Senate Bill S3996

                                 
BILL NUMBER: S3996

SPONSOR: PARKER
 
TITLE OF BILL:

An act to amend the mental hygiene law, in relation to the definition of
"developmental disability"

 
PURPOSE:

To clarify that in addition to meeting all the other conditions in the
existing definition to classify or define someone as developmentally
disabled, the individual may be found unable to engage in any substan-
tial gainful activity by reason of the disability (the definition used
to qualify someone for Social Security Disability by the federal govern-
ment) or found to have a substantial handicap to such person's ability
to function normally in society (the existing NYS criteria in the stat-
ute).

 
SUMMARY OF PROVISIONS:

Section 1: Paragraph (d) of subdivision 22 of section 1.03 of the mental
              

hygiene law, as amended by section 4 of part MM of chapter 58 of the
laws of 2015, Is amended.

Section 2: This law shall take effect on the thirtieth day after it
shall have become a law.

 
JUSTIFICATION:

In 2018 the CDC determined that approximately 1 in 59 children is diag-
nosed with an autism spectrum disorder. Therefore, New York State must
revamp its definition of developmental disability to ensure no one need-
ing services is falling through the cracks. Every effort must be made to
provide coherent and cohesive services early on to these and similarly
situated developmental disabled individuals who are currently being
denied services by the Office of People with Development Disability
(OPWDD). With the appropriate services, many can and do become independ-
ent and/or more productive members of society.

The current definition of developmental disability requires that an
individual's disability must constitute a substantial handicap to such
person's ability to function normally in society. OPWDD established
Advisory Guidelines in August 2001 that address issues in determining
eligibility for OPWDD services. Among other things, the eligibility
criteria the Guideline uses are too linked to adaptive behavior meas-
ures, which are measures that are used primarily to determine the level
of disability for people with subnormal intelligence.

These guidelines have had the effect of barring many individuals who are
unable to work or live on their own and meet all the other requirements
for services from OPWDD, except the adaptive behavior measures. Many of
these individuals, all of whom must have, among other things, a disabil-
ity that began before their 21st birthday, are high functioning autistic
people who may be able to score high on intelligence exams, but have
significant social, emotional and behavioral impediments that make it
extraordinarily difficult to join the workforce or live on their own
without assistance. However, given the appropriate level of supportive

services, these individuals can and do become productive members of our
society.

This bill does not seek to create a class of disabled individuals who
will become a financial burden receiving benefits for a lifetime.
Instead, this legislation will provide disabled individuals with the
supportive services they need early on to transition into adulthood and
independence.

Eligibility for OPWDD services can currently end when you are fully
employed and no longer need services to maintain that employment.
However, without these vital services many people become frustrated,
their conditions deteriorate and they end up needing and using mental
health services for anxiety and depression throughout their lifetime and
remaining dependent upon their families and society for the basic every-
day needs of housing and food.

Today, many disabled young adults and their families are being caught in
a catch 22. They are being denied OPWDD services because they are
considered too high functioning, yet because of their significant
social, emotional and behavioral impairments, they find themselves
unprepared and unable to function independently in society. As a result,
they are being left to flounder in search of an array of services
provided by many different agencies (the Office of Mental Health, VESID,
etc.) and providers, none of which are equipped to address the problems
they face. Some families are divesting themselves of everything, even
their family home, to send their child to a program that can help them
make the transition to independence. Others unable to get the appropri-
ate services are faced with finding someone to care for their child
after they die. The result is a group of young disabled individuals who
are unnecessarily falling through the cracks.

Not only is it morally imperative that we qualify these individuals for
OPWDD services, it is financially prudent to put the up front services
in place to help these disabled citizens integrate into society rather
than have society pay for care over a life time in various other social-
ly funded programs.

 
LEGISLATIVE HISTORY:

2023-24: S5273- Referred to Mental Health

2021-22: S5016 - Referred to Mental Health

2019-20: S.4607 - Referred to Mental Health and Dev. Disabilities

2017-18: S.3623 - REFERRED TO MENTAL HEALTH AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILI-
TIES

2015-16: S.2767A - Amend and Recommit to Mental Health and Dev.  Disa-
bilities

2013-14: S.3232 - Referred to Mental Health and Dev. Disabilities

2011-12: S.3431 - Referred to Mental Health and Dev. Disabilities

2009-10: S.186A/A.7787 - Referred to Mental Health and Dev. Disabilities

2007-08: S.8043/A.11020 - Passed the Senate, Died in Assembly Ways &
Means

 
FISCAL IMPLICATIONS:

To be determined.

 
EFFECTIVE DATE:
This law shall take effect on the thirtieth day after it shall have
become a law.