|Assembly Actions - Lowercase
Senate Actions - UPPERCASE
|Jan 04, 2012||
referred to cultural affairs, tourism, parks and recreation
|Jan 14, 2011||
referred to cultural affairs, tourism, parks and recreation
senate Bill S1908
Relates to oil and gas drilling in Allegany state park
Archive: Last Bill Status - In Committee
- In Committee
- On Floor Calendar
- Passed Senate
- Passed Assembly
- Delivered to Governor
- Signed/Vetoed by Governor
view actions (2)
S1908 - Bill Details
- Current Committee:
- Senate Cultural Affairs, Tourism, Parks And Recreation
- Law Section:
- Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation Law
- Laws Affected:
- Add §13.31, Pks & Rec L
- Versions Introduced in 2009-2010 Legislative Session:
S1908 - Bill Texts
Relates to oil and gas drilling in Allegany State Park.
view sponsor memo
TITLE OF BILL:
to amend the parks, recreation and historic preservation law,
in relation to oil
and gas drilling in Allegany state park
PURPOSE OR GENERAL IDEA OF BILL:
To specify the terms, requirements and enforcement of surface
access permits to entities proposing to
extract privately-owned oil or gas resources within Allegany
SUMMARY OF SPECIFIC PROVISIONS:
The bill adds a new section 13.31 to
the Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation Law to regulate oil
and gas drilling in Allegany state Park.
Subdivision one sets forth legislative findings and declaration.
Subdivision two requires a surface access permit to be issued by the
Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation in order to
extract privately owned oil or gas from beneath state-owned surface
lands in Allegany State Park, and requires that each application for
such a permit include at a minimum: proof of ownership or legal
control of the drilling rights; a map of proposed well locations; a
description of proposed exploration and production activities;
identification of sources of water to be used; a description of
associated disturbance of the land surface; a description of
transportation methods for the extracted resources; a description of
reclamation steps to be taken;
baseline environmental sampling results; an inventory of the affected
natural resources; and a description of affected historic,
archeological and cultural resources.
Subdivision three sets forth required conditions for each such permit,
which include: limitation of number of wells and amount of cleared
area associated with each well site to minimize the impact on park
a prohibition on disposal of wastes in the park and storage in open
pits; restrictions on road construction; authority to restrict the
timing of drilling and associated activities and use of public roads;
establishment and maintenance of funds to reimburse the Office for the
costs of a full-time on-site monitor and of consultants to conduct
environmental sampling and inspection and monitoring of environmental
impacts; corrective action at the permittee's expense Where needed to
eliminate adverse environmental impacts; financial security
sufficient to restore natural conditions after the conclusion of
extraction activities; and any additional conditions the Office
deems necessary to avoid for minimize impacts on park resources and
to protect park visitors and employees.
Subdivision four provides that the requirements of this section shall
be in addition to any other legal requirements for the exercise of
rights, including but not limited to those in Article 23 of the
Environmental Conservation Law.
Subdivision five provides that the Office will serve as lead agency
for SEQRA review for any action connected with oil or gas exploration
or extraction in Allegany State Park, which review shall include an
evaluation of all potential impacts of such activity in terms of
consistency with the Office's statutory mission.
Subdivision six provides for enforcement of permit requirements by
permit revocation and in an action for injunction and civil penalties
of up to $10,000 per day.
Subdivision seven provides the state office of parks with compensation
of lost revenue in the event of a spill or release of oil or gas
produced or transported in the park.
Section two of the bill provides an immediate effective date.
Section 3.09(8) of the parks, Recreation and Historic
Preservation Law authorizes the office to promulgate rules and
regulations for the performance of its duties, and 6 NYCRR Part 372
provides for the issuance of permits by the Office for the conduct of
various activities on state parkland, including commercial activities.
Article 23 of the Environmental conservation Law requires a permit,
and sets forth technical requirements, for each gas and oil well
located anywhere in the state.
There is a unique situation in Allegany State Park
whereby ownership of subsurface oil and gas resources under portions
of the Park was severed and retained in private ownership, prior to
the acquisition and creation of the Park in the early 20th century.
The Office has received preliminary inquiries from oil and gas
companies Asserting they have acquired ownership or leases of
privately-held oil subsurface resources and proposing to commence oil
and gas drilling.
This bill creates a comprehensive framework for the Office's review
and permitting of private oil and gas extraction to ensure that if
such activities are conducted, adverse impacts to the Park's natural,
scenic, and recreational resources will be minimized or avoided.
PRIOR LEGISLATIVE HISTORY:
2010: Passed Senate & Assembly - Referred to Codes
view full text
S T A T E O F N E W Y O R K ________________________________________________________________________ 1908 2011-2012 Regular Sessions I N S E N A T E January 14, 2011 ___________ Introduced by Sens. SERRANO, PARKER -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Cultural Affairs, Tourism, Parks and Recreation AN ACT to amend the parks, recreation and historic preservation law, in relation to oil and gas drilling in Allegany state park THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEM- BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. The parks, recreation and historic preservation law is amended by adding a new section 13.31 to read as follows: S 13.31 OIL AND GAS DRILLING IN ALLEGANY STATE PARK. 1. LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS AND DECLARATION. THE LEGISLATURE FINDS AND DECLARES THAT ALLE- GANY STATE PARK HARBORS UNIQUE AND IRREPLACEABLE NATURAL AND SCENIC RESOURCES AND PROVIDES AN EXTENSIVE VARIETY OF RECREATIONAL AND EDUCA- TIONAL OPPORTUNITIES FOR NEW YORK RESIDENTS AND VISITORS. THE PARK IS LOCATED IN A GEOLOGICALLY DISTINCT, UNGLACIATED AREA WITH UNIQUE TERRES- TRIAL, FRESHWATER AND OLD GROWTH FOREST ECOSYSTEMS THAT WARRANT SPECIAL PROTECTION, AND IS HOME TO NUMEROUS RARE, THREATENED AND ENDANGERED SPECIES OF PLANTS AND WILDLIFE. THE PARK'S SIXTY-FIVE THOUSAND ACRES ARE THE LARGEST TRACT OF INTACT, UNFRAGMENTED FOREST LAND IN THE WESTERN HALF OF THE STATE, INCLUDING MATURE SECOND-GROWTH AS WELL AS EXTENSIVE OLD-GROWTH FORESTS. THESE FEATURES ARE AN INVALUABLE AND IRREPLACEABLE PART OF THE STATE'S NATURAL HERITAGE WHICH THE STATE IS OBLIGATED TO PRESERVE FOR FUTURE GENERATIONS. THE LEGISLATURE FURTHER FINDS AND DECLARES THAT A UNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCE EXISTS IN ALLEGANY STATE PARK WHEREBY PRIVATE ENTITIES CONTROL SUBSUR- FACE OIL AND GAS RIGHTS BENEATH PORTIONS OF THE PARK. OWNERSHIP OF SUCH SUBSURFACE OIL AND GAS RIGHTS WAS SEVERED AND RETAINED IN PRIVATE OWNER- SHIP PRIOR TO THE ACQUISITION AND CREATION OF THE PARK BY THE STATE OF NEW YORK IN THE EARLY TWENTIETH CENTURY. IT IS THE PURPOSE OF THIS SECTION TO ENSURE THAT ANY EXPLORATION, DRILLING, OR PRODUCTION ASSOCI- ATED WITH PRIVATELY-CONTROLLED OIL AND GAS RIGHTS WITHIN ALLEGANY STATE EXPLANATION--Matter in ITALICS (underscored) is new; matter in brackets [ ] is old law to be omitted. LBD00398-01-1 S. 1908 2 PARK, INCLUDING ALL ACTIVITIES NECESSARY TO OBTAIN ACCESS TO SUBSURFACE OIL AND GAS, BE UNDERTAKEN WITH THE STRICTEST POSSIBLE OVERSIGHT TO MINIMIZE ADVERSE IMPACTS ON THE PARK'S NATURAL, SCENIC, AND RECREATIONAL RESOURCES AND THE PUBLIC'S ACCESS TO THEM AND ENJOYMENT THEREOF. IT IS INTENDED THAT THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION BE LIBERALLY CONSTRUED AND APPLIED IN FURTHERANCE OF THIS PURPOSE. THE LEGISLATURE FINDS AND DECLARES THAT THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION HAVE BEEN ENACTED PURSUANT TO THE STATUTORILY-MANDATED DUTY OF THE OFFICE TO PROVIDE FOR THE HEALTH, SAFETY AND WELFARE OF THE PUBLIC USING FACILITIES UNDER ITS JURISDICTION. THE LEGISLATURE FINDS THAT THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION CONSTITUTE REASONABLE RESTRICTIONS UPON THE EXERCISE OF PRIVATELY-CONTROLLED OIL AND GAS RIGHTS IN FURTHERANCE OF THE STATE'S SOVEREIGN POWER AND DUTY TO HOLD PUBLIC PARKLANDS IN TRUST FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE. 2. SURFACE ACCESS PERMIT. NO DRILLING, ROAD BUILDING, CLEARING OF VEGETATION, OR OTHER ACTIVITY IN FURTHERANCE OF THE EXPLORATION OR PRODUCTION OF PRIVATELY-CONTROLLED OIL OR GAS RIGHTS BENEATH STATE OWNED LAND WITHIN ALLEGANY STATE PARK SHALL BE UNDERTAKEN EXCEPT PURSUANT TO THE TERMS OF A SURFACE ACCESS PERMIT ISSUED BY THE OFFICE PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION. AN APPLICATION FOR SUCH PERMIT SHALL BE FILED WITH THE OFFICE CONCURRENT WITH THE APPLICATION TO THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRON- MENTAL CONSERVATION FOR A PERMIT TO DRILL AN OIL OR GAS WELL AND SHALL INCLUDE AT A MINIMUM: (A) PROOF SATISFACTORY TO THE OFFICE OF THE APPLICANT'S LEGAL RIGHT TO RECOVER OIL OR GAS RESOURCES BENEATH STATE OWNED LAND, INCLUDING COPIES OF TITLE REPORTS AND, WHERE APPLICABLE, LEASES WITH TITLE HOLDERS, AND A BOUNDARY SURVEY COMPLETED BY A LICENSED SURVEYOR OF THE AFFECTED AREA; (B) A MAP IDENTIFYING THE PROPOSED LOCATION OF EACH OIL OR GAS WELL FOR WHICH AN APPLICATION FOR A DRILLING PERMIT HAS BEEN SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION; (C) A GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSED OIL OR GAS EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION ACTIVITIES; (D) IDENTIFICATION OF THE AMOUNT OF WATER NEEDED AND ITS SOURCES; (E) A DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF ALL SURFACE DISTURBANCE ASSOCIATED WITH THE PROPOSED EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION OF OIL OR GAS, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE LOCATION OF ALL PROPOSED ROAD CONSTRUCTION, ALL PROPOSED WELL DRILLING LOCATIONS, AND THE LOCATION AND AMOUNT OF PROPOSED TREE AND VEGETATION REMOVAL, AND THE METHODS TO BE USED IN SUCH ACTIVITIES; (F) A DESCRIPTION OF HOW PRODUCED OIL OR GAS WILL BE TRANSPORTED OUT OF THE PARK, INCLUDING A DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE CONSTRUCTION AND LOCATION OF ALL PROPOSED TRANSMISSION LINES; (G) A DETAILED DESCRIPTION AND TIMELINE OF STEPS THAT WILL BE TAKEN TO RECLAIM THE AFFECTED SURFACE AREA AND RESTORE IT TO ITS PREVIOUS NATURAL CONDITION ONCE DRILLING AND PRODUCTION ACTIVITIES HAVE CEASED. SUCH DESCRIPTION SHALL DESCRIBE INTERIM RESTORATION ACTIVITIES THAT SHALL OCCUR IMMEDIATELY AFTER EACH WELL HAS BEEN DRILLED AND ANY ASSOCIATED TRANSMISSION LINES HAVE BEEN INSTALLED, AS WELL AS FINAL RESTORATION ACTIVITIES THAT SHALL OCCUR AFTER PRODUCTION HAS CEASED; (H) BASELINE SAMPLING RESULTS, TAKEN PRIOR TO ANY GROUND DISTURBANCE OR REMOVAL OF TREES OR VEGETATION, FOR SURFACE WATER, SOIL, AND EXISTING GROUNDWATER WELLS IN PROXIMITY TO PROPOSED DRILLING LOCATIONS, TRANS- MISSION LINES, AND ROAD CONSTRUCTION LOCATIONS AS DETERMINED BY THE OFFICE; (I) A COMPREHENSIVE INVENTORY OF PLANT AND ANIMAL SPECIES, ECOLOGICAL COMMUNITIES, WETLANDS, AND SURFACE STREAMS WITHIN THE AREA, AS DETER- MINED BY THE OFFICE, THAT MAY BE AFFECTED BY PROPOSED DRILLING S. 1908 3 LOCATIONS, ROAD CONSTRUCTION, TRANSMISSION LINES, AND ANY OTHER ACTIV- ITIES ASSOCIATED WITH PROPOSED EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION ACTIVITIES, AND AN ANALYSIS OF THE POTENTIAL ADVERSE IMPACTS ON SUCH SPECIES, ECOLOGICAL COMMUNITIES, WETLANDS, AND SURFACE STREAMS; AND (J) A DESCRIPTION OF HISTORIC, ARCHEOLOGICAL AND CULTURAL RESOURCES POTENTIALLY AFFECTED BY PROPOSED EXPLORATION, PRODUCTION, ROAD BUILDING, AND TRANSMISSION LINES. 3. SURFACE ACCESS PERMIT CONDITIONS. ANY SURFACE ACCESS PERMIT GRANTED BY THE OFFICE PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION SHALL INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING TERMS AND CONDITIONS: (A) THE OFFICE MAY LIMIT THE NUMBER OF WELL SITES, THE LOCATION OF WELL SITES, AND THE AMOUNT OF CLEARED AREA ASSOCIATED WITH EACH WELL SITE IN ORDER TO MITIGATE ADVERSE IMPACTS TO NATURAL, ECOLOGICAL, SCENIC, AND RECREATIONAL RESOURCES. (B) NO LIQUID OR SOLID WASTES SHALL BE COLLECTED OR STORED IN OPEN PITS NOR DISPOSED OF OR RELEASED WITHIN THE PARK. (C) THE OFFICE MAY LIMIT THE CONSTRUCTION AND THE LOCATION OF ACCESS ROADS IN ORDER TO MITIGATE ADVERSE IMPACTS TO NATURAL, ECOLOGICAL, SCENIC, AND RECREATIONAL RESOURCES. ALL NEW ROADS SHALL BE DESIGNED TO THE MINIMUM POSSIBLE WIDTH AND SHALL BE CONSTRUCTED TO AVOID OR MINIMIZE THE POTENTIAL FOR EROSION AND OTHER ADVERSE IMPACTS. ALL TREES CUT OR REMOVED AS PART OF ROAD CONSTRUCTION AND WELL SITE CLEARING ACTIVITIES SHALL REMAIN THE PROPERTY OF THE OFFICE. (D) IN ORDER TO PROTECT THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF PARK VISITORS AND EMPLOYEES AND TO MINIMIZE ADVERSE IMPACTS ON PUBLIC RECREATIONAL USES OF THE PARK, THE OFFICE MAY RESTRICT THE SEASONS THAT THE PERMITTEE MAY UNDERTAKE ROAD CONSTRUCTION, WELL DRILLING, AND ASSOCIATED ACTIVITIES ON STATE OWNED LANDS. THE OFFICE MAY ALSO DESIGNATE THE PARK ROADS THE PERMITTEE SHALL USE FOR VEHICLE ACCESS INTO AND THROUGH THE PARK, AND MAY RESTRICT SEASONS OR TIMES THAT THE PERMITTEE MAY EXERCISE VEHICLE ACCESS ON PARK ROADS OPEN TO THE PUBLIC. (E) THE PERMITTEE SHALL BE REQUIRED TO ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN A FUND SUFFICIENT TO REIMBURSE THE OFFICE FOR THE COSTS OF AN ON-SITE MONITOR, WHO SHALL BE HIRED BY AND REPORT TO THE OFFICE, WHO SHALL BE PHYSICALLY PRESENT DURING ALL LAND CLEARING, ROAD CONSTRUCTION, WELL DRILLING, INSTALLATION AND MAINTENANCE OF TRANSMISSION LINES, WELL MAINTENANCE, WELL CLOSURE, AND RESTORATION ACTIVITIES UNDERTAKEN BY THE PERMITTEE TO ASSURE COMPLIANCE WITH ALL REQUIRED PERMITS AND APPLICABLE STATE AND FEDERAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS. (F) THE PERMITTEE SHALL BE REQUIRED TO ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN A FUND SUFFICIENT TO REIMBURSE THE OFFICE FOR THE COSTS OF CONSULTANTS RETAINED BY THE OFFICE TO CONDUCT: (1) SAMPLING OF GROUNDWATER, SURFACE WATER, WETLANDS, AND SOIL; (2) MONITORING TO DETECT ANY ADVERSE IMPACTS TO SENSITIVE SPECIES OF PLANTS AND ANIMALS AND ECOLOGICAL COMMUNITIES; AND (3) INSPECTIONS TO DETECT ANY NON-NATIVE INVASIVE PLANT OR ANIMAL SPECIES THAT ARE INTRODUCED INTO THE PARK AS A RESULT OF THE PERMITTEE'S ACTIVITIES. THE OFFICE SHALL DETERMINE THE AREAS TO BE SUBJECT TO SUCH SAMPLING, MONITORING, AND INSPECTIONS, WHICH SHALL BE UNDERTAKEN ANNUALLY, OR MORE FREQUENTLY IF DETERMINED APPROPRIATE BY THE OFFICE, UNTIL THE PERMITTEE HAS CONCLUDED OIL AND GAS EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION ACTIVITIES AND COMPLETED THE RESTORATION REQUIREMENTS ESTABLISHED IN PARAGRAPH (H) OF THIS SUBDIVISION. (G) THE PERMITTEE SHALL BE REQUIRED AT ITS EXPENSE TO TAKE CORRECTIVE ACTIONS TO ELIMINATE ANY ADVERSE IMPACTS RESULTING FROM THE PERMITTED S. 1908 4 ACTIVITY TO THE PARK'S ROADS, FACILITIES AND INFRASTRUCTURE, OR TO THE PARK'S GROUNDWATER, SURFACE WATER, WETLANDS, SOIL, NATURAL RESOURCES, PLANT AND ANIMAL SPECIES AND ECOLOGICAL COMMUNITIES. (H) THE PERMITTEE SHALL BE REQUIRED TO OBTAIN FINANCIAL SECURITY IN AN AMOUNT SUFFICIENT TO RESTORE TO THEIR PREVIOUS NATURAL CONDITION ALL AREAS AFFECTED BY THE PERMITTEE'S GROUND DISTURBANCE, CLEARING, DRILL- ING, ROAD CONSTRUCTION, AND INSTALLATION OF TRANSMISSION LINES, AFTER OIL AND GAS EXPLORATION, DRILLING, AND PRODUCTION ACTIVITIES HAVE CONCLUDED. RESTORATION SHALL INCLUDE BUT NOT BE LIMITED TO A REQUIREMENT THAT THE PERMITTEE REMOVE AND REFOREST ALL ROADS AND CLEARED AREAS. (I) THE OFFICE SHALL INCLUDE ANY ADDITIONAL PERMIT CONDITIONS IT DEEMS NECESSARY TO AVOID OR MINIMIZE IMPACTS ON THE PARK'S RECREATIONAL, SCENIC AND NATURAL RESOURCES AND TO PROTECT THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF PARK VISITORS AND EMPLOYEES. 4. OTHER REQUIREMENTS. THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION SHALL BE IN ADDITION TO, AND SHALL NOT REPLACE OR AFFECT, ANY OTHER REQUIREMENTS FOR THE EXERCISE OF OIL AND GAS DRILLING RIGHTS, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH IN ARTICLE TWENTY-THREE OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION LAW OR OTHER APPLICABLE STATE OR FEDERAL LAWS, PERMITS, ORDERS, OR REGULATIONS. NOTHING IN THIS SECTION SHALL AFFECT OR SUPER- SEDE THE APPLICATION OF ARTICLE SEVEN OF THE PUBLIC SERVICE LAW TO THE SITING OF A MAJOR UTILITY TRANSMISSION FACILITY AS DEFINED THEREIN. 5. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW. THE OFFICE WILL SERVE AS LEAD AGENCY FOR REVIEW PURSUANT TO ARTICLE EIGHT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION LAW FOR ALL ACTIONS INVOLVING EXPLORATION AND PRODUCTION OF PRIVATELY-CONT- ROLLED OIL AND GAS RESOURCES BENEATH STATE OWNED LANDS WITHIN ALLEGANY STATE PARK, INCLUDING APPLICATIONS FOR A PERMIT PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION. IN CONDUCTING SUCH REVIEW, THE OFFICE SHALL EVALUATE ALL POTEN- TIAL IMPACTS OF PROPOSED WELL DRILLING, ROAD CONSTRUCTION, CLEARING OF VEGETATION, AND OTHER RELATED ACTIVITIES IN TERMS OF CONSISTENCY WITH THE AGENCY'S MISSION AS SET FORTH IN SECTION 3.02 OF THIS CHAPTER. 6. ENFORCEMENT. ANY VIOLATION OF A TERM OR CONDITION OF A SURFACE ACCESS PERMIT GRANTED PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION SHALL BE GROUNDS FOR REVOCATION THEREOF. IN ADDITION, ANY PARTY ACTING IN VIOLATION OF SUCH A PERMIT, AND ANY PARTY ENGAGING IN OIL OR GAS EXPLORATION, DRILLING, OR PRODUCTION ACTIVITY WITHOUT HAVING OBTAINED A PERMIT AS REQUIRED BY THIS SECTION, SHALL BE SUBJECT TO INJUNCTION AND LIABLE FOR A CIVIL PENALTY OF NOT MORE THAN TEN THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR EACH DAY OF SUCH VIOLATION, OBTAINABLE IN AN ACTION BROUGHT BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL UPON REFERRAL BY THE COMMISSIONER OR ON HIS OR HER OWN INITIATIVE. 7. COMPENSATION OF LOST REVENUE. IN THE EVENT THAT ANY SPILL OR RELEASE OF OIL, GAS, OR OTHER SUBSTANCE PRODUCED OR TRANSPORTED IN ALLE- GANY STATE PARK BY, OR ON BEHALF OF, ANY PERSON RECEIVING A PERMIT UNDER THIS SECTION RESULTS IN THE TEMPORARY CLOSING OF ALL OR PART OF ALLEGANY STATE PARK, SUCH PERSON SHALL BE LIABLE TO COMPENSATE THE OFFICE FOR ANY LOST REVENUE OR PARK USER FEES RESULTING FROM THE CLOSURE. SUCH COMPEN- SATION OF LOST REVENUE SHALL BE IN ADDITION TO ANY OTHER COSTS OR PENAL- TIES IMPOSED UNDER APPLICABLE LAWS, REGULATIONS, OR PERMIT CONDITIONS. 8. RULES AND REGULATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER IS AUTHORIZED TO ADOPT RULES AND REGULATIONS NECESSARY OR DESIRABLE TO EFFECTUATE THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION. S 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
Open Legislation comments facilitate discussion of New York State legislation. All comments are subject to moderation. Comments deemed off-topic, commercial, campaign-related, self-promotional; or that contain profanity or hate speech; or that link to sites outside of the nysenate.gov domain are not permitted, and will not be published. Comment moderation is generally performed Monday through Friday.
By contributing or voting you agree to the Terms of Participation and verify you are over 13.