of the youngest guys, so this is like a

        14       long, long debate.  And it was a Senator

        15       Donovan bill, and it was about raising the age

        16       of people, young people, to buy prophylactics.

        17                  And Donald is waiting his time and

        18       waiting his time, and some of the news guys

        19       were starting to doze off.  And Donald finally

        20       got to debate, after about two and a half

        21       hours.  And he got up and he said, "Let me

        22       make this simple and concise.  We let people

        23       buy -- you know, it's okay that they buy beer

        24       at 18" -- they wanted to make this 21 -- "and

        25       we let them buy cigarettes at 18, and we let


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        523



         1       them go to the Army."  He said, "This question

         2       here on the floor isn't whether they have the

         3       guns.  They got the guns.  We're just trying

         4       to get them the holsters."

         5                  (Laughter.)

         6                  SENATOR STACHOWSKI:    Thank you,

         7       Mr. President.

         8                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Klein, on

         9       the resolution.

        10                  SENATOR KLEIN:    Thank you,

        11       Mr. President.

        12                  I want to thank Senator Volker for

        13       bringing this resolution to the floor today.

        14       Everyone who knows Don Halperin I think

        15       quickly realizes his intelligence, his quick

        16       wit.  He's someone who I think we all consider

        17       to be a public man, who dedicated his life to

        18       public service, first as a state senator, then

        19       as commissioner of DHCR.

        20                  And I got to know Donald in his

        21       sort of second life as a lobbyist.  But even

        22       as a lobbyist, whether representing affordable

        23       housing groups or the taxi industry or the dry

        24       cleaning industry, he was always truly an

        25       advocate.  He always had an encyclopedic


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        524



         1       knowledge of all the legislation, all the

         2       issues that represented his clients, I think,

         3       in a very, very good way.

         4                  I think sometimes lobbyists don't

         5       always get the best PR, especially in this day

         6       and age.  But someone like Don Halperin was

         7       very, very passionate about the issues.  He

         8       was always prepared.  He took it upon himself

         9       to know each and every issue affecting his

        10       clients.

        11                  But I think the fondest memories of

        12       Don Halperin is all the political

        13       conversations and talks of government that we

        14       used to have, mostly in Chinese restaurants or

        15       even in Russian nightclubs in Brighton Beach

        16       in his district, or his annual canoe trip,

        17       where I attended on many occasions, as well as

        18       Assemblyman Steve Cymbrowitz, also several

        19       judges.  Judge Solomon, one year, who Don

        20       Halperin used to refer to that trip as "Jews

        21       in canoes."

        22                  (Laughter.)

        23                  SENATOR KLEIN:    But at the same

        24       time, we got an opportunity to talk about his

        25       love of government, his love of this process.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        525



         1                  And it always struck me that as

         2       someone who served all those years in the

         3       minority, how much he got accomplished.  I

         4       think it could be said -- and I know Marty

         5       Connor always talks about this -- there was a

         6       less partisan atmosphere 15 years ago or maybe

         7       even 20 years ago.

         8                  But I think it has more to do with

         9       Don Halperin's very special talents, his sense

        10       of humor and his ability, I think, to convince

        11       everyone.

        12                  I know he's going to be missed.

        13       But I do know he's looking down at us today

        14       with a smile, because he's being memorialized

        15       before the legislative body which I think each

        16       and every day of his life he was proud to

        17       serve in.

        18                  Thank you, Mr. President.

        19                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Onorato.

        20                  SENATOR ONORATO:    Thank you,

        21       Mr. President.

        22                  I too rise to join my colleagues in

        23       paying a special tribute to a very, very dear

        24       friend of mine.  I think Stack hit it on the

        25       head about the wonderful evenings that we had.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        526



         1                  Because one of Donald's favorite

         2       pastimes was going out to dinner.  And when

         3       you had Donald and Senator Solomon, it was

         4       complete night-and-day.  Senator Solomon was a

         5       complete health freak and always completely

         6       telling us:  "Don't eat that, don't eat that,

         7       don't eat that, don't eat that."  And Senator

         8       Halperin says, "Whatever youse don't eat, I'll

         9       eat.  Don't worry about it."

        10                  And he made it a point to sit next

        11       to me.  So did Stack.  Because between the two

        12       of them -- I'm a very small eater, and I never

        13       finish anything that I order.  So it was a

        14       little bit of a battle between Donny and Billy

        15       Stachowski, and occasionally Masiello would

        16       get in on the act too:  "Aren't you going to

        17       finish that, George?  I'll take it."

        18                  But he was a wonderful sportsman.

        19       And Billy mentioned, in fact, that they went

        20       on that canoe trip.  And who do you think that

        21       they had to guide them along the treacherous

        22       rapids?  Our Lieutenant Governor.  Senator

        23       Paterson was the guide to guide them along

        24       those treacherous rapids.  And after they hit

        25       a rock, Senator Paterson would indicate:  "We


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        527



         1       just hit a rock."

         2                  (Laughter.)

         3                  SENATOR ONORATO:    I think the

         4       other thing was, Donny loved to go bowling.

         5       And he had his own equipment all the time with

         6       him.  He had his bowling shoes, his bowling

         7       ball, and we went to the bowling alley.  And

         8       who was there?  Most of us in the

         9       old-timers -- Senator Gold, Senator

        10       Stachowski, Senator Masiello.  Who else was

        11       there?  Joe Montalto.

        12                  And we're down there, and we're

        13       starting to bowl.  And Donny, down there with

        14       his thing, with the perfect form, isn't doing

        15       too well.  And David Paterson was there with

        16       us, and he was bowling.  And he would throw

        17       the ball down, they'd guide him, and he's

        18       starting to beat Donny Halperin.  Now, Donny

        19       is getting frustrated at this.

        20                  So I says:  "Donny, don't get

        21       excited.  I'll take care of this.  I'll guide

        22       him now."  Senator Paterson, he had the 6-8

        23       pins standing.  He says, "What's standing,

        24       George?"  "The 8-10."

        25                  (Laughter.)


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        528



         1                  SENATOR ONORATO:    I did that for

         2       four frames.  And then Senator Paterson says,

         3       "Get Onorato out of there.  I'll do my own

         4       choice.  Don't let him guide me at all."

         5                  But we really enjoyed his sense of

         6       humor.  But he was also such a wonderful man

         7       on the floor here.  Years ago, there was a

         8       great many opportunities of actually passing

         9       legislation, and Donny did pass quite a bit of

        10       legislation, worthwhile legislation.

        11                  And everybody recognized the talent

        12       that he had, and were all so pleased when

        13       Governor Cuomo appointed him to the Housing

        14       Czar.  And he did an outstanding job of that.

        15                  So he is really sorely missed.  And

        16       to his family, I want you to know that I loved

        17       every moment that I shared with him, and I

        18       share those memories with you.

        19                  Thank you, and God bless you.

        20                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        21       resolution, Senator Stavisky.

        22                  SENATOR STAVISKY:    Yes, thank

        23       you, Mr. President.

        24                  I think everyone has noticed the

        25       warmth and affection with which everybody has


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        529



         1       spoken such great regard for Senator

         2       Halperin -- his humor, his what sounds like

         3       food fights over Senator Onorato's plate.

         4                  But let me just mention one other

         5       thing, and that is his role as a lobbyist.  He

         6       was extremely kind to my son.  They would have

         7       lunch together periodically, they referred

         8       clients as my son was first starting out in

         9       the lobbying business.  And it was

        10       appreciated.

        11                  Donald served with my husband in

        12       the Senate.  But the kindness that he showed

        13       to my son was appreciated then, and it will be

        14       appreciated by the Stavisky family for the

        15       years to come.

        16                  Thank you, Mr. President.  And I

        17       wish I had been invited on the canoe trips.

        18                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        19       resolution, Senator Hannon.

        20                  SENATOR HANNON:    Thank you.

        21                  I guess I'm not as good at reciting

        22       all the things why I was always in high

        23       admiration of Don Halperin.  I had worked with

        24       him when I was in the Assembly; I worked with

        25       him when I was chair of the Housing Committee,


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        530



         1       both in his role as Senator and then when he

         2       became Commissioner of DHCR.

         3                  I think what he did is epitomize a

         4       dedicated approach to government, a dedicated

         5       approach to reasoning together on policy.  He

         6       did it also, obviously, with a great sense of

         7       humor, of always finding the irony in any

         8       given situation.

         9                  He told me this story of one of his

        10       big discoveries when he just got to DHCR,

        11       helping to move a desk.  And in the course of

        12       moving the desk, a number of letters from

        13       Senators and Assemblymen fell out of the top

        14       drawer.  Unanswered.  And his was the first

        15       among that stack that fell out.  So he knew

        16       that he had a lot of work to do.

        17                  And I think we collectively

        18       accomplished a great deal when he was there,

        19       even going back to saying what's the whole

        20       theory of the department, what are its goals,

        21       and where is it going.

        22                  He's going to be sorely missed.

        23       The spirit that he drove in regard to public

        24       policy, the spirit that he drove in regard to

        25       bringing some of his clients as lobbyists was


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        531



         1       certainly refreshing, certainly inspiring.

         2       And it is one of the saddest things to have to

         3       speak on this floor of his memory because he

         4       did so much for all of us.

         5                  Thank you, Mr. President.

         6                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

         7       resolution, Senator LaValle.

         8                  SENATOR LaVALLE:    Thank you,

         9       Mr. President.

        10                  It's really a privilege to speak on

        11       this resolution.  Don Halperin was a very good

        12       and decent human being.  He was an exceedingly

        13       bright individual and had skills, social

        14       skills that he utilized to get an awful lot

        15       done.

        16                  I remember many years ago he was

        17       the vice-chair of the commission, with Senator

        18       Joe Pisani, on children and families.  And I

        19       think during that session, when the commission

        20       had made recommendations, he passed and had

        21       signed into law somewhere between six, ten,

        22       twelve bills in which he shared, Senator

        23       Pisani passing another large number of bills.

        24                  He was a member of the Higher

        25       Education Committee and was very interested


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        532



         1       and influential on an issue that is very near

         2       and dear to me, and that's truth-in-testing

         3       law.  And he and I together went down to

         4       Washington to testify on that issue.

         5                  He really was an individual who got

         6       into policy, was successful in what he did,

         7       and did it in a way that was just great.

         8                  Senator Klein, regardless of what

         9       period of time, whether it be the past or the

        10       present, Don Halperin would have navigated the

        11       politics in a great way and would have gotten

        12       results and would not have disturbed, upset

        13       other individuals on the other side in going

        14       about his business, because it was good for

        15       the public.

        16                  So those of us who knew Don

        17       Halperin, really, he leaves a great legacy,

        18       being one of the youngest Senators elected at

        19       that time -- I don't know if anyone else has

        20       beat age 26 coming into this chamber -- but

        21       also an incredible record of accomplishment.

        22                  And I guess the greatest legacy

        23       that we leave is being a good and decent human

        24       being.

        25                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        533



         1       Montgomery.

         2                  SENATOR MONTGOMERY:    Thank you,

         3       Mr. President.

         4                  I rise to express my gratitude to

         5       Senator Dale Volker and my colleagues for

         6       giving us an opportunity to express our --

         7       share our memories with Donald Halperin.

         8                  He was the head of the Brooklyn

         9       delegation when I first came here and took the

        10       time to come and take me out to lunch and talk

        11       and really welcome me into the organization so

        12       to speak, and that was really very special.

        13                  We went to Chinatown, to some

        14       restaurant I'd never heard of, and he

        15       suggested that I order duck.  I'd never had

        16       duck before.  And it turms out he ate half the

        17       duck.  But that was my introduction to Donald

        18       Halperin.

        19                  And he was just impeccably dressed

        20       always, very, very full of life, great sense

        21       of humor, and we had many, many laughs.  My

        22       heartiest laugh was when he told me jokes

        23       about how Marty Markowitz wore bunny suits and

        24       greeted his people in his district in bunny

        25       suits and Santa Claus suits.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        534



         1                  But he really shared a very, very

         2       special sensitivity to people that I

         3       appreciated and was extremely supportive as a

         4       colleague.  And he was a very, very wonderful

         5       human being as well as all of what's been said

         6       about what a wonderful legislator he was.

         7                  I really -- I was at the funeral of

         8       Donald Halperin, and I guess the best part of

         9       that funeral was the fact that, one, it was so

        10       crowded I couldn't even get into the room.

        11       But the other important part was what the

        12       rabbi said about Donald.  I felt so inspired

        13       by that.  Because all of the things that we

        14       have expressed here, the rabbi was able to sum

        15       up.  And it just seems that he touched so many

        16       people in a very special way.

        17                  So I am very, very happy to have

        18       been here with him and to have lived to

        19       experience the wonderfulness of this

        20       absolutely wonderful man.

        21                  Thank you, Mr. President.

        22                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Flanagan.

        23                  SENATOR FLANAGAN:    Thank you,

        24       Mr. President.  Four quick observations.

        25                  I was lucky to have someone who was


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        535



         1       my predecessor in the Assembly who is revered

         2       for his intellect, his wit and his talent, and

         3       that was my father.  And I think I could use

         4       those words to describe Don Halperin as well.

         5       And before anyone says anything, I know those

         6       characteristics skip a generation.

         7                  But the other three things I wanted

         8       to mention is that Don Halperin was very close

         9       to my predecessor here, Jim Lack.  And I

        10       believe I can go out on a limb and speak to

        11       the fact that Jim Lack would want to have

        12       everybody know how dear a friend he considered

        13       him to be, and that his loss is tremendous for

        14       people who no longer even serve here.

        15                  I would also add that, along the

        16       line of what Senator Stavisky said, in terms

        17       of Don's career as a lobbyist, that's really

        18       how I got to know him.

        19                  And this will tell you what a

        20       fabulous lobbyist he was, because he came in

        21       and lobbied about dry cleaning regulations.

        22       And you have to have real talent to make that

        23       sound anywhere near interesting.  And he could

        24       do that, and he did it well.

        25                  And finally, to I think people


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        536



         1       generally, it's very easy to note that someone

         2       is a friend and a colleague and is very good

         3       at what they do.  But I also feel how someone

         4       who is a sitting member treats the staff that

         5       we work with speaks volumes about who they are

         6       as a person.

         7                  And John Conklin, who works with

         8       me, loved Don Halperin.  He considered him an

         9       absolute dear, close, personal friend, and his

        10       life was blessed by knowing him.  And I think

        11       all of us were in the same regard.  And I

        12       would be remiss if, at least on behalf of

        13       someone I enjoy working with now, I don't say

        14       what a terrific man Don Halperin was.

        15                  Thank you.

        16                  THE PRESIDENT:    Does any other

        17       member wish to be heard on this bill?

        18                  The question occurs on the

        19       resolution honoring the memory of our former

        20       colleague Donald Halperin.  Would all those in

        21       favor please indicate so by saying aye.

        22                  (Response of "Aye.")

        23                  THE PRESIDENT:    Those opposed,

        24       nay.

        25                  (No response.)


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        537



         1                  THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

         2       adopted.

         3                  To his wife, Brenda, to his son,

         4       Jeremy, to his daughter, Rebecca, to his

         5       mother, Gladys, to his former colleagues who

         6       came here today -- Senator Montalto, Senator

         7       Masiello, Senator Solomon, and Senator

         8       Dunne -- to his former staff members who are

         9       here today -- Mona DeMay, Patty Tinto, Alton

        10       Landsman, and Stacy Brown -- we all miss

        11       Senator Halperin.

        12                  If you didn't know Senator Halperin

        13       and were just listening today, you would think

        14       he weighed 450 pounds.  But the fact is he was

        15       of average size and outstanding physical

        16       condition.  So no one ever knew what happened

        17       to the food that he ate.

        18                  Remember when your parents told you

        19       eat everything on your plate?  When you went

        20       to dinner with Senator Halperin, you didn't

        21       have to worry.  If you didn't eat it, he would

        22       do it for you.

        23                  The reality is that he had such a

        24       tremendous effect on other people.  He was

        25       often the brightest star in any gathering in


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        538



         1       which he engaged -- that even in this mournful

         2       time, even in this sad time, most of the

         3       Senators who addressed us today thought of

         4       happy times.

         5                  So let me point out to Senator

         6       Onorato that I beat him and Halperin in those

         7       bowling games, even though they used typical

         8       Senate Minority tactics, which I now

         9       disassociate myself from.

        10                  (Laughter.)

        11                  THE PRESIDENT:    And let me talk

        12       about the time Senator Halperin saved either

        13       my life or part of my life, when we were

        14       canoeing down the Delaware River with Senator

        15       Jerry Weinstein, whose canoe capsized.  So I

        16       got out and I helped Senator Weinstein turn it

        17       over and helped him back into his canoe, and I

        18       was sitting on a rock waiting for Senator

        19       Halperin to pick me up.

        20                  I didn't see the canoe coming.  At

        21       the last minute, he screamed.  It was the

        22       scream more than anything else that made me

        23       get up out of the way, and the edge of the

        24       canoe hit the spot that I vacated.

        25                  So I will always thank Senator


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        539



         1       Halperin that I became the proud father that I

         2       am today.

         3                  (Laughter.)

         4                  THE PRESIDENT:    From his service

         5       in 1970 to his accession to ranker on the

         6       Finance Committee in 1981, to his candidacy

         7       for Public Advocate in 1993 -- against an

         8       inferior collection, of which yours truly was

         9       a member -- to his service as Commissioner of

        10       DHCR in 1994 and his outstanding work as a

        11       lobbyist for the remaining 11 years of his

        12       life, we all miss him, we all cherish that we

        13       were around him, and we all will never forget

        14       the times we spent with him.

        15                  The fact that this resolution was

        16       offered by a member of the adversarial party

        17       is a testament to the collective love that

        18       streams through this chamber for Senator

        19       Halperin.  He would have those dinners, as

        20       Senator Flanagan described, with members of

        21       the opposite party, Senator Lack often joining

        22       us, Senator Donovan, and the regular crew from

        23       the Senate Minority.

        24                  Sometimes those days seem so far

        25       away.  But maybe from this moment that we have


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        540



         1       shared remembering Senator Halperin, it will

         2       reignite our understanding that all of us,

         3       even though it's at times adversarial, are

         4       really trying to fulfill our own dreams, which

         5       is his dream.

         6                  They say that the service to others

         7       is the rent we pay for our space on earth.

         8       Senator Halperin looks down on us today paid

         9       in full.  Let us never let him look down and

        10       find any of us in arrears.

        11                  Senator Marcellino.

        12                  SENATOR MARCELLINO:    Mr.

        13       President, if we could use the usual procedure

        14       of the house to put all members on the

        15       resolution unless they would prefer not to be.

        16                  THE PRESIDENT:    This resolution

        17       will be unanimous.  Anyone indicating

        18       otherwise can indicate so at the desk.

        19                  Senator Marcellino.

        20                  SENATOR MARCELLINO:    Yes,

        21       Mr. President.  I believe there's a report of

        22       Rules Committee at the desk.  Can I ask that

        23       it be read at this time.

        24                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

        25       will read the report of the Rules Committee.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        541



         1                  THE SECRETARY:    Senator Bruno,

         2       from the Committee on Rules, reports the

         3       following:

         4                  By Senator Johnson, Concurrent

         5       Resolution Number 459, amending Permanent

         6       Joint Rules of the Senate and Assembly;

         7                  And Senate Print 2131, by the

         8       Senate Committee on Rules, an act to amend the

         9       Tax Law.

        10                  Said bill ordered direct to third

        11       reading.

        12                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator

        13       Marcellino.

        14                  SENATOR MARCELLINO:    May we

        15       accept the Rules Committee report.

        16                  THE PRESIDENT:    All those in

        17       favor.

        18                  (Response of "Aye.")

        19                  THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

        20                  (No response.)

        21                  THE PRESIDENT:    The report is

        22       accepted.

        23                  SENATOR MARCELLINO:    Mr.

        24       President, can we at this time take up

        25       Concurrent Resolution Number 459.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        542



         1                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

         2       will read.

         3                  THE SECRETARY:    The Assembly

         4       sends for concurrence Assembly Concurrent

         5       Resolution Number 147.  Senator Bruno moves to

         6       substitute Senate Concurrent Resolution Number

         7       459 for Assembly Concurrent Resolution Number

         8       147.

         9                  THE PRESIDENT:    Substitution

        10       ordered.

        11                  The Secretary will read.

        12                  THE SECRETARY:    Concurrent

        13       Resolution Number 459, amending the Permanent

        14       Joint Rules of the Senate and Assembly, in

        15       relation to establishing a budget

        16       consideration schedule and joint budget

        17       conference committees.

        18                  THE PRESIDENT:    On the

        19       resolution, all those in favor please indicate

        20       by saying aye.

        21                  (Response of "Aye.")

        22                  THE PRESIDENT:    Opposed, nay.

        23                  (No response.)

        24                  THE PRESIDENT:    The resolution is

        25       adopted.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        543



         1                  Senator Marcellino.

         2                  SENATOR MARCELLINO:    Thank you,

         3       Mr. President.  At this time can we have the

         4       noncontroversial reading of the calendar.

         5                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

         6       will read the calendar.

         7                  THE SECRETARY:    Calendar Number

         8       7, by Senator Padavan, Senate Print 131, an

         9       act to amend the Penal Law, in relation to the

        10       crime of trademark counterfeiting.

        11                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

        12       will please read the last section of the bill.

        13                  THE SECRETARY:    Section 2.  This

        14       act shall take effect on the first of

        15       November.

        16                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

        17       will call the roll.

        18                  (The Secretary called the roll.)

        19                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Secretary

        20       will announce the results.

        21                  THE SECRETARY:    Those recorded in

        22       the negative on Calendar Number 7 are Senators

        23       Montgomery, Parker, Perkins, and Thompson.

        24                  Ayes, 55.  Nays, 4.

        25                  THE PRESIDENT:    The bill is


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        544



         1       passed.

         2                  The Secretary will read.

         3                  THE SECRETARY:    Calendar Number

         4       40, by Senator Maziarz, Senate Print 550, an

         5       act to amend the Judiciary Law, in relation to

         6       appointment.

         7                  THE PRESIDENT:    Read the last

         8       section.

         9                  THE SECRETARY:    Section 2.  This

        10       act shall take effect immediately.

        11                  THE PRESIDENT:    Call the roll.

        12                  (The Secretary called the roll.)

        13                  THE SECRETARY:    Ayes, 59.

        14                  THE PRESIDENT:    The bill is

        15       passed.

        16                  THE SECRETARY:    Calendar Number

        17       42, by Senator DeFrancisco, Senate Print 787,

        18       an act to amend the Surrogate's Court

        19       Procedure Act, in relation to computation.

        20                  THE PRESIDENT:    Last section.

        21                  THE SECRETARY:    Section 2.  This

        22       act shall take effect on the first of January

        23       next succeeding.

        24                  THE PRESIDENT:    Call the roll.

        25                  (The Secretary called the roll.)


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        545



         1                  THE SECRETARY:    Ayes, 59.

         2                  THE PRESIDENT:    The bill is

         3       passed.

         4                  THE SECRETARY:    Calendar Number

         5       53, by Senator Marcellino, Senate Print 616,

         6       an act to amend the Penal Law, in relation to

         7       including.

         8                  THE PRESIDENT:    Last section.

         9                  THE SECRETARY:    Section 3.  This

        10       act shall take effect on the first of

        11       November.

        12                  THE PRESIDENT:    Call the roll.

        13                  (The Secretary called the roll.)

        14                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator

        15       Marcellino, to explain his vote.

        16                  SENATOR MARCELLINO:    Thank you,

        17       Mr. President.

        18                  Since 1999 we have passed this bill

        19       in this house many times unanimously.  And

        20       recently I learned that some concerns have

        21       been raised about the fact that the bill is

        22       limited to dogs and cats.  It raises the

        23       penalty for the theft of these creatures to a

        24       Class E felony, with one to four years

        25       possible service and up to a $5,000 fine.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        546



         1                  One of the reasons we have done

         2       this is because there at least a couple of

         3       million pets a year are stolen and used for

         4       all kinds of evil things.  And because of the

         5       limited liability of the crime and the

         6       inability to actually put a value on these

         7       creatures, police forces have never really

         8       paid much attention to it.

         9                  I've always thought that that was a

        10       bad thing and we want them to do more in

        11       protecting the pets that people hold as part

        12       of their family and priceless.  These

        13       creatures are priceless when they're yours.

        14                  I'd like to expand this bill to as

        15       many creatures as we possibly could, but we

        16       can't even get dogs and cats, the theft of

        17       dogs and cats, through the other house.  I

        18       would like to.

        19                  So I would ask my colleagues on the

        20       other side who would like to see this bill

        21       expanded, as I would, to go to the other house

        22       and get the bill expanded so that it can come

        23       to the floor even as it is now.  Assemblywoman

        24       Glick has been carrying the bill.  She can't

        25       get it out for a vote.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        547



         1                  This bill is a no-brainer, quite

         2       frankly, Mr. President.  And I urge everyone

         3       to support it and seek help from the other

         4       house, as I intend to, to get this bill passed

         5       in the other house so it finally become law.

         6       And we can expand it and amend it once it's

         7       passed into law.

         8                  Thank you.  I vote aye.

         9                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator

        10       Marcellino will be recorded in the affirmative

        11       on Calendar Number 53, Senate 616.

        12                  Senator Hassell-Thompson, to

        13       explain --

        14                  SENATOR HASSELL-THOMPSON:

        15       Senator Thompson.  Without the "Hassell."

        16                  THE PRESIDENT:    Without the

        17       "Hassell," Senator Thompson, to explain his

        18       vote.

        19                  SENATOR THOMPSON:    Yeah,

        20       initially I wasn't going to support this bill.

        21       But I think, after thinking about some of the

        22       issues from being on the Buffalo City Council,

        23       in terms of dogs being stolen and used for dog

        24       fighting, which is a very big problem -- and I

        25       know that on the City Council in Buffalo we've


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        548



         1       dealt with that a lot as well.

         2                  So I don't know where the bill will

         3       go, but I'm glad to support it, and anything I

         4       can do to support this effort.

         5                  Thanks.

         6                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Thompson

         7       will be recorded in the affirmative on

         8       Calendar Number 53.

         9                  To explain her vote, Senator

        10       Montgomery.

        11                  SENATOR MONTGOMERY:    Yes,

        12       Mr. President, thank you.  To explain my vote,

        13       which I wasn't going to do.

        14                  But just so that I think we're not

        15       confused, this law does not specifically cover

        16       those situations that Senator Thompson pointed

        17       out.  In fact, it's just generally if a pet is

        18       stolen.

        19                  Now, obviously we don't want to see

        20       pets stolen.  But I think that we all

        21       understand too that pets have varying degrees

        22       of pedigree, and some of them are just common

        23       ordinary street cats and whatnot; they come

        24       in, and they become pets.  And if a child

        25       takes it or a youngster takes a cat -- maybe


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        549



         1       the cat has a collar, maybe it doesn't; maybe

         2       the dog has a dollar, maybe it doesn't -- but

         3       grand larceny is pretty serious.

         4                  And I think that we need to be much

         5       more careful about tagging every single action

         6       as a felony, because sometimes this catches

         7       people who really are not looking to do

         8       something dreadfully harmful, but maybe they

         9       want to take -- they would like a pet, they

        10       don't have one and they see a pet that looks

        11       stray and they take it in and, bang, they've

        12       committed grand larceny and they have an

        13       E felony charge.

        14                  So I think we should be more

        15       careful.  If we are talking about specific

        16       criminality associated with taking a pet, we

        17       should say that in the statute so that it's

        18       very clear that we are not talking about

        19       someone who mistakenly takes an animal into

        20       their home thinking that that's a stray animal

        21       and that person is committing a crime and gets

        22       labeled for the rest of their lives and cannot

        23       get a job for the rest of their lives.

        24                  So I'm specifically voting no on

        25       this for that reason.


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        550



         1                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator

         2       Montgomery will be recorded in the negative on

         3       Calendar Number 53.

         4                  The Secretary will announce the

         5       results.

         6                  THE SECRETARY:    Those recorded in

         7       the negative on Calendar Number 53 are

         8       Senators Hassell-Thompson, Montgomery, Parker,

         9       and Perkins.

        10                  Ayes, 55.  Nays, 4.

        11                  THE PRESIDENT:    The bill is

        12       passed.

        13                  THE SECRETARY:    Calendar Number

        14       61, by Senator Winner, Senate Print 897, an

        15       act to amend the Penal Law, in relation to the

        16       discharge of a gun or firearm.

        17                  THE PRESIDENT:    Last section.

        18                  THE SECRETARY:    Section 2.  This

        19       act shall take effect on the first of

        20       November.

        21                  THE PRESIDENT:    Call the roll.

        22                  (The Secretary called the roll.)

        23                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator

        24       Schneiderman, to explain his vote.

        25                  SENATOR SCHNEIDERMAN:    Yes, thank


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        551



         1       you, Mr. President.

         2                  I just wanted to say that this is a

         3       very moderate but commonsense piece of

         4       legislation relating to the problems of gun

         5       violence and injury related to firearms.

         6                  I appreciate the fact that Senator

         7       Winner has sponsored it.  He's in a district

         8       that many people would think makes it

         9       difficult to do anything that challenges the

        10       hegemony of those who would not have us pass

        11       any legislation related to firearms.  And I'm

        12       hoping that maybe it is an indication that

        13       this year we can move forward on the backlog

        14       of items that relate to gun safety.

        15                  This bill simply requires that if

        16       you discharge a firearm and injure or kill

        17       someone, you're required to report it.  There

        18       are a variety of pieces of legislation like

        19       this that would make New York a safer state

        20       for all of the people of the state, for all of

        21       our children.  And I hope that this is a good

        22       sign that maybe we can move forward with that

        23       agenda.

        24                  I vote yes.  Thank you.

        25                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        552



         1       Schneiderman will be recorded in the

         2       affirmative.

         3                  Results.

         4                  THE SECRETARY:    Ayes, 59.

         5                  THE PRESIDENT:    The bill is

         6       passed.

         7                  THE SECRETARY:    Calendar Number

         8       89, by Senator Maziarz, Senate Print 1694, an

         9       act to amend the Labor Law, in relation to

        10       contracts.

        11                  THE PRESIDENT:    Last section.

        12                  THE SECRETARY:    Section 6.  This

        13       act shall take effect immediately.

        14                  THE PRESIDENT:    Call the roll.

        15                  (The Secretary called the roll.)

        16                  THE SECRETARY:    Ayes, 59.

        17                  THE PRESIDENT:    The bill is

        18       passed.

        19                  THE SECRETARY:    Calendar Number

        20       95, by Senator Saland, Senate Print 1147, an

        21       act to amend Chapter 698 of the Laws of 1996

        22       amending the Education Law.

        23                  THE PRESIDENT:    Read the last

        24       section.

        25                  THE SECRETARY:    Section 2.  This


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        553



         1       act shall take effect immediately.

         2                  THE PRESIDENT:    Call the roll.

         3                  (The Secretary called the roll.)

         4                  THE PRESIDENT:    Results.

         5                  THE SECRETARY:    Ayes, 59.

         6                  THE PRESIDENT:    The bill is

         7       passed.

         8                  That completes the noncontroversial

         9       calendar, Senator Marcellino.

        10                  SENATOR MARCELLINO:    Mr.

        11       President, is there any further business at

        12       the desk?

        13                  THE PRESIDENT:    We have a motion

        14       by Senator Farley.

        15                  SENATOR MARCELLINO:    Can we

        16       recognize Senator Farley.

        17                  THE PRESIDENT:    Senator Farley.

        18                  SENATOR FARLEY:    Thank you,

        19       Mr. President.

        20                  On behalf of Senator Maziarz, on

        21       page 8 I offer the following amendments to

        22       Calendar Number 39, Senate Print 521, and I

        23       ask that this bill retain its place on the

        24       Third Reading Calendar.

        25                  THE PRESIDENT:    The amendments


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910

                                                        554



         1       are received, and the bill will retain its

         2       place on the Third Reading Calendar.

         3                  Senator Marcellino.

         4                  SENATOR MARCELLINO:    Thank you,

         5       Mr. President.

         6                  I move that we adjourn until

         7       Tuesday, February 13th, at 3:00 p.m.

         8                  THE PRESIDENT:    The Senate stands

         9       adjourned until Tuesday, February 13th, at

        10       3:00 p.m.

        11                  (Whereupon, at 4:55 p.m., the

        12       Senate adjourned.)

        13

        14

        15

        16

        17

        18

        19

        20

        21

        22

        23

        24

        25


                      Candyco Transcription Service, Inc.
                                (518) 371-8910