Regular Session - April 25, 2012

                                                                   2234

 1               NEW YORK STATE SENATE

 2                          

 3                          

 4              THE STENOGRAPHIC RECORD

 5                          

 6                          

 7                          

 8                          

 9                  ALBANY, NEW YORK

10                   April 25, 2012

11                     3:12 p.m.

12                          

13                          

14                  REGULAR SESSION

15  

16  

17  

18  SENATOR ELIZABETH O'C. LITTLE, Acting President

19  FRANCIS W. PATIENCE, Secretary

20  

21  

22  

23  

24  

25  

                                                               2235

 1              P R O C E E D I N G S

 2               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The 

 3  Senate will come to order.  

 4               I ask everyone present to please 

 5  rise and repeat with me the Pledge of 

 6  Allegiance.

 7               (Whereupon, the assemblage 

 8  recited the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.)

 9               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

10  you.

11               We are being joined today for a 

12  prayer by the Reverend Peter G. Young, of 

13  Mother Teresa Community, who you may have seen 

14  on the Rachael Ray Show recently, as well as 

15  on Channel 13, where they recognized all of 

16  his accomplishments and what he has done for 

17  the jobless and people in New York State.

18               Father Young.

19               REVEREND YOUNG:   Thank you, 

20  Senator.

21               Let us pray.

22               We're worried tonight because 

23  we've been told that a freezing temperature 

24  will threaten our plants.  But we're reminded 

25  that You, O God, provide for our future.  We 

                                                               2236

 1  depend on Your help in all things.  

 2               Our Senators gather today as 

 3  servants for our New York State citizens to 

 4  provide them with a quality of life that gives 

 5  them respect and happiness.  We ask You, 

 6  O God, to bless them in their legislative 

 7  agenda and duties.  

 8               We also take great pride in our 

 9  St. Rose champions, the national soccer 

10  champion, and congratulate them and bless them 

11  in their good work.  

12               Amen.

13               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The 

14  reading of the Journal.

15               THE SECRETARY:   In Senate, 

16  Tuesday, April 24th, the Senate met pursuant 

17  to adjournment.  The Journal of Monday, 

18  April 23rd, was read and approved.  On motion, 

19  Senate adjourned.

20               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:    

21  Without objection, the Journal stands approved 

22  as read.  

23               Presentation of petitions.

24               Messages from the Assembly.

25               The Secretary will read.

                                                               2237

 1               THE SECRETARY:   On page 12, 

 2  Senator Martins moves to discharge, from the 

 3  Committee on Local Government, Assembly Bill 

 4  Number 9012 and substitute it for the identical 

 5  Senate Bill Number 6222, Third Reading Calendar 

 6  94.  

 7               And on page 15, Senator Gallivan 

 8  moves to discharge, from the Committee on Health, 

 9  Assembly Bill Number 8414A and substitute it for 

10  the identical Senate Bill Number 6069A, Third 

11  Reading Calendar 238.

12               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The 

13  substitutions are so ordered.

14               Messages from the Governor.

15               Reports of standing committees.

16               Reports of select committees.

17               Communications and reports from 

18  state officers.

19               Motions and resolutions.

20               Senator Libous.

21               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Thank you, 

22  Mr. President -- Madam President, excuse me. 

23               And, Madam President, could members 

24  maybe take their seats.  There's a lot of 

25  commotion in the chamber this afternoon.

                                                               2238

 1               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

 2  you.  Could we have some order in the chamber and 

 3  less conversation.

 4               Senator Libous.  

 5               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Thank you, 

 6  Madam President.

 7               I have a number of procedural 

 8  motions today.  

 9               On behalf of Senator Bonacic, I 

10  wish to call up his bill, Print 6113, recalled 

11  from the Assembly, which is now at the desk.

12               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

13  you.  The Secretary will read.

14               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

15  92, by Senator Bonacic, Senate Print 6113, an act 

16  to legalize, validate, and ratify.

17               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

18  I now move to reconsider the vote by which this 

19  bill was passed.

20               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Call the 

21  roll on reconsideration.

22               (The Secretary called the roll.)

23               THE SECRETARY:   Ayes, 50.

24               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

25  I now offer up the following amendments.

                                                               2239

 1               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The 

 2  amendments are received.

 3               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Thank you.  

 4               On behalf of Senator Marcellino, 

 5  Madam President, on page 17 I offer the following 

 6  amendments to Calendar Number 277, Senate Print 

 7  6481, and ask that said bill please retain its 

 8  place on the Third Reading Calendar.

 9               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The 

10  amendments are received, and the bill will retain 

11  its place on the Third Reading Calendar.

12               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Thank you, Madam 

13  President.  

14               On behalf of Senator Fuschillo, on 

15  page 18 I offer the following amendments to 

16  Calendar Number 310, Senate Print 5012B, and ask 

17  that said bill retain its place on the Third 

18  Reading Calendar.

19               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The 

20  amendments are received, and the bill will retain 

21  its place on the Third Reading Calendar.

22               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

23  on page 24, on behalf of Senator Robach, I offer 

24  the following amendments to Calendar Number 439, 

25  Senate Print 4560, and ask that said bill retain 

                                                               2240

 1  its place on the Third Reading Calendar.

 2               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The 

 3  amendments are received, and the bill will retain 

 4  its place on the Third Reading Calendar.

 5               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

 6  on behalf of Senator DeFrancisco, I move that the 

 7  following bill be discharged from its respective 

 8  committee and be recommitted with instructions to 

 9  please strike the enacting clause.  That's Senate 

10  Print 5732A.

11               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   So 

12  ordered.

13               Senator Libous.

14               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Thank you, Madam 

15  President.

16               Madam President, we have a special 

17  guest with us in the chamber.  My colleagues, 

18  today we have Shanika Bridges.  And Shanika, 

19  please stand.  

20               Shanika is here today as one of my 

21  constituents.  And she is from Newark Valley.  

22  And Shanika is also the Miss Teenager of 

23  New York.  

24               And she has a pretty remarkable 

25  background, Madam President.  And we can 

                                                               2241

 1  understand why she took on 21 other teenagers 

 2  from across the state and came out number one.  

 3               She is a student of Ithaca College 

 4  and is studying premed.  She's a devoted 

 5  community member.  She volunteers by singing at 

 6  the church and is a group leader at vacation 

 7  bible school.  She serves as an interpreter, was 

 8  an assistant coach for peewee cheerleading at 

 9  Newark Valley.  She won the Miss Teen Tioga in 

10  2011, and it inspired her to go on to the state 

11  level and be successful to be the Miss Teenager 

12  of New York.  

13               She has tremendous talent.  Not 

14  only was her educational speech at the pageant 

15  about Type I diabetes, but she has inspired many 

16  through her talents.

17               She also sang a song, "You and I," 

18  by Lady Gaga.  And those who know me, Shanika, 

19  know that I had a Lady Gaga ring tone on my phone 

20  for a number of years.  So I certainly appreciate 

21  that.

22               She is here today with her mother, 

23  Judy, and her father, Jeff.  Let's give her a big 

24  round of applause.

25               (Applause.)

                                                               2242

 1               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

 2  you for joining us today.

 3               Senator Libous.

 4               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

 5  there's a resolution at the desk by Senator 

 6  Breslin, Number 3235.  It was previously adopted 

 7  by the house on February 15th.  May we have the 

 8  title read and call on Senator Breslin, who is 

 9  standing before us.

10               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

11  you.

12               The Secretary will read the title 

13  of the resolution.

14               THE SECRETARY:   Legislative 

15  Resolution Number 3235, by Senator Breslin, 

16  congratulating the 2011 College of St. Rose 

17  Women's Soccer Team upon the occasion of 

18  capturing of the NCAA Division II National 

19  Championship.

20               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Senator 

21  Breslin.

22               SENATOR BRESLIN:   Thank you, 

23  Madam President.  

24               The Capital District is well known 

25  for athletic teams, but never before has the 

                                                               2243

 1  Capital District had a national champion.  And 

 2  this past December, specifically on December 3rd, 

 3  the College of St. Rose won the Division II 

 4  Women's National Soccer Championship.

 5               It's extra special because the last 

 6  three seasons they had lost in the semifinals.  

 7  So this is a long record of accomplishment.  And 

 8  this year they won 24 games, after a standard 

 9  that had never been achieved before of 23 in both 

10  2009 and 2010.

11               In the final game on December 3rd, 

12  they were behind 1-0 through the first half.  And 

13  their goalie, who's here with us today, Jessica 

14  Gerski, who will be back, held off the opposition 

15  in the final, allowing St. Rose to become 

16  national champions.

17               And in the galleries with us today 

18  are Laurie Darling Gutheil, the coach; President 

19  Mark Sullivan, the distinguished president of 

20  St. Rose; Assistant Coaches Amanda Deck, Kalley 

21  Egbert, Jason Gutheil, Jim Lennox, Renae 

22  Ransdell, Lauren Steinberg and Mark Van Leuven; 

23  Head Trainer Karen Cravens and Assistant Trainers 

24  Jessup Pierce and Lisa Geiger.  And the team 

25  members here with us today are Lauren Minkoff, 

                                                               2244

 1  Melody Lawrence, Jessica, who I mentioned, the 

 2  goalkeeper, Marisah Case, Jourdan Thompson, Niki 

 3  Smith, La'Quilla Upton, and Lana Vecchiarelli.  

 4               They are just accomplished.  And 

 5  for the 11th straight year, they were recognized 

 6  nationally as Academic All-Americans.  

 7               So let's give a round of applause 

 8  to the national champions in Women's Soccer 

 9  Division II.

10               (Applause.)

11               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

12  you, Senator Breslin.

13               It's my personal honor to be 

14  presiding today, since I'm a graduate of the 

15  College of St. Rose, and to welcome President 

16  Mark Sullivan, the coaches, and these wonderfully 

17  talented women, academically and athletically, on 

18  a really impressive and major achievement.  

19               So congratulations, and we wish you 

20  well.  Thank you for joining us today.  

21               ("Thank you" from the gallery.)

22               (Laughter.)

23               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Senator 

24  Skelos.

25               SENATOR SKELOS:   Madam President, 

                                                               2245

 1  there will be an immediate meeting of the Finance 

 2  Committee in Room 332, followed by a meeting of 

 3  the Rules Committee.

 4               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

 5  you.  There's an immediate meeting of the Finance 

 6  Committee in Room 332, followed by a meeting of 

 7  the Rules Committee.  

 8               The Senate stands at ease.

 9               (Whereupon, the Senate stood at ease 

10  at 3:22 p.m.)

11               (Whereupon, the Senate reconvened at 

12  4:29 p.m.)

13               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Senator 

14  Libous.

15               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

16  I believe there's a report of the Rules Committee 

17  at the desk.  If we could have it read at this 

18  time.

19               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   There is 

20  a report of the Rules Committee.  

21               The Secretary will read.

22               THE SECRETARY:   Senator Skelos, 

23  from the Committee on Rules, reports the 

24  following bills direct to third reading:  

25               Senate Print 6182, by Senator 

                                                               2246

 1  Klein, an act to amend the Education Law; and 

 2               Senate Print 6694A, by Senator 

 3  Flanagan, an act to amend the Public Health Law.  

 4               Both bills reported directly to 

 5  third reading.

 6               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:  Senator 

 7  Libous.  

 8               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

 9  I move to accept the report of the Rules 

10  Committee.

11               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   All in 

12  favor of accepting the Rules Committee report 

13  please signify by saying aye.

14               (Response of "Aye.")

15               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Those 

16  opposed, nay.

17               (No response.)

18               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The 

19  Rules report is accepted.

20               Senator Libous.

21               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

22  before we go on to the noncontroversial reading 

23  of the calendar, I believe that you could call, 

24  please, at this time on Senator Adams for the 

25  purposes of an announcement.

                                                               2247

 1               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

 2  you.  First the Secretary will read the title of 

 3  the resolution.  

 4               THE SECRETARY:   Legislative 

 5  Resolution Number 3512, by Senator Parker, 

 6  honoring Ralph McDaniels upon the occasion of his 

 7  designation for special recognition by the Museum 

 8  of Contemporary African Diasporan Arts.

 9               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Senator 

10  Adams.

11               SENATOR ADAMS:   Thank you.  Thank 

12  you, Madam President.  

13               We often recognize pioneers on this 

14  floor, and I am just really just honored today to 

15  recognize Ralph McDaniels.  

16               You know, many of you won't know 

17  him -- but trust me, your children do.  Ralph 

18  McDaniels is a true visionary.  You know, 

19  everyone has eyes, but visionaries can see a 

20  vision far before many of us.  He was the creator 

21  of "Video Music Box."  

22               And when you look at what he did 

23  over 30 years ago, and the creation of allowing 

24  young people a venue where they can play music, 

25  they can hear music, it was an urban tone -- and 

                                                               2248

 1  it really cascaded throughout the entire country.

 2               He was an entrepreneur and 

 3  visionary who created the show, the first music 

 4  show focused exclusively to an urban market 

 5  broadcast on public television.  He grew up in 

 6  Brooklyn and Queens.  Ralph aspired to be a DJ.  

 7  He attended New York Institute of Technology, 

 8  where he studied communication, TV, film, and he 

 9  graduated in 1982.  

10               It was at this time that he started 

11  noticing an alarming array of talented hip-hop 

12  artists continuously being rejected and 

13  suppressed by mainstream media.  And he wanted to 

14  give those overlooked artists a platform where 

15  they could be acknowledged by the consumers who 

16  craved them.  

17               It was not long before "Video Music 

18  Box's" six-day, 60-minute public television 

19  viewership began to grow far beyond what any of 

20  the cable networks had expected.  By 1995, 

21  Billboard Magazine recognized the show and 

22  awarded "Video Music Box" as the Best Local 

23  R&B/Hip-hop Regional Show.  

24               And he did so much more.  And, you 

25  know, we were actually high school colleagues, we 

                                                               2249

 1  went to high school together.  And I just watched 

 2  throughout the years, I used to just watch him as 

 3  he hid, between the music, he put a message.  He 

 4  talked about antiviolence, he talked about 

 5  domestic violence, he talked about the things 

 6  that children need to do.  So between them 

 7  popping their fingers, he was planting something 

 8  in their minds.  

 9               And he was just a giant among the 

10  urban communities.  And now he's known far beyond 

11  the urban communities.  Many of the local areas 

12  that you represent, if you were to go home and 

13  ask your son, your daughter, about Ralph 

14  McDaniels, they would tell you he's a person that 

15  planted the seed of opportunities into so many 

16  young people that wanted to participate in music 

17  and what we can do with music.  

18               And so we just really want to thank 

19  him.  And I'm pretty sure those who are back in 

20  my district, Senator Parker's district, and those 

21  of us who are from Brooklyn, he's one of 

22  Brooklyn's own.  We thank him for what he has 

23  done throughout the years.  And we believe that 

24  he's going to continue to involve and do some 

25  great things around music.  

                                                               2250

 1               We need men like Ralph McDaniels 

 2  more than ever now, because a countless number of 

 3  children who are latchkey kids are going home to 

 4  nothing of inspiration and they're receiving just 

 5  junk food for the mind.  

 6               Ralph McDaniels has learned how to 

 7  take that junk food that one would perceive it to 

 8  be and implant something nourishing by telling 

 9  young people that they could do some great things 

10  with a level of academics, a level of commitment, 

11  and a level of desire and compassion.  And that's 

12  what Ralph McDaniels is known for.  

13               And so I want to thank him and, 

14  with Senator Parker, who's not here, honor him 

15  with this resolution.  And I thank you, 

16  Madam President, for allowing me the opportunity 

17  to do so.  

18               DJ Ralph McDaniels, thank you.

19               (Extended applause.)

20               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

21  you.

22               Senator Serrano.

23               SENATOR SERRANO:   I don't have 

24  much to add to what Senator Adams said, but I 

25  just wanted to mention that -- to thank 

                                                               2251

 1  Mr. McDaniels as growing up -- I was in high 

 2  school in the late 1980s, and the first thing I 

 3  would do when I got home was to turn on "Video 

 4  Music Box."  And it was on a UHF channel, so we 

 5  had to fiddle with the antenna to get it to come 

 6  in just right.  

 7               But it was really a pioneering show 

 8  because it was the entire spectrum of music.  It 

 9  was definitely urban music, but he mixed it up.  

10  And he put dance music and he put things that we 

11  had never heard of before.  So those of us, a kid 

12  like myself growing up in the Bronx, we were 

13  exposed to music from everywhere, artists I had 

14  never heard of before.  

15               And it was really enlightening, and 

16  it was a lot of fun, and it was good music.  And 

17  I think a lot of music shows today could learn a 

18  lot from the format, the very simple format and 

19  the interviews that he did with artists.  It was 

20  really amazing, and it was a wonderful show.  

21               Congratulations.

22               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

23  you, Senator Serrano.

24               Senator Smith on the resolution.

25               SENATOR SMITH:   Yes, thank you 

                                                               2252

 1  very much, Madam President.  

 2               And let me thank Senator Parker and 

 3  also Senator Adams for bringing this resolution 

 4  forward.

 5               As I was growing up, Brother 

 6  McDaniels, most people thought that I didn't know 

 7  how to dance.  But it was your music that moved 

 8  me through some moments.  As a matter of fact, my 

 9  wife of 26 years is as a result of your music one 

10  day.  But that's another subject.

11               But I will tell you that many of 

12  us, as Senator Adams indicated, that would not 

13  know of Ralph McDaniels, but many of us do.  We 

14  grew up to your music.  We grew up to your 

15  message.  We grew up to all that you told so many 

16  of us.  

17               And not just in the music by virtue 

18  of how great the rhythm was, but the message you 

19  had about being successful and who we should be.  

20  Which is why many of us on this side of the aisle 

21  grew up to your music, and we probably can 

22  attribute most of our success to you.

23               And so it's actually very much of 

24  an honor to be able to stand on this floor.  And 

25  I'm so happy to see you personally.  I've heard 

                                                               2253

 1  so much of you and so much about you and grew up 

 2  on your music.  And as we called it, "the Box," 

 3  it did so much for many of us.

 4               So to my colleagues that are here, 

 5  you are in the presence of a giant.  You are in 

 6  the presence of a treasure.  So I would only ask 

 7  that, not to disturb the floor that much, but you 

 8  should run over and get your picture.  It may 

 9  have value to you in this coming season that we 

10  may be in.

11               (Laughter.)

12               SENATOR SMITH:   So congratulations 

13  to you.  

14               And, Senator Adams, thanks so much 

15  for bringing this forward.

16               Thank you, Madam President.

17               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

18  you, Senator Smith.

19               This resolution was previously 

20  adopted by the Senate on March 13th.  

21               And I thank Mr. McDaniels for 

22  joining us today and would like to really 

23  congratulate him on this very special recognition 

24  for his wonderful music.  Thank you.

25               Senator Libous.

                                                               2254

 1               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

 2  if we could go back to motions, I have a motion 

 3  before me on behalf of Senator DeFrancisco.

 4               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Motions 

 5  and resolutions.

 6               Senator Libous.  

 7               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Thank you, 

 8  Madam President.

 9               On behalf of Senator DeFrancisco, 

10  on page 24 I offer the following amendments to 

11  Calendar Number 451, Senate Print 6642, and ask 

12  that said bill retain its place on the Third 

13  Reading Calendar.

14               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

15  you.  The amendments are received, and the bill 

16  will retain its place on the Third Reading 

17  Calendar.

18               Senator Libous.

19               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

20  at this time could we have the noncontroversial 

21  reading of the calendar, please.

22               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

23  you.  The Secretary will read.

24               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

25  89, by Senator McDonald, Senate Print 4525C, an 

                                                               2255

 1  act to amend the Mental Hygiene Law.

 2               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Read the 

 3  last section.

 4               THE SECRETARY:   Section 12.  This 

 5  act shall take effect immediately.

 6               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Call the 

 7  roll.

 8               (The Secretary called the roll.)

 9               THE SECRETARY:   Ayes, 57.

10               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The bill 

11  is passed.

12               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

13  94, substituted earlier by Member of the Assembly 

14  Weisenberg, Assembly Print Number 9012, an act to 

15  amend the Real Property Tax Law.

16               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Read the 

17  last section.

18               THE SECRETARY:   Section 2.  This 

19  act shall take effect immediately.

20               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Call the 

21  roll.

22               (The Secretary called the roll.)

23               THE SECRETARY:   Ayes, 57.

24               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The bill 

25  is passed.

                                                               2256

 1               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

 2  220, by Senator Seward, Senate Print 6078B, an 

 3  act to authorize the Town of Frankfort.

 4               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   There is 

 5  a home-rule message at the desk.

 6               Read the last section.

 7               THE SECRETARY:   Section 5.  This 

 8  act shall take effect immediately.

 9               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Call the 

10  roll.

11               (The Secretary called the roll.)

12               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Announce 

13  the results.

14               THE SECRETARY:   Ayes, 56.  Nays, 

15  1.  Senator Duane recorded in the negative.

16               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The bill 

17  is passed.

18               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

19  238, substituted earlier by Member of the 

20  Assembly Paulin, Assembly Print 8414A, an act to 

21  amend the Public Health Law.

22               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Lay it aside for 

23  the day, please.

24               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The bill 

25  is laid aside for the day.

                                                               2257

 1               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

 2  349, by Senator Robach, Senate Print 4407, an act 

 3  to amend the Vehicle and Traffic Law.

 4               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Read the 

 5  last section.

 6               THE SECRETARY:   Section 2.  This 

 7  act shall take effect on the 180th day.

 8               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Call the 

 9  roll.

10               (The Secretary called the roll.)

11               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Announce 

12  the results.

13               THE SECRETARY:   Ayes, 57.

14               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The bill 

15  is passed.

16               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

17  354, by Senator Huntley, Senate Print 3078, an 

18  act to amend the Mental Hygiene Law.

19               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Read the 

20  last section.

21               THE SECRETARY:   Section 5.  This 

22  act shall take effect immediately.

23               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Call the 

24  roll.

25               (The Secretary called the roll.)

                                                               2258

 1               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Announce 

 2  the results.

 3               THE SECRETARY:   Ayes, 57.

 4               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The bill 

 5  is passed.

 6               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

 7  388, by Senator DeFrancisco, Senate Print 6395B, 

 8  an act to amend the Education Law.

 9               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Read the 

10  last section.

11               THE SECRETARY:   Section 2.  This 

12  act shall take effect immediately.

13               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Call the 

14  roll.

15               (The Secretary called the roll.)

16               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Announce 

17  the results.

18               THE SECRETARY:   Ayes, 57.

19               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The bill 

20  is passed.

21               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

22  391, by Senator Hannon, Senate Print 1922, an act 

23  to amend the Family Court Act.

24               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Read the 

25  last section.

                                                               2259

 1               THE SECRETARY:   Section 3.  This 

 2  act shall take effect on the first of January.

 3               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Call the 

 4  roll.

 5               (The Secretary called the roll.)

 6               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Announce 

 7  the results.

 8               THE SECRETARY:   Ayes, 57.

 9               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The bill 

10  is passed.

11               THE SECRETARY:   Calendar Number 

12  454, by Senator Ritchie, Senate Print 5159, an 

13  act to amend the Agriculture and Markets Law.

14               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Lay it aside for 

15  the day, please.

16               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   The bill 

17  is laid aside for the day.

18               Senator Libous, that completes the 

19  reading of the noncontroversial calendar.

20               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Thank you, 

21  Madam President.  

22               Is there any further business at 

23  the desk?  

24               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   No, 

25  there is no further business at the desk.

                                                               2260

 1               SENATOR LIBOUS:   Madam President, 

 2  there being no further business, I move that the 

 3  Senate adjourn until Thursday, April 26th, at 

 4  11:00 a.m.

 5               ACTING PRESIDENT LITTLE:   Thank 

 6  you.  On motion, the Senate stands adjourned 

 7  until Thursday, April 26th, at 11:00 a.m.

 8               (Whereupon, at 4:41 p.m., the Senate 

 9  adjourned.)

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25