S T A T E O F N E W Y O R K
________________________________________________________________________
9169
I N S E N A T E
May 12, 2022
___________
Introduced by Sen. BRISPORT -- read twice and ordered printed, and when
printed to be committed to the Committee on Agriculture
AN ACT to amend the agriculture and markets law, in relation to the
directing the commissioner of agriculture and markets to reform
certain grant programs to promote opportunities for multi-generational
farming families and for beginning farmers
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEM-
BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Legislative findings. The legislature declares:
a. New York faces pressing needs to preserve and protect agricultural
working lands, while also helping at-risk farmers maintain their liveli-
hood.
b. New York dairy farmers face an uncertain future. According to
statistics from the United States Department of Agriculture's National
Agricultural Statistics Service ("USDANASS"), two-thirds of New York's
dairy farms have shut down since 1987, even as other forms of agricul-
ture have grown. In 1987, New York was home to 13,840 dairy farms. In
2012, that number had dropped down to 5,427. The most recent New York
State Department of Agriculture and Markets data from 2019 indicates
that New York is now home to just 3,843 dairy farms. This represents a
loss of 9,997 dairy farms over the past 32 years.
c. The decline in small and mid-sized dairy farms is not unique to New
York. Across the country, industry consolidation has changed dairy farm-
ing. Nationally, since 1987, the median dairy herd size has increased
from 80 cows to 1,300 cows.
d. The threat posed by industry consolidation has been clear for more
than a decade. According to a March 2010 report from the New York State
Office of the State Comptroller, the dairy industry has been in "crisis"
because the "decline of small family farms in the state negatively
impacts the local economies in which these farms are located, and also
changes the rural character and quantity of open space in upstate New
York".
e. Current New York state policy deepens consolidation and inequality
among dairy farmers. The Dairy Farmland Protection Initiative has
EXPLANATION--Matter in ITALICS (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD14240-01-2
S. 9169 2
invested more than $58 million to support 48 dairy farms over two appli-
cation cycles. Of these projects, more than 70% supported consolidation
and/or vertical integration, effectively "picking winners and losers".
f. Current New York state policy does not adequately invest in new
opportunities. Since 2014, the New Farmer Grant Program has only
distributed $4.19 million, less than 10% of the funding of the Dairy
Farmland Protection Initiative, and less than 4% of the funding provided
to farmland protection initiatives since 2018.
g. New York state agricultural policy must invest in farming's future
- fruits, vegetables, legumes, grains, and other "specialty crops".
Since 1987, the number of vegetable farms in New York state grew by 26%.
Fruit and nut farms have stagnated due to a lack of investment. Mean-
while, despite significant federal and state funding, the number of
dairy farms has collapsed.
h. Growth in specialty crops reflects national trends. According to
Farm Bureau analysis, the only farmers to see an increase in their cash
receipts in 2020 were "specialty crop" farmers - farmers who grow
fruits, vegetables, legumes, and grains that nourish people.
i. Investing in specialty crops supports nutritional security.
Nationally, only 1-in-10 adults consume Dietary Guidelines for Ameri-
cans' recommended servings of fruits and vegetables.
j. Investing in specialty crops supports New York's climate commit-
ments. According to a 2021 Columbia University analysis of food systems'
impact on climate change, including a survey of nearly 100 up-to-date
analyses, "In general, CO2-equivalent emissions from crop products are
10-50 times lower than most animal products, per kg of product."
k. Investing in specialty crops reduces New York's use of freshwater.
According to the Water Footprint Network, per gram of protein, the water
footprint for plant-based proteins like pulses is 1.5 times lower than
milk, eggs, and chicken meat. The average water footprint per calorie
for cereal grains and starchy root vegetables is 20 times lower than
that of beef.
l. In New York, the current distribution of agricultural land owner-
ship reflects and deepens systemic racism. According to the USDA NASS,
among all producers in New York state, 98% are white compared with 70%
of the overall population. On farmland with operators who all identify
as Black, 45% of land is rented, which is two-thirds more than White
operators. Operators identifying as Black or Indigenous less often earn
a thriving wage.
m. Nationally, according to the USDA, farmers identifying as Black
receive less than half as much in federal payments as farmers identify-
ing as White.
n. By keeping farms in operation and diversifying New York's working
lands, it is the intent of the legislature to increase agricultural
revenue in New York to help the state become a leader in supplying and
processing specialty crops and other plant-based foods and products to
meet growing demand.
o. It is further the intent of the legislature that it be the policy
of this state to adopt additional practices that will protect and
preserve the state's environment and natural resources. By encouraging
specialty crop production, the state can improve its efforts to imple-
ment this policy.
p. It is further the intent of the legislature that it be the policy
of this state to adopt additional practices that create more equitable
and just opportunities for farmland ownership and access among socially
S. 9169 3
disadvantaged farmers, and particularly farmers who identify as Black,
Indigenous, Asian, and Hispanic/Latino.
§ 2. The agriculture and markets law is amended by adding two new
sections 323-a and 323-b to read as follows:
§ 323-A. PROMOTION OF OPPORTUNITIES FOR MULTI-GENERATIONAL FARMING
FAMILIES. THE COMMISSIONER SHALL REFORM THE DAIRY FARMLAND PROTECTION
INITIATIVE GRANT PROGRAM IN A MANNER WHICH PROMOTES OPPORTUNITIES FOR
MULTI-GENERATIONAL FARMING FAMILIES. SUCH REFORMS SHALL:
1. PRIORITIZE SPECIALTY CROP PRODUCTION, INCLUDING FRUIT, VEGETABLE,
LEGUME, FUNGI, AND GRAIN PRODUCTION THAT DIRECTLY NOURISHES PEOPLE, AND
CROPS SPECIFIED BY THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AS
SPECIALTY CROPS THAT NOURISH PEOPLE, IN THE EVALUATION AND SELECTION OF
DAIRY FARMLAND PROTECTION INITIATIVE GRANTS;
2. WHEN POSSIBLE, FOSTER COLLABORATION WITH NEW YORK FRUIT AND VEGETA-
BLE ASSOCIATIONS, FARM-TO-SCHOOL PROGRAMS, AND FOOD HUB AGGREGATORS TO
SUPPORT SPECIALTY CROP MARKET ACCESS FOR FARMS IN TRANSITION; AND
3. REMOVE THE PROJECT-LEVEL FUNDING CAP ON EASEMENTS.
§ 323-B. PROMOTION OF OPPORTUNITIES FOR BEGINNING FARMERS. THE COMMIS-
SIONER SHALL REFORM THE NEW FARMER GRANT PROGRAM FOR BEGINNING FARMERS
IN A MANNER WHICH PROMOTES OPPORTUNITIES FOR BEGINNING FARMERS. SUCH
REFORMS SHALL:
1. EXPAND THE NEW FARMER GRANT PROGRAM IN THE STATE FOR BEGINNING
FARMERS. FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION, THE TERM "NEW FARMER" SHALL
MEAN AN OPERATOR WHO: (A) HAS NOT OPERATED A FARM OR RANCH FOR MORE THAN
TEN YEARS; (B) DOES NOT OWN A FARM OR RANCH GREATER THAN THIRTY PERCENT
OF THE AVERAGE SIZE FARM IN THE COUNTY AS DETERMINED BY THE MOST RECENT
CENSUS FOR AGRICULTURE AT THE TIME THE APPLICATION IS SUBMITTED; AND (C)
SUBSTANTIALLY PARTICIPATES IN THE OPERATION OF SUCH FARM OR RANCH;
2. REQUIRE HALF OF NEW FARMER GRANT PROGRAM FUNDING BE RESERVED FOR
SPECIALTY CROP PRODUCERS. FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION, THE TERM
"SPECIALTY CROP" SHALL MEAN FRUIT, VEGETABLE, LEGUME, FUNGI, AND GRAIN
PRODUCTION THAT DIRECTLY NOURISHES PEOPLE, AND CROPS SPECIFIED BY THE
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AS SPECIALTY CROPS THAT NOURISH
PEOPLE;
3. PRIORITIZE PROSPECTIVE FARMERS WHO IDENTIFY AS BLACK, INDIGENOUS,
ASIAN, AND/OR HISPANIC OR LATINO IN PROJECT EVALUATION AND SELECTION;
AND
4. WHEN POSSIBLE, FOSTER COLLABORATION WITH LAND TRUSTS AND OTHER
NON-GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS THAT SEEK TO CREATE LAND OWNERSHIP AND
LAND ACCESS OPPORTUNITIES FOR SOCIALLY DISADVANTAGED FARMERS.
§ 3. This act shall take effect immediately.