A. 11560 2
(4) STREAMING SUPPORT SERVICES, NOT INCLUDING STREAMING DISTRIBUTION;
AND
(5) OTHER RELATED SERVICES AND FUNCTIONS AS DEFINED BY THE PUBLIC
SERVICE COMMISSION.
B. THE TERM "DATA CENTER" SHALL NOT INCLUDE FACILITIES MAJORITY-OWNED,
OPERATED, OR OTHERWISE CONTROLLED BY A PUBLIC RESEARCH INSTITUTION AND
USED FOR RESEARCH PURPOSES.
2. "CONTROL", INCLUDING THE TERMS "CONTROLLED BY" AND "UNDER COMMON
CONTROL WITH", MEANS THE POSSESSION, DIRECT OR INDIRECT, OF THE POWER TO
DIRECT OR CAUSE THE DIRECTION OF THE MANAGEMENT AND POLICIES OF AN ENTI-
TY, WHETHER THROUGH THE OWNERSHIP OF VOTING SECURITIES, BY CONTRACT, OR
OTHERWISE.
3. "ELECTRIC CORPORATION" SHALL HAVE THE SAME MEANING GIVEN TO SUCH
TERM IN SUBDIVISION THIRTEEN OF SECTION TWO OF THE PUBLIC SERVICE LAW.
4. "GAS CORPORATION" SHALL HAVE THE SAME MEANING GIVEN TO SUCH TERM IN
SUBDIVISION ELEVEN OF SECTION TWO OF THE PUBLIC SERVICE LAW.
5. "WATER-WORKS CORPORATION" SHALL HAVE THE SAME MEANING GIVEN TO SUCH
TERM IN SUBDIVISION TWENTY-SEVEN OF SECTION TWO OF THE PUBLIC SERVICE
LAW.
6. "DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES" SHALL HAVE THE SAME MEANING GIVEN TO
SUCH TERM IN SECTION 75-0101 OF THIS CHAPTER.
7. "LARGE DATA CENTER" SHALL MEAN A DATA CENTER THAT HAS A PEAK DEMAND
OF TWENTY MEGAWATTS OR MORE.
§ 31-0103. MORATORIUM ON LARGE DATA CENTER PERMIT ISSUANCE.
1. NO PERMIT, CERTIFICATE, REGISTRATION, LICENSE, OR OTHER FORM OF
APPROVAL MAY BE ISSUED BY THE DEPARTMENT TO A LARGE DATA CENTER PRIOR TO
ONE YEAR AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS SECTION.
2. THIS SECTION SHALL NOT APPLY TO:
A. THE MODIFICATION, RENEWAL, REISSUANCE, OR RECERTIFICATION OF ANY
PREVIOUSLY ISSUED PERMIT, CERTIFICATE, REGISTRATION, LICENSE, OR OTHER
FORM OF APPROVAL; OR
B. LARGE DATA CENTERS COMMENCING CONSTRUCTION ON OR BEFORE THE EFFEC-
TIVE DATE OF THIS SECTION.
§ 31-0105. HEARING REQUIREMENT.
1. THE DEPARTMENT SHALL NOT ISSUE ANY PERMIT, CERTIFICATE, REGISTRA-
TION, LICENSE, OR OTHER FORM OF APPROVAL FOR A LARGE DATA CENTER UNLESS,
NOT LESS THAN THREE MONTHS BEFORE THE ISSUANCE OF SUCH PERMIT, CERTIF-
ICATE, REGISTRATION, LICENSE, OR OTHER FORM OF APPROVAL, THE DATA
CENTER, IN COORDINATION WITH THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION AND THE
DEPARTMENT, AND SUBJECT TO SUCH REQUIREMENTS AS THE PUBLIC SERVICE
COMMISSION AND THE DEPARTMENT SHALL STIPULATE, HAS HELD AT LEAST ONE
IN-PERSON PUBLIC HEARING IN AT LEAST ONE HOST COMMUNITY WHERE THE
PROPOSED LARGE DATA CENTER IS TO BE CONSTRUCTED.
2. THE DATA CENTER OPERATOR SHALL PROVIDE AT LEAST THIRTY DAYS ADVANCE
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF HOST COMMUNITIES OF ANY PLANNED PUBLIC HEARING.
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARINGS SHALL INCLUDE THE TIME, PLACE, AND LOCATION OF
THE PUBLIC HEARING, A SUMMARY OF THE LARGE DATA CENTER PROJECT, THE
SPECIFIC LOCATION OF THE LARGE DATA CENTER, A DETAILED EXPLANATION OF
THE PROJECTED ENERGY USE AND ENERGY SYSTEM IMPACTS, A DETAILED EXPLANA-
TION OF THE PROJECTED WATER USE AND WASTEWATER IMPACTS, AND A DETAILED
EXPLANATION OF THE STATE AND LOCAL ECONOMIC INCENTIVES THE LARGE DATA
CENTER IS APPLYING FOR AND THOSE IT HAS ALREADY BEEN AWARDED. METHODS OF
PROVIDING NOTICE TO A HOST COMMUNITY SHALL INCLUDE, BUT SHALL NOT BE
LIMITED TO, COVERAGE IN PRINT OR DIGITAL PUBLICATIONS OF GENERAL CIRCU-
LATION IN THE COMMUNITY, AND SUCH OTHER PUBLICATIONS AS THE DEPARTMENT
MAY REQUIRE. THE HEARING SHALL BE HELD AT A REASONABLE TIME AND PLACE,
A. 11560 3
AND MEANINGFUL OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC COMMENT SHALL BE PROVIDED AT SUCH
HEARING.
3. AT THE HEARING, THE LARGE DATA CENTER SHALL ADDRESS THE EFFORTS IT
WILL MAKE TO REDUCE ANY NEGATIVE IMPACTS TO THE HOST COMMUNITY AND ITS
ENVIRONMENT THAT THE LARGE DATA CENTER MAY CAUSE.
4. THE LARGE DATA CENTER SHALL PAY ALL EXPENSES FOR SUCH HEARING
INCLUDING THE COSTS OF THE DEPARTMENT AND THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
SERVICE.
§ 31-0107. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT.
1. THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION, IN CONSULTATION WITH
THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SERVICE, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, ENVIRONMENTAL
FACILITIES CORPORATION, AND THE FEDERALLY DESIGNATED BULK SYSTEM OPERA-
TOR, SHALL PREPARE AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT ON DATA CENTER DEVEL-
OPMENT IN THIS STATE.
2. THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT SHALL ADDRESS MATTERS INCLUDING,
BUT NOT LIMITED TO:
A. THE NUMBER, SIZE IN ACREAGE, AVERAGE AND PEAK ELECTRIC LOAD, AND
LOCATION OF CURRENT DATA CENTERS IN THE STATE, ACTIVE PROPOSALS FOR NEW
DATA CENTERS, AND PROJECTIONS FOR FUTURE GROWTH OF DATA CENTERS.
B. ELECTRICITY CONSUMPTION BY DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING:
I. THE AMOUNT OF ELECTRICITY USED BY DATA CENTERS WITHIN THE STATE;
II. IDENTIFICATION OF THE GENERATION SOURCES FOR SUCH ELECTRICITY;
III. PROJECTIONS FOR THE CHANGES TO THE AMOUNT UNDER SUBPARAGRAPH I OF
THIS PARAGRAPH FOR BOTH THE PROPOSED AND PROJECTED GROWTH OF DATA
CENTERS IN THE STATE; AND
IV. THE AMOUNT OF DISCOUNTED OR SUBSIDIZED ELECTRICITY USED BY DATA
CENTERS WITHIN THE STATE AND THE AMOUNTS OF SUCH DISCOUNTS AND SUBSI-
DIES.
C. WATER CONSUMPTION AND DISCHARGE BY DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING:
I. THE AMOUNT OF WATER USED BY DATA CENTERS FOR COOLING, INCLUDING THE
SOURCES OF SUCH WATER;
II. THE DAILY RATE OF CONSUMPTION OF WATER FROM SUCH SOURCES;
III. THE AMOUNT OF WATER WITHDRAWN AND DISCHARGED FROM DATA CENTERS
BACK INTO THE STATE'S WATER RESOURCES, THE TEMPERATURE OF THE WATER BOTH
AT POINT OF WITHDRAWAL AND DISCHARGE, LOCATIONS OF WITHDRAWAL AND
DISCHARGE POINTS, AND THE LOCAL IMPACTS OF THE DISCHARGE;
IV. THE AMOUNT OF WATER CONSUMED BY COOLING SYSTEMS, LOST TO EVAPO-
RATION, OR IN ANY WAY NOT RETURNED TO THE WATERS OF THE STATE;
V. PROJECTIONS FOR THE CHANGES TO THE AMOUNTS UNDER SUBPARAGRAPHS I,
II, III, AND IV OF THIS PARAGRAPH FOR BOTH THE PROPOSED AND PROJECTED
GROWTH OF DATA CENTERS IN THE STATE; AND
VI. THE IMPACT OF DATA CENTER DEVELOPMENT ON THE MANAGEMENT OF THE
STATE'S WATER RESOURCES, INCLUDING ANY IMPACTS RELATED TO CAPITAL PLAN-
NING, SPENDING, AND MAINTENANCE NEEDS OF WATER-WORKS CORPORATIONS OR
MUNICIPAL WATER SYSTEMS AND OF ANY WATER AUTHORITIES, WATER BOARDS, OR
SEWER AUTHORITIES ESTABLISHED UNDER ARTICLE FIVE OF THE PUBLIC AUTHORI-
TIES LAW, INCLUDING BILLING IMPACTS.
D. LAND USE FOR DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING:
I. THE TOTAL ACREAGE USED FOR EXISTING DATA CENTERS;
II. PROJECTIONS FOR THE CHANGES TO THE AMOUNTS UNDER SUBPARAGRAPH I OF
THIS PARAGRAPH FOR BOTH THE PROPOSED AND PROJECTED GROWTH OF DATA
CENTERS IN THE STATE;
III. IMPACTS ON FARMLAND, INCLUDING AN ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS ON PRIME
FARMLAND MINERAL SOIL TYPES 1-4; AND
IV. WHETHER DATA CENTERS ARE LOCATING ON AND REDEVELOPING EXISTING
PREVIOUSLY-DEVELOPED AND UNDER-UTILIZED PUBLICLY-OWNED LANDS, FACILI-
A. 11560 4
TIES, AND OTHER INFRASTRUCTURE THAT MAY BE AVAILABLE FOR REPURPOSING,
REDEVELOPMENT, OR ADAPTIVE REUSE, AND THE AVAILABILITY THEREOF.
E. POLLUTION FROM DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO:
I. THE AMOUNT OF GREENHOUSE GASES EMITTED BY EACH EXISTING DATA CENTER
AND THE CUMULATIVE TOTAL FOR THE STATE EMITTED OR PROJECTED TO BE EMIT-
TED BY EXISTING, PROPOSED, AND PROJECTED DATA CENTERS, EXPRESSED IN
METRIC TONS OF CARBON DIOXIDE EQUIVALENT, AS DEFINED IN SECTION 75-0101
OF THIS CHAPTER;
II. THE TYPES AND QUANTITY OF AIR POLLUTANTS EMITTED BY EACH DATA
CENTER AND THE CUMULATIVE TOTAL FOR THE STATE EMITTED BY EXISTING,
PROPOSED, AND PROJECTED DATA CENTERS;
III. THE TYPES AND QUANTITY OF WATER POLLUTION PRODUCED BY EACH DATA
CENTER, INCLUDING THERMAL POLLUTION FROM WATER DISCHARGES, AND THE CUMU-
LATIVE TOTAL FOR THE STATE PRODUCED BY EXISTING, PROPOSED, AND PROJECTED
DATA CENTERS;
IV. POTENTIAL PUBLIC HEALTH IMPACTS, IF ANY, DUE TO REDUCED AIR AND
WATER QUALITY IN COMMUNITIES NEAR DATA CENTERS; AND
V. THE LEVEL OF NOISE POLLUTION PRODUCED BY EACH DATA CENTER, WITH
PROJECTIONS FOR PROPOSED AND PROJECTED DATA CENTERS, AT REGULAR INTER-
VALS BEGINNING AT THE PROPERTY LINE OF THE DATA CENTER AND EXTENDING
HALF A MILE.
F. ELECTRONIC WASTE FROM DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING:
I. THE CURRENT VOLUME OF ELECTRONIC WASTE PRODUCED BY DATA CENTERS, BY
WASTE TYPE;
II. THE CURRENT METHODS BEING USED TO DISPOSE OF OR RECYCLE ELECTRONIC
WASTE PRODUCED BY DATA CENTERS; AND
III. PROJECTIONS FOR THE CHANGES TO THE AMOUNTS UNDER SUBPARAGRAPH I
OF THIS PARAGRAPH FOR BOTH THE PROPOSED AND PROJECTED GROWTH OF DATA
CENTERS IN THE STATE.
G. THE IMPACTS, INCLUDING HEALTH IMPACTS AND AIR, WATER, AND NOISE
POLLUTION IMPACTS, OF CURRENT, PROPOSED, AND PROJECTED DATA CENTERS ON
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES AND FEDERALLY OR STATE RECOGNIZED INDIGENOUS
NATIONS LOCATED WITHIN A TEN-MILE RADIUS OF SUCH DATA CENTERS.
H. A REVIEW OF CURRENT STATUTES AND REGULATIONS ADDRESSING THE ENVI-
RONMENTAL IMPACT OF DATA CENTERS.
I. IN CONSULTATION WITH THE EMPIRE STATE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AND
THE AUTHORITIES BUDGET OFFICE, THE AMOUNT OF PUBLIC FUNDS RECEIVED BY
DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING IN THE FORM OF STATE AND LOCAL TAX INCENTIVES,
INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO PAYMENTS IN LIEU OF TAX ARRANGEMENTS, SALES
AND USE TAX INCENTIVES, PROPERTY TAX INCENTIVES, MORTGAGE RECORDING TAX
INCENTIVES, AND REAL ESTATE TRANSFER TAX INCENTIVES.
3. THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT SHALL RECOMMEND NEW LEGISLATION AND
REGULATIONS AS APPROPRIATE TO MITIGATE THE IMPACTS OF DATA CENTERS IDEN-
TIFIED BY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO:
A. MINIMIZE AIR, WATER, SOIL, AND NOISE POLLUTION;
B. MINIMIZE WATER CONSUMPTION; AND
C. AVOID NEW BURDENS ON DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES AND AVOID CONTRIBUT-
ING TO EXISTING BURDENS ON DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES.
4. A DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT SHALL BE POSTED ON THE DEPART-
MENT'S WEBSITE AND SHALL BE SUBJECT TO AT LEAST ONE HUNDRED TWENTY DAYS
OF PUBLIC COMMENT FROM THE DATE OF POSTING. THE DEPARTMENT SHALL CONDUCT
AT LEAST ONE IN-PERSON PUBLIC HEARING IN AT LEAST FIVE OF THE FOLLOWING
REGIONS OF THE STATE: WESTERN NEW YORK, THE FINGER LAKES, THE SOUTHERN
TIER, CENTRAL NEW YORK, THE MOHAWK VALLEY, THE NORTH COUNTRY, THE CAPI-
TAL REGION/HUDSON VALLEY, THE CITY OF NEW YORK, AND LONG ISLAND, AS
A. 11560 5
DEFINED BY THE EMPIRE STATE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, AND PROVIDE MEAN-
INGFUL OPPORTUNITY FOR COMMENT AT SUCH HEARINGS.
5. THE DEPARTMENT SHALL ISSUE A FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT
AFTER THE PUBLIC COMMENT AND PUBLIC HEARING PERIOD AND NO LATER THAN
EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THIS ARTICLE SHALL HAVE BECOME A LAW.
§ 3. Subdivision 5 of section 65 of the public service law, as amended
by chapter 134 of the laws of 1921, is amended to read as follows:
5. (A) Nothing in this chapter shall be taken to prohibit a gas corpo-
ration or [electrical] ELECTRIC corporation from establishing classi-
fications of service based upon the quantity used, the time when used,
the purpose for which used, the duration of use or upon any other
reasonable consideration, and providing schedules of just and reasonable
graduated rates applicable thereto. No such classification, schedule,
rate or charge shall be lawful unless it shall be filed with and
approved by the commission, and every such classification, rate or
charge shall be subject to change, alteration and modification by the
commission.
(B) (I) THE COMMISSION SHALL REQUIRE EACH ELECTRIC CORPORATION, GAS
CORPORATION, AND MUNICIPALITY TO ESTABLISH, AND FILE WITH THE COMMISSION
FOR APPROVAL OR MODIFICATION, AN INDEPENDENT CLASSIFICATION OF SERVICE
FOR LARGE DATA CENTERS THAT IS SEPARATE AND DISTINCT FROM OTHER CLASSI-
FICATIONS OF SERVICE. THE COMMISSION SHALL ALSO REQUIRE EACH ELECTRIC
CORPORATION, GAS CORPORATION, AND MUNICIPALITY TO FILE UPDATES, IF
APPLICABLE, TO EXISTING CLASSIFICATIONS OF SERVICE TO EXCLUDE LARGE DATA
CENTERS AND TO UPDATE ANY OTHER FILINGS, DOCUMENTS, OR COMPONENTS THERE-
OF NECESSARY TO EFFECTUATE THE RECLASSIFICATION OF LARGE DATA CENTERS.
EACH SUCH SERVICE CLASSIFICATION FOR LARGE DATA CENTERS SHALL AT A MINI-
MUM, IN A MANNER THAT IS JUST AND REASONABLE, ESTABLISH A RATE, CHARGE,
OR SCHEDULE OF RATES, AND ADDITIONAL TERMS OF SERVICE, TO:
(A) ASSIGN THE COSTS INCURRED BY THE ELECTRIC CORPORATION, GAS CORPO-
RATION, OR MUNICIPALITY TO SERVE LARGE DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING, BUT NOT
LIMITED TO, THE COSTS OF ANY INFRASTRUCTURE UPGRADES, ADMINISTRATIVE
EXPENSES, IMPROVEMENTS, OR ADDITIONS AND OPERATIONAL COSTS, NECESSARY TO
FACILITATE AND MAINTAIN SERVICE TO SUCH FACILITIES, ENTIRELY AMONG SUCH
CLASSIFICATION;
(B) ASSIGN ALL COSTS RELATED TO THE RECOVERY OF ANY RATE OF RETURN
ATTRIBUTABLE TO LARGE DATA CENTERS ENTIRELY AMONG SUCH CLASSIFICATION;
(C) ASSIGN ALL COSTS OF THE DEPARTMENT, THE COMMISSION, AND AFFECTED
MUNICIPALITIES RELATED TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS PARAGRAPH ENTIRELY
AMONG SUCH CLASSIFICATION;
(D) ASSIGN ALL COSTS OF THE DEPARTMENT AND THE COMMISSION FOR THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION EIGHT OF THE CHAPTER OF
THE LAWS OF TWO THOUSAND TWENTY-SIX THAT ADDED THIS PARAGRAPH ENTIRELY
AMONG SUCH CLASSIFICATION; AND
(E) MITIGATE RISKS AND IMPACTS TO OTHER SERVICE CLASSIFICATIONS FROM
LARGE DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING ENSURING THERE ARE NO INCREASES TO
SURCHARGES, BASIC SERVICE OR OTHER FIXED CHARGES NOT DIRECTLY RELATED TO
ACTUAL ENERGY USAGE;
(II) THE COMMISSION, IN COORDINATION WITH THE FEDERALLY DESIGNATED
BULK SYSTEM OPERATOR, SHALL ESTABLISH, IMPLEMENT, AND ANNUALLY UPDATE AN
ADJUSTMENT MECHANISM TO ENSURE THAT ALL COSTS FROM ANY INCREASES IN
COMMODITY PRICES AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE CHAPTER OF THE LAWS OF
TWO THOUSAND TWENTY-SIX THAT AMENDED THIS SUBDIVISION, INCLUDING, BUT
NOT LIMITED TO, TRANSMISSION SERVICE FEES, ATTRIBUTABLE TO LARGE DATA
CENTERS ARE BORNE BY SUCH FACILITIES.
A. 11560 6
(III) THE DEPARTMENT MAY PROMULGATE REGULATIONS REGARDING FINANCIAL
SURETY REQUIREMENTS, BETWEEN AN ELECTRIC CORPORATION, GAS CORPORATION,
OR MUNICIPALITY AND A LARGE DATA CENTER, FOR THE PROVISION OF SERVICE TO
LARGE DATA CENTERS WHICH MAY INCLUDE ONE, OR ANY COMBINATION, OF THE
FOLLOWING: INSURANCE, GUARANTEE, SURETY BOND, LETTER OF CREDIT, OR
QUALIFICATION AS A SELF-INSURER. IN PROMULGATING REQUIREMENTS UNDER THIS
SECTION, THE COMMISSION SHALL BE AUTHORIZED TO SPECIFY POLICY OR OTHER
CONTRACTUAL TERMS, CONDITIONS, OR DEFENSES WHICH ARE NECESSARY OR ARE
UNACCEPTABLE IN ESTABLISHING SUCH EVIDENCE OF FINANCIAL SURETY.
(IV) FOR PURPOSES OF THIS PARAGRAPH, "LARGE DATA CENTER" SHALL HAVE
THE MEANING GIVEN TO SUCH TERM BY SECTION 31-0101 OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL
CONSERVATION LAW.
§ 4. Subdivision 5 of section 89-b of the public service law, as added
by chapter 715 of the laws of 1931, is amended to read as follows:
5. (A) Nothing in this chapter shall be taken to prohibit a water-
works corporation from establishing classifications of service based
upon the quantity of water used, times when used, purpose for which
used, duration of use, or upon any other reasonable consideration, and
providing schedules of just and reasonable graduated rates applicable
thereto. No such classification, schedule, rate or charge shall be
lawful unless it shall be filed with and approved by the commission, and
every such classification, rate or charge shall be subject to change,
alteration and modification by the commission.
(B) (I) THE COMMISSION SHALL REQUIRE EACH WATER-WORKS CORPORATION OR
MUNICIPAL WATER SYSTEM TO ESTABLISH, AND FILE WITH THE COMMISSION FOR
APPROVAL OR MODIFICATION, AN INDEPENDENT CLASSIFICATION OF SERVICE FOR
LARGE DATA CENTERS THAT IS SEPARATE AND DISTINCT FROM OTHER CLASSIFICA-
TIONS OF SERVICE. THE COMMISSION SHALL ALSO REQUIRE EACH WATER-WORKS
CORPORATION TO FILE UPDATES, IF APPLICABLE, TO EXISTING CLASSIFICATIONS
OF SERVICE TO EXCLUDE LARGE DATA CENTERS AND TO UPDATE ANY OTHER
FILINGS, DOCUMENTS, OR COMPONENTS THEREOF NECESSARY TO EFFECTUATE THE
RECLASSIFICATION OF LARGE DATA CENTERS. EACH SUCH SERVICE CLASSIFICA-
TION FOR LARGE DATA CENTERS SHALL AT A MINIMUM, IN A MANNER THAT IS JUST
AND REASONABLE, ESTABLISH A RATE, CHARGE, OR SCHEDULE OF RATES, AND
ADDITIONAL TERMS OF SERVICE, TO:
(A) ASSIGN THE COSTS INCURRED BY THE WATER-WORKS CORPORATION OR MUNIC-
IPAL WATER SYSTEM TO SERVE LARGE DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMIT-
ED TO, THE COSTS OF ANY INFRASTRUCTURE UPGRADES, ADMINISTRATIVE
EXPENSES, IMPROVEMENTS, OR ADDITIONS AND OPERATIONAL COSTS, NECESSARY TO
FACILITATE AND MAINTAIN SERVICE TO SUCH LARGE DATA CENTER FACILITIES,
ENTIRELY AMONG SUCH CLASSIFICATION;
(B) ASSIGN ALL COSTS RELATED TO THE RECOVERY OF ANY RATE OF RETURN
ATTRIBUTABLE TO LARGE DATA CENTERS ENTIRELY AMONG SUCH CLASSIFICATION;
(C) ASSIGN ALL COSTS OF THE DEPARTMENT, THE COMMISSION, AND MUNICI-
PALITIES RELATED TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS PARAGRAPH ENTIRELY AMONG
SUCH CLASSIFICATION; AND
(D) MITIGATE RISKS AND IMPACTS TO OTHER SERVICE CLASSIFICATIONS FROM
DATA CENTERS, INCLUDING ENSURING THERE ARE NO INCREASES TO SURCHARGES,
BASIC SERVICE OR OTHER FIXED CHARGES NOT DIRECTLY RELATED TO ACTUAL
WATER USAGE.
(II) THE COMMISSION SHALL ESTABLISH, IMPLEMENT, AND ANNUALLY UPDATE AN
ADJUSTMENT MECHANISM TO ENSURE THAT ALL COSTS FROM ANY INCREASES IN
COMMODITY PRICES AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE CHAPTER OF THE LAWS OF
TWO THOUSAND TWENTY-SIX THAT AMENDED THIS SUBDIVISION, INCLUDING, BUT
NOT LIMITED TO, WATER SERVICE FEES, ATTRIBUTABLE TO LARGE DATA CENTERS
ARE BORNE BY SUCH FACILITIES.
A. 11560 7
(III) THE DEPARTMENT MAY PROMULGATE REGULATIONS REGARDING FINANCIAL
SURETY REQUIREMENTS, BETWEEN A WATER-WORKS CORPORATION OR MUNICIPAL
WATER SYSTEM AND A LARGE DATA CENTER, FOR THE PROVISION OF SERVICE TO
LARGE DATA CENTERS WHICH MAY INCLUDE ONE, OR ANY COMBINATION, OF THE
FOLLOWING: INSURANCE, GUARANTEE, SURETY BOND, LETTER OF CREDIT, OR
QUALIFICATION AS A SELF-INSURER. IN PROMULGATING REQUIREMENTS UNDER THIS
SECTION, THE COMMISSION SHALL BE AUTHORIZED TO SPECIFY POLICY OR OTHER
CONTRACTUAL TERMS, CONDITIONS, OR DEFENSES WHICH ARE NECESSARY OR ARE
UNACCEPTABLE IN ESTABLISHING SUCH EVIDENCE OF FINANCIAL SURETY.
(IV) FOR PURPOSES OF THIS PARAGRAPH, "LARGE DATA CENTER" SHALL HAVE
THE MEANING GIVEN TO SUCH TERM BY SECTION 31-0101 OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL
CONSERVATION LAW.
§ 5. The public service law is amended by adding a new section 114-b
to read as follows:
§ 114-B. SERVICE CLASSIFICATION FOR LARGE DATA CENTERS. 1. THE COMMIS-
SION SHALL:
A. NOT APPROVE ANY CHANGE OF RATES OR RELATED UPDATES TO A TARIFF
REQUESTED BY AN ELECTRIC CORPORATION, GAS CORPORATION, WATER-WORKS
CORPORATION, OR MUNICIPALITY AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS SECTION
UNLESS SUCH PROPOSAL INCLUDES A SERVICE CLASSIFICATION FOR LARGE DATA
CENTERS AND AN ADJUSTMENT MECHANISM IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF
PARAGRAPH (B) OF SUBDIVISION FIVE OF SECTION SIXTY-FIVE OR PARAGRAPH (B)
OF SUBDIVISION FIVE OF SECTION EIGHTY-NINE-B OF THIS CHAPTER, AS APPLI-
CABLE; AND
B. ENSURE THAT ALL NEW OR MODIFIED SERVICE CLASSIFICATIONS AND ADJUST-
MENT MECHANISMS REQUIRED BY PARAGRAPH (B) OF SUBDIVISION FIVE OF SECTION
SIXTY-FIVE OR PARAGRAPH (B) OF SUBDIVISION FIVE OF SECTION EIGHTY-NINE-B
OF THIS CHAPTER ARE FULLY IMPLEMENTED BY ELECTRIC CORPORATIONS, GAS
CORPORATIONS, WATER-WORKS CORPORATIONS, OR MUNICIPALITIES NO LATER THAN
JUNE FIRST, TWO THOUSAND THIRTY.
2. FOR PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION, "LARGE DATA CENTER" SHALL HAVE THE
MEANING GIVEN TO SUCH TERM BY SECTION 31-0101 OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL
CONSERVATION LAW.
§ 6. The public authorities law is amended by adding a new section
1854-e to read as follows:
§ 1854-E. ENERGY CONSUMPTION EFFICIENCY GOALS. 1. NO LATER THAN ONE
YEAR AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS SECTION, THE AUTHORITY, IN
CONJUNCTION WITH THE FEDERALLY DESIGNED BULK SYSTEM OPERATOR, THE PUBLIC
SERVICE COMMISSION, AND THE NEW YORK STATE CLIMATE ACTION COUNCIL SHALL
DETERMINE REASONABLE ENERGY CONSUMPTION EFFICIENCY GOALS FOR THE DESIGN
AND OPERATION OF DATA CENTERS AS DEFINED IN SECTION 31-0101 OF THE ENVI-
RONMENTAL CONSERVATION LAW, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, RECYCLING OF
WASTE HEAT EMITTED FROM DATA CENTERS INTO AN ENERGY SOURCE. SUCH GOALS
SHALL ALIGN WITH THE BENCHMARKS SET FORTH IN THE CLIMATE LEADERSHIP AND
COMMUNITY PROTECTION ACT ENACTED BY CHAPTER ONE HUNDRED SIX OF THE LAWS
OF TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN AND SHALL BE REVIEWED AND UPDATED ACCORDINGLY,
ANNUALLY.
2. A DATA CENTER OPERATOR THAT HAS COMMENCED OPERATION PRIOR TO THE
EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS SECTION SHALL HAVE TWO YEARS TO COMPLY WITH THE
ENERGY CONSUMPTION EFFICIENCY GOALS DEVELOPED PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION.
A DATA CENTER OPERATOR THAT HAS COMMENCED OPERATION WITHIN ONE YEAR OF
THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS SECTION SHALL HAVE ONE YEAR TO COMPLY WITH
SUCH ENERGY CONSUMPTION EFFICIENCY GOALS.
§ 7. The energy law is amended by adding a new article 19 to read as
follows:
A. 11560 8
ARTICLE 19
DATA CENTERS
SECTION 19-101. DEFINITIONS.
19-103. RENEWABLE ENERGY USE STANDARDS.
19-105. RENEWABLE ENERGY PRODUCTION STANDARDS.
§ 19-101. DEFINITIONS. FOR PURPOSES OF THIS ARTICLE, THE FOLLOWING
TERMS SHALL HAVE THE FOLLOWING MEANINGS:
1. "DATA CENTER" SHALL HAVE THE MEANING GIVEN TO SUCH TERM IN SECTION
31-0101 OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION LAW.
2. "RENEWABLE ENERGY SYSTEMS" SHALL HAVE THE MEANING GIVEN TO SUCH
TERM IN SECTION SIXTY-SIX-P OF THE PUBLIC SERVICE LAW.
§ 19-103. RENEWABLE ENERGY USE STANDARDS. EVERY DATA CENTER WITH A
PEAK LOAD OF FIVE MEGAWATTS OR MORE SHALL DEMONSTRATE THROUGH ANNUAL
THIRD-PARTY INDEPENDENT VERIFICATION ACCEPTABLE TO THE PUBLIC SERVICE
COMMISSION THAT IT IS PROCURING, WHETHER THROUGH CONTRACT OR ON-SITE
GENERATION, THAT:
1. AT LEAST ONE THIRD OF ITS ELECTRICITY CONSUMPTION IS DERIVED FROM
RENEWABLE ENERGY SYSTEMS FOR THE YEARS TWO THOUSAND THIRTY THROUGH TWO
THOUSAND THIRTY-FOUR,
2. AT LEAST TWO-THIRDS OF ITS ELECTRICITY CONSUMPTION IS DERIVED FROM
RENEWABLE ENERGY SYSTEMS FOR THE YEARS TWO THOUSAND THIRTY-FIVE THROUGH
TWO THOUSAND THIRTY-NINE, AND
3. AT LEAST NINETY PERCENT OF ITS ELECTRICITY CONSUMPTION IS DERIVED
FROM RENEWABLE ENERGY SYSTEMS IN TWO THOUSAND FORTY AND THEREAFTER.
§ 19-105. RENEWABLE ENERGY PRODUCTION STANDARDS. EVERY DATA CENTER
WITH A PEAK LOAD OF FIVE MEGAWATTS OR MORE SHALL DEMONSTRATE THROUGH
ANNUAL THIRD-PARTY INDEPENDENT VERIFICATION ACCEPTABLE TO THE PUBLIC
SERVICE COMMISSION THAT IT IS DERIVING AS MUCH OF ITS ENERGY NEEDS AS IS
TECHNOLOGICALLY, ENVIRONMENTALLY, AND PRACTICALLY FEASIBLE FROM ON-SITE
GENERATION FROM RENEWABLE ENERGY SYSTEMS.
§ 8. Host community benefits. 1. For the purposes of this section, the
following terms shall have the following meanings:
(a) "Host community" shall mean any city, town or village within which
a large data center, or any portion thereof, has been proposed for
development.
(b) "Eligible residential technologies" means:
(i) cold-climate air-source heat pumps and ground-source heat pumps
for space heating and cooling, including but not limited to geothermal
ground source heat pumps and thermal energy networks;
(ii) heat pump water heaters;
(iii) distributed solar photovoltaic systems; and
(iv) behind-the-meter battery storage systems.
(c) "Community infrastructure" means:
(i) local broadband infrastructure;
(ii) large data center noise mitigation measures;
(iii) municipal drinking water infrastructure;
(iv) municipal- and community-owned renewable energy systems, as
defined in section 66-p of the public service law;
(v) energy transmission infrastructure; and
(vi) large data center pollution mitigation.
(d) "Large data center" shall have the meaning given to such term by
section 31-0101 of the environmental conservation law.
(e) "Waters" shall have the meaning given to such term by subdivision
4 of section 15-0107 of the environmental conservation law.
A. 11560 9
(f) "Closed-loop cooling system" means a system in which the same
water or other coolant is recirculated, with only make-up and blow-down
losses, and minimal fresh water intake.
2. Each new large data center, or any existing large data center
undergoing a major expansion that will meet or exceed 20 megawatts of
additional load, shall, pursuant to subdivision 3 of this section, fund
a program to:
(a) install eligible residential technologies for host community resi-
dents;
(b) develop community infrastructure in the host community or communi-
ties; and
(c) implement measures to prevent increased levels of water pollution,
strains on wastewater infrastructure, water scarcity, and other adverse
impacts to waters in the host community or communities, which may
include but shall not be limited to the adoption of efficient large data
center cooling technology, such as closed-loop cooling systems;
provided, however, such measures shall not be required with respect to
adverse impacts which are addressed pursuant to paragraph (b) of subdi-
vision 5 of section 89-b of the public service law.
3. (a) The public service commission shall, within ninety days from
the effective date of this subdivision, commence a proceeding to estab-
lish a program under which large data center owners would be required to
fund the program described in subdivision 2 of this section. Such
proceeding shall establish a process for large data centers to notify
host communities of the program and the process for implementation,
including meaningful community engagement.
(b) With respect to the program components contemplated by paragraphs
(a) and (b) of subdivision 2 of this section, the program shall allow
such communities to indicate preferences for the installation of any
eligible residential technologies or community infrastructure. The
proceeding shall further determine the amount of such eligible residen-
tial technologies and/or community infrastructure to be installed based
on community input and all other factors deemed appropriate by the
commission, including the expected average electric and water demand of
the facility, the average number of electric and water utility customers
within the large data center host community, and the expected aggregate
annual electric and water consumption within such host community or
communities, and shall include prioritization of low- and moderate-in-
come households and disadvantaged communities, and the role of utili-
ties, if any, in implementing any aspect of such program. The public
service commission shall consult with the New York state energy research
and development authority, the federally designated bulk system opera-
tor, and the empire state development corporation in fulfilling its
responsibilities pursuant to this paragraph, and may also consult with
the affected utilities in fulfilling its responsibilities.
(c) With respect to the program components contemplated by paragraph
(c) of subdivision 2 of this section, the data center shall fund all
appropriate measures necessary to fully prevent the adverse impacts set
forth in such paragraph. The proceeding shall determine what measures
are appropriate to satisfy such requirements based on input from the
host community and all other factors deemed appropriate by the commis-
sion in consultation with the department of environmental conservation
and the environmental facilities corporation, including the number of
wastewater customers within the large data center host community and the
expected aggregate annual wastewater volumes within such large data
center host community and the role of wastewater management entities and
A. 11560 10
local natural resource management entities, if any, in implementing any
aspect of the program. The public service commission shall consult with
the department of environmental conservation and the environmental
facilities corporation in fulfilling its responsibilities pursuant to
this paragraph.
(d) The large data center shall annually submit independently audited
financial reports to the public service commission for such fund.
4. The data center, in coordination with the public service commission
and the department of environmental conservation, shall hold at least
one hearing in at least one host community to inform the proceeding
contemplated by subdivision 3 of this section. Reasonable notice shall
be given in advance of such hearing, the hearing shall be held at a
reasonable time and place, and meaningful opportunity for public comment
shall be provided at such hearing. The data center shall pay all
expenses for such hearing including the costs of the department of
public service and the department of environmental conservation.
5. All community infrastructure projects as defined in subdivision 1
of this section with a total construction cost of not less than 1
million dollars shall be subject to prevailing wage requirements in
accordance with sections 220, 220-a, 220-b, 220-i, 223, and 224-b of the
labor law, provided that the requirements of this subdivision shall not
apply to:
(a) a project conducted under a pre-hire collective bargaining agree-
ment between an owner or developer and a bona fide building and
construction trades labor organization which has established itself,
and/or its affiliates, as the collective bargaining representative for
all persons who will perform work on such a project, and which provides
that only contractors and subcontractors who sign a pre-negotiated
agreement with the labor organization can perform work on such project;
(b) construction work on one- or two-family dwellings where the prop-
erty is the owner's primary residence, or construction work performed on
property where the owner of the property owns no more than four dwelling
units; or
(c) construction work performed on a multiple residence and/or ancil-
lary amenities or installations that is wholly privately owned in any of
the following circumstances:
(i) where more than twenty-five percent of the residential units are
affordable and shall be retained subject to an anticipated regulatory
agreement with a local, state, or federal governmental entity, or a
not-for-profit entity with an anticipated formal agreement with a local,
state, or federal governmental entity for purposes of providing afforda-
ble housing in a given locality or region provided that the period of
affordability for a residential unit deemed affordable under the
provisions of this paragraph shall be for no less than fifteen years
from the date of construction; or
(ii) where no less than thirty-five percent of the residential units
involves the provision of supportive housing services for vulnerable
populations provided that such units are subject to an anticipated regu-
latory agreement with a local, state, or federal governmental entity.
§ 9. The Long Island Power Authority shall establish a program for
large data centers within its service territory to achieve the same
objectives and in the same manner as set forth and described in section
eight of this act.
§ 10. The labor law is amended by adding a new section 224-g to read
as follows:
A. 11560 11
§ 224-G. LABOR STANDARDS FOR CONSTRUCTION OF DATA CENTERS. 1. FOR THE
PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION:
A. "DATA CENTER" SHALL HAVE THE SAME MEANING GIVEN TO SUCH TERM IN
SECTION 31-0101 OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION LAW.
B. "COVERED DATA CENTER" SHALL MEAN A DATA CENTER WITH A PEAK DEMAND
CAPACITY OF FIVE MEGAWATTS OR MORE.
C. "FISCAL OFFICER" SHALL MEAN THE COMMISSIONER; EXCEPT FOR PROJECTS
PERFORMED PURSUANT TO A PERMIT ISSUED BY A CITY WITH A POPULATION IN
EXCESS OF ONE MILLION, IN WHICH CASE THE "FISCAL OFFICER" SHALL MEAN THE
COMPTROLLER OR OTHER ANALOGOUS OFFICER OF SUCH CITY.
2. THE CONSTRUCTION OF A COVERED DATA CENTER OR EXPANSION OF AN EXIST-
ING DATA CENTER WHICH WILL BE A COVERED DATA CENTER AFTER SUCH EXPANSION
SHALL BE SUBJECT TO PREVAILING WAGE REQUIREMENTS IN ACCORDANCE WITH
SECTIONS TWO HUNDRED TWENTY, TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-A, TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-B,
TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-I, TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-THREE, AND TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-
FOUR-B OF THIS ARTICLE, PROVIDED THAT SUCH REQUIREMENT SHALL NOT APPLY
TO CONSTRUCTION OR EXPANSION OF A COVERED DATA CENTER CONDUCTED UNDER A
PRE-HIRE COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT BETWEEN AN OWNER OR DEVELOPER
AND A BONA FIDE BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES LABOR ORGANIZATION
WHICH HAS ESTABLISHED ITSELF, AND/OR ITS AFFILIATES, AS THE COLLECTIVE
BARGAINING REPRESENTATIVE FOR ALL PERSONS WHO WILL PERFORM WORK ON SUCH
A PROJECT, AND WHICH PROVIDES THAT ONLY CONTRACTORS AND SUBCONTRACTORS
WHO SIGN A PRE-NEGOTIATED AGREEMENT WITH THE LABOR ORGANIZATION CAN
PERFORM WORK ON SUCH PROJECT.
3. THE OWNER OR DEVELOPER OF SUCH COVERED DATA CENTER SHALL REQUIRE
THE USE OF APPRENTICESHIP AGREEMENTS AS DEFINED BY ARTICLE TWENTY-THREE
OF THIS CHAPTER; OR FOR INDUSTRIES WITHOUT APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS,
REQUIRE THE USE OF WORKFORCE TRAINING, PREFERABLY IN CONJUNCTION WITH A
BONA FIDE LABOR ORGANIZATION; AND CONSIDER USE OF REGISTERED PRE-APPREN-
TICESHIP DIRECT ENTRY PROGRAMS FOR THE RECRUITMENT OF LOCAL AND/OR
DISADVANTAGED WORKERS.
4. THE ENFORCEMENT OF ANY CONSTRUCTION UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL BE
SUBJECT TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTIONS TWO HUNDRED TWENTY, TWO HUNDRED
TWENTY-A, TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-B, TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-I, TWO HUNDRED TWEN-
TY-THREE, TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-FOUR-B OF THIS ARTICLE, AND SECTION TWO
HUNDRED TWENTY-SEVEN OF THIS CHAPTER AND WITHIN THE JURISDICTION OF THE
FISCAL OFFICER; PROVIDED, HOWEVER, NOTHING CONTAINED IN THIS SECTION
SHALL BE DEEMED TO CONSTRUE ANY PROJECT COVERED THIS SECTION AS OTHER-
WISE BEING CONSIDERED PUBLIC WORK PURSUANT TO THIS ARTICLE.
5. THE FISCAL OFFICER MAY ISSUE RULES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING THE
PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION. VIOLATIONS OF THIS SECTION SHALL BE GROUNDS
FOR DETERMINATIONS AND ORDERS PURSUANT TO SECTION TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-B
OF THIS ARTICLE.
6. FOR ANY BUILDING SERVICE WORK ON A PROJECT COVERED BY THIS SECTION,
PREVAILING WAGE SHALL BE PAID CONSISTENT WITH ARTICLE NINE OF THIS CHAP-
TER.
7. THE OWNER OR DEVELOPER OF SUCH COVERED DATA CENTER SHALL REQUIRE
THAT THE IRON OR STEEL USED OR SUPPLIED FOR CONSTRUCTION, INCLUDING BY
ANY CONTRACTOR OR SUBCONTRACTOR, SHALL BE PRODUCED OR MADE IN WHOLE OR
SUBSTANTIAL PART IN THE UNITED STATES, ITS TERRITORIES OR POSSESSIONS.
IN THE CASE OF AN IRON OR STEEL PRODUCT ALL MANUFACTURING MUST TAKE
PLACE IN THE UNITED STATES, FROM THE INITIAL MELTING STAGE THROUGH THE
APPLICATION OF COATINGS, EXCEPT METALLURGICAL PROCESSES INVOLVING THE
REFINEMENT OF STEEL ADDITIVES.
§ 11. Severability. If any clause, sentence, paragraph, section or
part of this article shall be adjudged by any court of competent juris-
A. 11560 12
diction to be invalid and after exhaustion of all further judicial
review, the judgment shall not affect, impair or invalidate the remain-
der thereof, but shall be confined in its operation to the clause,
sentence, paragraph, section or part of this article directly involved
in the controversy in which the judgment shall have been rendered.
§ 12. This act shall take effect immediately.