S T A T E O F N E W Y O R K
________________________________________________________________________
6679
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
I N A S S E M B L Y
April 28, 2023
___________
Introduced by M. of A. SANTABARBARA -- read once and referred to the
Committee on Governmental Employees
AN ACT to amend the retirement and social security law, in relation to
enacting the "police and fire employees retention act"
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEM-
BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as
the "police and fire employees retention act".
§ 2. Legislative findings. Over the past several years, increased
workloads on our police and fire employees throughout the state has
resulted in a large reduction in personnel resources due to retirement
and separation from service. The loss of talented and experienced
personnel in these important job titles further results in a structural
deficit of experienced trainers for our next generation of dedicated
police and fire personnel actively entering their public service lives.
This legislation seeks to induce talented and experienced personnel to
remain in service to the public while allowing their pension payments to
be deferred during a specific period of time while they continue employ-
ment.
§ 3. The retirement and social security law is amended by adding a new
section 381-c to read as follows:
§ 381-C. DEFERRED RETIREMENT OPTION PLAN PAYABLE TO MEMBERS OF
OPTIONAL TWENTY-YEAR RETIREMENT PLAN. A PARTICIPATING EMPLOYER WHICH HAS
ELECTED OR WHICH ELECTS, PURSUANT TO SECTION THREE HUNDRED EIGHTY-ONE OR
ANY SECTIONS UNDER THIS ARTICLE, WHO PARTICIPATES IN A TWENTY-YEAR
RETIREMENT PLAN MAY PROVIDE FOR A DEFERRED RETIREMENT OPTION PLAN.
A. DEFERRED RETIREMENT OPTION PLAN, (HEREINAFTER REFERRED TO AS
"DROP"), IS A RETIREMENT PLAN UNDER WHICH AN ELIGIBLE MEMBER OF A
PARTICIPATING EMPLOYER MAY ELECT TO PARTICIPATE, DEFERRING RECEIPT OF
RETIREMENT BENEFITS WHILE CONTINUING EMPLOYMENT. FOR THE PURPOSES OF
THIS SECTION, AN "ELIGIBLE MEMBER" IS ANY MEMBER OR OFFICER EMPLOYED BY
EXPLANATION--Matter in ITALICS (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD07326-02-3
A. 6679 2
THE STATE, LOCAL, MUNICIPAL, COUNTY, VILLAGE, AUTHORITY OR DIVISION
WITHIN THE STATE ELECTING TO PROVIDE THIS OPTION. DURING THE PERIOD OF
CONTINUED EMPLOYMENT, THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER'S MONTHLY RETIREMENT BENEFIT
SHALL BE DEFERRED AND HELD BY THE RETIREMENT SYSTEM ON BEHALF OF THE
MEMBER PLUS INTEREST AT AN EFFECTIVE RATE OF ONE AND ONE-HALF PERCENT
FOR THE SPECIFIC PERIOD OF PARTICIPATION IN DROP AS PROVIDED IN SUBDIVI-
SION C OF THIS SECTION. UPON COMPLETION OF THE DROP PERIOD, THE ELIGIBLE
MEMBER SHALL RECEIVE THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF RETIREMENT BENEFITS DEFERRED
UNDER DROP WITHOUT OPTIONAL MODIFICATION AS PERMITTED BY SUBDIVISIONS D
AND E OF THIS SECTION AND SHALL BEGIN TO RECEIVE THE PREVIOUSLY DETER-
MINED NORMAL SERVICE RETIREMENT BENEFIT WITH OPTIONAL MODIFICATION AS
FURTHER PROVIDED IN SUBDIVISION D OF THIS SECTION.
B. ANY ELIGIBLE MEMBER WHO IS CURRENTLY EMPLOYED BY A PARTICIPATING
EMPLOYER ELECTING TO PARTICIPATE UNDER THIS ARTICLE AND WHO QUALIFIES TO
RETIRE PURSUANT TO THIS TITLE BY REASON OF COMPLETING TWENTY YEARS OF
CREDITABLE SERVICE MAY ELECT TO PARTICIPATE IN DROP.
C. SUCH ELECTION MUST BE ON A FORM SUPPLIED BY THE RETIREMENT SYSTEM
AND MAY BE FOR ANY PERIOD OF TIME NOT LESS THAN TWELVE MONTHS OR MORE
THAN SIXTY MONTHS DURATION. ANY ELIGIBLE MEMBER WHO ELECTS TO PARTIC-
IPATE IN DROP IS CONSIDERED RETIRED ON THE DAY FOLLOWING THE EXPIRATION
OF THE DROP PERIOD. PROVIDED, HOWEVER, THAT ALL LOANS AND EXCESS
CONTRIBUTIONS MUST BE RESOLVED BY THE DATE OF ENTRY INTO DROP AND NO
ADDITIONAL LOANS OR EXCESS CONTRIBUTIONS SHALL BE PERMITTED AFTER THE
DATE OF ENTRY INTO DROP. UPON EXPIRATION OF THE TIME PERIOD SELECTED BY
THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER, SUCH MEMBER'S PARTICIPATION IN DROP SHALL TERMI-
NATE.
D. (1) EFFECTIVE WITH THE DATE OF PARTICIPATION IN DROP, THE ELIGIBLE
MEMBER'S NORMAL SERVICE RETIREMENT BENEFIT SHALL BE CALCULATED, USING
CREDITABLE SERVICE AND FINAL AVERAGE SALARY AS IF THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF
RETIREMENT WAS THE DATE OF ENTRY INTO DROP. THE AMOUNT DEFERRED PURSUANT
TO DROP SHALL BE CALCULATED BASED UPON THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER'S ZERO OPTION
RETIREMENT ALLOWANCE UNTIL SUCH MEMBER HAS OBTAINED THE APPLICABLE MAXI-
MUM SERVICE RETIREMENT LIMIT BASED UPON YEARS OF SERVICE. ANY ADDITIONAL
PARTICIPATION IN DROP AFTER A MEMBER HAS OBTAINED THE MAXIMUM SERVICE
RETIREMENT LIMIT BASED UPON YEARS OF SERVICE SHALL BE CALCULATED BASED
UPON SIXTY PERCENT OF THE MEMBER'S FULL ANNUAL RETIREMENT ALLOWANCE. IN
ADDITION, FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION, THE ANNUAL RETIREMENT ALLOW-
ANCE FOR ANY MEMBER ELECTING DROP SHALL BE CALCULATED USING A THREE-YEAR
FINAL AVERAGE SALARY AS DEFINED ELSEWHERE IN THIS ARTICLE. THE ELIGIBLE
MEMBER SHALL, HOWEVER, ELECT HIS OR HER OPTIONAL RETIREMENT BENEFIT AT
THE COMPLETION OF THE DROP PERIOD.
(2) IF THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER DIES PRIOR TO COMPLETION OF THE PERIOD OF
PARTICIPATION IN DROP, THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER SHALL BE TREATED AS IF SUCH
DROP ELECTION DID NOT EXIST. IN LIEU OF THE DROP PAYMENT, A DEATH BENE-
FIT SHALL BE PAYABLE CONSISTENT WITH THE TERMS OF THIS CHAPTER AND ALL
SALARY AND SERVICE REPORTED FOR SUCH ELIGIBLE MEMBER DURING THE DROP
PERIOD SHALL BE CONSIDERED IN CALCULATING THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER'S DEATH
BENEFIT.
(3) IF THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER IS APPROVED FOR DISABILITY BENEFITS
PROVIDED IN THIS CHAPTER DURING THE DROP PERIOD, THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER
SHALL BE TREATED AS IF THE DROP ELECTION DID NOT EXIST. IN LIEU OF THE
DROP PAYMENT, A DISABILITY RETIREMENT BENEFIT SHALL BE PAYABLE CONSIST-
ENT WITH THE TERMS OF THIS CHAPTER AND ALL SALARY AND SERVICE REPORTED
FOR SUCH ELIGIBLE MEMBER DURING THE DROP PERIOD SHALL BE CONSIDERED IN
CALCULATING THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER'S DISABILITY RETIREMENT BENEFIT.
A. 6679 3
(4) IF AN ELIGIBLE MEMBER OTHERWISE FAILS TO COMPLETE HIS OR HER PERI-
OD OF SERVICE AS ELECTED PURSUANT TO SUBDIVISION C OF THIS SECTION, THE
ELIGIBLE MEMBER SHALL BE TREATED AS IF SUCH DROP ELECTION DID NOT EXIST.
IN LIEU OF THE DROP PAYMENT, THE NORMAL SERVICE RETIREMENT BENEFIT SHALL
BE PAYABLE CONSISTENT WITH THE TERMS OF THIS CHAPTER AND ALL SALARY AND
SERVICE REPORTED FOR SUCH ELIGIBLE MEMBER DURING THE DROP PERIOD SHALL
BE CONSIDERED IN CALCULATING THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER'S SERVICE RETIREMENT
BENEFIT.
(5) IF AN ELIGIBLE MEMBER REMAINS EMPLOYED AFTER HIS OR HER PARTIC-
IPATION IN DROP IS TERMINATED, SUCH MEMBER SHALL FORFEIT ALL DROP BENE-
FITS AND CONTINUE EMPLOYMENT AS IF SUCH DROP ELECTION DID NOT EXIST.
SUCH MEMBER SHALL THEN BE ELIGIBLE TO ELECT DROP CONSISTENT WITH THE
TERMS OF THIS SECTION.
(6) IF AN ELIGIBLE MEMBER IS APPROVED FOR DISABILITY BENEFITS AFTER
BENEFITS PAYABLE PURSUANT TO DROP HAVE BEEN PAID, THE ELIGIBLE MEMBER
MAY ELECT TO RECEIVE THE DISABILITY BENEFITS IN LIEU OF DROP BENEFITS,
BUT SUCH DISABILITY BENEFITS MUST BE ACTUARIALLY ADJUSTED FOR ANY BENE-
FITS PAID UNDER DROP.
E. AT THE CONCLUSION OF THE MEMBER'S PARTICIPATION IN DROP, THE
RETIREMENT SYSTEM SHALL PAY THE DEFERRED SERVICE RETIREMENT BENEFITS IN
ONE OF THE FOLLOWING METHODS AS ELECTED BY THE MEMBER:
(1) ALL ACCRUED DROP BENEFITS, PLUS INTEREST, LESS WITHHOLDING AS
REQUIRED BY THE INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE, SHALL BE PAID TO THE DROP
PARTICIPANT OR ELIGIBLE BENEFICIARY OR AS OTHERWISE DETERMINED BY OPERA-
TION OF LAW;
(2) ALL ACCRUED DROP BENEFITS, PLUS INTEREST, SHALL BE PAID FROM THE
RETIREMENT SYSTEM TO A CUSTODIAN OF THE ELIGIBLE RETIREMENT PLAN OR
OTHER ELIGIBLE PLAN OR ACCOUNT AS PROVIDED PURSUANT TO THE INTERNAL
REVENUE CODE AS DIRECTED BY THE MEMBER OR ELIGIBLE BENEFICIARY;
(3) A PORTION OF THE DROP BENEFITS SHALL BE PAID TO THE DROP PARTIC-
IPANT OR ELIGIBLE BENEFICIARY, LESS WITHHOLDING REQUIRED BY THE INTERNAL
REVENUE SERVICE AND THE REMAINING DROP BENEFITS MAY BE ROLLED OVER AS
OTHERWISE PERMITTED BY THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE. FOR PURPOSES OF THIS
SUBDIVISION, THE TERM "ELIGIBLE BENEFICIARY" IS ONE WHO QUALIFIES TO
ROLLOVER BENEFITS FROM A QUALIFIED BENEFIT PLAN OR ACCOUNT AS PROVIDED
BY THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE.
THE DROP BENEFIT COST CONTAINED IN THIS SUBDIVISION SHALL BE PAID BY
ANY PARTICIPATING EMPLOYER, FOR ALL ELIGIBLE MEMBERS SPECIFIC TO SUCH
EMPLOYER, THAT HAS ELECTED TO PROVIDE THIS BENEFIT.
THE FORMS OF PAYMENT PROVIDED BY THIS SUBDIVISION MUST COMPLY WITH THE
MINIMUM DISTRIBUTION REQUIREMENTS OF THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE.
F. THE COMPTROLLER SHALL PRESCRIBE SUCH REGULATIONS AS MAY BE REQUIRED
FOR THE EFFECTIVE ADMINISTRATION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE PROVISIONS OF
THIS SECTION.
§ 4. This act shall take effect immediately.
FISCAL NOTE.--Pursuant to Legislative Law, Section 50:
This bill would allow employers in the New York State and Local Police
and Fire Retirement System (NYSLPFRS) who participate in twenty-year
retirement plans to provide their members with the option to elect to
participate in a Deferred Retirement Option Plan (DROP), deferring
receipt of retirement benefits while continuing their current employ-
ment. The features of this DROP are:
1. Members may elect to participate in the DROP upon the attainment of
retirement eligibility.
2. The service retirement benefit shall be the single life allowance
determined based on the service and final average salary at the
A. 6679 4
commencement of DROP participation. However, once a member's total
service credit (including service during the DROP period) exceeds 32
years, the monthly payment into the DROP account will be limited to 60%
of the single life allowance.
3. The NYSLPFRS shall consider DROP participants active members, and
annual employer contributions shall continue to be made by the partic-
ipating employers on behalf of such members.
4. The length of participation in the DROP must be specified at the
time of election and may not be less than 1 year nor exceed 5 years.
However, if the affected member should leave employment before or after
the scheduled DROP termination date, such member shall forfeit all DROP
benefits, and shall be treated as though there were no DROP election.
5. During the DROP period, the monthly pensions of such affected
members will be deferred and held by the NYSLPFRS on their behalf and
shall accrue interest at 1.5%. Such account, with interest accumulation,
must be distributed in full at the end of the specified DROP period.
6. If an affected member should die or become disabled during the DROP
period, such member shall be treated as though there were no DROP
election.
7. Upon termination from the DROP, such affected members shall receive
their deferred payments, and shall also begin to receive their previous-
ly determined pensions.
Section 212 of the Retirement and Social Security Law generally
prevents service retirees from receiving salaries of more than $35,000
for public employment before attaining age 65. This proposal would allow
members to receive a full salary and retirement benefits SIMULTANEOUSLY
for up to 5 years.
The Partial Lump Sum program currently allows NYSLPFRS members to
receive lump sums up to 25% of the present value of their pensions. In
combination with this proposal, an affected member could potentially
receive a lump sum exceeding 65% of the present value of their pension.
This significantly reduces the value of ongoing pension payments over
the member's remaining lifetime.
If this bill is enacted during the 2023 legislative session, it is
estimated there would be an increase in the annual contributions of an
electing employer in the NYSLPFRS for the fiscal year ending March 31,
2024 of approximately:
Retirement Plan Increase in Annual
Contributions
20-year 5.0% of salary
20-year with additional 60ths, non-State 2.5% of salary
20-year with additional 60ths, State Police 1.4% of salary
In addition to the annual contributions discussed above, there would
be past service costs which would depend on the current salary, age, and
length of service of the affected members. It is estimated that the past
service cost per member of an electing employer in the NYSLPFRS that
would be due on February 1, 2024 for local employers or March 1, 2024
for the State, would average approximately:
Retirement Plan Increase in Annual
Contributions
20-year 100% of salary
20-year with additional 60ths, non-State 85% of salary
20-year with additional 60ths, State Police 75% of salary
If the anticipated retirement experience of members who are eligible
for this benefit changes significantly in the future, there would be
additional increases in employer costs.
A. 6679 5
Summary of relevant resources:
Membership data as of March 31, 2022 was used in measuring the impact
of the proposed change, the same data used in the April 1, 2022 actuari-
al valuation. Distributions and other statistics can be found in the
2022 Report of the Actuary and the 2022 Annual Comprehensive Financial
Report.
The actuarial assumptions and methods used are described in the 2020,
2021, and 2022 Annual Report to the Comptroller on Actuarial Assump-
tions, and the Codes, Rules and Regulations of the State of New York:
Audit and Control.
The Market Assets and GASB Disclosures are found in the March 31, 2022
New York State and Local Retirement System Financial Statements and
Supplementary Information.
I am a member of the American Academy of Actuaries and meet the Quali-
fication Standards to render the actuarial opinion contained herein.
This fiscal note does not constitute a legal opinion on the viability
of the proposed change nor is it intended to serve as a substitute for
the professional judgment of an attorney.
This estimate, dated April 17, 2023, and intended for use only during
the 2023 Legislative Session, is Fiscal Note No. 2023-123, prepared by
the Actuary for the New York State and Local Retirement System.